Portal Reloaded Didn't Need To Be Portal 3 To Be Amazing
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 кві 2021
- A new mod/fan-game for Portal 2 introduces a fourth dimension - time.
►SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/users/ConnorShawVA?...
►WHERE TO FIND ME: bio.site/connorshawva
PORTAL RELOADED: store.steampowered.com/app/12...
PORTAL STORIES: MEL VIDEO: • The Closest We'll Ever...
♫ Outro Song: Scootin' Through Clocktowers Beneath the Sea - A Hat in Time: gearsforbreakfast.com/games/a...
#Portal #Portal2 #PortalReloaded - Ігри
a positive video! i'm feeling a bit better!!
I'm really happy to hear that!!!!!
Be happy
This is a threat
Yay! Glad to hear it!
Glad to here! :3c
Very cool
5:10
I mean
Even portal 2 breaks some of its own rules sometimes
Im looking at you neurotoxin laser section
Lol yeah exactly what i thought when i played it through again lately
Agreed, the single new portal is such a tiny addition that completely changes how the puzzles can be presented and its exicuted well
It also adds new ways to fry your brain!
in portal 2 the part where he kills you, theres even a voiceline talkin about the "three portal device"
where
@@jackkrempa8069 when weathly asks you to come back he starts talking about everything that chell will find in the pit if she decides to jump
@@vxnnybunny So he was not lying? Maybe he knew about the testing facility down there?
It's just Wheatley desperately trying to convince you to killing yourself
@@Securityism this isnt official but cool idea
I think that Portal Reloaded has such a different approach to level design from PS: Mel. I love the mechanic of time travel and (most of) the maps it is used in. But unlike Mel's levels where the developers thought of various ways to make the maps difficult without being impossible(usually only one solution), Reloaded's approach was making them work with one solution in mind while accepting others. My favorite moment in Reloaded was when I completed a puzzle in an unintended timeline. I managed to reach the exit in the present while I should have reached it in the future. Should I have been able to do that? Probably not. But instead of breaking the game and finding a dead end of the map, the developers showed that they expect people to find unintended solutions, and had provided a way to get back on track. there is even unique dialogue in place for when you do that. I will also say that I definitely passed many levels in purely unintended ways (like running past the third laser grid when it was off for only a split second). Would I have called this Portal 3? No. I feel like it doesn't have enough polish, puzzle or narrative to be considered a third entry. Was it really fun to play and something I would suggest to any portal fan? Yes! Play it and have fun. Also good luck on Chamber 17, the solution I found (which seems to be the only viable solution to that chamber) is not intuitive nor a solution that any other chamber uses. Good Luck.
just a tiny bit late but if you no clip in the final chamber to finish in the wrong timeline there's a secret message
Lol. I've completed this mod today and while i was searching for solution i also find that the third grid can be disabled for a brief moment. Though i wasn't fast enough to actually do this way. Anyway all puzzle's were really thoughtful and it really was a pleasure to actually solve them by myself.
The puzzles based around the new mechanic made me really want a mod that lets you shoot portals through portals with new puzzles based around it
5:05 I never thought of that. In my head it makes sense why the future cube you spawned would go away after altering the past cube, but no you're absolutely right. The future cube should remain unaffected. Imagine how much more intricate the puzzles could get with a mechanic like that!
if you alter the past cube, you're changing the conditions that led to the future cube's placement. the future cube only existed where it did because the past cube remained untouched in that time span.
@@yikes6758 exactly, most time travel stories have delayed cause and effect for the purposes of the story? Oh no you made your parents never meet? you have a couple hours before you are erased.
Portal Reloded: Oh no you moved the present cube? The future cube matches it instantly.
What a coincidence. I just fell into the rabbit hole of portal and this video is posted just 35 minutes ago.
4:59 it make sense if you think about it:
if you destroy the future cube and respawn another one (through the button in the future) you have another separate cube indeed, *but*, if you move the cube in the present you're changing the timeline of the cube itself (the same one you destroyed in the future), hence you wouldn't have a reason to destroy it in the future.
Both of these Mel and reloaded feel exactly like what they are
Expansions on portal 2
Nothing will be portal 3 except for portal 3 if and when it comes out
Mel and reloaded are incredible expandions on portal 2 but i think valve are the only oned that can really create a portal 3
Unless the teams behind these came up with a super mod using source 2 which seems like a massive undertaking.
So basically it's Effect and Cause from Titanfall 2 but it's Portal.
Reminds me of Titanfall 2, The time travelling stage
Yeah, same
Thanks Connor, really needed this today, great video as always, keep up the good work!
2:34 "Despite appearances, the cleaned-up chambers are actually the past, and the rotten and overgrown ones the future"
Well, yeah, that's kind of obvious.
