Wait a minute...Holy crap! I just realized the comic Spike accidentally burned as a Pony version of Action Comics #1. If that comic has the same value as our world's version, then Shiny's freak out is suddenly all to understandable.
I really think a case can be made that Pinky is a chaos magic user. It would make a lot of sense out of her physics defying cartoon antics, and her pinky sense. The glimpses we have seen into her mind and dreams would indicate that chaos is fundamental to how her mind works. Although I think it is probably something she dose subconsciously.
Spikie your right after discrord get his magic back from tirek he has trouble useig it and hiydismd is left open a rift which pinke pie fall into and figure out it's rules
Okay, so two of the most rage prone personalities on the Analyst Community made a collab, and nothing caught on fire... ... ...Maybe the episode needed more fuel, a slight spark, and possibly Eliyora to join in. ... ... ...Don't pretend you didn't want to see stuff burn too.
I empathize with you Josh, I was so eager to see Spiderman Homecoming, and then somebody I worked with spoiled the entire movie for me two days before I was planning to watch it.
dracohalo117 I sympothize too. I had the ending to the LAST Harry Potter book spoiled for me AND what happened to Stoick in How To Train Your Dragon 2 spoiled as well. It ruined the experience even tho both were still awesome. 😔
5:30 Oh, come on, ants don't look THAT scary up close! It's what they actually can and actually *do* that's so terrifying! Now wasps...*those* literal buggers are the *real* monsters!
Ants are related to wasps and bees. Ants can sting you with there oviposter as the stingers on workers are basically there lady parts turned in to poison injection parts.
I have a mix of a Polish, American/Canadian (depending on who you ask!) and Scottish accent (I'm Polish originally) . Scottish accents are interesting!
Currently watching this in the middle of the night because I couldn't sleep due to a stomach ache. One hilarious review later, stomach ache is gone. Thank you Josh!
Okay, who was the pink mare ranting about guard uniforms? That was great. Seriously, I demand a full deconstruction of the Equestrian Royal Guard and its effectiveness at dealing with problems seen in the show.
10:58 Yeah, the Mane Six never visited a psychologist after the events of The Return of Harmony, where Discord brainwashed five of them and the sixth mentally broke all on her own due to having already utterly failed, letting down her friends and Princess Celestia. Furthermore, Twilight never visited a psychologist after A Canterlot Wedding, where everypony she cared about turned on her, belittled her justifiable worries, and ignored her. Her friends, her brother (though he was being mentally controlled), and even Princess Celestia.
watching one's own videos is in the same category as reading ones on fanfiction, sometimes it's not done out of arrogance or Pride sometimes it's done just so you can review what you've already done and see where you can better from it. I'm the big fan of your work van and hope you continue it
If you think about it, the padding about Pinkie's tasks, they actually helped her solve the riddles easier, since Shining and Cadence sent them everywhere Pinkie was helping.
Of course there would be reference jokes in this video! The ambient music is itself a joke cause it's the theme to "I've Got A Secret." #GoingMetaTooSeriously
this was a much-needed watch. after hearing about Chester from Linkin Park dying I've hit a really depressing state, but fortunately this has gotten me to smile and laugh a little. thanks Josh and Maddie, I needed that. that was a fun and great review of a fun and fantastic episode
Also, heck yeah it's good to watch someone you love or care about or are friends with watch something you know and love or know and like! The woman I love is currently marathoning the whole of Dragonball Super, Dragonball, and Dragonball Z, and it's TON OF FUN watching her live tweeted reactions!
The chemistry between the two of you was surprisingly good in this! If you're compiling a short list of people to do repeat collabs with in the future as you go through this run, Munchkin should definitely be included on there.
Oh my god! This was funny and he got my childhood with that old Secret Formula outro! Man I loved listening to that on Cartoon Network, and they sometimes played it before or after Dexter's Laboratory
When I first became a brony in January of last year I binge watched every episode up through season 5 and this one was my favorite for quite some time. I just love the humor and slapstick it hurts my sides. It was my favorite until gauntlet of fire.
