Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Palestinians: Do you want to expel the Jews?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 січ 2023
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
props to the guy that said "we all deserve to love each other" and said they should share the land. we need more people like that in this world.
well he is cristian
He was Christian...not Muslim. Its really a Muslim mentality that is the problem.
Christian - not surprising
@@freeyourmind2261 The Jews believe in an eye for an eye so its both that are a problem
Theres plenty of us. And we are trying. Sadly god forgot about Palestine. Even he had enough.
These interviews really demonstrate the utter hopelessness of the situation.
It's really sad to hear them say that Jews cannot stay in Israel. These types of opinions will hasten the demise of the Palestinian people.
@@rotfogel Not all said that.
@@howard5992enough did, and that's how you know Hamas has general Palestinian support.
No it exposes Islam.
It depends what you define as isreal they are occupying lands calling it isreal and that's a crime in international law. And they are not all palestinian jews. Most are American. European. But if they stayed in their isreal and didn't expand isreal that would do a lot for the situation. Maybe some would still want them gone completely but that would be against international law if they tried to oust them from isrela proper. They do need to leave palestine or else live under palestinian rule. Just as irish people can go live in England but they can't take England's land and call it ireland. We were given our Republic and we have to be happy with that even though we once owned the whole of ireland. For peace to exit sometimes you have to give up land and both isreal need to guve up settled colonised lands and palestine have to accept that isreal within its legal borders exists.
One guy shows up with a peaceful message of tolerance.... Aaaaaaand he was Christian. That speaks volumes.
Dude, do you have any idea how many people have been killed by Christians over the centuries?!?!? I'm a Catholic, and we Christians have done more evil stuff than anyone!
Ok, I agree it looks bad overall. But there is that guy too 7:24; who is a bit tolerant, also the woman before him could be persuable!
Bro he literally looked like Jesus too 😅
One guy? Did we watch the same video?
These people never met a peaceful Jew, the only Jews they know are the military men who occupy them, and you expect them to be peaceful and tolerant towards them. Come on. They equal jew with zionist who oppress them.
These Palestinians have only learned one side of the story.
Yes! Totally.
Ask them where their ancestors came from... Palestinian is an invented identity..
There is no evidence for such people in all history..
@@einavyam-hod6645 with this line of logic, American is an invented identity so is Mexican etc etc
@@AymenBoukthir-cn8fwAll national identities are invented so this argument doesn't hold much water for either side
For the ladies who didn’t think Israelis should be able to buy land and live on “their” land, do they think Arab immigrants to other countries should not be able to buy land or live there for a long time because it’s not their homeland? I believe Palestinians should be free and have equal rights but I also believe all humans have equal right, Israelis too.
I get your point, but if these immigrants were taking houses by force and killing owners I bet you would not feel the same.
Anyway, the majority of Palistinians would be fine if Israel committed to Oslo accords and UNSC resolutions that were signed 30 years ago, but unfortunately Isreal did not.
I have same sentiment as you - these ladies would like to establish a Palestinian apartheid regime to replace the current Israeli apartheid regime - switch injustice from one side to the other. As for your question of Palestinians being able to buy and own land abroad - I think the problem is quantity - would you be ok with 10 million Palestinians buying land in your country to the point that it replaces its people and it’s not your country/culture/rules anymore? This is what Israel has been doing in Palestine for decades now
These people are selfish. Possessive.
@@kamelali1631look deeper. 2000 years ago.
@@kamelali1631Arabs are the biggest colonizers ever. So what are we talking about!!
'we as Muslims' tells you a lot about what many Palestinians think 'Palestinian' means.
Palestinian is a completely invented people. Ethnically, there is zero difference between them and the other Arabs in Jordan that was given to the Arabs by the British.
@@jake1776 And? All countries borders are "invented".
@@thejanssen6030this.
@@jake1776you an idiot lol use history and ethnicity and you start sounding fairly racist telling people where they were born and where they belong because of the color of their skin or their ‘ethnicity’. If that’s the case Jews and Americans belong in Europe and Poland and Germany. Where you are born is where you belong. All these places were invented.
@@jake1776 I am well aware of the history, and I am of a similar opinion. That said, just because their nationhood is very, very young does not mean their identity is not heartfelt or vital to many of them. The Arabs of the region certainly had a distinct culture and dialect long before the British mandate and it is not beyond reason that they should be acknowledged as a distinct people. The fact now is that they are, on the whole, fiercely nationalistic and very numerous. Trying to rehome all of them in nearby Arab countries is neither realistic nor ethical. It should also be noted that whilst Faisal seemed to have been willing for Jews to establish a colony in that region, it was only to be done in such a way as would not totally displace the Arabs of the region. I think this Faisal agreement is pivotal to the history, and I think the Sykes-Picot agreement was a travesty and betrayal of our Arab allies (though not so mush a betrayal as the disgusting French betrayal at Damascus). However, I think it is reasonable to suggest that this area ('Palestine') was not included in the Lawrence agreement. This area was hugely neglected by the Ottomans because it is not of central importance for many Muslims (or wasn't). Faisal rightly thought that an influx of Jews would bring prosperity to this neglected region and he was right. Sadly that has also meant huge numbers of Arabs immigrated to the region too and one huge mistake which is often made is to imagine that all of those who call themselves Palestinians are descendents of the original Arab inhabitants (many are defended from much later Arab immigrants attracted by the fall of the Ottoman Empire and the prosperity brought by the British and Jewish control of the area). It is a very recent nationality, and the most absurd bit of that invention is the 'it's our land' line you hear again and again. The people seem to genuinely believe it, even when they are descended from Arab immigrants who moved to the area long after many of the Jews who lived there. It is no surprise (sadly) that those interviewed here who were friendly to Jews were the residents of Bethlehem. It is true that many 'Palestinians' are not Muslims, but I strongly suspect they (often Christians) would be better off in an Israeli state, with Israeli citizenship, than they would in a predominantly Muslim Palestinian state (not to mention anyone else Islam deems less than worthy of care and dignity).
As an indigenous Englishman with mass immigration from the Middle East coming into my homeland, I will treat them, how they would treat me from what I have learnt from this video.
As you should. and that's besides, fascist colonialist "religion" of Islam. you should be treating Muslims like Nazi groups. Jew hatred and wanting to genocide Jews check, hatred of anything not Muslim check, fascist laws check, apartheid like discrimination and laws (sharia) check.
You must understand that the Israelis steal Palestinian homes and lands, not like immigrants who buy or rent a house
Why? So we can make everywhere an Israel Palestine conflict? What is the point of doing that?
I spent my whole life until October 7th viewing all the women as victims who shared my values and just needed the safety of the west. It's been so sad and scary to face reality
You don't have the right to do that because you colonized and looted their countries for decades. Your country is the problem this issue is there in the first place, so you should be the last person to talk about this.
As an Israeli-Jew I just want peace with the Palestinians
Unfortunately, you want the impossible. Sorry
@@l-uk3xm I guess all of us would prefer peace instead of war
@@SaharMaorLevy By all means yes, except that it doesn't seem achievable w/the Arabs. They're too far gone in their hatred for us. Very seldom do I hear reasonable voices from them. It's mostly like these respondents or worse.
Wow - He was asking the EXACT question I was wondering. Most of them really do mean the entire state of Israel should be dissolved, not just to the 1967 boundaries. ALL of it. That's the reason a 2-state solution has never been able to be achieved.
Because all of Israel was founded illegally by the Zionist movement, with the British who promised them a homeland in Palestine when they had no right to do so.
So you take what a few think (even though they had a big variety in their answers) as something worth punishing an entire country for? How far up your ass is your head?
Those two girls at the end are HamaSS followers.
Its both ways tho a lot of Israeli also want the historical Israel
@@AhmedBouali-wf6zh
Perhaps now, but in 1947 there could have been 2 state, one for the Jews and one for the Arabs, but the Arabs wanted everything and started a war, witch they lost.
And you wonder why the Israeli right political parties keep growing?
What part of an invasion dont you understand, they have every right to hate israelis, their claiming land that isnt theirs, pushing borders, kicking out families as old as Islam, defecating in their holy mosque, and they dont have the right to fight back?Sounds imperialistic
and you wonder why the palestinians want the jews gone. maybe its because of the invasion and attempted genocide over the past 100 years, just a guess
Please, don’t be a simpleton. Per the 1947 United Nations resolution, The land was to be shared between Jews and Palestinians. They rejected this and lost the war. They rejected numerous peace efforts since. They reject Israel’s right to exist and launch countless terror attacks. Once they except our right to exist, they will live a peaceful existence.
@@sfrentals4769 i feel sympathetic for your people with human values. from what i see though the jewish people are very elitist and this is the where the problem with sharing the land stems from.
