High end spinning rod weigh off!! Megabass vs Shimano vs St Croix vs Dobyns.... OH MY!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @KJMFISHING
    @KJMFISHING 4 роки тому +2

    Thanks for the video! You hit the nail on the head when explaining the Dobyns balance and how they feel lighter because of it. I have rods that are lighter on the scales than some of my Dobyns, but in the hand it's a different story, the Dobyns feel lighter when the others have too much weight distributed towards the tip. It also makes a big difference is sensitivity.

    • @rapalaman6681
      @rapalaman6681 4 роки тому +1

      Correct. Balance is everything, well maybe sensitivity but yet again the lighter rod has likely more sensitivity. I have a few Edge rods and are not the lightest but fish light because of better balance. I also have the new 7' 2020 Legend Xtreme and compared to my Legend Elite feels lighter but in truth is not BUT the balance point is over 3" further back!! Balance points are getting more important because reels are getting lighter. QUESTION. The Expride and Legend X both weighed the same. How does their balance compare? Awesome review and thanks! Would be fun to weigh the tips on your scale?

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      I think the extra bulk & weight of the Xtreme's "skin" handles help the balance. I had a previous generation Xtreme (the blue ones) and it was also well balanced.. for St Croix.

    • @rapalaman6681
      @rapalaman6681 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing The new 7 foot 2020 Xtreme balance point with the AGS guides has a balance point of only 4" to center of rod foot. With the new 2020 Metanium the balance point is touching the reel.

  • @nyewang
    @nyewang 4 роки тому +3

    I have three 7M rods and it seems the cheaper the lighter in my case:
    1) Daiwa Tatula XT 7M (MSRP $99) and it comes at 3.4 oz. Fishes VERY well and I have pair it with a light Okuma RTX reel which 6.6 oz and my daughter use it all day without getting too tired.
    2) My expride 7m is at 3.75oz so good weight tolerance there in compression with yours.
    3) My Dobyns Champ Extreme HP which has the highest MSRP is at 4.75 oz but its rated higher for both line and lure weight. I feel this rod is more MH and I use it accordingly.
    Keep up the great videos!

    • @nyewang
      @nyewang 4 роки тому

      BTW, I bought the expride based on your recommendation a while back. Still trying to get some more time on the water with it.

    • @nyewang
      @nyewang 4 роки тому

      I just got a Kistler Zbone 7m spinning. Came out at 3.49 oz. Just fyi

  • @toddwilliams8911
    @toddwilliams8911 3 роки тому +1

    I know it didn’t exist when the video was made, but for $180.00, the St Croix Victory VTS610MLXF drop shot rod weighs in at 3.1 oz. I’ve used it all season this year & caught a bunch of fish on it. I highly recommend it.

  • @umdivx
    @umdivx 4 роки тому +2

    You're welcome on the loaner rods 😎

  • @rangerjonoutdoors6429
    @rangerjonoutdoors6429 3 роки тому +1

    Great video brother really enjoyed it. I’m a Rod snob as well. Great to see my thoughts on the tatula confirmed! Rock on

  • @edwingroot4751
    @edwingroot4751 Рік тому

    Hey Hello, I fish a lot with the drop shot at 85 feet with 2.5 inc lures and with 3/8 drop shot lead. which rod from st croix or any other good brand is the best? Must be a 2 piece fishing rod. I look forward to your reaction.

  • @alexanderlee6509
    @alexanderlee6509 3 роки тому +1

    Interesting factoid about weights. My brand new Levante EMTF arrived today along with lightly used 7’6” St Croix Legend Elite Medium Fast spinning. The EMTF is a 7’5” medium with medium fast action. The St Croix came in at 4.0 ounces while the Levante at 4.6 ounces. Using you method of testing action, the St Croix had a much softer action compared to the EMTF despite the EMTF being designed for treble hook applications. Bought them both from American Legacy Fishing. They have a trade in program so you can sometimes find noteworthy used rods. The product pics show the serial number and with St Croix, you can decipher the manufacture date from it. So this rod was less than a year old.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  3 роки тому

      You're going to love that legend Elite!

