The Messed Up Origins of Rumpelstiltskin | Fables Explained - Jon Solo
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- Let's break down the messed up history of one of the most famous VILLAINS in fairytale history: Rumpelstiltskin! His legacy goes back much farther than you thought... ಠ_ಠ
► Support the series on Patreon!
www.patreon.co...
► Want more?
» Messed Up Origins: bit.ly/MessedU...
» Disney Explained: bit.ly/DisneyE...
» Fables Explained: bit.ly/FablesE...
» Mythology Explained: bit.ly/Mytholo...
» Messed Up Murders: bit.ly/MurderP...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
► Social Media:
• Twitter: / jonsolo
• Instagram: / jonsolo
• Facebook Fan Page: / therealjonsolo
• Official Subreddit: / jonsolo
► Join the Official Channel Discord:
» / jonsolo
Business: (NOT for theory recommendations!)
biz@messeduporigins.com
If you have a theory you'd like me to talk about you can comment down below OR share it on my official subreddit! Please do not send it to my business email :)
► Sources:
• Brothers Grimm Version: www.pitt.edu/~...
• "The Name of the Helper" Stories: www.pitt.edu/~...
► Music Sources:
• REVEALING MY INTRO SONG! • REVEALING MY INTRO SONG!
• Background Music: Killing Time Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
#MessedUpOrigins #Rumpelstiltskin #FablesExplained
The moral of Rumplestiltskin is clear enough: Always look for loopholes in your contracts, and exploit them without shame.
I first learned the word,"loophole,"from the first Rumplestiltskin cartoon I saw.(Fractured Fairy Tales)
😂😂😂
Right!
Kurt perfect story for future lawyers lol
Yep
The dark one has always been my favorite character dearie...."All magic comes with a price dearie"
Ouat😍🤞
Lol sounds like him
QUEEEN
Sound like him Says me who has watched the whole show 6 times FOR REAL my favorite TV show
QUAT for lifw
I think the moral in the grim version was to avoid arrogance. The father's bragging almost doomed his daughter and rumple's gloating in the forest allowed the messenger to learn his name.
they were teaching kids and just ppl in general to use people and not pay up
I agree with both of you, example stories do a better job of guiding folks than telling them don't/do something... I sorta feel bad for Rumplemintz ;) since he did all the work and was not rewarded (I am NOT in support of human trafficking!) though considering when the original story was written, a servant/apprentice could likely have been brought in for quite a bit less then spools and rooms of gold.
I love delving into tales like this
Of course!
That's what I was thinking. The bragging of the father got the daughter in trouble and the bragging of Rump ended up in his actual death. That at least is what I got from Grimm version. Also be cautious of who you do deals with. There is danger when it comes time to collect. You may or may not be able to pay in the future. She just lucked out because of Rumps arrogance.
Yeah, why did the daughter have to pay?!
I remember asking my sister what was the moral of the story and she told me "Probably don't make deals you can't keep".
"Dont write a check your ass cant cash" is what my southern great grandma used to say
I get " rich people are never satisfied".
DeathSerpent "don't write checks your tush can't cash" is what I learned from Otto's dad on rocket power
I remember the saying"Don't let your mouth write a check your butt can't cash!"
Amen
"Ach wie gut, dass niemand weiß,
dass Ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß!"
I never realised that the song only works in german (edit: works in dutch and other northern european languages too!) and people who read the translated version missed out on an iconic rhyme.
He quotes lots of lazy translations. I'm sure they could have found a version that rhymes in English
Nah, the greek translators wrote a poem that rhymed. I don't remember what it was because I was 8 or 9 when I read it, but I do remember pissing my γιαγιά (grandma) off cause I kept singing it to her.
@@stephjovi Even if it there is a english version that rhymes, and I do have seen/read some, I personally find myself a little more fascinated by the german version. I don't even know why.
@@trainwhackk5321 :) well I`m Austrian so I grew up with the german versions of all the fairytales. I would guess you prefer it because it is because the original.
@@stephjovi yeah probably, good childhood memories attached etc :)
The lesson is “don’t write a check your ass can’t cash”.
Yeah. Don’t let your alligator mouth get your chicken ass in trouble.
Is how we used to talk to a boisterous loud mouth.
Pretty much huh.
Well!!!!!!
PRECISELY.
Actually, looking at todays world, that’s a good lesson to teach
The moral is dont brag
The father “brags” about his daughter
And then rumple “brags” about getting her kid
Morgyn Kivimaa rumple brags about no one knowing his name and foolishly singing it aloud
The moral of the story is about the power someone has over you once they know your name
Sounds like trump
@@derpderpson8803 You may actually be right. In magical lore names (True names) have power. It's how you invoke or banish supernatural creatures. But I think modern depictions fixate on the "Don't brag" version of the moral.
I think the moral is don’t do deals with the devil
The best version of Rumplestiltskin is the one from Once Upon a Time
Amen sister! 👏🏽😍
Agree
Girl yes I have watched Once Upon A Time 6 TIMES
I agree I live once upon a time I wish it had more seasons tho ❤️
Yup.
Once Upon a Time is an amazing TV series, and Rumplestiltskin is the best actor and character in the whole series. The way he say "Because we all know, every magic comes at a price!" has been imprinted forever in my mind. Absolutely stunning performance
I think the moral of Rumplestilskin is to not lie or brag about something that isn't true because you never know who will get hurt.
