Why You Shouldn't Put A Case On Your MacBook
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 лют 2024
- Most people buying an iPhone want to protect it with a case as soon as possible. Something Apple has recommended for over a decade. Recently, this behavior has carried over to MacBooks. With users attaching plastic covers to protect their investment. But this may be doing more harm than good. Since a MacBook’s low-tolerance clamshell design can be damaged by a case that’s poorly designed or fitted improperly.
Unlike iPhones, MacBooks have a hinge that allow the lid to open and close. And cases can apply unnecessary stress to the hinge in a variety of ways. First, being excess weight. - Наука та технологія
I've received quite a few emails asking how I make my videos, if you're interested in learning about it in a detailed course let me know here: greg-s-site-7f5d.thinkific.com/
When will the course release?
It would also be fitting to get a skin from dbrand too, would my mind if you pinned a comment to help people still be able to use their laptops without the fear of scratching?
I have to add I been following you for half a decade now and you do amazing videos and love the simple graphics you use, you are an inspiration.
how about screen protectors?
The voice in these videos sound like Gregg from Lofty Pursuits candy shop in Florida, which also has a UA-cam channel called Lofty Pursuits...I really wonder if it's the same Gregg that's doing these videos.
This comment made 1 day ago and the video 20 hours ago. WHAT THE
I find it *really* odd that the reason not to put a case on the lid of the MacBook is because of excess weight on the hinges. Meanwhile, Apple advertises continuity camera with a mount that attaches to the lid of the MacBook with an iPhone on it which is significantly heavier than a plastic case and puts more weight on the hinges.
yes, but that weight is only applied for a short period of time, you're not gonna have your iPhone stuck on the back on your mac all the time. a case tho, puts constant weight on it for a very long time, and that can weaken the hinges, over years of constant weight.
@@hazel_888 Though it is for shorter time, it still has the same effect, If you were someone who uses continuity camera a lot, your hinges will still weaken over time, At a faster rate at that due to the heavier weight.
In case you haven’t noticed, this guy has no idea what he’s talking about in any of his videos…
@@themarquis336 Oh, I've noticed, I still comment anyways.
Come on, man!!! Have a little bit of respect. You may have a different opinion and you are allowed to express it, but your comment has no additional value. This video is based on facts from an article that studied this phenomenon so there is some truth in that. So keep this disrespectful comment to yourself. And Yes, this man KNOWS what he's talking about.@@themarquis336
Plot twist: This is an Apple MacBook Sleeve ad.
You don’t need the Apple sleeve any other brand will do the same job
An even bigger reason, Thermals! My Macbook air gets hot as-is, it would be much worse with a case.
blud replied with ai💀💀
@@idrinkalmondmilk2918I intend to take their channel for myself. I would benefit much more from 6M subscribers than they ever could.
@@idrinkalmondmilk2918i guess his sub count isn't the only thing he's botting
Not at all. A case would actually improve thermals
Do the thug shake
"In extreme cases" is such a nice pun!
Surprised this video didn’t discuss heat dissipation and airflow issues caused by even well designed cases.
The unibody enclosure of MacBooks is designed to act as a heatsink and radiate heat from components outward.
Much like the human body, if this process is impeded by a non permeable layer touching or close to the skin, overheating will occur.
i seriously agree my guy, macbooks dont have fans unlike their counterparts, so its like holding a hotpan, and the melting plastic is even worse
@@vasipalle Macbook Pros _do have fans_ , my 16" M1P has two of 'em actually.
Macbook Airs on the other hand? They're fanless.
@@rtmpgt Even the 14" has 2 fans, its only the Airs that are passively cooled (ironic huh)
@@vasipallewdym, if they dont why does my macbook sound like a helicopter every time i turn it on
I know just use a slice instead of a case. It also maintains the appearance of the laptop
As a repair shop of 7+ years I wouldn’t say the cases weight significantly affects the hinge mechanism. The example you’ve used in your video sounds like she had a case and developed Flexgate.
I agree that the slight gap left between the bottom casing and lid is a problem (especially if weight is applied to machine while closed). This can crack the lcd internally.
In addition, cases that restrict the natural airflow of the machine can result in overheating and after extensive use, discolouration (especially on the coloured models).😮
A good sleeve and some discipline goes way further than a cheap case!
hi may I ask, if I only use the case for the lid and don't use the bottom case, would it cause the same harm like using both of the cases?
