Porsche 911 Turbo vs Nissan GT-R vs Audi R8 V10
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 чер 2024
- New Porsche 911 Turbo vs Nissan GT-R vs Audi R8 V10. Which car wins our flat-out super test? Find out more at www.autocar.co.uk/porsche, www.autocar.co.uk/audi and www.autocar.co.uk/nissan
- Авто та транспорт
I like the porsche the most
GT-R for track day.
911 Turbo for Grand Touring with speed and comfort.
R8 V10 + for luxury, style, and attention grabbing.
Pick which one is best based on that.
yeah
Half the price, faster around the circuit, more comfortable and...with a proper boot. MY GOD, WHAT A CAR!
I don't have to think it at all GODGILLA for sure !!
WhiteLion2013 GODZILLA not GODGILLA
Furgil Pinas It doesn't fucking matters .......GODGILLA OR GODZILLA what it does matters is that he's FUCKING AWESOME !!
WhiteLion2013 -_-
Dude, I have respect for the GTR now. For such a smaller engine, it kicks ass.
I'm not sure about the choice between the 911 Turbo and the R8 V10 but I think I'd pick the R8 V10.
+Alex Le lambo is much better than audi
My nigga ;)
@Howie262 what car do you drive on a daily basis?
Thank you for posting this beautiful video.
I want to like the GTR but I can't get over how ugly it is. Well, maybe ugly is a strong word. Boring. It doesn't look like a supercar. More like a brick.
I want to like your comment but you are too ugly and your comment is too boring. You do look like a brick.
He rode that nissan the hardest then babies the other two! Someones takin' the piss!
Exactly!
@Scalibq: in fact, the first 4WD electronically controlled with active diff was the Porsche 959 in 1982 but Nisan and Mitsubishi made the first non-expensive ones!
@thepunisheruae Im NOT a gtr hater but pay close attention at the top gear video when Jeremy announces the lap time for the Audi R8. He remarks: "That was sort of a dampish lap!" He then announces the time of the zr1 which is 1:20.4. That's 7/10ths of a second slower on a dampish lap. If you go to the drag race portion of that video, you will notice that it was mostly sunny, lol!
R8 is seriously one of the worst sport cars ever made
Why because its not fast? Have fun owning a gtr for 2 years while the audi lasts a life time.
Ok list one reason an audi r8 is shit.
Youssef 32000 look at the lap times, it's clearly slower than all the same class rivals, despite being not bad on the paper
What does it matter about speed. Its about quality. You're not just going to buy a car so you can race, and they were litteraly apart by a second. That matters why?
You can't go wrong with German engineering. I'd rather have a quality car thats fun to ride and looks good rather than a plastic pocket rocket.
Audi is the best
audi is best
@Zyphon400 I dont this you get my point. In the Top Gear review I was referring to, Clarkson said the R8 V10 was much faster and he was able to go much quicker in it. But around the track in the hands of a skilled driver, the ZR1 was a lot quicker. I suppose its the driver that matters at the end of the day but I do think Sutcliffe isnt a competent enough driver (no offence) to get the most out of these cars.
@blazzing4321 O wow!
The Alpha 9 GTR ran 10.4 seconds @ 136.6 MPH.
How much does it cost for the package?
Japan is the Best! Haters gonna hate!
btw, is this the new 2012 GT-R? or the older model?
@Blueball0120 Im not sure about that one.
The Ligenfelter ZR1 ran 10.03 @ 141.50 MPH
@kempowarrior it did on a slightly wet track aswell would like to see it in the dry!
@vitessemeister
Actually the back seats come in very handy for a couple of suitcases, even a toddler.
@SilentNinja1774 what bulb3145 said. it's supposed to be really fuel efficient and reliable, so you wont have to worry about fixing it up every couple of months. its made so that you can take drive it to work and back everyday with no problems.
whats the theme song in the background?
@StriderCX But an american magazine got the "standard" Turbo to do 0-60 in 2.8...
