Here we are 4 years later. Same 4 products are pretty much the only ones in that space and form factor. 2024 and still really appreciate the vid. the comparisons were done in a way that the differences/similarities couldnt be more easily noticed. thanks so much
You are welcome and I'm really happy that you appreciate the video! This video, actually, is the one with more views in my whole channel.... Thank you!
My opinion is simple: Mr. Leo Gibson makes the best gear comparison videos. Period. I can't imagine the amount of time a video like this took to be made, from conception, data gathering, recording, editing. Amazing...
The Valeton's ability to change the order of the effect blocks is priceless, especially if you want to play certain genres, like post-rock/shoegaze, where it's almost essential to have a distortion effect after the reverb, or modern/djent metal that favors a noise gate between the boost effect and the amp.
Thank you for pointing this out!!! I have been commenting on a bunch of multi fx pedal reviews on a Hunt to find one that can change the order of the effects!!
Leo you are the most honest reviewer I have ever known. You tell the truth about every unit you review without any favoritism. I respect you Sir. After listening to all the tone the Nux MG300 nailed it. You proved that what I heard was true. I am ordering my NUX MG300
@@lorenzoblum868 It's like asking why the current Iphone review doesn't include the original iphone ^^ the RP is a stone age device. I had one of these. It couldn't compare to more modern devices (say 5 years old), and it sure can't compare to the latest generation budget devices. I mean, at all! Modellers have come a long way. All of the devices in this video blow every other budget device (≤250 bucks) of the last 20 years away, in every aspect. Do yourself a favor and upgrade to a current device. It's 100 bucks well spent.
@@ssm445 I have a Zoom G1 Four that has amazing tones for the price (love the amp sim), I bought to upgrade from a decade old Vox Tonelab ST. I agree that the technology in amp modeling has come a long way, but are there any newer multifx pedals that are even better than the Zoom G1 Four and that competes price wise?
@@socialdef3 I still got the G1Xon, the predecessor to your G1 Four. I think these are great devices for their money, unrivaled in their performance for below €100 before the Nux hit the market. If I would buy a new device in that price range, I would go for the Nux MG300, it just has more features and has probably (even) a bit better sound, but it's not that of a huge step than from the old Digitechs. I wouldn't necessarily upgrade from the Zoom to the Nux though, I mean, you seem happy with the G1. My 2 cents 😉
Only 5k subscribers? You deserve 5M! ;) What an amazing work. Like everybody here, I prefer the MG-300 despite its flaws because for musicians only the quality of the sound matters (and sometimes the price).
I have been suggested to this page because I was looking for an MG300 reviews and comparison. It's a bit hard to get a grip of the accent at first, but I kind of understand the context and now I am getting used to it. Great content, aaaand a new subscriber here. :)
@Leo Gibson, I actually like your accent, to be honest. And the way you speak, you really sound sincere, no pretentions at all. you don't need to improve your English, it's already great. Besides, your content is much more important.
@Leo Gibson. English is not my mother language...nevertheless I am trilingual as many of the people who don't live inside a box. Your English is perfect...ignore people who criticize that. They are just being aholes...seriously, who the hell doesn't understand or minds the accent in the video?? how is that possible?
This is one of the best comparison videos I've ever seen. Concise and thorough with no fat and well anticipating all the questions a potential buyer might have about the differences between units. The comparison chart with all the specs is immensely useful. I struggled a bit with the gentlemen's accent but was able to understand everything. Well done. I'm now a fan.
Leo provides the most comprehensive reviews and comparisons of gear I've ever experienced. His knowledge and understanding of the equipment is far superior to most of the other reviewers. His channel is my first stop for all gear reviews. Thanks, Leo!
@@LeoGibsonGtr It was heartfelt. There are too many so-called reviewers out there who only provide cursory overviews and comparisons. Your thoroughness and attention to detail are rare but greatly appreciated. Keep up the great work!
Luckily I bumped to your video. This is the better explaination without favor any brand. I was searching a shootout GE150 vs MG300 ( the best & easier explanation), yours is superb!! I don't want to spend too much, so I decided to get MG 300 just because of 'Tone'. Hard to get those multi effect with great tone especially cheaps gear. Good luck Leo, stay safe & god bless you always🙏
Thank you very much for sharing this comparison. The truth is that the Nux MG 300 does not have as many amps and effects, but it is perceived that they are of better quality. Greetings from Argentina! 😎👍🏼
Excelente comparativa Leo Gibson, aunque lo veo con sub títulos para leerlo y así entenderlo mejor, tu reseña es tan didáctica que se entiende en cualquier idioma, muchas gracias
Thanks Leo for another excellent review. It must have been a lot of work to compare so many features across the different units. Based on sounds, I think the NUX and the Valeton were the clear winners. I did come across some information about the NUX Expression Pedal, and some potential issues. There are 3 short videos on the "Helmut Shatner" UA-cam channel that potential purchasers should watch first. Maybe Leo can comment based on his use of the Expression Pedal as well regarding those potential issues. Thanks
In the US we do not have Harley Benton. However a new multieffects unit came out last year in the US called the Flamma FX100 and looks exactly like the Harley Benton and uses the exact same software. and has identical specs. We also have the Mooer GE 150 in the US. Great review!
The Nux MG 300 seems to be the best buy for tones, but for me build quality matters, if only they had used a full metal case, and a larger display. For now i will wait and see if they release a better made model improving on this ones weak spots. This is by far the best review on UA-cam, i will subscribe to your channel, thank you for your excellent presentation.
Harley-Benton and Mooer Multi-Effect (and Amp&Cab IR/Tuner/Looper/Rhythm Machine/Audio Controller) does have stomp mode for switching desired expressions On or Off, by applying pressure to the pedal (indicated with "EXP" LED). Pedal can be calibrated for min. and max. positions and pressure. Expressions function can be set separately for each Preset/Program. So many features in a little box for a really good price. An electric guitar, headphones or speakers, optionally a computer, one of this amazing devices and you're all set.