@@lplizzie721 @@lplizzie721 However,@@lplizzie721dead @@lplizzie721 for the top@@lplizzie721any @@lplizzie721f it’s about@@lplizzie721styles the game@@lplizzie721
@@lplizzie721 Hi, I would consider opting for a sleeve over a case for your Mac / using bare where appropriate however, if you're dead set on a case, I would advise a slim one to avoid any major issues :)
Just beware of potential discoloration over time and added hinge stress. If you ever remove the case, your top lid might look a bit funky against the bottom casing as the top may end up lighter than the bottom! 🤣
If it’s about protection: sleeve & discipline > case
If styles the game: stickers or skins > case
this gave me anxiety
From buying my very first MacBook in 2013, I've always bought plastic cases and I've never experienced any ramifications by doing do. By installing a case, your investment is not only protected but the resale value is much greater than a MacBook that's damaged or in a poor state by constant drops, which can't be prevented with a sleeve..
How often do you drop your MacBook…?
Interesting, but I think your later point sums it up. Don't buy cheap. I've used INCASE cases for years and have never had any real issues. I have had issues with Apple's hinge clutches which they may specify carefully taking into account reasonable use and screen weights, but are in-fact not always manufactured to acceptable quality.
I have an incase for my 2021 macbook pro
I have an incase on my Mac air will it be ok?
Yes i have one on my MacBook i wouldn’t worry that is a high quality well known brand
Man! Greg you’re really good at this. Short but informative insightful videos, well done.
I always wanted a case for my Mac for this very reason. Now, I’m still likely to get one, but much more scrutinized. Thanks man!
I only put a cover on the top for looks, the bottom stays coverless so it doesn't overheat
Literally watching this video with cased macbook 💀
(Edit: Bruh Safari didn't even recognized Macbook lmfao, it autocorrected to Matchbook 😢)
Not even half way through and my case was gone, oh and it damaged the edges of the body too.
@@Ben_442 what model do you use?
same dude
me wondering if i should i keep it on or not?
@@Kiwi.mp4_ Keep it on. I've been using it for 2 years. Even tho the case pushes the screen down, I'm fine with it. And nth happened for past 2 years.
@@prasetyo1884 202 Air
This is why I use skins on MacBooks to retain their natural shape, but prevent any scratches. I also use a carry bag (or sleeve) so that MacBooks remain protected when on the move.
If it’s a MacBook Air (fanless)
It’s actually bad to use a skin,
Because MacBook uses its body to dissipate heat
I used to have a case on my air and within weeks after owning it, I read up on this and luckily I have a sleeve from my previous MacBook. Very helpful reassurance
I’ve had a hard shell case on my M1 Air since day one. Taking it off later today. Thank you for this
Never thought about this. I’m checking my case right now. But I think this is a problem mostly for cheap cases bought from random providers trying to cash in without worrying about real world use.
True
This also applies to even the expensive cases.
MacBook doesn’t need a case, it’s not an iPad or iPhone.
It’s very heavy, putting a case will just add up extra weight.
@@nasseralsharif depends on your use. I have pets that walk my tables and I take it everywhere and my case has saved me multiple times from having to buy a new one. I also once spilled water on my table and the case rubber “feet” saved it from being soaked.
the weight of mac case is so light tho… prob only add like 1% extra weight😂
Even Apple themselves are selling hard cases on their site from InCase. I have used it in my stuff for years with no issues. If a MacBook Air over heats with that on then you have a laptop issue, not a case issue. I have recently switched to skins over cases though. That way docks work fine.
I had to get my M2 MacBook Air display replaced because the hard shell case I used loosen the hinges. Also what you did not mention is that cases can also cause damage to the laptops display. The case makes it more likely for the laptop to open and close in your bag which can allow dirt and debris to get in causing dents on the display.
The algorithm is real, I just looked how to replace a hinge on my MacBook Air and I also have an Amazon hard shell. Taking it off immediately, thanks!
it will be nice to have a case just for the corners of the MacBook, u don’t will have all of those problems and your Mac can be secure for corner damages
I have my case on my MacBook Air for about 4 years and it’s the really cheap kind and still looks new and no bends or pink lines anywhere to be seen!
