You actually got me creating a whiskey budget. Since starting watching in March I went from rotating 5-6 random bottles to now having 27 bottles. Yeah I blame you. You're without doubt my favorite whiskeytuber and the only one I watch. Told 3 of my like minded friends to watch you. Thank you for your videos.
If I was forced to only choose one Irish whiskey for the rest of my life, this would be the one. The true definition of what an Irish whiskey should be. Blows the regular 12 out of the water. Cheers Erik 🥃
I’m not even an Irish fan but I will always have a bottle of this. Absolutely mind blowing whiskey. Wish more Irish brands would go the cask strength with good age route.
Excellent review Erik! I've got a bottle of this and haven't opened it yet. I'm still loving the Red Breast 40% right now. Looks like I need to open this bad boy up and enjoy! Cheers!
I’m doing the same. My regular 12 yr old has opened up for the better with about 2-3 months being opened. Had a dram last week and I was like oh my I need to replenish before I’m out. I’ll keep enjoying the regular until I open the CS. Contemplating not cracking it up quite yet. Cheers 🥃
Although the 12 near me (Florida Panhandle) is $65 and the Cask Strength is $85. I passed on the the Cask about 3 months ago and kicked myself for doing so. Last week I finally found another bottle and did not let this one slip by. Initially I can't say I liked it more than the 12 but after letting the neck pour sit and open up it blew me away. Great review...as usual my friend.
A great whiskey. Out of the 12, 12CS, 15 and 21 this is my favorite. This bottle is at an entirely different level. My biggest decision when having a dram of the CS is whether or not to add some water, it is equally great either way. I’m fortunate like you, about $65 here.
Not a fan of Irish whiskey at all but after your video I have to get a bottle of this asap. Thanks for another very high quality and entertaining review.
if they have Super King Grocery Stores in S.F. area get there for the Redbreast CS 12 for $59.99 right now on sale. Best price I have seen for this stuff
Yes! This is by far my favorite irish whiskey to date! In my opinion, THIS is the definitive DNA for true irish whiskey! Granted, I haven't had the 21 or the 27 yet, but either way, this one hits all the right marks and the price and availability blows away almost every other credible whiskey in its range
I was waiting for you to grab a hold of this one!. For me, this is the best, most unique, yet definitive 'Irish style' whiskey. A beautiful whiskey on those long dark winter nights by the fire with a book in hand. In Ireland its €95, compared to €180 for Midleton very rare. Half the price for twice the quality IMO. Really enjoying the Irish tour!.
This is in my top 5 favourite whiskey’s. Loving the Irish whiskey month, I’ve become a huge fan over the last couple of years. It’s creeped up my favourites and is second only to scotch
15yr redbreast is my everyday for Irish, 12 cask is equally as good but is more of a friday night due to higher abs. Redbreast is the benchmark for rating any other irish whiskeys
I guess I should get around to opening mine soon. I look at it often when I’m trying to decide which dram to have, but can’t bring myself to open it, haha.
Great review. I keep coming back to the regular 12. Not sure why. I have the B1/17 batch of 12CS and it is too hot. Even with water the spice is too much.....but in the end the whole line is fantastic.
I have this arriving shortly (53€+shipping!) along with Glenfarclas 12 and 105. I was thinking of making a home vatting of those two and then started thinking, how about the CS as a cherry on top? Perhaps 10%? I'll be wiser once I have tasted it of course, but I suspect that would make the whole dram a lot more unique.
Erik - It seems that they have taken the age statement off the bottle and box. I did not see the 12 year statement on your bottle or box. I have the old bottle and the 12 yr statement is displayed prominently.
Good eye! Actually the image I used for the thumbnail is an older bottle. On my bottle the age is spelled out “Aged Twelve Years” rather than using the number “12”. This is Batch B2/19.
Great bottle. Since it's still at the mentioned price range, it's not being hyped or hoarded - yet. This expression screams for an ice cube, sipping it on the porch on a hot summer day or night. Erik's put out there, so expect this now to get some attention.
