Israelis: Do Smotrich and Ben Gvir represent you?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
It's also important to realise that, because the Israeli electoral system is proportional, only a small minority of Israelis voted for them. Ben Gvir and Smotrich's parties got ONLY ~5% EACH. That's TINY. Yet because of the political havoc, they are indispensable for the coalition they're in.
There are Jews named Alex dude
😂
So? Netanyahu and all the rest of them think alike, individually they are less unhinged then those two but that's about the only difference one can detect.
this is why i think we should abandon our parliamentarian system and become a republic with 2 chambers with national and regional representation.
even it would help to governments like the bibi one, so he would not be dependent on them in order to continue in the chair.
Likud is just hamas but in Hebrew
3:08 translation mistake
She haven't said "all the death and terrorists" she said she don't support the calls for "death TO terrorists"
She is 18 dude, why picking
More accuratley she said she doesn't support capital punishment for terrorists.
@@roylebitski6685 what do you mean ?
the Israeli people are sick. They don't see who the real terrorists are. they have exceeded the limits!
No maybe that’s what she meant but the translation is accurate word for word
Now ask Palestinians if sinwar represents them…
I'm not a Palestenian,,,but yes he represents me
Well that would be difficult in Gaza right now. Also, Palestinian are under two different governing bodies
I don't like this comparison
Sinwar represents 7 Billion of people who wish you stay in hell, if that means something to you!
75 % of Palestinians said YES. (Source: Palestinian authority)
The question of not doing something to get rid of them is stupid. They were elected in democratic elections. That means they do represent a slice of the population, over 10.8%. Netanyahu chose to collaborate with them, and he himself represents the largest slice of the population, 23.4%. He managed to build a coalition, comprising of over 50% of the elected Knesset members (MPs), meaning that ultimately, these freaks represent the majority of the people. That's democracy. Sometimes you're in the majority and sometimes in the minority and that's it.
These people did do something to get rid of them, and that was to vote for a different party in the elections. That's what everyone CAN do. Protests don't do anything but say "we don't like that we lost the elections".
And in the next elections after October 7th, the Israeli left will hopefully be voted completely out. I'm tired of their contempt for this country and its people.
Yeah but government systems matter. In the US a party that gets 23 percent of the vote won’t end up in charge.
@@adigriffon funny. Our Supreme Court got 0% of the vote and they are somehow in charge. And they continue to get my people killed.
That's exactly because Bibi got 23% that he had to form a coalition with far right extremists, he needed them to reach the majority at the Knesset
It can be hard to comprehend from the US political system but in many country, there's between 3 to 5 important political parties surrounded by sometimes dozen or other smaller ones.
When a consensus can't be reached by one of the big parties, he has to compromise with smaller ones that are the closest to his view.
When the war started, other parties form the left ask Bibi to form a new coalition, with them in it, at the condition that he would kick out the far right extremists such as mentioned in the video.
Bibi chosed to refuse their offer as he knew that his political field of action would be less restricted by keeping the far right at his side, rather than try an alliance with the left, that could sabotage him in the long term.
"Why aren't you doing something to restrain them?"
What a democratic concept!!!
@Yvanoel01what racism? Who is discriminated against in israeli universities? In army service? In land prices? Who?
Really what can one individual really do
@FaiezCader In a democracy, what you do is you accept the outcome of democratic elections.
@@chayimjakob5499 yes but Isreal didn't except the Democratic Elections that Palestinian Resistance won.We all want Palestinians and IsreAlis to live in peace but to achieve that it's to end the occupation of Palestinians
Yashir Koach from Chicago. I haven't seen your videos lately for maybe a year. Glad you're continuing. Todah Rabah!
The last but one woman, the daughter, was brilliant. Really being part of the solution, than part of the problem.
As an Israeli...I found this fascinating.
Thank you again for your invaluable work.
Perhaps Israel isn’t the problem but extremists: I am beginning to realise
I would like to hear more about why you found it fascinating??
I was just watching a video of a wounded Palestinian man on the bonnet of an IDF truck. He had been shot by them and his blood was flowing down the front of the truck. Just another war crime
@@thomasjosullivan9179 Israel has said from the beginning that it's soldiers violated protocol.
@@AbdulSoomro-kj5lt That is true.
@@thomast6851do you think Israel is committing genocide in Gaza? Note that the UN declared today that over 20,000 children are estimated to be lost, disappeared, detained, buried under the rubble or in mass graves. Do you think Israel is deliberately starving Palestinians? 9 out of 10 Palestinians are not eating every day and it’s been declared a man-made famine.
I wonder why did nobody answer to your question of "why don't you do anything about it"
what is there to do about it? it's a democracy. as much as I dislike Ben Gvir and Smotrich - they are elected by the people in the same democratic way any other government representative is elected.
The only way you affect it is by voting and raising awareness for the next time there are elections.
It's dont mean that at this point, they represent the israels people. They won't go to election because they know they don't gonna be part of government. But the damages they did and they continue to do it already impossible to fix
yes. that was a stupid question.
It's also important to realise that, because the Israeli electoral system is proportional, only a small minority of Israelis voted for them. Ben Gvir and Smotrich's parties got ONLY ~5% each. That's TINY. Yet because of the political havoc, they are indispensable for the coalition they're in.
Nobody sane wanted to form a coalition with Likud, so Bibbi got those two idiots. Now they wield power totally incommensurate with the number of people they represent. We have this problem in the U.S. congress right now too. The MTGs of the world can hold the entire caucus hostage because they can’t pass anything without her vote.
