(Parody) Everything Wrong With The Mane Attraction in 5 Minutes or Less
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2020
- Pop music bad. Piano music good.
Cinemare Sins is a fan-made series inspired by Cinema Sins. Be sure to check out the original: / cinemasins
Cinemare Sins Playlist:
• ALL Cinemare Sins Videos
Thanks to Casper, Flynn, and Hojokono for their suggestion!
See channel links for a form to submit your own sins for future episodes!
Consider supporting me on Patreon!
► / littleshyfim
$1 tier includes Discord server perk, patron-only feed, and early access to new videos. Thanks for your support!
Follow me on Twitter!
► / littleshyfim
Endgag music: • Undertale OST - MEGALO... - Комедії
Missed sin: I'm guessing since Rara ditched the flashy pop star persona all her male stripper backup dancers are all now out of a job I guess?
And so is the autotune guy
The Great MC lmao yes 🤣🤣👌🏻
Yup
guess so
Gues they all got hired by that one signer form the mlp movie then :P that's show buinesss.
@@zuzoscorner I don't think Songbird Serenade (Sia) would hire them
This might go against the moral of the episode, but I think her popstar design is a lot more interesting than her normal look
Oh my gosh same! XD
Kimball Belliston ngl her pop star design was pretty unique
Yeah it was better
As someone else wrote, pop is almost all you hear today (sadly). It is incredibly easy to write and the showier your outfit is, the better it is (and more popular you become).
I don't think it goes against the moral. The entire point she looked like that was to be society's standard "attractive popstar". In fact, I think it only adds to the plot on how they tried to change her.
I actually like rara's name, because it's a non simple reference. Countess Coloratura, aka Rara - > Countess = Lady - > Lady Rara - > Lady Gaga. I just love spoofed names that aren't lazily simple.
In the latinamerican dub they translated her name (Condesa Coloratura) and kept her nickname Rara which doesn't sound good at all because it means Weird. So you watch Applejack refering to her childhood friend as a weirdo for the entire episode like it's totally normal.
@@lucielakira bah, in Italian, Rara means Rare, so... Mmm... It doesn't bother me
@@MariuigiKhed same in spanish
@@lucielakira then again, it's like calling Lucy "Lulu"
I get what you mean, it just simply didn't work in spanish. Like, at all.
"Twilight comes out onto the runway, but then walks backwards and falls into the crowd offscreen-"
"WAAAAAAAAAAHH!"
My god, this is just too good 🤣
Newgate - Zero Hour “Countess ColoraturaAAAAAAHHHH!”
i laughed so hard haha
I burst out laughing at that too.
That made me laugh xD.
If you're wondering when that is, 4:02
‘Alicorns are basically spy drones’ Best sin line ever
Equestria's version of "birds aren't real they're just government drones"
*who knows what they have been watching...*
@@cinderleaves3949 you in the toilet seat
@@g0thicut1e68 well shoot
Ever since suggesting that cutie mark sin, I'm in a deep existential crises about whether cutie marks are mirrored on one flank and whether they should be...
2:06 for those wondering. Vinyl Scratch's cutie mark is like this, too. The noteheads face toward her butt, so the eighth notes appear normal on the right side of her body.
And if they are mirrored, which is the original?
Imagine having a letter as your cutie mark. Also why is your comment 4 days old and why are some other comments too?
Y'all acting like this hasn't been a question since 2011 :') it's always been a mystery. At least to me, who learnt to draw ponies while growing up on the show
How does your one says 4 days ago for me
Counterargument: The reason why the Pop Rara is bad is not because of the music, but because she's not being herself.
How can aj know it though
People change
I think the actual reason the show was trying to convey was that all this spectacle distracted from the fact that the song was literally about putting on a show to distract the audience from a song without meaning.
Like, if you listen to it without the visuals, you'll see it's kinda boring, and doesn't convey any messages. Many modern pop songs are the same: They have no actual message in and of themselves, and their only selling point is the actors in the music video.
Music is an art form, and like any art form, it is supposed to convey emotions and tell you about the artist. Pop songs don't do that. They're just background noise for the music video.