32 bits in ADC/DAC is a pure marketing. The noise caused by quantization with 24 bits is much lower than noise caused by frequency jittering of ordinary (cheap) digital circuits (quality of 24 bits is not reachable) . So that 32 bits literally gives nothing. (and i am not saying yet about ordinary analog noises, those are thousands times bigger than any digitals) By my opinion the leader is Valeton. Great review. Thank you!
OMG i was looking for someone to show me the way, and found it!!! now im on my way to buy that Valeton :D Cheers all thw way from Portugal you the best ;)
Also, I truly respect you doing reviews in a language that is not your own. You're accent is thick (others keep commenting on it) but you're doing a fantastic job! I'd like to see them try to speak a foreign language in front of a camera lol.
Thank you so much...I know that my English should be improved, but I've no time so far to invest in this area...as music and UA-cam videos really require a lot of time! I really appreciate your comprehension and support!!! Thank you!
You're welcome. I think you'll get better as time goes on. And you're perfectly fine now. I'm gonna comment and watch as many videos of yours as I can to show support. See you on the comment threads! Have a great day
Amazing work Leo! This proves that NUX has the best IR capabilities for it's price range! Sounded natural and open to my ears. The other pedals suffered to sound true to an amp to me.
Great comparison review. I got the NUX because of your past review. I can vouch for the realistic tone of the NUX. It seems NUX focused all their efforts on the tone. All These units offer different trade offs depending on personal preference.
hey man thank You so much, here in my country are very hard to get the mooer and the Harley Benton, so I was between the Valenton and the NUX but now I know witch one I should to buy, once again thank you
I think Harley Benton repackaged the Mooer. It's pretty obvious you're getting the same unit. Awesome video with great comparisons via audio and specs. These comparison vids must take forever to create with so many comparisons....but thank you very much. It's only this sort of thing that allows people to make informed choices.
Thanks Leo, a most excellent review - you obviously put a lot of work into that! I agree with your conclusion that the Nu-X MG-300 produced the best sounds and has the nicest software interface, despite coming bottom in your technical comparison. It seems to me that this unit is aimed squarely at the domestic market, where build quality and lots of i/o are less important than quality of sound. Nu-X seem to have made all the right compromises for this market, as you suggested in your dedicated review of the unit. It is also very competitively priced compared to the other units.
I was happy to hear from both of you that the NUX MG300 wins in best sound. Mine is to arrive by mail 2 hours from now. I can’t wait to try out this plastic thing. 😂
Damn dude... You're good!!! U should have at least 1M subs. I bough NUX MG300 becoz of ur prev review, without seeing this comparison video. Luckyly i pick the right one. Despite of less features, NUX has the best tone, especially the screamer! and for me that kills everything else. In realty u only need +/- 10 present, 200 is just too much, LOL. Thanks dude
@@LeoGibsonGtr what version does your ge150? My otg doesnt work at all after updating it to latest version 1.2. It works before i updated it. I tried downgrading it but still doesnt work.
@@kurtkengrava7887 Hi, I have the last version. Mine has never worked...I wrote it also in the comment of the video..I have a Mac. I didn't investigate the issue too much, but I noticed that other guys had the same problems. I'm sorry for that.
Grazie Leo, non capisco nulla di queste macchine con scheda audio integrata. Sto guardando i tuoi video che sono spiegati benissimo, e finalmente capisco anche l'inglese :-) Una grande risorsa il tuo canale. Complimenti. 🍻
Grazie Samuele, sono veramente contento che i video ti piacciano e che li trovi utili: i vostri feedback ed apprezzamenti sono veramente importanti per me!! Grazie!
Great video as always! I really like your comparison videos, they're the most educational and most complete comparison videos in all UA-cam... This specific one really helped me decide which one to buy for my daughter who is a beginner, and that is the Mooer GE-150. The deciding factors were: 1. It has the most number of effects, amps, cabs, so my daughter really can explore more, 2. It has the longest looping time that would really help her play around with different riffs, 3. It is the lightest, most portable and most trendy-looking, that I think would really attract younger users, hehehe, 4. The NuX may sound the closest to the real thing, but I really like the warmer sound of the Mooer GE-150 more... also, I'm not sure if it's just the video, but I noticed that in your effect switching part, the NuX seemed to kill the sound for like half a second when switching to a different effect, which for me, not a good thing in live situations. Of course, these are really not the types of processors that one would use in live gigs, not to mention that it's for my daughter as a beginner's gear, but still, worth mentioning. But then again, I'm not sure if that only happened in this specific video. Thank you for making these content, very, very helpful! Edited: I forgot to mention that you really, really are a great guitar player!
Hi, thank you so much! I'm super happy that you like the video and found it useful!! Thank you also for your compliments related to my guitar playing...it really means a lot to me! Your support and appreciation is very important for me!!!
Thank you, really appreciated!!! Yes, they are both pretty good devices. Maybe you can check out my reviews: >> NUX: ua-cam.com/video/XxgJcqzRyhI/v-deo.html >> Valeton: ua-cam.com/video/18QLA8UP9dY/v-deo.html Thank you!!!
Very nice video 👍. I came by your video by accident and I'm very glad I found it. Very much information and you don't seem biased twords any one product over the other . I'm subscribing and wish you much more luck!!!
De verdad graciass por hacer la comparación justo de las tres pedaleras que tenía en mente por comprar, ahora estoy seguro al 100% de cuál compraré, gracias
Man, your videos are the best. They are always very detailed and precise, not to mention that you play amazing, that's why I follow your channel. Thank you very much for your content and keep going. One question, are the "NUX amp academy" amps the same as the "MG 300" amps?! Thanks a lot!!! Cheers.
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the channel...it really means a lot to me!!! In terms of tone they are very similar, almost identical. I have not done a direct comparison, but they sound very similar. Nevertheless I think that the DSP has been updated, as for instance the latency is much better in the Amp Academy. Thank you once more!
