Audi R8 vs Porsche 911 Carrera - Top Gear - BBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 сер 2008
- Jeremy reviews the new Audi R8 supercar and claims it to be one of the best supercars in the world - only to be interrupted by a competitive Richard Hammond in a Porsche 911. Which one is better - the Porsche 911 or the Audi R8? The only way to settle this argument is through a Top Gear special drag race!
Subscribe for more awesome Top Gear videos: ua-cam.com/users/subscription_c...
Top Gear UA-cam channel: / topgear
TopGear.com website: www.topgear.com
Top Gear Facebook: / topgear
Top Gear Twitter: / bbc_topgear
This is a commercial channel from BBC Studios. Service & Feedback www.bbcstudios.com/contact/co... - Розваги
4:12 that drift must be one of the most epic things I've ever seen. The whole composition with the R8 in front and everything is just perfect.
+Stryke It's probably the most perfect shot in all of Top Gear. You have the R8 in a straight line in-focus, then here comes the wild, maniacal 911 swinging wide behind it to try to ruin its day, the focus then blurs the R8 and settles on the 911. Things are about to go down.
If I were a movie director of car chases, I would be constantly using that shot. It's an absolute masterpiece.
Holy shit I was about to say. Best car entrance ever
They used it in the intro for years too
I think I bought my car strictly based on that intro...
And the 911 did manage to ruin the R8's day.
For Audi's first attempt at a supercar they did an awesome job.
Nah, they own Lamborghini and Bugatti. Easy to copy and paste
@@juandef4115 which they didn't do, they improved it big time. You can now drive a Lamborghini without it falling apart at one point
The original R8 is one of the most beautiful cars ever made.
Past experience from Le Mans and Group B
Not a big deal with so much experience from LeMans and other races.
That scene at 4:13 is probably my favourite shot from all of Top Gear.
in comes the porsche haha
Man, this powerslide gives me to much life... I watch it every few months
honiballist that power slide is the reason Hammond is in the hospital all the time
The scene from forza motorsport 4
Adham hamed 21 hours ago haha I was just about to write that, I actually came here from that
I'm still amazed by how well the R8 aged. It still looks great, 11 years later.
Yeah it does
Yeah definitely you can tell the 911 has changed a lot but the Audi is timeless
@@morganatkinson4768
911 ist also very timeless in my Opinion.
I just like the R8 alot because it way more rare than the 911, at least in Germany.
It does not look anywhere near the same though, the 911 has changed as well but not as much and the Porsche was always the better looking car.
@@morganatkinson4768 That is one of the most retarded replies I have ever read on the internet. The Porsche has basically been the same for 30 years but the Audi does NOT look anywhere near the same today. That's not to even mention the engine in those cars. The Porsche has the boxer six, as it had since it was first introduced in 1963 while the new Audi has nothing what so ever in common with that version, nothing at all, not a single thing.
Jesus Christ you couldn't be more wrong if you took a lifetime of trying.
I don't know what Jeremy was talking about.
That Audi still looks stunning in 2021...
Exactly my thought!!! If only he had seen the later generations of the r8👀
"oh look, hammond appears to have joined us in his Volkswagen Beetle" best thing I've heard all day
funnymakeslifesunny well ferdinand porsche designed vw beetle. and vw owns porsche not 100% but some
***** 49.9%
gowtham chowdary thank you
***** your welcome
funnymakeslifesunny nah mate...."he's probably rabbitting on in there about how he feels an organic part of the machine when the simple fact of the matter is, HE'S BEHIND ME!..........#MEGALOL......
I may well be a Porsche fan, but my God the first gen R8 still does look good to this day.
4:10 Best entrance ever?
+Jonathan Cheung definitely, yes. This has to be one of the best scenes ever shown on television.
Go to bed, Hammond.
Hammond:"I took the kids to school in that this morning and drove straight here"
Clarkson:"And I didn't, so who's the daddy now?" hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaa
+Trevor Price to be fair, only kids could possibly fit into these back seats ...