Don’t be a creepy father who brags about your daughters looks
And don’t exploit people’s problems to get something in return
I think the tales moral is, that words have power. to know the name of something that scares you, to call it out, that gives you power over it and reduces it's impact on you, for what we really fear most is the unknown.
In the past, when someone would find out the name of a demon, then the person would have power over the demon. They could exorcise or invoke them. I am guessing this fairy tale has it's roots in something like that type of story.
Fear is the unknown, meaning to say that what we call fear is just the brains way of processing unknown variables, with a rational end. Rational being self preservation leading to the flight or fight reaction being activated. The most common fear is nyctophobia, the fear of the dark. We don't know what's in there so our brain says " yeah no I'm cool let's stay over here"
shawn goff
Oh god I hate the dark.
It's never just the dark, it's what COULD be in the dark. Even if we can see a scary thing, sure it's still scary, but we can take the needed action to escape it while aware of where it is. As for the dark.. it surrounds you, and so could the things in it.
I think I just peed myself..
... That's deep...
Woooowww im loving this channel more...this is my 1st time in his comment sections n im totally loving it
"I'd rather just steer clear of the topic than spread potentially false information"
OMFG thank you for actually being a decent person!! 🤣 I really wish more UA-camrs would hold themselves to that standard.
“And who knew he was a big Rihanna fan”
Omg 😂😂
Is kiara really your name?! I’ve always loved that name and of course the lion. King is my all time fave movie
Omg you here?! I watch your videos you're awesome!
The moral of the story:
instead of marrying the king, marry a little man that can TURN STRAW INTO GOLD! STRAW into GOLD!!
Paw Moo talk truth, she would be richer than the king
Omg Rumpelstiltskin was the first vsco girl wtf
Moral of the story: a woman who can spin, is worth her weight in gold?
I would have married Rumplestiltskin 🤣
Yup exactly
German here. In German it kinda rhymes. Also I’ve grown up with the “creepy origins” . So in the version I grew up with the father was drunk and kinda flexing on the people in this tavern . So this rumor gets to the king who in this type of time is really in need of money. They also say they cut the fathers head of for lying or his daughter or both . He keeps lying cause at this point he knows he’ll die . He rather sacrifices his daughter. Then as you told I just know the detail that all the artefacts she gave Rumpelstilzchen
We’re from her mother that died. also in the german Version i know the father after is really bitter cause he and his relatives are really poor and his daughter now married the kings son.
Also pretty creepy: in German the rhyme includes Rumpelstilzchen actually singing that he is planning to eat this child . Good research I just guess in Germany they added more details or maybe some got lost in translation.
ManGo away That’s the version I know too, I don’t even know where I heard it
Off topic, But I'm trying to learn german!
Ah thank you, I've been trying to find origin stories of why he wanted the baby at all. and this is one of the first times I've heard any reason given.
@Vicodyn yeah most of our stories are pretty gruesome in their origins. The 'funny' thing is most of these we get told as cautionary tales. And you're right there are actually a lot of tales that involve childrens hands getting cut off...
As a Child i was a little bit Confused because of the Sentence "Heute koch ich, Morgen brau ich, übermorgen stehle ich der Königin ihr Kind". And didn't thought that he would eat it
In German he sings:
"Heute back ich
morgen brau ich
Übermorgen hol ich mir der Königin ihr Kind.
Ach wie gut das niemand weiß,
das ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß."
The last part is rhyming in german. Also the germans see the moral of Rumpelstiltsken, that you shouldn't make deals with the devil! It doesn't pay out well, because the queen can't find the solution on her own. ^^
Interesting, the 3rd line i remember as
“und das kind der königin klau ich“
wich does ryhme in german
+Jonny Q That would be so much better, but I remember it as "Übermorgen hol ich mir der Königin ihr Kind" too because I remember thinking that this sounded strange
how can she find the solution she either dies or doesn't i would pick the latter
AWESOME... Also look at my last name 🙂
I feel like the moral is if you have sensitive information that can result in a big pay off keep your mouth shut.
In the book I used to have the rhyme went something like..."Today I bake, tomorrow I'll clean. I'm going to take the child from the queen. She'll never win this little game, for Rumpelstiltskin is my name!"
In another book I have called Grimm's Complete Fairy Tales the rhyme goes...
"Today do I bake, tomorrow I brew,
The day after that the Queen's child comes in;
And oh! I am glad that nobody knew
That the name I am called is Rumpelstiltskin!"
at least its catchy
The one I know from my german fairy tale book is:
Ach wie gut dass niemand weiß,
dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß
Ach wie gut dass niemand weiß,
dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß
it actually rhymes but doesnt say as much
roughly translated It is:
Oh how good that no one knows,that my Name is Rumpelstilskin,
Oh how good that no one knows,that my Name is Rumpelstilskin
@@noctilucera7585 there's actually a part before that which goes
"Heute back ich, morgen brau ich,
Übermorgen hol ich der Königin ihr Kind"
Which is the same as
"Today I bake, tomorrow I brew,..."
@@wandalouise7585 I see! I cannot remember that part, next time I have to check my childhood book again, thank you.
Oh another moral: don’t sing your name if someone needs to know your name
He was so happy because in the German translation he was going to eat the baby the next day
@@MoejiiOsmanTV damn wtf
Rumpelstiltskin -- *Top 10 Strongest Characters Who Can Defeat Thanos (Even In Infinity Gauntlet)*
No one snaps their fingers at me daerie. No one.