A lot of work went into this video. The Nux did have the best tone, but I would only buy it as an additional pedal. I would get the Mooer if this were going to be my only multi-effects unit. Thanks again for a great review and great playing.
Same IR comparison 12:28 Vox 12:44 Mooer 12:59 HB 13:15 Valeton 13:31 Nux (top boost) 14:48 Marshall 15:00 Mooer 15:12 HB 15:24 Valeton 15:36 Nux 17:28 Marshall + TS 17:48 Mooer 18:08 HB 18:28 Valeton 18:48 Nux Not sure about the Vox, but if you "match EQ" the Marshall simulations to the real amp recording, you get 99% similar sound. The remaining 1% could be different harmonics. I believe the Valeton is the closest to the amp without the matching thing. The Nux has something strange in the gain structure. Some strange muddiness that neither the amp and the Valeton have, which is surprising, considering the technically superior A/D conversion. Finally a tip: you can easily apply the matched EQ curve to the IR file an the import the result in the multi fx!
Great video and review like usual! You really are coming into your own as a fantastic UA-camr! Love your playing and creativity which shows off the pluses and minuses of each modeler. I'm impressed with the NUX (really all of them sound pretty good with usable tones). I'd love to hear the NUX compared with the more expensive modellers like the POD Go, FM3, Ampero, etc. It would be interesting how it fairs against stuff costing many times more than the NUX. God bless and rock on 😎👍🎸
Thank you! Your compliments really mean a lot to me!!! Yes, I'm actually also curios to compare the tone of the NUX against the real deal and the FM3...I think I will do it...thank you for your suggestion!
I'd totally grab the Harley Benton along with one of their pedal boards if they didn't want $80 to ship to the US. And their Reverb store only sells guitars.
Great work as always Leo ! interesting to know that the Harley benton is the same as the Mooer, i was thinking that when you made the technical comparison and then you said it.
Thank you, really appreciated! Yes, also if you take a look at the user manual, the amp models are exactly the same and in the same order...thank you for your message!
*By far the Mooer loses that just disappointed me a lot, and by far NUX wins... The VALETON surprised me for good ... I didn't think it sounded so good ... I really didn't expect it ... It's almost like the NUX MG300 THANKS and LIKE*
Thank you, this is a great compliment!!! It would be great...but I would need a good singer....😊 If you are interest in my music, you may check out this playlist: ua-cam.com/play/PL5d6_Yq6oCrwnnNHTA0KoVX-H6L1Jo134.html I hope you enjoy!
@@LeoGibsonGtr You may try out session vocalists Leo. Maybe you may find someone on www.fiverr.com. I suggest you to go for the song and complete it. Maybe it'll take some time and effort but I think it'll be worth it😃😎👍 Ok, I'll check it out.
Nice work Leo!! Great chanel. I can’t understand because the HB and Mooer doesn’t allow to change the order of effects.... this is a grain of sand. HB is the guy.
Hi, thank you, really appreciated!!! I would just like to add the these units are pretty cheap so they need to save some money in some way. Anyway I agree with you that the possibility to change the order is a pretty useful and basic functionality. Thank you for you message!
@@reinhardmuller9137 You are correct, I was interested in this pedal before it’s release and initially it was supposed to alternatively run on 4 AA batteries however they eliminated that feature before production. Thank you for pointing that out, I will edit my previous comment.
I hope the NUX manufacturer puts a separate pedal position for the Booster pedal (not put in the category of effects pedals given a yellow color mixed with overdrive pedals or distortion pedals this has already happened in the Nux MG100). This booster is indispensable for guitar solos, where for guitar solos you need 2 effect pedals simultaneously overdrive / distortion and a booster pedal to amplify the volume during guitar solos.
Thanks for this Leo. Probably the most comprehensive pedal review that I've ever watched. Just wanted to ask, have you tried using the valeton for a bass guitar? It's my first time purchasing a multi-fx, and thought what a deal it would be if I could use my on my bass as well. Only thing that is stopping me is the problem that you encountered with it and the tone of the NUX, lols! And if is it even worth relying on it bass guitar-wise.
I would buy the Harley Benton, because the sounds can be matched up with EQ and Compressor features. More flexibility, more versilaty and the less price.These are catagories which counts! Even the Valeton is not bad for it's price!
The problem with you is that you could plug into a washing machine and make it sound good. It's really difficult to tell which unit is better as you clearly manage to get the best out of each...
Great review Leo, new subscriber to your channel... keep them coming... do you have a comparison of the more expensive units like the Line 6 and Headrush etc...?
Hi, thank you so much, I'm really happy for your sub!!! I'll post here some links to other videos: > Fractal FM 3 vs Kemper Stage: ua-cam.com/video/KyRmj1sEgdU/v-deo.html > Line 6 Helix vs Headrush: ua-cam.com/video/m3y1e2nxjIE/v-deo.html > GT 1000 vs Line 6 Helix: ua-cam.com/video/dIdf4ms2kxg/v-deo.html > GT 1000 vs FM 3: ua-cam.com/video/vlXo_dW-2jI/v-deo.html > GT 1000 vs HEADRUSH: ua-cam.com/video/JWLUe53aSYY/v-deo.html > FM3 vs Kemper vs Helix vs Pod GO vs NUX vs Valeton vs Mooer vs Soldano: ua-cam.com/video/m1CglhicbJ8/v-deo.html Thank you once more!!!
@@LeoGibsonGtr thx Leo for the quick reply. Now a great idea would be to compare a few expensive ones with the cheaper ones without showing each one is which and do a sound off... See if you can tell which one is expensive and not. :)
The cab ir. has the biggest gamecjager lately. they become so good. & you can choose so many & that’s almost the biggest sound quality Q. than i don’t get why such options does not go in every such unit. in my opinion nux blows all the rest easily due just on that one thing. + the audio quality seems to be better on paper as well. so ... why you need those tons of effects you don’t use . if you could have just few but great ones.