@@aa-bm9ln Svengallop forced her to become this way. Plus, Rara says "You clearly don't understand the REAL me!" and takes her veil off, symbolizing her standing up to him and saying she doesn't want to be like this anymore. Also, if she didn't want to change, she would've told Applejack.
@@Kartoffelkamm Nice points!
@@Kartoffelkamm I just wish that they could have done a complex moral in which she still changes and uses a pop style, but shows real meaning. (The problem is that it wouldn't be very obvious to a layperson, and so it risks diluting the whole thing.)
"Applejack is absolutely enamored by her friends' butt"
I literally laugh at that line and was like " Why is Applejack starring at her butt???"
Applejack "SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNYYYYYYYYYYY!"
Is this a ship? It should be
Pretty sure Appledash is canon after s9 ep26 "The Last Problem."
In her defense it was quite literally glowing
Lol
This is one of the best episodes of not just season 5 but the entire mlp series, especially since it has some of the shows most memorable songs!.
The Commenter Dragon it’s one of my favorite episodes
Underrated? I don't think I've heard any brony say they don't love this episode. If I remember correctly, it even won a poll asking about the best S5 episode in the past.
We can debate about it being the best (especially with the mentioned actually-serious-sins in the video), but it surely isn't underrated.
@@liborkundrat185 I think he saying it's underrated because there have been people in the fandom who have talked crap about the episode, i know because i've seen it.
@@theponyofglory8545 If so, then I missed it completely. I've seen the vast majority of people reacting positively to the episode.
The Commenter Dragon This episode is one of my favorite of season 5, but not of the entire show.
I really wished this episode did something more with her cutie mark, giving it a subplot. When Rara sings, it glows. Neat, but thematically empty and not all that interesting.
Now imagine the story where she actually got her mark at the summer camp when she sang for the first time.
Then, at some point during the episode after her catchy popstar song, it's revealed that she somehow lost her cutie mark and has been painting on a fake one. It would be this huge scandal, but more importantly, it would be a literal representation of how she lost her identity in the process of becoming famous and adopting the "Countess" persona. Plus, that would open up lore implications that ponies could actually lose their cutie marks if they abandon their calling.
But, to tie everything together, during the final song of the episode, Rara's cutie mark actually returns now that she's finally embraced her inner truth once again.
The episode wouldn't be the story of a popstar firing her manager, but instead a story about losing your sense of self and how to find it again.
And I think that story is far more meaningful.
That would leave us with a universe plot hole since never in mlp we had a cutiemark disapear due to loss of the talent
"I've booked the biggest pony popstar!"
Twilight: **books a different celebrity for her own festival**
"Alicorns are basically spy drones"
*UAV Online. Target confirmed. Firing for effect. Splash. Hostiles down.*
I don't know why but every time I think of "The Mane Attraction" I always confuse it with "It Isn't The Mane Thing About You". I'm always like "Is it that episode where Rarity messes up her mane?". Then I'm like, " No no wait, it's the one with Coloratura"
It's really easy to remember. The episode that has "ra" in it is about Rara. The one without "ra" is about Rarara.
@@usernamenotfound80 Hmmmmmm.....
Lol i dont remember It Isn't The Mane Thing About You bc i quit watching mlp in 2017 and when i came back to watching it in 2019, i didn't (and still dont) care much for newer seasons
Uh, curious about something: why did you refer to Minuette as "Colgate" in text form at 1:08, but properly as "Minuette" at 4:35? Is that a sin? I'm thinkin' that's a sin.
😂
I think where he took the video from was one of his older videos where colgate wasn't officially known at minuette.
@HBegaming YT The main reason they couldn't use Colgate is because it's trademarked. On the side, they ended up using both Bon Bon and Sweetie Drops (which had both been used on merch) in the 100th episode. She'll always be Colgate the toothpaste pony in my heart.
@HBegaming YT I know it's her fan name. The joke is that it could be viewed as a mistake and/or a sin.
@@prickitt1743 I think you're talking about Shoeshine.
I'm liking this video for the Undertale reference alone!
