Why Businesses don't Flourish in Pakistan? I
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 лис 2023
- There is a well-established notion that #businesses do not flourish in #Pakistan due to a non-conducive #environment which includes bureaucratic friction, uncertain policies and #political instability, among other reasons. However, there may be another perspective to it. Do we really possess a #mindset for doing business? Or are we just #Seths? Why cannot companies run as conglomerates and be broken down into smaller individual companies when transferred on to the next generation?
- Why does Pakistan have no multi-billion companies?
- Why are there mostly family-run businesses in Pakistan?
- Why is there almost no company headed by #professionals?
- Why is there no Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) market?
- Why no new #products?
- Why no #R&D?
- Is our industry overprotected?
- Are government licenses/permissions restricting investment?
Panelist:
MR OSMAN SAIFULLAH
Chairman, Saif Holdings Ltd.
MR SHAHZAD SALEEM
Chairman, Nishat Chunnian Ltd
MR SHAHID SATTAR
Former Member (Energy), Planning Commision of Pakistan
MR MAHBOOB MAHMOOD
Chief Executive & Founder, Knowledge Platform
MS RAHAT KAUNAIN HASSAN (Moderator)
Former Chairperson, Competition Commission of Pakistan
EconFest Website: econfest.pide.org.pk/
For Further Details Please Visit:
@PIDEOfficial
www.pide.org.pk
/ pideofficial
/ pidepk
/ pideislamabad
/ pidepk
/ pidepk
First and foremost, 90% of your population are highly radicalised , until and unless if you don’t ditch this mindset of your society , you can’t compete in this highly competitive world. Forget about IT or BT, nothing comes so easy.
India is on the same Path. India is radicalizing.
@@nitin1947 one more assssssmani kitab logic user 🤣
@@nitin1947 explain me how? Why should I consider your argument? A logical one .
@@nitin1947bullshit. Appease the Islamists at your own peril .
Say a guy who's country is ruled by a prime minister who commited genocide in Gujrat and was banned by USA to enter for this very reason.
The party of this genocidal maniac is RSS which takes its inspiration from Mousalini and Nazi party of Hitler.
The home minister of India Amit Shah calls immigrants "termites".
Please google "RSS India" to confirm the above
Madrassa students yawning !!! poor chaps have no idea what's going on
they are waiting for someone to shout " Pakistan ka matlab kya..........🤣"
You must be tanatani andhbhakt from cow belt Hindi states with typical r ight wing communal propoganda social media channels
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 You must be a "Porki" masquerading behind an Indian name to legitimize your intent.
@@nikhildeshmukh6221Thank God some good Islamists like you are able to live amongst these bad people in India. 👍
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 What's up Sack ball ?? Have seen u everywhere in Pakis comment section searching for your Momma but can't find her...Poor lad trying hard to earn brownie points by taking validation 😂😂
Great sum up of a incurable country!!
I like how these businessmen say Pakistan’s textile industry is so good when Pak is not even in the top 10 textile exporter.
They export only tee shirts. 6 dollars a dozen.
sir you are wrong,what the business man said was top bottom 10 from below.
bhai there r alot of sectors/ areas where v need to improve, it seems v r not even ready, v r not even eligible to handle the burden of a large economy so how can v reach there, its like u r expecting someone to lift 100kg who can't even lift 10kg of weight.
@@searchfortruth6889 Pakistan ka textile industry 2.2 se 1.7 percent pe aa gaye hai. Discussion mein aisa keh raha hai ki textile ne na jane kaunsi revolution kar diya, ghum phir ke truck ki batti.
@@provocateur-in-chief i live abroad and i see Pakistani textile items here that r always on sale, it shows how much demand the textiles of Pakistan have abroad. Secondly, as one of the audience has asked the question that biggest corporations in Pakistan don't keep any budget for R&D & there was no answer to his question from the side of guests. All the developed world has developed on the sole idea of research, v r manufacturing items which hav either become obsolete in the developed world or they r of the lowest quality. These businessmen or CEOs instead of saving their asses should atleast put the facts right. The world has passed through the age of industrialization and moved towards tech and IT and v haven't even reached that stage where USA was 100 years earlier. Pakistan was much more advanced then South Korea in 60s and see SK now, they r leading in the sector of tech and manufacturing. Wat i hate to listen is that "kitni besharmi sey ye khud ko justify kr rhe hein".