Here we are 4 years later. Same 4 products are pretty much the only ones in that space and form factor. 2024 and still really appreciate the vid. the comparisons were done in a way that the differences/similarities couldnt be more easily noticed. thanks so much
You are welcome and I'm really happy that you appreciate the video! This video, actually, is the one with more views in my whole channel....
Thank you!
My opinion is simple: Mr. Leo Gibson makes the best gear comparison videos. Period. I can't imagine the amount of time a video like this took to be made, from conception, data gathering, recording, editing. Amazing...
Thank you so much, this is such a great compliment that really makes me happy, pushing me to make more and better videos!
Thank you!
The Valeton's ability to change the order of the effect blocks is priceless, especially if you want to play certain genres, like post-rock/shoegaze, where it's almost essential to have a distortion effect after the reverb, or modern/djent metal that favors a noise gate between the boost effect and the amp.
Hi, thank you for sharing!
Thank you for pointing this out!!! I have been commenting on a bunch of multi fx pedal reviews on a Hunt to find one that can change the order of the effects!!
You can do that with the Valeton and NuX models covered in this video. I can't comment on the other units.
.
You just make the BEST and most convenient reviews I could ever find. Just THANK YOU for your great work.
Thank you, I'm really happy that you find the video helpful!!!
Leo you are the most honest reviewer I have ever known. You tell the truth about every unit you review without any favoritism. I respect you Sir. After listening to all the tone the Nux MG300 nailed it. You proved that what I heard was true. I am ordering my NUX MG300
Thank you, this is really a great compliment! Thank you once more!
@@LeoGibsonGtr I wish you included the Digitech RP255 which is the one I use. Did you ever get a chance to try this one?
@@lorenzoblum868
It's like asking why the current Iphone review doesn't include the original iphone ^^
the RP is a stone age device. I had one of these. It couldn't compare to more modern devices (say 5 years old), and it sure can't compare to the latest generation budget devices. I mean, at all! Modellers have come a long way. All of the devices in this video blow every other budget device (≤250 bucks) of the last 20 years away, in every aspect.
Do yourself a favor and upgrade to a current device. It's 100 bucks well spent.
@@ssm445 I have a Zoom G1 Four that has amazing tones for the price (love the amp sim), I bought to upgrade from a decade old Vox Tonelab ST. I agree that the technology in amp modeling has come a long way, but are there any newer multifx pedals that are even better than the Zoom G1 Four and that competes price wise?
@@socialdef3 I still got the G1Xon, the predecessor to your G1 Four. I think these are great devices for their money, unrivaled in their performance for below €100 before the Nux hit the market.
If I would buy a new device in that price range, I would go for the Nux MG300, it just has more features and has probably (even) a bit better sound, but it's not that of a huge step than from the old Digitechs. I wouldn't necessarily upgrade from the Zoom to the Nux though, I mean, you seem happy with the G1. My 2 cents 😉
Only 5k subscribers? You deserve 5M! ;)
What an amazing work.
Like everybody here, I prefer the MG-300 despite its flaws because for musicians only the quality of the sound matters (and sometimes the price).
Thank you, this is really a great compliment!!! Thank you also for sharing your opinion with us!
@@LeoGibsonGtr i.postimg.cc/mk50bPxP/NUX-VALETON.png
NUX MG-300 FAQ
www.vguitarforums.com/smf/index.php?topic=28904.0
@@LeoGibsonGtr Valeton GP-100 FAQ
www.vguitarforums.com/smf/index.php?topic=28681.0
Valeton GP-100 Parameters
drive.google.com/file/d/1Ns4NyUVBweI9aI4Q1WCdwcUDJH7KBoMf/view?usp=sharing
I have been suggested to this page because I was looking for an MG300 reviews and comparison. It's a bit hard to get a grip of the accent at first, but I kind of understand the context and now I am getting used to it. Great content, aaaand a new subscriber here. :)
Hi Jose, thank you so much, your sub is really important for me!!! I will try to improve my english...:)...
@@LeoGibsonGtr i think your english is great
@Leo Gibson, I actually like your accent, to be honest. And the way you speak, you really sound sincere, no pretentions at all. you don't need to improve your English, it's already great. Besides, your content is much more important.
@Leo Gibson. English is not my mother language...nevertheless I am trilingual as many of the people who don't live inside a box. Your English is perfect...ignore people who criticize that. They are just being aholes...seriously, who the hell doesn't understand or minds the accent in the video?? how is that possible?
This is one of the best comparison videos I've ever seen. Concise and thorough with no fat and well anticipating all the questions a potential buyer might have about the differences between units. The comparison chart with all the specs is immensely useful. I struggled a bit with the gentlemen's accent but was able to understand everything. Well done. I'm now a fan.
Thank you, your appreciation is really important for me!!!
Leo provides the most comprehensive reviews and comparisons of gear I've ever experienced. His knowledge and understanding of the equipment is far superior to most of the other reviewers. His channel is my first stop for all gear reviews. Thanks, Leo!
Hi Steve, thank you so much, your comment really push me forward to try to do the best I can!!
Thank you once more!
@@LeoGibsonGtr It was heartfelt. There are too many so-called reviewers out there who only provide cursory overviews and comparisons. Your thoroughness and attention to detail are rare but greatly appreciated. Keep up the great work!
Thank you once more!
Luckily I bumped to your video. This is the better explaination without favor any brand. I was searching a shootout GE150 vs MG300 ( the best & easier explanation), yours is superb!! I don't want to spend too much, so I decided to get MG 300 just because of 'Tone'. Hard to get those multi effect with great tone especially cheaps gear. Good luck Leo, stay safe & god bless you always🙏
Thank you so much! I'm really happy that you like the video and to have been of some help!!! God bless you too.
Just ordered the Nux MG300!
This channel has answered all my questions 😃 thanks Sir.
Hi, thank you for sharing, I'm happy to have been of some help!
hi, can you tell me why did u chose the nux over the others ? im having a difficult time making a choice XD
@@MrAmine5210 much better sound and highest quality converters
Clean > Overdrive > Solo
Real amp 11:08 - 13:48 - 15:48
Mooer 12:44 - 15:00 - 17:48
HB 13:00 - 15:12 - 18:08
Valeton 13:16 - 15:24 - 18:28
Nux 13:32 - 15:36 - 18:48
Only for me.
