Yes, I imagine my younger self asking me if i became rich and famous and me laughing myself to death leaving my younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self then laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self then laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine whichthen laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self. Oh no, I've gone cross eyed.
@Daniel Appleton There was this old twilight zone. This guy stopped on the side of a road next to an empty gas station. Hearing the unmistakable sound behind the gas station he naturally followed it. As he slowly approached he saw a man somewhat blocking the road. He recognized the carnival and the man. It was his dad. They stopped to chat and not too far off in the distance a young boy was playing. It was himself. He asked his dad if he could go say something to him. His dad thought long and hard and replied "No son, let him be. You've had your summer let him have his". That older man himself respected his dad's wishes and told him he loved him. Something he always wanted to say but never got a chance. They hugged and and dad replied the same. He walked away and the carnival disappeared. Best lesson I've ever remembered from a TV show. If I ever go back in time.. I've had my summer.
@Matthew Caughey >>>> It's nice to think of but you can't do that. Anything you say could disrupt your life. Remember Picard in "Tapestry"? He said that he pulled that loose thread on the tapestry of his life and the whole thing unraveled.
This is one of those rare scenes where we can see a character at both the beginning AND the end of his character arc in the same moment. Spock Prime has reconciled his human and Vulcan halves and is comfortable with both while the younger Spock is still wrestling with the fact that he is a child of two worlds and that one of those worlds has been virtually obliterated. Time travel stories can be confusing, but they can also give awesome moments like this one!
Time traveling to your past self, *if done right,* can be the most helpfull thing both of you can ever have. Not reccomended, but that small sliver of hope can be hope the world over.
And especially in this case, Spock Prime is a -POSSIBILITY- not a certainty. It gives hope for the character to gain balance and synergy without knee-capping the story-building tension. ...but then Into Darkness made death a mere inconvenience so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Actually... so called Prime Universe from which Spock came is still there (as Picard series and photo of the original ToS crew in their movie uniforms (which would NOT exist in first place if said prime timeline would dissapear) showed in Beyond Darkness proved) when Kelvin timeline is kind of paraler Universe to it.
Speakjng of the two worlds part, my favorite quote that spock says is “seeing as i am half Human that makes Earth the only home i have left”. Although he’s spent his entire life on Vulcan he has compassion for Earth because it is technically his home too.
Only Spock could convince Spock to do what feels right. His mother took forever to finally convince old Spock to embrace emotions healthily when needed. She saw the benefit of emotion tempered by logic and logic informed by emotion. Spock just taught himself this lesson without all the hardship he would need to face to learn it otherwise. And it def came in handy when facing Khan. Spock finally unloaded emotion
@joshcreek9531 no where did i say ye suffered no hardship. Maybe you never watched the original series and the 6 movies (5 if we dont count the motion picture)
Spock held that realization in _The Undiscovered Country_ when he inferred to Lieutenant Valeris that logic is an _instrument_ to obtain wisdom-- it is not the _product_ of wisdom. I would go further and conject that _emotion_ is yet another instrument in that pursuit. Well-timed utilization of both logic and passion (with a little guidance from your friends) serve to find that wisdom.
This is one of the nicest "passing of the torch" scenes in history. It has been said many times since that Zachary Quinto was nervous wreck during making of this scene and that there were concerns if he could pull it off, but reportedly they managed to make it in just one take.
@@staxmantim Working with a cinematic legend whose role I just HAPPEN TO BE PLAYING, my stomach would be in KNOTS, I'd sweat bullets & about to freaking PASS OUT.
"Because you needed each other. I could not deprive you of the revelation of all that you could accomplish together, of a friendship, that will define you both, in ways that you can not yet realize." My favorite line in the film.
To quote Dr McCoy from The Wrath of Khan: "He's really not dead, as long as we remember him." Rest in peace, Mr Nimoy. And thank you for all the great adventures. Live long and prosper.
Can't speak for other Trekkies, but I absolutely loved this scene. You see how the humanity and sensitivity of Kirk and McCoy have influenced Spock Prime's way of thinking: He imparts sound and gentle wisdom into his younger self, much like a loving human father would into his son. Very cool.
Leonard Nimoy first portrayed Spock in 1964, for the first Star Trek pilot. Network hated it. Too cerebral. No shoot-em-ups. NBC wanted The Great Bird to get rid of that bossy No.1 woman exec and that satanic looking, slightly green Spock. Rewrite the script too. Gene got rid of literally everything except the ship and Spock. Nobody that cares will ever forget Leonard Nimoy.... Ps. No1 came back as Nurse Chapel, Majel was Gene's wife at the time and all... RIP to 😢all the good crew of The Enterprise that are no longer with us... To absent friends... 😢
"I could not deprive your of the revelation of all that you could accomplish together. Of a friendship that will define you both, in ways you cannot yet realize." Beautiful summary of the Kirk/Spock friendship.
Kirk always said he knew he'd die alone...and he did. McCoy and Spock weren't there when he died. Yes, Picard was there but Picard wasn't his family. Kirk died without any of his family. He was alone.
I do now. I'm ashamed to admit that I never truly appreciated Leonard Nimoy until he was gone. Oh, I certainly THOUGHT I did. I admired and respected him. But I guess you just never truly know how valued people are until they... aren't anymore.
"Put aside logic...do what feels right " This line warmed my heart; I have watched some episodes and seasons of Star Trek the Original series; the past Spock would say it's illogical. So I am happy and proud he had grown from it
"I am not our father." Oh yes you were, Mr. Nimoy. You were the father of a great character, named Spock, and for many young boys you were a bit of a father figure, and a friend. We miss you, so much.
When Spock travelled back in time Sarik would have been deceased, as would have his Mother. Knowing I could see my Father again would bring me some personal stability after losing my planet. However the question of ‘How are our Mother and Father?’ would be devastating to both Spock’s no matter which one asked. For different reasons of course.
So many people try to say their decisions are based on logic (and of course there's even idiots who think you can use logic to "think away" feelings that "don't make sense"), but it's been proven to be impossible to make decisions without it being based on *some* underlying emotion
This film was my introduction to the Star Trek universe. I saw it when I was 9, and it blew me away. I then checked out the original series and its 6 feature films. The stories and characters of Star Trek resonate with me. Star Trek not only changed how I see storytelling, but it changed my life. Because of this, the Kelvin movies have always been special to me. Star Trek (2009) is the reason I became a fan.
Duuude me too! I was near the same age and in 4th grade a new student in my class saw me doodling the Enterprise and he introduced me to TOS TNG and the rest. That guy's been my best friend for 10 years now :)
0:38 This moment shows that even after his days with the Enterprise are done, Spock still fondly remember Kirk as being the one friend who helped make him the man he is.