  • @joexiong13
    @joexiong13 4 роки тому +1

    So glad I purchased some NRX before the price increase. Although I did get discount pricing at the time.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +1

      Everyone gets discount pricing on NRXs :)

  • @nawinchester
    @nawinchester 4 роки тому +1

    Great stuff Brian. Love the topic. Creates interesting discussions. I was surprised at the Dobyns weights, as I have six Dobyns in my lineup, all Champ Xtr HPs, and your point about balance is a good one as it seems like no matter what reel I put on the Dobyns, they marry well from a balance standpoint and fish/feel much lighter than they weigh. Looking forward to your reviews of the Conquest and Orochi XX spinning to see if they are 1) worth the money and 2) if you have found your perfect drop shot rod. Thanks for the video and look forward to future content.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +1

      What stood out to me is how much lighter standard Tatula is vs the elite

  • @Amir-zx5xh
    @Amir-zx5xh 3 роки тому

    Dog over there”I don’t give a crap about any of that,get me a treat”🥓

  • @jethrobodine011
    @jethrobodine011 3 роки тому +2

    This is sick. Some people hang art on their walls I hang rods and guns

  • @TheTravelingFisherman
    @TheTravelingFisherman 2 роки тому

    I currently have a Daiwa tatula 7'3 M XF paired on a Shimano stradic ci4 2500, primarily a shaky head setup, not liking the rod,looking at getting a Megabass Orochi 7" shaky head rod, thoughts?

  • @gtaoutdoors8997
    @gtaoutdoors8997 4 роки тому +1

    Awesome video 👊 I'm currently looking to purchase the glx852s jwr 7'1" . On the gloomis website has a glx892 jwr 7'5" which I'm leaning towards, both have the same action can you tell me the difference?

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      What techniques do you like to throw?

    • @gtaoutdoors8997
      @gtaoutdoors8997 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing I'm looking for something very universal so from tubes , weightless senkos, topwater poppers , jerkbaits maybe even 1/8 walleye jigs

    • @gtaoutdoors8997
      @gtaoutdoors8997 4 роки тому

      Lots of thinking 7 ft shimano expride or glx 852 what would you pick ?

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      @@gtaoutdoors8997 spinning? I would expride over the GLX every time.

    • @gtaoutdoors8997
      @gtaoutdoors8997 4 роки тому

      Wow really .. yes spinning thanks you. now I just have to wait until July on backorder

  • @joexiong13
    @joexiong13 3 роки тому +1

    Not sure how I missed this video. But I honestly sold my NRX 822DSR after using the MB WhipSnake. Lol. The accuracy of the MB is just way superior for casting and also the parabolic bend is way better. I haven’t missed lost a single bass on Drop shotting yet.

    • @joexiong13
      @joexiong13 3 роки тому

      Nvm. I lied. Lol I see my comment on the bottom 😝

  • @davidrauschenbach6871
    @davidrauschenbach6871 4 роки тому +1

    Nice comparisons, I picked up a shimano poison adrena medium casting rod! Hopefully they’ll come out with more spinning models.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +1

      I'm waiting for a 7'-7'3 posion adrena spinning rod. Maybe next year.

    • @davidrauschenbach6871
      @davidrauschenbach6871 4 роки тому

      PunchFishing With ICAST being cancelled doubt they’ll release one. But yes a longer one would be great! Just wondering if shimano was ready to release a new metanium dc ?

  • @BigBass-xf5yi
    @BigBass-xf5yi 3 роки тому +1

    All hail G Loomis!!!
    My favorite stick.
    Hey Brian, I noticed that you don’t really work with the Steedz rods at all. Any reason ???

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  3 роки тому +1

      I've had a steez spinning rod in the past. They are quite nice! Something about AGS.. it just doesn't really do it for me.

  • @jb-nl7ki
    @jb-nl7ki 4 роки тому +1

    If u go on asian fishing portal u can buy exprides for 160-200 depending on models as well as other products for way cheaper than retail. The shipping is fast I’ve bought from there before

    • @rapalaman6681
      @rapalaman6681 4 роки тому +1

      Considering how China has screwed us over would be nice to buy American. Hard to do I know but it crosses my mind more than ever.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      Luckly there's some great options for American Made fishing rods.. reel's however... there are none.

    • @rapalaman6681
      @rapalaman6681 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing But we can still choose Japan manufacture over Communist China reels. Even South Korea or Malaysia (their flag is similar to ours-check it out) are higher quality reels. There is another site that reviews reels most BFS from China and they mostly have some kind of problem. PS Rapalaman is also a Minnesota guy.

  • @bass_n_guitar_8682
    @bass_n_guitar_8682 4 роки тому +1

    How do the Champion extremes compare to the expride in sensitivity

  • @rich5916
    @rich5916 2 роки тому

    Can you do this video again with your current lineup?

  • @termite122
    @termite122 2 роки тому

    the first dobyns rod you weighed was 7.3in so you cant count that with the 7 footers..overall weight of a rod is basically irevelant..its a balanced rod with the correct reel weight that allows comfortable fishing all day with no arm fatique..nice video

  • @5.7.0bassin2
    @5.7.0bassin2 4 роки тому +1

    Have you ever used the tatula xt casting rods i just bought was wondering if you have any takes on it

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +1

      Nothing beyond picking them up and playing with them in stores. I don't really have any concrete thoughts or opinions on them though.