I really suggest using a sleeve. Cases can block airflow to your MacBook vents causing overheating and eventually permanent damage. MacBook airs especially need these vents as they do not have fans. I suggest using sleeves because they provide great protection while also oftentimes including a small handle making it easier to hold on the go. And it also maintains the beautiful sleek design and when in use.
The newer MacBook are much more fragile than last time, and it is a feature haha
@@jun_suzuki42 2018-2020 MacBook airs are much more susceptible to damage. They have tolerances so low that even if you so much had a paper thin object in between the lid and the case it may genuinely crack the LCD. The same is true for a grain of rice.
Ask me how I know.
In phones and ipads, it make sense to use a case, because you can grip and handle them.
But a laptop, it’s usually on a lap (hence the name laptop). And the laptop case won’t actually protect the laptop if it drops. Waste of money
Cases will only protect very very minor scratches if you are using it on a desk but if you put a laptop in a sleeve instead it survive ten foot falls if it a good one
I don‘t think the extra weight is a big problem, considering apple wants us to use our iPhones as MacBook Front cameras and many people sticking a SSD on the back of their screen for extra storage
I get your point and you said some cases but tbh i’ve had an m2 for over a year with a case and no problems whatsoever, i think it all depends on how you use it and how much stress you put on it eg. people who go around on jt all day long. Nice video
I think an “Apple explained to help you sleep” idea might be cool. These videos are really chill and an extended compilation on certain subject would be neat, an iPhone edition, Mac edition, Apple Watch, etc
I recently thought about buying a case for my MacBookAir but gave up and with this video you gave me the reason.👍🏻
My M2 Air fits perfectly into the Apple Leather Sleeves that used to be sold several years ago. Had a case for a while afterwards. But came back to the sleeve and no longer use a case.
What about dbrand skins? I’m assuming the skin on the outside of the MacBook wouldn’t be an issue, but I’m most curious about the skins that lines the inside of the MacBook around the keyboard?
I was expecting the plastic to cause overheating, but the hinge wasn’t what I expected, maybe I’ll try it with the case off and live with the finger prints on my black MacBook (which is probably more hygienic by more frequent cleaning anyway).
had a mac with the case on it for 8 years and the hinge was in perfect condition. but my new mac has been creaking without the case
true, i put a hinge on mine for a bit and then took it off coz it added weight to it. Once i took it off the hinge started making this weird rubbing sound, but it has gone away after a while
You also forgot to mention that small debris can enter the case, which causes damage that never would occur without a case. I'm speaking of experience; I bought a €3 case 7 years ago, I had scuffs/scratches after a few months of regular use. Now I'm using a Dbrand skin (have had it for over 2 years now) and it's great
what about screen protector is there any harm of benefit of installing a good one
I Love your Videos. We will Rectify/Correct our mistakes from
you. Thanks for your advice.❤✨
Ok, fine. Will you then tell me where to get that sleeve? It looks super fabulous!
It is an official Apple leather sleeve, but I don't think you can buy it anymore because Apple doesn't use leather anymore. So the only way is through 3rd party stores/webs (just try to look up official Apple leather sleeve).
I got a used m1 Mac 16” that came with a case. I didn’t like how elevated it was and how warm it got, so I took it off. I love the silver finish too much to not have it naked, got AppleCare+ on it anyway. Now, I have a studio display to use in clamshell mode.
Thank you for agreeing with me.
Honestly this makes sense. I use cases though my Macbooks aren't my daily drivers, they're travel laptops for me so I don't use them that often so I think it's okay for now. But whenever I buy a new case I end up having to file some plastic just so my Macbook even FITS within the case (seriously, does nobody check these beforehand?) and then it usually ends up not closing fully anyway. I think I'll settle for a decorative+protective skin and a sleeve.
I buy a cover and only put the monitor part on because I cracked my screen a few years back and it felt like a very avoidable incident if I’d had a screen. Doing this prevents basically all issues listed-never ever had a problem with the hinge either but I think the MacBook Air had a subpar hinge which I never owned. Older macs also suffered from extra heat insulation if you used the bottom portion of the cover. Another reason I left it off
Glad I invested in the mous carrying case for the macbook pro, it’s really nice!
Also, I can confirm this from using a phone case, debris can get underneath the case and it will scratch and build-up dust. I just put a Slickwraps Clear matte with a logo cutout and It's perfect for me. Highly recommend
Ever since apple put out the article saying that a simple camera cover can cause your macbook's screen to crack, I've always been skeptical about putting a case on any macbook and probably will continue to use sleeves for the rest of time.