"captain, you almost make me believe in luck." Spock in the original series, remembering that line, the fact he now wishes his alternative/young self good luck is so heartwarming :3
Man when I see Leonard in this film, I tear up every time. Just such a good performance. I really don't care if half the fan-base hates the reboot films, this film is incredible, and Leonard made it even better. It's a perfect farewell from him to us in his iconic role if you ask me. And Beyond was a perfect farewell to him. We miss you Leonard...
That tribute with the original crew (shatner, nimoy, and the gang), was the part i teared up. Cause nimoy has passed, and they even gave Quinto's spock the news and had him react. Beautiful tribute
"I could not deprive you of the revelation of all you could accomplish together. Of a friendship that will define you both in ways you cannot yet realize". Young Spock can't begin to imagine, this is only the beginning 🙂.
Of a friendship that will define you both in ways you could not yet realise. Not only for Kirk and Spock, not only for Pine and Quinto but for nearly 50 years, Shatner and Nimoy. Brothers in arms. Take great care Leonard Nimoy. Until next time.
I thought it was pretty cool they didn't just pretend TOS and it's movies never existed, but instead intertwined the two universes. Now that's a classy reboot.
J.J. Abrams must have had the easiest time of his career "directing" Leonard Nimoy. By that I mean, you don't direct a guy who's been playing the same character for about 50 years - you just give him his lines, point the camera, and say "action" and let the guy who knows the character best do the rest.
You should look at the bloopers for st4 and st5. In the fourth movie, McCoy says, "Well, nobody's perfect." Spock ponders a couple of seconds, gets an irritated look on his face and responds, "Oh, yeah?" In the fifth movie, Kirk says, "Let's see what she's got." Sulu responds, "Aye sir." As Kirk shifts in his seat, Spock says, "Get your hand off my leg." Hilarious on both counts!
If they have a good acting team the director lets them do what they do and they just piece it all together. Frequently it’s better if the director stays out of the way, in a matter of speaking
Spock always moves around the meaning of a lie. Whenever it came about he said a lie was: he exaggerated, an omission, an error. Then Valeris asked of lying and she says, "a choice". Love it.
Nimoy is playing it as though Spock has finally fully accepted his human side and freely allows his emotions to show without guilt or shame. And what's great is he's done this change very subtly slowly throughout the years. It's very Zen.
Death and being stuffed in a torpedo casing to bagpipes and then shot out of said casing into an atmosphere that all rights should have basically cremated him. Such things make you rethink your whole outlook.
Personally I am not a fan of the reboots, but this scene is awesome. I love seeing the comparison, how open Spock Prime is with emotion here, let it show on his face and in his voice, smiling with ease, which totally seemed to mystify his young counterpart. It's great to see how far Prime has come in embracing his human side.
He embraced after his father mind melded with Picard and Spock mind melded with Picard and felt through him what his father's true feelings for him were and that's when he truly felt at peace especially with his long lasting friendship with Kirk and the rest of his former starfleet comrades
If not for his appearance on "Into Darkness", this would've been the PERFECT cap-off to Nimoy's tenure as Spock. Saying goodbye, and wishing the new generation well. RIP good sir.
True, but think about the two Spock's conversation in Into Darkness: "Did you defeat him?" "At a great cost" If that isn't a fitting farewell I don't know what is.
Emmett Krantz I know. This scene from the '09 flick. His appearance in "Into Darkness" totally cheapened his appearance here. Like, this was his way of just letting the new crew do their thing. And the movie itself wanted to forge its own identity away from the original 60's continuity...... all of a sudden you have Spock asking Spock Prime what they did. Such a cheat. That basically suggests that if this new crew has ANY problems, they can just ask Spock Prime what they did in the situation. If there's any good that comes from Nimoy's passing (and this is in NO WAY a disrespet to him), it's that the writers can no longer rely on using his character for major plot points. Maybe it'll force them to come up with something fresh for these characters to deal with.
Rob C Well by Spock Prime's own admission he fully intended to stay out of the affairs and let them forge their own fate. But Khan was such a harbinger of damage that he felt compelled to give them the advice given he was considered their greatest adversary. particularlly with the rapid advancement as a consequence of Nero and Spock coming back in time, had Khan kept a hold on the Vengeance he would have reaved uncalculable damage across space. That said this is indeed a fantastic 'farewell' a few years ahead of schedule.
This scene is very symbolic: Leonard Nimoy was finally leaving the legendary role that he had played for almost fifty years, and passes the torch onto Zachary Quinto. Now he is gone. RIP Leonard Nimoy, you have earned it. As for you, Quinto, live up to the role of Spock, and Live Long and Prosper
I am 45 and grew up with the movies from Star Wars & Star Trek. I also watched every rerun that I could catch on TV about Star Trek. In my youth, there were no cable companies and satellite dishes available to those like us who just did not have the money. When we moved back into Tupelo, MS ( I was 12 ) my father had a great job that allowed us to get cable TV!! We were the first in our neighborhood and our house became a private theater!! LOL. Doctor Who and Star Trek, with all of the spin offs included of course, will always be my favorites. It is the year 2015 and many of my peers are pioneers of many current technologies being used today. The internet has allowed people like me to ( and you my fellow Trekkies ) to fully enjoy Mr. Nimoy's career as Mr. Spock and all of the things he was involved in. For those out there who look at us and shake their heads, they have no idea what is was like growing up with the cast of the original crew of the Enterprise. Thank you Mr. Nimoy for the many, many worlds that your character opened up to us.
I watched TOS as a boy. I think Spock is still one of the most beloved fictional characters of all time. I actually cried when he died in the Wrath of Khan. But the loss of Leonard Nimoy was a real tragedy. He was a truly great actor. The world is a sadder place without him.
+Jacqui Gawne dude the original series is one of the greatest tv shows ever, I'm not a trekkie but it sure did turn me into one. I thought it would be boring but boy was I wrong.
Same here. I never watched the TV series to begin with when I first watched this scene, which was brilliant. I watched movies II - IV first, then the 2009 reboot and Into Darkness in 2014 in the span of 4 days. In 2015, after watching Star Trek Beyond in the cinema, I completed the classic movies, watching I, V and VI. After I finished uni in November, I watched Star Trek movies VII - X. This year, I plan on watching Star Trek: The Original Series on Netflix, starting my fan experience as a Trekkie. :)
"Since my customary farewell would appear oddly self-serving, I shall simply say good luck." Fucking Spock, this character's vocabulary is one of my favorites in Trek next to Data.
ST-VI "Spock, you want to know something? Everybody's Human." "I find that remark.... Insulting." Nimoy brought an incredible character to life, an excellent character arc, and that one thing that is so important to a main character: Their discovery of their self makes us look at our own lives and motivations.
I absolutely love this scene. It is one of the most absolutely heart-wrenching scenes in Star trek history. The last time Leonard Nimoy portrayed Spock.