Simple you take our homes and cut our trees and kill our children expect us to hate you
This is exactly why the Palestine problem can never actually be solved. Not until people's attitudes change on both sides. I heard Isreali Settlers in another video claiming their goal was to drive all Muslims out of Palestine eventually. I have no clue how anyone can ever fix this mess.
The difference is that if a Jew is claiming that about Muslims as to driving them out, it's because of Islam as a religion itself that exclusively calls for the eradication of Jews and Christians.
Islam is a genocidal blood cult and is on par and if not worse then Nazism. In fact history backs me up on this claim of them being at least on par with the Nazis as they cheered on Hitler for what he was doing to the Jews. In fact the Imans of that era claimed that their only regret was that it was Hitler and not Allah commiting these atrocities against the Jews....
That's the difference.
I was thinking the same thing, watching videos from both sides it seems neither want to share the land and rule together. For both sides it has to be either Palestinian or Israeli rule.
@@jasonsingh8464 Israel shouldn’t exist, it’s Palestine..
Why was there Jewish Temple twice in Jerusalem if jew wasnt there before the Parlistinian?
Ask Palestinian Arabs why there was no resistance when Turks, Brits , Jordanians and Egyptians occupied Palestine.
Cuz they were Muslim
@@AbdullahKhawar262 the brits are muz linz?
@@AbdullahKhawar262they were Muslim and Palestine was powerless
I don't get how they can say Jewish people are occupiers. Do they not know that Islam forcibly arrived to that land in the 600s and 700s and has occupied that land ever since? It's just not a good argument.
These people always conveniently ignore that fact or take it for granted. In their world view the violent history of Islam is just forgotten
They are simply too stupid.
yea 👍
The only ethnic group in the world that simply does not want to move on
from what
WOULD YOU LIVE UNDER AN OCCUPYING POWER?
This video pretty much sums up why the Palestinians don't have their own state, and probably won't get it any time soon.
Is the Israeli side any better?
There was a deal for a 2 party state and 10% more land given to them but Palestinians rejected it.
Hush
@jbd4365 as they should
@@Introvertical873There is. In a few videos a lot of Israelis are very positive about Arabs. Of course, there’s always bad apples. Just here, it’s a very worrying majority and think this way.
Just today a Palestinian stabbed 7 people in Northern Germany, killed 2. Now imagine why these checkpoints exist
So...all Palestinians are inherently evil and inferior. They must be deprived of basic human rights on a daily basis. They have to be abused, harassed, tortured and humiliated in checkpoints.
How come the world doesn't seem to realize how moral and righteous we are ???
IsLaM is a ReligIoN oF pEaCe
It’s true.
Then german will be apartheid
@@user-ux2py9td8w What a load of crap.
Blah blah "It's our land", "all of balestain", "leave our land", like that's going to happen.... How many nonsenses can they say, alot of crying no real solution.
Then expect ww3 soon and a nuclear hollow cost
Viva Palestina 🇵🇸💛
The attitudes of normal every day people is all or nothing, no compromise. Until this mindset changes the conflict will never end.
Thank you. This video really shows what situation is like, how hopeless it is for Israel and the Palestine to live in peace. And this is before the October 7th, 2023 attack. Being merciful to the other side is to be cruel to oneself, unless both sides honestly acknowledges both sides. Peace is unlikely to happen unless both sides can acknowledge the other.
how do you watch this and talk like its the same on both sides? pretty much every arab muslim he interviewed said they should kick out the jews. watch the video where he asks the jews the same question, youll be unpleasantly surprised that they dont want to expel the palestinians.
yes. the jews dont have anywhere to go other then israel, and no one wants to take the palestinians beacuse they ruin countries. the palestinians dont rockegnise the jews that have lived in judea and the kingdom of israel etc with david solomon etc.2 nations only one land and palestinians wont accept 2 state solution
Don't you find it amazing that there were still more than one person who was willing to live in peace with Jews? After 75 years of occupation and horrific horrors. You'd be hard pressed to find one Zionists who can say the same about Palestinians.
@@tonytooshort you're wrong, look at his videos where he asks Israelis they're almost all agreeing for any sort of peace.
@@tonytooshortbrain washing is endless. Yet you’ve probably reached its end.
The lack of symmetry is astounding since day one.
Violence is initiated from one side only, peace settlements are declined consistently by the same side.
Try just a little bit to know the facts before making up your mind.
The majority responses in this video are why the occupation of the West Bank will never end and a Palestinian state will never fully be.
Because it will never happen, No one will pay for the Palestinian state.
Way to blame the occupied for the actions of the occupiers. You must sympathize alot with your colonial ancestors.
@@fallasleep9472 which occupiers? The Persians, the Babylonians, the British, the Ottoman Empire, the Jews, the Egyptians?
@@teeemm9456 The Palestinians (muslim, jewish, christian, etc) that have been living in the land for centuries and get kicked out of their homes by a bunch european immigrants who think they can reclaim a land which their ancestors lost and decided to live in harmony with people of other faiths.
@@teeemm9456 what are you talking about the isrealis are the current occupying power?
As you can see, the majority of "Palestinians" do not want a two-state solution. It's not just Hamas, it is the vast majority of the Arabs living in in Eretz Yisrael.
Any negotiations with the Palestinians are pointless and useless because they are not interested in a two state solution using the 1967 borders. This has been offered to them several times and they always refused, but it is the best deal they will ever get. Israel is not moving anywhere.
During that time more than 60% of mandatory palestine was gives to jews and around 30% to Palestinians knowing jews were one third of Palestinians in population
And Palestinians who were living in jewish territory had to evacuate and move out
Isreal builds settlement in West Bank and illegally occupied Jerusalem was met even gives to them by the British
There is no agreement when the whole thing begins in the wrong way
Jews can live Palestiniane and cherish thier history
But they don't not come from there but from Poland Ethiopia france...as they left long ago and came as refugees to Palestine after making plans with the us on a zionist state
So no isreal shouldn't have any power as isreal itself violated every right a Palestinian had
While jews were fine living before the land got divided
@@w444rbv That's BS, Jews have lived in modern day Israel for many thousands of years and the historical and archeological records prove it
Wow. This is a good explanation of why peace isn't going to happen.
Imagine going to someone's house, trying to steal half of it, and then complaining about how the home owner doesn't want peace with you. It's absurd. The creation of Israel was from the very beginning morally corrupt and most of the Zionists themselves knew it was immoral but they did it anyways.
Nooooooooooo stop being islamophobic >:(
Yes 💯 peace will never happen until we Muslims free plastine Inchallah
Because the occupied will not give up land to the occupiers.
@@n30escape Well around 1950 Arabs tried the same in the war against Jews and it backfired pretty hard against you... History will repeat itself, but with the twist, that there is no Gaza anymore ^^
The third guy is from Beit Jala, a Christian. How different is he from most of the rest
And fool as well because no jew respects "turn the other cheek" christ to them is usurper and his philosophy weak.
@@jeffpliskin so what? Christians don't do that to expect something back, or at least that's what they say
@@lrosas_sp @Luis Rosas " Turn the other cheek" is not workable period. Many chrstians say it is taken as verse out of context, that is my opinion. Its impossible for humans to do especially a man. However Ghandi maybe achieved some like that with his philosophy activism however he wasnt even a christian. Obviously two competitve sides don't show weakness it doesnt earn respect.
@@jeffpliskin it does work as a philosophy especially for personal mental health, not everything has to be ordered around political maneuvers
7:25 was really different too
The girls at the end saying 'they can't live here, it's our land' - I wonder if they feel the same about other Palestinians moving to places like Europe...
The Israelis steal lands and houses from the Palestinians, so say, “This is our land.” But the Palestinian who lives in Europe buys or rents a house, does not steal a house and says, “This is for me.”
@@deemaabobaker5894 Plenty of Palestinians are illegal immigrants. And if you're in any position to buy a house in Europe, then it is your house and anyone buying a house thinks it is their house, because it is. Are you high?
Exactly, now imagine the contradiction if as legal residents in Europe they still having the same beliefs 😊
THE PALESTINIANS DONT COME TO AMERICA AND STEAL SOMOENE ELSES HOME, THEY PURCHASE THE HOME OR LAND.
@@deemaabobaker5894they bought all land. They actually bought land that was full of malaria that no one wanted to buy!!! Enough with the lies!
You can tell how brainwashed these people are if they call Palestine their country. Palestine has never been a country, but a region. The name “Palestine” is even a Roman name, Roman word for Israel’s ancient enemy the Philestines, given to replace the name of Israel to mock the Jews. After the Romans controlled the area, the Byzantine empire controlled it, then the Ottomans, then the British. It has never, not once in all of history been a country.
It is, in fact, Jewish land that was stolen by the Romans, then they would ethnically cleansed out by the Muslims, and now that they’ve returned, they are constantly being attacked, regardless of recognition by over 150 nations around the world.