For last 20 years they were asking why is india growing better than Pakistan. Now they are asking why is Bangladesh better than pakistan.
In 2050, the panel would be asking why is Afghanistan growing better than Pakistan. They wont ask how many students are Madrasaas Vs proper science schools.
Wonderful bro. In the next 20 years Porkistan will be competing with Uganda, Chad and Solomon Islands.
@@gowrishankarkn6499Solomon islands receive decent number of tourists to have 100% literacy
Uganda is growing better than Pakistan
Chad is middle of desert with izlamik dictatorship
Agreed bro.
@@KanishQQuotes
Pakistan wont be existing in 2050.Just punjabistan
😂😂I think afganistan doing much more better than Pakistan
I live in the U.S. and a Papa Johns outlet is pretty close to my place. It's not possible for an army General to to gather the type of wealth as the ex Chairman of CPEC General Bajwa did. Make the armed forces personal accountable, Pakistan can match up to others
Islam was carried on the shoulders of ghazis. Are the great ghazis of Pakistan not to be rewarded?
😂😂😂😂You forget pakistan is army with nation 😂😂😂
retired Army Officer if Indian Army here....here our salary is just enough to get a flat in a place like Delhi and Mumbai...and then we scrap by on pensions....we however have to work even after retirement to maintain same lifestyle....and that is same for our retired generals......I remember there was a huge furore when one of our retired Chiefs tried to book a flat in Mumbai which was meant for widows of Martyrs....and he was given a boot.....but I didnot know Pak army officers are so rich...is their pay more
@@sureshtripathi7363 not high pay. It's Corruption.
Don't give them ideas. Let them use thr own brains
All of the panelists are talking without understanding ground reality of Pak.
Amazing & excellent observation . . . It is sad reality of all Pakistani discussions . . .
That is the precise definition of these industrialist descenders of elite progenitors.
You have discussed everything,but missed the elephant in the room. Somebody talked about IITs. Our economy today is not where it is because of the IITs. In fact,most IITians migrate abroad and haven't contributed to our economy much
Our economy is where it is today because of our investment in basic education that is modern. In our government schools we teach science, not religion. The result was that when the country had to liberalize in 1992, we had abundant human capital that could be exploited.
So whatever policy changes you make, whatever strategies you adopt, whatever facilities you provide, unless you invest in producing a workforce that has a scientific temper, you will not make much progress.
Deradicalization of the masses must start now and with earnestness. If you do that , may be in the next 20 years, you can become a $1 trillion economy
You're just highlighting social issues and composing them with the failure of economic al progress......do some research of Pakistans economic models and their bank policies
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 Fact is they have had no policy. Their entire economy has been based on the premise that they will receive perpettual funding to fight communists.
Now that avenue has dried up. So they have to produce assets that can generate wealth. But the biggest and most important raw material for wealth creation is human capital which they dont have. Until they have that , the best of policies can not revive their economy
@@tksrajan1How is it that we can clearly see the bare naked ugly truth of Pakistan economy but Pakistanis themselves just can’t grasp the root of their miseries ? They are so unwilling to change or to develop. It’s mind boggling how much begging is appreciated en masse rather than a stable self-sustaining economy.
@@tksrajan1 paxtan's biggest problem is islam and koran, what you can expect from masses of country where in childhood they'r taught that go kill the kafir's(Hindus/Christians/Jews) don't make them your friends, they're infidels, 72 virgins, heaven etc. They can't think beyond koran.
These people think entire India is run buy someone from IIT. That's how narrow minded these people are.
I have a small scale manufacturing business (45 employees) in Ahmedabad India, we have absolutely no government harrasment, everything I mean everything is to be done online. Any fund requirements from Banks for expansion would take maybe a week at most.
Really !
Wow, its good to hear.
I suspect situation in most of the other states are not so good
Gujarat is an exception man. It’s still harder for other states in India too .
@@Charvak-Atheistyes it’s not . Gujarat is leaps and bounds better for businesses . From infra to logistics to capital availability there is no comparison .
@@contrarian322
That's what I said.
@@contrarian322yes but other industries are also running in other states.
It's not all doom and gloom
Bangladesh has a GDP greater than India? Shocked! This is the level of awareness of Pakistani CEOs!
Per capita
What's wrong if in India GDP of only those is counted who are wise enough to follow Islam? The output of the rest is haram.
Bangladesh gdp per capita is $2458. India gdp per capita is $2257. Moreover 5% of Indians own 60% of the wealth. Most of India is dirt poor. We Indians are being conned by godi media.
