Whats it like to be a string player in orchestra

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,7 тис.

  • @captainmilkman
    @captainmilkman Рік тому +14002

    Violinists play for all 2 hours of a 2-hour-long concert but the bits they get are all background bits
    Trombonists play about 5 minutes of a 2-hour-long concert but the one bit they do get is the coolest bit.

    • @nowhere1327
      @nowhere1327 Рік тому +782

      Trombonistbros, we cant stop winning

    • @mitchellfriesen4795
      @mitchellfriesen4795 Рік тому +371

      Then tubas either play 3 different notes, 10 different notes or rests for half the performance. As a highschool tuba player

    • @enriqueperezarce5485
      @enriqueperezarce5485 Рік тому +133

      @@nowhere1327Tubabros, we can’t stop winning 😂 (don’t even play tuba I play guitar and piano)

    • @formyflounders
      @formyflounders  Рік тому +766

      We also get paid so much less for so many more notes HAHAH

    • @gas9605
      @gas9605 Рік тому +38

      And there's us recorder players with just nothing

  • @EmareeVA
    @EmareeVA Рік тому +2699

    All their little bows frantically moving all at once like they're desperately trying to be heard as a tiny little army is equal parts adorable and sad 🥲

  • @Ghost._Mae
    @Ghost._Mae Рік тому +8

    “Damn, the trumpets are so loud! It’s like I can’t hear anything else!”
    *absolutely just sobbing and throwing up in french horn*

  • @thelookingcat
    @thelookingcat Рік тому +11

    Those oboes and clarinets lifting their instruments as if it does anything XD

  • @Smoke---
    @Smoke--- Рік тому +4

    This reminds me of the ending of the Rimsky Korsakov Russian Easter Overture I played in high school. 152 to the half note and crazy, slurred, string crossing, arpeggios with accidentals eight note passages everywhere as a violist. Especially at the end. SO. FAST. And listening to the performance you can’t hear us, just the brass. I spent so many hours practicing those parts 🤦🏽‍♂️

  • @S4VVYGAMES
    @S4VVYGAMES Рік тому +3

    This is so true, even without a total orchestra. You can just hear those 45 cellos and bass blasting the violin out when they’re play high half notes

  • @mattg6262
    @mattg6262 Рік тому +126

    Life is SO much more stressful for principal wind and percussion players. EVERYONE will hear their errors like more than half the time.

    • @shondig
      @shondig Рік тому +1

      REAL OMG

    • @electrocuti
      @electrocuti Рік тому +2

      So true bc I do the percussion that isn't drumkit in a wind band and if I fuck up a rhythm or play a bar early or something it's acc humiliating

    • @AcheronAlex
      @AcheronAlex Рік тому +4

      I do percussion. No one pays attention to us unless you mess up. You lose the beat and the whole orchestra goes haywire. And unless you play shit like bells or the anvil no one thinks you re cool or talented cause all you do is bang around

    • @ryanadams0922
      @ryanadams0922 10 місяців тому +3

      this^ this right here. Every time I made an error my heart skipped a beat and I can feel the hell fire of my directors eyes staring at me. Not a good feeling o_o

    • @LordHelmchen190
      @LordHelmchen190 10 місяців тому +1

      Yes, but you get to have the time to prepare your solos, because they are not that many.
      Being a violinist you have to play solos too and everything in between. No breaks and the conductor knows when you're not playing the right notes, even if the audience doesn't hear it.
      I'm talking about professional league here and not amateur.

  • @thebakagirl5293
    @thebakagirl5293 Рік тому +3

    That bunch of violinists seem like they’re fighting for their dear life to make the violin be heard

  • @yasserhussaini2104
    @yasserhussaini2104 Рік тому

    Wow she's beautiful!

  • @emperorofgaming8146
    @emperorofgaming8146 8 місяців тому +1

    As a trombonist, thank you for picking this excerpt

  • @YoungDymisty
    @YoungDymisty Рік тому +1

    When I played violin I prefer to play with other than on my own. The harmonies just sounded like heaven!