How beautiful, and I am grateful that Mr. Nimoy had the time with us to bring the role of Spock completely full circle--both in passing the role to the next generation, and in showing what is IMO the final reconciliation of Spock's human and Vulcan halves into one harmonious whole. The man he portrays here is one utterly at peace with himself, and that is such a gift to watch.
It is one of my greatest joys, to have been able to sit down at a table in a bar with Leonard Nimoy, have a drink with him and his wife, and talk about life. He was a wonderful person.
That moment at 0:53 is just so perfect, plays with the character without damaging it, Spock wouldn't lie but found the grey area and it's just such a brilliant piece of writing that kind of 'who me? never' kind of thing.
RIP Leonard Nimoy. I cry not only for his death, but also for my uncle who died of lung cancer and was such a great fan of the original show. Hi older sister (my mom) got me into TNG and I also saw the old show.
I was 14 years old when the original Star Trek series first aired. It was something amazing and new and terrific fun. I can't watch the above very nicely accomplished clip without finding tears in my eyes. Farewell to the old guard, welcome to the new, and as Spock says, good luck!
I can't even begin to describe how awesome this scene is. It's awesome how this scene essentially combines the new generation with the classic generation. It's awesome how Spock sets his time travel brother down the path of coming to terms with his humanity. It's awesome to see how Spock Prime has developed over the years. And it's awesome seeing the two give each other the peace sign! Granted it's a Vulcan symbol, but it's iconic all the same.
A truly heartfelt passing the torch from the original Spock to the new Spock! May Leonard Nimoy rest in peace and happy 50th anniversary to Star Trek. I sure hope Star Trek Beyond will be dedicated to Nimoy's memory
I'll never forget seeing this in theaters with my family. My dad grew up as a hard-core trekkie and I was new to it. So in the scene where Leonard Nimoy first shows up, my dad chuckles while sitting next to me, then leans over and says "That's the REAL Spock" before continuing to watch the film. 😂😂
As someone who saw TOS in its original run, I have to say this: JJ nailed it. While I didn’t agree with all his choices, I have to say that it’s clear he understood the closeness and feelings that people have for these characters. I support him and the films he made, and hopefully there are more to come.
well it took Ambassador Spock 150+ years, death, a forced mind meld with McCoy regeneration on Genesis, refusuion of his consciousness, retraining of his mind regaining lost memories, and fighting with his father all his life until said father died to do it. You'd learn to get comfortable with yourself too after all that.
***** Dying and resurrection and all the fun during and after said dying and resurrection of Older Spock is more than enough for most people to rethink a lot of things about life.
I don't know if you've ever watched the original series or the original Star Trek movies, but Spock was true to himself. The Spock from the future was EXACTLY the way young Spock was. Extremely logical to a fault and disciplined. All those many, many, many years with Kirk and crew mates have made him who he is today or as you see in the new movie....how he is in the future. That was a great ass scene.
"An act of faith... one that I hope you will repeat in the future at Starfleet." Yeah Spock, way to throw Kirk under the bus at the beginning of Into Darkness!
I'm guessing Spock was still trying to find his place in Starfleet, in his friendship with Kirk, and his own future when "Into Darkness" happened. He still didn't have complete faith in all three and therefore could not defy his own Vulcan sense of logic.
Yes, they clumsily tried to show that young Spock was still clinging to his Vulcan origins in terms of strict honesty, complete candor and complete obedience to the "rules". In the original series, Nimoy's Spock used to display these qualities by citing the astronomical odds they were facing, or citing how what they're doing is a complete violation of Starfleet regulations...esp the Prime Directive. Here they had Spock literally "betray" Kirk, when in fact, Kirk was indulging Spock's plan (itself a violation of the prime directive) to save the indigenous people of that planet by averting the volcano eruption. THIS Spock was doing it because Vulcan was destroyed and this Spock did NOT want to see it happen to other species. Nonetheless, this Spock did indeed throw Kirk under the bus...when he outted Kirk's actions (in saving Spock's life no less) to Pike!
Leonard Nimoy really takes it home... the actors from the original star trek have so far lived amazingly long lives... a lot longer than any other show of the era... I wonder if continued interest from fans keeps them socially engaged and always moving.. that's the answer to long life... happyness... staying active... people and expecting you to
Some from that era lived to be older even though they're not with us anymore of course back then a lot of actors were veterans of WWII, including the actors who played the original McCoy and Scotty in Star Trek TOS
Of all the actors I've watched over 50 years, Leonard Nimoy, and the character he brought so much life to, and in his own way influencing some of mine, especially my imagination as a child, he comes first above all others. Each of the original cast played a part in that as well because each had something different in the characters they portrayed that appealed to my young mind back in those days. But Mr. Nimoy / Spock came first... First star to the right, and straight on 'till morning. RIP...
Rest in peace, Mr. Leonard Nimoy. You have been, and always shall be, our friend. You have touched our hearts and souls over the years, and you shall not be forgotten. You have, as Ambassador Spock would say, lived long and prospered. And in our memories, you shall always live and prosper. That is a promise.
I love the dynamics in the scene. Showing how resolute the younger Spock is compared to the tempered wisdom and, "outside the box" thinking of his older self. Well done guys! ❤
Of all the souls that I have encountered yours was the most human. Thanks for your logic and your genius . I am and always shall be , your fan. You will never be dead as long as we remember You in the series and movies which is my proud collection on dvd and blu ray. Hope your soul is having FUN with Scotty and bones abroad the enterprise. May your journey to the stars and the final frontier be a peaceful one. Third star to right and on till morning. ...R.I.P . You take with you a piece of my childhood. Live long and prosper old friend.
I like that, because of how time travel works in this specific continuity, they don't worry about the dangers of meeting your future self. Because they openly acknowledge that this film takes place in an alternate reality separate from the original series and movies, so it's possible Red Matter time travel doesn't necessarily work like how it does in _Back to the Future_ or _Terminator._ Probably works the same way that it worked in _Avengers: Endgame_ and the _Dragon Ball_ series; multiverse theory. So, if anything happened to Kelvin timeline Spock, I doubt it'd have an affect on Spock Prime, because he's more from a different reality than just another time.
I believe Discovery outright confirmed this, they say there are three universes that run alongside one another, The Prime Timeline, The Mirror Universe and The Kelvin Timeline
I had the pleasure of seeing Mr. Nemoy in 1989 by accident. I was visiting Universal studios and he was there for a speaking engagement? Im not sure but i know i didn't know he was going to be there and i was so happy to see him and went to listen to him speak. He was the only star trek actor I had not seen up till that point. My mother took us to a lot of Star Trek conventions when I was a child.