I'd love to see more of you and Maddie colaborating! I find you two to be the most sincere, down-to-earth, and unpretentious reviewers in the mlp community, and I really enjoy your points of view.
Xaldin wolfgang Hmmm... I wonder that episode has enough materials to make fun of in his channel and perhaps make it as his review later down the road.
What really bugs me about this episode is that Pinkie never addressed to Twilight that Pinkie knew about the baby. The scavenger hunt is over, and Pinkie says NOTHING to Twilight!
Man. First I catch a wild Gyarados in Pokemon Go, then I take a gym for team Instinct, and now a review from FOB Equestria and it's a collab. This has been a good evening so far :)
I think the term "Mane 6" is out-dated, and from the start excluded spike. So I'm proposing a new name, The Knights of Friendship. Now including Starlight, Spike, and whoever gets called by that stupid table. That takes a bit longer to say, so I'll just shorten it to the K.O.F. or just, The Knights.
So.... I Guess There's a Lot Of work for Our Fiery Joker. And By Lot, I mean BIG-Work That's Piled Up To Space So Much That Firebrand Can't Stand You so Much...LOT! No Offense,Amaru.
Well if they had not told us if they were having a baby, we would have seen the very obvious clues and been frustrated over how nobody else noticed, likely.
Cody Hines my thoughts exactly. I absolutely LOATHE the idea of agreeing with the likes of Lily Peet, but genetics dictate this was a logical outcome. moreover she isn't supposed to contribute to the story is not much being a BABY!
Cody Hines simple genetics. Her mother is an alicorn so of COURSE the kid is an alicorn and Twilight's family clearly has A LOT of magical potential. put it all together and you've got one insanely powerful child by nature
its not so much people HATE flurry heart...so much it is that flurry heart is BORING. one reason is that she's a baby, so one day *that we'll probably never see* she'll get older. another reason is she's the fifth alicorn princess. nothing about her really stands out. and, for me anyway, I really was hoping it was gonna be a boy XD that would have given the baby at least something to stand out from the other alicorns.
"Hi Pot, I'm Kettle, TELL ME MORE ABOUT TV TROPES."
JakeSnake07 classic
JakeSnake07
I call that a rocking parry.
also watch a " buck to the face" reviews...
JakeSnake07 you guys did a great job.
Says the one with a character named after a TV Tropes page.
"STILL no Mary Sue cameo?"
"Nah. I don't collab with Lightning Bliss until later." 🤣 I absolutely love all the jokes about the other critics
Wait a minute...Holy crap! I just realized the comic Spike accidentally burned as a Pony version of Action Comics #1. If that comic has the same value as our world's version, then Shiny's freak out is suddenly all to understandable.
Yeah no kidding; sold on eBay for 3.2 mill? Woof.
How could you Spike!?
Twilight no doubt had to pull some royal fucking strings to get it.
I noticed that the first second it was shown. I also felt the pain when it was damaged.
I really think a case can be made that Pinky is a chaos magic user. It would make a lot of sense out of her physics defying cartoon antics, and her pinky sense. The glimpses we have seen into her mind and dreams would indicate that chaos is fundamental to how her mind works. Although I think it is probably something she dose subconsciously.
reminds me of a story on FimFiction called "triptych" by Estee.
i don't want to spoil it...
Spikie your right after discrord get his magic back from tirek he has trouble useig it and hiydismd is left open a rift which pinke pie fall into and figure out it's rules
Koala is referring to this comic book:
ua-cam.com/video/FBmKMHMt5ww/v-deo.html
Can we PLEASE have more of Maddy and Firebrand interacting?! Like, it is amazing and I love it! So funny!
I agree. They are a better lover story than ... nope. Too easy.
love story? TAKEN!
Mad Munchkin? Didn't you tell Firebrand to stop reading the comment sections? Someone's being a hypocrit.
We are both raging hypocrites.
