Shehbaz Sharif is talking peace. India must keep mum, leave Pak to Pak
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 січ 2023
- #IndiaPakistan #ShehbazSharif
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif said in an interview with the TV channel Al Arabiya that Pakistan had learnt its lesson, having fought three wars with India, and now wanted peace. In this week's #NationalInterest, ThePrint Editor-In-Chief Shekhar Gupta explains three things that Pakistanis need: Strategic breathing space, financial generosity and most of all, relevance.
Brought to you by @KiaInd
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read this week's National Interest here: theprint.in/national-interest...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read National Interest, 'leave Af to Pak' here: theprint.in/opinion/why-india...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
the mum keeping policy lead to creation of pakistan, its time to act
This episode should have been aptly named CUT THE CLUTTER ….I.e cut out or ignore the clutter of pak playing to the gallery - international media and drumming up attention all for USD so as Shekar aptly said we should sit back relax and play a wait and watch …
Probably even abstain for engaging on a diplomatic level in any way sort or means - for eg providing meds they seem to be running low on or any other form / kind of aid …
Anyways they have their bell weather big brother China for all that …
@@awakeningforce8798 a de stable nuclear armed islamic fanatic country run by maulana and armed taliban would guarantee a nuclear war
It's in India's interest to make Pakistan remained on the same path of security state. And it needs timely measured and adequate provocation from India. And Modi's recent statement ( if at all recent) is right n necessary in terms of time, situation and long term strategic interests of India. It's a psychological game as well.
Because Pakistan wants resources only to fight against India and not for betterment of it's own citizens.
PORKI BEGGER TALKING ABOUT PEACE,
Their economy is growing at half the pace and their population is growing at twice the pace of India. I think that sums it up nicely.
And when their economy is 11 times lesser than india
Their Community is doing same thing in india breeding and inbreeding like rats to make hindus Minority and turn this country into next paxtan. Hindu poticization in nonuse to begin with
If you can't stop demographic shift. Demography is Destiny
We should keep our own house in order and never a burden to any other states.
Population of peaceful community in INDIA is growing at the same level as Pakistan. Cut the clutter
@@youthink5552 must stop providing them reservation
And I trust the current govt to not react to the tempting offer for ‘talks’. We will have to wait for the their collective IQ to improve, before we can talk!! Let them meet their logical end!
They will not refer to 2019 Modi speech
Nothing Tempting about it. And They are actually mostly best left it's not even worth responding to them most of the times. Some indians and particularly the keyboard warriors with nothing to do get easily led around by Pakistan though . Thankfully the Govt is not stupid like they are .
I have full trust in Dr jaishankar
I donot think modi will care to respond to these morons
This could be a point of interest to congress and their appeasement parties
Thanks to 🇮🇳 and Indians for electing Modiji and the BJP. My head used to hang in shame when I used to see the UPA, it's corruption and how PM MMS was treated by pappu and his party. Like the rest of the world, I too was shocked to see the UPA give a non response to 26/11 due to their vote bank politics. If we don't want to return to those days, it's Modi and BJP again in 2024 🙏💪
See I'm also a centre right wing democratic capitalist secular ideology person. It's about every person I can agree on Modi ji international diplomacy at its best but we cannot forget the economic reforms of Dr Manmohan singh that changed India's future.
We have two Pappus now- Amby and Andy -Ani .
The only PM who visited Pakistan in last 20 years, that too to have a biryani uninvited.
I remember MMS resolutely refusing a visit unless there is a break through. That strong position was squandered away by wreck less whimsical decision - in the sky- we are told.
@@jkardez4794 They ( business tycoons ) of india never let india sink the way pakistan is sinked by their own incompetent politicians, corrupt beurocracy, judiciary, army in absence of business. Do not forget indian govt revenue were over $350 billions. Out of this business houses contribution were half of it. And india has more than 100 business houses worth more than $10 billions a dream for bankrupt nation. This together with urban middle class indian never let india beg to IMF, WB, ADB, US, EU, birader musalman numalic. Pakistan has lost its relevance to US, EU, China for failure of CPEC.
Thanks!
