I disagree with that idea that D lost his soul from Godwyn the Inseparable Sword states "The inseparable twins found solace in the Golden Order, the only institution not to revile them as accursed beings" the accursed is implied to be their sharing one soul and only joining the Golden Order they were instilled with this Anti-Death doctrine
Melina is a kindling maiden, she is “burned and body less”, I would bet that she is one of or a composite of these burned corpses. Marika was having children to send them to the forge of the giants to burn the erd tree, but their bodies were just being burned instead. There’s talk of the Recusant’s maiden being burned at the forge of the giants in one of his armor descriptions.
I'm inclined to agree, but we find Melina's dagger in the divine bridge lift outside Leyndell, together with Official's Attire, a robe also worn by Inquisitor Ghiza. It seems she never made it to the giants forge, and was maybe burned by an inquisitor.
@@Xandros999 very good point. I’ve been wondering more about her connection to the black knife assassins, and what it really means to be a numen. Love all the mystery in this game’s lore, but sometimes it makes it maddening to talk about.
@@nottwo Something I've been wondering about is their fighting style: Malenia, Melina, and the black knives have similar fighting styles. We know Malenia had a tutor from the eternal cities, but conversely I'm not sure it has anything in common with the NOx sword stresses. While on the topic there seems to be another popular style used by Blaidd, Godrick, and the sword wielding gargoyles where they go into a stance and start swinging furiously.
I wasn't so sure that undeath such as skeletons have overlapped with that of the nobles who just can't die or the erdtree guardians who seem directly connected to the tree. However there's an example of such undeath in spirit ashes, which is condoned by the Golden Order. BTW There are also headless trolls. Do they have a purpose other than associating Caria with the Mausoleum Knights?
Exactly bro I think you really cracking some s*** everybody else follows the same little template or whatever but I'm glad that you breaking off of the the normal and I'm so glad you said something about darker skin tone cuz for some odd reason everybody who did an elder ring video has not seen nobody who's darker skin in the elder man cuz they haven't talked about it
Fucking quality video, my man. I'm getting sick of all these butt sniffers making the same video as their friends in roughly the same timeframe. This is a fresh concept, and one that's viable to boot.
Man I couldn’t get through 5 seconds because of that damn robot voice. In this day and age if you’re too camera shy and her e so many good sounding AI voices. Why would you do this
I disagree with that idea that D lost his soul from Godwyn the Inseparable Sword states "The inseparable twins found solace in the Golden Order,
the only institution not to revile them as accursed beings" the accursed is implied to be their sharing one soul and only joining the Golden Order they were instilled with this Anti-Death doctrine
Nice vid man 👍🏽
coming back to this after the dlc announcement was a jackpot
Great lore video, hope this gets out to more of the elden community, really helps explains what undeath actually means in elden ring.
Melina is a kindling maiden, she is “burned and body less”, I would bet that she is one of or a composite of these burned corpses. Marika was having children to send them to the forge of the giants to burn the erd tree, but their bodies were just being burned instead. There’s talk of the Recusant’s maiden being burned at the forge of the giants in one of his armor descriptions.
I'm inclined to agree, but we find Melina's dagger in the divine bridge lift outside Leyndell, together with Official's Attire, a robe also worn by Inquisitor Ghiza. It seems she never made it to the giants forge, and was maybe burned by an inquisitor.
@@Xandros999 very good point. I’ve been wondering more about her connection to the black knife assassins, and what it really means to be a numen. Love all the mystery in this game’s lore, but sometimes it makes it maddening to talk about.
@@nottwo Something I've been wondering about is their fighting style: Malenia, Melina, and the black knives have similar fighting styles. We know Malenia had a tutor from the eternal cities, but conversely I'm not sure it has anything in common with the NOx sword stresses.
While on the topic there seems to be another popular style used by Blaidd, Godrick, and the sword wielding gargoyles where they go into a stance and start swinging furiously.
Great theories. Subbed.
I wasn't so sure that undeath such as skeletons have overlapped with that of the nobles who just can't die or the erdtree guardians who seem directly connected to the tree. However there's an example of such undeath in spirit ashes, which is condoned by the Golden Order.
BTW There are also headless trolls. Do they have a purpose other than associating Caria with the Mausoleum Knights?
Exactly bro I think you really cracking some s*** everybody else follows the same little template or whatever but I'm glad that you breaking off of the the normal and I'm so glad you said something about darker skin tone cuz for some odd reason everybody who did an elder ring video has not seen nobody who's darker skin in the elder man cuz they haven't talked about it
The way the TTS pronounces Maliketh 😂
5:16 How was Ranni present when her burning corpse is in Liurnia Divine tower.. thats not Ranni
Very very interesting
This is a quite functioning theory. I like it, this might be it.
Fucking quality video, my man. I'm getting sick of all these butt sniffers making the same video as their friends in roughly the same timeframe. This is a fresh concept, and one that's viable to boot.
I think Fia is Miquella.
Good video
Undeath and Eternal Life are not the same thing...
Shit, I think you're probably right
nice lore video bur can't stand robot voice
Obviously you can
Man I couldn’t get through 5 seconds because of that damn robot voice. In this day and age if you’re too camera shy and her e so many good sounding AI voices. Why would you do this