Mad Munchkin
I love you Maddie
Okay, so two of the most rage prone personalities on the Analyst Community made a collab, and nothing caught on fire... ... ...Maybe the episode needed more fuel, a slight spark, and possibly Eliyora to join in. ... ... ...Don't pretend you didn't want to see stuff burn too.
In my head canon, all of those one-time voices that opened a door before slamming it and leaving... caught on fire from their off screen rage.
Rage prone...you make that sound like a bad thing here.
Also...nothing caught on fire. I was shot out of a canon. Does that appease you? :P
Not unless there was an explosion at the end.
also watch a " buck to the face" reviews...
@@DragoSonicMile
At the very least, Firebrand would have sent them off by Party Howitzer as well.
**door opens**
"Love you too guys!"
**door closes**
-"FUCK- YOU."
That was good
The Doctor I want to rewatch that scene but forgot what the time was.
The Doctor Fuck you 22222
I know it was hilarious
@@Gentle-x8f 8:12
'Like.. watching.. their.. own.. UA-cam.. videos.. yeah'
Hheh, WHO DOES THAT -Looks around nervously-
I watch my own videos and have no care in the world of what anybody think of me. lol
Me......
me because i love them
Me too and I don't care about anyone who cares.
Me. I put lots of time and effort into my videos, so I'm gonna enjoy them.
The sarcastic duo is here! :D
I empathize with you Josh, I was so eager to see Spiderman Homecoming, and then somebody I worked with spoiled the entire movie for me two days before I was planning to watch it.
dracohalo117 Yeah,I got spoiled Star Wars 7, now if I really want to see a movie I like, I just stay off the internet until I see it.
I wasn't spoiled for it, I saw it, and frankly thought I wasted two and a half hours of my life and ten dollars.
dracohalo117 I sympothize too. I had the ending to the LAST Harry Potter book spoiled for me AND what happened to Stoick in How To Train Your Dragon 2 spoiled as well. It ruined the experience even tho both were still awesome. 😔
OH that SUCKS!
5:30 Oh, come on, ants don't look THAT scary up close! It's what they actually can and actually *do* that's so terrifying! Now wasps...*those* literal buggers are the *real* monsters!
joinmarch76 amen 😖
Ants are related to wasps and bees. Ants can sting you with there oviposter as the stingers on workers are basically there lady parts turned in to poison injection parts.
Reminds me of that episode of Hey Arnold where those two ants talked with stock phone chatter
Eww...
Wasps are horrible.
joinmarch76 I know how to make ants more terrifying, infect them with the cordesypes fungal parasite
I think I'm in love with Munchkin's accent.
I have a mix of a Polish, American/Canadian (depending on who you ask!) and Scottish accent (I'm Polish originally) .
Scottish accents are interesting!
I'm part Scottish from my dad's side, so thank God I'm not the only one.
@@claytonhess5512 She will fire an RPG round at you if you fire back.
Currently watching this in the middle of the night because I couldn't sleep due to a stomach ache. One hilarious review later, stomach ache is gone. Thank you Josh!
Yay I helped too! :D
AHHHH! Maddie-sama acknowledged me! I love you! Great video!
Anyone else like Mad Munchkin's OC?
i do
@Natalie Swalve ok
I can relate to the hairy shins and being Celtic;cause I’m of Celtic ancestry(which has given me the super power of shin hair).
@@gyrogenerations8373 ok
MrGabeanator ok
I love this episode and the fact that we find out at the beginning and get to feel with Pinkie rather than being confused by her.
Okay, who was the pink mare ranting about guard uniforms? That was great.
Seriously, I demand a full deconstruction of the Equestrian Royal Guard and its effectiveness at dealing with problems seen in the show.
Caleb Johnsen that was Aramau, Firebrand's new secretary. :)
Aramau the Fiery Secretary hiiiiii you two are so cute together!
@@AramautheFierySecretary And I'm surprised you haven't killed firebrand or shot him out of the Giant Canon
@@darknight2146 she does we dont see it
@@leeterry96 ok when
"Better exit than Brexit" HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! Nope, Mad stole best joke there.