The the first gen R8 will never age! It looks mesmerizing and futuristic!
I'm from the future, it looks dated and not that great today IMO.
@@johnhunter7244yep
That first gen r8......
Looks better than the new one in my opinion
The best generation of the both cars, But i prefer the 997.2 (facelift).
Its the iron man car. The smart and elegant supercar
The prototype was even more gorgeous, those head lights and wheels were bonkers.
The old R8 is still the best looking car Audi has ever made.
I’d make an argument for the 2008 RS6 Avant.
I prefer the new 2020 RS6/7
100% I love the 2011 version. The 2016 one looks like an old lizard whose vomited it's insides out through it's hideous protruding grille.
Plus they removed that rear 'panel-wing'. That's a big nono to remove a design quirk like like, a piece of soul really!
I agree with you but from outside only not from inside
@@netweed09 It is everyone's else's preference. I actually like 2016 and newest R8's
The video editing of BBC Top Gear is like a classic car. Even to this day is a joy to watch and you can learn from it. Timeless art.
Yeahhh
Always loved how the 3.8 flat six sounds.
+8x5t3e7s4r6y Its like Jackie Chan. small and tiny yet so amusing and powerful.
Type in Audi r8 advert on rolling road.Thats Sooo much better then a straight six
flat 6*
Yeh that
It's actually 3.6 liters
Like smearing honey into Keira Knightley? Must be a good car then!
Its be better to sleep with kiera knightly so this car is not as good as it could be
Jokes aside though this car looks bad and expensive and boring, it is good but thats how it is, id take something fun like a corvette or that porsche
@@michealbithi1290 I think if you smear honey into hear you kinda advanced over just sleeping with her
Meh, I'll pass - she's too skinny with a freakish underbite.
“Why is there smoke coming out of your Audi, Clarkson?”
“That isn’t smoke, it’s steam. Steam from the Audi V10 I’m driving.”
*v8
V8*
Mmm, steamed V8.
Probs one of the best and famous power slides by Hamster in his Porsche.
...performed by a racing driver
I think the Audi R8 looks better than most exotic cars out there..
Lamborghini aventador and Ferrari laferrari and BMW i8 and pagani zonda cinqu roadster and mercedes sls AMG all look better then this
true, I will get this one
AUDI Q7 VS BMV X6
@104588468812239755218 YOUR WRONG. very. Most of those cars are laptops, mere computer cars, with no soul or passion. And 2 are even a hybrid!! You need to grow taste. The R8 is ageless in design, the others look like they were all crashed. Dents and bends, angles, twists and turns. Its mere windtunnel design, not sexy. Ok, except the Pagani.
but it has no o seets ol
2:19 Jeremy complained about the headlights 12 years ago. Boy what the hell it aged well👌
In his defense they quickly changed them to not include all those little individual LEDs and just made it a clean line
I thin the headlamps are the sexiest aspect of the R8 .
Nicolas Broszky New r8 is super sexy
yeah that mid-2000's styling was horribly gaudy...the new R8's are much better looking
Ege Coskunsoy truly
New R8 is terrible looks so boxy
it did pioneer LED running lights which everyone copied.
edit: personally I like all the R8s including the Le Mans Quattro concept. my personal favorite being the late model first gen R8 V10 with the 6-speed.
4:13 that shot is so freakin awesome
oh look, hammond appears to have joined us in his Volkswagen Beetle
LOL
Some say thats his actual car
Every Porsche looks like a beetle in the front
@@karimgougui5686 996
@@karimgougui5686i think porsche used to make beetles fkr vw and they evolved the design
Ironically Saying it inside a car made by Volkswagen
This whole review is one of the best compositions the Top Gear team ever made. The rotating shot that begins at 1:45 is just fantastically done.
I like the experimental cinematography in the og Top Gear.