Thanks. Give this guy some good vintage gear
Your isn’t a friend, you are brother, my friend
Don't say it's biased Leo. Your judgement of tone is perfect and I always agree with your assessment.
Thank you, much appreciated!
Thank you very much for sharing this comparison. The truth is that the Nux MG 300 does not have as many amps and effects, but it is perceived that they are of better quality. Greetings from Argentina! 😎👍🏼
Hi Ruben, you are welcome! Thank you for sharing your opinion...and yes, the amp in the NUX are not so many...you are right....
Excelente comparativa Leo Gibson, aunque lo veo con sub títulos para leerlo y así entenderlo mejor, tu reseña es tan didáctica que se entiende en cualquier idioma, muchas gracias
Thank you so much, I'm super happy that you like the video!!
Significant amount of time and effort has gone into this, it's a brilliant video.
Thank you, I'm super happy that you appreciate the effort behind the video!
Thanks Leo for another excellent review. It must have been a lot of work to compare so many features across the different units. Based on sounds, I think the NUX and the Valeton were the clear winners. I did come across some information about the NUX Expression Pedal, and some potential issues. There are 3 short videos on the "Helmut Shatner" UA-cam channel that potential purchasers should watch first. Maybe Leo can comment based on his use of the Expression Pedal as well regarding those potential issues. Thanks
In the US we do not have Harley Benton. However a new multieffects unit came out last year in the US called the Flamma FX100 and looks exactly like the Harley Benton and uses the exact same software. and has identical specs. We also have the Mooer GE 150 in the US.
Great review!
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the review!
Thank you also for sharing these info!
Out of the 3 which is better? I know that they are clones of the mooer but which of them sounds the best?
@@jesseparrish9198 I think they are just clones of each other so they basically sound the same
@@dbreardon thank you for replying back
The Nux MG 300 seems to be the best buy for tones, but for me build quality matters, if only they had used a full metal case, and a larger display.
For now i will wait and see if they release a better made model improving on this ones weak spots.
This is by far the best review on UA-cam, i will subscribe to your channel, thank you for your excellent presentation.
Thank you Allan, for the compliments and for sharing your opinion! Your sub really means a lot to me!
@@LeoGibsonGtrthis review really details. thankyou. which one will you personally choose?
Harley-Benton and Mooer Multi-Effect (and Amp&Cab IR/Tuner/Looper/Rhythm Machine/Audio Controller) does have stomp mode for switching desired expressions On or Off, by applying pressure to the pedal (indicated with "EXP" LED). Pedal can be calibrated for min. and max. positions and pressure. Expressions function can be set separately for each Preset/Program. So many features in a little box for a really good price. An electric guitar, headphones or speakers, optionally a computer, one of this amazing devices and you're all set.
Hi, thank you for sharing!!!
Thanks for all the detailed work! The veridict is that we are highly spoiled and can get so much for so cheap these days 😁
You are welcome and thank you so much for sharing your findings!!
thanks for this man.i was actuallyin thorn between nux and mooer thanks to your comparison i decided to go to nux because it fits my taste, tone wise
You are welcome and I'm really happy to have been of some help!
you deserve more subscribers. Your reviews are very accurate and straight to the point
Thank you Fabio, your appreciation is really important for me!
32 bits in ADC/DAC is a pure marketing.
The noise caused by quantization with 24 bits is much lower than noise caused by frequency jittering of ordinary (cheap) digital circuits (quality of 24 bits is not reachable) . So that 32 bits literally gives nothing. (and i am not saying yet about ordinary analog noises, those are thousands times bigger than any digitals)
By my opinion the leader is Valeton.
Great review. Thank you!
You are welcome!
Thank you for sharing your opinion and experience!
OMG i was looking for someone to show me the way, and found it!!! now im on my way to buy that Valeton :D Cheers all thw way from Portugal you the best ;)
Thank you sooo much, I'm really happy that you appreciate the video!!!
This guy is putting in work. I gotta subscribe, purely off his ethic. I hope you go far sir. Fantastic review
Thank you, your subscription really means a lot to me....much appreciated!!!
Also, I truly respect you doing reviews in a language that is not your own. You're accent is thick (others keep commenting on it) but you're doing a fantastic job! I'd like to see them try to speak a foreign language in front of a camera lol.
Thank you so much...I know that my English should be improved, but I've no time so far to invest in this area...as music and UA-cam videos really require a lot of time! I really appreciate your comprehension and support!!!
Thank you!
You're welcome. I think you'll get better as time goes on. And you're perfectly fine now. I'm gonna comment and watch as many videos of yours as I can to show support. See you on the comment threads! Have a great day
Thank you once more!!!
Amazing work Leo! This proves that NUX has the best IR capabilities for it's price range! Sounded natural and open to my ears. The other pedals suffered to sound true to an amp to me.
Thank you, I'm happy to have been of some help!
Thank you also for sharing your opinion!
This video has rally help me a lot. Thanks for talking the time of detailing each aspect!
Hi, thank you! I'm really happy to have been of some help!!!!
In my opinion, Nux so good to my ears. But, The Nux have a material quality that is not strong enough. So i choose The Valeton for my Opinion ❤️.
Ok, thank you for sharing!
Thank you very much once again Leo! The amount of time and effort you put into your videos are truly appreciated.👍
You are welcome! I'm really pleased that you appreciate the effort I put in this video...thank you!!!
Thanks for all of your videos!
I'm binge watching them right now!
Very well made videos!
Thank you, really appreciated!!
@@LeoGibsonGtr No thank YOU!
I got a YT channel, I know all the effort you put in your videos.
That's a hella lot of work you did!
The NuX sounds so good. It would be interesting to hear how this compares to the Ampero line.
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion... good point!