Erik I would buy it but in arkansas the 12cs is 100 bucks. I get lustau for 75, the 12cs may be worth the extra 25 bucks but don't think I'll find out anytime soon
It sure is a good Irish. I will say from experience that the older releases of RB 12 Cask were the best ones. After about the ‘18 or ‘19 release they weren’t quite as good. That does not mean you shouldn’t buy the new ones in the new packaging, it’s just what it is. The early 2000s were phenomenal. Those are difficult to find. You can still find as old as the 2012 release in some stores. I highly recommend getting those. The RB 21 is unreal but you must pay that much more. The Cask 12 is the sweet spot for value.
Great Review! i have the 12y Redbreast and really like it. I cant decide whether to get the cask strength or the 15y next, since they are the same price here in germany. Are you going to review the 15y as well?
The price you get for this is insane, for me that's the cost of a regular 12! Here the average price for the 12CS stays around 94€ (111$). Just in some rare occasions (big promos) the price drops to around 70€ (83$). You lucky bastards :)
Sorry, I've not tasted any RB 12 with older label designs. But I have never heard any Redbreast fans (such as in the American Irish Whiskey Fan Facebook group) make any complaints about newer bottles.
$67 That’s a great price for this. How does it compare to the Redbreast 15 yo. Wow, 110°! I’m griping because it’s going up to the low 90’s next week.😏
Erik Wait Whisky Studies A little smoother than regular 12. Probably on par with 12 CS, though CS might have more flavor because of the ABV and cask intensity.
☘ WATCH MORE OF MY IRISH WHISKEY REVIEWS HERE: ua-cam.com/play/PLFE4H6ZO6VFZra6fOv0Qzltk_aNIgWX4S.html
You actually got me creating a whiskey budget. Since starting watching in March I went from rotating 5-6 random bottles to now having 27 bottles. Yeah I blame you. You're without doubt my favorite whiskeytuber and the only one I watch. Told 3 of my like minded friends to watch you. Thank you for your videos.
If I was forced to only choose one Irish whiskey for the rest of my life, this would be the one. The true definition of what an Irish whiskey should be. Blows the regular 12 out of the water. Cheers Erik 🥃
I'm much more a Scotch guy...but there is one Irish whiskey that I keep around and this is it. Delicious.
Good stuff!
I’m not even an Irish fan but I will always have a bottle of this. Absolutely mind blowing whiskey. Wish more Irish brands would go the cask strength with good age route.
@@bluegriffin9453 yes my preference is Scotch. But I’ll admit that bad Scotch is much worse then bad Irish or Bourbon.
Bought it yesterday! It’s, magnificent...
It really is!
This is one of my favorite whiskeys in my small collection. It’s beautiful.
100% AGREE - BUY IT!!!!
I’ve had the standard and the lustau, but not the cask strength. The Lustau is my favorite Irish whiskey that I’ve tried.
A delight to watch and I could not agree more. This is a must buy for everyone on this whiskey journey. Delicious.
Love watching this review It’s one of those 1 off amazing whiskeys
This is my next purchase!!!
One of my favorites Wow it’s fab on the palate 😃
It's so good!
I highly recommend trying this with Hagen Das, Belgian Chocolate
Great review! For its price it might be the best Cask Strength whiskey on the market full stop.
Couldn't agree more!
Excellent review Erik! I've got a bottle of this and haven't opened it yet. I'm still loving the Red Breast 40% right now. Looks like I need to open this bad boy up and enjoy! Cheers!
I’m doing the same. My regular 12 yr old has opened up for the better with about 2-3 months being opened. Had a dram last week and I was like oh my I need to replenish before I’m out. I’ll keep enjoying the regular until I open the CS. Contemplating not cracking it up quite yet. Cheers 🥃
Although the 12 near me (Florida Panhandle) is $65 and the Cask Strength is $85. I passed on the the Cask about 3 months ago and kicked myself for doing so. Last week I finally found another bottle and did not let this one slip by. Initially I can't say I liked it more than the 12 but after letting the neck pour sit and open up it blew me away. Great review...as usual my friend.