@@ericgeddes3353 Yeah that's what I'd expect also right before this
Rumple- *snaps the gauntlet to him* Now let's make a deal
And then Belle dumps him again after he uses the gauntlet
@@wolfduckstudios yes
Agreed, the Gauntlet may be powerful...but I've seen Rumple steal something right out of someone's hands with just a snap of the fingers.
If he wanted, Rumple could steal it from Thanos and send the Avengers back in the past with the Time Stone
Friendship what about the sun from super Mario Bros 3
I think the father or the King is the real Villain of this story than Rumpelstilskin.
Breeze Devlin did u know that perter pain is runpluskin father
Rose_ Buildz No where do you hear that from?
Breeze Devlin the show once apon a time am watching it now btw ITS RLLY good it’s about fairytails if u watched it u would under Peter Pan not a good a person
Ok
Breeze Devlin good show recommend it
"The Rumpelstiltskin Problem" by Vivian Vande Velde is perhaps the most entertaining collection of retellings (from the hilarious to the heartbreaking) of this fairytale. She does well to point out, "Why the heck would a guy who can spin a whole room full of straw into gold do it in exchange for a tiny ring?" The short "Straw into Gold" was worth the whole book itself.
Rumplestiltskin, "hello dearie"
My favorite OUAT character.
@@Hinatachan360 you my friend have great taste in characters so here is like from me
I LOVE ONCE UPON A TIME!!!!!!!!
OUTA is life, but who's the best character?
Robert Carlyle...physical proof that you can be attracted to and creeped out by his character Rumplestiltskin
I sometimes find it difficult to see Rumplestiltskin as the _bad_ guy in all this. I feel like the king and the miller are the ones that screwed the poor girl over! Anywho, my favorite adaptation of the tale is the Britannica one.
agreed.
Simsala Grimm version is my childhood.
Definitely the greedy king is the main villain. The Miller next just for lying. The girl was put in a bad situation, and should have stated to Rumplestiltskin to take the life of the king. She should have never agreed to having the child being a bargain piece, and Rumplestiltskin makes no sense to sing out loud his name.
Rumpelstiltskin is wrong too, why tf would he want her baby? it's weird and suspect
I see Rumplestiltskin as the victim in this story. Not only did he help someone who was not even thankful enough to ask him his name but he was swindled out of his payment for his hard work. Since he is obviously quite ugly hes not going to be having children of his own so I can see why he would want one.
I think not having loose lips is the actual moral. The father, daughter & Rumplestiltskin (also another trio) each had to face some consequence/regret for shooting their mouth off to/around the wrong person.
Me: sees Once Upon A Time Rumplstiltskin *internally screams* ❤️
Born To Ship VICTUURI! yeah because it’s so bad
Right
Same 💙
Imagine me watching this series for the first time and him and grahm are my favorites
We stan! lol
Moral of the story: Know every single living being's name in the world.
or at least the most dumbest and outlandish names
EVER.
Eh, more like don't lie about your own abilities so you don't get involved in some mess.
@性爱Minniebby That is true, but I meant in a general sense; don't let others lie about you either (unknowingly or not) or problems will occur. Apologies for wording it a bit oddly in my initial comment. (• ▽ •;)
I definitely do think the story meant for the father to look like a fool in some regard since, unless magic knowingly exists to the public and is accepted, who would feasibly say their daughter could spin gold from hay? He could've been seen as a lunatic, lol. It's a fairy tale and obviously there's magic involved but only with Rumpelstiltskin. Makes ya wonder what goes through the mind of some of these characters, haha.
@@Foirelle how do you not let people lie about you if it is done "unknowingly" to you?
There’s this version I read in Arabic when I was younger that was kind of similar to this and it goes like:
Once upon a time there was a widow that lived alone with her beautiful young daughter, but this daughter was very lazy. One day, the old widow baked 5 kaaks (some sort of bread) and left them by the chimney to cool off. Her daughter was walking through the house when she saw them chilling by the chimney so she decided to take a piece and eat it. And after 10 minutes she came by for another piece, and so on until all the 5 whole breads were gone.
When the old widow finished working, she called on her daughter to bring the bread so they would eat together, and that’s when the girl confessed what she had done. Her mother, furious, went out and continued working all the while singing this song whining about her daughter’s laziness (I don’t remember the song but it was something like “my daughter ate 5 full loafs of bread” or something like that).
After a while, an expensive carriage passed by, and in it was the king of the land they lived in. The young man heard the old widow singing this beautiful song but couldn’t make out the words. So he came closer and asked the lady about those lyrics. The widow, ashamed of her daughter’s laziness changed the lyrics to something like “my daughter made 5 golden like, those weaving things idk what they’re called in one day”. The king, amazed, asked the old lady to send her daughter to the palace and told her that he’s marry her daughter if she could make him 5 of those golden weaving things for one year.
Skip to when the girl finally arrives to the King’s castle. The king locks her in a room and tell her to make him give of those things for tomorrow or else he’d kill her (romantic much).
Night came and the girl gave up on finding a way to make those things so she started crying.
From her window came a little, ugly man that asked her why she was crying and she told him her story, so he made a deal with her.
Everyday he’s being her 5 of those gold thingies and she’s have three chances to guess his name, if one year passes and she couldn’t guess his name, he’s take her firstborn child.