So you shouldn't have your car constantly adjust power to each wheel as it drives for better grip? And it also shouldn't adjust the suspension as you go around a corner?
So would you say that ABS is for wimps?
@Northax maybe the zr1 will, but i doubt that as well
@MrMickle28 a manual gearbox is and will always be slower to shift then a flappy paddle one... that is why
is is ALWAYS raining in the UK ..seems the test tracks are ALWAYS wet
@Lillnick1524 Did I say something offensive? And the G2RS is comparable to the Nissan GT-R and the Audi R8 V10 because it has a 6 cylinder engine. So exactly what are you saying?
@AutoFanBoy but the gt-r is lack of adrenaline and it might be pleasuring on circuit,but not on legal road
Nice versus.
@AutoFanBoy its the driving experience the car gives you that is important
@AutoFanBoy i must admit,the gt-r is a very good grand tourer.Its comfortable,it's controllable,and it's practical like what a grand tourer should be.But for certain people that only use their sportscar on weekends,i would recommend the R8,as it's more fun to drive,the engine sound creates adrenaline.I live in a place with lots of bad roads,so i only use them for weekend,so i choose the R8.
I had a go in this model Porsche at the weekend and the surge of acceleration is just astonishing but considering the price the GTR is just incredible. In fact even if it was the same price it would look like a good deal.
@Howie262 since when has the number of years doing something made you guaranteed to be better at doing whatever it is you're doing as someone else?
top gear and the r8 v8 and it kept up with the porsche. How did he drive the v10 and be so much slower?
@Gearskid2012 How come? They crush the production car lap times everytime they make a new car.
Anyone having this problem, whenever i press the full screen, the video needs to load from the point where i pressed the full screen button.
@Carbbon11 I agree on the Lotus fab cars!!! As for shifting yes I have used manual and I hate it foot in left hand move left foot off clutch then jerk I totally hate it. I used to own an MG ZT manual until I got my Jag XFR and I will never go back to manual (unless I get a track day car)...
@xxCappuccino hand mad means it was made without production machines in today's standards... making crankshafts and such in few min vs a few hours. similar to what production machines were 20 years ago
@SPHINX144 sticks are for real lovers of driving, but the truth is that the flappy paddle is quicker, this is a fact.
also the other 2 were in flappy paddle
@Howie262 ah the good ol 190. one of my good friends drove one all through high school.
interesting tidbits, i'm pretty sure that the r8 can be equipped with carbon ceramic breaks, which would probably bump up its time, and they were all on a wet track, which could affect times as well
@ThatIdiotJason i agree with them being all beautiful cars and everyone has their own taste after all
@vitessemeister practicality? what the hell, the R8 is a 2 seater and hardly has any trunk space. how is it practical?
@jakeboi i agree but the thing is that the porsches headlights and the exterior design doesnt really impress me that much
@youiable it can accually get up around 525 hp or higher. All the engines are hand made so each ones hp is different
love to see the comparison with a Turbo S
@Scalibq well....nissans first supercar is the R390. altho it hasent seen the public road ( tho it was a production car) it was a killer on the racetrack in Le Mans GT2 series faster then some LMP cars.
DO A VIDEO OF AUDI TT VS BMW Z4!!!
@265008888 agreed... and they should have runned the course not for just one lap, but say 20 laps and see which car comes out winner at the end.
good video
Porsche,Corvette ,mustang,etc,,et al
none can drive over that course without bouncing the driver to bits.
The Gtr makes it look easy.
The Benchmark
The flappy paddle gear box maybe better in terms of lap times but for pure fun factor i'll take a 6 speed manual anytime of the day!
I love competition between super-car companies... the consumer gets more overall quality, speed and agility in their car. Not to mention awesome UA-cam videos. BTW they should remake this video using the new Porsche 911 G2RS which has 650 HP and can go 0-62 mph in 3.2 seconds...
