Madonna @ Eurovision - outoftune VS autotune
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 тра 2019
- Did anyone else notice the difference between last night live performance in Tel Aviv and the edited one released the day after on her channel?
No haters! Just ears. - Наука та технологія
Lol! The boohing was muted too in the 'fixed' version!
12 points to technical expert
Hello from Greece. I think, although I can't say I am 100% sure, but I think there may have been a few vocals that have been sung again for the uploaded video or perhaps vocals from another performance were layered at times and subsequently auto-tuned. An example of this is the phrase "out of the sky" at 2:05 and the way she pronounces the word sky at 2:14 in the auto-tuned version. It isn't just pitch-fixed , it's also pronounced and sung differently. I believe that at that point the vocals for "sky" were pasted from another and perhaps older live performance. Another thing I am noticing is that the real live performance might have also had auto-tune which was tuning her voice wrong at times. There are a few notes that just can't be so much off. This has been known to go wrong in the past when using auto-tune on live performances as it once did for Justin Bieber. An example of one such note that is pretty obvious it has gone auto-tune wrong and that is the phrase "Just like a child" at 3:07 and specifically the word child. There is no way that a normal voice would wobble like that. It distinctly sounds as if auto-tune is trying to tune to a certain note but does not do so. This is why one should never auto-tune a live performance. Because in the studio you can fix it afterwards or redo it if it goes wrong. When live, you can't and if auto-tune goes wrong it can REALLY go wrong.
It is a remarkable change, an utterly different mix, and sometimes during her worst off-key moments you can hear the auto tune effect really strongly, so much so that she sounds a bit chipmunk at times, but I like that we can hear what the intention was with Madonna’s remix though
Maybe she wasn't hearing herself good enough. Shit happens.
why did the pitch go up in this video, that’s not how it sounds for the unedited or edited
She sounds better than when she first released this song.
She sounds drunk. Especially in the beginning.
Its funny when you notice that she allready used autotune in the live set but she sang so much out of tune that even the autotune couldnt handle it
Jan Solo the autotune was set to the wrong key, when she sang at the met gala in 2018 without autotune she sounded MUCH BETTER
Auto-Tune‘I rebuke thee’
@@giwrgoshymn Well yes but then again why would you need Auto tune then?
Σ cuz it’s a big event and they wanted everything to be perfect but that didn’t happen
@@giwrgoshymn Well the perfection in art comes from the imperfection. So it wouldn't have been awesome even with the correct Auto tune besides she's using autotune also out of such big events too on her own shows.
Madge summons Covid-19
This took me back to my childhood! She sounds exactly like when the tape recorder was running low on batteries... She was great once but perhaps it’s time to retire...
She didn't even try people. Shameless cashgrab. Also the place was terrible sound wise
I hate to agree... but that was shitty
Every entry, every other performer was great, perfect even... Only on her performance the sound was qeustionable? Give me a break!
overall still wasn’t that bad, and i’m not a madonna “s t a n”. of course some parts were undeniably not so good at all
yall she is 61. stop hating on her because she sang not perfectly or edited the song. some of you can not even sing but when it comes to judjment yall all first. ofc she knew she is not perfect she just went for it cuz tel aviv gave lots of money. im sure yall would also go if you were offered millions, even tho you have no idea what is singing.
Imagine being the host and bragging abt this for months only to have this happen on stage lol.
Obviously the sound guy's fault as she never sings out of tune like that - so she either had to in order for autotune to work OR her feedback in her ears made her sing off
UA-cam: mocca party
thats it...
see ya everyone, im heading back to "Like A Virgin"!
Sound technicians should have been paid double
Why not perform the whole song in a lower key? 🙉
Why is nobody talking about the whole performance? Shame on Israel!
Shame? I Can't be more proud of my country, of our brave soldiers for keeping our safety.
@@sefafefa Please leave us in Peace with your national Propaganda.
Greetings from inside of Germany!