Even Jews in the 1800-1900’s were called Palestinians because it referred to the region. The Arab Muslims didn’t have a problem when the Muslim Turks ruled the area. They didn’t protest when the Muslim Egyptians or Syrians or Jordanians controlled sections of the land. They only don’t want the Jews to live in the land that the Jews called home for 2500 years before Islam ever existed.
Great comment
Never been recognised as a country, of course it’s a country look at these people’s surroundings, does it not look like a country?
@@encryptedaviation1452 what are you talking about? Palestine literally has never been a country. It’s never had its own government. It’s never had its currency. It has always been a territory of another country or empire. Early 1900s the Jewish people living in that area were known as Palestinians. this is because it’s a region, not a country
@@dead2me82 that’s actually a good political standpoint if I’m being fair, but they don’t have to commit genocide, instead of a two state solution since that dosent work, I suggest during the beginning they should have a made a one state solution which combines both Israel and Palestine, with both religions and cultures prominent, the problem is that didn’t work out because the government of Palestine wants a two state solution, but Israel keeps attacking them and oppressing and being violent to the state of Palestine, so the people got upset and then October 7th and all of that jazz, I think it’s still not too late for this to happen. As long as Israel is willing to contribute to the reconstruction of Palestine, and not being selfish and imperialistic.
@@encryptedaviation1452 you keep saying, “the government of Palestine”. There is no government. The area is just run by Hamas, an organization that actively trains terrorists starting in elementary school (you can find videos of this on UA-cam).
I’m also not sure why you think Israel is being “Imperialistic”. After the Ottoman Empire fell, Great Britain owned/controlled all of these lands , including what we know today as Jordan. Originally, Israel was to get far more land than they got, including the entirety of Jordan (which wouldn’t have ever been a country). GB and the UN created a 2-state solution which the Jews accepted and the Arabs did not. So the Jews compromised and gave up all of the Jordanian land and the West Bank. The Arabs refused the offer, but the UN decided to move forward with the proposal to the Jews. The Palestinian Arabs simply said “no” to the offer for the land (that was never theirs as it was part of Rome, than the Byzantines, then the Ottomans, then Great Britain’s), and the Jews said “yes”. So Israel was formed and the Arab Palestinian people are still in this situation.
The first day Israel was declared a country, the entire Arab world of the Middle East and North Africa attacked Israel in an act of genocide. Yet Israel survived and has thrived. 6 times there have been talks to try and achieve a 2-state solution and all six times, the Israelis have conceded more land and the Arabs refuse.
In the early 2000’s (2005 i believe) Israel finally withdrew all people and military presence from Gaza (they were there to stop the Palestinians from bombing and attacking them) and let the Palestinians elect their own leaders…we got Hamas. This is despite those Jews having invested in that land and created some of the most beautiful and bountiful beaches and farmland in the entire Middle East (which Hamas has destroyed). In Hamas’ charter statement, they declare that they want the eradication of Jews (genocide).
Israel has consistently allowed Gazans to enter their nation for work. They have offered concessions on 6 occasions of creating peace talks. Israel has the capability to carpet bomb the entire region with one swoop and wipe the Palestinians off the map due to a highly advanced Air Force and military…yet they don’t. They don’t seize lands. They were attacked on Oct.7th in one of the most heinous acts we’ve seen this century, if not the most. And in all of that, Israel has not sought to take ownership of Gaza, they have only sought to eliminate Hamas.
This is not emblematic of Imperialism.
Do the Palestinians realize that Judaism existed before Islam?
Most likely do not. They think that Islam always existed which is preposterous of course, but widely believed nonetheless.
Another good question for Corey!!
Muslims believe that Abraham, Moses, David, etc., were originally Muslims, but that their religion got corrupted into Judaism
@burnin8orable its called trolling.
Muslim Palestinian Arabs believe the first evolved bacteria that stewed in the deep oceans were Muslim.
Shame on these middle class palestinians. They seem like the one who benefit from peace with israel, instead they promote conflict.
I am indonesian muslim, I stand for Israel's right to exist, yet at the same time condemn their mistreatment to palestinian, but to be honest, I think palestinian will learn their lesson the hard way.
In europe we are sick of these "palestinians" who are mainly criminals who terrorize our cities.
This is the problem; children, woman, men think the same. They do not want to compromise. They taught to hate neigbours and yet preaching about peaceful?
Clearly the education system has failed there, too.
Absolutely
Some people keep saying "they are not indigenous" How, when Jews are quite literally refugees for thousands of years? Romans even renamed Judaea and connected it to Syria Palaestina after Jewish revolts against Roman rule, to erase all memory and association. These people were resettled and persecuted all over the world long before British Mandate debacle, but held their claim for thousands of years, never forgetting it? It's just wild to me that it's ignored, when I learned it I could never look at this situation the same way.
That's a valid point... However, I'd like to hear your response to the validity of ownership of land for the Natives in the US, since they are undoubtedly indigenous to that land? I'm quite certain they haven't forgotten about it either :/
@@abademy8185 I am not American, but I had a privilege of experiencing two different Native-American reservations. The USA is home for them. They have all the rights as any citizen, politically represented, plus enjoy unique property rights, tribal sovereignty, education networks, grants, housing assistance, entrepreneur programs, land rights and tax benefits unique to Native-American People. Their history is acknowledged, and I am sure that whatever gripes they have they can voice without their lives getting threatened. Most of the world is not like this. Jews and Arabs can only dream living in the same country, equally, and feeling like it's their country, and their home. There are forces that don't want this dialogue to ever happen
@@AtomizedMass You seemed to have missed my point, so I'll clarify it for you.
You say that due to their religious beliefs and history, they have a rightful claim to Palestine. Please correct me if I'm wrong to assume this is what you said based on your text.
My point is actually quite simple. Natives of America were indisputably first on the modern land of the USA, right?
Okay, then should they not have a right to claim this land and kick all Americans out, at least so we can avoid double standards?
I'd appreciate it if you could give me a straight answer. It's basically a yes or no answer, I can't simplify it further.
@@AtomizedMass Also, it seems that you are unaware of the fact that prior to the occupation of Palestine, Jews, Muslims, and Christians all lived as natives of Palestine equally under the Palestinian flag. So this "dream" that you are referring to is quite simply part of the religious portion of the narrative that somehow Jew's are hated by Arabs in order to justify any and all actions taken by the Israeli state against the occupied Palestinians.
@@abademy8185 It's obvious from my previous response. Why would a Native-American throw other people out, at this point? Arguably, they could try. But the land is already theirs, a Native-American person can even run for President, if they want.
And about Jews: the whole point of their culture is to remember that they are refugees and that one day they hope to return. Some gave it up, some kept going - for better or worse, but it's what they always wanted. The politics and cultural integration of Jews and Arabs could've been handled so much better in the past, by everyone, instead of this mistaken mess now
"Palestinian" answers to peace initiatives:
1897: No
1917: No
1947: No
1948: War
1949: No
1956: War
1967: War
1973: War
1978: No
1982: No
1991: Probably not.
1995: We'll agree to wait to say no later
1999: No, Intifada
2005: No
2009: We're not even gonna answer
2015: No
2023: 🤔
1956 was the only war in which isreal did attack Egypt with the Brits and French, it wasn’t a strict arab-Israeli conflict and the only one Israel was fighting an offensive not a defensive war.
@@SebaX92 Correct! 👍🏻
Hasbara in action. Hilarious.
And of course, all the bots and shills of this channel are liking this comment.
Star hopper, Linda Shmeckel, "Patriots of Israel" - what a sad joke you are.
The 1956 Suez Crisis was the Brits being butthurt for losing the Canal due to Nasser Nasionalization Programme. Can't blame him because I'd done the same if am in his shoes 😅 Israel was being Opportunistic to get on the good terms with the Brits for a change after the 1948 debacle of Brits siding with Jordan seizing the Jewish Quarters & huge swath of the West Bank 😏 Uncle Sam played his card by siding with Egypt to prevent any possible return of Brits & French Imperialism in post-WW2 New World Order 🤭 & also to extend his brand of DemoCrazy to fight off the Reds growing influence in newly Independent States 😉 Israel deservedly got schooled by Uncle Sam's show of Force & slinked back home; very embarassing for us homies tbh 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 anyways, Israel sank the USS Liberty in '67 probably as "payback" for that embarrassment 🤪 and more than willing to pay Uncle Sam the $hekel$ 🤫
Addendum : Israel got something more i.e. Casus Belli in the form of Straits of Turan in the 1956 ho-hum 😉 because its closure in 1967 lend Just Cause amongst other Security Reasons for the infamous 6 Days War 🤭 We got complacent after that & paid a hefty price in Jewish blood during the 1973 conflict 😢 but we had the Egyptians & Syrians by the throat towards the end until the Reds were forced to threaten Nuke to save their Clients 😡 That's probably why we see most Middle-Eastern States support Putler the Poop despite his Imperialistic land grab attempt in Ukraine 🤔
just asking legit questions is enough to get you "in trouble..."
what an awesome society.
