Dog food review: Purina One vs Purina Beneful

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Dog food review comparing Purina One Lamb and Rice VS Purina Beneful with real beef.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 50

  • @ceciliaault4240
    @ceciliaault4240 11 місяців тому +1

    It's always helpful to add up the points for each brand so that you are clear about who scored better. I don't want to spend time watching the comparisons, to be confused at the end as to which one was the best.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  11 місяців тому

      This was before I came up with the point system, but yes that was the idea in inventing it

  • @mannylorenzana2799
    @mannylorenzana2799 3 роки тому +5

    Hi I feed my dog purina pro plan and I am thinking on switching him to victor hi pro plus can you do a video on comparing those two ?

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +2

      Ill add it to my list of diets to look into.

  • @bacz42
    @bacz42 Рік тому +1

    Do you have a suggestion/favorite for an overweight dog with chicken sensitivity? My 5y/o rescue dog has been on Purina One Lamb & Rice for a few years (I add carrots or other veggies too). But she’s struggling to lose weight (shes 32lbs and should be about 25lbs). She also has a mild heart murmur purportedly from grain free diet when she was at a shelter. The vets say this food she’s on is “fine” and had no other suggestions.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  Рік тому +1

      First check to make sure your diet isnt all life stages, then make sure you are feeding the weight they should be, not what they are using the resting energy requirement. I have several videos on this. Lastly, I wouldn’t necessarily limit yourself to a chicken free diet because all OTC diets likely have some chicken in it because unless it’s an RX diet it’s processed with other diets and is not regulated. This may open up your options to diets like perfect weight ( I have a video on that one) or other restrictive diets like Purina OM

  • @seasongreetings3200
    @seasongreetings3200 3 роки тому +6

    I thought you were going to say which one is better.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +4

      This channel is more about giving you the tools to evaluate the food for whats best for your pet. I just point out the important things to look at and all the tricky marketing traps.

    • @karenfaumuina9395
      @karenfaumuina9395 Рік тому

      Lol me too

  • @carolineshomestead2560
    @carolineshomestead2560 8 місяців тому +1

    I tried a bunch of high end foods for my Dogo Argentino mix and nothing was working for her and I was having to express her anal glands weekly. Switched to Purina One Lamb and Rice and solid poops! I just add additional probiotics and glucosamine to her food. Very pleased

  • @blush427
    @blush427 3 роки тому +2

    Would purina be a good brand to stick to? I wanted to switch my newly adopted puppy to blue Buffalo slowly. Thanks, super helpful video :)

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +4

      The purina brand is really broad. Some of their foods are better than others. You should check out my video on pro plan vs Purina one for a more in depth explanation. But the short answer is, it depends Wich Purina food you are talking about.

    • @blush427
      @blush427 3 роки тому

      Thanks!

    • @dogagility411
      @dogagility411 3 роки тому +4

      Purina puts a lot of scientific research behind their foods. Totally can trust them! Switching my girl from Nutrisource to Purina Pro Plan. :) They are the few that meet WSAVA guidelines.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +4

      Very true, well said

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +2

      I’m glad the video was helpful

  • @BADASSMARIA
    @BADASSMARIA 3 роки тому +2

    Hello, I have a question is grain free food better than regular dog food?

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +5

      Grain free is actually recently proven to cause heart failure in dogs. It is recommended that if you feed grain free you change as soon as possible

    • @densan7856
      @densan7856 3 роки тому +1

      Or ad some home made grains to your pets food, de cuality of grain free food its better, no corn,wheat , soy and no by-products.

  • @luismanuel5423
    @luismanuel5423 Рік тому

    Hi, can you do a review on the purina one true instinct? Is it worth the extra bucks?

  • @teleportdinero
    @teleportdinero Рік тому +1

    whoever sold me this beneful betrayed me

  • @martacastellanos3394
    @martacastellanos3394 3 роки тому

    Cual es la mejor comida para perritos pequeños adultos

    • @eljona1665
      @eljona1665 2 роки тому

      Cualquier comida que diga “small breed”

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  Рік тому +1

      I try not to recommend any specific food, I just try and give you the tools you need to make an informed decision

  • @pandora_3314
    @pandora_3314 3 роки тому +3

    Thanks for the video, lots of good information. Is Purina Dog Chow, the classic original formula, a good food in your opinion? Thanks.

  • @chrism.4544
    @chrism.4544 5 місяців тому +1

    she doesn't introduce herself as doctor with credentials.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  5 місяців тому +2

      Introducing in many many past videos and credentials listed with 100% transperancy in the description box of every video. I don’t go over it anymore because I’m
      Literally 3 years and 6.6k subscribers in and they don’t want me degree dropping every video

    • @kimmytaehyuine5039
      @kimmytaehyuine5039 3 місяці тому

      She’s probably the only person on UA-cam who is an actual vet. But you seem to be one of those to take the opinion of someone with a online certification over someone who actually went to school for years to do what they love

  • @ThaRedPitbull
    @ThaRedPitbull 3 роки тому

    Do you think Purina is an alright dog food? I was feeding my dog the "healthy" dog food that doesn't have the grains and corn but he starting drinking a lot of water and peeing like a race horse. I got him the Lamb and rice and now he's drinking water normally again. He's a senior dog too. 14 years old.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +1

      I would get into your vet as senior dogs with increased drinking can be signs of more concerning conditions and not likley related to diet.

    • @ThaRedPitbull
      @ThaRedPitbull 3 роки тому

      @@AnimalDocRea He was taken to the vet for it. They said it was because he was old. It seems that it was something in the dog food because it has stopped.

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  3 роки тому +1

      glad he is doing better

  • @sheilaparsley1562
    @sheilaparsley1562 3 роки тому +1

    I use Purina One Chicken and Rice

  • @karenfaumuina9395
    @karenfaumuina9395 Рік тому

    That’s all I wanted to know which one is better lol

    • @AnimalDocRea
      @AnimalDocRea  Рік тому +1

      It’s all on an individual basis. These videos are about giving you the knowledge to pick out marketing pitfalls and assess a food for your pets specific needs

  • @jessicamiles5487
    @jessicamiles5487 Рік тому

    Is purina beneful and purina one and purina pro plan good to feed?