He meant per capita income. Yes, now the per capita income of Bangladesh is more than India.
@@perincherigopinathan3586 Per capita income for gdp doesn't mean how much money one country has. It means how much economic activity happens in terms of one person.
If you count per capita PPP then you will realise how much money the nation has in terms of one person.
The question that needs answering is ‘Why does Pakistan exist? How did it come into being?’
Once you come to know the real reason for its existence then these question will become meaningless and supposed answers self evident
IMO, all Pakistanis, including the esteemed speakers, appear to have a general mistrust and dislike for India. And that’s preventing them for learning the best practices of Indian economy.
India didn’t become a trillion $ economy overnight.
It made mistakes (several) and keeps making them and yet, finding a way to succeed.
If only these people can open their hearts and minds first and be open to learn.
Religious fundamentalism and hatred towards #Hindus are ingrained in them from their schooling onwards.. what else can you expect from a people who reduced their minority population to near extinction
This is what will always keep them in the beggars list . They do not understand modernity . The world is going to zoom past them and in the end will become Bihar’s cheap labor market . 😅
Denial is biggest issue
The guy saying “If the top Indian companies like Ambanis or others were put under the same scrutiny as the Pakistan companies, 20-30% of them would have already failed”…this is an idiotic statement, because their growth cannot be assured if there was something fundamentally wrong with them. This statement feels like it is generated from a feeling of “sour grapes” by this industrialist.
In India IITians are not the enterpreurs. They go to High paying jobs wherever they are and then to Civil services. The enterpreurs are often non IITians.
Why a representative of establishment/Army is not on panel,the biggest buisness entity in Pakistan
A mulla and a major in full fatigue is badly missing!
Chalo nice to first time see Pakistanis Compare themselves more with Bangladesh than India.
Finally Pakistan has accepted defeat to India.
Now, i just Hope to see Pakistan compare itself with Afghan Businesses in 2040.
Sorry, I will not be available to watch.
You must be andhbhkt from cow belt Hindi states
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 Abey Pakistani Muhllayy, Tujhay Kitni Baar Expose Kiya Hai Fir Bhi Hindu Naam Rakhkar UA-cam Par Baitha Hai.
We can also make 1000 Accounts with Pakistani Muzlim Names.
Fir Tum royegay. Tu Sudhar Jaa Beta.
@@nikhildeshmukh6221yes he is a Sanghee.He will never compare India with China
@@nikhildeshmukh6221
Haha
अंध भक्त कौन हैं, कुछ लोग जो एक ऐसे आदमी को सपोर्ट करते हैं जो गरीब परिवार से आता है, कभी चाय बेचता था, अब अपनी मेहनत और लगन से देश का का PM है I
जिसने देश का नाम इतना बढ़ाया है की US, UK, ऑस्ट्रेलिया आदि के PM उसका लोहा मानते हैं l जिस ने देश की इकॉनमी 10वें नम्बर से 5 पर ला दी l पाकिस्तान पर सर्जिकल स्ट्राइक की और कर
से को घुटने टेकने के लिए मज़बूर कर दिया
या फिर वो लोग जो एक ही परिवार की गुलामी करते आये हैँ और किसी भी पप्पू को PM बनाने के दिवा स्वप्न देख रहे हैं l कुछ लोग तो उसकी बहन को बनाना चाहते हैं क्योंकि उसके बाल इंदिरा से मिलते हैं l यह ही पैमाना हैं तो जयराम रमेश को बना दो, बाल तो उसके ज्यादा मिलते हैं 😃😀😄
None of them are talking about families of Pak
It's a business conference
No one is watching- none of your videos crossed 1000 views. Bunch of jokers justifying why they continue to be in top class.
Look at your own country, why the duck you would go to someone's channel nd insult them....jahil
Very insightful points.
1. Protected industries is not a sharia haram halal issue.
2. Providing or not providing protection to industry is prerogative of Govt.
3. Lack of basic quality education is the impetus of elite capture.
4. When cost of production is 4 times the international competition than subsidy is a given
What nonsense. What parts of life are not subject to Islam?
@@PS-ej2xnif you need a matric fail maulvi to tell you the basics of life... You're lacking
@@KanishQQuotes So the basics of life should not adhere to Allah's instructions as detailed in the Holy Quran and according to Sunnah?