You do understand that citizenzs themselves can't enforce elections before the term's end, right? BTW, both parties have roughly 10% of the seats, it's just the close results between the two blocks that gave them power beyond their actual size.
"Democracy" even if they like or not, they represent them as elected represents.
We have also two arab countries in parliament. Don't worry for us.
What a stupid question....
For that exactly question we have elections, and you can see exactly how many Israelis are voting for them.
And about 12 procent voted from them directly
And more than 12% will vote for them in the night selections
And over half the Knesset seats went to a coalition that all agreed to have Ben Gvir and Smotrich in it.
12% of the vote and 100% of the power
@@StapleGenius99 No, it just means there are 12% of Israelis who fully support Ben Gvir or Smotrich, and a majority of Israelis who say, "I'm can live with them, even if point-by-point I don't agree with what they say". Isn't that what democracy is all about: finding the greatest possible consensus and acting on it?
@@StapleGenius99 unfortunately not.
The ultimate power in Israel is still held by the unelected Supreme Court, who are to Israel what the Mullahs are to Iran.
My favorite thing about these videos is the candor often displayed. My least favorite thing about these videos is the ads that often play with them.
3:43 מה קורה במדינה הזאת? מה זה "ללכת לקיצון" כשמדובר במפלצות הנוח'בה?
She said ‘death penalty’ is extreme. idk whether it is or not. I’m against the death penalty but I don’t live in a country where there are people trying to murder random people all the time. We’ve had a few attacks but our anti-terrorism infrastructure is pretty good so far. And we aren’t dealing with a centuries old murderous grudge.. When people try to say “this didn’t start on October 7 it started in 1948” I always argue with “so explain the Hebron massacre of 1517 to me.. how does that fit in?”
If people bother to read the evidence in support of Israel is there. Not least of which the newspapers from 1947 which report the 1945 loan contract between Hitler and Amin Al-Husseini. The world couldn’t exactly walk away without allowing a Jewish state after seeing that contract.
@@freedahlogic8368 you dug a bottomless pit when you mention Hitler. The Zionists and the Nazis were in a long term relationship, next to the one night stand with Amin Al-Husseini.
I suggest you do some research into this shameful subject
@@freedahlogic8368 Totally agree w/you. Those liberal leftists are our 5 th column, and this film maker is one of them.
As an Israeli, our government is atrocious. The sheer disconnect from the public--especially regarding education, foreign relations, the Palestinian question, and religion--is mind-bending.
one state with equal rights for all, you agree?
@@eKoush are you referring to a centralized, unitary state for the Palestinian and Israeli populaces? Absolutely not. Yes, everyone should be treated equally under the law, but the supposition that both peoples could be integrated into one is unrealistic and has never been echoed in Israeli society for a reason--it's unattainable. It is crucial the remember that the non-Jewish Arab minority in Israel was absorbed from the Arab designated state of the UN Partition--they are Israelis through and through. Arab residing outside the UN Partitioned Jewish State have evolved differently; religiously, culturally, and politically. Add the 90+ years of conflict between the groups and these basic, fundamental changes, no. Your One State ideal, for many another reason, would lead to bloodshed.
@@eKoushIt's too late. If Israel gave all Palestinians citizenship in 1967 before Hamas and Fatah took over, then it would've been possible. But now both loathe each other, so it's never gonna happen.
@@cakeye1258 I’d claim Israeli society is more fearful of Palestinian integration than bigoted against it. We’ve grown to detest any such proposition for the ensuing violence. Palestinian society is more-albeit not entirely-radicalized and is motivated more out of disdain and hatred toward us. It is important to remember that 1967 saw the initial support of the Palestinian public to the invading Arab armies; it is also important to remember that before Fatah and Hamas, we had the PLO, which carried out several terrorist attacks. In the beginning of the 1970s there was the Black September Massacre.
@@grandpasmokes904 Incase you haven't noticed, there's already been bloodshed. Your country is currently eradicating human life in Gaza and the West Bank at a genuinely astonishing rate. But aside from that, if you don't support a unitary state yet you do support equal rights, are you suggesting an Israeli-led state that governs the Palestinians in some way? Do you support Palestinians having their own state and if so what are the borders of this state, generally speaking?
Here's a question about fate... Do you think relations between Israelis and Palestinians would have turned out happier if Yitzhak Rabin had not been assassinated by Yigal Amir?
not answering the question but adding: yigal amir is on the same side, same views as ben gvir and smotrich. ben gvir stole the car symbol from rabin's car
no, because the paestinians think every single rock in land of israel should be theirs so the 1967 borders is not enough for them
iam an israeli arab im talking from experience of living with people in the west bank and gaza
on the other hand the jew dont care they just want to live they have been living in fear for more than 3500 years of being chased out of their homes and killed all over the world even in the land of israel before 1948
most of the house around the dome of the rock and al-aqsa mosque in jerousalem were owned by jews but in 1929 the arabs attacked them and stole the jews homes
hope that helps
As an Israeli, that's a good question. I think after Yitzhak Rabin death the country went backwards...before the goverment did a lot more against racisem he was the prime minister of everyone, not just for the people who voted for him. I miss him a lot, his integrity. My child wrote form school a long letter for him very moving about how it might have been better here had he was still alive. (She is 10...)
No. But maybe the relationship between left and right would.
Not at all. Terrorism got insane by the assassination, Oslo was a failure.
I don't understand the second part of the question... what do you want them to do? Ridiculous
In any democratic country, people protest if they are not happy with the governing body
He has a point, we have a collective responsibility for the deeds of our government. Just like the Palestinians.