I too had a chance encounter with him... I delivered a bunch of furniture to his house in Incline Village, and he was so happy to recieve it, he came down to sign the bill!😃👍
My Mother was at a charity event in LA years ago and he was there. She asked him if she called me if he'd leave a message, to which he agreed. I was supposed to be at work but was sick that day so I picked up. I was giddy like a little kid when I realized who it was and I think he got a chuckle out of the reaction. He was very nice. We talked for just a minute and at the end he said "Live long and prosper, Jackson". I just about dropped to the floor. It would have been nice to have a message from him to go back and listen to, but the memory and experience to get to talk to him even for a minute was far more valuable. I'll never forget it.
Lord I miss that man. He was such a important piece of my childhood. Lenard Nimoy I hope you are as happy in you new life as you made mine. Rest in joy, love and peace.❤
"Spock, in this case do yourself favor: Put aside logic. Do what feels right." My favorite scene in the movie. R.I.P. Leonard Nimoy, gone but not forgotten.
“Since my customary farewell would appear oddly self serving, I will simply say, good luck.”
Hell of a line, RIP Leonard
I always took that line as Leonard nimoy passing the torch and saying good luck with the role
I also see it as a reference to the line in tos where he says ‘Captain you almost make me believe in luck’ an absolutely amazing scene
“Live long and prosp…. Oh wait I already am” 😂
Columbo still locked him up though.
@@highlander723, role.
Imagine meeting yourself from the future and all he tells you is that you’re gonna be besties with that annoying guy who led a mutiny against you
Yes, I imagine my younger self asking me if i became rich and famous and me laughing myself to death leaving my younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self then laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self then laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine whichthen laughing himself to death leaving his younger self with mental problems which results in him designing a time machine which results in contacting his past self. Oh no, I've gone cross eyed.
This cracks me up! Lol
@Daniel Appleton
There was this old twilight zone. This guy stopped on the side of a road next to an empty gas station.
Hearing the unmistakable sound behind the gas station he naturally followed it.
As he slowly approached he saw a man somewhat blocking the road. He recognized the carnival and the man. It was his dad. They stopped to chat and not too far off in the distance a young boy was playing.
It was himself.
He asked his dad if he could go say something to him.
His dad thought long and hard and replied "No son, let him be. You've had your summer let him have his".
That older man himself respected his dad's wishes and told him he loved him. Something he always wanted to say but never got a chance.
They hugged and and dad replied the same.
He walked away and the carnival disappeared.
Best lesson I've ever remembered from a TV show. If I ever go back in time.. I've had my summer.
@Daniel Appleton
I'll watch it. It's scratching a memory but I don't remember it.
Thanks.
@Matthew Caughey >>>> It's nice to think of but you can't do that. Anything you say could disrupt your life. Remember Picard in "Tapestry"? He said that he pulled that loose thread on the tapestry of his life and the whole thing unraveled.
This is one of those rare scenes where we can see a character at both the beginning AND the end of his character arc in the same moment. Spock Prime has reconciled his human and Vulcan halves and is comfortable with both while the younger Spock is still wrestling with the fact that he is a child of two worlds and that one of those worlds has been virtually obliterated. Time travel stories can be confusing, but they can also give awesome moments like this one!
Time traveling to your past self, *if done right,* can be the most helpfull thing both of you can ever have. Not reccomended, but that small sliver of hope can be hope the world over.
And especially in this case, Spock Prime is a -POSSIBILITY- not a certainty. It gives hope for the character to gain balance and synergy without knee-capping the story-building tension.
...but then Into Darkness made death a mere inconvenience so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Actually... so called Prime Universe from which Spock came is still there (as Picard series and photo of the original ToS crew in their movie uniforms (which would NOT exist in first place if said prime timeline would dissapear) showed in Beyond Darkness proved) when Kelvin timeline is kind of paraler Universe to it.
Speakjng of the two worlds part, my favorite quote that spock says is “seeing as i am half Human that makes Earth the only home i have left”. Although he’s spent his entire life on Vulcan he has compassion for Earth because it is technically his home too.
well said.
Only Spock could convince Spock to do what feels right. His mother took forever to finally convince old Spock to embrace emotions healthily when needed. She saw the benefit of emotion tempered by logic and logic informed by emotion.
Spock just taught himself this lesson without all the hardship he would need to face to learn it otherwise.
And it def came in handy when facing Khan. Spock finally unloaded emotion
Tell my mother I feel fine.
@@charlotteb6898 GOOD CALLBACK to Star Trek 4. 1 of my favorites with the originals.
His mom is dead, his planet is destroyed and his species is on the brink of extinction. Yeah, no hardship there at all...
@joshcreek9531 no where did i say ye suffered no hardship. Maybe you never watched the original series and the 6 movies (5 if we dont count the motion picture)
Spock held that realization in _The Undiscovered Country_ when he inferred to Lieutenant Valeris that logic is an _instrument_ to obtain wisdom-- it is not the _product_ of wisdom.
I would go further and conject that _emotion_ is yet another instrument in that pursuit. Well-timed utilization of both logic and passion (with a little guidance from your friends) serve to find that wisdom.
This is one of the nicest "passing of the torch" scenes in history. It has been said many times since that Zachary Quinto was nervous wreck during making of this scene and that there were concerns if he could pull it off, but reportedly they managed to make it in just one take.
Leonard Nimoy was very supportive and acted as a bit of a mentor toward Zachary. Over time, they became good friends.
@@captainpharaoh I would expect nothing less from Original Spock.
Apparently Nimoy pulled it off in one take. I don’t know what Quinto was doing
@@staxmantim Working with a cinematic legend whose role I just HAPPEN TO BE PLAYING, my stomach would be in KNOTS, I'd sweat bullets & about to freaking PASS OUT.
Then the ZQ in search of omg it was so good
This was the time when reboots were not evil, shadow controlled dividers of the race of man
"Because you needed each other. I could not deprive you of the revelation of all that you could accomplish together, of a friendship, that will define you both, in ways that you can not yet realize." My favorite line in the film.
"I have been, and always shall be, your friend."
@@CommanderZoom In any universe.
To quote Dr McCoy from The Wrath of Khan: "He's really not dead, as long as we remember him." Rest in peace, Mr Nimoy. And thank you for all the great adventures. Live long and prosper.
So say we all
Reminds me of a mandalorian proverb "we remember him so he is eternal. Eternal until the last of us are forgotten"
@@vegaobscurax23 so say we all
That was because McCoy had a very special memory of him.
@@vegaobscurax23 BSG reference, but I agree.
Can't speak for other Trekkies, but I absolutely loved this scene. You see how the humanity and sensitivity of Kirk and McCoy have influenced Spock Prime's way of thinking: He imparts sound and gentle wisdom into his younger self, much like a loving human father would into his son. Very cool.
Never liked any of the new Trek movies, but every scene with Mr Nimoy is always perfect
"Do yourself a favor..." Nimoy sounded like himself here, a wise Jewish dad.
