What Makes This Jew Different Than All Other Jews? Race, Difference, and Safety in Jewish Spaces
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
- We are a people of questions, but perhaps certain types of questions directed at certain kinds of people diminish the safety of all of us. A modern liberal idea? MaNishtana thinks not; he explains that checking people at the door is not something we Jews can or should recognize as traditional.
Some of the white Jews seem to be a little uncomfortable.... we all need to get uncomfortable ..., we need to dig deep ans get to the root of the issues
1. Jews fighting for civil rights, some dying
2. liberal "tikun olam" replaced with generic social justice tropes.
3. continuation of fighting for black causes even after louis farikans trope
4. the crown hights riots.
5. BLM's endorsement of the BDS movement.
6. More "tikun olam"
Self-sacrifice much?
I don't think racism towards black Jews is a jewish thing per say, it is a racist thing. I agree with you that racism within the Jewish community is a destructive force, something we cannot afford. It must be fought. Yet, imposing white guilt onto the Jewish community is not gonna help either, and it has the same destructive and divisive force as rejection of animosity towards darker jews.
yes
Yea i'm black in Israel, and i look super Haredi. I live in the old city, and I get haggled almost twice a week. I think i legit share my story every shabbos too.
Jews are not white
Such a beautiful and important speech. Bless you for continuing to be an observant and dedicated Jew when so many others, who don't face what you do simply by virtue of genes, find it hard to stay committed to Judaism.
Hello :)
I have some questions - maybe someone can enlighten me? Traditionaly many Jewish ppl or judaism believers want to counsel other ppl something like - "your nationality and your ethnicity is not important realy, forget the ethnocentrism and get some multiculturalism" or smt along this lines. But they cavil to their own nationality throughout the ages. They also usualy are suspecting of being rasists bc they persecute the black african ppl who live by judaism religion and those orthodox judaism believers who are living in Israel but dont think that Israel as it is now is their promised land by the rules of the Bible. Both of these groups are not treated well by the authorities of Israel. But Jews usualy are against rasism of other ppls and they use to say to others that rasism is very bad ideology (I agree). But - again - they themselves want to be discriminate as 3 or 4 or more sub-groups (Misrahi, Ashkenazi, Sephardi etc) in what is supposed to be one nation. So what am I to do with these contradictions? I m sorry for my poor English language I m trying to be understandable :)
I dont care you are black - You are Jewish and therefore my brother
thoughtful, intelligent. i enjoyed it. thank you for sharing your eloquent thoughts
I love this person .... truly one who speaks truth ... and keeps it real .... we all should be having these conversations
Do most Jews not like spices tho 🤷🏼♀️bc I do lmao
no its a joke about european jews (ashkenazi)
excellent
This was an awesome presentation.
Not all White Jews are racist.
you are great enjoyed your speach
Wow! Go Shais! I wish I had known about this. Kol hakabod!
Speak. Yessss.
I have shared this talk with colleagues--really important wisdom here!
Yea, I'm a black Jew in the Old city in Yeshiva. Imagine that! I think i share my story every shabbos..
Truly inspired.
I love this.
Kol Y'israel!
Epic
It's a Black, it's a Jew, hey hey, how are you?
great talk besides the lgbt thing the talk was great
Why is it okay to make a Jewish caricature like the one at the beginning? Thats what the nazis did. I would happily stand by your side knowing that you are a Jew according to Halacha, even though you may not come across as the "average" jew in others eyes. That doesn't mean its okay to make belittling cartoons of ashkenazi jews, and belittle through stereotypes, its still your community you are talking about. Its not okay to attack your own community with stereotyping cartoons.
Shmuel Rabinowitz he is not Even attacking.. where is you’re sence of humor ?