@@PS-ej2xn yes totally correct
By the time IT comes of age in Pakistan, it would have reached saturation point...
Remember east pakistan was making more gdp than west
How is it that all these insightful videos on Pakistan are mostly watched by Indians??? That itself answer the question of this panel
Firstly Pakistanis should stop their comparison with India..
On one hand India is striving to get its economic strength.. brick by brick..
Pakistan still continues to get its identity..this is what happens when you create a nation without its soul..
شکریہ pide . حقائق کو منظر عام پر لانا ایک کٹھن اور مقدس کام ہے جو اپ انجام دے رہے ہیں ۔
textile Seth versus ping pong loving IT engineer - wrong discussion
First ask this lady to wear a Hijab/burkha and ask the men on the pannel to grow beard. How can Pakistan call itself an Islamic nation without even following basic Islamic rules? This is the reason why Allah is angry on Pakistan and Pakistan is going thorough difficult times.
Sarcasm ? 😅
Who says, businesses don’t flourish in Pakistan. Here if you invest in Islamic Madarsa Business, Radicalisation Business… see they are flourishing. See…Darul Uloom Karanchi, Darul Uloom Haqqania, Tariq Jameel Business…Army Business.
I came here for the comments
Marrying your cousin for Canadian or British citizenship does not count as exports
When you decide to start a business, always look who your competitors are. Pakistan will have to compete with India and it will be at a disadvantage there. When India entered IT industry, there was hardly any competitor. All the IT experts you create will ultimately migrate to western country. End of story. What is the incentive for professionals to stay in Pakistan? Zero.
Why do they think they were FAR ahead of INDIA.........its not like they were LONDON n INDIA was present day LAHORE.....
It's a lie. They were never richer or ahead than india. They had illegal money and cars coming from USA which made them feel. They are doing great
As a common man, a 25 year old chemical engineering graduate from India i can easily say that your army IS the reason for the inability of your country to develop, prosper or even be competitive in the world, the annual budget it takes every year is ever increasing and it directly impinges upon any funds available for either development projects (existing/new) nor for any meaningful reforms to be carried out as they simultaneously have control over 70% of the industries with them, so good luck getting out of this mess lol, unless this issue is fixed NOTHING will change in Pakistan !!!!
Respected, Kindly evaluate/ discuss, how people opened businesses in 1948 till 1970. People trust for businesses to self employment and Pakistan. Why trust level is low. Civil Bureaucracy/ Law and order. Absolute security from government. Elimination of all Mafias. Total system to refurbish. Please discuss why they opened businesses in first 10 years of independence. What was the Psychology.
It's usa business not pakistan
Really Disappointed about the level of discussion and the quality of panel members.... This kind of thinktanks is certainly not capable of helping Pakistan to be an Industrial Country!!
Wow! What a seminar. We the citizens of India are just flabbergasted about the growth of entrepreneurship in Porkistan. All the panelists have rightly pointed out the ills of this Paleolithic economy. How to improve the situation to enable Porkistan to compete with Bangladesh seems to be the Million Dollar question on their minds. Here goes the magic wand ; a) You guys have to first come out of this burqaa/hijaab/skull cap mindset. We are seeing Economics/Management students in this traditional 10th Century BC uniform in a Business Meeting. b) Secondly, you need to immediately privatize the Army. They are the main culprits who are bleeding the economy by opening fast food outlets in the West. c) You need to develop on your Core Competency which is Jihaad. This business model has been copied by many other Islamic countries including Syria. You guys should have obtained a Copyright long back. d) You need to immediately appoint Mullahs and Moulvis as the CEO/CFO of your big businesses on a war footing. e) Your IT Panelist has rightly pointed out that it has taken 14 years to come back to Porkistan to serve your economy. We can understand the speed at which your economy is growing. Congrats. and lastly, f) Your young talented population should be educated in Business Schools of India than in Madrassas of North West Frontier Province. The sooner you adopt these strategies, the faster you will become the Jihaadi Republic of the World. Inshallah.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I expected an objective discussion , away from religion,politics etc.
The fact that one of the panelists had to start his discussion with a praise of Allah shows the mindset. The conservatism and not wanting to be seen standing outside of religion inherently kills any forward thinking.
And they want to progress 😂
29:25 please look at the 'subsidy' given to the IPPs.
29% return on equity.
Pass through costs.
Indexed return in US Dollars.