Lmfao vote differently maybe??
@@liaa4172 who said they didn't vote differently? This is a naïve question that reeks of ignorance
@@ntheg is that why bibi and his ppl are in power??
Will he ask Palestinians if Hamas represents them? Very few Arabs are against Hamas.
when u see what israel is doing i think it starts to make sense why they would but you apparently have no clue
@@dianalee1589What Israel is doing exactly? You don't like Israel killed terrorists? So you supporting terrorists?
The extremist parties elected by the Israelis were the ones who were financing Hamas 😅
Well Palestinians have been under siege for over 90 years under occupation 58 years and now genocide so they have two views of hamas generally they don’t like them because they are corrupt and authoritarian but at the same time they’re the only ones who stand up to their oppressors.
@@dianalee1589Israel doesn't have a goal to kill Palestinians. It's consequences of war, as Hamas hides between civilians. Israel is trying to minimize civilian death but it's very difficult especially when many people are looking for Israel to fail..
" you can't equate the violence of the oppressor with the violence of the oppressed. They are not the same, and the oppressor is the ultimate source of violence from both sides." Caitlin Johnstone.
This is not the logic of peace. You cannot have rapprochement without reconciliation and you cannot have that if you cling to blind arrogance. I'm Jewish and half Irish so I understand the peace process and your way of thinking is antithetical.
It's reashed french anti colonial discourse from the 60's.
Stupidest way of thinking ever, justifying the killing of innocent and the adoration of terrorists ever since
U are asking secular assimilated Jews go to observant orthodox areas and u will get completely different answers
Unfortunately most Orthodox Jews are just as assimilated. They speak as though they are in medieval Germany 18th century Polish nobility.
Orthodox are even more against them I'm from here I know
This so called journalist is another leftist, “the enemy within” Shame on him
Orthodox don't even serve in the military...
@@nirmiller3277 You're talking about the ultra orthodox, orthodox just means religious Jews, but that's irrelevant because even the ultra orthodox are sitting with Ben Gvir and Smotrich in the same coalition.
I live in the North and my opinion is that the political atmoshphere here is very different than those in the center. Bibi, Ben Gvir and Smotrich are much more popular here as we live close enough to see Lebanon every day.
Don't they notice that warmongery brings more harm to IL and Palestinians? That more cruelty and occupation to Palestinians causes violance from their side?
@@anastazjaQwhat do you call the 7th of october?
@@dogbert52 a response, lol, crying about 7 oct and ignoring your apartheid system and everything else come with it
@@anastazjaQ What occupation was there in Gaza on Oct. 6? The PA in Judea and Samaria is in the areas agreed upon by the Oslo Accords that both sides signed. The whole thing is a false narrative by the terrorists of the PA and Hamas.
@@dogbert52 I call it a horrible wake up call to the deluded Left wing people in Israel who thought that there could be peace with Hamas and the PA.
For me, Ben Gvir and Yair Golan are one and the same. Both have a terrible impact on Israel.
It doesn't matter if they do or don't.
It matters only that Ben Gvir, Smotrich and Weiss operate with impunity.
Most Germans were not in the SS either.
Israeli far right is not the SS, watch your language. If you want to seek for an equivalent to SS in the middle east you a many examples, Hamas is one of them.
The democratic nature of the Israelis is always revealed in these interviews. They can freely speak their minds... But can we say the same about the Palestinians?
What's the use of a democracy if it's oppressing and genociding civilians ?
LoL
Well maybe if palastine had not been choked by isreali?
Well what if i told you that Israel is the one preventing them?
Choked? You mean the Israelis that left Gaza unilaterally and got rockets and kidnappings in return? Israelis who offered peace in 2000 and a two state solution and got the second intifada in return? What rational Israeli could believe that most Palestinians want anything other than the destruction of Israel and the wholesale slaughter of the Jews?
It's superinteresting to listen to these answers. Well done Corey. 12:00 best answer imho. Greets from Belgium.
השאלה "למה אתה לא עושה משהו נגדם" היא לא דמוקרטית.
בדמוקרטיה צריך ללמוד לחיות עם דעות שלא תואמות את הדעות שלך, בשביל זה יש בחירות...
דמוקרטיה זה לא רק בחירות. בדמוקרטיות אפשר לעשות הרבה נגד השלטון ולהתנגד ולהשפיע. דרך עיתונות, הפגנות, ביקורת אמנותית וכל צורת ביטוי אחרת. זה חופש הביטוי הדמוקרטי וכך מפעילים לחץ
If this Corey wasn't obviously biased against Ben Gvir and Smotrich he would have interviewed people in areas that support Ben Gvir & Smotrich and his audience amy have heard what these two politicians represent and not the lies and misinformation that he's trying to perpetuate.
Couldn't agree more. The film maker is a pathetic leftist and Arab lover.
They are both devils who murder children
@corey appreciate you doing this - however just curious on the methodology of how you chose the people and places you visit. Curious as a student of conflict resolution/representation to see if views are adequately represented and how do you control your own bias.
Also, by shoving a camera into peoples face, how do you people aren't being politically correct. I am sure if you were to do a parallel where you aren't recording people and not talking to them on the streets, my hypothesis is that the answers may change.
I would like to know this too, as his bias is showing here.
Corey is a bad source on this I'm afraid. I used to follow him as well. The problem is he enjoys stirring the pot, which was acceptable before this war, but for him to do it now when the country needs unity is absolutely shameful, not to mention how manipulative what he shows us is.