NO POLITICAL HUMOR. PEOPLE.TAKE THOSE JOKES WAAY TO SERIOUSLY.
After th ed waving ...arm? Thing. OH MY GOSH THE SELF AWARENESS IS OFF THE CHARTS!!!!!! Sorry equestron refrence. Can't resist.
Don't get me started!
@@ambermargheim5726 Wacky waving inflatable arm flailing tube man!
@@fiend-off-the-grid lol
Also the “I’M GOIN TO DINEY WORL!” Was SO CUTE
“People take those jokes WAY *too seriously * “HEHEHEHEHEHE GEDDIT ! He made a pun. A beautiful pun.
4:23
"Those are meme faces!"
I'm thinking nightmare fuel.
11:06 "I don't remember there being music at this moment... ... Wait just a *goddamn minute*--"
It was "I'm so happy, to be finally going home" by Eduard Khil, AKA "Trololol".
"I want to live there so badly"
Me: we all wish we could live in Equestria, we all wish that Maddy
10:58 Yeah, the Mane Six never visited a psychologist after the events of The Return of Harmony, where Discord brainwashed five of them and the sixth mentally broke all on her own due to having already utterly failed, letting down her friends and Princess Celestia.
Furthermore, Twilight never visited a psychologist after A Canterlot Wedding, where everypony she cared about turned on her, belittled her justifiable worries, and ignored her. Her friends, her brother (though he was being mentally controlled), and even Princess Celestia.
I'm pretty sure the closest they have to a psychologist is *princess Luna*.
Who else paused the video for every single piece of text that popped up on screen for a second?
The editors do that on purpose. ;)
Allison McCabe YES AND IT IS IRITATING
I read fast
I did.
Ah, that blue's clues refrince...right in the childhood ^_^
raphaela ratzlaff, *reference
Max Harter thanks
11:12 "Convenient!"
Hello, Joshscorcher.
I love the ending music, will. I. am and Dexter laboratory. also loved the voice cameos.
watching one's own videos is in the same category as reading ones on fanfiction, sometimes it's not done out of arrogance or Pride sometimes it's done just so you can review what you've already done and see where you can better from it. I'm the big fan of your work van and hope you continue it
If you think about it, the padding about Pinkie's tasks, they actually helped her solve the riddles easier, since Shining and Cadence sent them everywhere Pinkie was helping.
Ha! The sarcasm and burns have been doubled!
How many puns do I receive?
Of course there would be reference jokes in this video! The ambient music is itself a joke cause it's the theme to "I've Got A Secret."
#GoingMetaTooSeriously
I've got a secret the game show?
13:39 You just described the Game Grumps viewers every time Arin plays.
this was a much-needed watch. after hearing about Chester from Linkin Park dying I've hit a really depressing state, but fortunately this has gotten me to smile and laugh a little. thanks Josh and Maddie, I needed that. that was a fun and great review of a fun and fantastic episode
Maddie's desperate attempts to be funny are the cutest things 😂❤️
Best Ponyreveiwer.
You two are big mean butt heads!!! ^W^
Real mature, Lightning Bliss. Real mature.
Weston Fox Her sense of maturity is very SMALL
;)
Lightning Bliss Rainbow Alicorn does not like jokes about her! *gives her a rainbow frosted cookie* Because, reasons!
you show em Blissy
I must say though, that line delivery was absolute GOLD.
The part when pinkie looks like she gonna lose it, reminded me of who framed Roger rabbit
Also, heck yeah it's good to watch someone you love or care about or are friends with watch something you know and love or know and like!
The woman I love is currently marathoning the whole of Dragonball Super, Dragonball, and Dragonball Z, and it's TON OF FUN watching her live tweeted reactions!
This keeps popping up in my recommended and at this point I accept that UA-cam want me to watch this over and over
I ON THE OTHER HAND AM IRISH, LOVE ME
Okay. I'll love you. I'll blow you a kiss from the mid-west.
