Jazz drummer reacts: Tool-Rosetta Stoned (Danny Carey Clinic)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 сер 2019
- Yes, I know there are better versions but I already recorded this one so yea....
Thank you for clicking!
teespring.com/stores/garrett-... / garrettmillerdrums
/ garrettmdrums
/ garrettmillerdrums
it was a poly-swiss triplet flamadama tap diddle ding dong double roll.
With a parabolic, step down, multi-tronic inversion.
Oh, see I totally missed the ding dong!
garrettmillerdrums we all miss the ding dong sometimes
S S wtf
@S S Did this use to say dong? I feel like it used to say dong...🤣
When you realize your looking at a screen, of a man watching a screen, filmed by a man watching a screen.
F**k! I read your comment and immediately close youtube and start to rethink my life! What the hell we are doing!?
With another screen in the background
Did your top stop spinning? o_o
@@TheGuyATX seriously great movie reference.
I showed this to my friend through iphone video-calling.
The "what is happening " moment kind of sums up listening to Danny Carey
You know when I went to the tool concert I was a complete maynard fangirl (I still am) but when I left I knew Danny was the MASTER OF THE CEREMONY!
Yvkes he always is. I’ve been twice now and his drums just dominate the music. Live, he also throws in amazing improv parts with the rest of the band. Everyone’s eyes just fixated on Danny. He’s mesmerizing.
Couldn't have said it better. He keeps the 9 planets spinning.
"What the hell are you doing?!"
Yeah I feel like that's most of us when trying to analyse Danny Carey..
Beat me to it.
If Neil Peart is The Professor, Danney Carey is The Sorcerer.
Man, do more Tool please. Lateralus please. Danny Carey in my opinion, is the most creative drummer in metal music.
Fixed for you: Man, do more Tool please. Lateralus please. Danny Carey in my opinion, is the most creative drummer in music.
@@alexsurles Saved his ass, man.
Give me a schism or right in two please I say
@jonny j nope, you're the annoying one champ.
What about Sean Reinart?
I'm actually glad to hear that you need more context. I've always thought that what makes Danny such a great drummer is that he's tasteful and complementary; all of the crazy/amazing shit he's doing is in service to the song rather than just being showy and superfluous (on top of it all just being really creative and sounding great). Hope to see you react to more Danny Carey. Would love to hear what you think of "Pneuma."
itypewithmykneecaps1 I agree. Danny is a supporting member. Context is needed to appreciate what Danny chooses to play.
DC is like Neil Pert merged with John Bonham. There is a ton of passion and although it is quite technical, it is written for the song and very powerful and progressive.
Throw in some Bill Bruford too
That is a really good way to break him down, actually. Neil's precision and virtuosity combined with John's power and impeccable sense of groove.
It takes longer to explain what he's doing than it takes for him to switch into a new time signature. Danny is just too good.
The great development of mobile phone camera's has brought to us millions shity live videos.
It's great isnt it
Drok 😄
Drummers fascinate me. You have to play all different kinds of patterns with all different kinds of body parts, keep the tempo, count, and some drummers sing backup. Phew
I used to teach drums - and I'd tell my students that if they pursued the craft and started playing with other musicians they'd soon start hearing jokes about how drummers aren't _actually_ musicians. I'd assure them that if they became proficient at drumming that they were actually the _only_ musician in the band - after all, the drums are not really as a melodic an instrument as say the guitar or piano or voice are - so, it takes a _true_ musician to take a not so melodic instrument and create music on it.
Brann Dailor from Mastodon fits the bill too.
And STILL some people think it’s the easiest part of the band, ridiculous.
@@cseguin Very true and well said! But i find this more important...Drummers are the foundation of the song. Even in electronical music you hear a beat. The beat or drumpart accentuates the rythm details the next layer of the song...not all genres are dependent on this. Soundscapes for example. But live, you are the guide and the control and the metronome. If you fuck-up....everything falls. The biggest pressure of the band is on the drummer. Your band is as good as your drummer.
@@mikevandriel Yep - I've also noticed over the years of watching many a band play live that the drummer is the quintessential instrument on stage. You can take a mediocre guitarist, bassist and vocalist and add a very competent drummer and produce a respectable band. But, if you take a virtuoso guitarist, bassist and vocalist and add an incompetent drummer the resulting band would probably be trash.
12:10 garrettmiller.exe has stopped working
He’s a Beast! Danny is among the greatest rock drummers ever!
Tool in a nutshell “tease a feal , Give ya 6 then next bar cut it back to 5” I love that sort of jamming.
