MG Comet vs Tata Tiago - Which Budget EV To Buy? | MotorBeam
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2023
- We compare the newly-launched MG Comet to the popular Tata Tiago EV to help you decide which budget EV suits your requirements the most!
Become a #MotorBeamer: bit.ly/MotorBeamer and join the #MBSquad
Meet us - www.motorbeam.com/join-us/
Visit our website: www.motorbeam.com
Follow us on Instagram: / motorbeam
Like us on Facebook: / motorbeam
Follow us on Twitter: / motorbeam - Авто та транспорт
Hey #MotorBeamers! Which one will you buy and why?
I'm going to buy Tata tiago ev because it's more value for money
Tata Tiago any day
This is not right comparison. Tiago EV is for budget buyer who want a single car. However comet is for people who have 2 cars, one big suv like Safari for outstation use and one small for city use.
Tiago ev, mg car looks very bad
@@tanmay4274 Exactly!
The MG Comet is not for middle class people buying their first car or smth its for the ones having it as a secondary vehicle specifically for daily urban commute, for the ones who have to travel alone for work everyday for maybe 50 to 100 kms, definitely makes sense.
I will choose tata tiago anyday without having a second thought 😂
They need to launch higher variant with 27kwh battery and real life range of 300km for 10L something with fast DC. I will buy for sure. In china they have launched with much bigger 26-28 kwh battery and fast DC for higher variants at 12000USD so why not India
@@nayanatopiwala8751 mg car not practical looking very small and ugly
Same here bro
Same here tata Tiago have more practical tham comet
@@nayanatopiwala8751 They think we can't afford it 😡😡
Tata should launch a nano ev which can easily take over that mg
Yes , and launch nano ev with 5 to 6 lakh pricing definitely it will kill comet
Comet is already dead I think
Nano is more ugly than comet.
Tiago is way better than comet. Only some smart ass people will buy comet for show off rest will go for tiago
No need tiago is enough who on earth would buy this Mg cartoon character while better product Tiago in the market in similar price range
The amount of steel used in comet. In that amount maruti can make 3 ertigas
Underrated comment😂😂
😂😂😂
MG looks like an electric auto with some modern features 😅
Very true 😂
It is a chinese auto 🛺 bro by MG forsure😅
Mere muh ki baat cheen li, bhai China main ditto product ata hai MG ke parent brand ke name se
True just like Tiago is a taxi.
@@theelectricmile474 bro, We trust Taxis, Taxis are build to last longer and are practical on Indian Condition. Toys are for small kids 😅.
Tata should bring Nano ev, Indians ko design/tech/safety features/ncap rating yeh sab ka chaska lag Chuka hai...comet won't attract much customer but for sure this will create another segment.
Thanks for this review. You got it write but most people commenting against this car are probably not understanding the market segment it serves. Right segment for this car is people who 1. Already have a big car like Safari/innova for outstation drives 2. Have place to park 2 cars 3. Have infrastructure to charge electric car. 4. Need a small car for small city commutes like office, dropping kids to school, driving to crowded market.
This car is far better than any other car currently sold in India when it comes to 1. Ability to park in tight spaces 2. Drivability on crowded, bumper to bumper city traffic
There is truly no competition in current market for comet as its only product in that segment.
Tiago EV segment is budget EV, which is different from lifestyle EV segment that comet comes in. If Tata relauches Nano in electric avatar, then it will be competition for comet.
MG should provide fast charger and ADAS based city creep mode features and bump price to 10L to remove tag of cheapest EV
Tiago Ev clear winner sir
Because DC charging not available in Comet EV
DC charging not available is just one of many points to go for Tiago Ev over Comet Ev
Why you’re not comparing with full option Tiago EV? Did MG Pay you? 😂 If the interiors need to be comparable with Comet, you’ve chosen the wrong variant. You still missed to show crucial features like DC fast charging port, auto sensing wipers, auto sensing headlamps, cruise control etc this variant of Tiago EV offers. Excellent video idea, but a poorly executed one. Btw, there is no Eco mode in Tiago EV.