3:18 "This is like smearing honey into Keira Knightley"
The Audi R8 ladies and gentlemen.
I love the way the R8 looks. Those headlamps are great; in fact every time I see a new A4 coming up from behind me at night, I think "oh crap is that an R8, if so, I might as well just slow up and let it by".
This generation is so iconic
The R8 is my favorite supercar of all time.
The intake on the side, the LEDs on the headlights, the spartan interior, and Audi's awesome 4 wheel drive system.
It has been discontinued💔
"rubbish, I'll show you stunning"
Drifted across the camera frame.
Irrespective of what car you buy, the VAG group is always the winner. :P
Siddharth Senthilnayagam unless it comes to emissions.
Tomfoolerydoozle its a problem of the industry
You realize they busted almost all at this point?
The rest fixed the software.
What vag did was in your interest.
They tried to fool the state and protect your engine from getting destroyed due to ruining it with all that shit thats done to it in order to reduce co2 and no emissions
Vag. Hmmmmm. That sounds familiar
Around 2008 they made a concept vehicle with a 6.0 liter V12 TDI. 500 HP, 740 torque. Would love to see that as a final product!
well, I think they already made that into production mate
@@LonesomeDrifter1987 no, it was used in the r10 for the lemans but not in the road going r8. The car that got the v12 tdi was the q7, but the engine in it shared only a few parts with the r10.
4:12 That Drift >XD
gives me goosebumps every time
Who’s here 10 years later ?
11 my friend, 11 years! 😂
Almost 12
11
2020 bro.
12 my man
The Porsche... looks like a very surprised turtle.
The 996 looked better.
Firemarioflower The 996 looked worse. 997 mark 2 and 991 are the best IMO, along with the older 911s.
NoStressCrossfire NO they aint. The old ones arent balanced and the new ones are for control freaks and geeks. The 996 is the best looking ever. Not a beetle for once.
The 991 is such a fake car, having 4 wheel steering, electronic power steering, dsg clutch (so has the 997), ugly rear lights, 2000 suspension settings, dumbass gismos, a true nerdfest.
NOT a proper Porsche.
The 996 is beautiful and the most fun porsche to drive. Not to mention more reliable and sounds god like. It handles fabulously and pure on instinct. A REAL porsche, that communicates with you.
Martin Allen No why would i?
I don't know why but 911s kinda remind me if a fish
Completely fell in love with the current 991 generation - in my opinion it is the best 911 so far. I never used to like porsche 911s but the current ones (well actually the ones before the turbo charged engines) are just amazing.
6:32 the front number plate is falling
Mohamad Hadi thank you for noticing that... I suspect it was covering another set of plates RV06 KVH
Who's here from Alex driving this same car on Car Throttle
Aye
I love porsche.
"...it's like smearing honey into Keira Knightly..." HA!
Little did Jeremy know, those led running lights on the r8 would go on to be used on thousands of different cars for years to come.
No we have daytime running amber lights like in the Ford Raptor LOL
“Who’s daddy now” - Jeremy Clarkson 2008 😂😂😂
6:59 That sound is amazing
I *so* miss just this type of reporting/entertainment - whatever you want to call it, it was MASSIVELY fun to watch.
I’m coming from November of 2019, and except the great review as always, when Jeremy announced the 0-60 time of the R8, I immediately thought: “today similar acceleration can be performed with a hot hatch”.
Yeah its crazy how far cars have come
Min 2:59 Clarkson actually driving like a racing driver, gear 3-4-3 in a matter of second.thumbs up!
Anyone here after car throttle drove this exact R8?
That drift at 4:15 tho... holy shit !!
100 mph and sounds like your in church, Except now your really with god.
@KoivuTheHab don't be too harsh with him, back then you couldn't edit UA-cam comments.
@@jooplin the guy has an inferiority complex, don't bother
TheCarFanForever I am just amazed how he can judge by a simple spelling error how good his education is, just pure comedy
@KoivuTheHab you look like you got triggered by that atheist comment. Believing in God in 2019, you're the one who needs an education, you Jesus freak.