@@sujithkumar2041 that fool MMS was the one who shamed India in Sharm Al Sheikh by admitting that India is fomenting trouble in Balochistan. No wonder it followed by 26/11 and without any response by India. It is also shameful that India did not respond and meekly surrendered due to then government. They were more worried that by taking hardline stance against Pakistan, they may lose their votebank.
This is maybe for the first time i have seen Shekhar Sir taking a strong stance on Pakistan with tinge of nationalist's ego. I like to see this side of him more often 😀
You can't make strategic choices based on ego. Shekhar has taken this position based on the past learnings and inherent attitude and beliefs of our neighbors. So, there shouldn't be any engagement with our Western neighbors for at least the next 20 years. Let India focus on other priorities to bridge the gaps and become a developed economy. On per capita basis (GDP) and HDI, etc, we are still lower (than many African nations or even Bangladesh), and our benchmark can't be a failed society. Thanks 🙏🏻
India should Not totally keep quiet , it should act from background and show there r quiet.
We should take whole advantage and opportunity of this situation.
We can grow our economy more by doing this 👇👇
India should try to make every effort to bring great famine starvation, civil war , TTP and Taliban t e rrorism,total collapse of infra, economy and social structure. Afghanistan Pakistan war ,r i o rs, Balkanization disintegration division of Pakistan into sindudesh Balochistan Gilgit Pashtunistan KP and Punjab.( More casualties,Make population perish to more than half - bio weapons )
India would benefit.
Pakistan may have to surrender nuclear.
Tax will be save due to reduction in security surveillance arms costs.
Weak , eradicated Pakistan can be exploited for pipeline for cheap petrol gas oil .
Paks water way, ports , land ways can be used for export import of cheap goods.
Indian corporate companies can exploit Pakistan and resources this creating jobs
,
Yes, his final words were leave PAK for PAK means he still biased on it, doesn’t like to be told off.
Ego is not automatically a bad word, in the context that you are using it. Ego is the driving force in our life.
I remember those 'two minute silences' in my School assemblies in 2000s in Mumbai.
The one after 26/11 was a teary eyed one, the terrorists gunned down my friends Chef Dad at the Taj!
I felt like , we're a ' Haari Hui Quam', even as Congress leadership barked Rss ki saazish!
The NDA at least has made Pak growel after Uri 2016.
Have to agree this time with SG.
I always wonder how can it be jst a इत्तेफ़ाक..kasab came wearing hindu kalawa in hand nd congress with some liberal intellectuals nd bollywood ppls labelled 26/11 as RSS (hindu) ki saazish with a book written on the same...!! Was it a chronology or jst some इत्तेफ़ाक..!?
@@chaitanyachaman3815 The one launching that book on 26/11 RSS ki Saazish - Mr Mahesh Bhatt's son was a friend of Headly (who came for 26/11 recce). In fact, that decade definitely had a lot of chronologies and not mere ittefaaqs again and again.
Also, the then Govt not reacting strongly against Pakistan, not showing any military aggression, too raises the same doubts.
@@raghvendrasingh9675 spot on.
The fact is jr Bhatt has a clean chit. His father, his step mother( a Pakistani British), Arrogant Alia bhatt are still very much 'barking' since that day.
Any rational critic is labelled as 'attack on democracy '.
Other members of this sleeper cell are Javed Akhtar, Shabana Azmi, Naseeruddin Shah, Ratna Pathak, Salman Khan( this drunk criminal thinks 93 blast accused are innocent)....
The Nexus was deadly with combination of politics, bollywood, mafia!
See that's karma,RSS lost interest in politics after the way the first bjp government acted, the attempt to pin 26/11on them got their attention and then Modi happened
For all inhuman atrocities they've done. For all the precious lives we've lost. For too many widows we've seen.. we must not lend a hand of help to them. For we've paid too heavier price for decades..
True 👍
@@Ram92026zPakistan govt and Pakistan itself is separate.
Fully agree. We are still coping with ongoing terror. Any leeway will only buy Pakistan time to hit us another day .
Pak to Pak, what a brilliant analysis! 👏👏
Let the terrorism hub of the world Pakistan collapse!😆😄
It's in India's interest to make Pakistan remained on the same path of *Security-State* . And it needs measured, calculated and adequate provocation from India from time to time. And Modi's recent statement ( if at all recent) is right n necessary in terms of time, situation and long term strategic interests of India. It's a psychological game as well.