Many years ago I had a huge Dell Inspiron 7500 with the big for its time 15.4” screen. I had to replace the hinges on that thing twice. The laptop was 10lbs itself and screen was heavy too. I think about how many times I open and close my MacBook everyday and hope it doesn’t break.
Then why is Apple still selling incase cases in their direct stores?😅
This makes so much sense. My wife has a second hand macbook air with loose hinges. Probably had a case.
I feel like the laptop case thing could apply to any laptop honestly
Windows laptops doesn't need any case as most of them has the intake vent spread across the whole bottom cover. Even I have to use 4 eraser blocks to rise the bottom of my laptop in order to get as much air as possible, so my laptop doesn't thermal throttle when in full load
yeah but this is Apple explained
apple explained or more like Apple Excuses
I know this video was meant to deter me from buying a MacBook case but that purple one is kinda fire. You got a link?
thanks for making this before i used a leather case on my upcoming macbook pro i want i will still use case but when i go outside with it only for short term
Could I use a case on the bottom but not on the top?
What about screen? How should I protect the screen? Should I use a screen protector or not???
We should help him with video ideas
Something that I have done is remove the bottom section of the case and keep the top section so it's still protected from scratches and sometimes small impacts and keep the hinge functioning optimally. I just keep the top part of the case on and the bottom part off.
Apple sells licensed third party MacBook hard shell cases on their website though
UAG, Tech21 and Incase are all brands Apple sells in their stores iirc.
Thanks, was about to order one online.
Excellent video! I thank you very much for these informations.
This applies to any Modern notebook laptop and not just MacBooks and MacBooks already don't have the best thermal design compared to a Windows ultrabook laptop such as the galaxy book, so the case is even worse as it is suffocating the Mac even more and not allowing passive cooling (air blowing past the magnesium/aluminum body) to happen with the plastic covering up the body.
I have been using a Spigen Thin Fit Case for two years on my Macbook pro 16 m2 and had zero issues so far. I am always happy to have a case when I hit something by accident. Especially when going through airport security. It is not cheap but well designed.
I also think it might not be best brectice to do this in something like a macbook air m1 with no active cooling since the macbook's metal is better at conducting heat than plastic. If the device sences that it gets too hot it might even lower the power to the soc leaving you with less performance.
That’s why you should use a wrap like dbrand sells because there’s no hard things and just a big sticker so it does more good than harm
Any recommendations for sleeves?
I'm worried more on heat dissipation problem. This is more on the Pro's or when you use the unit in high performance mode, you see MacBooks unibody functions as a major heat sink for the electronics to cool down. When you cover the metal body it lessens to dissipate the heat as intended to be, so covering it up might slowly cook the internals...
I've had cases on my MBP since 2012 and never had any issues. But I only use cases that are from reputable brands.
If my MBA M1 didn't had the case for the past two years, I might had a dent on the back of the screen already or it's been scratched up from wear and tear.
But my laptop never had any issue from the case, it can close properly without those two plastic case touching together and the hinges are still strong. Also no line bars on the screen.
I use a vinyl for scratches and a sleeve for hits with my MBP
I've subscribed to this before: sleeves over cases, and using my MacBook Air bare. Come time when there was accidental damage to my laptop, I had lines running off-center, and over time, it turned into a black bar. Yeah, cases carry risks, but using my MacBook Air caseless bit me back when accidental damages happened.
I agree to the improper closing of the lid.. I went through at least 8 cases for my 16 M2 Pro and 14 inch M3 Max MacBooks.. until I found one with the clasps that attach to the MacBook that allow for complete close only then was I satisfied. I have a toddler so a case is a must have
thanks for sharing - which case is this ? I also have a tiny gap with my new incase and a bit concerned
Love your videos!!!
If I bought a case from the apple website themselves, can I get compensation for it if it deteriorates?
This is why it is important to buy a case from a trusted brand such as Incase, another one of those instances where it's cheaper to do it right the first time.