Right back at ya Call me Scott and my Great Grandma Madeline will haunt yer bloody ass
115th stormtrooper But I'm Irish and Scottish, so calling me Irish is okay, and calling me Scottish is okay,... dangit I'm weird.
The chemistry between the two of you was surprisingly good in this! If you're compiling a short list of people to do repeat collabs with in the future as you go through this run, Munchkin should definitely be included on there.
Yeah I have been waiting for a colab with joshscorcher and madmunchkin
Wait no longer!
I screamed a bit when Pinkie Pie said it at the beginning, I was so happy for the couple
Amaru stole the show. Great review btw.
That Guy and she and firebrand start dating soon enough.
I loved fire's scream at the beginning
I don't know why...but Maddie's scream, as she falls into the pot of gold is...hilarious
sadlobster1, that was josh screaming like a girl
I was talking about when Maddie was falling into the pot of gold. For some reason, her screaming as she fell sounded silly
ITS CHRISTMAS!!! JOSH RELEASED TWO TOO SERIOUSLY REVIEWS IN A ABOUT A MONTH FROM EACH OTHER!!!! 😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊☃☃☃❄️🎄🎄🎄🎄🎄
Starry Song No. He's actually got the stick out his butt and is now trying his hardest to make up for the waterfall that is lost time.
Spike just incinerated a mint copy of Action Comics 1. I really want to shoot something right now.
Abi Sain Could be worse, it could be a comic from Palcomix.....I suddenly feel hated
Oh my god! This was funny and he got my childhood with that old Secret Formula outro! Man I loved listening to that on Cartoon Network, and they sometimes played it before or after Dexter's Laboratory
Yaas! Scorch likes Until Dawn, Fandom is still not completely dead! I wonder who is his favorite character tho..
While I'm not a Pinkie Pie fan (Least favorite pony) I can't deny that they did a stellar job with the episode. Excellent work!
In regards to the royal guard's uniform, they're wearing gold slippers!
The amount of references in this video is TOO DAMN HIGH, ;and I LOVE IT!!!
15:31 and being pulled by the ear by a mother figure people take too seriously
She was still doing it during the last few credits too xD
14:16 God, I love Freakazoid! Thank you for that reference!
14:35 - I got a kick out of that Samurai Jack reference.
Ahhhhhh, seeing the Blues Clues reference makes me want to go back in time...
...again
11:31 this scene is EXACTLY why I LOVE Shining Armor
When I first became a brony in January of last year I binge watched every episode up through season 5 and this one was my favorite for quite some time. I just love the humor and slapstick it hurts my sides. It was my favorite until gauntlet of fire.
How long has it been since we got a "convenient"?
5:58 The best description for reaction videos right there
TRUTH!
Freakazoid reference! Can I say I love you even more for that one? Because I do.
I'd love to see more of you and Maddie colaborating! I find you two to be the most sincere, down-to-earth, and unpretentious reviewers in the mlp community, and I really enjoy your points of view.
Hey Josh you skipped Crusaders of the Lost Mark or unless you are saving that for another review? Or another Collab with someone?
he will take it seriusly next time
Xaldin wolfgang Hmmm... I wonder that episode has enough materials to make fun of in his channel and perhaps make it as his review later down the road.
Xaldin wolfgang I'd go for the second
I thought tweeting his reaction was enough
I see what you did there.
good job. you've already given me nightmares with the close up of the ant and i HAVEN'T even gone to bed.
What really bugs me about this episode is that Pinkie never addressed to Twilight that Pinkie knew about the baby. The scavenger hunt is over, and Pinkie says NOTHING to Twilight!
i mean why would she. Twilight prop figured it out by connect two and two together. with how pinkie was behaving before the reveal and afterwards.
Man. First I catch a wild Gyarados in Pokemon Go, then I take a gym for team Instinct, and now a review from FOB Equestria and it's a collab. This has been a good evening so far :)
14:09 we now tune into an episode of Dora the Explorer
Fantastic video, much better than normal animation and the musical choices were top notch.
So Firebrand has a new secretary...
Why do I want to make so many dirty jokes about that?