Bro probably Tata paid him, to make the obvious choice in these 2 cars clear to a lot of people.
Most channels are doing the same thing. By just comparing comet with tiago , they are placing comet on two segment above. Also claming 5 star for comet . Whereas result is not available.
Suddenly huge respect for tata nano😂
Shit company Tata. No spares no service filthy service centers
Compared to Tiago comet is better option,you get to see more features and efficiency, there's a premium feel in the interiors
Sahi me premium feel de rahi
Totally agreed
Tiago me nahi h ye sab
Tiago se better h bhai comet
Will you pay 10+ lakhs for such a small car
Bhai koi nahi lega is dabbe ko😂😂 is price me , 4-5 lakh me aati to sahi rehta abhi to yeh disaster hai
True, lekin EVs in general expensive hoti hain
@@pgohil100 bhai rival se compare Karo na same price me Tiago aati hai better features,range ,size,build quality sab kuch better hai yeh to overpriced hai
@@pgohil100 tiago ev is better any day than this dabba
Reva (mahindra e2o ) is much more practical...but tiago is car...
Haa Bhai ko 2lakh m milega 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why tata tiago- 300km range, 5airbags,
practical in every possible way, storage plenty,
seating -your wish,
safety -more than 3star and based on your driving.
Reliable-100% guarantee tata has put so much research and development in his car.
Last is- its a car that will live longer if you treat it right and it will always be there for you
I think you streched back, the front seats of TATA Tiago too much, which makes it look like less spacious in the back seat.
16:56 seats are going beyond the door opener.
I get 200+ constant range on my LR Tiago..
Its all about using the regen effectively!!
How many times in the video did I say “so that’s about it”? 🤭
How many ever times you said 😂
Comet is cute but tiago is practical
Ugly
Cute 😂
Boss, Tiago EV top variant comes with Contrast Black roof. Also Tiago EV has Cooled glovebox, leatherette seats, push button start, iTPMS, Auto headlamps, Rain sensing wipers, follow me home lamps, home fast charging etc.
MG COMET could have replaced autos and taxis in India, had the prices been lower (3-4L INR). But in 10Lakh this is not at all a worthy EV to buy considering the fact that we have Tiago EV in the same price range.
Just giving LED setup and few gimmicky features will not attract Indian buyers, considering such a low market design of COMET.
🚙 Tata Tiago EV is a hatchback
🚗 MG Comet EV is an urban electric vehicle
No rear doors! Can’t replace autos.
@@NidhishAbraham MG comet is a covered AC golf kart😂
MG COMET re branded Wuling air ev from china
@@RARE_0_0_7 thanks for pointing this bhai.. the other reason to reject this EV
Important thing people forget is in china it was wuling mini ev (2020 launch)that was far more successful than air ev which is comet and recently launched in 2022. Wuling mini ev started at 4500 USD unlike air ev that is launched at 10K-11K even in china where battery and electronics is much cheaper
The high cost of the car is due to Indian Govt policies where importing cars has insane amount of taxes. Also India doesn't allow manufacturing in India for MG or BYD as they are from China. So obviously they have to sell at high price. Can't blame MG
@@subhashishpanda2617 India allows manufacturing locally. Currently both byd and mg follows assembly model where most of platform comes ready from China and some component sources locally and assembled. BYD does not have much local sourcing but planning one. MG has local plant in halol. It uses this plant for export to south east Asia earning us forex. But cost is due to battery sourcing. Due to limited supplier in India and mandate of around 60% sourcing for fame 2 battery supplier have leverage on price as well as customs unlike china where both batteries and electronics are cheaper
Old school mind
@@subhashishpanda2617 What a bullshit, MG has a plant in Gujrath and BYD has a plant in Chennai.India do not discriminate Chinese companies.But what China is yet to allow 100% disinvestment in Chinese automobile sector, which means you need to have a Chinese partner to enter Chinese market.