Excellent review Leo. Comparison sorted it for me. Nice playing too!
Thank you!!! I'm really happy that you like it!
You really take passion in making videos and music. Mad respect for you Leo! Keep making helpful videos. Much love from the Philippines!
Thank you Kevin, your message and appreciation is really important for me!!! You give me the energy to go on...thank you!
Great comparison review. I got the NUX because of your past review. I can vouch for the realistic tone of the NUX. It seems NUX focused all their efforts on the tone. All These units offer different trade offs depending on personal preference.
Hi, yes, I do agree. Thank you for letting me know and for sharing your opinion!
hey man thank You so much, here in my country are very hard to get the mooer and the Harley Benton, so I was between the Valenton and the NUX but now I know witch one I should to buy, once again thank you
You are welcome, I'm happy to have been of some help!
I think Harley Benton repackaged the Mooer. It's pretty obvious you're getting the same unit. Awesome video with great comparisons via audio and specs. These comparison vids must take forever to create with so many comparisons....but thank you very much. It's only this sort of thing that allows people to make informed choices.
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the video! Yes, HB = Mooer...👍
Thanks Leo, a most excellent review - you obviously put a lot of work into that! I agree with your conclusion that the Nu-X MG-300 produced the best sounds and has the nicest software interface, despite coming bottom in your technical comparison. It seems to me that this unit is aimed squarely at the domestic market, where build quality and lots of i/o are less important than quality of sound. Nu-X seem to have made all the right compromises for this market, as you suggested in your dedicated review of the unit. It is also very competitively priced compared to the other units.
Hi Richard, I do agree you! Thank you for your message and the compliments that make me happy!
I was happy to hear from both of you that the NUX MG300 wins in best sound. Mine is to arrive by mail 2 hours from now. I can’t wait to try out this plastic thing. 😂
What an excellent, in depth review 👏👍
But I still can't decide!!
Thank you, really appreciated!!!
Great comparison!!! Nux has the similar algorithm of amp modeling( nux tsac hd) as fractal. That’s why sound is so realistic... I will buy one ...
Thank you, really appreciated! Yes, actually I'm doing a video about it...also comparing the MG300 with the FM3...stay tuned 😊
Thanks Leo, this is super helpful. Helped me make the best decision. Fewer features, better tone for me!
Thank you John, I'm happy that you have found the video useful!!
Damn dude... You're good!!! U should have at least 1M subs. I bough NUX MG300 becoz of ur prev review, without seeing this comparison video. Luckyly i pick the right one. Despite of less features, NUX has the best tone, especially the screamer! and for me that kills everything else. In realty u only need +/- 10 present, 200 is just too much, LOL. Thanks dude
Thank you, great compliments, that makes me happy!!! I'm also happy to have been of some help!!!
Never stop doing videos man, maybe yrs from now. You have millions of subsribers, u deserve that for this kind of reviews
Thank you, this is really a great compliment that makes me happy and gives me new enrgy!!! Thank you once more!
@@LeoGibsonGtr yup, planning to buy ge150 next week because of this video 🤘🤘
Thank you for letting me know!
@@LeoGibsonGtr what version does your ge150? My otg doesnt work at all after updating it to latest version 1.2. It works before i updated it. I tried downgrading it but still doesnt work.
@@kurtkengrava7887 Hi, I have the last version. Mine has never worked...I wrote it also in the comment of the video..I have a Mac. I didn't investigate the issue too much, but I noticed that other guys had the same problems. I'm sorry for that.
Grazie Leo, non capisco nulla di queste macchine con scheda audio integrata. Sto guardando i tuoi video che sono spiegati benissimo, e finalmente capisco anche l'inglese :-) Una grande risorsa il tuo canale. Complimenti. 🍻
Grazie Samuele, sono veramente contento che i video ti piacciano e che li trovi utili: i vostri feedback ed apprezzamenti sono veramente importanti per me!!
Grazie!
Great review. Got more than what I expected! Very nice, dude
Thank you, I'm happy to have been of some help!!!
Thank you also for sharing: your feedback is super important for me!
Thank you Leo! Great, comprehensive review!
Thank you, your appreciation is really important for me!
Wow excellent job in all aspects. You are going to be the new go to guy for gear reviews! Thanks!
Hi Samuel, thank you so much, you appreciation is really important for me!
I really appreciate your comparison of these four units. I do however wish that you had demoed the drum machine portion of these units.
Hi, thank you both for the compliments and for the suggestion! Maybe in a future video...
Great video as always! I really like your comparison videos, they're the most educational and most complete comparison videos in all UA-cam... This specific one really helped me decide which one to buy for my daughter who is a beginner, and that is the Mooer GE-150. The deciding factors were: 1. It has the most number of effects, amps, cabs, so my daughter really can explore more, 2. It has the longest looping time that would really help her play around with different riffs, 3. It is the lightest, most portable and most trendy-looking, that I think would really attract younger users, hehehe, 4. The NuX may sound the closest to the real thing, but I really like the warmer sound of the Mooer GE-150 more... also, I'm not sure if it's just the video, but I noticed that in your effect switching part, the NuX seemed to kill the sound for like half a second when switching to a different effect, which for me, not a good thing in live situations. Of course, these are really not the types of processors that one would use in live gigs, not to mention that it's for my daughter as a beginner's gear, but still, worth mentioning. But then again, I'm not sure if that only happened in this specific video. Thank you for making these content, very, very helpful! Edited: I forgot to mention that you really, really are a great guitar player!
Hi, thank you so much! I'm super happy that you like the video and found it useful!! Thank you also for your compliments related to my guitar playing...it really means a lot to me! Your support and appreciation is very important for me!!!
This demo song is amazing. Nice comparison, I did not get a conclusion to which one I would pick, they are so the same good quality.
Thank you Fernando...when you like my music .... I'm happy!!!!
Man! Congratulations! I'm impressed with your organization on every step! Bless ya!
Thank you Lucas, I'm super happy that you like the video!!!