Update: they got married
I just played that song in the background for my winter consert.
Honestly Maddie is the only reason I'm watching your video. Please collaborate with her more often.
Blissy Cameo!
Thespy Cameo!
Munchkin!
Great episode!
😂
And censored cameo
I think the term "Mane 6" is out-dated, and from the start excluded spike.
So I'm proposing a new name, The Knights of Friendship. Now including Starlight, Spike, and whoever gets called by that stupid table.
That takes a bit longer to say, so I'll just shorten it to the K.O.F. or just, The Knights.
I really enjoyed watching you two review this episode together
So glad I'm not the only one who isn't very fond of Flurry Heart.
Chuck Lee Though I don't mind her, The community seems to see her as Poof 2.0
Ha! The entire fandom hates her, besides me
MaidenofBagEnd actually you’re not the only one
Me being the type that loves watching things first and getting spoiled and teasing people who don’t like getting spoiled
Toon Kritic in this video, huh?
Well this video aged like milk.
Ha! Ha! Nice review! I missed you doing these, so it's good to have you back Josh.
So, um, who's the manager pony at the beginning?
fictionfan0 The best character in the video that's who
It said in the credits it's Firebrand's new secretary Aramau
You meme like Jerry Peat was for about a month?
;''3
(except hopefully less of a psychopath? ^-
That would be me! Hello! I am Aramau, the Fiery Secretary, at Firebrand/Josh's service. :)
So....
I Guess There's a Lot Of work for Our Fiery Joker.
And By Lot, I mean BIG-Work That's Piled Up To Space So Much That Firebrand Can't Stand You so Much...LOT!
No Offense,Amaru.
its been like 9 years. i think its ok to bring back this is sparta jokes.
14:35 Charming...
i also have a head cannon on how equestria affords party equipment
ITS FREAKING TV SHOW!!
Wait. Were those blue paw prints a reference to Blue’s Clues?
Yes.
LOVE the reference to "Up".
Can you keep Maddie? You two are a perfect pair! (not THAT kind of pair)
...Again. TAKEN. :p
Holy damn, you two were an awesome combo, loved the episode!
hey Mad Munchkin did really try to be funny and I think she did pass the test
Yay! I passed the test!
Well if they had not told us if they were having a baby, we would have seen the very obvious clues and been frustrated over how nobody else noticed, likely.
Oh come on guys, Flurry Heart isn't THAT bad
James W Why do people think she's bad anyway?
Cody Hines my thoughts exactly. I absolutely LOATHE the idea of agreeing with the likes of Lily Peet, but genetics dictate this was a logical outcome. moreover she isn't supposed to contribute to the story is not much being a BABY!
James W Logical outcome? what do you mean? (no spoilers for any episodes of season 7 plz)
Cody Hines simple genetics. Her mother is an alicorn so of COURSE the kid is an alicorn and Twilight's family clearly has A LOT of magical potential. put it all together and you've got one insanely powerful child by nature
its not so much people HATE flurry heart...so much it is that flurry heart is BORING. one reason is that she's a baby, so one day *that we'll probably never see* she'll get older. another reason is she's the fifth alicorn princess. nothing about her really stands out. and, for me anyway, I really was hoping it was gonna be a boy XD that would have given the baby at least something to stand out from the other alicorns.
yo pony lynch smiles so rarely that her smiles seem that much more adorable
13:04 That would be me
With all of the doors in the Rift being pocket dimensions, you'd think they'd be sound proof.
That brexit jab doe!
Josh you're funny when you get anvils dropped and I think it's cool that munchkin referred to Sparta! 10/10!
13:46 every time I watch the Game Grumps, why?
Dakota Metzgar because gamer brains are turned off when the camera turns on.
I honestly can't wait till you review a royal problem, I'm not gonna spoil, but it's big, really big XD
Yikes, the toonkritic parts are now so hard to hear...
Random appearance by dawillstanator makes it complete! 10/10!!!
aren't you Scottish
nods head repeatedly
I love the fan art in your corridors.