Because Pakistan wants resources only to fight against India and not for betterment of it's own citizens.
Those era of silence and reticence in terms of passive foreign policy of carrier-diplomats has gone few decades ago. *Please think about it profoundly* before agreeing to the vintage classical proposition of the past which SekharJi has mastered.
So far abt 161 idiots think that statement wasnt sarcastic.. smh 🤦♂️
Modi Government learnt early "Leave Pak to Pak".
SG is just summarizing it now.
That's why we have faith in our Prime Minister.
Absolutely
Pakistan and INDIA are the product results of the Vampire Queen Victoria and her 5 Beedee Eyes offspring.
Still doing very well as seen today.
Since they have a long culture of not to forgive, extremely hard headed, too proud to admit errors, no loyalty, extremely selfish, double dipping back and forth, and the biggest problem is greed.
Keep them 2 busy for more centuries to come.
watching from Arunachal, on the opposite side to our terrorist neighbour border, fully agree with Shekhar ji, plus us responsible people should also try to observe the policy in individual capacity, let's not throw unnecessary comments at their plight, instead just peacefully observe them sink to the bottom on their own
It will be a ship wreak, and India will help the people of Pakistan to get into four life boats.
I agree. Making fun of Pakistan's financial problems or taking joy in their misery doesn't show us in good light. We need to be humble as a nation.
I absolutely agree with you my north eastern friend. I see lot of immature Indians boasting about our achievements below pakistani news channels. It is embarrassing. 🤦♂️
Unnecessary comments?!! It's Pak trolls which still have ego, look at Shahbaz Sharif's attitude, even in that interview, he put the condition that Kashmir should be discussed... And FM Bhutto only knows Kashmir Kashmir.... It shows, they are not even affected by their plight, they r not ashamed of their present condition. So, don't be too sensitive, it's not like if common Indians troll them, paxtanis going to cry lol. Moreover, Govt is silent, u can't control what common Indians do on Twitter...
@@gosliglitzho What's wrong in boasting?? Btw, I understand that India has to achieve a lot & catch up with China.
Majority of paxtanis still have superiority complex, look down on India. Leave common Pak people & media, even Pak PM, FM who should be responsible leaders, don't have a bit of shame, still trolls India & have audacity to lecture that "let's sit down on the table & discuss Kashmir", then said, no talks until India reinstates 370. So much smugness despite being literally beggars...
On the other hand, u guys bow/hang ur head in shame, embarrassment just because some Indians boast about achievements in Pak channel. Why r Indians so sensitive & feel guilty over small matters?
If Indians boast in front of Japanese & western countries, that'd be an embarrassment, I understand. But, no need to feel shame over Indians boasting in front of Paxtanis. This is inferiority complex.
For once I must fully agree to Shekar Ji. Kudos.
It's in India's interest to make Pakistan remained on the same path of *Security-State* . And it needs measured, calculated and adequate provocation from India from time to time. And Modi's recent statement ( if at all recent) is right n necessary in terms of time, situation and long term strategic interests of India. It's a psychological game as well.
Because Pakistan wants resources only to fight against India and not for betterment of it's own citizens.
Those era of silence and reticence in terms of passive foreign policy has gone few decades ago. *Please think about it profoundly* before agreeing to the vintage classical proposition of the past which SekharJi has mastered.
*kh
Thank you for watching...best wishes, Shekhar
When the enemy is destroying itself, don't disturb it.
Love your statement.
But the enemy awakened and don't know it's learnt its mistake but realising that it has take hard decisions to revive ifs economy.
@@raghunandan9290 if they have learnt their lesson after 3 wars then they should return what they annexed during the war.
Some times Shekhar Gupta talks sense.
This is one of such rare episodes.
He make sense mostly
Liberals hor Bhakt dono against hote hai sensible person k
Ya be happy with the fact that you're only a few steps ahead of Pakistan and still many steps behind countries that we actually should've been competiting with. The king of opponents you pick shows your aukat.
Yes. All those who were pushing for talks with Pakistan have changed their mind.