You may notice that everyone he interviewed was from a coastal city, and only one of them was a Mizrahi.
Ben Gvir received 11% of the vote (about 14 or 15 percent of the Israeli Jewish vote) and many more Israelis who didn't vote for him in that election said that they would vote for him in the next one now that he's proven to be a competitive candidate.
During the struggle to pass judicial reforms, in the face of the leftist tantrum, Ben Gvir won even more support. After the wake-up call that was October 7th, the entire country shifted to the right, with only the most insane fringes remaining on the left. Those who had voted for labor will now vote for Bibi or Benet, and those who had voted for bb or Benet will now vote for Ben Gvir, Smotrich, or Sofer.
@@neonred7594 You are all talking nonsense. The 12% who voted for them are still being represented in this video. Corey isn't here to give you statistics.. you can find all that online by yourself.. He just walks in random places and ask people on questions.. It's not a social study of the general Israeli opinion.
@@snakey934Snakeybakey The film maker is a super leftist and Arab lover. I saw his other vids, and it's very transparent. Keep in mind too is that he's not Israeli, he's Canadian, he doesn't seem to understand the Middle East very well.
Ben Gvir and Smotritz, like everyone in the Israeli government, represent their constituents, they obviously do not represent all the voters in Israel.
Those who want to know how many elected them, that is, how many support them, should look at the statistics of the last election.
From an Israeli point of view, you asked the wrong sector, seculars (for the most part) will not vote for them, they are popular among the right-wing conservative and religious Zionists, and Ben Gvir is a rising star even among the Orthodox (Haredim).
@WeWe-vp6qf Let's not get carried away. Messiah has nothing to do with it.
@user-jt8vj1vm6y I've never heard that name before.
@user-jt8vj1vm6y Ok fine, I don't know. I have no opinion.
@user-jt8vj1vm6y I have no opinion about people I don't know.
@user-jt8vj1vm6yHanah Arendt wasn’t Israeli. Even if an Israeli loved everything she ever said, she wouldn’t “represent” them.
1:45 תותח ! אהבתי את התשובה המקורקעת
Your question of 'why don't you do something to get rid of them' is anti-democratic and inflammatory. Israel is proud to be ruled by the system they chose. Yes, the system definitely has its flaws. There have been left wing governments with small extreme left parties represented. No one created chaos because of it. The way to create change is to vote. To respect the system, even if you do not personally like the outcome, and get out to vote
Protesting against government ministers who are enabling settler violence (which makes both Israelis and Palestinians more unsafe) is not undemocratic.
@Yvanoel01no he wasnt. Read history.
This is a lie, we support them very much, the people of Israel are very strong
Loads of people vote for them, that's how they got to kenesset. So they have lots of support at grass root level
Only 5% voted for them. They are "swing-parties." Bibi used them to gain the support of the Orthodox community--not all of it, since Shas isn't there. They were appointed Cabinet-like ministries for this reason. Your claim is stupendously ignorant.
Enough people voted for them to be a small party (many Israeli arabs voted for Ben Gvir strangly because they thought he will be tough on crime in arab villiages. )
I think they got more popular since October 7th even though they are responsible for many of the problems on October 7th. Still the majority of Israelies will say they are extreemist that don't represent them. I think they are very racist and have done a lot of damage to the Israeli society not to mention internationally. I hope they won't be a oart of a future goverment ever again.
bullshit. in Israel, the party leader with the most votes gets a mandate to assemble a government with any other party leaders - even if they have just reached the threshold number of votes required to be in the parliament. this means Bibi (who got the most votes in the last election) could assemble a government with any fringe lunatic politician - as long as they qualify under this criteria.
Absolutely
They got 11% of the vote combined.
It's reassuring to see that Israelis feel as helpless and demoralised about their political system as the rest of the world does about theirs
"as a Jew yes, but as an Israeli no" this reply is very important, and I hope people understand what that really means
so he basically goes to tel aviv and asks the question to the left?! what's he expecting... go to any of the shetachim or jerusalem and you'll see a very different answer
The left? What "left"?!! I'm from Tel Aviv. NOBODY believes in concessions and repeatedly begging for peace from people who intend to kill us. Not any more. But, supporting Ben Gvir and Smotrich is supporting the far-right extremists, terrorists. 90% of people on the Right, do not support these scumbags.
No. He goes everywhere youre not listening (maybe you dont want to acknowledge the fact that ppl have all kinds of opinions here). One of the women was from Ashkelon - a southern city near Gaza
@@ציפיספרן my point is that many people really approve of both ben gvir and smotrich (even if there are many that don't). and he seems to have gone into an area where that opinion is not represented, and reported it as if it's the only opinion on the matter.
1:14 is that the same person from your video on Israelis: Adam and Eve on 2:26?
אחשלי הלכת למקומות הכי שמאלנים וגם במקומות ימניים שמת את השמאלנים ששם בסרטון
ראשון, פתח תקווה ונתניה זה המקומות הכי שמאלנים? חחח זה שלא כולם חושבים כמוך והבועה שאתה נמצא בה לא אומר שכל המקומות שהוא הלך אליהם שמאלנים
@@Firstname_Surname ראית את החלק השני של התגובה?
@@איתימשולם-נ2ב ראיתי אבאלה אבל אין לזה משמעות כי לא משנה מה יציגו לך אם זה ילך נגד מה שאתה חושב אתה תגדיר את המקום כשמאלני
@@Firstname_Surname ממש לא, יש אנשים(גם בסרטון) שהם ימניים אבל לא מסכימים עם הדרך של סמוטריץ׳ ובן גביר.