Why would being left untouched for 20 years make it any cleaner than when it was built?
Because polished clean sci fi gives imagery of "the future", while nature is often closer to our current time. :>
@@Lemilie Well, when a building is all dirty and falling apart, that usually means it's been there a while.
@@hatandhoodie_ exactly :)
Just like a ruin surrounded by jungle has been there for a while.
The ruin definitely looks *older*, but not necessarily like it's from the future
I would personally look at that ruin and think "oh that's a relic from the past!".
portal 2's old chambers are overgrown and the "new" ones are clean
There is an upcoming Portal 2 mod named Portal: Revolution that needs more attention. The developers plan to release it December 2022 on Steam, so it’s quite soon. I have been following its mod page and I am personally excited. I hope you would review it when it eventually gets released?
I don't see this as a Portal 2 but I do think it works as a sequel where GLaDOS invented a new Time Travel Portal Device and got a test subject and an A.I to test it, and that's it. This is also how I feel with the Paint Gun game
Dayum! This is an exceedingly good video. I can’t think of a single thing missed. Now a subscriber.
Connor back it again! Been watching sense how do drills work!
Or that was my first I watched video at least. Not 100% sure : \
The reason the "breaking the rules" chamber works is because the position only changes when:
1. you pick up the cube and drop it
2. the cube touches the ground.
did you notice that the future cube disappears only after the collision when it lands on the glass? that's because it hit the ground
Good to see you back
Happy to see you back
Portal Desolation really seems like it’s going to be the portal 3 we’re looking for
Is it still in development or is it dead? Also whats with repercussions?
YEA NEW CONNER VID
I like how the portals glow in this mod
Why didn't youtube tell me about you uploading, I always enjoy watching your videos
I arrived at this channel for the payday videos, and stayed for the other great content.
LESSSS GOOOOOOOOO NEW CONNOR VID
Honestly, I love the confusing mind bending part of time travelling in this game. There were times in portal 1 and especially 2 were things felt like too clear and straight forward. Compared to this game where you actually feel like test subject in a laboratory. You only have the goal and the tools. You need to make your own direction
HELL YEAH COMAR VIDEO LESSSS GOOOOO
This mod is literally built different.
we need a cube counter
Well there IS a story tho, You're a test subject trying to stop Chell from killing GlaDos in Portal 1 which the AI who guides wake you up to do because it was to check on the future via the time portals if the facility was still going fine
and it wasn't,we all know the story of portal and what happens 20 years into the future with Portal 2. and there only 2 endings that would make sense,the escape ending and the tube ending. with the tube ending if you decide you wanna go through with this mission then you would be 'saving' the facility but at the same time erasing the events of Portal 2. however should you go for the tube ending your facing reality by facing the headcrab zombies (Combine invasion).
imagine portal with RTX and light can travel through portals 2:46
My fucking brain aaaahhhhh
Maybe Gaben should invest in this company’s developers.
Just one guy made it lol
Didn't know about this wth need to play this but damn seems already so confusing
2:33 my favorite part
Is aperture tag considered a portal game?
As much as I love Portal, I'm way too dumb to finish this game on my own. I needed the official walkthrough for half the chambers.
I can solve almost any community made test chamber in portal 2 but for some reason I got to chamber 6 in reloaded and it completely broke my brain lol
I’m confused…but I am definitely gonna download this mod, lol
it would be cool to see a portal reloaded 2- WAIT THIS GAME IS LIKE VALVES ENDING WITH PORTAL 2!!!!!
DARN
Well this goes one step further and actually shows you what happened to the outside so maybe one day we will actually get to play after escaping aperture.
Awesome!
Yeah the gameplay mechanics are phenomenal, although the story doesn't need to have much depth if the game is just that good.
This mod reminds of sonic cd
Cool video about a cool mod
Counterpoint: Portal Reloaded is Portal 3, in a purely mathematical sense... because you can shoot three colors of portal. 👀
Actually, no, I have an even better idea. Portal 3... is actually more of an _Into the Aperture-Verse_ kind of thing, like the canon Perpetual Testing Initiative but each of these fangames takes place in those different parallel Apertures. Reloaded, Mel, Desolation, Prelude, arguably Desk Job even though it's Valve-made... all of these, _collectively,_ are Portal 3.
Hl2 betya r e a l
Great video! Love your essays about Portal fanmade content ♥️
(Though I wish you'd give some love to Aperture Tag. May not be the best, but it's one of my favourites ^^)
For me, Portal Reloaded is Portal 3
Chamber 22 that you showed is not actually a breaking of Reloaded's rules, the tutorial just doesn't explain it well enough. Basically, the future cube only changes position when the present cube's _destiny_ is _altered_ (as the tutorial states), which is _almost_ the same as "move present cube, future cube snaps into place in the future", except not quite.