@@spetsnazGru487 Thats bullshit. BYD is just assembling in Chennai no manufacturing. Asa for MG, no more investments, they are not able to expand production due to restriction by Indian Government. Chinese EV market is doing insanely well. BYD is the largest in the world, but only 1-2 models of BYD comes to India
you should appreciate Parth for bringing in regular content including comparing a car with an electric golf kart 😜
MG costs 8.4 lakh on the road
Tiago costs 12 lakhs
Tiago is a car
Comet is a box
Now Mg revealed the variants and its prices look at that😂😂😂
MG cost 10.4 lakh
and also he compared the comet ev full variant but showed Tata Tiago ev XT variant. XZ+ Tech lux which is full variant has more good features auto rain sensing wiper, auto fog lamps, leather seats, automatic motor bboot opening etc. It is not at all a fair comparison. And also look at the space offered in the rear in comet ev 😂
And also he told Tata Tiago ev range is 160-180km but i own Tata Tiago ev XZ+ Tech Lux which has given me 217 km with full charge
Wait till TATA launches Altroz EV base model under 10 lakhs. Then these Auto Rickshaws don't stand a chance. Tiago was just a trailer before launch of Altroz EV.
Been Waiting for it!! No Updates on those as well..
@@prashanthgv86 They don't want to release Altroz EV because Tiago EV was launched just 4 months back. Demand for Tiago will drop if they announce the launch of Altroz EV. Once they are done with selling targeted number of Tiago EV, they will launch Altroz EV. Most likely it will get launched along with Nexon facelift in October festive season.
Comet
No fast charging, 5 to 8 hours fully charge
zero to 100 in 25 seconds !!
Poor handling and Stability
Ride quality is poor
Safety is very low
On road price: 8.5 lakhs
Tiago EV (with similar battery pack - mid range)
Fast charging
Better handling, stability and Ride quality
4 star
8 year warranty on motor and battery
On road price: 9.5 Lakhs
==============
I think people know which one to buy
👌
Wah ji wah me soch hi raha tha yeh dono ka comparison ❤❤ thanks motorbeam
Comet EV is strictly targeted for rich city people who want second or third car. This car has premium interiors, and millineals who want to stand apart may like it. However, some of them may instead go for the top lux variant of Tiago EV which is not far behind in terms of comfort features.
Anyway this micro EV segment is becoming very interesting. In China, these were hugely successful with millions of micro EVs on road. Do youb think they will work in India?
Took a test drive today and I'm impressed with it. It'll be my second car to go around in the city. It's decently comfortable and doesn't really feel like just 40ps.
I'm not really sure if it'll attract a lot of buyers but it's perfect for me.
This isn't for the mass. It's just a hit or miss just bcz of the price of it. No Fast Charging in 2023 and at this price tag is a big no.
In China it was wiling mini EV at starting price of 4500 dollars i.e roughly 3.5L not this one. This one in china cost 9700-11800 usd. Wiling do have proper 4 door with bootspace car called wuling bingo ev, you can search online. That would succeed in India. Its its around 1000-1200 usd costlier than wuling air ev
They will work if according to their size they will price them between 3L to 5L
For price difference, I would take Tata over comet as 2nd or 3rd car. Comet has no crumple zone you get involved in accident and you are for sure dead with family.
Mg commet looks similar to Wuling Mini Ev 😮
It is the same car only, just sold with a different name in India
🚙 Wuling Air EV
It's basically Chinese car
Because it is wuling mini ec
For EV cars, please always tell how much it takes to charge from 20% to 80%. Generally that is very fast. The time it takes to reach from 80% to 99/100% is what is most of the charging time. So if the driving range for you is within 80%, please plan with that sense. For most EVs that should be 2 to 3 hrs.
One suggestion... Since U do a lot of back and forth with Tiago and Comet, it makes sense that everytime U discuss/show Comet, caption "Comet EV" should appear. Same for Tiago.