That's what Corey does. He's a bit manipulative sometimes to put it politely
Smotrich and Ben Gvir don't represent any of them? how they become deputies then, you bunch of hypocrites?
first learn what coalition means in a democracy
@@ori1676 first learn what extremists acceptance means in a democracy. So hypocites AND extremists, my bad.
@@samramzy544 Netanyahu and his political aliies are far right extremists thats true, but only 50% of the citizens voted to this coalition (enough for Bibi to form a government)
@@samramzy544you guys are hillariously salty, criticizing democracy while you have non in your own countries 😂😂😂😂
@@dogbert52 Indeed. But democracy means responsability. Ppl who can vote and vote for extremists are more to blame than ppl who cant choose. So correction: hypocrites, extremists AND irresponsible. The more i tlalk to you the more i discover who you are. Thanks.
Thank you Corey, a tiny glimmer of hope. Maybe there are more Israelis with some humanity than I had believed.
The rest have no hunanity? Ok dolfi
Sure, being a terrorist lover is super human. The film maker is Canadian, not Israeli, he doesn't seem to understand that "humanity" in this region is viewed as a weakness and an open invite to aggression. There was a lot of humanity shown on Oct 7 by the Arabs.
@@l-uk3xm There has been a lot of terrorism on display by the Israeli people every day since the 7th Oct
@@l-uk3xm How many police and soldiers died on the 7th Oct??
@@thomasjosullivan9179 Estimated 300+
can you please ask Palestinians in the West Bank (Judea and Samaria) whether the PA represents them?
Thats a good idea by the way
75 % said that hamas/sinwar is representing them.
Source : Palestinian authority.
They will chose anyone who will fight against the illegal Israeli land grab, they are desperate
@@mikeel6323 I know, but it would be interesting to hear from them why that's the case.
@@yoavba5706 Why? Probably bc the PA is busy cleaning the shoes of Netanyahu and his cohorts whereas Hamas and Sinwar care about Palestine's right to exist. That's why.
Your videos show the world Israeli's humanism
Ask the religious extremist people and they'll support those two.
Why don't you ask a wide range of people from all sides? That would be much more interesting and helpful.
Because those who support Ben Gvir are in Gaza fighting Hamas, risking their lives to protect these people with BDS (Bibi Derangement Syndrome).
ALSO FOR ME, AS A NIGERIAN 🇳🇬, I LOVE ITHAMAR BEN GVIR & SMOTRICH WATCHING FROM NIGERIA, WITHOUT THEM ISRAEL WILL BE IN SMOKE, YOUR FIRST MISTAKE O ISRAEL IS THAT YOU THINK YOU CAN EVER BE IN TRUE PEACE WITH ISLAM, ... YOU CAN'T IMAGINE THE HORROR WE ARE SUFFERING IN THE HANDS OF THE ISLAMISTS OVER HERE IN NIGERIA
Based Nigerian!!! Are you Igbo by any chance?
@@snakey934Snakeybakey Why do you ask?.
@@snakey934Snakeybakey He is a nut in any event
My love to you from Israel. ❤ We know it is terrible, but always have to hope for better days.
@@EverestOnyekwere Because my favorite teacher (in Israel) lived there for a while, and taught me some of the language. Don't worry, I have nothing against any of the other Nigerian groups.
Smotrich ang BGwir forewa!
Those are my fav politicians!
What's its like in the gutter?
9:27 I could have sworn she is said she works in Hizbollah, I almost fall of my chair.
Same lol
same here, where did that kh come from lol
Lol hasbra not hizballah
Hasbra means explaining in hebrew
lol.. no she said ‘Hasbara’. People think it’s like saying “I work for RT” or TRT or Al Jazeera; but it isn’t. It’s more like ‘I advocate for Israel because the western media gets this thing all wrong’.
Why the transcription is interrupted between 8:20 and 10: 17 ?
There are no religious people and no settlers here - not representitive at all.
How can you tell where people live?
@@bereldovlerner5557 There are captions for each interviewee. Here it's "Petah Tikva", "Rishon LeZion" etc. Corey also notes explicitely when the locations are West Bank settlements.
@@OrlyYahalom But the ratio of about 12% of the votes is still represented in this video.. so it doesn't really matter.. and the religious ultra orthodox and the settlers, are a very small community.
Wow, mom, tell us what you really think! 😂
Ben Gvir is not a racist.
He's just the only one in the Knesset who believed Sinwar when he said he would cvt the hearts out of the Jews.
You should really pay attention to Ben Gvir.
I’m not sure what planet you live on.. he literally holds a photo of a man that committed a terrorist attack on Palestinians as a hero. The whole world views Ben gvir as a racist
ah i see, he's the guy who totally didnt have a picture of a terrorist in his house, and did celebrate a kid dying.
@WeWe-vp6qf
Why would you call anyone but yourself stupid as a Zionist?
That doesn't make any sense dummy.
The world knows your society is racist and so much more asf.
Who do you want to fool?
@@AC-mp7cx yep the guy who is too cowardly to even serve in the idf and has been convicted for charges of terrorism.