@blazzing4321 What are performance stats for the LPE ZR1? O yeah
Viper ACR>GTR
Alpha 9 or 10 GTR>LPE ZR1
I don't know the performance stats for the LPE ZR1 but I bet the Alpha 9 GTR would smoke it.
@kungfu49 Not sure if u know about it or not, but go check out the Nissan GT-R Alpha 10 or 12. 1000-1100bhp, 9.10 sec 1/4 mile. It can keep up with a Veyron, and for only an additional $30k (US dollar).
@MrMickle28 If you look at modern race cars and racing sequential gear boxes dominate. Faster you shift and less movement wasted the quicker you will go around a track. Just the way it is.
@SwiftHDX amen dude
at 5:02 the porsche must be racing to the restroom! LOL
@blazzing4321 The GT-R alpha 10 did 9.19 @163mph. ZR1 what?
@TheNashu66 O yeah I forgot about the Alpha 10 GTR.
@Yavoesz eh to me it's all about the thrill I won't put any nation above another I mean I probably buy more japanese cars than others but mainly because they are affordable and cheap aftermarket to take out some big dogs around the track, I love muscle cars but I also love time attack and they aren't rounding a track quick enough to even take out a mildly modded miata but that roar when you put your foot down still makes me melt lol
@Scalibq: Yeah! you're right about the year of production! my memory's gone!! lol
The diff were electronically controlled with a 4 programs choice, the suspension were also electronically controlled. But, for the Nurb lap times, nobody can check them, so I no longer take them for real, for example, nobody managed to obtain the R35 laptimes claimed by the factory, which is logical, when you consider its huge weight and problems it causes, nevermind, it is a fast car, but not so fast as they say!
@vtknight777 when i think of Nissan, the car "Micra" comes in mind.
Do i see many GT-R racing around? well everyone goes still for all the other brands not for nissan, fast as a porsche but quality as a Micra.
@latbeast Mostly,its called powersliding.
Drifting takes a wider angle the takes up too much speed.
@AutoFanBoy You confused the Turbo and the GT2. The Turbo has AWD and 4 seats, the GT2 is a RWD, 2-seater with a more powerful version of the Turbo's engine (essentially a GT3 with more power).
@jcpturbo00 The Gumpert Apollo managed a 7:11 time on the Nürburgring and the GT2 RS managed a 7:18. They are much faster than the GTR. And when driven by the same driver, the GT2 and the GT-R both did a 7:38 and the 911 Turbo wasn't far behind.
@ratmtbola
I never said that based of its technological advancements were the reason it outperformed the 911.
i guess you re right, its all about the $. when it comes down to cutting cost, as an audi driver myself, i have to admit there is room for performance.
@loudblazer yeah true my mistake
@charlesholzy Its all about preference
@Zyphon400 Or not? the turbo has been clocked doing 0-60 in 2.7 secs, its got carbon ceramic brakes, it has all the technology porsche could cram into it, it mashed the 458 italia in a drag race too? The gtr wouldnt stand a chance around a power circuit? maybe on a twisty, slow one though since its the best car around corners atm IMO.
@DATSlovely tht and also look at the engines
@5Bullet5
maybe you should drive a porsche. BTW, the turbo is an all wheel drive, which is understeering. even a gt2 is going to understeer, as long as you don´t push it to it´s limit.
most cars have an understeering setup, it´s kind of protection for the typical unskilled drivers. ;)
@rocaho001 Unfortunately, they are all used NOT brand new.
@Blueball0120 (fyi 9.95s quarter mile, and alpha 10 turns out a 9.19s quarter mile)
Only wish Nissan would incorporate a bit more style into the next GTR, partiularly the cabin . Hope it would take some cues from the last 300ZX turbo , which was way ahead of comparable europeans in both style and performance back then. It still has bags of character and looks menacing from the rear view mirror.
unbiased driver? what the fuck are you talking about? this is a professional review. it's as legit as it gets.