He talks sense most of the times. You are so on the right that SG looks like a leftist. Not his problem.
complete agree 😁
Excellent video 👍👏🙏
5:08 I recall an interview you gave ShekharJi in the immediate aftermath of Balakot where you lamented that unfortunately today, we have a govt that will not only respond but even escalate any misadventure by Pak. So glad and grateful to hear you acknowledge that it was the right move for India. Der aaye, par durust aaye. Thank you. Hope your friends in the media and the left listen to your wise words.
7:24 Can't thank you enough for highlighting this- every time some liberal idiot, particularly from Bollywood said (and still say) that the people of Pak want peace with India, we should have people-to-people ties, they are choosing to live in such denial. If the people of Pak really wanted peace with India, how come there hasn't been a SINGLE protest or demonstration there?
True, he is congress sympathiser hence Pakistan sympathiser and even now he didn’t mention Narendra Modi’s name.
As congress going down in India so is Pakistan.
@Teja.... Well said.
@@akshytube 🙏
For those who believe Pakistani aam janata are peace loving, one has to only watch these people speak on their TV interviews. Spewing hatred against Hindus, RSS ,Israel and any other topical country, is ingrained in their psyche. On one Pak national TV channel a senior Army retired officer mentioned with aplomb that all Pakistanis ( army, governments and people) are agreed on the three uncompromising objectives of this country viz Islam, Kashmir and Pakistani Army. All others on the same panel nodded their agreement and no one questioned as to who had done this survey. The average Pakistani on the road after crying about the shortage of food and rise in costs of items will then make his mandatory reference to India, Hindus and RSS.
Just so funny. It's like the bully wants to make peace. All the bully has to do is stop bullying to get peace. Unfortunately this bully only wants strategic time out so it can get back to bullying again
Yes Agreed.This is talked out to bully supporters in TN.Ameer and VJS among others.
Not really. Bullies are physically stronger than the bullied. In this case, it's more like a pomeranian snapping at the heals of an elephant and thinking it is bullying the giant.
@@GopiKrishnanzexcept the Pomeranian has control of the elephants land in Kashmir and the elephant is too timid to do anything about it. That’s embarrassing, and an insufficient analogy
@@veerchand2129 pak is a rabid dog
Beautiful. 100% agreed. I am no foreign policy expert, but I think Modi got Pakistan policy right. He made his efforts, and when he saw Pakistan is sticking to its old methods, he just cut them off. No need to talk to Pakistan.
I still remember the great Mani Shankar Aiyer’s philosophy of “uninterrupted and uninterruptible dialogue”. I wonder what was on his mind.
Absolutely correct...let Pakistan go whichever way it goes. We are fed up of a neighbour always inimical to us. We should not be unduly worried about Pakistan breaking up or its nukes falling into the wrong hands.
Good analysis... Shekhar sir. We cannot & never ever trust this Islamic State of Pakistan. It will always stab you in the back when the time comes. After 26/11 we should have declared a complete halt to engagement with Pakistan. But PM Modi repeated the same mistake as earlier PMs and paid the price with Uri. Now that Pakistan is almost on the verge of collapse we must continue to tighten the screws and show no mercy. We should not sympathise with common Pak folks as we cannot forget the pain of our 26/11 and other victims.
No, Modi initially reached out to Pak to give them a chance & also show the world that India is ready to mend ties with Pak.
Modi did right thing because there should be no guilty that under Modi leadership, India didn't reach out to Pak & there r many over sensitive Indians who might have even claimed that Modi didn't give a chance to Pak. Since Modi made such efforts initially, now India can simply ignore Pak without the feeling of guilty & nobody can blame modi for not having talks with Pak.
Inspite of sehabaz's statement of peace, there was a contradictory statement from their FO that there will no talks without restoring Art 370. This has been the scene for a long time. The present Modi government adopted the ignore and isolate Pak strategy, which has given good results.