12:16 when you realize that dany has actually 2 brains
🤣
@deadend their are always exceptions to the rule, even in nature.
I’ve been saying that forever.
hes gotta keep up with his eight arms
I feel like The Grudge, Lateralus or Fear Inoculum by Tool would be good examples too.
Its that smile you see on peoples faces that know or appreciate music, when Carey does a little magic, that means so so much...
Try to watch John Kew cover of Rosetta Stone for much clearer view/perspective. It wil blow your mind. Danny Carey is the beast!
Yessss glad someone else knows of JohnKew’s Danny Carey covers ! His videos are what really inspired me to get on the drum set
I had to stop briefly at 2:05. Dude you are so correct! It took me months to really perfect that and now that I haven't played in a couple years, I might not be able to play it now. I remember getting so frustrated at thinking this sounds so easy so why tf is it so hard for me to get this. You got an immediate sub from that alone.
At some point, everyone who watches Danny play is reduced to a mere spectator.
What is a performer without a spectator? An amazing performance is nothing without a spectator to amaze
@FresnoCAPunkrockMetalHardcore OldFigGang you're a jackass
@FresnoCAPunkrockMetalHardcore OldFigGang You’re a bitch 😂
I have to say, this is more than just a reaction. The breakdown of what is happening is very interesting. Makes you appreciate what you're listening to.
The part where you said something about getting used to a beat and then Carey changes it really is a perfect way to describe his drumming in Tool.
There's a guy called johnkew thats done some mad covers. He's done Rosetta stoned as well. Give it a listen!
His breakdown of rosetta stoned is the best I've seen. Very worth checking out
@Garrettmillerdrums
Check out "Chocolate Chip Trip" on their new album
YES
Make sure to take a shit first
Hell yeah dude!
It's awesome seeing that even a professional can be dumbfounded at points with just how crazy complex Danny Carey is. :)
Check out Ticks and Leeches. That's the first song I thought you'd enjoy
MooseyFate the intro alone is too good👌🏼
Oh man, you could spend months listening to Rosetta Stoned, and still pick up nuances and such... it's one of my favorite TOOL songs.
Danny Carey live drum cam of Triad is awesome...sound is good until guitar kicks in but still audible and very enjoyable..the 8:47 video is the best one
I just found your videos and boy do I love them. I like how you break things down as I myself am not a drummer. Keep rocking \m/
Danny's so f*cking rad
I love your breakdown of this was really fun to watch you dig into it.
Thank you! That was the best description of Danny Carey's playing style I have heard yet.
Also wanted to say Danny has included vocabulary from classical Indian playing as well. He took some lessons from Aloke Dutta. He also does the African beats.
I second this. Worth a deeper look. Super cool that Garrett went straight to Afro-Cuban though.
@@lukester5280 I'm not sure though because I saw Danny say that he's not as much into the Latin grooves...
'\/😕\/' Maybe he has since changed that...
Danny is probably the best source for what he considers inspiration, but I appreciate the kneejerk comparison based on limb independence. There are a lot of similarities and I hadn't really thought of it that way.
I think my favorite Tool piece, for purely drums, is off their new album, a track called Chocolate Chip Trip. It sounds like its almost entirely drums, with an electronic piece acting almost like a metronome.
did you hear it remixed with willy wonka boat trip? Trully psychodelic masterpiece
Watch the live version its entirely danny playing it
The drum solo is of course fantastic, but that synthesizer line is SO annoying. I only listened to it twice.
Christopher NE NOW BA DING!!!!
Danny Carey has a by far the best independence I've ever heard. Granted, I haven't heard every drummer out there, he just has an inate ability to separate one limb from the other.
Dude can play 4 poly rhythms at the same time
Minnemann probably has the best Independence. At least the best i know of
Watch Pnuema drum cam
i have been watching for a few days straight now my man....and every day i look you gain 2k subs. i have literally seen from 5.6k to 7.7k to 9.4k and now to 11.7k - - - you are killing it please keep it up brother
Pretty sure you could make a whole channel breaking down ole Danny boy
that "swiss tripplet" was playing the Tom (right hand) and the high hat/snare (left hand). he is a talented drummer for sure. so complex
Love your channel dude... it's very interesting to hear these kind of crazyness themes explained... keep it up ;)
i had some unique seats for their show in LA for this tour and my girlfriend, who enjoys the music, but isnt huge into the band as a whole said to me after the show "the drummer is incredible. i was just watching him most of the show and it was just exhausting. how does he even do any of that so consistently"
i think she finally understood why hes talked about so much.