The late, the undeniably great Leonard Nimoy. May his legacy never be forgotten 🖖
Live long and prosper
@@cross-zevol4056 Peace and long life
Leonard Nimoy first portrayed Spock in 1964, for the first Star Trek pilot. Network hated it. Too cerebral. No shoot-em-ups. NBC wanted The Great Bird to get rid of that bossy No.1 woman exec and that satanic looking, slightly green Spock. Rewrite the script too. Gene got rid of literally everything except the ship and Spock. Nobody that cares will ever forget Leonard Nimoy.... Ps. No1 came back as Nurse Chapel, Majel was Gene's wife at the time and all... RIP to 😢all the good crew of The Enterprise that are no longer with us... To absent friends... 😢
🖖🏻
Yes. I must be getting old as this clip brought a tear to my eye
"I could not deprive your of the revelation of all that you could accomplish together. Of a friendship that will define you both, in ways you cannot yet realize."
Beautiful summary of the Kirk/Spock friendship.
RIP Leonard Nimoy,you were the first and the best of the Vulcans!
+Charlie Dunes RIP and God Bless Leonard Nemoy.
Live Long and Prosper (or Good Luck).
Livin up in New Zealand Kia Ora Right on.
+Trekkie in New Zealand Kia Ora - Live Long and Prosper
Daniel Appleton I though Ambassador Soval (from Star Trek: Enteprise) was the first Vulcan ambassador to Earth.
It breaks my father's heart as well as mine. R.I.P Leonard Nimoy. Live Long and Prosper.
When he mentions their "friendship" it just brings tears to my eyes because you realize how much it meant to him
Of course. In his original future, only one of his friends- Scotty - is still alive after being in transporter limbo for decades.
They were brothers.
Powerful stuff….
@@johnnyd3158 yessir ❤️
Kirk always said he knew he'd die alone...and he did.
McCoy and Spock weren't there when he died. Yes, Picard was there but Picard wasn't his family. Kirk died without any of his family. He was alone.
RIP Leonard Nimoy, a man who lived up to his catchphrase.
Since my customary farewell would appear oddly self-serving, I shall simply say, "Good luck."
The moment when Leonard Nimoy turned around... Did anyone shed a tear while watching their meeting or is it just me?
When I saw this in the theater, I cried with this scene.
I pray that Zachary Quinto savors this scene as much as the rest of us do.
Oh, yeah. Tears streaked down my cheeks.
I was expecting Quinton to mutter “fascinating”
I do now. I'm ashamed to admit that I never truly appreciated Leonard Nimoy until he was gone. Oh, I certainly THOUGHT I did. I admired and respected him. But I guess you just never truly know how valued people are until they... aren't anymore.
"Put aside logic...do what feels right "
This line warmed my heart; I have watched some episodes and seasons of Star Trek the Original series; the past Spock would say it's illogical. So I am happy and proud he had grown from it
"I am not our father."
Oh yes you were, Mr. Nimoy. You were the father of a great character, named Spock, and for many young boys you were a bit of a father figure, and a friend. We miss you, so much.
OpenMawProductions and you know they were boys
For many young girls too!
Even father to some who had none
Luke. I am your father....
Nnnnooooo.....!
That's impossible!!!!
When Spock travelled back in time Sarik would have been deceased, as would have his Mother. Knowing I could see my Father again would bring me some personal stability after losing my planet. However the question of ‘How are our Mother and Father?’ would be devastating to both Spock’s no matter which one asked. For different reasons of course.
No other actor will ever portray Spock as perfectly as Nimoy
Yeah, old school is unbeatable. Still, Zachary Quinto is better looking.
@Andrew Layton He does fine as a Vulcan, not as a Spock.
@Andrew Layton I agree. He did a fantastic job. Got the character of a young spot perfect. In fact all the lead actors in this were great.
yes Rest in Power Leonard Nimoy, we missyou
So true
"Put aside logic, and do what feels right." Wise words Spock, wise words.
+Semeroth21 why is spock talking to spock??
+Ben noneofyourbeeswax Watch the movie and find out.
So many people try to say their decisions are based on logic (and of course there's even idiots who think you can use logic to "think away" feelings that "don't make sense"), but it's been proven to be impossible to make decisions without it being based on *some* underlying emotion
Indeed, and also strong echoes of his talk with Valeris in Star Trek 6: "Logic is the beginning of wisdom, not the end."
Semeroth21 after 200+ years, death, rebirth and cowboy diplomacy, a man tends to have a much different attitude about life in general
This film was my introduction to the Star Trek universe. I saw it when I was 9, and it blew me away. I then checked out the original series and its 6 feature films. The stories and characters of Star Trek resonate with me. Star Trek not only changed how I see storytelling, but it changed my life. Because of this, the Kelvin movies have always been special to me. Star Trek (2009) is the reason I became a fan.
Welcome to the family. :)
Duuude me too! I was near the same age and in 4th grade a new student in my class saw me doodling the Enterprise and he introduced me to TOS TNG and the rest. That guy's been my best friend for 10 years now :)
Omg, that’s the same with me! 🖖
@@lucinavonnolaran8728 Thanks! :)
@@coloradoavocado6632
That’s a good friend.
0:38
This moment shows that even after his days with the Enterprise are done, Spock still fondly remember Kirk as being the one friend who helped make him the man he is.
R.I.P. Mr. Nimoy.
+Doom Victor Amen
May Mr. Nimoy rest in paradise. I miss him 😔
"captain, you almost make me believe in luck." Spock in the original series, remembering that line, the fact he now wishes his alternative/young self good luck is so heartwarming :3
Man when I see Leonard in this film, I tear up every time. Just such a good performance. I really don't care if half the fan-base hates the reboot films, this film is incredible, and Leonard made it even better. It's a perfect farewell from him to us in his iconic role if you ask me.
And Beyond was a perfect farewell to him.
We miss you Leonard...
That tribute with the original crew (shatner, nimoy, and the gang), was the part i teared up. Cause nimoy has passed, and they even gave Quinto's spock the news and had him react. Beautiful tribute
I teared up too when Quinto's Spock looked at that original cast picture.
I seriously wonder how they will now handle Chekov replacement for the next movie...
Przemyslaw Kuszynski They won't recast him.
Asheer JJ said he doesn't have the heart to replace Anton and he can't find anyone to fill Anton's shoes.
Star Wars: I am your father
Star Trek: I am not our father
Star Trek: Somehow Khan Survived
Star Wars: Somehow Palpatine Survived
@@AzguardMike Somehow Khan survived? What're you talking about?
@Azguard Mike 2013 i dont understand. Somehow, khan survived?
They are his mother and they's pronouns are it and them. lmfao.
Didn't he get refroze, or was that just his minions?
"I could not deprive you of the revelation of all you could accomplish together. Of a friendship that will define you both in ways you cannot yet realize".
Young Spock can't begin to imagine, this is only the beginning 🙂.
of the end of the reboot
@@dougclark9921*requel
Of a friendship that will define you both in ways you could not yet realise.