Lmao. Did you know it is illegal to talk abt the Nakba in Israel? Do you know they have a name for Jews who speak out against Israel and its government? They call them self hating Jews. So my question to you is, will you also sarcastically call Israel an 'awesome society'? Or is it just the brown people you'd like to diminish. 🥴
You do realize the IDF regularly beat and jail Jewish Israelis for protesting/speaking out? Or wait no you don’t care because you’re a racist w/ an agenda.
you wouldn’t understand bud
@@purpleheartski explain it to me, chump.
the islamic and china/north korea/russian societies are fucked up
Great videos. I'm tired of hearing interpretations of what they think. It's great to hear it straight from their mouths. One lady was like 'They can stay with Palestinian rules'. We all know how well that works out for the Jews in an Arab country.
So get out
What happened to the jews in Arab and Muslim countries do you even know anything about history???
The jews lived amongst muslims for more than thousand years and were in way better conditions from the jews in Europe, you can hear it from their mouths , that majority for them had a good life especially the old generations who lived in Egypt or Lebanon or Morocco for example, in Egypt we had ministers and celebrities who are jews.
All the mess and drama started when the colonial Zionist movement decided to steal an Arabic land and all the Zionist brutality and terror attacks started , go read about "Lavon Affair" please
@@luvangel8149 to countries that they never lived in?
Certainly better than it works out for them than living in germany. Also the jews lived under very good circumstances during the ottoman empires reign.
Actually, it worked out pretty well for Jews in Arab countries. Far better than Europe at least at the time. This obviously changed drastically once zionists held public zionist conferences in the Arab world, broadcasting their plans to take over Palestine, then the hate started, and got worse once Israel was established, that the Mizrahi community became a victim of Ashkenazi colonial greed, and Arab anger.
At least the Jews can say that they tried.
Jews can but “pathological progressives” will always blame Israel because they are racists. Minority sup rem a cists! Who have nothing but a hierarchy of race & ethnicity!
what jews?
ignore these tools. we will have a synagogue in mecca before they have a state
@@gordumherseyi
Your sarcasm is too sophisticated for this channel.
@@ef2718 sarcasm? 😎
Dear Palestinian Muslims ! read your Koran ! Allah assigned the Holy Land to the Jews ! Not to you !
This is why that shit will never be settled.
As an Egyptian muslim watching this now, i can tell why Natenyaho said, "we are dealing with animals"!!! Come on, there is no way that this is the teaching of islam i learned from the prophet and Quran!
Hamas are animals. These people are just pissed their land was taken from them. Ain't no American giving up their land to a Native American anytime soon lol
I'm not even Jewish or Israeli and this is incredibly depressing. I don't know how you do it!
They are pure Nazi-level extremists that want mass murder and expulsion.
Only education to coexistent instead of hate can fix this.
You know what is depressing? A 70+ year long military occupation where israelis humiliate women, murder children, force men to demolish their own homes, bomb hospitals, and hold hate speech rallies where israelis happily chant "Death to Arabs!"
It might be depressing but i hope it taught you something.
I have no patience for anyone who can't simply agree that ethnic cleansing is depressing. Be gone bigot!
You can’t just kick every Israeli out who is born in Israel/Palestine because they are Israelis. They were just born where they were born. You can‘t decide where you get born.
Thank you so much for making these videos. Sometimes they're emotionally difficult to watch, but it's a really important project
so true
Gh
im an iraqian atheist and after a long religious study i think after 100 years maybe when the brilliant minds of the western world conqure other planets they should not permit an prohibit any earth religions from spread between people community on other planets and leave all the earth for them so they slay and rape and sodomize and loot each other and let their god yahva or allah or jesus watch and have fun even if they put together in heaven or hell they will kill each other ... حتى لو سكن المسلمين جنب اليهود في الجنة او النار سيذبح بعضهم بعضا حتى لو ذهب بقية البشر لكواكب اخرى سيقاتل بعضهم الاخر على كوكب الارض المسألة ليست ارض او مساحات او ثروات او سلطة انها مسألة حقد وضغينة عقائدية وثارات وتخلف وهمجية وحب للاغتصاب والنهب والقتل
@@salmanman3771 Jesus never did any of what u just said, unlike the catholic church or mohammed and his followers!
Fuck ishiteal occupation 🐖💨💩🇮🇱💩🇮🇱
Anyone noticed all the background buildings and stores? We keep hearing in the liberal news how Palestinians live in refugee camps and Gaza is an open air prison.
Non poteva mancare il commento idiota.
as a brit where we have a massive multicultural problem right now it really grinds my gears that some of these people say we dont want them this is our land yet if a brit said that about the immigrants we are condemned and called racist
I call them racists for wanting to expell jews based on their race, or for wanting them to be second class citizens.
Yup. We all have these huge religious and ethnic tensions to look forward to in 20,50, 100 years time when the European people’s start to become minorities in their own lands.
Well there is a small difference in that very few British families have been chased out of their homes by Pakistanis.
Some of the people interviewed here are direct descendents of people who were expelled from their villages in 1948. I don't agree with them but it's no wonder Palestinians think ethnic cleansing is a viable solution if they themselves have been ethnically cleansed out of their own homes.
There is a difference between immigration and occupation. These people were literally expelled from their land and homes. They were stripped away from their rights and political power, basically the whole dynamics of the land changed and some of the people were never able to return.
Not exactly. They left, fled, or were pushed out -- It's a combination of reasons-- after they started a war in 1948. If they had accepted the mandate they would have had a country all this time, just like Israel and Jordan
Abba Eban: Palestinians never miss a chance to miss a chance.
Opportunity, not chance
@@shainazion4073 ☺ 😊 😇
When you kick them out of their homes illegally, defecate their holy site, kill 100s of innocent palestinians, call yourselves the true natives when most of you are european decent, peace is not an option.But all of that is excused thanks to the german mustache man
@@reemdaak3591 With Jews in Israel, the situation is clear: They are a people who had been kicked out of their ancestral land ca. 1900 years ago & in the 19th C, some of them nationally matured & created a national movement to establish a nation-state in their ancestral homeland..
Various Arabs living in Palestine/Israel have populated that area in the past 1400 or so years. They clearly are not historical people of that region in any particular sense as Jews are (Hebrew language, historical culture & taboos, food taboos, cultural physiognomy as expressed in Jewish literature in the past 2000-2500 years, Jewish music & musical instruments, Jewish calendar, …).
Of course, that doesn’t mean that Israelis can just kick out Palestinian Arabs, as many of them would like to. The argument “I was here before, at least 1500 years before your ancestors had appeared at the scene” doesn’t hold water.
But, having in mind that the official Israeli policy has long been a 2 states solution & all Palestinian representative bodies declined that offer, evidently wanting to either kick the Israelis out or to ethnically swamp them & reduce them to a defenseless & humiliated minority, the only solution is status quo.
With such intransigence, mostly from the Palestinian side in the last 30-40 years, the only realistic option is status quo ad infinitum.
@@urvanhroboatos8044 you changed my perspective
That's why i can't support them.
Same
The irony is that Palestinians speak Arabic (a language from the Arabian peninsula) and most adhere to Islam (a faith originally from the Arabian penninsula).
Jews at least speak Hebrew, a language indigenous to Palestine only.
The Jewish faith is indigenous to Palestine as well.
Go figure.
Another irony: when the Ceusaders invaded Palestine in the 11th century, Jews and Muslims fought them together.
Today, Palestinian Christians seem to be more accepting of Israelis.
On another note, many Palestinians acknowledge Israeli "system" as superior (social security, health insurance, nursing homes, education, etc).
Israel*
@@mm6max918
Using the name Palestine for the historical region, as in Syria Palestina, aka Judea and Land of Israel.
@@makpazon11 because nobody loves to live with terrorist colonizers from Europe
The French speak a Latin language even though the Franks were Germanic, the Finnish people speak a Uralic language though they are Scandinavians . There is documented information that Arabic was spoken in the Levantine since 400 B.C , King Herod the great father was an Edomite and his mother was Nabatean that makes him an Arab not an Israelite .
@@saqeralthawara2342 surenames are a relativly new invention , given in the last 400 to 150 years. Most ar abs in israel carry surenames indicating foreign origins , hejazi =from hejaz in saudi rabia, masri = from egypt (masr) , horani = from horan in syria etc etc
It is NOT palestine and it is NOT their land! It is Israel and it is a Jewish land!