And so one for months, every morning he’d bring her the 5 golden weaved things and she’s try to guess his name, but to no avail. By the time she was near the end of her one year sentence, she married the king and was pregnant with their child.
One day before the end of the one year, the young woman was growing worried because she still couldn’t figure out the name of that little man. And that night, the king invited her to a dinner in the grand ball for pre-celebration of her release.
They talked and talked, but the king could see that his wife was worried, he’d asked what was wrong but she’d say nothing. She asked him about his day and he told her about that funny thing that happened to him today while coming back from his hunting trip.
He told her that he saw a funny young man dancing by the fire and singing an odd song “No one can guess my name it’s _-insert odd name here-_ “.
The woman was elated. She finally figured out that little man’s name.
That night, which was the last night of her weaving things for the king, she told the little man his name. The odd man, shocked by how she knew his name, fell on the floor and in a fit of anger, ripped himself to shreds.
And the girl and her king (and their little baby girl) lived happily ever after...
God I loved that book. Also if you made it this far, you’re the best!
P.S: sorry if there is any typos I’m NOT proofreading that I’m too lazy to do so. Also, if he already talked about this in the video, I’m sorry I’m still in the beginning of the video and I’m NOT deleting that comment ever, it took way too long to write!
Have a good day/ night ❤️
Love this story! Thank you for taking your time to write all of this! 😁😁
❤️
Rumpelstiltskin needs to see a therapist because he has some really crazy anger issues.
Thanks for sharing! I loved it ❤
@@lavinialadlass9432😂😂😂 Psychopathic rage.
Don't brag/lie or you get left out of the rest of your daughter's story.
Trinka B I would have cut him off too if I were her 🤷🏻♂️
Ohhh so THAT'S the moral
@@JonSolo very early version of ghosting. A lot of dads in these are horrid parents!
@@nurailidepaepe2783 it's pretty well hidden.
Your channel is so underrated, so much research has gone into all your videos, and your videos never fail to entertain me!
The K Channel - When you're right, you're right. Great post. 🤗from this🍁gal
I also concur. I can watch for days 😍
*"I WOULDN'T EVEN TALK TO LUCIFER IN PUBLIC!"*
I'm a simple person. I see Once Upon a Time... I click, dearie.
Sameee
Such a cringe meme.
YoU FEeD thE MaDnEss, It feEdS oN YOu...
In a creative writing class many years ago, we were asked to reimagine a well known story from a different point of view. I chose this one, and in mine, Rumplestiltskin was a sympathetic character who wanted the child to raise as his own and teach his craft to. ( I don't think I've read a version that says why he wants the child). I made the princess as a greedy and spoiled child who was prone to manipulation.
It was fun to look at it from a different perspective.
That's how I have always viewed the story.
Yeah I really never thought about that. chances are the young child may grow up to be as greedy as his father and become a bad ruler or Rumpelstiltskin was an alchemist and may have wanted to raise the boy as his apprentice.
In the version I was told as Child Rumpelstilzchen wanted to eat the Baby
I also know the version where he wants to eat the child.
The chanting around the fire seems like he‘s preparing a feast. „today i‘m brewing, tomorrow i‘m baking...“
Holy crap! I would love to read that!
I grew up with two different versions, this version is one of them. In the other version, she was told the king's proposition when he arrived home, plus the deal was for her to marry the king's son instead and, when Rumplestiltskin gave her the three days to learn his name, she went straight to her husband (he was the baby's father after all) fearing to be put to death but, the prince loved her very much and he was the one who sent out the man to learn the name, which upon learning, he told his wife. What I don't understand is, upon hearing the miller's lie, why didn't the king suspect anything amiss? .... I mean really, a miller has a daughter that can spin straw into gold yet the miller remains poor and doesn't have her spin any gold for neither themselves nor any of their neighbors or friends, yet he'll lie to the king.....Just sounds odd to me. It's always been one of my favorite fairy tales though. Nice video.
Rumpelstiltskin aka The Dark One aka Beast is the most awesome OUAT character.
The trickster of heart
That entire series is genius.
Don't forget being the son of Peter Pan :P
Moral of story nothing is free
Unless you have spies to trick a singing nigga to give up his name. That's just obvious, duh!
@@peebay3515 You still gotta pay the spy for his work. Everything has a price, dearie
@@sarmaangel True but she probably was a massive whore who paid her bills on her back.
"Wife, how did you get him to call off the baby-taking?"
"I just guessed his name, I swear!!! I didn't have to like... scream it out or fake any orgasms or anything..."
ulysses 300 trueeeee!! It's a good moral
I think the adult version his name is actually “Rinkledforeskin”
Oh no
A classic
What the, actual fuck
Where is this version at???
Hahaha
As soon as I saw rumple I clicked fast then you can say “hey” 😂😂 “all magic comes with a price”
That was an excellent device for the show!
Ha ha dearie all magic comes with a price
Magic comes with a price, dearie! My favorite character on "Once Upon A Time" was Mr. Gold. When my sister first got into it she freaked out that I said that. Now she loves my impression of him.
Mr. Gold is awesome :)
Mr. Gold was my favorite as well as long as Captain Hook. I loved when he called him the crocodile.
Mr. Gold not only makes a great and complex character, he us also the embodiment of the Dark side of what Majik, or in fiction"magic" really entails, that anything provided comes at a cost from somewhere.....