I'd always prefare a Porsche, due to its perfect engineered Technology and outstanding Quality. The normal "Turbo" is
by the way the consciously Comforable one, the "Turbo S" must be the choice for the Race track - and for the comparison vs GTRs because of its defined purpose.
@traneum this is why topgear has a stig lol, his a controlled variable
@Fsunka The 911 looks amazing. I'm currently saving up to trade in my Viper for it. Personally, I don't like the looks of the GTR, but as for the performance, it's a beast. You own a GTR? Track days must be fun :)
@grant6730 thank you! people dont realize the porsche has big leather cumfy seats lol its not all carbon fiber and uncomfortable like most sports cars.
@MarcusAurelius28655 March 2011 GTR is released and doing 0-60 in 2.9 seconds...
@MrBabirusa I write very specifically about this; Objectivity vs. Subjectivity. Objectivity is easy - this car is this fast to 60 MPH vs another car which is slower. Subjectivity is tricky - its more fun to drive, better, better looking etc.
The problem with subjectivity is that I can say that the Toyoto Prius is the better driving, best looking car compared to anything in the world - and since its my opinion - it can't be argued. This is why I prefer to stay as objective as possible.
Peace.
The thing is, different ppl buy cars for different reasons, and others don't understand why ppl buy certain cars. All 3 cars in this video are great, they are carefully made, beautifully crafted and they perform well. The origin of their backgrounds make them what they are, what interiors/exteriors they can have, etc etc. SO as consumers, we have to appreciate these three great car makers for allowing us to have choices to buy whatever we want...only if tthe price was lower for all 3 lol..
GTR has the best race pedigree of all these cars. But the Audi r8 is the best looking, has the best quality interior and sounds awesome. The Porsche on the other hand is undoubtedly brilliant. It looks so cute!
+Samaksh uppal I loled .. "GTR has the best race pedigree of all these cars." :)))))
@AutoFanBoy thats because people like the way they look the ford f 150 looked the same for the last 4 or 3 years, under the hood it will get more powerful i gurentee
@5Bullet5 The Porsche Turbo is AWD.
@eskimo810 Actually, you're wrong as well. Porsche uses flat 6(or H6) engine.
@coolcarman555: even if, in Europe, the name Skyline hasn't been chose, xhere do you think the "R35" come from??? Do R32, R33 and R34 names speak to you?
Good job cars. My favorites the GTR too
And I appreciate your compliments. All words are terms and subsequently they have meaning. There is a reason why there is a term for exotic and a term for super car. Super car deals with performance. A car can be fast and not an Exotic (rare, super expensive, elitist etc.). An Exotic can be rare/elitist etc. and not be fast (on a track or in a straight line). Sometimes they are both (Superexotic). Your beliefs do not change reality - the GTR is a Super Car - as per many many industry experts.
@rocaho001 In Los Angeles, for the past few years each Nissan dealer will only get ONE every year and they will mark it up at least US$25,000. There is also a long wait list.
Same here
@TheNashu66 Which is a good price tag.
@Scalibq: Without a shadow of a doubt! The Skyline series is very far from being new! but if people don't (especially young nes...) know nothing about it, what ca we do? A person who love cars MUST know the Skyline, and other cars if he wants to understand where today's cars come from! There are tons of old cars which are interesting! (In fact, I prefer old ones to new ones but it's a matter of taste!)
@fctsui57
what is the cheapest car? audi?
@TakashiNippon well the nissan is around 85 and the audi aroun 125k
@blaze651000 Yeah but previous Skyline GT-R's weren't in the same league as the 911 Turbo. And of course this is the first GT-R not to be based on the Skyline
@XNarutoX67 The Nissan GT-R is one of the best.
0-60 in 3.2 seconds
1/4 mile in 11.6 seconds @120 MPH
Top speed 195 MPH
Nurburgring lap time 7:24
The Nissan GT-R is one of the best supercars for its price