An intensive course on the history of the PALESTINIAN STATE:
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state.
2. Before the British mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was an Islamic Mamluk state from Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic Mamluk state from Egypt, there was an Ayyubid Arab-Kurdish empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayyubid Empire, there was a Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there were the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there were the Seleucids, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was Alexander the Great's empire, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before Alexander the Great's empire, there was a Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, there was a theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was a conglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
In reality, on this territory, there has been everything EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE. (borrowed from a friend)
A bit more history for those who want to 'restore Palestine'.
In 132 AD, Emperor Hadrian decided to suppress the Jews and their religion. He sold all Jewish prisoners as slaves after the Bar Kokhba revolt, prohibited the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed the name of Jerusalem to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to erase the national identity of Israel and the Jews.
So if you're looking to restore Palestine to the Palestinians, you should return it to the Jews.
And before whatever government/society whoever you live, probably some kind of indigenous people, so GTFO of wherever you live, and STFU.
Bollocks
?@@vincentkerrigan6775
@@vincentkerrigan6775 He's technically correct, but there's always been tribal peoples that lived there. Just because it's not a nation of distinct culture, doesn't mean that group of tribes should be kicked off land they've held.
The problem is of course spoils of war.
By this logic china, india, canada, germany and a ton of countries can’t exist
7:25 this guy is an angel. The sanest of responses in the whole video
Yes
Agreed. The most rational acknowledging two states, addressed a peaceful solution to settlers, etc.
I used to be pro-Palestine before I started watching these videos.
Out of curiosity, what was the turn~around for you?
@@larosadesierta9146ha ha they are horrific cruel people
I used to be pro-palestine until the last three days
@@larosadesierta9146look at what they do ? Do Israelis go in and kidnap kids and chop their heads off ? Never.
Lies
Where were these so-called Palestinian people in the Roman province of Jerusalem? Oh wait, Palestine as a state has never existed.
It is a ferry tale that Israel was Palestinian land. In 1920 there were hardly any Arabs living in the barren land. Jewish organizations bought land from Arab landowners who were living elsewhere. Arabs started immigrating there to find jobs offered by the British and the Jews.
The people of "no compromise" religion of peas strikes yet again
A lot of people are not very knowledgeable about history because there’s a lot of it and it takes alot of time to study and catch up… which is why we have historians.
Most people just take for granted what ever their parents or family told them.
exactly, and as that courageous guy said, that he can't voice his opinion without getting into trouble...
So true. The truth is lost and Palestinians ignore it to fuel their inherent hatred. I see nothing but hatred and evil.
@@SoonEnough Did he say from his family? It could be from the israelis themselves.
@@n.b.6033 I had the sense he was more hesitant with regard to Hamas and Hamas supporters
People can't live in the past that's the problem. They need to live in the hear and now.
I hope that young Palestinian guy who just wants to live in peace with everyone is safe. He is one of the good ones who deserves to be freed from Hamas.
Yes. It is very sad. I watched a young Palestinian lady with an Instagram Acct and it had me in tears. She was pleading for food and water with her little sister while living in a tent near shifa hospital. Wizard_bisan1 so sad and heartbreaking and I feel ashamed that I never real knew the whole story of what’s been happening in Israel and Gaza. I never paid attention or gave it much thought being an old American. So heartbreaking and there is no easy solution.
This is the West Bank. Nobody lives under Hamas there.
He’s good because he is willing to let them steal their land?
these videos are so informative. the whole world focusses on the fringe opinions of someone like Ben Gvir but almost everyone in these videos wants either expulsion or dhimmitude.
dude, these people are delusional, Israel is basically a regional super power!
Backed by $4 billion US taxpayer dollars per year
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748 well thanks for that, James!
you are now officially invited to the upcoming purim carnaval party at the Federal Reserve
shalom shalom
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748 people really don’t understand the power of diplomacy, this clearly includes you. Because if Palestinians were smart they would choose a powerful ally as well, but I guess this is a reflections to each populations IQ.
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748 Israel is the American wet dream, Give the Israelis money to put up a defensive front in the middle east against our enemies, and all of it won't cost American soldiers lives, at the same time they will kick our enemies butts, build new technologies that are going to be used by us in warfare if needed, they will become battle tested veterans who will teach our soldiers from their personal experience and we will get benefits from all of their struggles.
There are good reasons why America backs up Israel, it's a win win situation for both of them.
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748
Israel's GDP 2022 is ~530 Billion USD.
4/530= ~0.75%.
Israel's defense budget is ~18 Billion USD (22B if you add that 4 Billion USD subsidies for US made weapons).
4/22=~18%.
For understanding the proportions, the annual cost of Al-Udeid US Air Base alone is 2B USD.
I used to really side with the Palestinians, but after watching tons of these videos and listening to “iT’s OuR lAnD!!!” like whining little children who can’t accept reality….. well, it’s incredibly hard to feel sorry for them. And I’m descended from people whose religion has been destroyed by Christianity and who have been occupied by England for almost 1,000 years (the Welsh). I don’t get to live in my ancestral homeland, I’m living on the homeland of the Ancestral Puebloans and their descendants (ie, Native Americans from the SW of what is now the US). Just like Hopi is a dying language, so is Welsh. It’s sad, and I don’t like any of it, I wish we could all live in peace with no borders and no nations, but we can’t, so here we are. At some point, we have to accept reality.
Also, if the Jews were to be expelled, they should take everything they built from the Palestinians. Ya know, since it’s their land, they don’t need Tel Aviv which was built by the Jews, they don’t need any of the roads and infrastructure that was built by the Jews,they can have it the way their former occupiers, the Ottomans, left it. They seem to forget they’re speaking the language of other occupiers, and then there were more occupiers, and previous occupiers. 🤦🏻♀️
At least the guy at 1:19 has a soul, and the one at 7:27 also gives me some hope.
Also, I do hate some of the Israelis when I hear their opinions, especially the right-wing ones, but it’s just a smaller number it seems.
ETA: also the Muslims seem most extreme but are too dumb to realize not only are they speaker the language of colonizers, they are practicing the religion of colonizers. At least Christianity is an indigenous faith.
Before Tel Aviv was constructed, there was a vibrant Arab port named Yafa which later became absorbed by Tel Aviv which started out as a small Jewish settlement next to Yafa. Stop being ignorant as if Arabs did not have cities and buildings, and as if they lived in huts (which they certainly did not). That said, Arabs lost most of historic Palestine because they chose violence over peaceful coexistence. Even if they had a legitimate grievance about the U.N. Partition Plan, violence was the wrong way to settle it. They lost the entire Galilee, which was the most fertile part of historic Palestine, they lost big chunks of land further south, and kept losing more territory as they decided to expel every Jew who had settled in Palestine, even those who living there as part of legitimate land purchases from Arab landowners, and tried pushing Jews into the sea. It is no longer 1948, it is 2023, and they still have not given up the impossible dream of pushing Jews into the sea.
@@adamashelanu who declared war on who in 1948?
Who enslaved who as dhimmi for 1400 years?
@@adamashelanuyafa still exists...
Well, it’s indeed their land, and stating a solid fact isn’t whining. You are projecting your anger, bigotry and hatred on Palestinians, like a child. It’s difficult to believe that someone with such a bigoted mentality has ever sided with Palestinians.
@adamashelanu
Palestinians lost their land because thieves from 5 continents expelled them and stole it. People don’t normally “coexist” with home invaders.
"It's our land" says the people from the Arabian peninsula.
I'm an Israeli Jew and i want a two state solution and i don't want "us" to have more than "them". What a crazy, racist, nasty world we've become. So sad.
There were one million Jews in the Arab countries in 1948. Today there fewer than 5,000 left. There are more Arabs in Israel (even within "pre-1967 borders" ) than there were in 1948. Jewish communities in Jordanian and Egyptian controlled Palestine were completely destroyed and uprooted. Who displaced whom?
There are about 10,000 left in the 22 Arab Muslim countries.
Well said
@@shainazion4073 so a decimation of a decimated Jewish population denotes "tolerance"? Morocco is probably the most tolerant Arab country as far as Jews are concerned. There are only about 3,000 Jews left in Morocco. There are about a million Israeli Jews of Moroccan descent. The point is the Palestinians and Arabs generally demand respect, tolerance and self determination for themselves and show none toward Jews (and little toward Christians, Yazidi and other minorities). It's a one way street as far as they're concerned.
@@steve3131 - I think she just wanted to be accurate.
The Moroccan gov. is ‘tolerant’ towards the jews. The Moroccan immigrants and their offspring in my Netherlands Hate the jews and are the reason for modern anti semitism and attacks in Holland. Which our cowardly pc communist gov. does not dare to acknowledge.
in regards to countries like Morocco, Algeria, Iran and Iraq, with the promises of Zionism as well as the influences of French colonialisms, the Jews LEFT on their own. French colonialism and the mass numbers of Jews who left Algeria are hand in hand.