I know he was my favourite character
He's TERRIFYING and AWESOME at the same time. I HOPE BELLE GETS HET MEMORIES BACK D:
Totally agree with you Jon, Robert Carlyle's version of Rumpelstiltskin is definitely my favourite :) The writing on that show was so good at interweaving him into every fairytale as the REAL villain, behind the wicked stepmothers and evil queens, and dastardly pirates...(and then season 7 happened, but we don' talk about season 7) :)
I'll make note, then
~Season 7 bad~
Anything else I should know before I watch the series? Do the other 6 seasons have problems?
Hansel and Gretel next?
Yaaaaaassss
YES
I just love Grensel and Hatel
and remember ...
magic _always_ comes with a price dearie !
I haven't seen once upon a time in so long, thanks for the memories 😂😂
Lupe 😂😂😂
I've always thought it was terrible that she would have to marry a man who would kill her for such a frivolous reason--king or not.
Look on the bright side - she gets to be Queen, and her son is next in line to be King.
I mean what choice does she have?
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh dude i have been waiting for a rumpelstiltskin i never think i would saw those words
On the third day she's starting with Hinz and Kunz which is basically the German version of Tom, Dick and Harry. "Hinz und Kunz" are as far as I know only used in that saying, I never ever heard someone being called by these names. Btw they stand for Heinrich or short Heinz and Konrad.
About Rumpelstilzchen name:
rumpeln = to rumble
Stelzen = stilts
Stilzchen = small or short stilts (referring to his legs)
Stelzen is also linked to the German verb "stolzieren" which means to walk proudly. The story deals with narcissistic characters that use one another. The father wants to fool the king to get his daughter married to him, the daughter makes promises of giving her child away to save herself and the king is in for the gold. The most narcissistic character however is Rumpelstiltskin and he pays a price - dies by rumbling his short stilts (er rumpelt die Stilzchen).
The last name of a friend of mine actually is Kunz.
Hinz und Kunz were the most common first names around the millenial (1000ad) in Germany. Over half of the male population had that name. If i would have to guess how a Person at that time is called i would go for Hinz (Shortform of Heinrich btw) or Kunz, too.
I Know the Term hinz und Kuntz, its very common in Berlin.
Thank you. In Dutch the name doesn’t make any sense
this is the best explanation i’ve ever seen
Once Upon A Time (minus the last season) is an amazing show. The Rumplestiltskin interpretation was amazing.
I love his hand pose
Season 7 was my favorite personally
“He turned into a bird and started singing around his own name, as one does” 😂😂
Sir Robert Carlyle is amazing as Rumple!
Stefanie Medina he soooooooooo is
He is🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Yes ma'am he is. He's amazing in everything he does.
Sorry I have Dib's
or does rumple play him?
In Once upon a time Rumpelstiltskin was just a simple man, a coward actually, and then he became "The Dark One" by stabbing the last Dark One with the Kris dagger (which is a half of Excalibur, and the perso who has it can control The Dark One), because he wanted to protect his son, Baelfire, from the ogres war, but then the power and the darkness overwhelmed him so he become evil, and later he lost his son through a portal in our world, and than after some years he went to a kingdom to make a deal with the king, that he'll make the king win the ogres war in exchange for his daughter, Belle (yes, from The Beauty and The Beast), so he can make her his maid forever, but after some time they fell in love! That's pretty much his story, and now the thing about him the girl who had to spin straw into gold: it happened long before he met Belle, and as this girl was locked in a tower, and told that if she doesn't turn the all the straw into gold by morning she'll be killed, and than, as Rumple has a weakness for deals, he appeared in the tower and told her that he'll do the job for her in exchange for her first born child, but she told him that she wants to learn how to do it, not just he to do it, so they made the deal, he kept visiting her on the castle, and after a while they fell for each other, so he asked her if she wanted to change the deal, so she wouldn't have to give her first born child to him anymore, she had to make a child with him, she agreed, but after some time she ripped her own heart out and put it in a box so she could not be able to feel again (there, the people with magic could've ripped hearts out without killing the respective people or themselves b as long as they keep the heart they could control the person), so she tricked him and married with the king, so she was the only one who broke a deal with him, oh and also the girl was named Cora, The Queen of Hearts which is also Regina's/The Evil Queen's mother, (the one from the Snow White fairy tale), if ye'd like to watch the series, know that there is a half of season about The Dark One! I recommend it! (P.S. Idk who needed to know that but I felt like had to explain it when I got the chance :)))))
Don’t forget that his parents were Peter Pan and the black fairy
as a german, attending english classes, I really admire ur vocabulary
>uses ur
Jesus Christ correct me If I am wrong, but I do believe that “your vocabulary” isn’t wrong
Suii Chann actually your is a possessive variation of you, ur is colloquial (slang) but understandable.
a hellenic pagan Oh okay, thanks :)
Jesus Christ actually the fact that she can use slang comfortably shows she can speak English well, as opposed to being overly formal and sounding somewhat awkward.
The song did get messed up in translation, I'm German and in the original he sings:
Heute back ich,
Morgen brau ich,
Übermorgen stehle ich der Königin ihr Kind.
Ach wie gut, dass niemand weiß,
Dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß.
Still not the best song but at least it rhymed in the end.
Jumpie Studios
It, honestly sounds good. Just, a bit mesy on the final two verses personally, but hey...I’m no lyracist...