This was again a self goal by Pakistan. It shows to the world that what their PM says is not to be taken seriously and there is no solid form of policy in pakistan. It also shows that pak doesn't have functioning government system. How world leaders will deal with such country where PM says X , Establishment says Y and people want Z. Its absolute circus... true Banana Republic. 😁
This is a master piece by Shekhar Ji. “Precise”; “Correct”; “Insightful”
Ghanta masterpiece.Its the work of modi or else abhi tak mms rehta hai millions of dollars abhi tak pak ko milta aur shehbaz ko khande par utarkar ghumta
It has to be one of the most clear headed analysis on our policies regarding Pakistan and I think present dispensation fully agrees with this stance. Kudos Mr Gupta for such crystal clear elucidation of the issue at hand.
Thank you for watching...best wishes, SG
Excellent commentary Shekhar, supported by facts and learnings from the past. India needs to remain focused on its priorities of economic growth, managing internal conflicts - the enemies within and increasing its diplomatic clout with the rest of the world. India has a bigger challenge on its Northren borders, and all energy should be behind bridging the gap vs. China. Very catchy - slogan " Leave Pak to Pak". Thanks, Shekhar- it's the best option in the current situation. 👍
to deal with Pakistan u must follow two rules
rule 1: never trust Pakistan in any circumstances and in any condition what so ever.
rule 2: always follow rule no 1 in any circumstances.
Correct.... Pakistan might want to talk to India presently due to its bad economic condition but it will again show it's colour once it come out of this condition...
Better. Be. ♥️ HEARTLESS.
Well. Said 👌👌👌👌👌
Very well articulated news Shekhar sir. Been in IT industry, but following the Pak afgan india affairs from last 15 years. This is very well summarised theory "leave pak to pak" and do not engaged with them . Awesome 👍
Awesome! like you ever got to engage with any Pakistani lol
@@Ak-wv7dt i don't engage. More than to talking with them . I like listening more to them from podcast to Twitter space to UA-cam.
Listening someone more let you know what is there in heart and mind and saves your energy.
@@Ak-wv7dt It doesn't matter how peaceful or kind a common Pakistani is, what matters is the policy of Pakistani state towards India which as of now is hostile.
M' continuously bothered by- what was the relevance of "been in IT industry" in your comment
@@manasgaya Once you do get to engage with Pakistanis on a personal level you will then realize that a common Pakistani doesnt have hatred towards an any indian vs the amounted of hatred and hostility you will find in an indian's heart against Pakistanis for having to lose a part of their land. As for Pakistanis it is shocking appalling disheartening when you see such hate filled comments directed towards Pakistani's whether it be the bjprss paid it cell or a common indian.
Finally Shekharji learning what MODIJI and RSS have been saying all along
RSS has been saying "all along" that we should leave Pak to Pak? What are you smoking??
@@shubs3566 In RSS defence they have been saying about the mindset of Pakistani's for a long time in opposition to the 'aman ki asha' gang. Only recently common people have understood the mentality of common pakistani's.
@@shubs3566 RSS is saying that Muslims in Pakistan believe that killing Hindus would book their place in heaven. Hence discussing peace with people wanting to kill you is foolish
Sir, i listen to you like a student of geo-politics of this region in particular. Your content, and analysis are so interesting and insightful, even an average person like me tends to understand it on the surface, seemingly. To which - I say thank you very much.
In earlier (various) episodes , vis a vis Pakistan-India, I remember media (Secular)pushing India for negotiations/talks with Pakistan ( keeping Discussions open)when Modi Govt. was so strong on it's policy with Pakistan..Now, asking keeping quiet ( which Govt.doing for quite long) ... Not sure if media(secular)changed it's stance or acknowledging it as right what Govt. was doing for quite some time.
First leave "Af to Pak"and now...
"Pak to Pak" after few months next video will be leave Pak to TTP 😂
Lol
In the mean time Pak is rescued by Dada (America).
The first one to accept partition of India was Sardar Patel. He told that when any body part get infection so severe that it can harm entire body. It must be cut down.
We see that.
They made nation based on religion.
Made history books full of hatred.
They put religion over science.
Now they suffer.
We mustn't lose our focus. Keep intact our own credentials else we will suffer.
Unfortunately some elements in is trying do the same in India with radical Islam and radical Hinduism
@@knightofgodserventofholymo7500 I agree. That is why I made the comment.
Gupta Ji is repeating the same mistake as Pakistan was not 66% richer than India (however this is overstated ) due to good economic policies, trade and industrialisation but due to influx of dollars from Kafir Americans first for joining Cinto Santo and later Afghan Jihaad to expel Russians.