4:52
I read this before watching the episode and the sin counting ended and I felt bad for not noticing! Then the pianolovania came around 😂
@@alicethedemon6551 I KEEP ON CLICKING IT
Yee
Pikkon64 me to
Very cathartic to hear someone else mention how flawed this episode portrays certain aspects of what's going on. Made me feel incredibly uncomfortable that the autotuned Rara was supposed to be the "fake" or "bad" version of her, and that the one playing the piano was instantly loved despite how deceptive it would appear to promise a flashy concert yet deliver an orchestral performance.
"Childhood filly friend." Childhood and filly are the same unless it means something different like girlfriend? AH HA! They were laying the groundwork for the end show :D
Josh Haber made Rainbow Dash ambiguosly Bi back in S4E03; then Applejack was a textbook closeted lesbian in S4E13.
-> Then the rest of the writters distracted us with the Rarijack for years.
Childhood girlfriend. Wow, I did not pick up on that. It does seem like a hard thing to do by mistake when the obvious correct line is fillyhood friend.
@@adolfodef one year late but what happened in Castle Mane-ia to imply that Dash is bisexual? I tried to search it up but didn't find anything
It should have just been foalhood friend.
Wow, that piano version of Magnalovania (forgive me if I misspelled it) after the sin tally and sentence was nice!
It’s “Megalovania,” but yes, i agree, that was great
One minor quibble in otherwise an excellent CinemareSins:
Svengallop's listing off of stuff from previous episodes is actually a little nod to a bunch of other Amy Keating Rogers episodes -- that's what they all had in common, and that's why it was included in the episode seemingly at random. I was actually quite looking forward to this moment in the Cinemare Sins video, as I was expecting that you'd probably remark on this, haha.
rara: _fires her manager_
her career: *time for the spectacle*
Am I the only one who noticed that the unicorn giving coloratura the auto tone assist looks like Prince
Nope! Others have noticed that, myself included. Not a whole lot granted.
Its not the only reference to Prince, in the episode where Celestia is forced into a play one of her coaches is Raspberry Beret, the name of one of Prince's songs
No, I noticed this as well. I believe this reference was intentional.
To be fair, Rara was becoming more famous for the flashy effects of her shows and not actually her own ability to sing. As many have speculated before, that awful manager could put anypony in that outfit and the results would be largely the same. I respect Rara's decision to go the Pearl jam route of going smaller scale and focusing more on her music rather than putting on some show that ultimately distracts from her.
Everything Wrong with this episode Svengallop, nuff said.
I think mainly the idea of Rara getting upset so easily, svengallop leaving without a fight and Rara panicking was to show and demonstrate an unhealthy manipulative relationship
0:39 your subliminal messages don't work on me Starlight
LanFour Yeah, me neither.
Yaas I was searching the comments for people who ALSO saw that!
@@ibee623_ Fs in chat for people who didn't notice and were affected by Starlight's message.
it says the end is near
Next one is going to *BACK TO THE FUTURE*
4:01 whoever also said that this sin made them laugh
I
I
V
I've always been curious about Rara's "real" version of "I am just a pony." Before she starts she says "This song may sound familiar, but it's totally different." This implies she had this song already played before, but with just slightly changed lyrics and the magic effects.
4:52 try as you might there's no escaping Sans, or the undertale fandom.
4:42 Rara can't show AJ that anymore after how interested she seemed at Camp Friendship. That's why Rara put the veil over her butt.
Cantersoft it’s funny because AJ is literally staring at her butt in that shot XD
@@xrobinx3290 Yeah that's what I was getting at xD I guess I just didn't phrase it correctly.
@@Cantersoft XD
I just realized that this comes out on the first of every month so it will come out on my birthday yay!:)
Lovely _ocean sameeee
On the topic of birthdays, I know/ know of a surprising amount of people who share a birthday with me
@@gavinbrown216 rlly what is it
Lovely _ocean I’m not sharing it for privacy reasons
@@gavinbrown216 oh sry
I got the notification for this video and rushed over as soon as possible. The mane attraction is one of my favourite episodes of my little pony! I'm so glad you made this!
This episode probably has one of my favorite musical preferences in the entire show. (I mean the pop music one, not the piano one.)