The song rhymed in the version i heard this is the only part I remembered "soon i will no longer play this silly game rumpelstiltskin is my name
Ay another german 😂 bu i think it's not so bad
Funny, i wanted to write the same. Translating from german can be quite difficult, and i once saw a fan translation of 7 Zwerge-Männer alleine im Wald. ironically the hunter scene was less offensive translated.
,,Bring me the Trapper" No, not the Rapper, the Trapper".
Oh ich habe gehofft, dass wer das kommentiert 😊
Off the top I agree: Robert Carlyle made me excited about the depths a fantasy can go in a way that I hadn't felt since childhood reading the classics (at least not with something other than Anime). His version added SO much depth to the character in the first few seasons!
Please do an episode on the rule of 3, and please start including the Aarne-Thompson index numbers for the tales you discuss.
Dude Once Upon a Time is the most craziest, amazing show I have ever seen. I recommend it
AYYYYYYYY ONCE UPON A TIME FAM
The only show I liked better then that is supernatural check it out if you haven’t already the first 2 seasons are slow but then it gets really really good
@@arktitan6225 I warched all of it and it kinda repeats the same thing over and over
Yessss. I watched all the seasons at least 10 times 😂
CrystalRose Martinez ooo. Same. I love seeing a Oncer out in the open
And as my friend would say: "All magic comes with a price, dearie"
I love the story tale and the character in Once Upon A Time
Moral of the story, dont do a deal with the devil
nicolochan leo exactly
Cuphead
@@fresdea that game is awesome
No thats Faust
Apparently all these people did and got away with it though...
To quote Lisa Simpson; "There is no moral! It's just a bunch of stuff that happens."
Justme Stillme favourite comment
Firstly, I completely agree with you about " Once Upon A Time". One of my favorite shows, and Rumpel, or "The Dark One" is a character that is constantly changing. Secondly, my favorite rendition of the story has to be Terry top. Great job!
Mike Cann “Constantly changing” we call that character derailment.
@@shrekisthebestfranchiseand5032 whatever, yt-e
Moral of the story, don’t make any deals. Nothing is worth losing something precious.
I loved Robert Carlyle's version of Rumple his is my favorite version of Rumplestillkin.
When I hear Rumple the first thought of mine is Once Upon a time
SAME thats the best show lol
Did anyone else only click on this because of the once upon a time with ouat. Im slightly obsessed with robert carlyle now. 😅😅. Also cuz jon solo. But i am obsessed with ouat
This actually convinced me that UA-cam is cyber stalking me D: (I watch OUAT on the T.V. as well as UA-cam)
Dude omg I got into OUAT over the summer and I’m still obsessed. Rumple has been my favorite TV villain since aaaa
In German the song he sings accually rimes :)
"Ach wie gut, dass niemand weiß, dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß'"
"Oh so good that nobody knows, that my name is Rumpelstilzchen"
I was singing this in the tone of die woodys fichtl's lied haha
Remember dearie, all magic comes with a price
Robert Carlyle deserved an Emmy for his portrayal of Rumpelstiltskin
"All magic comes with a price Dearie" - The dark one
And that millers daughter ended up being the queen of hearts. And the evil queens mother
ONCE UPON A TIME
My mum's not deaf, but she was learning sign language for a while, and my first experience of this story was watching a video cassette compilation as a child called "Story Time in Sign" where various stories were verbally narrated, as well as having a person on the screen signing the story and standing in front of (presumably) a green screen, where images to do with the story were shown. I don't know why, I just really enjoyed listening to the story and watching it in sign language as well. That's a particularly fond childhood memory of mine.
That's dope n I get it...wen I was in like 1st grade I got really into Greek mythology n i found a book of it in sign language n have always been interested in it since....I take taught some of my best friends in elementary school n we communicated all da time like across da cafeteria n stuff it was fun....I honestly wish it was like a second standard to know just to know pol... N the deaf community is pretty freakn awesome! They r some of da realist people u want to meet!
That later version, when everything that he spun turns into ash, made me think about something not really being "yours" unless you work for it.
I had to write a play for a children's development class based on Rumpelstiltskin last year. The morals of the story that I saw were fairly obvious, "don't lie" and "don't make deals with the devil"
You should definitely read “Rump the true story of Rumpelstiltskin” in my opinion it is a very good and very magical book. it talks about how he discovered his full name and the power it has✨
legstring...
Legstring...
LEGSTRING...
*LEG STRING*
Angelic Melody G STRING
I’m so sry I couldn’t resist
I think the most interesting modern retelling and my personal favorite: in elementary school I read a book called ‘Rumplestiltskin’s Daughter’. Basically in this version, when Rumple asks for her first born when she becomes queen, the Miller’s Daughter is like ‘nah, I don’t want to marry this jerk who locked me away and forced me to spin gold. But I like you, how about we get married?’ And they do and the rest of the story is about their daughter teaching the same king to not be greedy. Weird, but I always thought it was kind of sweet.
"Rumpelstiltskin"! :-D So funny! Didn´t know that! The name originally is "Rumpelstilzchen". That "chen" at the end is a minimization, meaning: "Little Rumpelstilz". "Rumpel" is onomatopoetical for something rumbling. The part "Stilz" is a real surname in Germany but the meaning of it is not known. So this man supposedly is Mr. Stilz who is often clattering around and Rumpestilzchen means "Little rumbling Stilz". Could be an opener in a horror series: Camera moves close to a doorbell with the name Stilz on it...