Also Inflation bhi matter karta hai kahli returns nhi
Pakistan's main problem in that they continue to live in past!! Saying that Pakistan was doing well than India 30 yrs back has no credible evidence....is more a heresay! Living on donations from America will not create Economy....it will create only charitable institutions...stop the donations or charity, the institution collapses. Indian economy was definitely not in good shape at that time but there was no leadership vacuum and it had already set the direction for harnessing its immense human resources.... that's how today India is where it is.... it is not built only over past 30 yrs...as it is assumed ....though it did gather pace since 1990's.
The main problem is the middle class has not been addressed. Unless this is addressed the purchasing power goes down leading to poor economic activity. The second problem is seeking parity with India and spending a huge amount on the army instead of doing business with India. Another bad descision is selling out the country to China. Too much emphasis on religion in the form of conversion, blashphemy and other outdated laws. Finally the most important - women empowerment by way of education and other benefits is dismal.
Desert connection! Sand, date palms, camels and stones alone can thrive. Don't feel sad, it is universal to all rats.
🤣🤣🤣
The guy who started his speech as illa billa millla……. He is the reason why Pak is in dump
Seths have left labours at the mercy of Thekedars , they are not paying minimum wages to labours, treating their employees like their slaves, lack of transparency and tickle down economic fruits.. There is lack of merit in seth organization therefore well qualified youth prefer Multinational Compony here or to go abroad. Go ans survey various textile and other mills. Even in some elite so called O level schools where there is seth system and example is Karachi Public School where even after 37 years working as a teacher by a man has not been given appointment letter and where teachers have to pay for drinking water. When they call their employees on holidays and the excess time they dont pay but in disguise of late coming deduct huge amount. So there is need to end this SARMAYADARANA SETH SYSTEM>
Highly appreciate such discussion events. This should be done more often in all universities. 👏👏
University kids would do much better talks in India with much more confidence. Students are encouraged loan by banks to do pilot projects and such is result of 105 unicorns in the past 15-20 years time.
Pakistan is no where 100 years closer to India in any aspect. Hope they learn and grow
30.52 Pakistan has a lot of hunger and Jazbhaa to fight for Muslims all over the world 😂😂😂
sorry to say after 1 hour of watching this vlog not one insight i could highlight that will take pakistan in the next phase of development and be a global player. such discussions-will not even find a place in B rung indian business colleges. feel sorry for the quality of human capital in pakistani society.so should you blame the army, politicians or religious fundamentalism ? i rest my case here . best wishes from india 🇮🇳 !
This discourse is very good for Pakistan. For World and India.
Such Seriousness regarding economy in pakistan 😆 such small turnout to listen to this debate... even the online viewership is from india. look at the remarks... maximum from indians... pakistanis ar'nt serious about their economy...
Majority of Pakistanis don't speak or understand English that this video is in.
The ones that do, have jumped the boat and are in London, Canada and Australia. Pakistan is a country they are embarrassed about and many identify themselves as Indian.
Establishment control most of your business/industry ( they are doing business in every industry - look at fauji foundation etc.) and since they get subsidy and tax advantage...which is very high barriers for new entrants in the industry.
IN Pakistan, When companies are doing business overseas, they do not want to be based in Pakistan. They'd rather open a company in Dubai and then keep the money there. This needs to change. Now that Dubai has introduced corporate tax, this can be a great opportunity for Pakistan to attract back the businesses.
No point in discussion if everything is mostly headed by Pak retired generals.
Pakistan was doing well as long as the US needed them…..then, religious fundamentalism and the US losing all interest in propping up Pakistan became a double whammy. Religious fundamentalism now is the root cause for the poor state of the economy in Pakistan….
Lekin terrorism business to bohot bada he apka... Bohot naam he aapka...isko america me export karo, apko bohot dollars milenge..
We want more program like this whare we discussed our different problems
Punjabi Hindu/Sufi culture is bashing rich or businesses as cruel blood suckers.
I am no one from Hong Kong but whenever I visit my Indian Punjab village people think i must have done some illegal activities to just make a proper house and a good car.
Noone beats cycle wala during accidents even every one know blame lies with cycle guy, more hate you get richer you are.
the reason is 23:21
The last guy telling story of training people in IT seems quite innocent. Why he didn't sign a bond with them to work for his company for 2 years and train 2 more employees (each) before leaving. This way, he could have lots of fresh blood and people leaving him after 2 years won't ask for pay rise for being senior... Also, these people then send dollars back home anyway. It is a win win situation for everyone.