Same
3:35 twilight must have found celestia's forbidden book
I was so sad to see Amy Keating Rogers leave. I wonder if she's still with Disney since I know that's why she left the show. Lena Hall for me did have the best singing voice in the show (but that's no surprise, she's a Broadway singer and I think those people tend to be some of the best singers ever).
You just couldn't resist with the Megalovania, could you?
I saw Lena Hall sing 'I am just a pony' live at PoNYCon 16. It was beautiful and cry tears of joy.
“Svengallap would be great at Brony trivia”
Silver Quill: CONTINUITY!
“better sin it just in case”
Oh, I get it
hasbro: - makes unnecessarily costumes -
littleshyfim: BUY OUR TOYS
Can u do "Parental Glidence" or "Newbie Dash"
There are many sins.
Parental Glidence sins:
1: How did they not get kicked out of the show?
2: How did they get in the locker rooms?
3: They should know Dash is a Wonderbolt cuz there r news spreads.
4: Misty Fly and Surprise (yellow mane and white coat pegasus) were never in the show when High Winds (the pegasus under Soarin) was in the show.
5: Where did Scootaloo get all those pictures from? I know shes a fan but this is kind of stalkerish
I mean... he will. He does every episode in order.
As someone who seriously has issues with the way pop stars are represented in this episode, I'm glad that you called it out at times. Great video as always!
Dude, imagine looking through for every detail in every frame in an episode for a video
I give you my respect
Rara: plays megalovania
Me: It doesnt even matter if your hooves are playing it or not, ITS MEGALOVANIAAAA
2:18 'Fillyfriend' is the pony equivalent of 'girlfriend'. Think about that.
I love how you called Minuette "Colgate"
If it weren’t for this I’d forget it was my birthday month,
Thanks.
2:24 Derpy doesn’t agree with what you said their by the looks of it
Who's ready for Everything Wrong With The Cutie Re-Mark?
Hasbro will probably make a Camp Friendship spin-off after Lauren Faust dies.
They don’t need to wait for her death.
0:57 since u said this i just realized that i’m not the target demographic anymore oh my god
4:05
And I died laughing
1:52 Countess just didnt know that have you even seen the episode!?
Missed sins: 1. That copy-pasted scene in the "Spectacle" showing.
2. None of the ponies realize that it's autotune even though it's blatantly obvious since no one can sing with that filter and cut off notes (there may be an exception, but still), and there's a giant beam of magic cast at her neck.
3. The point of a live show is to NOT have autotune, yet here that one pony goes casting an autotune spell.
4. The insane amount of ponytail flipping.
5. Those blocky eyelashes.
Great vid, mate! You always make me laugh with these!
I was wondering why there were only 86 likes, then I realized...
*I'M FLIPPING EARLY FOR ONCE*
Same
I actually saw the episode more a way to show how something good can be deceitful. It doesn't seem to be something wrong overall with her popstar persona (Gallop seem like an ass regardless), AJ it's just shocked by the difference because it doesn't reflect the persona she used to know. One's the episode makes it clear that it is indeed a fake persona, the message for me becomes more of "Not everything that shines it's made of gold" instead of "It's always better to stay true to one self" even tho I'm sure that was the intent. Even tho it seems she has successful career, she is unhappy, and not living her life to the fullest. Even if everything she grew during that time dissapears, finding her true self it's more important in the end because she finds it more fulfilling. If she wanted she could have stay as that persona popstar one's she got rid of Gallop, but she chooses to go with something that brings her joy. It's a selfish message, and a tad foolish, but I have seen worse
I’ve been waiting for this one! My fav episode!! Can’t get enough of these
This was one of my favorite episodes when I first watched it and this brings back a lot of memories
I haven't watched one of these in a LONG time, but I kept laughing out loud! Good to know these are just as great as I remember!
After he played megalovania at the end of the video and then played his outro,
I can confidently say that his outro sounds very similar to megalovania.
I have never been more happy from the end of a Video.
2:08 Actually, in season 1, episode 14, "Suited for success," there is a scene where rarity is walking down a runway with the POV facing from the top and we can see the there are 2 cutie marks on her.
I rewatched all the sins videos, and the improvement from the first one to this one is astounding!