  • @Touhouuu
    @Touhouuu Рік тому +5

    As a contrabassist this is how we feel with literally any non-solo piece. Tubists can relate.

    • @gregoryf4186
      @gregoryf4186 Рік тому

      Nope, go listen to ein heldenlaben or Beethoven 9

  • @phretbord
    @phretbord Рік тому

    Sometimes it’s not about what you’re playing but how you look when you’re playing and you look great always! 😁😁😁

  • @bakamon523
    @bakamon523 5 місяців тому +1

    EXACTLY!!! Im always 2nd violin, and always sitting near the winds section. We all say we can not hear ourselves. No one hears us. We get out played by everyone. Sometime embarrassed to call myself a violinist, in a symphony orchestra 😔

  • @Gravata_Prata
    @Gravata_Prata Рік тому +11

    Which symphony is this? Sounds so good!

    • @SuuSinator
      @SuuSinator Рік тому +6

      Ein Heldenleben by Strauss (Des Helden Walstatt)
      One of my favourite works of Strauss!
      I'd recommend you to listen to the version of Strauss himself conducting Vienna Philharmonics. It's obviously an old recording so it lags a bit in terms of sound quality but imo it's still by far the best. You can even clearly hear the strings at the part of the video :D

  • @Shartrais
    @Shartrais Рік тому +1

    - Metal wind enters the orchestra.
    - Everyone else stop being heard.

  • @amanisalami3367
    @amanisalami3367 Рік тому +3

    Cries in Cello

  • @saltwater7366
    @saltwater7366 11 місяців тому

    This is definitely a violin moment of All Time.

  • @judahwilliams2431
    @judahwilliams2431 Рік тому +595

    Can't believe the most privileged instrument in the orchestra is complaining. At least you ain't the timpani in a Beethoven symphony playing 2 notes, or the trombone waiting 50 minutes in Bruckner to play the climax. 💀

    • @skepple1554
      @skepple1554 Рік тому +18

      Facts

    • @felixrouthier2202
      @felixrouthier2202 Рік тому +4

      Louder please 😂

    • @skepple1554
      @skepple1554 Рік тому +27

      @@Quixel_Pixel_ we’re pretty much even? As Brass players we spend most of the time resting lol y’all never have that, come back to me when you’re resting for multiple movements in a piece.

    • @judahwilliams2431
      @judahwilliams2431 Рік тому +31

      @@Quixel_Pixel_ Well, I still don't think it is equal. The violins have generations of repertoire compared to instruments such as wood winds or brass. Don't complain.

    • @USA_UNITED1776
      @USA_UNITED1776 Рік тому +23

      Your literally saying violin is privileged because it is hard as fuck, what?

  • @experthuntsman
    @experthuntsman 5 місяців тому +1

    As a cellist in a high school orchestra where we don’t include band into our concerts, this is just the Harp (with most of our pieces) and the Violas.

  • @elram2649
    @elram2649 Рік тому

    Yes, I can! 😊
    Albeit, when live, it's so much easier to hear them.
    Every instrument resonates around you. 😎👌

  • @coconutletsplay
    @coconutletsplay 9 місяців тому +2

    Fr so true I play the chello, but the funny thing is no one ever hears us because we are so low. LOL 😂

  • @basil2850
    @basil2850 10 місяців тому +4

    :cries in bass clarinet:

  • @caramelastic
    @caramelastic 10 місяців тому +2

    that's why i prefer playing jazz in my bigband instead, you feel more necessary

  • @rickywhenIcatchuuricky
    @rickywhenIcatchuuricky Рік тому +1

    i got you girl 😔 we only hear the trombone trumpet and co🧍🏾‍♀️ but we are the most difficult to play and THAT'S a flex

  • @TheEarthScienceTeacher
    @TheEarthScienceTeacher 8 місяців тому

    I remember the playing bass clarinet with the full orchestra and I was used to playing in a full band where all of our instruments balanced well. Yes, woodwinds were on the quieter side, which is why we were in the front. When playing with the orchestra we had around 15 band members, half woodwinds and half brass. The 15 of us were in the back and even with us playing piano and the strings playing forte we would still overpower the 50-60 string players. It is kinda crazy.