Listening to the comments from Palestinians they will not accept any deal with Israel except Israel's removal as a state. Pretty sad.
The video is not about eliminating Israel as a state it is about eliminating Jews.
*"Do you want to expel the Jews?"*
@@ef2718 I look at it the same way. They say it is Palestine not Israel in the video.
Israelis already did and still doing this to Palestinians, even the Christian Palestinians.
So, Shut tf up 🙂
@@-MohammedAhmed There seems to be Palestinians not expelled commenting on if Jews should be expelled.
This is a really cool project. One question I have is: Who do Palestinians think built Jerusalem/Nazareth/Bethlehem/ect? I think it would give interesting insight as to who they think some of the original founder were.
Jerusalem was first founded more than 5000 years ago, way before Judaicity even existed, by a civilisation that may or may not be a common ancestor to both Jews and Palestinian. But who cares ? What matter are the people that are living now, not the ones that are long dead.
All those places were built destroyed and rebuilt many times by many people. Just because they are mentioned in many people's favorite fictional narrative doesn't mean that's the whole story
I was wondering the same thing, there is a ton of archaeological evidence of the Hebrews in Israel going back thousands of years.
@@fragile1976 It was the Canaanites who most likely laid its first stones around 3000BC and around 1000BC the Jews took over and created the Kingdom of Israel. So the first record of Israel goes back 3000 years and Jerusalem about 6000 years. It was actually the Romans who occupied the land the longest in recorded history funny enough and they actually did expel the Jews from their homeland after a rebellion of the Jews. And funny enough this is where the name Palestine comes from as the Romans renamed the region. It means something like 'land from the expelled ones'. The Romans thought that was funny after they expelled the Jews from their homeland.
@@HTH565 Bro it does matter because they are claiming to be indigenous when in fact Jewish people were there before them.
The nice Christian boy at 1:20 gets the idea. Muslims always tell me they believe in Jesus but they don't seem to remember Jesus was an Hebrew/Aramaic speaking Jew from Judea who preached to love your enemies. He wasn't a zealot.
Beacuse Jesus was a jew, that means jews cant be bad people🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️we have to love the bad jews too. What a idiot. Let them steal your land and house, and see if u love them to
@@messi-mk3cq Good and bad is among all people. Without a doubt I believe more Jewish homes and property have been confiscated by Arabs than Jews throughout the ages. How many Jews live in Arab lands now?
@@loveandmercy9664 not many. U do know that isrealie jews are just white western jews. Who came over here. I dont Even think They are the same jews as the bible and the quran talk about🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Who ordered the roman occupiers to kill Jesus accusing him of witch-craft?
@@messi-mk3cq No. The majority of Israelis today descend from Jews kicked out of Syria, Egypt, Iraq, Lebanon, Morocco etc after the creation of the state of Israel. 6million of the European jews were massacred in the holocaust, a holocaust supported by the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem. There weren't many European jews left after the holocaust because they were a minority group to being with.
It belongs to the Jews. This goes back to biblical times. I understand there are innocent Palestinians as well but it still belongs to the Jews.
One of the biggest problems that many of the people in this video don't realize is that what they call Palestine has been the subject of an influx of population for centuries. The Jews have been moving there from the time of the Spanish inquisition. That is in addition to the Jews who were already present. There were many Jews from Eastern Europe who emigrated there in the late 18th century. With the emergence of Zionism, even more Jews came. When the British were in charge, many jobs became available, and that attracted many Jews and Arabs.
So you can't really say that its your land and you originate there because your family most likely emigrated there a generation ago or even two generations.
Yup
Hmm you obviously have not read history either. In 1920 there were 2000 Jews in that land they loved under palestinian British rule... they were not zionists. They mixed eith the Muslims...only when the Muslims were forcefully marched to Lebanon did the jews leave their homes mixed in Muslims and Christians and go to the isreali settlement of isreal. Those displaced Muslims were not free. Did not get to stay in palestine. With their people. Were sent to refugee camps in Lebanon instead. Then jewish american immigrant started to take all the land outside their isreal. If they wanted to live in palestine fine ...but they instead took lands illegally outside isreal and call it isreal. Thats not right.
@Padraigp 1920? Hmm, that rings a bell. Oh, right! 1929, when Al-Husseini, best buddies with your boy, Adolf Hitler, lied about the Jews destroying the al-asqa mosque, sparking an outrage all over the area resulting in Arabs killing and beating the Jews they so "loved."
Give me a break.
@@Padraigp wasn’t that after the war where they annexed a lot because they attacked by all the Arab countries sounding them this is genuine question.
@@benclements5808 after which war dear? In 1920 it was after world war one and before world war 2. It was noy only before amexing and settling beyond the 1948 lands they were given by Britain but it was before britian left. In the 20s Britain controlled the whole area but didn't colonize it. They managed ports and all sorts of things but didn't send settlers ..at that point a few jews lived in tandem with the muslims and catholics peacefully. They weren't zionist jews they were just palestinian jews. The xionists came from Europe I believe. Not from palestine. But when the zionists got britian to give them the lands in 48 they also took the palestinians jews into their zionist lands away from where they were mixed with palestinians. I dont know if they forced them to leave the mixed areas or if the jewish chose to leave. I honestly don't know much about history I just have been watching videos since this whole thing blew up. I watched some old TV shows from the 80s and 90s which were more helpful about the past. Cant remmebet them now but some were BBC. One was really good and I wish I could remember the name of it for you, it went from before the 192ps and had footage and photos of that era and also showed the economic activities going on like building railways and exporting products and the British seem to have overseen a lot of that. If I find it I will try to Come back and post it here.
I find it very interesting that they beleive all of "Palestine" is theirs. Does anybody know how they arrive at that conclusion? I really want to understand how they get there. But, it makes no sense to me.
They keep on saying, "this is our land," but their ancestors are still in the Gulf before Muhammad was born. The Jews are already in the land at the times of Moses.
Palestinians and the ancient jews are one the current Israelis are a bunch European converts from khazar.
@@Viclip24 Really because the majority of Jews in Israel are Mizrahi not Ashkenazi so explain that you clwn, or do u even know the difference? 85% of “Palestinians” are Arab, Arabs are not from the land at all….
@@Viclip24 pastalinis? Cannanites? Ar abz? Muzlinz? Now ancient je ws? Lol
You guys change the lie every 10 minutes.
Yalla yalla back to saudi ar abia
@@Viclip24
THe Khazar myth is just that -- a myth. It is not supported by the discipline of archaeology. Where are the Synagogues and Jewish cemeteries in Khazaria?
You are not them don't get it twisted you're just random collection from around the world y'all not bani isreal y'all Zionist nazis
1:18 I wish there were more people like this young man on both sides, and in general.
he is christian
Both sides : the one with the 58 states and the one with only 1.
The jews will no longer be genocided or removed from their ancient homeland. There is no both sides.
There are. Unfortunately we don’t speak up enough.
Christians are not hateful
I hate this framing. It completely ignores palestinian Jews. Half way through he says "im talking about the israelis" THEN FUCKING SAY THAT. Conflating Judaism and Zionism is dangerous.
I think a good question to ask Palestinians is "Do you believe you would be in trouble with your people if you said the Jews deserve to stay?" I think this question can give a bit more honest insight into potential reasoning for answers in the future.
I would never want to pay Jizzia
I would only charge interest to the Gentiles
Jizya costs less than the Zakat which Muslims have to pay. You sure?
@@omaralfar1666 I don't think they would want to pay Zakat either.
@@Abilliph Zakat is only reserved for Muslims, so nn-Muslims aren't even allowed to pay it.
@@omaralfar1666 lol imagine thinking non-muslims would be happy to pay tax for protection just to practice their religion. delusional muslim
There is no solution. Just remember Hitler's best friend and the first Palestinian leader Haj Amin El-Hussaini
at the time was a different faction that actually wanted to live in peace with the Jews. two people were able to share the land. but Haj Amin El-Hussaini made sure they will be out of the picture. Haj Amin El-Hussaini was the product of the idiots of the British empire. Herbert Samuel was of these idiots. if he approached the peaceful factionת we would have a different tale. instead of ongoing conflict. the odd part there are streets in Israel after his name. I can't figure out why would he deserve honor after this.
@@yigalgurevitch2936 well, we all can agree that moderate or extreme, if the Palestinian/Arabs would have won in 1948, almost all the jews there would've been murdered.
@@yigalgurevitch2936
Herbert Samuael made the mistake of trying to appease power hungry Amin El-Hussaini ,an extremist whose first ambition was to create an Arab Islamic state from Iraq to Egypt, him and his cronies violently eliminated rival leaders.