Great review, hard to decide between Valeton and Nux
Thank you, really appreciated!!! Yes, they are both pretty good devices. Maybe you can check out my reviews:
>> NUX: ua-cam.com/video/XxgJcqzRyhI/v-deo.html
>> Valeton: ua-cam.com/video/18QLA8UP9dY/v-deo.html
Thank you!!!
Very nice video 👍. I came by your video by accident and I'm very glad I found it. Very much information and you don't seem biased twords any one product over the other . I'm subscribing and wish you much more luck!!!
Thank you Aaron, your sub really means a lot!!!
De verdad graciass por hacer la comparación justo de las tres pedaleras que tenía en mente por comprar, ahora estoy seguro al 100% de cuál compraré, gracias
You are welcome, and I'm super happy to have been of some help!!!
Cuál?
The best comparison I have ever seen and hurt. This is a great service. Thank you.
Hi Rick, thank you so much! I'm really happy you like the video and find it useful!!!
Great comparison, thank you. Neither one of this modelers had slight breakup that real VOX have.
You are welcome, thank you for sharing your opinion!
Lol, DNAfx and GE-150 have exactly the same specs.
Awesome comparisons btw.
Amp and overdrive pedal names also look exactly the same. :)
Yes, the Harley Benton is a rebranded Mooer GE 150!
Thank you for your messages!
Thanks.
Although i am a beginner in electric guitar, i can say this is the most helpful review for the mentioned models.
Thank you so much, I’m super happy that you like the video!!!
Man, your videos are the best. They are always very detailed and precise, not to mention that you play amazing, that's why I follow your channel. Thank you very much for your content and keep going. One question, are the "NUX amp academy" amps the same as the "MG 300" amps?! Thanks a lot!!! Cheers.
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you like the channel...it really means a lot to me!!!
In terms of tone they are very similar, almost identical. I have not done a direct comparison, but they sound very similar. Nevertheless I think that the DSP has been updated, as for instance the latency is much better in the Amp Academy.
Thank you once more!
@@LeoGibsonGtr Thanks, man. What an interesting time to be a guitarist. Cheers!!!
You are welcome and yes....I do agree with you!
Wow, what a detailed video. Very helpful.
Thank you so much, I'm happy that you found the video useful!!!
Thank you for your hard work on this stuff. I shared your video and got a lot of positive and eye opening response.
You are welcome! Thank you so much for sharing, your support, appreciation and feebdack is really important for me!
A lot of work went into this video. The Nux did have the best tone, but I would only buy it as an additional pedal. I would get the Mooer if this were going to be my only multi-effects unit. Thanks again for a great review and great playing.
Thank you, really appreciated! Thank you also for sharing your opinion with us!!!
Liked the review man.
Also that tele is beautiful!
Thank you, really appreciated!!! I do agree...this Tele is amazing!
The stomp mode in the valeton gp 100 for live gigs as i let you activate up to three effects an once.
Hi, thank you for your message!
Same IR comparison
12:28 Vox
12:44 Mooer
12:59 HB
13:15 Valeton
13:31 Nux (top boost)
14:48 Marshall
15:00 Mooer
15:12 HB
15:24 Valeton
15:36 Nux
17:28 Marshall + TS
17:48 Mooer
18:08 HB
18:28 Valeton
18:48 Nux
Not sure about the Vox, but if you "match EQ" the Marshall simulations to the real amp recording, you get 99% similar sound. The remaining 1% could be different harmonics.
I believe the Valeton is the closest to the amp without the matching thing.
The Nux has something strange in the gain structure. Some strange muddiness that neither the amp and the Valeton have, which is surprising, considering the technically superior A/D conversion.
Finally a tip: you can easily apply the matched EQ curve to the IR file an the import the result in the multi fx!
Thank you for sharing!
Very Helpful! Great playing and song too!
Thank you, rally appreciated!!!!
Great video and review like usual! You really are coming into your own as a fantastic UA-camr! Love your playing and creativity which shows off the pluses and minuses of each modeler. I'm impressed with the NUX (really all of them sound pretty good with usable tones). I'd love to hear the NUX compared with the more expensive modellers like the POD Go, FM3, Ampero, etc. It would be interesting how it fairs against stuff costing many times more than the NUX. God bless and rock on 😎👍🎸
Thank you! Your compliments really mean a lot to me!!! Yes, I'm actually also curios to compare the tone of the NUX against the real deal and the FM3...I think I will do it...thank you for your suggestion!
Man, you've done such an amazing job! Thank you so much
You are welcome and I'm really happy that you like the video!!!!
I'd totally grab the Harley Benton along with one of their pedal boards if they didn't want $80 to ship to the US. And their Reverb store only sells guitars.
Hi, thank you for sharing...I didn't know that the posting price was so high...and that there was no availability in USA...interesting info, thanks!
Broo i was just lookin for this comparison
Thank you, I'm happy to have been of some help!
What a quality, Leo! Thanks for this very usefull videos, i love it, where are you from?
Thank you, really appreciated!!! I've promised that when I will reach 10k subs...if ever...I will reveal my nationality...😊
Thank you once more!!!
Sounds Italian to me😎
Tone wise the NUX JCM800 is the winner by a mile! Amazing value for money!
Hi, I also love the Nux model of the JCM 800….
thank you for your message!
Great work as always Leo ! interesting to know that the Harley benton is the same as the Mooer, i was thinking that when you made the technical comparison and then you said it.
Thank you, really appreciated! Yes, also if you take a look at the user manual, the amp models are exactly the same and in the same order...thank you for your message!
Great job! Thanks for posting
You are welcome!!! Thank you for your message!
*By far the Mooer loses that just disappointed me a lot, and by far NUX wins... The VALETON surprised me for good ... I didn't think it sounded so good ... I really didn't expect it ... It's almost like the NUX MG300 THANKS and LIKE*
Thank you, really appreciated! Thank you also for sharing your findings!