Ps: I didn't want to bring religion into a car video but I had to.
@KoivuTheHab You sure must be a fun guy to hang out with. Do you point out every insignificant error of your friends to? Your company must be a real gift. Again, looking at a "grammatical error" (I hope I got it right this time) you are able to conclude this guy has no education, so you are making an assumption based on a serious lack of information. I think that indicates either a big ass inferiority complex that forces your attention on minor mistakes to make you feel better or you posses the cognitive ability of a greenfly, but I'll allow you to make this judgement by yourself because who would I be to have an opinion on someone based on some UA-cam comments.
he thinks the r8 isn't a good looking car.
what.
+jason lol innit
+jason When I 1st saw it, I thought the World was spinning the wrong way, and that before I saw it was made by Audi,,, xD
+jason i know right!
Clarkson also said that F50 looks horrible to him and F40 looks amazing. Different taste. I love the F50, but i don't really like the R8 design. Looks boring.
It isn't.
Good old days 🥲😢😭 I really have tears in my eyes
13 years on and Car Throttle feature the act same R8 on their channel
2:40 Zero to sixty in 4.6 seconds... and the new BMW M340i, which is just a slightly beefed up sedan and not even an M3, does it in 4.2 seconds. Cars really came a long way in the last 10 years. Regular saloons are outdoing former supercars in some regards.
That’s cause cars today are all about 0-60 and dcts and turbos
I agree. A normal Audi A6 3.0 will outperform an old 911 or R8 at the highway. However, it is still much more fun to cruise in a 911 or R8 than in a fast limousine or estate car
I remembered watching this on BBC late at night with everyone already tucked away in bed... When that 997 drifted into the scene, i jumped, screamed and yelled as if my favorite team scored a winning Champions League Final Goal. Back when Top Gear was Top Gear.
Carfection just drove that exact same R8 (same number plate) in their new vs old test. Pretty neat.
I'm coming from Mat Vatson's review and this car aged very well. Perfect time for investing manual ones.
The r8 is my favorite car of all time
+Spencer Breneman shame that..
+Spencer Breneman I h8 supercars, and I love this 1 xD
You're a hairdresser, are you?
Nothing really beats a 911 at the end of the day but the original R8 will forever be iconic. Truly two of the most memorable cars here
4:13 might be the best top gear shot
of all time
The audi no good looking? Are u crazy? Looks better than most supercars in my oppinion.
I like how at 4:13 The Audi just easily comes around the corner then the Porsche comes Flying out of the turn and slides sideways for like what looks like at least 30 meters.
Audi r8 is my favorite car in the world
2:12 „And I don‘t think it‘s a particularly good looking car“
🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
The 911 looks extra beautiful in this video.
Yes
Those black rims make it look so mean
That's what I love about Porsche, always beating cars that are faster on paper.
I heard the new porsche was the fastest right?
OverSizedMidget Theres no competition. Porsche has always been THE ONE TO BEAT for a reason.
eduardomdsr I just meant that i read that the new Porsche 918 Spyder is the fastest car in the world i don't know if that's true
+OverSizedMidget McLaren P1 and LaFerrari are both faster, but honestly who cares? None of us mere mortals will get to drive it.
Bailey Smith we might make a lot of money
Easily one of my favourite Top Gear reviews, ever.
I drive an R8 V8. Sure it is not the fastest car on the market. But with the sport exhausts it sounds fantastic nd it handles fantastic. It is also easy to live with an can be used as a daily driver both summer and winter without a problem. I also think it is beautiful which off cause is subjective. When I want more power, if I ever will, I supercharge it.
Love that Porsche!
Amazing, and both are manuals too!
1:15 "I am now doing 100 mph and it's like i am in church here"
perfect for autobahn
12 years later this is one of the best looking cars ever made
The most beautiful supercar of this century. Utterly iconic, elegant, sleek. And it looked like nothing else when it came out.