It had always run on US, arabia generosity in past. US alone gave it $ 57 billions during first afghan jihad during Gen. zia 12 yrs rule and later $ 50 billions during mushraff era. And handouts from various arabian country during first summit of OIC. Otherwise this country is unfit for modern world for any business. There is only one industry in pakistan that is real estate.
Seems entire wealth and resources have been spent on islamabad instead of more provision on social spending. Thanks!
@@ranjaypandey4360 Spot on Ranjay Ji 👍
Finally Shekarji is accepting India's response, be it balakot or non-response.. This should be taken as back handed compliment of modi's administration. It's appreciating your own kid's academic performance by looking at neighbor kids dismal perfomance... Wonder at this time if Pakistan was doing economically good, what would be Shekarji's reaction of balakot or non-response.. (when Balakot happened.. anyways we know you had at best sceptic muted reaction)
One of the great National interest episode. Thank you professor of journalism Shekhar Gupta.🙏🙏🙏
In 10 mins Sir explained 72 points. Kudos
Good to know that Mr. Gupta reads the comments in his videos. Leave Pak to Pak was the overarching sentiment of viewers of his previous CTC on Pakistan.
Right
Excellent explanation, with the outstanding Cartoon.
Yes " Leave Pak to Pak "
Profound words of wisdom 🙏
Amazing artwork btw for the thumbnail, describes the situation straightaway
Amazing quality content as always. Thankyou Mr Gupta. I’ll always support your journalism.
@@Callingnone I have already bought their subscription from their website. I have been doing so since 2020.
100% agree with you Sir..Best response to Pakistan is No Response at all.
As usual great discussion 👍👍🙏
So well said👏🏻
superb analysis. And Hats off to whoever does the thumbnail illustrations, excellent work❤👌👌
Really well said Shekhar!!
Good speed :), clarity and some very interesting points!
With public peace talks there is always a threat of sabotage looming.
I have always been certain that interview was for the consumption of a certain audience, which did not include the populace of Pakistan. (verified by the needed clarification by the prime minister's office) After you said what you did, it made me realise that the audience was the powers that are in the middle east. To speak to the Indians he needed to pick up the phone and not give an interview.
Strategic hubris.... Perfect wording guptaji.... The real problem is whenever there are talks there are terror strikes in India and even this time the result will be the same... 100% leave pak to pak
Perfect analysis from an unbiased viewpoint as against some others who are clamoring for Pakistan friendship.
Very happy to see that the advocates for continuous dialogue are now realistic enough to allow Pakistan to go on its own way. While we may wish good times for the people of Pakistan, it is altogether different for us to allow the Pakistan authorities to intercede in our affairs by distracting continuously from our path of progress.
Mr. Shekhar Gupta's content is a delight. I love his journalism ! One of the sane and balanced voices we hear on the internet! Very well said about how to engage Pakistan at this juncture. While our hearts go out to all the ordinary people that are suffering, the power structure is as diabolical as ever. It is a horrendous snake pit that requires no concessions! Current situation is their own doing, bailing them out easily will send an absolutely wrong message.
Couldn't Have Said It Better... crisp analysis by Shekhar.
Yes give them no response at all . Govt. Wasting any more time on them is actually a bigger crime in my view
By talking Kasmir issue with India, will Pakistan's economy improve? Pakistan's Prime Minister has to answer this question first. How long Pakistan wants to cheat its own people. India shouldn't care about the calls.
Superb piece by Shekharji! Balanced and really focused on Indian good.
You have rightly said, let's see the dhamaka as a silent spectator
Well said. I am very hopeful, that the Indian government doesn't go soft here and goes for the throat.
Your thumbnail art man is very intelligent in describing the situation
Simply the most sensible episode on foreign policy by SG. Kudos Sir.
Hope our MEA & PMO are listening.
Can't agree more. Leave Pak to Pak. Never trust this neighbour!
Thats what I am also saying from last 2 to 3 years. Let the pakistan died in its own cocoon. As chanakya says "Do not disturbed your enemy when he is making mistakes "
The world will not let pakistannn collapseee...