Even if comet had few more amazing features i would chose tiago in a heartbeat. No second thought 😂
Saste log ki Sasti Chize 😂
Loved the futuristic approach
Comet is much better in looks and more advanced in tech than Tiago!!❤..it's ideal for crowded, city commute and not for long drives where Tiago covers that part of requirements
Another failed compact Car in a market, people in India did not spare any space for Nano ( actually practical city Car) for 2 lakh , so what about this compressed chinies Wagonar 😂😂 Tiago is any time best in this price segment
Tata should bring Nano electric to compete cars like comet....
No need to bring nano ev. There is no competition at all from comet for Tiago
Tata Tiago is good 😊👍
this comparison makes no sense , mg comet is made like an secondary car for city for market/shopping etc like an utility , and tiago is an actual car
All about money, you pay little bit similar for both
its all about money. both cars have almost same pricing. thats why he is comparing.
We Indians have mentality of Bigger is always better. May be thats why Reva failed and Nano also. And by the looks of the Comet it might be the next one joining the Nano gang soon.
What would be the battery replacement cost for tiago ev
Instead of going for basic cars like Tiago, we can upgrade to technologically more advance car like Comet
True 👍🏻
Well said
For fair comparison should have shown tiago xe ev
The comet shown here is not 7.58 lakh...it's more
@@manoja538mg have officially launched only a single variant so idk what they gonna deliver
Its high time for Tata to launch Nano EV under 5 Lakhs.
Side by side size comparison could've been shown better. Parallel parked all sides so we could see length width height difference easily.
Comet definitely looks tempting as a second car just for crowded city areas...however at that price range its a joke ...I feel sad for people who will fall in their trap and buy this toy for 10-12lakhs 😂😂😂
Wdym?? Batteries are expensive + all the quality and features + the taxes in India have made it expensive
@@asap8368 Yes however Tiago EV offers much more at that price and is a proper car...why would one go for a half baked semi car at the same price just some little premium colors and dashboard materials?
Comets makes sense at 7-9Lakhs on road..anything above 9.. Tiago EV becomes the logical choice.
@@herambpatkar
Comet on road price is 8.5 lacs
@@RAJ-km8gw for the base variant...tiago ev base comes at 9.8L on road just 1.3L more and you get a proper 4 seater car with safety standards.
@@herambpatkarWith recent price reduction,Comet has been brought to 7-9 lacs on road now.
Absolutely our brand TATA Tiago wins both hearts and competition.
Tiago driver seat has been set back maximum and not to your drive position. So there would be better space in the back seat
Comet should have been named meteor as I am pretty sure it will burn out once it enters the competition.
Well said...😂
Comet has no competition as far as maneuverability is concerned.Yet doesn't sell in numbers.
MG is covering up comet's deficiencies by not giving fast charging. By that it prevents taking it on the highway. Its highway manners are questionable.
It still should have a boot by extending half ft at least.
The price at the current configuration should not be more than 6 lacs on-road.
They recently reduced the price, still the mid variant costs 8.3 which doesn't even have reverse camera ( shame on MG) then why does it have 10.5 screen?.
No auto AC. Seats not comfortable....
Oops... Comet as you said is already turning out to be a meteor....
Lack of DC fast charging & usable boot at 9 lacs....
MG , you are joking.. and do the selling for TATAs really.
Wu ling air comes with a fast charging version outside India but not in India.
MG thinks of Indians as fools.
We should stay away from the MG comet in its price range and features.
The internet inside is a gimmick.