@@sefafefa Israel sucks
Age Still on tune on Live TV, but The autotune bug and she sick.
Well seems that preformance was way to critical...
It sounds like her lung strength is diminishing.
Well, she had some notes that sounded decently strong.
One thing I do know about singing is that if you can’t hear yourself, it makes it very hard to stay on key
Sei italiano... Conservatorio G. Verdi
Thanks for this compare !!! Madonna une Très Mauvaise Performance en Live !!! Il faut assumer et non essayer de mentir et de nous berner !!!!!!!!!!!! MADONNA HAS BEEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Na campana
Madonna ist einfach genial mutig!! Die beste Leistung ihres Lebens. Ich danke ihr von Herzen für diesen Auftritt. Ich war damals life dabei und habe aber leider noch nichts kapiert und durchschaut.
Feige für den, der dieses Video abkürzt.
Its bad
Looks like all musicians out here 😂🤣😂
Svetlana Belova thank you for your comment.
If you are talking about me... I’ve studied violin @ Conservatorio Giuseppe Verdi: unfortunately it’s like having a diapason in my head 🙃 but in this case everyone is able to understand what happened; of course, not the reason.
Ciao!
2:58 - 12 - 3:28
3:28
1:56
1:24
0:52
5:17
Both versions sound horrible.
She sang so bad, Satan has left Israel lol
No. Madonna left Israel, Satan is still there.
Maybe she was nervous bcause of what might come flying at her for what she expressed at said day and place.
the complete show is full of signs of the illuminati...Oh my god...i have seen yesterday for first time this complete song from Madonna and Quavo. I´m interested by "Q" in an facebookgroup. Many things i saw yesterday in this show, full of illuminati signs and demonic signs. The portal behind Madonna is an lightening red skull...The "Q" in front of Madonna´s skirt( my hope on "Q" it is now smashed, because Madonna robbed my illusion for the help from "Q" for a better world)....her crown on her head means the corona virus...crown=Corona...than the words she said to the people in the white dresses..."They are so naive...they think we are not aware of their crimes...we know, but we´re just not ready to act..the storm isn´t in the air, it´s inside of us...i want to tell you about love and loneliness ( that means our curfew at the moment) but it´s getting late now...can´t you hear outside of your supreme hoodie...the wind that´s beginning to howl...(than she blows in face to the white dressed people (she infected them wit the virus)...these are my thoughts of the stage appearance from Madonna...this is the plan of the Elite!!! This show was last year in may...and now it is the reality. It was all planned....and Madonna ´s voice, without power, terrible...and the text says all what will happening...
people have used studio gear to sound better for years,compression,e.q,reverb,phasing,chorus, double tracked vocals whats the big deal!?! x
Such a car crash of a performance. Bad karaoke.
Her tone itself is awful, no matter how much autotune you put on it...
I don’t know why people are taking this so serious I think she did great
I can sing better then this...
The thing is she alrleady used autotune at the live performance but she sang so much out of tune that the autotune snaped it to closest wrong note.
So when you cant sing your song live with autotune you might have a problem :)
She got 1.5 million dollars for this performance... that's why...
Because her entire job is to entertain, it's her art.
If people are paying to be entertained, you owe them your best.
@@energistlisak and not playback nor autotune
Why can't she just retire??
at least she sings live most of youn artist even didnt sing
Awful. Poor audience having to losten to this sh#t.
Please retire
Why would she? She's a legend.
Satanic ritual
What happens in Israel every day is very satanic.
It's time to retire Grandma!
That what you het when yoi mess with the chosen people. Long live the nation of Israel 🇮🇱✡️💙
Chosen for what?
@@koolandklear you're not aware, apparently, but I'll answer: chosen for lighting the world.
@@sefafefa
I can push a button myself. I dont need your help.
@@koolandklear that answer state the exact opposite
For Gods Sake, learn how to write.
To be honest I don't hear a big difference.
UA-cam: mocca party