Not only for Kirk and Spock, not only for Pine and Quinto but for nearly 50 years, Shatner and Nimoy. Brothers in arms.
Take great care Leonard Nimoy. Until next time.
And Quinto & Nimoy
and shrek and donkey
@Liam Berg (STUDENT) live long and prosper
Pine and Quinto are actually good friends too, that's what makes it so great
Too bad SHATner ruined that friendship, and never attempted to reconcile before Nimoy died.
Is it just me, or did Spock Prime mellow out as he got older? He's rather bouncy.
At this point, Spock Prime seemed to be more of a kind-hearted grandfather who would end up reading to children.
Oh, yes, he is at least 140 years old at this point.
I did say "at least." I didn't stop to make the calculations.
he's been through a lot, especially with the stuffs with Romulan and the supernova.
Blame it on Kirk lol.
I thought it was pretty cool they didn't just pretend TOS and it's movies never existed, but instead intertwined the two universes. Now that's a classy reboot.
You wouldn't think so given how much pissing and moaning trekkies do about it.
That said, I agree.
@@Savage-- IMO that's literally the best thing about the storyline. Not very often you see a movie that's both a reboot AND a continuation.
I’m happy they did that to
@@Savage-- Yeah I don't get it. I've been a big star trek fan my whole life and loved this reboot. Star trek discovery not so much.
Bitchslapper316 you can’t make everyone happy to me this reboot is awsome I love that they had the original Spock in it
One of the best scenes in the entire movie series. We miss you, Mr. Nimoy.
J.J. Abrams must have had the easiest time of his career "directing" Leonard Nimoy. By that I mean, you don't direct a guy who's been playing the same character for about 50 years - you just give him his lines, point the camera, and say "action" and let the guy who knows the character best do the rest.
Not to mention Nimoy was himself directing tv & film when Abrams was still in high school.
You should look at the bloopers for st4 and st5. In the fourth movie, McCoy says, "Well, nobody's perfect." Spock ponders a couple of seconds, gets an irritated look on his face and responds, "Oh, yeah?"
In the fifth movie, Kirk says, "Let's see what she's got." Sulu responds, "Aye sir." As Kirk shifts in his seat, Spock says, "Get your hand off my leg." Hilarious on both counts!
Although Leonard Nimoy acted this way during the second and third season of the original series infuriating directors
If they have a good acting team the director lets them do what they do and they just piece it all together. Frequently it’s better if the director stays out of the way, in a matter of speaking
He IS Spock.
"Since my customary farewell would be oddly self-serving...."
XD
👍😆
😁😁😁
V :)
🖖🏼
It's not literally the same him though.
You lied.
Oh...I implied
Vs.
You lied.
I exaggerated.
An act of faith. /:)
Hours instead of minutes
Kirk would be so proud
Spock always moves around the meaning of a lie. Whenever it came about he said a lie was: he exaggerated, an omission, an error. Then Valeris asked of lying and she says, "a choice". Love it.
@@SupermanKalL The omission was my favorite growing up, Spock has always been low key cheeky and loved him for it and so much more.
Nimoy is playing it as though Spock has finally fully accepted his human side and freely allows his emotions to show without guilt or shame. And what's great is he's done this change very subtly slowly throughout the years. It's very Zen.
When the old Spock embraces his human side while the young Spock doesn't understand his.
Death and being stuffed in a torpedo casing to bagpipes and then shot out of said casing into an atmosphere that all rights should have basically cremated him. Such things make you rethink your whole outlook.
This scene and the one in Beyond after Spock and McCoy crash land were the two most memorable scenes of the franchise.
McCoy wipes a tear.
"He.......... He's dead Jim."
RIP Leonard Nimoy you have been and always shall be our friend.
Personally I am not a fan of the reboots, but this scene is awesome. I love seeing the comparison, how open Spock Prime is with emotion here, let it show on his face and in his voice, smiling with ease, which totally seemed to mystify his young counterpart. It's great to see how far Prime has come in embracing his human side.
Counts his "blessing" to have failed that Kholinar ritual I'll wager.
He embraced after his father mind melded with Picard and Spock mind melded with Picard and felt through him what his father's true feelings for him were and that's when he truly felt at peace especially with his long lasting friendship with Kirk and the rest of his former starfleet comrades
I do like this movie, it has character. Others were meh.
Bro it's not a reboot, Spock is literally in the scene with himself....
The actors in the reboots are really good, they deserved better.
If not for his appearance on "Into Darkness", this would've been the PERFECT cap-off to Nimoy's tenure as Spock. Saying goodbye, and wishing the new generation well.
RIP good sir.
True, but think about the two Spock's conversation in Into Darkness:
"Did you defeat him?"
"At a great cost"
If that isn't a fitting farewell I don't know what is.
Emmett Krantz I know. This scene from the '09 flick. His appearance in "Into Darkness" totally cheapened his appearance here. Like, this was his way of just letting the new crew do their thing. And the movie itself wanted to forge its own identity away from the original 60's continuity...... all of a sudden you have Spock asking Spock Prime what they did. Such a cheat. That basically suggests that if this new crew has ANY problems, they can just ask Spock Prime what they did in the situation. If there's any good that comes from Nimoy's passing (and this is in NO WAY a disrespet to him), it's that the writers can no longer rely on using his character for major plot points. Maybe it'll force them to come up with something fresh for these characters to deal with.
Rob C Well by Spock Prime's own admission he fully intended to stay out of the affairs and let them forge their own fate. But Khan was such a harbinger of damage that he felt compelled to give them the advice given he was considered their greatest adversary.
particularlly with the rapid advancement as a consequence of Nero and Spock coming back in time, had Khan kept a hold on the Vengeance he would have reaved uncalculable damage across space.
That said this is indeed a fantastic 'farewell' a few years ahead of schedule.
This scene is very symbolic: Leonard Nimoy was finally leaving the legendary role that he had played for almost fifty years, and passes the torch onto Zachary Quinto. Now he is gone. RIP Leonard Nimoy, you have earned it. As for you, Quinto, live up to the role of Spock, and Live Long and Prosper
I am 45 and grew up with the movies from Star Wars & Star Trek. I also watched every rerun that I could catch on TV about Star Trek. In my youth, there were no cable companies and satellite dishes available to those like us who just did not have the money. When we moved back into Tupelo, MS ( I was 12 ) my father had a great job that allowed us to get cable TV!! We were the first in our neighborhood and our house became a private theater!! LOL. Doctor Who and Star Trek, with all of the spin offs included of course, will always be my favorites. It is the year 2015 and many of my peers are pioneers of many current technologies being used today. The internet has allowed people like me to ( and you my fellow Trekkies ) to fully enjoy Mr. Nimoy's career as Mr. Spock and all of the things he was involved in. For those out there who look at us and shake their heads, they have no idea what is was like growing up with the cast of the original crew of the Enterprise. Thank you Mr. Nimoy for the many, many worlds that your character opened up to us.