    • @5.7.0bassin2
      @5.7.0bassin2 4 роки тому +1

      Thanks i know you like your higher end stuff lol figured i throw it out there lol

  • @NS3644
    @NS3644 4 роки тому +1

    Don't forget the Shimano/Jackal Poison Adrena and Poison Ultima which weigh in all around the NRX or well under the NRX. :)

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +1

      Yes, everyone can't stop talking about the Adrenas! I may grab one at some point. Theres just not a model that I need in my lineup... Yet

    • @NS3644
      @NS3644 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing Have 2, just can't get enough of them :) "Tight Lines"

  • @taylorlufflongchamp7992
    @taylorlufflongchamp7992 4 роки тому

    So is the daiwa tatula rod the black one is it sensitive like it should be a $300 or 400 rod .?im thinking of getting it but idk if I should spend that I have a $250 limit or is it worth getting shimano or what if that makes any sense lol

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      The Tatula is not as crisp and sensitive as rods higher than it's price point, BUT for around 130$ it's a heck of a rod line. I have a full review of the Tatula rod in my video history.

  • @seanhung14982
    @seanhung14982 4 роки тому +2

    What about those poison adrenas?

  • @coachMiguelfishing
    @coachMiguelfishing 4 роки тому +1

    Nice vid, yea I’m a daiwa and dobyns rod fan but recently switched to just dobyns because of they warranty one of the best out there I recently broke the tip of my daiwa I had to ship the whole rod to them and the receipt luckily I had a rod box already or it would have cost me over 50$ to ship.. with Dobyns all you have to do is mail then the section that tells you the length and power so like 5$ and a flat rate of depending on the I have mainly champions so 60$ for a brand new rod no receipt necessary 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      Dobyns warranty is legit! No question.

  • @5.7.0bassin2
    @5.7.0bassin2 3 роки тому

    Id like to see what ya think of that 13 rod after you fished it im just curious cuz i kno2 most of their stuff is budget friendly

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  3 роки тому

      I sold it already, but I did make a review video if you look in my video history.

  • @Ryan-re1rs
    @Ryan-re1rs 4 роки тому +1

    I have a few decent rods and setups. I go out with my 4 year old son fishing the pond in my backyard, I throw my 270 dollar shimano rod around, but I always end up having to help my son cast his 10 dollar Mickey mouse rod. After 20 min he is done and throwing rocks, but I seem to still use his little cheap rod and catch more bass on it then I do my 600 dollar setup. Goes to show $$ gear doesn't make fish bite. Plus it really feels like a fight with a 3 foot poll and 5 pound line.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      Quality gear isn't really a out catching more fish, it's enjoying your time between bites.

  • @russhaight3225
    @russhaight3225 4 роки тому +1

    Quickly becoming my favorite fishing youtuber.
    Do you not like the Conquest?

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      I do like it.. but it's hard to recommend for the price. I'll be doing a review soonish. It did land a Musky today while I was smallmouth fishing.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      Also.. I don't make fishing videos! There's way better fishing UA-camrs out there.

    • @rapalaman6681
      @rapalaman6681 4 роки тому +1

      @@PunchFishing Now that I am in my 70's, I have found that the mid price of anything is the best value. And we pay a lot more to gain a declining amount of value. But what helps me justify the new Xtreme or Conquest rods is the made in USA thing. Thoughts?

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому +3

      @@rapalaman6681 I don't think you can really justify any bass rod over $600. At that price point they are "flagship" model rods and only really designed for the true enthusiast. Every company that manufacturers a product needs to have a flagship version of that product that shows off what they can do with technology and design. It doesn't matter the hobby really. Golf clubs, cars, guns... Companies need to "show off what they are capable of" and thus we have ultra high end products on the market. If you got the money, and you are passionate about these kinds of things then by all means grab a conquest or Xteme. Are they "worth the money?" No.. not really. You can get nearly the same performance in rods half the price. Are they still fun to use? Hell yes! You spend 90% of your fishing trip making casts that don't result in a bite, why not make that as enjoyable as you can with quality gear?