My M2 Air bottom case show discoloration where the case vent holes are. Never use any case ever since
I really don’t put any case on a laptop as it is hard to take off, unlike the sleeve case where you just slide it in. Not to mention if you would need to clean the case of the MacBook that would be difficult to take off
I’ve had a hardshell case on my MacBook Air M2 for about a year now. Should I be worried that it may cause damage to it? I don’t remember where we got it from, but I’m 99% sure it was from Amazon
Just stop using it. It has done minor damage but not significant yet most likely
@@Jan-bv8bt alright. Thanks for telling me. We spent so much for that, and I don’t want to damage further than it has been
İ never put a cover on. i use a sleeve! But what about a screen protector???
Plus scratching and adding to overheating from poor ventilation
I've used a cheap hardshell case for over 10 years with no issues.
Have had an 'incase' shell on my M1 MacBook Air since purchase, no sign of wear on the hinge or any issues whatsoever. I imagine as you say if you buy a £10 case from amazon, then yes your mileage may vary.
The incase shell is sold on Apple’s website. In fact it’s the only MacBook case on their site. Of course that one is okay
Ye I'm have 2 MacBooks using the Incase Shell and they are running strong since 2020 and 2023. No sign of wear or damage so far. Amazing product.
I use a sleeve but I have used one of those silicon keyboards covers and that just messed up the monitor of the MacBook. Never again.
Cases are mostly useful on the bottom, since the space between the bottom cover and the surface is so thin, it can lead to some scratches if there's some dirt on the surface. Of course, the surface must be clean, but it can happen when you're taking your machine with you.
Some quality decal can do the job while being lighter.
I use hard case before, but as i observed, it really does bend the screen thats why i removed it immediately, i even put screen protector and keyboard silicon cover..
I made the mistake of putting a keyboard sleeve/cover whatever it is called back in 2015 and I'm pretty sure it is the reason my screen got damaged. Definitely don't need a case or keyboard protectors. Just be careful with it when taking it off the desk.
Yes but have you seen the damages and unavoidable scratches your mac gets without having a skin/case on it after about a year or so., i’d rather have some kind of protection on it especially that they cost a third more than US prices where i leave 😊
Learned this the hard way. Listen to the video kids, keep your MacBooks case-free.
how come ? what happened
Just keep it in a good protective bag/sleeve when you’re not using it. It’s too big for a case like a phone. Plus it needs to exchange heat.
I love this channel a lot
I put the bottom piece of the case on and leave the top open so that it doesn’t damage the hinge. Of course i also have a dbrand skin on the mac as well to prevent scratches. The reason why i have the bottom case is to prevent the sides and corners from scratches
Funny how Apple offers 3rd party cases on their site but discontinued the very sleeve you showed, way before they decided to do away with leather for carbon neutral. I just think the lack of durability of their products is just a money grab to be honest……
Do skins impair thermal performance?
With all the dings I see on used macbooks I think we’ll take it from here 😂
had a similar experience with a mid-2015 15 inch MacBook I had way back when. The hard case put so much pressure on the hinge that it started to become looser and looser, and then the whole laptop snapped in half just because of the case
I put a case on my MacBook because I don’t have a sleeve and I use regular tote handbag.
I won’t put hardshell case if I have MacBook with fans.
i have used a hardshell case on my 2015 inch MacBook pro for years I got one that had the tabs at the top of the case away from the hinge area so it would close properly what would bend my lid was a swollen battery because of the chasey being bent what I did was unplug it let the batter swelling go down put my iPad on the laptop closed leave it while it gets hot by the time I sold the 15 inch no warping or damage I got over retail price too it was in that great of shape too no issues either just slow from the lack of CPU ram and horsepower being intel 4th gen and a AMD 370mx mobile GPU 2 gp ram
Been using cases for my macbooks for about 15 years nothing happens 😂
and also most laptops dont even need protective cases anyways as we can use laptop bags
true
an ncase is really good imo i've had my MacBook since 2020 and it never broke unless I sliced it direcetly.
We used vinyl skins that pull off easily to protect from scratches and small drops
can i just keep case on base, not display?
And what about continuity camera mounts?
I always just thought cases on computers were crazy and looked odd
Okay, so what about the cases from the company UAG? Because I have that on my macbook pro and it's about to come off. Also, Apple cases have been absolute trash on my iPhone and iPad - why should I trust it with my $2600 macbook?
You should have mentioned debris stuck between the machine and the case scratching the surfaces if not cleaned regularly.
But even then for how expensive these laptops are the metal scratches so easily.
HAHA, funnily enough I recently got a MacBook, and have been contemplating getting a case for it. Video could not have come out at a better time!!