Any infinite loop (between portals or between faith plates) does not count as a destiny change. Think about it -- if you just left that loop going for 20 years... you'd still find the cube looping after 20 years.
It's just that chamber 22 is the only time you're really tested on this idea, and the tutorial does _not_ show you an explicit example. Massive confusion results.
(Confusion also seems to result on chamber 17's time field trick -- I didn't have a problem with it, but apparently it even often got reported as a bug, which makes me think something really has gone astray in terms of game-to-player communication. Just _getting_ to chamber 17 takes real effort, so I can't just say "people aren't git gud-ing enough" to this, even if I don't understand why so many people found it so hard to notice.)
i think they might even have a voice line about how the faith plates are configured to work for decades? fair enough!
I have played Mel when "Advanced" was the only mode, and I did not find it all that difficult (I did try story mode when that came out and thought like "wow they really needed to make it this much easier? man either I'm a portal genius or the other players for whom this mode was made are just noobs"), I also can play a reasonable game of 5D Chess with Multiverse Timetravel, and still Reloaded got me stumped for quite a while on some puzzles.
Agreed. I loved Portal Reloaded. It’s a fun game with a lot of good puzzles.
However, Portal Stories: Mel is still my favourite fan game ever. I love the characters, the puzzles and the story. That’s not a slight on Reloaded. Reloaded is really, really good.
I love the Portal fandom and all the dedicated fans that take the time to make things like this.
The original portal was revolutionary because it forced you to think in a new way. Portal 2 did not really achieve that for me. It was a little too easy. Portal reloaded did force me to think in a new way. And for that reason I would consider it the better sequel. Even better than portal 2 IMO. Portal for me was never about the story but the puzzle and that feeling you get when forced to think about something in a completely new way. A completely new experience.
Класс
People really need to stop calling Portal mods Portal 3.
Both Mel and Reloaded are still clearly linked to the design aesthetic, gameplay style and art style of Portal 2.
A true Portal 3 would be as different from Portal 2 as Portal 2 is from Portal. Whilst also telling a narrative on par with P1 and P2 and having test chambers as refined as P1 and P2.
0:43 IT IS PORTAL 3 SILLY, PROBABLY BECAUSE PORTAL 3 HAS THE SAME TRIPLE PORTAL DEVICE!
I'd argue that reloaded is closer to a portal 3, since it does something new I'd expect from valve.
2nd
first
reloaded is genuinely too 5head for me, i had to just watch playthroughs
no story? I'm disappointed the story was my favorite part of Portal.
I think he was understating it a bit. There's some lore, it's just not the main focus and tbh the ending kinda wasn't that good.
The story is very simple but at least it doesn't drag on, the main attraction for Reloaded are the puzzles, and the overall pacing gives you that, puzzle after puzzle
Portal 3 is a game that is capable of 3 portals from the triple portal device. Triple is 3 portals in one device. MOUSE3-Shoot green Portal. So Portal Reloaded is just like Portal 3.
think this is the first time ive completed disagreed with connor, i hated this mod
What was wrong with it? Just curious 'cause I thought it was ok.
@@non-shockingtopics7563 the concept was gimmicky at best and confusing and disorientating at worst, every puzzle solve was literally just a sigh of relief rather than feeling like i actually accomplished anything. i feel like most of the puzzles i solved i just solved by doing random shit until it worked. the difficulty creep was ridiculous (one chamber took me 5 seconds and the next one took me like half an hour). i think at one point the game literally told me i wasn’t supposed to solve it the way i did. the story is awful and cringeworthy, the crosshair isn’t dynamic and looks like it was drawn with ms paint. the art direction was utter trash (in the final sequence there’s literally just a random out of place portable surface to allow you to escape). the programming is also god awful (all the time portal stuff is run through console commands *in the map* which involves *turning cheats on* just to run the commands). i genuinely have no idea why the portal community thought this mod was the best thing since sliced bread.
@@sticks_stuff I see what you mean. Said it in another comment, but I needed a walkthrough for most of the game, that's more my own fault though. Overall I thought it was pretty decent for a Portal mod. The only real problems I had with it was that the maps were under-detailed for the most part, there wasn't any real story, and the ending kinda sucked.
Beyond those things I thought it was a pretty cool concept, and having made some maps myself (as well as trying to make mods and having absolutely no idea what I was doing), pretty impressive for one guy to pull off with so few resources.
We, I guess we just have to agree to disagree.
Why would someone need Portal 3? Lots of people portal and half life fans have a brain damage. Since, those projects were CANCELLED. Also, (if your reading this as a fan for first time) those don't know "why Valve refused?" Valve announced, had issues from Source 2. They tried another chance. Unfortunately, they had to cancel IT. They don't have to say anything about their cancelled games.
Класс