Concerning the rhyme: In German it goes like this:
"Heute back ich, morgen brau ich,
übermorgen hol ich der Königin ihr Kind;
ach, wie gut, dass niemand weiß,
dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß!"
That falls into two segments:
"Heute back ich, morgen brau ich,
übermorgen hol ich der Königin ihr Kind;
" does not rhyme and is all about the rhythm and metric and the rule of three (today, tomorrow, the day after tomorrow).
"Heute back ich, morgen brau ich,
" is trochaic (heavy-light: _ . ).
"übermorgen hol ich der Königin ihr Kind;" is complicated but emphasises "Kind" (child) in the metric this way: _ . . . _
The second segment
"ach, wie gut, dass niemand weiß,
dass ich Rumpelstilzchen heiß!" also deals with the trochaic metrum while "Rumpelstilzchen heiß" sticks out as "Königin ihr Kind" with the same metric (_ . . . _).
But this segment on the contrary to the former rhymes (as can be seen): "weiß" (knows) with "heiß" (is my name).
This little piece of poetry alone shows how well the Grimms where educated and skilled (as professors for German language).
Hope you read this, Jon: I put a bit of brain cells in here! ;-)
And the version I remember goes;
Today I brew,tomorrow I bake
And then the child away I'll take.
Little knows the royal dame
That Rumplestiltskin is my name.
@@richardranke7878 I would say a good translation wich puts a rhyme where originally none was.
Ich kenne versionen wo er singt
... übermorgen das Kind der Königin klau ich
@@Stephanie8uv6vnfi Oh! Kenne ich nicht. Interessant!
Sounds good, but it's a little simpler than that.
About Rumpelstilzchen name:
rumpeln = to rumble
Stelzen = stilts
Stilzchen = small or short stilts (referring to his legs)
(Crosses Rumplestilskin off)
Left on the list
- Bluebeard
- Chicken Little
- Puss'n Boots
- The Ugly Ducking
- Hanzel and Gretel
- Jack and the Bean stalk
- Robin Hood
- Jack and Jill
- Alice in Wonderland
(- Insert Fable or tale)
Moana should definitely be on the list
Boku no Pico
There is one similar story you didn't cover that has a happy ending. I can't remember the girl's name but she too was forced to spin star into gold. She cried and three fares show up and offer to do this for her in exchange for her necklace the first time and her ring the second. On the third time, they say she has to invite them to her wedding. She does so and introduced them to the king. He asks the first fairy why her lip is so big she stated it was to wet the straw to spin it. He asks the second fairy why her hands are so big? She says twirling the straw. He asks the last one why her feet are so big and she said it was to press the pedal to spin the wheel. The king appalled by this forbids his queen from ever using a spinning wheel again and they live happily ever after.
guys but we can't forget about kugerl and his no pants policy
YES
Also 23rd like!
yesssss Rumple from OuaT is the BEST, I'm glad you put him in the thumbnail otherwise I might not have clicked on this vid haha
@Vicodyn matter*
I agree with you about Once Upon a Time. I LOVE the Rumplestiltskin character as portrayed. And that series was amazing
12:02 “England”
*show a picture of the uk*
*proceeds to show Wales*
Namē uhhhm
Same with Sweeden. 🤫
That is NOT Sweeden. That's Sweeden AND Norway! :/
I love it when non-german ppl try to pronounce german names😂
American here. When I was in college I worked with a lady from Germany. I was trying to connect with her, so I told her my grandfather's family was from Cologne. She went on a rant about how irritating it is that Americans can't be bothered to learn the proper pronunciation of names and places in other countries. Whoa! I had never even heard it pronounced any other way, so how would I know I wasn't saying it right? I didn't talk to her much after that.
ok, pronounce correctly it for us.
Sorry i was born in America and only know and speak English
Mentally Disturbed Science oh no, I am so sorry for your bad experience.. but don’t worry not all Germans are like that. Just don’t give up by learning the language. I’m always impressed if someone tries his/her best. :D
Lol Ikr it’s so cute when they pronounce it wrong🥺
If I were to explain rumpelstiltskin’s relationship to every character in OUAT we would be here all day. Husband to belle, father to baelfire, grandfather to Henry Mills (who is the grandson of Snow White and Prince Charming, great grandson/adoptive son to Regina mills aka the evil queen), SON OF PETER PAN (who is evil) AND THE BLACK FAIRY, former lover of the queen of hearts (who is also the evil queen’s mother), and the list goes on. Love that you mentioned that version of the character
Whenever someone or something read “dearie” I swear to you I read it in the dark ones accent
I remember choosing this story for storytelling lesson and I actually sang the silly song:
Tomorrow I brew, today i bake, and the child away I take.
For a little deem, my royal dame,
That rumplestiltskin is my name!
(better rhymes, at least)
So she married a king but didn’t marry someone who can turn Straw to gold
I mean Rumpelstiltskin treated her better than that murderous King. I bet he would also make a better father
*Fun Fact:* There was a scrapped Disney version of Rumpelstiltskin where the title character is a babysitter who wants to know about family other than a villain himself.
I kinda like this concept but it's kinda sad it was forgotten from scratch.
Friendship sounds like how a serial killer would attempt to find love
@@stephsmanicshenanigans8017 True. If only Disney will have a chance to get this fairy tale on the spotlight.