R.I.P Leonnard Nimoy
Live long and prosper.
I watched TOS as a boy. I think Spock is still one of the most beloved fictional characters of all time. I actually cried when he died in the Wrath of Khan.
But the loss of Leonard Nimoy was a real tragedy. He was a truly great actor. The world is a sadder place without him.
I never watched the original Star Trek and I still got chills from this scene
To be honest, I never watched the original Star Trek before I first watched this scene either.
+Jacqui Gawne dude the original series is one of the greatest tv shows ever, I'm not a trekkie but it sure did turn me into one. I thought it would be boring but boy was I wrong.
***** Cheesy? no its ahead of its time
Same here. I never watched the TV series to begin with when I first watched this scene, which was brilliant. I watched movies II - IV first, then the 2009 reboot and Into Darkness in 2014 in the span of 4 days. In 2015, after watching Star Trek Beyond in the cinema, I completed the classic movies, watching I, V and VI. After I finished uni in November, I watched Star Trek movies VII - X. This year, I plan on watching Star Trek: The Original Series on Netflix, starting my fan experience as a Trekkie. :)
John Smith Leonard Nimoy as Spock gives you that feeling that you’ve known him all your life. That’s how good he’s acting is, or was. RIP.
Godspeed, you magnificent *Human* Being.
kuribayashi84
Dude, he's *Half* human! :P
Farewell, Leonard Nimoy. RIP :)
"Since my customary farewell would appear oddly self-serving, I shall simply say good luck."
Fucking Spock, this character's vocabulary is one of my favorites in Trek next to Data.
Jesus, I know. "universe ending paradoxes" "Oh, I implied." "I've already located a suitable planet to establish a vulcan colony"
Detroit, Michigan?
I loved how the "Oh, I implied" ties back to the "I exaggerated" line in Wrath of Khan.
I love how Leonard’s Spock has become okay and even embracing his humanity.
ST-VI "Spock, you want to know something? Everybody's Human."
"I find that remark.... Insulting."
Nimoy brought an incredible character to life, an excellent character arc, and that one thing that is so important to a main character: Their discovery of their self makes us look at our own lives and motivations.
I absolutely love this scene. It is one of the most absolutely heart-wrenching scenes in Star trek history. The last time Leonard Nimoy portrayed Spock.
He did play him again in Into Darkness for a brief one scene cameo.
How beautiful, and I am grateful that Mr. Nimoy had the time with us to bring the role of Spock completely full circle--both in passing the role to the next generation, and in showing what is IMO the final reconciliation of Spock's human and Vulcan halves into one harmonious whole. The man he portrays here is one utterly at peace with himself, and that is such a gift to watch.
The passing of the Torch....
I was looking for a comment like this.
This whole scene felt like it was passing on the torch, from the old generation to the new one.
RIP Mr. Nimoy you lived long and you prospered.
It is one of my greatest joys, to have been able to sit down at a table in a bar with Leonard Nimoy, have a drink with him and his wife, and talk about life. He was a wonderful person.
How did you arrange that? Lucky
tell us more!
Wow.... Kind of a gift from God to be able to chat with him.
Spock / Leonard just seemed like such wise souls
Rest in Peace Mr. Nimoy. We all miss you very much.
RIP Leonard Nimoy, we'll never forget you man.
"I cannot deprive you of the revelation of all that you could accomplish together. Of the friendship that defined you both." Melts my heart.
And then I wanna cry.
You have been and always shall be our friend Mr. Spock. RIP...
That moment at 0:53 is just so perfect, plays with the character without damaging it, Spock wouldn't lie but found the grey area and it's just such a brilliant piece of writing that kind of 'who me? never' kind of thing.
Leonard Nimoy has such a rare warmth. Seeing him as Spock Prime brings a lot of comfort to my not so inner child.
Goodbye, Mr. Nimoy ... We will all miss you dearly ...
RIP Leonard Nimoy. I cry not only for his death, but also for my uncle who died of lung cancer and was such a great fan of the original show. Hi older sister (my mom) got me into TNG and I also saw the old show.
I was 14 years old when the original Star Trek series first aired. It was something amazing and new and terrific fun. I can't watch the above very nicely accomplished clip without finding tears in my eyes. Farewell to the old guard, welcome to the new, and as Spock says, good luck!
RIP Leonard Nimoy.
I can't even begin to describe how awesome this scene is. It's awesome how this scene essentially combines the new generation with the classic generation. It's awesome how Spock sets his time travel brother down the path of coming to terms with his humanity. It's awesome to see how Spock Prime has developed over the years. And it's awesome seeing the two give each other the peace sign! Granted it's a Vulcan symbol, but it's iconic all the same.
Yes.
Spock is one of the greatest characters ever, regardless of the media. Just amazing.
A truly heartfelt passing the torch from the original Spock to the new Spock! May Leonard Nimoy rest in peace and happy 50th anniversary to Star Trek. I sure hope Star Trek Beyond will be dedicated to Nimoy's memory
Cássia Reis Your welcome
Finally someone who understands the new Star Trek
We miss you Leonard. Say hi to Gene, DeForest and James for us!
I'll never forget seeing this in theaters with my family. My dad grew up as a hard-core trekkie and I was new to it.
So in the scene where Leonard Nimoy first shows up, my dad chuckles while sitting next to me, then leans over and says "That's the REAL Spock" before continuing to watch the film. 😂😂
I sound as bad as him when watching Ghostbusters Afterlife. I was excitedly telling him about the cameos. T'was magic as this was too.
As someone who saw TOS in its original run, I have to say this: JJ nailed it. While I didn’t agree with all his choices, I have to say that it’s clear he understood the closeness and feelings that people have for these characters. I support him and the films he made, and hopefully there are more to come.
Amazing how much more personality Ambassador Spock has. His speech patterns, mannerisms, makes his younger self look like a fucking robot.
Daniel Appleton Definitely.
well it took Ambassador Spock 150+ years, death, a forced mind meld with McCoy regeneration on Genesis, refusuion of his consciousness, retraining of his mind regaining lost memories, and fighting with his father all his life until said father died to do it. You'd learn to get comfortable with yourself too after all that.
***** Dying and resurrection and all the fun during and after said dying and resurrection of Older Spock is more than enough for most people to rethink a lot of things about life.
I don't know if you've ever watched the original series or the original Star Trek movies, but Spock was true to himself. The Spock from the future was EXACTLY the way young Spock was. Extremely logical to a fault and disciplined. All those many, many, many years with Kirk and crew mates have made him who he is today or as you see in the new movie....how he is in the future. That was a great ass scene.
considering Spock and Data met each other and had a sort of kinship, you are not far off.