First one being friendship is magic part 1
i came back out of nostalgia and to find out you're still doing this is amazing omfg i love it
“That is not an appropriate thing to ask a crowd of children, Rara”
I’m dead😂
Omg omg omg. I have been waiting for this for a long time. Thanky you.
Omg this is the earliest I got ever for your videos love you
Is no one gonna talk about the fact that applejack has more freckles as a fillie then in the present?
Honestly, the fact that either her fans will join her on her journey of self re-discovery adds some weight to the song. Though they sure could have found a few seconds somewhere to mention the possible collapse of her career.
Lol wonderful video, really love watching the little mistakes is miss while watching the episode, bravo 👏 : )
holy shit youre still making these. my childhood
LittleshyFIM: Fernando is the best character
the entire fandom:
DERPY DISAPPROVES
your videos always make me laugh!
OMG! YOU FINALLY DID MY FAVORITE EPISODE!!! I already knew about the tiny SweetyBelle and waited for this video so you could sin it!
0:39 you’ll be so missed Amy❤️
Yay you posted on my birthday!!!!
i finally caught up! i absolutely love your work and you're like the funniest person ever, i know it's really dumb but i haven't been able to laugh at anything in a long time. things have honestly been pretty shitty lately but your channel's been a bright spot in my life. deepest apologies for being all sappy and sentimental. thank you so much for doing what you do
Thanks for the comment, it means a lot to me. Glad you enjoy!
3:29 The thing I hate the most.
A five minute video of everything wrong with The Mane Attraction? Impossible.
I've been out of town for a week, and watching this is the first thing I did when I got back home.
3:56 I actually did think about that 2 years ago. I knew it would be a good opportunity to give Rara another episode where she may get to interact with more main characters than just Applejack and Twilight. Lena Hall's most favorite Mane 6 pony isn't Applejack, it's Pinkie Pie. I asked her at the 2018 Brony Con and she told me so. December 24, 2020, 2:05pm
1st of all, great that you remember the exact time
2nd of all: you just made me realize, *2020 was 2 years ago! This has been happening for 2 YEARS!*
Tune in next month for commie horse revenge/ time travel shenanigans that are more confusing then Endgame's time travel logic.
Pretty much the S5 finale lol
I'm sure someone out there has tried to explain how different versions of stopping the rainboom has led to timelines where different villains have won, but it's really hard to conceive the connection with the villains. Or especially the final world where it's just armageddon.
Presumably Rainbow herself has to be the cause of it all, since the lives of the other 5 shouldn't be affected outside of not getting their cutie marks at that moment.
Endgame’s time travel is simple, branching timelines that you can choose to which one you go, they even mention it in the film
@@gavinbrown216 I meant paradox wise.
ah, its been a long time since i've binged this series. gonna have to catch up!
always a good day when littleshy uploads
I always look forward to the first of every month to watch these.
Rara should have been the pop star for the movie. Would have answered the "Where did her career go?" question, and she's an established character who could have helped AJ with crowd control when escaping the StormKing.
My favorite episode!! ❤️Been waiting for this ever since I watched it
The megalomania at the end awakened my undertale side
My undertale side: WHO SUMMONED ME
my other sides: AAAAAAAAAHHHH
Cinemare Sins returns once again!
Love these vids
another sin is that the cutiemarks were on the left side instead of the right at 1:07
4:55 I swear, I'm having a strong dejavu watching Rara playing megalovania, but I don't know of what.
I have been waiting for this episode of cinemare sins forever
2:41
It's backlit and has a roof and back, it's normally lit because it has lights in it
0:39 I think at that flashing scene of the video said "THE END IS NEVER" maybe
I’m really glad you’re still doing this stuff. Bronies will live on
Omg i love ur channel
I like how only like 8% of the characters are wearing clothes
1:13 also, it's Russell from Up on the left.
Also for 1:38 I too am curious why that was the case. Your hypothesis sounds like an interesting one. It'd be fun to hear what someone involved during production of this episode has to say.
I HAVEN'T WATCHED YOU IN YEARS OH MY GOD I'M SO HAPPY YOU'RE STILL HERE