@@MikeJones888x the 48 war is the byproduct of Haj Amin El-Hussaini.
@@yigalgurevitch2936 maybe, but if you compare the cultures one is drenched in blood for hundreds of years and the other tried to survive for the most part.
This is the same situation we have in Ukraine. A stupid neighbour who doesn't even see an option of living besides peacufully. How can you find piece with someone who's only wish is to destroy you?
Okay. The Jews all leave and ownership of Palestine returns to England. The British crown will not treat trouble makers so kindly.
Anybody that knows the region well wouldn't be surprised by any of the answers. Obviously there is still a palestinian majority that considers all of Israel their land, it is what they are taught all their lives. If they truly desired the 67' war territories only, they would already have their country as it was offered twice to them by two different former prime ministers of Israel in just the last 20 years. People that have no clue about the history like to whine about the poor people in the occupied territories as if it's all that mattered historically and without regard to the escalation from the arab side.
😂😂 Arabs are warriors sonny. Not like Zion ists (excluding Sephardic and normal religious Jews).
This is a really good explanation. Wow 👑
If you mean the Ehud Barak offer, no, it didn't promise even the pre-1967 borders to Palestinians.
"Barak’s proposals were, in the context of Israeli politics, path-breaking and courageous. But, as Malley wrote in a New York Times op-ed that is a CliffsNotes version of his NYRB piece, “[T]he measure of Israel’s concessions ought not be how far it has moved from its own starting point; it must be how far it has moved toward a fair solution.”
Which is the second PM offer?
@@husnahasanca Unfortunately the idea of a "fair solution" includes Israel self destructing which they are not inclined to do, which is a major issue for the Palestinians. The Ehud Barak offer was the Gaza strip entirely, 73 percent of the west bank immediately, and working toward upwards of over 90 percent of the west bank in a few years. Obviously this is a problem as Israel doesn't immediately put themselves at a massive security risk by withdrawing immediately from the west bank (as they did eventually from Gaza), and they don't accept a million refuges that were born in camps over decades either. Israel really should know better than to try to retain security over the desires of those that attacked them continuously. The second prime minister was Olmert, this didn't get as much publicity, apparently Abbas rejected his offers because he couldn't bring a map out of the confidential meetings, truly a good faith negotiation.
Or….. these videos as a whole are a pile of bullshit. While they are interesting in the fact that we are exposed to both sides’ perspective; it actually suffers from one logical error. Corey clearly edits these videos and compiles them himself. Who’s to say he didn’t decide to include other footage of other Arabs saying something else? He’s pushing his viewpoint very subtle, and that’s what should be understood here. By using these small sample sizes and compiling these clips where Palestinians are shown as ignorant or hateful; it does it’s intended goal. When you poll or ask questions, you’ll suffer however from one of two things. With a large sample size. I will suffer from little detail in responses in return for accuracy in my polling. With small sample sizes, I get more detailed responses but I sacrifice accuracy due to small sample size. I guarantee a Palestinian from the territories would speak very different about topics than a Palestinian raised in the west, or people from the Gaza Strip which obviously Corey can’t go there. But there’s clearly a narrative being pushed, and for the sake of peace im not replying to anyone after this comment. But you also have to understand that of course these people feel this way, they’ve been done wrong by their leaders and by the occupation, these are both obstacles to an average Palestinian. Now go and ask them how many family members they’ve seen killed. I’ve seen conflict even in my own neighborhood I grew up in the US with gangs. Clearly if a rival gang killed your family member or friend or parent (resulting in broken homes) you’ll hate the rival faction and live by violence. This is a matter of understanding, not agreeing. That’s very different. Understand what I’m writing here, but you can disagree. What I’m saying is, this channel has inherent bias(with sneaky tricks like editing out other voices) to encourage a narrative that Palestinians are hateful and ignorant. Suppose they all are even, then I’m not even the slightest bit surprised they think how they do because they experience death often, violence and harassment. Hurt breeds more hurt. You could never live a day in their lives. I cant. In fact, a great video that’s not giving inherent bias to any side of this debate, I believe it was titled can Israelis and Palestinians see eye to eye. It’s an interesting watch. Maybe when the killing stops, maybe when the occupation stops.. maybe we will see a change. Like I said, don’t agree with me, you don’t have to, but understand and ask well why is it these people say these things in these videos? That’s a great way of thinking critically about the conflict, and I think both sides need to ask themselves questions and soul search a bit.
The irony that they go and buy land everywhere and REFUSE to assimilate but they would never allow a Jew to own land
The Israelis steal our homes and lands, they do not rent or buy them
90% of “Palestinians” are from another place, etc. etc.
61% of the Palestinians are indigenous Canaanites, while 8% of the Jews in the whole world are from the children of Israel who lived on the land.
Ok. No source. God took the Land of Israel from the Canaanites and gave it to the People practicing Judaism, studying the Torah, and worshipping HaShem. That is why they are there.
@@d_l_singer No, that is not true. There is a difference between the children of Israel and those who converted to Judaism, such as the difference between the descendants of the Prophet Muhammad in Saudi Arabia and the Russian Muslims or European Muslims. Only the Jewish children of Israel have the right to live as indigenous people, like the Palestinians of Canaanite and Jewish origin, but the Israelis who converted to Judaism in other countries do not have the right to live. As indigenous people
This is seriously painful to watch. It’s as if these Palestinians have zero clue as to the history of Jews in the region going back 3,000 years, and they won’t even let them do anything other than “pilgrimages” to land that has THEIR history more than 1,000 years before Islam even existed. 🤦♂️
They don’t. Their education is probably very focused on the beliefs their leaders want them to know. They are told to have many children and all of those children are taught the same things and it will repeat for generations. It is crazy that in modern times the Palestinians have been living that way and unable to thrive and learn and prosper like people around the world. It’s very sad.
Palestine: Made by Rome
Israel: Made by God
*israel: made by zionism.
Fact
I prefer being under Israeli leadership than Palestinian leadership. I do not agree completely with the creation of the Israel we see today but the Palestinian leadership would and could not make that nation better than how Israeli leadership is.
Israel is literally backed and helped by almost every Western country. Palestine has no government.
Your statement doesn’t really add up
@@azharrftw it should be obvious that I was implying if Palestine had a government and power. Palestine is recognized officially by the majority of the Arab League and the Islamic Republic of Iran. There is even an active Palestinian Embassy in Tehran as we speak. There is recognition. I am speaking about what is good for the majority of the people living in that region both Israelis and Palestinians and it is not an established Palestinian government sitting at the helm. Whether or not we agree with Israel's treatment of Palestinians or the way Israel was created there is no doubt that Israeli leadership is what's best for the most amount of people living there, by a long shot
@@om33d Who do you think the Palestinian government works for behind the curtains their Zionist overlords 🤣 same thing with every Arab country it’s obvious since the fake peace treaties they made they know darn well a true Muslim leader will never join forces
@@om33d this recognised Palestine is only recognised because its obedient to Israel. They live on welfare from the USA and Israel, they are hated by their people and that's why they are failing. Israel on the other hand get over 5 billions a year support from USA.
“I prefer”
If you aren’t Palestinian then what you “prefer” is irrelevant. “That” region has been called Palestine for over 2500 years. Anybody who partially agrees with how that entity was created is a disgusting person.
These interviews really demonstrate that the Palestinians are the real problem. We need to change their beliefs if we want long term peace
If you had any questions about what the average Palestinian thinks - here you go. Its all or nothing. If so, expect to get nothing
"It's not their homeland" when Hebrews literally built Jerusalem...
Built? You mean the ancient infrastructures that were demolished in crusades?You must be older than Moses
The entire Levant is full of Roman, Ottoman, Arab, Hebrew, Assyrian and Aramaic buildings. The Levantines speak Arabic because of Arabization , they have different cultures and dialects. In Europe there are countries their language is English but they are not from England. did you understand what I mean.
The Hebrews who built Jerusalem are from there they were born there and their families too
They did not come from Europe and Africa and America and Asia !!
No. David took Jerusalem (Jebus) from the Jebusites. Jerusalem was called 'the stronghold of Zion' at that time. David renamed it the City of David. (2 Samuel 5 6-10).
@@Aychabouaziz1You're confusing races with tribes. The Palestine are related to Jews but not the descendants. Europeans jews are decended from Jewish men, who married European woman, genetically they are about 50/50 and rather inbred because they hardly married Europeans after that.
3:30 To see that girl smile with happiness and hatred and saying "sure" when they ask her if she would *expel all Jews* reminds me of Nazis.
Old allies.
The supreme leader Amin El-Hussaini was a Nazi army officer, same was the commander of the invading Arab Liberation Army who was appointed by the League of Arab countries, Lebanese born Muslim of Turkmen ancestry, Fawzi al-Qawuqji.
wife material right there
She would be standing in line to ignite the ovens...