Modified version of Bajaj Auto
Guys it's real name wuling air ev
Like now time is like we are comparing this shit car which I don't know why we are even calling it car
To a proper hatch back from indian company make in India design in India manufactured in India
None of the UA-cam channel will tell you that all mg cars are basically Chinese rebranded cars
Even gloster is rebranded and it's real name is siac maxus d 90
I feel disgusted when our indian youtuber promote shit sab bikau hai
Agr inko paise do to yee log to fortuner ko lc se compare kar denge and thode aur jyada paise do to fortuner ko lc se accha bhi bata denge
Exactly 💯
Pesa do toh desh bech denge
Tata ka car hota toh sab bekar bol rhe hote dogle reviewers
@@DanzZerous shi kaha aapne bhai
Aaj kal ke dekh rha hu har ek youtuber
Is gaadi pe video bana rha hai
@@DanzZerous seriously bro
Agar Indian company se kuch bhi aage peeche galti ho jaaye to log to matlab ussi ko highlight karte rehte hai
Might be they are not giving them enough money ig
@@ooppww1923
Woh toh bahi embargo system hai...
Everyone was curious to see a toy car on road 😂
actually im a MG ASTOR PROUD owner im telling u my experience with MG is the best very good car and very good service , so its better to choose Comet but its upto u .
I have GRAND i10 Asta (TOP Variant) AUTOMATIC, So I recently purchased the MG Comet Ev ( 2nd variant, play) for city usage and I must say I'm thoroughly impressed with its performance. The range it offers in Eco mode, averaging around 190-195 km with AC level 3 out of 9 , is quite commendable and meets my daily commuting needs perfectly Also Planning for mg hector plus .. as it is very spacious 7 seater car
Mg comet is not a practical car for lots of 🇮🇳Indian. But Tata is our nation pride and family car and small specious car. And most important 5star safity car is tiago.
the main difference is Comet is 2 seater and Tiago is 4 seater.
& Tiago looks like proper car unlike Comet, which looks like a joke
Comet is 4 seater car
And Tiago is 5 seater car
@@iNeed2.pcomet ev looks awesome.. BETTER Than YoU😡
No Tiago, No Comet....
Wanted to upgrade from 2013 Nano Petrol to Nano EV. Nano will be always perfect City Car
Tiago EV any day. For 2-3 lakh more, you get a proper car! The comet is strictly for filthy rich hoping to get some second looks by driving something quirky.
Should have shown difference in size by parking them side by side
Commet looks like an upgraded version of bajaj qute. So Bajaj can lunch quet in electric version for private use. If Quet price will be around 500k with standard features, it could be acceptable all
Dono car best hai aur dono ki alag hi khasiyat hai.
mujhe personally Comet EV ka concept jyjada achaa laga.
Anyone looking for a compact car should go with comet 👍🏻
Tiago is anyday preferred than comet given the pricetag it has. I guess come is a good city driver given they sell if for some what around 5/6 lakh and not more. Comeon, we indians love more car per money
20:05 and 20:14 desh ka loha "tata harrier" coming for a safety test. 😂😂😂
Harrier be like ek baar iska safety sest bhi yo kar le. 😂😂
Only hope for comet , if it's under 8 lacks....😏
were is the ec3?
in india instead of buying each individual cars in Already crowded roads...dont make sense..what one can do is for each colony or society'...thre can be a shared pay as u go model for such EV, so each colony society can buy this and share among the members on cost basis...this will create a ecosystem and keep trafifc uncrowded...hope someone listens this idea....and try it....
If MG comets comes in price range of 5 to 6 lakhs, it will be best option for middle class..
Prices are already out. Its 7.98 L ex showroom price
@@vaibhavgarg1752 😂now i will go for tata💯🇮🇳
No brother! When middle class people spend 5-6 lakh, it is their ONLY car in the family. This car needs to be versatile. It should be able to carry 5 people occasionally, fair bit of luggage and last at least for 5-7 years. The comet clearly fails on all above parameters.
@@kiranabhyankar4095
It's a lifestyle vehicle and targeted to premium and rich customers...
Those who have big cars in their garage and need a small car for city usage...
That's their Targeted audience...
STILL NOT WORTH IT EV VEHICLE BATTERY REOLACEMENT COST FOR THUS IS MINIMUM 2-3 LAKH
Build quality is good in both. As a secondary car Comet is good but for a first time buyer Tiago is no brainer.