Maybe you don't see him a racist cause you're also a racist yourself
Dear Akiva (great name) I really don't think Caitlin Johnstone's quote is antithetical but rather fundamental to understanding the path to peace, and I will explain, but first introductions. I too am a product of two cultures British born and bred but keen to understand and learn about my Palestinian Christian heritage. We could argue that we both should be in a position to better understand the outlook of oppressor and oppressed. I've always admired the culture of the Irish people as connoisseurs of social justice. To have a homeland where you can achieve self-determination and escape persecution is a very reasonable aspiration, and the Palestinians thought the same with the early Jewish settlers, arriving before the conflict started. My own grandfather, a Christian Palestinian in Haifa, took in two Jewish families into the family home. He was horrified by the stories of persecution they had suffered in Europe and was happy to offer them hospitality. Providing hospitality to visitors and new neighbours was not unusual - it was the norm, custom and practise. My mother told me stories of how Palestinian farmers helped to show the early Jewish settlers how to work the land and which crops to plant, european settlers that were sometimes unfamiliar with farming let alone farming in the middle-east. Christians and Jews in the region had lived in peace with the Muslim majority for generations. My grandfather was forced to get his family to safety at the point of a gun in 1947. There but for the grace of god go I. Having listened to historians like Avi Shlaim I know that Arabs and Jews could and have lived in peace with mutual respect. Implicit in Caitlin Johnstone's quote is the understanding that if you remove the violence and subjugation of the oppressor you are well on the road to peace. I would suggest that you can't have reconciliation without justice being seen to be done for the benefit of both sides such that mutual respect can start to be restored. If you feel like replying I for one would be keen to read it.
They do a better job of representing me than anyone else in that parliament.
Well, I hope Israel doesn't cease to exist one day, because of their "contributions" to democracy.
Why are there 2 sets of subtitles? And the smaller font subtitles also have a time-delay. which is confusing.
I bet most people outside of Israel don't understand the political system here. Both Ben Gvir and Smotrich now have power all out of proportion to the number of people who support them. They are from 2 pretty tiny parties and represent relatively few people. Enough people voted for Bibi Netanyahu that he won the Prime Minister-ship - unfortunately IMO. BUT he needed to have more mandates to form a government. So he made deals with pols from smaller, more extremist parties. They have become way too powerful. Extremism is dangerous.
Cory provides subtitles and UA-cam also does when it detects something that’s not English. You can switch off the UA-cam titles by pressing CC.☮️
Corey, you won't succeed in dividing Israel. Your entire channel is centered around division. Just because you delete my comment doesn't make it any less true.
Calm down yo. He's not dividing anyone...he is a cool dude...
when it got filmed ??
Ben gvir and smotrich represent us in a way, mostly regarding to counter terror actions, other than that they don't have anything to offer.
They just show it in childish manner.
Have you ever considered that maybe you're the terrorist? Think about it.
Have you considered that you're the terroist? Everybosy else thinks so, they can't all be wrong.
Interesting perspective 🤔. And a correct one when one thinks about it! People and their ideals are multi-faceted. They just represent one sliver of the Israeli ideology that is being focused on at the moment. Hopefully, soon, we will put this part of our ideology that they have forced everyone to focus on away, and we won't see it again for quite some time!
To say that they are acting in Childish manners is way out there.
Say it as it is pure evil Yes time will tell that they were no good at all for Israel
Whats childish about it?
How many times are you gonna botch the word 'meyatzgim'?
😄 botch it
why you assuming that those who not agree with Ben Gvir and Shmootriz don;'t do anything about it? you ask them "so why you don't do anything about it" like you 100% sure they don't do nothing
Thanks for your great videos.
They definitely represent a huge amount of Israelis except that the media constantly slanders them to downplay this. They got more votes than Gantz in the last election
Even a young, "centrist" girl doesnt see there's two sides to a story...
And casually admitted she is a paid social media propagandist…
centrist my ass, she proceeds to unironically say she works in "Hasbara".
"Both siding" for jih adis :)
Yes, there is a side that dreams of october 7th gleefully and theres the side of the j oose.
I can guess on which side you are
@@dogbert52 zionist indoctrination worked well on you.
Yet their polling says otherwise.
This is truly embarrassing.. why you think they had 12 mandates? I was one of the people that choose them, and i will keep elect them.
המדינה לא היתה אף פעם במצב נוראי כל-כך אבל אתם ממשיכים ללכת עם הראש בקיר. לא הגיע הזמן לנסות משהו אחר?
@@caetanas1783 It was the leftist who got us here, and who held a monopoly on power until now.
Mr. Corey - it is heard in your interview (a lot of Israelis) that they want peace with Palestinians. How? Which peace? as a gift from Israel? where security of Israel is more important than the risk of living with Palestinians? Why - for Israelis - Palestinians come second or third? why does a Jew from New York have more rights in a Palestinian village than the Palestinian himself? How do Israelis who want peace feel bad if Palestinians resist settlers? what do they expect from Palestinians ? to hug them and to give them their land? What peace?
The peace of 7th of october?
The peace of the 1400 years of dhimmi?
The peace that yazidis got?
The peace of the 22 gen o cides of the native jooose in the arnab states?
What was the young journalist’s IG page again?…
Miki dubry
He does do something that is foreign to the Arab world…. He votes!
A more revealing question would have been 'Is it justified killing civilians in Gaza?'. That would have gotten some far more awkward responses. EDIT: my responses are repeatedly being removed.
It's a moral quandary for sure. Every war on land, especially in urban areas, entails the death of uninvolved civilians. You can work hard to minimize that number, or be murderous to maximize that number, but the number exists and will inevitably exist due the nature of war. Since it goes hand in hand with war, the question you propose is not different from "Is the war in Gaza justified?", of which the answer would be a resounding yes. The threat on Israel must be dealt with, and it cannot be allowed to pose danger on the Israeli population anymore. As a bonus, the population of Gaza would be free of the tyrannical rule they've been under.