  • @stanreedy2686
    @stanreedy2686 2 роки тому

    by any chance do you know any weights on the GLX

  • @stanreedy2686
    @stanreedy2686 3 роки тому

    I have the NRX 802C its extremely light do you know the weight on it

  • @ericjchastain
    @ericjchastain 4 роки тому +3

    I have 6.8 nrx medium heavy inshore rod it’s like 4 oz also have a sarge customs with recoil guides rod like a feather it’s 6.9 medium heavy it’s only 2.8oz rod makes nrx feel heavy and the sentivity of the rod is off the charts with the recoil guides his baiaster medium action are like 2.45 oz it’s crazy and it only cost $
    389. Still like my nrx for heavy jigs and heavier 3/4 to 1 1/2 lures but sarge custom are a dream to fish have in ballistic lt 3000 whole combo like 8.7 oz feels like a toy when you cast it feel like your going throw the whole thing in the water.

  • @jacobturner9947
    @jacobturner9947 4 роки тому

    Great video brother. Was really hoping for a Dobyns Xtasy in there... 😝

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      Dobyns should send me one!

    • @jacobturner9947
      @jacobturner9947 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing I know right! 😅 you pay shipping I'll send you mine and my Poison Adrena...

    • @KJMFISHING
      @KJMFISHING 4 роки тому +1

      They're not a whole lot lighter than the Extremes. They have more Kevlar wrapping on them and AAAA full cork handles. They do feel light in hand though like he explained about Dobyns rods and I don't think there is a better looking rod. The blanks on them are crazy skinny, but powerful. I've went to grab my 755c a few times and thought I was grabbing my 702c HP. Xtasy 723c weighs 4.6 oz and the 755c weighs 5.1 oz.

  • @antoniocabanas460
    @antoniocabanas460 4 роки тому +1

    What about the Glx 852s ?

  • @jimt5683
    @jimt5683 4 роки тому +1

    Dobyns is not the lightest, but I take balanced and warranty over lightness. Dobyns FTW

  • @Jon-nz3dm
    @Jon-nz3dm 4 роки тому +1

    Hey dude, do you have the Orochi 7' "Shakeyhead" rod? If so, can it actually throw 1/8oz baits as the rating would suggest? I'm looking into getting a rod that's a step up from what I'm used to($130-$200 rods). I would just get something that's like 7'6" but I want to be able to throw nose hooked flukes and other small baits that require rod twitches as well as steady retrieve baits. All around rod that can throw 1/8 to 3/8 well. Also looking at the 7'1" medium Tatula AGS rod. Let me know if you've used either.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      I do not own the Shakeyhead Orochi. The 7'1 Medium Tatula AGS Brent Ehler rod would be perfect for that. It's a killer rod, I actually owned it for a year. I liked it a lot.

    • @Jon-nz3dm
      @Jon-nz3dm 4 роки тому

      @@PunchFishing Sooo I just ordered the 7'1" Tatula AGS rod and I got it for $217 shipped! You can get any daiwa product on americanlegacyfishing's website for 20% off right now. Use code "DAIWA" if you're interested in anything(i think the code ends tomorrow). I also had some points and got an additional $10 off. I'd say I got a damn good price for this $279 rod.

  • @TheSisavath
    @TheSisavath 3 роки тому +1

    Kistler zbone is 3.2 it’s a m 7’

  • @TheArsenal187
    @TheArsenal187 4 роки тому +1

    Dang someone must of hit the thumbs down on accident......LOL. Awesome video

  • @alexrod714
    @alexrod714 3 роки тому +2

    I have the same st Croix Legend X. My absolute favorite rod. Also you can't beat st Croix warranties on these rods.

  • @moistsoggybottom7506
    @moistsoggybottom7506 3 роки тому

    When you said mid to high range rods it caught me off guard whem you just started at $150, I thought you were gonna start with something like $70 bionic blade

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  3 роки тому

      I'd argue mid range is that 160-230 price point.

  • @JelsmaOutdoors
    @JelsmaOutdoors 4 роки тому

    Wow, it's great to know that our 7 foot med is still lighter than everybody else.

  • @czykrepublic4323
    @czykrepublic4323 4 роки тому +1

    $695 fpr a Conquest? Good Lord.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      The new price increases on NRX and conquest is tough to stomach

  • @q4life551
    @q4life551 3 роки тому

    Only rod you need: nrx

  • @PATHETIC_DISASTER
    @PATHETIC_DISASTER 4 роки тому +1

    If you channel was bigger, i can assure you 13fishing bots would be damage controlling your "13fishing is trash" in the comment section. But yes, their producs are overpriced Lada's.

    • @PunchFishing
      @PunchFishing  4 роки тому

      I'm actually going to do a full review on that 13 Envy. I picked up for like 120 bucks last year. I need to drag the bottom with it a little more this weekend, then I'll give it a full rundown. It's a weird rod.

  • @denelvo
    @denelvo 4 роки тому +1

    "If you made it this far, you ARE a rod snob, and MUST subscribe" :-D