Show us the byd seagull.
Comparing auto with a car
Is it possible to fit a roof carrier on the Comet EV? Perhaps it might not be a good idea, given the compact dimensions, but a roof carrier could solve the boot space issues.
Already it a tall call has bodyroll and if u put on a roof carrier ☠ bodyroll will become huge
There will be quite less balance.
Will definitely prefer comet as it has more features
Really wanna buy tiago ev but also want the honda city, But really don't have any money
just because of size I ll go for mg comet this ev is best for daily city use.
So premium means 7hr of waiting time. Not hanks
Do mileage test
Milage nahi re.... range test😅
For the purpose of which MG Comet was built for, can't Tata Tiago do the same things but with better space and comfort. The base prices are also similar. The only advantage is the better/easier parking of the Comet. Not at all practical at the mentioned price of the car.
Tiago xz plus which compare cost 13 lakh on road
Where comet cost 9 lakh
Comet looks cool and cute
Too expensive. What happened to Chinese brands? One would expect them to be cheaper than Indian brands. I'll wait till Xiaomi or Realme launches an ev.
Looks wise Comet it’s different (not bad). But I’m sure it has better quality control compared to Tata.
I don’t know why every UA-camr tell Lies about prices how they are said both ev will come in 8 to 10 lakh while prices start with minimum 9 to 12.70 lakh
I love how quiet Comet EV is, no noisy engine sounds.
Every ev is same
Back seat of MG commet is sooo good that definitely it was designed by a father like me who have crazy kids.....
Not required to worry about kids sitting behind if thry open the door or if they put hands out of window....bla bla..... bla
It's time for micro cars,we should give chance to MG's comet
Technologically comet is more advanced, Tiago is just a normal basic ev
MG Comet sounds an excellent city car. Huge respect for the MG team for providing an option to the country. The feature is top of the class at the price point. Many homes are going solar under the govt schemes. Just add couple of more solar panels to your setup and you should have free ride for the life time of your car. As a side note, the Transport Ministry allows registering EV without batteries. The entry (initial) price of an EV could be half of what we buy in present times if companies come together and offer the battery on lease. It will be huge impact on two wheeler, may be for four wheeler it might not be as effective.
Tata Pixel would have been the perfect competitor to MG Comet. Sadly it never happened!
Just imagine going in comet and some big SUV hits from behind,
That SUV will be COMET for passengers ☠️
I totally trust the quality of MG👍🏻
You are a troll. Their is no comparison. Only an idiot would choose comet over Tiago.
Bhai thoda camera ek jhg rkh kr he video bana .. le ...esa lg rha ... boomerang bana raha
If it was priced at 5 to 6 lk on road, it would be a very easy buy. For 10l, its just a car for the few people in very traffic dense commute who have a few lakhs lying around. Makes no sense for anyone else.
Good to notice 🍺🍻 holders in Dashboard 😘
Mg is premium small micro car…..maybe best buy if you have multiple cars…..tata is practical hatchback…..so choice is as per requirement…..
Comet have body roll and not aero dynamic but tiago ev is all rounder and far more aerodynamic
Main issue no fast charging in mg comet but tata has even in low spec
Interior Mg Comet ( Dashboard Only! ) And Space For Tiago Ev , The looks for tiago ev and 1 lakh more than comet this is very good selection to tiago ev and more range , more power than comet and its a china 😂 so don't go for it
Tiago is the best
Tiago are good for service
good in the showroom servicing charge only 1000 to 1500 so don't go for comet and overpriced 😅
Up hiil pa bhi try karo 😅
Comet reminds me of TATA NANO . I wish nano returns as a EV filling the void
It’s kind of quadricycle.. it’s totally different segment than car.. how you can compare car vs quadricycle type car..compare with similar class vehicles which actually make sense..
I'll definitely go with tata Tiago anyday .... Becz
Better service station network available
Safe car
More power and battery range and boot capacity... A proper 4 door car and a small hatchback
Cartoon vs Car