Danny Carey has been my favorite drummer since i first heard undertow in the 90s. I also love his signature sticks! They're almost like cheating. They have a taper right where u hold them and they're weighted so nice. I feel like his stick alone have improved my playing immensely
100% Agreed !!
Man. More Tool, please. The world needs it.
You should definitely react to Gavin Harrison from Porcupine Tree playing Anesthetize.
YESSSS!!
better yet Gavin playing in the 3 drummer King Crimson live videos..
5:03 dont just call it an open roll. Listen to it carefully. From 32 to 16 to 8 and so on..
You can see on his face that's the moment he gets it
How could you not get into TOOL? These guys are the tightest musicians around.
I know, other drummers scoff about it, I just was listening to other stuff all these years and didn't have a sit down with Tool. I did listen to all of Fear Inoculum and am interested in their other albums. Danny's my kind of drummer.
@@garrettmillerdrums Danny is right their with Pert and Bonham.
@@garrettmillerdrums check out Vic Firths artist spotlight on Danny.
ua-cam.com/video/2t1lt99CWnA/v-deo.html
I expected a bigger comment from the "big open roll". Not just any roll, hope you heard what he did. If not listen again and 🤯
Drummers dont get the recognition they deserve. When I listen to music, I'll listen to songs a few time over so I can seperate each instrument to hear whats they are doing. I watched the Terry Bozzio guitar center drum off from 2011. Never realized how good he is. The guys playing also rip. Good job on your channel. Definitely subscribing
Describing Danny Carey's drumming is like trying to describe color to a person who was born blind. But, you did a damn good job.
Great breakdown!
I love your reactions, “what”, “what’re you doin dude?!”, “oh you f$&@er”. But honestly it’s cool seeing/hearing reactions of people who play music and can comprehend what the hell is going on. Or at least be amazed by it. Keep me up! I highly recommend right in two by tool. Won’t be disappointed.
That “wtf” moment was a 3 way polyrhythm. The 5 guitar part you heard + 4 + 3. Pretty insane stuff!
7:20 he totally strokes out for a minute. I'm dying
Hahahaha!! Bucket of fish! Brrrrrdegadat! Perfect explication my friend. It was a pleasure to watch you break this down.
I’m not even a drummer yet it’s nice to see someone else geeking out about it. I dig your take on things
Some clips to check out:
The Mars Volta - Goliath drum cam (can’t hear the rest of the band unfortunately)
Meshuggah - clockworks drum (audio is great and everything plus you hear the rest of the band, but I know you’ve covered them once already)
Anyways, have a good one!
Meshuggah !!!! Don’t look down !!
your videos are awesome dude!
I just tripped, cuz you mentioned Karl Hunter...I played with him in the big band in college, yeaaars ago (in SB). Forgot about him. Good to know he's still "rockin". Fun channel, man.
TOOL is so awesome live. They're even better in the studio. IMHO. PEACE & LOVE.
Funnily enough this was the first Tool song that really hooked me. So cool and unique. I knew them from their older stuff but just didn't really pay attention until I heard this song.
There's a really fun vid of Danny out there playing the Pot at what looks like a local dinner with a group of kids. A great example of enjoying what you do, and really cool to see him use a really small set and still make it rock.
Favourite drummer of all time
There's a video of him doing the middle part from the same clinic without music
I love the objectivity of yours. Got yourself a subscribe.
For me as a guitarist is amazing to see someone to see this and starting counting- "ok thats 11 open high heats" and shit :D
Would like to hear your review on more TOOL. Great Insight.
4:30: "What are you doing?" Perfect comment for Danny.....
Another master of Polyrhythms is Tim Alexander, since you played some Primus you shouldn't miss on him. Mostly his work on Pork Soda
Fuck yesssss Primus !!!!!
I was at this clinic!
My older brother got me in to Tool.
He spent a lot of time betting me that I couldn't learn various songs from tool.
At 14 or 15, I remember spending hours and hours every day breaking down every bar of "46&2" for 3 or 4 months.
He spent a lot of time just coming down to watch me play by the end of that!
Learning that one song almost 20 years ago, changed the entire course of my musical career.
I owe my brother a lot for fucking with me like that way back when.
And Danny has a way of making even the most seasoned drummers say "what the fuck?"
Not a whole lot of guys who can play three beats simultaneously.