Good luck in the next life Mr Spock :( RIP Leonard Nimoy "Long Live and Prosper"
R.I.P Mr. Nemoy. You are a legend, and will always be.
The single most defining character in science fiction,everyone knows Spock.
He is Star Trek....
THIS is why Nimoy passed over Generations. He needed something with meaning
"sense my customary fair well would seem oddly self serving" such a great little line
"An act of faith... one that I hope you will repeat in the future at Starfleet."
Yeah Spock, way to throw Kirk under the bus at the beginning of Into Darkness!
I'm guessing Spock was still trying to find his place in Starfleet, in his friendship with Kirk, and his own future when "Into Darkness" happened. He still didn't have complete faith in all three and therefore could not defy his own Vulcan sense of logic.
Yes, they clumsily tried to show that young Spock was still clinging to his Vulcan origins in terms of strict honesty, complete candor and complete obedience to the "rules". In the original series, Nimoy's Spock used to display these qualities by citing the astronomical odds they were facing, or citing how what they're doing is a complete violation of Starfleet regulations...esp the Prime Directive. Here they had Spock literally "betray" Kirk, when in fact, Kirk was indulging Spock's plan (itself a violation of the prime directive) to save the indigenous people of that planet by averting the volcano eruption. THIS Spock was doing it because Vulcan was destroyed and this Spock did NOT want to see it happen to other species. Nonetheless, this Spock did indeed throw Kirk under the bus...when he outted Kirk's actions (in saving Spock's life no less) to Pike!
Leonard Nimoy really takes it home... the actors from the original star trek have so far lived amazingly long lives... a lot longer than any other show of the era... I wonder if continued interest from fans keeps them socially engaged and always moving.. that's the answer to long life... happyness... staying active... people and expecting you to
Wally and beaver are still alive from leave it to beaver. Eddie Haskell toI
Some from that era lived to be older even though they're not with us anymore of course back then a lot of actors were veterans of WWII, including the actors who played the original McCoy and Scotty in Star Trek TOS
What a legend Leonard Nimoy was/is/and always will be. RIP Sir you were a Titan
Seeing 2 Vulcans in this video who are from the past and the present is heartwarming
Rest in peace Leonard Nimoy ... You have lived long and prospered but now its time to rest, you will be missed by many.
Of all the actors I've watched over 50 years, Leonard Nimoy, and the character he brought so much life to, and in his own way influencing some of mine, especially my imagination as a child, he comes first above all others. Each of the original cast played a part in that as well because each had something different in the characters they portrayed that appealed to my young mind back in those days. But Mr. Nimoy / Spock came first... First star to the right, and straight on 'till morning. RIP...
Rest in peace, Mr. Leonard Nimoy. You have been, and always shall be, our friend. You have touched our hearts and souls over the years, and you shall not be forgotten. You have, as Ambassador Spock would say, lived long and prospered. And in our memories, you shall always live and prosper. That is a promise.
love the smart attention to detail in the writing here. Such great word choice.
I love the dynamics in the scene. Showing how resolute the younger Spock is compared to the tempered wisdom and, "outside the box" thinking of his older self.
Well done guys! ❤
As much as I dislike the Kelvin Timeline, I got admit that Zachary Quinto did a pretty good job!
Perfect reflection of knowledge vs experience "You lied" "I Implied" and "A gamble" to "An act of faith"
"Put aside logic. Do what feels right"
Words to live by
The best moment in Star trek history.
Spock for the last time. 🥹
“Live long and prosper” continues to reverberate to this very day even if he’s not around anymore. 🖖
Seeing Leonard Nimoy here, hearing him talk, something in my heart hurts so violently and aches more than I could ever express.
Of all the souls that I have encountered yours was the most human. Thanks for your logic and your genius . I am and always shall be , your fan. You will never be dead as long as we remember You in the series and movies which is my proud collection on dvd and blu ray. Hope your soul is having FUN with Scotty and bones abroad the enterprise. May your journey to the stars and the final frontier be a peaceful one. Third star to right and on till morning. ...R.I.P . You take with you a piece of my childhood. Live long and prosper old friend.
Leonard Nimoy will be a tv legend forever may spock live and prosper in heaven
The only flaw in this scene was his reply to "you lied"
He should have responded "I exaggerated"
I like that, because of how time travel works in this specific continuity, they don't worry about the dangers of meeting your future self.
Because they openly acknowledge that this film takes place in an alternate reality separate from the original series and movies, so it's possible Red Matter time travel doesn't necessarily work like how it does in _Back to the Future_ or _Terminator._ Probably works the same way that it worked in _Avengers: Endgame_ and the _Dragon Ball_ series; multiverse theory. So, if anything happened to Kelvin timeline Spock, I doubt it'd have an affect on Spock Prime, because he's more from a different reality than just another time.
I believe Discovery outright confirmed this, they say there are three universes that run alongside one another, The Prime Timeline, The Mirror Universe and The Kelvin Timeline
Man, this has got to be one of the best reboot in the movie industry. Well done.
RUBBISH!
That was nice of Spock to take time out of his busy schedule just to talk to Zachary Quinto.
Certainly on of the greatest scenes in all of Star Trek! I am not our father! Whomever wrote that line deserves a bonus!
I had the pleasure of seeing Mr. Nemoy in 1989 by accident. I was visiting Universal studios and he was there for a speaking engagement? Im not sure but i know i didn't know he was going to be there and i was so happy to see him and went to listen to him speak. He was the only star trek actor I had not seen up till that point. My mother took us to a lot of Star Trek conventions when I was a child.
I too had a chance encounter with him... I delivered a bunch of furniture to his house in Incline Village, and he was so happy to recieve it, he came down to sign the bill!😃👍
My Mother was at a charity event in LA years ago and he was there. She asked him if she called me if he'd leave a message, to which he agreed. I was supposed to be at work but was sick that day so I picked up. I was giddy like a little kid when I realized who it was and I think he got a chuckle out of the reaction. He was very nice. We talked for just a minute and at the end he said "Live long and prosper, Jackson". I just about dropped to the floor. It would have been nice to have a message from him to go back and listen to, but the memory and experience to get to talk to him even for a minute was far more valuable. I'll never forget it.
Lord I miss that man. He was such a important piece of my childhood. Lenard Nimoy I hope you are as happy in you new life as you made mine. Rest in joy, love and peace.❤
Thank you for all of the great memories, Mr. Nimoy. You truly were one of the most human. #sadbeyondwords
"Mr. Scott. One to beam up."
I am glad he lived long to make this scene.
Rip Leonard Nimoy.
Thank you for our childhood! :)
RIP Leonard Nimoy, may you travel peacefully to the stars
"Spock, in this case do yourself favor: Put aside logic. Do what feels right." My favorite scene in the movie. R.I.P. Leonard Nimoy, gone but not forgotten.
I like the way that nemoy passed down the torch