Religion is a sixth century politico-militant doctrine. Religion is always use as mode of conquest. In Abrahamic religion indulging in any activity or thought which temporarily or permanently stops oneself from thinking about god or following gods commandments is forbidden to keep the followers in military discipline that's why questioning the belief (checking historic authenticity, scientific study) , idol worship,polytheism, apostacy, prophet hood, yoga meditation, sexual feelings , non virgin, homosexuality, intoxication, music are considered biggest sin in Abrahamic religion.
A true believers biggest motivation is heaven and the only intoxication should be submission to god. Also not going to worship places, not obeying pastor ,not studying the religious books are also considered bad.
If there are a 100 discussions like these in a year, perhaps there is some hope.
Without political and economic stability business can not flourish. Other reasons are over religious fanaticism . Wrong political decisions like supporting terrorism and unnecessarily following Anti India foreign policy. Lack of strong feeling of Nationalism and above all corruption
How many major corporations did Pakistan have 30 years back? What did they produce, and where have they disappeared?
30 years ago Pakistan benefited from its alignment with the U.S for its help in containing Russia. All this produced was radicalised warriors who became redundant after the Americans walked away.
Want to know before thirty years in which sector pak was ahead of india, can any Pakistani enlightened us, according to world community per capita GDP in pakistan was higher in pak in 80's only due to USA grant ,it was only borrowed economy,same as afganistan, as long USA was there their economy was much better then pak but as soon as USA left afganistan then what about afg economy, india built its economy of its own, but unfortunately these so called economists don't ready to accept the reality, so no way, you will remain same as you now.
Stop beating around the bush..... Its over involvement islam that is the root of most problem.
Topic suld be... How can we grow terrorism industry and cousin marriage faster 😂
This is the kind of pakistan we want to see. Not the punks who want to focus on Religeon and islam and manufacture terror. Why cant you guys in business lead the country? You guys no doubt have more brains than the others that lead the country. A country is nothing different than a company. its just bigger. of course a lot bigger but still it runs like a company. you guys can do it!
Nice narratives from PIDE to continue this charade.
Good subject chosen. Appreciated from India.
32:39 pool of capital?
Even 'Islamic' banks mostly invest in government bonds.
No capital availability for SME.
Pakistan was never ahead of India even 40 years back! Just that Pakistan was getting dollars from west, borrowed economy flourished!
The answer to this debate is the people on the stage. They don’t have a deep understanding of economics or the real issues or history of pakistan.
23:35 everyone cannot be computer scientists by way of attitude.
We need civil engineers, bus drivers, nurses etc. as well. Must not forget.
Perhaps we are looking at one side of the coin.
But pakistan want jihads😂
Good vlog. Appreciated from India.
I.Ramamurthy
The reality in pakisthan that there is no person freedom for the citizens. Without freedom no country will flourish except china. Unless pakisthan free from the clutches of army, politicians and zihadist, there may not be any improvement. Also must have inclusive growth of middle class and poor class people. In reality middle class and poor class families contribution to society is very huge.
Such a low viewers on line.More than 50% are from India. Probably internet is not accesible to the masses or the programme is in English.
bro india has 2nd largest native english speaking popular in the world
for whome is this program? why not in urdu
بے شرم پنجابی اشرافیہ پاکستان کے مسائل پر انگریزی میں گفتگو کر رہے ہیں! کتنے فیصد پاکستانی ہیں جو انگریزی میں اس طرح کے پیچیدہ مباحث کو سمجھتے ہیں؟ کوئی تعجب نہیں کہ یہ ملک ڈوب رہا ہے۔ پاک فوج کی اجارہ داریوں کا کوئی تذکرہ نہیں، اس حقیقت کا کوئی تذکرہ نہیں کہ سکولوں کی اکثریت مدارس کی ہے اور وہ آپ کی نوجوان آبادی کو بالکل بیکار اور انتہائی مذہبی متعصبوں کی ایک غیر ہنر مند اور غیر پیداواری جماعت میں تبدیل کر رہے ہیں۔
These are elites and not for madrassa chaps.
@@Taqiyya-Slayerpushpendra kulshres ke bcche aa gaye.... andhbhakt from cow belt jahil Hindi states wali comments karne
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 ? Indus Civilization has close connections with cows , as Arabs have close connections with camels . Totally not offended caling me from the cow belt. Since it's our true identity coming from non violent, agrarian society.