By wording your question the way that you did, I assume you imply that there's a goal or intent in this war TO kill civilians, as if there's a quota to fill. This is not a war of revenge, there's no eye for an eye. There's no intention to kill civilians, there's no war room where generals point at the civilian Mahmoud Muhammad's home and say his family should perish. The civilians are collateral, unintended casualties, in the war against Hamas. Israel and the IDF in particular operate incredibly to minimize the number of civilian deaths, but as I previously said, a number is inevitable. That number can be pinned on whoever started the war, for he knew that civilians would die if he gave the go-ahead, and that is Hamas.
@@lforlight My responses are being removed but suffice to say that Israel are committing war crimes and it is well documented. I won't bother with a longer reply in case it is deleted again.
@@lforlight I wonder why my responses that are critical of Israel are being removed?
@@mbvbac UA-cam has upped its automatic moderation a few months ago, so it automatically removes comments that mention certain things. It makes commenting on current events very hard.
@@lforlight Yes, UA-cam appears to censor views critical of Israel. Perhaps their lobbying of Meta has worked.
1200 Israeli's butchered Oct 7th. Smotrich and Gvir say never again and there is controversy? Ignorance at its finest.
I have zero respect for Corey. He's always liked to stir the pot, and I was fine with that, but not when the country needs unity more than anything... I want him sent back to Canada.
How this happened?
@@lilam.9261Good! They discuss ethnically cleansing Jews from Judea and Samaria in the parliament on a daily basis, and now that these brave souls talk about removing a foreign Outpost of Islamic colonialism you have your panties in a bunch? Cry harder! Your tears mean nothing to us, we saw on October 7th what makes you cheer.
@@jhingoorpatima237I can answer that. treacherous Israeli politicians ethnically cleansed the indigenous Jewish population from Gaza, and gave it to the islamist as a reward for their killing of Jews. Since then they have deliberately sabotaged to the IDF in every engagement so that they could not do their jobs.
@@lilam.9261what did your darlings do on october 7th?
And who declared war on who repeatedly since 1948?
4:21 Based Mizrahi
But what have they ever really said that indicates huring people? They have a right to wish to throw out the Palestinians (never said anything about Arab Israelis) but i dont even think thats exactly what theyve said. Who wants to keep around their enemies. I dont think what they suggest is practical or feasible ao why say STUPID things, but in theory nothing is wrong with their opinions.
Oh my god. "Who wants to keep around their enemies"? Are you 7 years old? Do you know anything about these people? Ben-Gvir has a background in extreme right party Kach, which supports jewish supremacy, and has now been outlawed as a terrorist organization. He was deemed too extremist to serve in the army. Imagine a jewish organization that is banned IN ISRAEL as a terrorist group! Imagine being too extremist to serve in the ISRAELI army! Smotrich lives in a settlement that is classified internationally as illegal and even denies the very existence of a palestinian people. He was arrested in 2005 for possession of 700 litres of gasolene in an attempt to blow up a highway, to protest disengagement from Gaza, and repeatedly displays extremely homophobic and misogynistic views. These are completely unhinged racist extremists and terrorists, and their power is a perfect proof of the illness in israeli society. It's doomed.
Much of this was predicted by the late professor Zeev Sternhell, a Holocaust survivor and Israel’s foremost authority on fascism, who explained in his 2018 essay titled “In Israel, Growing Fascism and a Racism Akin to Early Nazism” that these fascists “don’t wish to physically harm Palestinians. They only wish to deprive them of their basic human rights, such as self-rule in their own state and freedom from oppression.” Though the appointment of the sadistic Ben Gvir as minister of National Security is about wishing the Palestinians physical harm.
In short, those who continue to doubt that fascism is an impending danger for Israel, are not paying attention to how its coalescing chauvinistic forces are planning on ravaging whatever is left of Israel’s liberal institutions in order to turn the Jewish state into a full-fledged fascist theocracy.
3:08 she didnt say death and terrorists, she said death to terrorists, which is what ben gvir proposes, a death sentence to terrorists, which israel gets a lot of regardless of this war.
Thanks!
It's not a war its a Genocide, its occupation, its apartied .The greatest sin of all is to stand by silent and indifferent.
i understand why not liking these guys my self but...these reasoning i heard....bad...you guys need to up-great your reasoning's, but hey witch country does not...the problem with these two is that they are pro-religious
Asking the spicy questions
"Hamas are an asset"
- Smotrich
Surprisingly he actually said that (~10 years ago and way before October 7 but still....),
"Smotrich is an ass"
-most Israelis
He meant as a formal govt ruling Gaza and not just chaos of different factions
@@ChaosRider726 Don't worry, he already said it also after the 7th October in an interview.
"I am obligated to improve infrastructure & services, and everything to which Arab citizens are entitled by right, not as charity." Smotrich
The question should be ” are you against colonisation ? "
@Mon Amie ask Palestinians: 1) Would you vote for a female president who has the same political beliefs as you do, 2) What origins are black palestinians, 3) What are your thoughts on veganism..
What's the point in all of these questions? 😂
They present me
Cuz ur a 🤡
A Blessed Shavuah Tov To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion 💙 🕊 💙 from Chevron, The Second Holiest City In Israel 🇮🇱.
All My Good Thoughts And Prayers For Our Brave Soldiers And Hostages 💙
They will say they are not in support of Them, but they also vote in support of Right wing. To understand how they feel, they will tell you that Ben Gvir and company are not Racist. This shows their real intentions.