I love the sound of this whiskey.
It tastes even better!
A great whiskey. Out of the 12, 12CS, 15 and 21 this is my favorite. This bottle is at an entirely different level. My biggest decision when having a dram of the CS is whether or not to add some water, it is equally great either way. I’m fortunate like you, about $65 here.
Not a fan of Irish whiskey at all but after your video I have to get a bottle of this asap. Thanks for another very high quality and entertaining review.
if they have Super King Grocery Stores in S.F. area get there for the Redbreast CS 12 for $59.99 right now on sale. Best price I have seen for this stuff
I've never heard of Super King Grocery Stores. I moved and now live about 2 hours east of the SF Bay Area.
Yes! This is by far my favorite irish whiskey to date! In my opinion, THIS is the definitive DNA for true irish whiskey! Granted, I haven't had the 21 or the 27 yet, but either way, this one hits all the right marks and the price and availability blows away almost every other credible whiskey in its range
Couldn't agree more!
I was waiting for you to grab a hold of this one!. For me, this is the best, most unique, yet definitive 'Irish style' whiskey. A beautiful whiskey on those long dark winter nights by the fire with a book in hand. In Ireland its €95, compared to €180 for Midleton very rare. Half the price for twice the quality IMO. Really enjoying the Irish tour!.
Couldn't agree more!
I will continue to buy this as long as they keep the age statement on it.
I also have two open bottles right now. One in my bar and one in my shop.
Wow in a bottle. Fantastic whiskey.
It really is!
This is in my top 5 favourite whiskey’s. Loving the Irish whiskey month, I’ve become a huge fan over the last couple of years. It’s creeped up my favourites and is second only to scotch
Ben Robson I’m glad you’re enjoying this series (or as I call it “marathon”), it will last until about the end of October.
15yr redbreast is my everyday for Irish, 12 cask is equally as good but is more of a friday night due to higher abs. Redbreast is the benchmark for rating any other irish whiskeys
I liked the look of the old bottle better. I’m saving mine and refilling it with the new stuff.
I guess I should get around to opening mine soon. I look at it often when I’m trying to decide which dram to have, but can’t bring myself to open it, haha.
My Favorite right next to ( OK slightly behind) Big brother RB21. Bang for the buck this is it.
Great review. I keep coming back to the regular 12. Not sure why. I have the B1/17 batch of 12CS and it is too hot. Even with water the spice is too much.....but in the end the whole line is fantastic.
Thanks!
I have this arriving shortly (53€+shipping!) along with Glenfarclas 12 and 105. I was thinking of making a home vatting of those two and then started thinking, how about the CS as a cherry on top? Perhaps 10%? I'll be wiser once I have tasted it of course, but I suspect that would make the whole dram a lot more unique.
Erik, have you tried (or will you try)RB27? I hate to fork out that much money unless it is a special whiskey. I can get two 21's for the 27 price.
I’ve not tried the 27. After the RB Lustau I’ll be moving in to other Irish Whiskies.
Hey Erick keep an eye out for the 15yr at total wine, it should be out sometime in October of this year. Only $10 more
Thanks for the tip!
Erik - It seems that they have taken the age statement off the bottle and box. I did not see the 12 year statement on your bottle or box. I have the old bottle and the 12 yr statement is displayed prominently.
Good eye! Actually the image I used for the thumbnail is an older bottle. On my bottle the age is spelled out “Aged Twelve Years” rather than using the number “12”. This is Batch B2/19.
Great bottle. Since it's still at the mentioned price range, it's not being hyped or hoarded - yet.
This expression screams for an ice cube, sipping it on the porch on a hot summer day or night. Erik's put out there, so expect this now to get some attention.