Also, I did enjoyed Rumpelstiltskin from Shrek 4.
Yeah and I liked the character in once upon a time. It would need to be a new character of him though to make it successful imo. Like puss in boots didn’t really do well by himself but with shrek it was hilarious
oh, bummer. I thought you said "Rumpelforskin"..
oh, too...If you pull his hoodie down three times, he'll spit on you.
Why would he need the skin around your neck?? Eegh.
@@dankshadow7101 Um
*whispers* Someone doesn't get the circumcision joke...
Why would he take the skin off they're neck when he could cut off someone's foreskin? That would be more fitting for his name! Lmao xD
Rumplestiltskin and Captain Hook's Alligator from the original Grimm's Fairytales were combined into one amazing character for Once Upon a Time's Robert Carlyle to play with. He was brilliant.
I always hated the story of Rumpelstiltskin (okay as a child it actually scared me) but as an adult it upset me because as John pointed out she wasn't a bad person but she wasn't good either... That's why I liked Duffy and the Devil story so much... Would not have even known that version existed if not for this chanel so thanks Jon.... I'm curious if you have read any of the fables graphic novels? If so what did you think?
She was a teenager who was going to be killed, do you really think so lowly of children? Lol
Loved Robert Carlyle as Rumplestiltskin/ Mr. Gold
Jess M Bobby Carlyle is an amazing actor. I love him in everything I’ve ever seen him in.
The biggest plot twist in Once Upon a Time is when we found out that Peter Pan is Rumpilstiltskin’s (probably didn’t spell that right) dad and that the girl who had to spin straw into gold was the evil queen’s mom
Yeesh (spoiler alert)
I really love your sarcasm and facial expressions, Jon! So entertaining! Keep it up! 👍🏻
Rumplestilkin i didn't see the cartoon , i didn't know the vilain in shrek 4 was Rumplestilkin and i though the Rumplestilkin in the once upon a time was the beast😂
AND years later i learn who he is in a sketch on youtube from "studio c" it was very funny😂
But I never knew there was a scrapped Disney version of the story except Rumpelstiltskin is a BABYSITTER.
Also, that character from Courage the Cowardly Dog which it's Muriel's "uncle".
Chris !!! Oh my gosh!!! Same here!! I had a book about him but I did watch the studio c sketch!!!!
I just can’t understand why they made Rumplestilkstin into the Beast and why is he tall and not a dwarf?
@@willlyon7129 robert Carlyle is not tall. He is only 5'8".
He's also in the movie Happily never after.
Another great video. I always loved the "Muppets Classic Theater" version of 'Rumpelstiltskin'. Piggy plays the Miller's Daughter/Queen, Kermit is of course the king, and his 'loyal royal advisor' is the one who throws her in the dungeons after her father fabricated that she could turn straw into gold just for a chance to speak with 'the sad and lonely king', threatening each time she would be thrown into the dungeon if she failed. Gonzo is of course the "Wierd Little Man" who helps her and when he arrives and makes the agreement he'll give her three days to come up with his name, she explains to the king, her father, and the advisor what really happened and King Kermit prevents her from being thrown in the dungeon, surprising both the advisor and Piggy's father "I didn't marry her for the gold, I married her becaus I love her!" The entire Muppet Kingdom then breaks into song about how they've "Got To Get That Name" as they try and try again over the next passing days. When Piggy says it's unfair, Gonzo replies, "If life where fair, would my mother have sent me to summer camp every year of my life? If life were fair, would I have been cursed with a name like..." he stops, realizing everyone's leaned in listening for his name and laughs at them, "You almost got me." Piggy suddenly realizes he said he'd been to summer camp and orders someone to grab him, she takes a peak at the tag on his shirt and says, "There you are Ralph Lauren! Oh, no, wait.... Rumpel... Your name is Rumpelstilkstkin?"
He declairs it unfair and when Kermit asks how she knew, "Because every good mother sews her child's name into their clothes before sending them off to summer camp."
I had a crush on Rumpelstilskin in Once Apon A time. Yeah I...IDK either
Um, I like to believe that the lesson is telling us that family is the real treasure. Like the the father gave up his daughter and his daughter gave up her child.... in return its riches and what not. In thee end the real gold is family... idk...
but the daughter got gold AND family in the end.......
It is said that only children have eyesight good enough to spin the finest of gold wires in the ancient style. I think the spinning part in the stories comes from some factual piece of history, maybe harkening back to a time when child labor was used (forced) to manufacture that wire.
"What's up solo cups" - dead 💀😂
After sad shit happened to me I got excited to see this
crazy joker omg same here
Hope you feel better.
What happened? R u okay?
@@WhitneyDahlin I'm okay now I thought I was pregnant because my period was late by over a week it was almost 2 weeks late. I went all of October without a period then today had a lot of blood I was very upset.
@@Pandaperson95 I'm so sorry that must be so tough I wish you the best! *Hugs*
I love the way you give old nursery rhymes the elaboration it needs. You bring these stories life and I'm a happy subscriber! 🫶🥰🫶. Greetings from Corpus Christi , Texas.
I think you should do The Messed up Origins of Hans and Gretel/// LIKE PLEASE SO HE CAN SEE THIS
LOBSTER LINER yeah
Ella Meda Ngalibali 3
That's already pretty messed up.
YES THAT WOULD BE AMAZING!!!