First ask this lady to wear a Hijab/burkha and ask the men on the pannel to grow beard. How can Pakistan call itself an Islamic nation without even following basic Islamic rules? This is the reason why Allah is angry on Pakistan and Pakistan is going thorough difficult times.
Good luck
Why businesses don't flourish in Pakistan? Simple! And that is characterlessness short sightness uneducation racism linguistic bias and obove all lack of fatherly visionary leadership!
There could be several reasons
You will remain blessed like this forever in Pakistan 🙏
I think looking at the big ppt slide behind in the big screen , it can give you an idea how seriously Pakistanis take anything. Even my 15 years old niece can make much better displays with much engaging matter. That slide at the big screen is atrocious. May be Pakistanis should start with taking things seriously and stop this casual approach and become being sincere about what they are doing and then things will start improving gradually.
paxtan is # 1 in the universe in economy
From last
European and US Companies strictly do not want to transact with Pakistan
Pakistan has a business unfriendly mindset. Your nearest neighbor is india, and your trade happens through UAE.
Business environment is not condusive, religious fundamentalism, people behavior method of speaking some things which aren't encouraging business
Your country will flourish only when remove the hate emotion towards India, rather I would say just forget about India just focus on your. Terrorist business is only business which is being successful amongst very few other businesses.
1:04:30 corruption is every where
but we are involved in plunder.
These business men talk like family businessmen in 1080 in India. They were fully supported by the existing political system. Only Mr. Mehboob made some sense. But thinking that India progressed on only IT is wrong. These industrialists are protected and don’t face real competition and their dynasties are lazy and incompetent. Open all sectors. Don’t ever subsidise them expect basic sectors like agriculture and education. Govt and other establishments like military should not be on business. Govt should spend money on infrastructures like road, rail, ports and airports. Govt should deal by digitalised homogeneous and transparent system. Last but not the least , the govt should stop Jihadi business
These panelists or businessmen did not address the CORE ISSUE, which is Education and giving GOOD Education to all sectors of Pakistan.. Just average basic discussions on why and where Pakistan lacks...You won't get profitable IT sector if you don't create good engineers. You wont get successful Pharma companies if you don't produce PHDs. People only talk about India's IT sector. India is the called Pharmacy's Capital of the world with highest Global sales which is more than USA. FINALLY @1:04 One of the panelist spoke about Education and giving good education and that was at time when they were ending the discussion. I could see the students/crowd were not interested and whoever stood up to ask questions were really Stupid Dumb questions. Just buying Arms and Planes will not get Pakistan its economic freedom. You need to get out of ""Hate India" mindset and create more Entrepreneurs and the government should back them which will create more jobs and economic freedom. Best Wishes and Good Luck
They're thinking IT/BT as Bhelpuri cart😆😆, have no idea how long it takes to establish a company like Wipro or Infosys. You need a qualified employee to dot the job not a madarsa certified engineer.
FYI: Pakistan have some IT companies and they're struggling to make a difference, many are in the verge of closure due to quality issue, trust and cheat.
In Pakistan people dont understand this foreign language. All viewers are Indians whose hunger for knowledge if any from any quater is welcome .
Now these people want to ape Indians in every fields where they are successful . Do they know the level of knowledge and mindset of Indians .
Pakistan is 5th or 6th Largest producer of cotton in the world, Guess who is number one…😂 it’s India. China, India and US are top 3 in the world
That guy representing Pakistani Textile Industry said Pakistan is the largest producer of cotton in the world 😂
Such an enlightened discussion in Pakistan ?
No real business will flourish in any society obsessed with anachronistic customs and beliefs.
😂😂😂 businesses they already have terrorist industry department
Intolerance against other religion avoiding pakistani businesses to rise..
The anchor should not give her opinions rather moderate the talk
جو بزنس بھی کامیاب ہوتا ہے تو طاقتور لوگ اس بزنس پہ قبضہ کر لیتے ہیں تو کسی کو کیا ضرورت ہے کہ یہاں بزنس کرے؟؟؟
bro business is pretty much important for busyness
50:55 Nobody dared to answer my man here.
Why are we discussing Pakistan ??
😂😂😂😂abbe sale
Ye Pakistan ka hi channel he , tu bahar se aya he
Why this keep coming in my timeleine? Neither i follow nor i am interested about Pakistan.
Govt needs to perform its role by providing law and order for its citizens. That alone will encourage businesses to invest