You can see this actual R8 in Mat watson's new video, it is still in epic condition after 13 years!
In my opinion the headlamps look pretty good
This is from 2008, when Audi (I think) start this trend. He thought it was a bad idea, now everyone is using it xD
And yeah, looks awesome!
True, Audi started it all with the R8.
Just bought an '08 R8, and I absolutely love it. It's had a magnesium exhaust put on it, it's a rare color, and that manual gearbox is silky smooth.
"Seems like Hammond has joined the party, with his volts wagon beetle" That killed it, xaxaxaxa!!!
I think the R8 is beautiful.
Totally agree with you
Just me, or does the older R8 look better?
Looks a lot better imo!
Bread Loaf it looks a lot better
Bread Loaf i have one and it is
tomgt4tom I find the older R8s much more inovative.
Yea
Another good review...nice job guys.
Really miss the first gen R8, it has its own special place, nowadays R8 don't look that great tbh.
yep ;)
The R8 looks much more handsome than the porsche... anyday
still the best editing I've ever seen, from any visual medium
That pull up that Hammond did was the best I’ve seen from any car video💯🔥
i love how the 911 just comes flying in sideways lol that completely sums it up
11 years later, what a great car especially with a V10
Once I was in a Grerman town and saw an R8 full kickdown right in the city centre... That was great
The cinematography here is absolutely brilliant, and the cars are great too, I prefer that first generation LED-headlight R8 look to the later ones
the 911 is way better, and after all that was only the carrera (mr practical) just u wait jeremey until the turbo and gt3 come!
Audi R8 V10 prototype on fire...little did they know what was coming
Love the way Richard Hammond just invites him self into the mix 😂😂😂 bring back top gear with the old guys and Harris 👏🏽🥂👊🏽👍🏽
porsche was all about hammond's statement in 5:35 and now 911 turbo s 992 shouts like a vacuum cleaner :)
"whats the point of having a sports car if you cant hear it?"
Welcome to the future of porsche hammond
Who else came here from car throttle?
Yes sir
God really miss the terrific trio Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May and the old top gear.. You made this show legendary.
8:40 "would you like to see what happened once they put the steam out?" Lol.
R8 simply looks like a supercar.
The Porsche, not so much.
That's because the only supercar they make is the 918. This on the other hand is a GT car
Do you have amy of them?
***** it is a supercar but the 918 replaced it
my friend said Porsche is better!
+Mansa Musa only super/hyper cars porsche makes is 918 and was carrera gt and well 959 but 911 isnt a super car you can simply tell that by 4 seats
R8 is so solid. It feels just right on a track, the seating position is excellent, the clutch is suprisingly easy to operate and the best bit is the sound of the gear selector moving in the shift gates (or what ever you call it). Those metallic 'click' sounds are music to ears (in addition to R8's nice sounding stock exhaust). What a great car it is!
Haha indeed
12 years ago and I remember it like yesterday
Still coming back to watch this in 2022 👌🏾
I miss the early 2000’s, when it was very good and acceptable for a car to have 400-500hp. Nowadays everybody wants superchargers, twin turbos, sportchips...
How can someone say that the OG R8 isn't astonishing beautiful?
This was one of the first episodes that I have watched of Top Gear.
HEY! The 911 only won because it had an unfair advantage at the start since it was about 3 feet ahead of the R8, and that is how much it won by. If the Drag Race had been fairly set up, then the R8 may have tied the 911, if not beat it. And don't call me a cock, because I actually like Porsche as well as Audi.
I smell.....
A LAWSUIT
The R8 was only 1 foot behind the Porsche at the start. But won't a 911 Carrera S vs R8 V10 be fun?
Plus Hammond is probably 100 kilos lighter than Jeremy.
SIMcityplayer2002 even if it was one foot behind, it's still unfair. And the r8 V10 would nail a Porsche any day