Well said! Let the Pakistanis decide what kind of future they want for themselves! Why should we bother? If chaos comes there, let the radical Islamists and Taliban capture Pakistan! We have no problem as long as they seek peace with India! At least, those guys are not hypocrites and clearly state what they want- Sharia Implementation!
@@aryanhassan4659 Well that's up to the Afghan Taliban, TTP and the Baloch people! Stay safe and fed though!
@@aryanhassan4659 who told you this.?4 tukde honge pak ke dekh lena 👆😳
@@sohambanerjee99 I'm indiannnn....and stop acting as if india is a first world country...and what's the status of 80 crore people who get rations??? Lol.... people like u have audacity to call out others when we ourselves are not richhhhh.....smh
Brilliant punchy summary SG.
Your third bullet was the most significant one...' Relevance'...its squeezes the essence of Pak Geopolitics for last 7 decades
...and the parting line if 'Leave Pak to Pak' should sum up Indias Pak policy for next decade.
But important question is, How to we get PoK back?
We shouldn't be concerned about it. When Pak falls as it inevitably will, they will join us if wish to. If they don't want to then what's the point of forcing someone to be with you when they don't want to?
@@yomamasohot6411 abe chomu.Pok is our access to central asia without which we can never ever compete with china.Plus pak ne humesha block kiya hai India ko.2 saal pehle ki baat hai wheat ko block kiya tha afghanistan me hum bhej rahe the rab
@@jackyjones5626 People in Azad Kashmir don't want to be part of India.
Blessed to have you a gem of journalist, your knowledge, wisdom and insights are invaluable, you have the all the support from patriot Indians. Keep going...
Leave Pak to Pak. Excellent One of the Best quotes in recent times
"We don't need an enemy we have ISI" - A wise Pakistani quote
Salute Shekhar Sirji. Well said. I will subscribe your channel
For once, I fully agree with Mr.Gupta!!
Sekhar sir, wonderful to hear from a senior with decades of experience 🙏
Very well thought out piece. India needs to remain focused on its own development and strategic ambitions and not get distracted by Pakistan, which has nothing but nuisance value. But, India must always remain vigilant and ready to respond militarily or otherwise to any misadventures by Pakistan
Very good initiative. Thank you for wonderful Bharat Jodo Yatra. God bless you and all Indians.
"Its better to be heartless for now" - BANG!! Nail on the head
Great analysis. It’s not the time to budge. Let it settle down. Pak is desperate and we must not take the bait. Or settle it all at our conditions. After pak elections.
It is good that the Pakistans are fighting war to each other. Not a sweat for Us 🙂. Karma hits back. Pakistan terrorism backfires to Pakistan. Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🙂🤝
Great thought leave pak to pak
This Sanghi here, completely agree with your assessment - leave Pak to Pak, for now.
Never interrupt your enemy which he is doing mistake: napoleon
Gupta ji deserves Padma for National Interest ✌️
Well said, sir. I second you. "Best response is no response"
First leave Af to Pak and now leave Pak to Pak 😂 and what will be the next ?
Next there won’t be a Pakistan maybe he will say leave them with balochistan or FATA or Sindh province 😂😂
Leave PAK ,SL other SAARC to china.Let them deal with people there.
Despite all the mess and all the economic failures, Pakistan is an amazingly resilient country , I must say .
You can say whatever you want
Of course it’s resilient. It’s like a cockroach, went to IMF for loans 23 times went for IMF bailout 13 times. Every time those Gulf nations or USA arrives to save this cockroach when it is in its death bed. Even now US along with Gulf nations and Western European nations have announced to lend 10 billion while when Sri lanka was going through similar crisis no gulf or US came forward to help.
Ghanta resilient .Pura pak usa and saudi ke funding me pal raha tha.Jaise hi funding band hua Goo khane lage pakis.Sadak ke kutte ki tarah hai pak
It's not Pakistan's resilience but the World's 💰
Brilliant insight...well coined '...pak to pak'👌🙏
Perfectly PUT. As it happened after the 1971 war when Pak requested peace and said they do not want any further wars with India. They just wanted to buy time and get back up again. Instead of Direct war Pak decide to play Proxy war by indulging in cross border terrorism. They did not stop the war but only the war tactics. Mr. Shekhar Gupta said it very correctly. India had enough from Pak and anyways there is no gain for India.