Amazing song👍 It'll sure hit the charts if completed properly😎
Thank you, this is a great compliment!!! It would be great...but I would need a good singer....😊
If you are interest in my music, you may check out this playlist: ua-cam.com/play/PL5d6_Yq6oCrwnnNHTA0KoVX-H6L1Jo134.html
I hope you enjoy!
@@LeoGibsonGtr You may try out session vocalists Leo. Maybe you may find someone on www.fiverr.com. I suggest you to go for the song and complete it. Maybe it'll take some time and effort but I think it'll be worth it😃😎👍 Ok, I'll check it out.
I do agree .... it's a possibility...thanks
Nice work Leo!! Great chanel. I can’t understand because the HB and Mooer doesn’t allow to change the order of effects.... this is a grain of sand.
HB is the guy.
Hi, thank you, really appreciated!!! I would just like to add the these units are pretty cheap so they need to save some money in some way. Anyway I agree with you that the possibility to change the order is a pretty useful and basic functionality.
Thank you for you message!
Great and explicative video, thank you Leo
You are welcome Daniel!!! I'm happy that you like it!!!
Thx Leo, your work is 5***** ! 🙏🏻😉
Thank you so much!! I'm super happy that you like the video!!!
I use it with headphones. It also sounds the best imo, despite all its limitations.
That is not true, the MG-300 does not run on batteries.
@@reinhardmuller9137 You are correct, I was interested in this pedal before it’s release and initially it was supposed to alternatively run on 4 AA batteries however they eliminated that feature before production. Thank you for pointing that out, I will edit my previous comment.
I hope the NUX manufacturer puts a separate pedal position for the Booster pedal (not put in the category of effects pedals given a yellow color mixed with overdrive pedals or distortion pedals this has already happened in the Nux MG100). This booster is indispensable for guitar solos, where for guitar solos you need 2 effect pedals simultaneously overdrive / distortion and a booster pedal to amplify the volume during guitar solos.
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion. It would be for sure a nice addition. Thank you for message!
As a musician you would always choose the one that gives you the best sound, I would choose the nux
Hi Luis, thank you for sharing your opinion!!!
Can you tell me why you choose nux?what the advantage for this pedal?sorry for my bad english..
Excellent, high quality, performance and review!
Thank you, really appreciated!!
Oh man I need that nux mg300, love your vids btw
Thank you, really appreciated!!!
Really good work. Amazing. Thank you .
You are welcome, I'm happy that you like the video!!!
Vox: 11:10
Mooer: 11:25
Harlery: 11:40
Valeton: 11:55
Nux : 12:13
JCM800 + TS: 15:49
Mooer + TS: 16:09
Harlery + TS: 16:29
Valeton +TS: 16:48
Nux + TS: 17:09
Thanks
Great video. Really helpful! Thanks!!
Thank you so much, I'm really happy that you find the video helpful!!!!
Thanks for this Leo. Probably the most comprehensive pedal review that I've ever watched. Just wanted to ask, have you tried using the valeton for a bass guitar? It's my first time purchasing a multi-fx, and thought what a deal it would be if I could use my on my bass as well. Only thing that is stopping me is the problem that you encountered with it and the tone of the NUX, lols! And if is it even worth relying on it bass guitar-wise.
I would buy the Harley Benton, because the sounds can be matched up with EQ and Compressor features. More flexibility, more versilaty and the less price.These are catagories which counts! Even the Valeton is not bad for it's price!
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion.
Great video, Leo! Thanks!
You are welcome!!!
Yes! The NUx MG300. The Tones! I love it.
Hi, thank you for sharing your opinion!
The problem with you is that you could plug into a washing machine and make it sound good. It's really difficult to tell which unit is better as you clearly manage to get the best out of each...
Thank you Enrico!
You are a great humain and player. Cheers from Chile 🇨🇱
Thank you Francisco, this is a great compliment that makes me happy!!!
For me the NuX is the winner.
Better sound quality and more slots for 3rd party IRs + the low price.
Hi Jonny, thank you for sharing you opinion!!!
Keep up the amazing work!
Thank you, your feedbacks are rally important for me!!! I'll try to do my best!
in a general, all jcm800 simulations sounds bad but the nux sound best.
Seems to be the best amp modeling in this price range
Hi Marcus, thank you for sharing your opinion!!!
Great review Leo, new subscriber to your channel... keep them coming... do you have a comparison of the more expensive units like the Line 6 and Headrush etc...?
Hi, thank you so much, I'm really happy for your sub!!!
I'll post here some links to other videos:
> Fractal FM 3 vs Kemper Stage: ua-cam.com/video/KyRmj1sEgdU/v-deo.html
> Line 6 Helix vs Headrush: ua-cam.com/video/m3y1e2nxjIE/v-deo.html
> GT 1000 vs Line 6 Helix: ua-cam.com/video/dIdf4ms2kxg/v-deo.html
> GT 1000 vs FM 3: ua-cam.com/video/vlXo_dW-2jI/v-deo.html
> GT 1000 vs HEADRUSH: ua-cam.com/video/JWLUe53aSYY/v-deo.html
> FM3 vs Kemper vs Helix vs Pod GO vs NUX vs Valeton vs Mooer vs Soldano: ua-cam.com/video/m1CglhicbJ8/v-deo.html
Thank you once more!!!
@@LeoGibsonGtr thx Leo for the quick reply. Now a great idea would be to compare a few expensive ones with the cheaper ones without showing each one is which and do a sound off... See if you can tell which one is expensive and not. :)
Yes, cool idea!!!
Dear Leo, thanks!
You are welcome!!!! Thank you for your message!
The cab ir. has the biggest gamecjager lately. they become so good. & you can choose so many & that’s almost the biggest sound quality Q.
than i don’t get why such options does not go in every such unit. in my opinion nux blows all the rest easily due just on that one thing.
+ the audio quality seems to be better on paper as well. so ... why you need those tons of effects you don’t use .
if you could have just few but great ones.
Hi Janis, thank you for sharing your opinion!
Fantastic video. Good work.
Thank you, really appreciated!