Adam says he plays 5 including his last limb, lmaoo
Another awesome reaction man. Matt Greiner is another badass drummer from August Burns Red. Sick breakdowns
this why i say he is one of if not the best drummers ever cause he is all over the place the time signature changes just wow
I'd love to hear what you think about Carey's drumming on Tool's The Grudge.
You should hear this song with the whole band, it's crazy.
You should hear them live. It's such an amazing experience it almost religious is the only way I can describe it.
If you listen to these songs enough you can hear everything even at this quality. Your brain will supply the rest.
I implore you to check out Danny Walker, former drummer of Intronaut, his work with odd time and polyrhythms are mind boggling
On a different video he said he actually went to high school with Danny Walker! One of the Wintersun ones
5:43 That's what I really like about a couple of things they did with 11/8. It's like there's a groove that gets going and then gets "cut off", and I like the way it feels to listen and play to.
I wish Buddy Rich was still alive so when he says "if you don't get good enough, you'll end up being a rock drummer", you can show him Danny Carey play.
Buddy who? let me lol... what a massive asshole he was.
In all fairness Danny is a "jazz" drummer. He plays in a progressive metal band but his foundation is in jazz. Jazz drummers, and musicians in general are way more advanced technically speaking. Buddy Rich is an arrogant prick though.
Would love to see your reaction to Danny playing Stinkfist on drum cam! Epic!
Danny Carey makes me proud to be from Kansas. His hometown (Paola) is right next to mine (Olathe).
watched 2 videos and this guy jumps up 100 subs lol on that come up. also lookin like nick from New Girl. love the reactions
Another video of a demonstration is Gavin Harrison Anesthetize, which is a 17 1/2 minute Porcupine Tree song that has been pared down to 6 minutes and 40 seconds. The sound and video quality is extremely good. Would be interested in your thoughts.
When Neil passed away his torch was passed down to Danny as the world's greatest LIVING Drummer.
Watching him play makes me have the meat sweats. 🤘LONG LIVE DANNY CAREY🤘 LONG LIVE TOOL🤘
Haha Garret Millers head is MELTED!!! Haha!
Danny is an amazing drummer. He grew up near me and studied for awhile at UMKC the same school I went too for music. He was to big for this city. :)
You're talking about the jazz band called Volto! that Danny also plays the drums for. I was gonna go see them @ The Baked Potato a couple years ago but missed out cuz my ride bailed. He's such a awesome drummer and definitely number one on my list of favorites.
Man I know nothing about the technical aspect of music but I wish I did so I could appreciate this stuff more. I always knew Danny was incredible but I cant fully comprehend it like a musician can. Bummer.
7:26 You were talking over my favorite part! haha.
Danny is the absolute best
Danny Carey - A god among men
100% agree with learning Sober as a beginning drummer. My first venture with independent rhythms was thanks to learning it.
If you listen to that drum roll closely, him and Adam or Justin are matching pace with the slide of the pick on the string and the digression of the drum roll, sounds badass!! (This is my favorite tool song of all time)
Your rant on Sober is something that me and my bandmate (we used to be in a death metal band) have talked about on end. You described it perfectly, no drummer I've ever known can play Sober tight. It's nature confuses your brain and body...
Honestly, anything tool is hard to play on any instrument, but sober is among the hardest for its simplicity being so obscure !!
Local jazz band drummer. Low-key weekend out for the greatest drummer ever. Yeah. Buckadafish. Buckadafish. The way the bar line disappears in the section of three's is mesmerizing.
In the bridge section, Danny's playing a straight right-hand lead Swiss triplet in 6/8, with the hi-hat foot on 1, 3, and 5, with the snare on 4. Prior to the bridge (and in the outro), he plays the same 6/8 pattern over the rest of the band playing in 5/8.
Would be great to see you check this out on a studio quality version especially for the swiss triplet mindblowing section and to understand how the drumming relates to the song 👍
Right on the nose about the simple intricacy of Sober.
That roll from 4:59 - 5:08 is amazing.
I saw another comment on CarBomb's Constant Sleep. Elliot Hoffman. You really should cover him. I was having a really hard time counting him. the music is changing time so sporadically it's hard to catch what he's doing on the drums. Excellent stuff.
Would love to hear your reaction on Travis Orbin playing Unleash the Pwnies
One of my favorite metal drummers is phil dubois from Revocation. Maybe check out "the blackest reaches"
If they mixed the record like that live drum mix it wouldn't suck...dude is cracking tom shells hitting that fucking hard
When he started tapping on the desk I thought my house was shaking lol