It's in India's interest to make Pakistan remained on the same path of security state. And it needs timely measured and adequate provocation from India. And Modi's recent statement is right in terms of time, situation and long term strategic interests of India. It's a psychological game as well.
For the first time Shekhar is talking sensibly
Totally agreed!!!
Brilliant. Loved it. Thank you.
Only the "Aman ki aasha" gang keeps tabs on Pak. Even BCCI's Women IPL has fetched 10 times the amount of PSL's broadcasting rights. Kohli's specs alone will cost more than the salaries of the entire PSL roster. Forget India, even Afghanistan doesn't want to compare itself with Pak. SG should take the advice himself. He is the one wasting at least 2-3 Ctc episodes on Pak.
We shouldn't interfere but we should OBSERVE. You are suggesting we should stop observing and bury our heads in the sand like an ostrich ???
@@orkkojit OBSERVE, Yes. OBSESS, Big NO. The chief architect of Pak's destruction, Imran Khan Niazi, is seen by the masses as possible saviour. India should leave the country to its own fate. No need for any Herogiri or Gandhigiri.
*Excerpts from American Intelligence preparation of battlefield (IPB) Manual:Role of Sharia in war.*
In Islamic Law, Muslim fighting forces may only call for a truce when they are in a position of weakness and require time to resupply and rebuild forces.
Quran verse 47:35:-"So do not be fainthearted and call for peace when it's you are the uppermost."
Our forefathers were forced to pay Jizya.
Yet we are unaware of taqiyya.
time to make them randiya
Whole Quran was made to support Muhammad's lust and criminal acts
Ya
Thank you, Shekar, for a wonderful insight into the state of affairs of our esteemed neighbor. It was music to my ears to hear you say URI and BALAKOT attack called on PAK bluff. What does all these tell us, we have a strong leadership, and India is under safe hands. My bet is that the current leadership will not pay heed to Pak overtures.
Very meticulous, near perfect analysis..... You are very right in saying let the people of Pakistan decide what is better for them...Army or democracy....👌🏻👌🏻
No need for talks, let Paxtan disintegrate organically. We should fund separatist movement in Paxtan be it sindh, Balochistan, PoK and KPK. Ones Pakistan loses these territories and only Punjab remains they will come to India themselves.
another brilliant analysis after pak to pak!! wow!! height of brilliance on the other side of the border! LMAO ☕👍 🙈🙉🙊😝😂🤣😂 🤣😂🤣
We should first worry about north east india....and Naga separatist.....as well as the red corridor..?
@@aryanhassan4659 we should worry about rabid Pakistani sympathizers in india
@@abhimanyujha5550 nice reply 🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@aryanhassan4659 ya ur pedophile prophet is supporting them right😅😁
In the context of India - pakistan relations, blood will always flow either in Islamabad or in Delhi. Indian govt has to decide where? Choose wisely.
Not after the Iron Dome is completed with the Help of Israel in the Western Borders of India, no more bloodshed on Indian side then.
@@VikramHalderkonVict
Lol.
You will use iron dome against target killings done by terrorists.
You high on drugs ?
@@VikramHalderkonVict cost effective solution is intense civil war in Pakistan
Nope! Now the bloodshed would be limited to Pak! It is entirely up to the Taliban, TTP and the Baloch people to decide the future of Pakistan- whether it will remain united as a nation or get split up! Don't worry, I will cry for Pakistan after its demise!
Very few times I agree with Coupta ji. This is one such rare occasion
Beautifully said, as always.
Strong and very sensible advice.
Leave pak to pak!
Absolutely 💯 % agree with Mr. Shekhar’s stand 🙏🇮🇳
Very well Said! And brilliant analysis...
Shekhar, you are at your very best when you cover Pakistan!!
Highly accurate analysis
With tonnes of logic .
Excellent analysis. Very precisely correct. Leave pak to pak. If you leave anything to pak it's guaranteed that they will mess it up. It's something about the working of their brains.
Brilliant, just brilliantly summarised Sir!
Spot on Shekhar Ji…
Thank you SG sir.