  • @oyleistenaber
    @oyleistenaber 9 місяців тому +1

    Bir gitarist olarak sadece gitarların, piyanonun, kemanların ve baterinin olduğu bir gösteri vermiştik ve en çok kemanlar parlamıştı ve biz gitarlar duyulmuyorduk

  • @_ie_jewls_
    @_ie_jewls_ 9 місяців тому +1

    As someone who played french horn and is now learning violin
    Im so sorry
    And i feel this

  • @SerAres_
    @SerAres_ Рік тому +1

    Composers: I think the strings need to look like they are working furiously too *aggresive airbowing*

  • @oofrandomlol999
    @oofrandomlol999 Рік тому +1

    Sobs violently in bass

  • @vituslai3486
    @vituslai3486 Рік тому +1

    Better than playing Bruckner Symphony No.4, doing tremolos for several mins in the opening

  • @gloomychai
    @gloomychai Рік тому

    welcome to the club, as a bassooonist I relate to the whole "why am I here " thing

  • @potatodecimator131
    @potatodecimator131 Рік тому +2

    Piece is Ein Heldenleben for people who want to know

  • @carina-nonbinary
    @carina-nonbinary Рік тому

    True. Also back when i played violin in the school orchestra and was practicing my mom used to ask me what i was even playing. She could only hear that weird single notes and repetitions, but in my head i could hear the whole orchestra xD

  • @bl4ckcheri
    @bl4ckcheri 9 місяців тому +1

    the fly in my room at night:

  • @drmeechbinanddrtinbin3767
    @drmeechbinanddrtinbin3767 Рік тому +1

    as a violist we get that too

  • @BrisaPadilla-s3j
    @BrisaPadilla-s3j 9 місяців тому +2

    I can hear it but it might be cuz i learned how to divide each group up for my school orchestra

  • @jpdj2715
    @jpdj2715 Рік тому

    It's the same as how the middle finger feels of the pianist, between the other digits.

  • @Jereizsus
    @Jereizsus Рік тому +1

    As a fellow person who plays violin I can tell you that's how it feels

  • @Generalissimo_David-B
    @Generalissimo_David-B Рік тому

    This Is Why I Like to Be a Violinist and Conductor.

  • @foxieplayzvr
    @foxieplayzvr 6 місяців тому +1

    HAHAHA TAKE THAT STRING PLAYERS ( says the brass and winds )

  • @TheProptechScout
    @TheProptechScout Рік тому

    I hate seeing these passages because of their difficulty, but I love that the rest of the orchestra provides cover so I don't have to practice 😉

  • @indigosaboteur9686
    @indigosaboteur9686 Рік тому

    “If the brass rushes if going to bring my blow gun” 😂

  • @Iheartskincare197
    @Iheartskincare197 10 місяців тому +1

    Omg so true I’m a violinist myself and it’s actually really hard

  • @volkanbinboga6743
    @volkanbinboga6743 9 місяців тому +2

    I can't even hear myself sometimes 😭😭

  • @dennisyelchaninov2613
    @dennisyelchaninov2613 Рік тому +5

    What is this piece called?

    • @Berny27
      @Berny27 Рік тому +2

      I found this in the comments and I'm just spreading it around now lol: Ein heldenleben by Strauss (Heldenleben Battle Scene) it sounds so good!!!!!!! GOD BLESS Y'ALL MY FRIENDS AND HAVE AN INCREDIBLE DAY 😊

  • @dylansmith8215
    @dylansmith8215 Рік тому

    the color guard of orchestra right there.