Did you watch the video?
Sounds like the blurred girl at 10:05 underestimated herself...
I'm Iraqi Ex Muslim & I would support Ben Gvir for prime minister.
It's time for Israel to have a Iraqi Jewish leader.
we need a PM with balls not thinking of him but thinking of the country, Ben Gvir has balls but the level is not up to being a PM in my opinion
@@elirosen530
I think a stong leader like Ben Gvir would scare the Palestinians to force them to make a peace deal.
@@Sammy19929On and on it goes...Fear based nonsense, endless revenge
The majority of Israelis support him. Corey is just acting as a propagandist here
@@asynchronicitymay youu experiance an october 7th , repeatedly
Last lady was based
Those interviews are misleading, selective and not representative of the majority of Israelis.
What would you know about it? THe majority of Israelis cant stand smotrich and ben gvir. Only a small minority support them.
There were about 8 interviews and one guy answered yes. 12% of Israeli population voted for bengvir and smutrich party.
Its an exact representation of the voting in Israel.
Really really goid one Corey
You take a side and tried to convince the people that they are racists....
As an Israeli American those 2 are the future and will make sure October 8th 9th and etc. will never ever happen. Open your brain not heart. Big difference
You'd complain about extremists but say two right wing extremists are the future of Israel. Nice analogy
@@seuntimilehin3381 as much as I dislike ben gvir I'm sorry but those extremists are not equivalent. Ben Gvir doesn't go telling his population to go and randomly murder Arab civilians that have done nothing wrong. meanwhile you have Hamas leaders going on stadium encouraging people to murder people and a terrorist fund by the Palestinian authority.
what you're doing is Is like comparing hitler to an average American trump supporter and pretending like they're the same.
And who's going to make sure the umpteenth Nakba and more land grabs by the squatters won't continue to happen. Just go back to the US where you came from, stop squatting in other people's homes.
@WeWe-vp6qf Are you a bot?
Nonsense, Oct 7th happened on their watch and it was directly related to their policies, if they had all the power in Israel they would destroy the country.
Yes, they do
do not put words into people's mouth.
watch the video before commenting
@@ido3211
Their word is just theater play
@@ido3211he's not putting words in anyone's mouth. The video is manipulative because Corey remained in the major coastal cities in did not ask anyone from any other part of the country. Ben Gvir had the support of a significant minority which grew after the heinous behavior by the radical leftist in response to the judicial reforms being proposed, and is now a firm majority after the reality call of October 7th.
@@snakey934Snakeybakey
Also this
Why did Hungary and Poland get sanctioned by the EU for being far right when they don’t let illegal immigrants while the EU is completely fine with those 2 in Israel’s government doing far worse?
Israel is not part of EU that is the first thing(therefore you signed that you accept the authority of European commissions),Second those 2 didn't do anything but talk so I don't know what you mean by "doing far worse"
Totally different things here... First, because they're in the EU and didn't execute the agreements... Nothing to do with being far right at all. And Poland didn't got sanctioned for not taking immigrants, but for their former government manipulating democratic laws regarding the judical powers. But since the new gov stopped the mentioned law, also the EU stopped the sanction process. Secondly, what has Israel to do with the EU? They're not an EU member.
Israel is in the EU? Being right winged is a crime now?
@@worldgreaThat's not true. In Poland, nothing has changed legally, because the previous government still has a president who vetoes laws. The European Union withdrew the sanctions based not on legal facts, but only on the assurances of the new government, which is heavily criticized.
Because Israel is not part of the European Union. Another point, Hungary and Poland were sanctioned not for being far right but for a variety of reasons concerned with things like rule of law.
No one seems to acknowledge Israeli terrorism, even among the illegal settlers and the IDF. Hamas terrorism pales in comparison.
Hamas defence comment.
Corey approved
Will when it comes to Palestinians, most Israelis are like netanyhu and ben gvir.
Netanyahu is on the cusp of being ousted, the moderates left his war cabinet and even the IDF spoke out against his Gaza plan. Israel is a democracy with many Israelis ranging from European to African to Arab.
You are delusional and wrong
You simply know nothing about the conflict
But i will enlighten you
The core of the conflic
Jews want state of their own- Palestinian want no jew state at all
Try solving this puzzle
It's not true
@lordlorian81 It’s not a puzzle it’s a fact. It’s written in the Hamas charter.
Netanyahu represents about half the country, sometimes more and sometimes less. But he did nothing wrong
Just because they dont smot and ben g, doesnt mean they dnt support their policies
You should ask young settlers to have greater representation of views
thing is, the % of positive to negative answers he got are very much in line with the % of people who voted for them. going to extremist Israeli communities and trying to paint all Israeli society that way is not it m8.
@@ghosthunter0950 What I care about is the way of argumentation rather than the number of opinions. Young settlers form the core of his support. One city boy voting for Bibi doesn't say much about who his electorate is.
@@ghosthunter0950 they're not extremist israeli communities, they're normal Israelis. It happens he went to tel aviv where there's a much stronger left wing presence, it's not representative of the entire country.
orthodox people, and those forced to leave Gaza in 2005.
There is no such thing as settlers. The State of Israel belongs to the Jews; they are citizens. Settlers is an invention of Muslims and anti-Semites.
Please ask Palestinians: How did you react to 9/11? How do you feel about that attack?
Ben gvir represent me
You should ask people in other arab states their opinions on Israel Palestine. It would be good to see how Moroccans, Jordanians or Emiratis view it
Corey, your Hebrew is a little rusty my man.