Well the jews act like zionist tho
@Amaj Media
Zionism existed 1400 years before Islam.
Where do you think David and Solomon had their Israeli kingdoms, in Antarctica?
I'm really rooting for Palestinian autonomy/statehood, but hearing comments like these makes my head want to explode. Not only wrong, but impractical too.
I’ve watched a lot of these videos over the years, and it strikes me that the women tend to be the most zealous and intolerant. Many more men say, “sure, why can’t we just get along?” Yet, when the terrorists attack, and the retribution bombing comes, all we hear about are the “innocent women” and children. 🤔Maybe the women aren't so "innocent"?
or maybe because they have a strong reason to say that..... most of them are traumatized what do you expect them to say?? be logic
With these kinds of views expressed as plainly in this video it's no wonder people find the Arabs ("Palestinians") to be unreasonable. It's bizarre seeing so English fluent young adults act nostalgic for a country that literally never existed, and solely because of an inability to compromise.
I agree, they’re taught an alternative history. I sympathize with the Palestinians that lost their homes in 1948, but the idea that it’s ALL their land when most of them immigrated from neighboring Arab nations during the past few generations, just like the European Jews.
They feel nostalgic for their homes that were taken from them. For when they had freedom to move, to own land, to be with their loved ones without someone coming into their homes and killing them ro take their homes. They shouldn’t have to compromise when its about their dignity as human beings.
Why didn’t the zionists compromise? No one had a problem with them living with us infact we welcomed them with open arms after ww2, the problems began only after they wanted to create a state for jews only. And to do that, they had to kill a lot of palestinians. Something we were never able to get over. It didn’t stop and it still goes on to this day. They still steal land that is Palestinian land under international law. I’m talking about the west bank. Not just that but the violence and diregard for palestinian life has always been. there
@@DrunkDrynastywhere is your info coming from? That Palestinians are refugees themselves?
A country that never existed? You're playing a semantic game, with no relevance. It doesn't matter whether or not there was ever a "country" named Palestine. The area *was* called Palestine by at least the Romans, the Ottomans, and the British. There was currency called the Palestine Pound in Palestine in the early 20th century. There was a Palestine Railroad. So tell me, what is the relevance of what you said?
This whole thing with people saying there is no Palestine and no Palestinians is ill logic that only works on people who can't think clearly or recognize what is relevant.
Ask a similar question: should non- Palestinian Muslims be expelled / allowed to own land in palestine?
ua-cam.com/video/as_DZKPCG6k/v-deo.html "Can foreigners move to Palestine?"
I think they are allowed to. Shireen Abu Akleh was Christian.
@@husnahasanca Shireen Abu Akleh is a Palestinian Christian. She has, and should have, the same rights as Palestinian Muslims.
@@husnahasanca - Yes but Palestinian.
Under the Umah that will not be a problem. As long as they bring money.
No go on social welfare. As the muslim immigrants into Europe.
These people are so brainwashed, it’s truly tragic for everyone 😢
What you do seems quite balanced. You ask hard and the most important questions in this conflict and you always drill deep to get a clear answer even tho most people are quite uncomfortable talking about it. I normally use the phrase 'brave and stunning' sarcastically since it gets used so often nowadays for mediocre deeds, but what you do really is brave and important to the whole world.
Ask questions like:
Who controlled Gaza and the West Bank between 1948 and 1967?
Have Palestinians ever brought forth terms for a two state solution?
Who have been the aggressors in every major war there (1948, 1967, etc.)?
Has there ever been a Leader of a Palestinian Peace Movement?
The majority are islamists! You can't make peace with radicals!
I was thinking something similar. I think the original Palestine was handed to the Zionists by the British and that's it. There's no illegal occupation. Because Palestine/the ottoman empire fell. The end.
ua-cam.com/video/76NytvQAIs0/v-deo.htmlsi=8pdpFgMsLvE3Pj_8
A peace movement from a people who aren't even recognised as a nation and their existence being constantly denied? Sure.
Who wants peace with Nazis?
I am 86 years old, and only people my age or older know the truth about what happened in 1947/1948 in the Holy Land..
!) The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was on the German side in WW 2 , and approved of the Holocaust.
2) The British were on the Arab side.
3 ) there were 800,000 Jews and B50,000 Arabs in the Holy Land in 1948. .
4)50,000 Jews had come from Austria and Russia from 1880 to 1947 but.750,000 Jews' had Ancestors who had lived there since Bible times
5) The United nations divided the Hol;y Land into 2 parts The Jews and the Arabs got the part where they were in the majority.
6) In the 1948 war the Jordanians captured the West Bank and Northern Judea.The Egyptians captured Gaza. .The Jews captured Southern Judea , the coastal strip and Galilee.
7) There has never been a country called Palestine . From about 1400 to 1917 The Holy Land was ruled by the Turks . 450 AD to 1400 it was ruled by the Greeks 165BC to about 450 AD it was ruled by the Romans.
8) After 1950, 5 million Jews were expelled from Morroco,Tunisia,Libya,Egypt Arabia, Syria, LebanonJordan,Turkey , Iraq and Iran .They were only allowed one suitcase each and left homes and businesses behind This is the main source of migration to the Holy Land
9) The Russians have been expelling their Jewish population since 1995 , sending them to the Holy Land .
10) 6 million Jews did NOT migrate from Europe tp Israel The 6 million are dead , and lists of names of the people killed were found in East Berlin after the Fall of Communism.
11) The British and American Jews are still in Britain and America,They give money , but are happy in Britain and America.
12) The French Jews went to France from Algeria , together with 2 million Ethnic French in 1968. They are beginning to go to Israel now.
Hahaha.
What a load of dribble.
Why was you banished from every corner of the world, lets look at the reasons why King James of England banished you, then let us look at wht leo banished you hundreds of years earlier, same reasons. MANIPULATION OF HOST NATIONS INFRASTRUCTURE, FINANCES AND SOCIETIES.
Who, was first to declare war in ww2?
To.anyone who wants to know how to deal with lying zionists. Ask them who declared war in ww2 and acted upon said declaration.
Christian Arabs in the Holy Land should be allowed to remain in the Holy Land , as they are ,like the Sabra Jews , the ancient Inhabitants of the Holy Land. Over the centuries , these people were originally Jewish Samaritans but became Christians. THe Muslim inhabitants are fairly recent immigrants , and should be sent to Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia , Egypt and Saudi Arabia , and be given the money and property of Jews expelled from these countries in the Early 1950s.There were over 5 million Jews who were expelled in the early 1950s.The Governments of these countries pocketed the money and Wealth , and the Muslim Arabs of the Holy Land are entitled to it, providing they go to the Southern Mediterranean countries . They cannot go to Libya , or Iraq , because of instability in those countries.
@sheilanixon913. Are you able to answer a question I have?
That's the exact reason why they never have had a country and never will have it.
This is why I will never stand with palestine
What is Palestinian identity and culture other than anti-Zionism?
That sound like a good question to email Corey.
oh you're missing a lot if that's the only thing you know about palestinians
Go and learn some history 🤦♂️
BMA
They are Muslims!!!
And brothers & sisters to us!!!
As a bereber ,these palestinians have no idea of their Own History , long life Israel.
Wow, no wonder the Palestinians have never accepted a two state solution…
In another one of his videos he asked if they want a two state solution and not one said yes. And when asked where they should go if it is one state and if it was all Palestine they said Israel citizens would need to leave and some even said they need to be killed. So when people claim this as some sort of magical solution what they don't touch on is that it is not wanted by the majority of citizens and Hamas. They do not want Israel and the Jews there and the goal is to wipe out Israel and the people in it. They paint Palestine as this place that just wants to be free and Israel just is not letting them. The fact is they want it to be free from the river to the sea which includes Israel not existing and Hamas has continually attacked Israel with rockets and other weapons to try to make that happen. So what is the solution here.
there goes the term "innocent civilians" more like brainwashed puppets@@juliadawn33
you cant make peace with these people... just cant
It was fascinating to watch the contradictory perspectives being shared by the two women at the end, and subsequent backtracking and realignment of their positions. The one who was calling for religious pluralism does not want to be seen as out-of-sync with the mainstream Palestinian view; thus she caved and simply parroted the other girl's hardline stance. A real-time microcosm of the social pressure to conform in Palestinian society.
what would you do if you were on the losing side as has been for the Palestinians since the Zionists arrive ?
@@MrBeen992, the palestinians sold for them a lot of land from 1880 to 1945
@@guilhermemauricio4858 yeah, the jews bought a lot of land. But I am sure you are not so dumb to include the occupied land, right ?
@@MrBeen992 , Sure!
@@guilhermemauricio4858 occupied land is illegal ownership owned by killing of palestinians