  • @eddiemoreno4127
    @eddiemoreno4127 Рік тому

    I really understand, the only good thing about it is that if you play a wrong note, nobody will notice, but if you play the wrong rhythm, it will be bad

  • @McPersun
    @McPersun Рік тому

    "you guys get to play?"
    -violas

  • @ICREAMTOHANDTIE
    @ICREAMTOHANDTIE Рік тому +49

    fr practicing so long to play something that cant be heard 😭

    • @jub8891
      @jub8891 Рік тому +1

      your section and the conductor can hear it though right?

    • @Heirloop
      @Heirloop Рік тому +1

      @@jub8891 yes

    • @GardeniaRose1-
      @GardeniaRose1- Рік тому +1

      Me as a Viola player every time 🙃

  • @justherexsisting2585
    @justherexsisting2585 Рік тому +4

    …. We understand your pain -flute player

  • @krisdabaliguy6850
    @krisdabaliguy6850 9 місяців тому +1

    That’s why brass is the best

  • @LeeLee_strawberry
    @LeeLee_strawberry 11 місяців тому +1

    Cries in oboe

  • @Wwesto
    @Wwesto 11 місяців тому

    Can confirm as a cellist as all the string interments can barely be heard while the other sections are overtaking the sound in the room so ig we are just there for visual

  • @ultimawerewolfbluephoenix9670

    Can we talk about the two oboes pointing their bells at audience?💀

  • @siemp0333
    @siemp0333 Рік тому +6

    Yeah that happens when you play Strauss with the best brass section in the world😂

  • @mosesmckinney1373
    @mosesmckinney1373 9 місяців тому +1

    Yeah just play like a tenor instrument. They get to play like half as much and get all the coolest parts. Speaking from the experience of a tenor sax player whose friends play cello trombone and French horn.

  • @nuage9538
    @nuage9538 Рік тому +10

    As a double bassist, same with us but we never get the melody. I don’t wanna see any violinist tears 😂

    • @gregoryf4186
      @gregoryf4186 Рік тому +1

      Basses literally start this piece with the melody lol

  • @jonathanmolina7690
    @jonathanmolina7690 Рік тому

    Reminds me of the cello part to Bartoks Concerto for Orchestra...

  • @That.french.harpist
    @That.french.harpist Рік тому

    Meanwhile the harp gang is sitting in the audience, forgotten by all composers🙂🙂🙂

  • @Imjustastay
    @Imjustastay Рік тому

    Normally, the orchestra I do is only violin. But this year im going to do it with guitar, more guitars,(idk what its called) recorder, flute and a saxophone ( including violin.)

  • @duolingoOvvl
    @duolingoOvvl 7 місяців тому

    Same for the flutes until we hit the highest note we can possibly ever hit

  • @korruptedkritz9665
    @korruptedkritz9665 10 місяців тому

    Me a pianist: I feel you

  • @Lemon_Lime499
    @Lemon_Lime499 7 місяців тому

    As a violinist, I understand your pain.😂

  • @Guitar_4everr
    @Guitar_4everr 9 місяців тому +1

    Ayo violinists are like me, a bassist!

  • @Aaron-bu3mo
    @Aaron-bu3mo 7 місяців тому

    Better than drinking in a alley.

  • @superskeleton37
    @superskeleton37 8 місяців тому

    As a violist, I FEEL YOU 😭

  • @KReallyJams
    @KReallyJams 8 місяців тому +1

    Yes I can hear the violins quite a lot.

  • @southpark5555
    @southpark5555 7 місяців тому

    I know that one! Flight of the bumble bee! Kidding only. Good vid.

  • @LMnYng
    @LMnYng Рік тому

    Lol i remember in high school and we had a combined concert and just in practice the orchestra teacher was livid that no one can hear the strings cuz at the time our class size was like 1/3 of the bands class size 😅

  • @homicidal._goose
    @homicidal._goose 10 місяців тому

    Well, if you can’t hear the violins then I guess the cellos don’t even exist anymore 💀

  • @harryrthanu
    @harryrthanu 8 місяців тому

    It sounds like TROMBONES 🎉🎉💪💪

  • @Woodland26
    @Woodland26 Рік тому

    My colleague's daughter is quite a good viola player. Parents spent 250k for her viola made by some master craftsman and during mid year break she flys to Europe to learn from the best.