Sir once visit and explore Irish whiskey and if possible make videos like u made in Scotland visit tour.
I was planning on visiting Ireland 2 years ago but then COVID happened. Eventually I will get there!
Erik I would buy it but in arkansas the 12cs is 100 bucks. I get lustau for 75, the 12cs may be worth the extra 25 bucks but don't think I'll find out anytime soon
Mine was all peanutty. Did I get a bad batch?
Hmmmmm.... I don't know. I've never heard "peanutty" described as a flaw. I'd have to smell and taste it myself.
It sure is a good Irish. I will say from experience that the older releases of RB 12 Cask were the best ones. After about the ‘18 or ‘19 release they weren’t quite as good. That does not mean you shouldn’t buy the new ones in the new packaging, it’s just what it is. The early 2000s were phenomenal. Those are difficult to find. You can still find as old as the 2012 release in some stores. I highly recommend getting those. The RB 21 is unreal but you must pay that much more. The Cask 12 is the sweet spot for value.
Great Review! i have the 12y Redbreast and really like it. I cant decide whether to get the cask strength or the 15y next, since they are the same price here in germany. Are you going to review the 15y as well?
12yo CS > 15yo
Not even a question :)
I'm not planning on reviewing the RB 15 during this series but I may in the future.
Definitely cask strength instead of the 15
The price you get for this is insane, for me that's the cost of a regular 12!
Here the average price for the 12CS stays around 94€ (111$). Just in some rare occasions (big promos) the price drops to around 70€ (83$). You lucky bastards :)
I've heard that newer bottles (ones with the redesign) don't taste as good. Would you be able to comment on that?
Sorry, I've not tasted any RB 12 with older label designs. But I have never heard any Redbreast fans (such as in the American Irish Whiskey Fan Facebook group) make any complaints about newer bottles.
How does the 15 yo cask strength compare to this? Also, have you tried The Whistler 10 yo Irish Whiskey?
Jakob W I’ll tell you in my review of the Lustau Edition.
in the uk the cs is 2x the price of the 12 :/
Sorry to hear that!
$67!! Here in Ireland that bottle will set you back €90 to €100 ( ~$118 ish), easyyyyy. That's crazy
Seems to be so much cheaper in the U.S compared to here in the UK - supply and demand I suppose
Which batch was that one. B16 here is going for crazy money on the secondary market.
Slight difference between batches. They do 1 or 2 runs a year.
This is Batch B2/19.
I bought the cask strength. I wasn't ready... I'm still a bigger fan of Green Spot though.
If you can find the Green Spot Chateau Barton do yourself a favour and grab it - 46% ABV Green Spot plus that French wine finish...ridiculous!
@@cianoc8211 is it delicious??
@@MuttonBiryani1994 amazing
@@cianoc8211 thanks
The standard 12 is $65-70 by me. Cask strength pushing $90.
I would get it. Burning afraid of the extra alcohol content
I didn't get any "burn" per se, but I have built a tolerance to it. It is definitely great on ice which would remove any burn.
$67 That’s a great price for this. How does it compare to the Redbreast 15 yo. Wow, 110°! I’m griping because it’s going up to the low 90’s next week.😏
I've not had the 15 yet.
Erik Wait Whisky Studies A little smoother than regular 12. Probably on par with 12 CS, though CS might have more flavor because of the ABV and cask intensity.
My bottle is only 54.6%. Bummer.
Anything over 50% abv makes me happy!
Is there any whisk(e)y you don’t give 90 points and above to Eric! 😂 I guess you’re easily pleased! Nothing wrong with that!
Watch more of my videos. I frequently give 85, 87, 88, 89. In fact I scored Glyph Molecular Whiskey 62 points.
Lidicious 🤣🤣🤣
Any one drink it neat?
The cask strength is only $10 more than the 80 proof version by me, and it's so much better. The 80 proof is so blah.