  • @justinbill3101
    @justinbill3101 Рік тому

    That's because you got a bunch of op brass players, this kinda situation wouldn't happen in my country, most of the time the one that disappeared is brass :)

  • @svanaseynhaeve5744
    @svanaseynhaeve5744 8 місяців тому

    I am a violonist for 7 years now and smtimes i have a bisg concert but online Whit the violins cello and the contrabase and its very ard to play then

  • @seitzstringpros
    @seitzstringpros Рік тому

    😂😂😂 Nailed it!!!!

  • @njmtrumpet
    @njmtrumpet Рік тому

    Brass is KING

  • @ethanbolyer2361
    @ethanbolyer2361 Рік тому

    Cries unrepentantly in pianist

  • @Trae2k22
    @Trae2k22 Рік тому

    Like why are we so loud alone but so quiet together in a full orchestra

  • @adrianozuna875
    @adrianozuna875 Рік тому

    Cries in bass

    • @gregoryf4186
      @gregoryf4186 Рік тому

      Bass has a better part than the violin in this piece

  • @BenjaminBekesi
    @BenjaminBekesi Рік тому

    as a violin stundent i agree!

  • @violatione
    @violatione Рік тому

    This is so true!!!!!

  • @acscw8408
    @acscw8408 Рік тому

    That's the point. even if u play a bunch of wrong notes.. nobody can hear u :x

  • @stacys_dad1348
    @stacys_dad1348 Рік тому

    as a low brass player I feel this

  • @yeppers8051
    @yeppers8051 Рік тому

    You know what it's like to be a violist? All of that is rests.

  • @YourBassClarinetPlayingPetDuck

    It’s to make it look cooler you’re not meant to hear them, because the winds are just clearly cooler.

  • @ephremcortvrint2376
    @ephremcortvrint2376 7 місяців тому

    Eh, take one part away and you immediately hear it. We are all essential in an orchestra

  • @benpowell5348
    @benpowell5348 Рік тому

    i wonder if they had mics on the winds specifically during the recording so the balance is off. Tho i wouldn't doubt a brass section can overpower strings if they want. They just seem usually not to

  • @Dedell000
    @Dedell000 Рік тому

    I felt that

  • @N-ggy
    @N-ggy Рік тому +1

    Tbh if we didn’t play no one would notice

  • @ttesc9253
    @ttesc9253 10 місяців тому

    We played heldenleben this fall and i lowkey just gave up practicing this part since the brass is so loud you cant even hear yourself play lol

  • @ponyonoodles6568
    @ponyonoodles6568 5 місяців тому +1

    Cellists: :')

  • @todokumo
    @todokumo Рік тому

    nah literally 😭😭

  • @hannahherrmann4921
    @hannahherrmann4921 Рік тому

    this is how woodwinds are treated in wind band😭

  • @shupesmerga4694
    @shupesmerga4694 8 місяців тому

    All i gotta do is follow the bowing, screw the notes😅

  • @chuyreal5522
    @chuyreal5522 Рік тому

    horns are best section

  • @digitaldizzy
    @digitaldizzy Рік тому

    typically i do not understand why people put angry comments on videos. but as a cellist who is always being told to play quieter in chamber music so that the violins can screech away... godddd the audacity

    • @formyflounders
      @formyflounders  Рік тому

      Weird! Cellists are usually told to play louder in most chamber settings bc they have the most important bass line/ the register is low so harder to project

  • @dougdumbrill7234
    @dougdumbrill7234 7 місяців тому

    Well good job anyway!!! You could have to count literally a zillion measures of rest like the third trumpet! (That’d be me!😂)

  • @amazinggrace2907
    @amazinggrace2907 Рік тому

    So relatable

  • @mrithyunthegamer
    @mrithyunthegamer 8 місяців тому

    Meanwhile the violins in my class don’t practice 😅