Pakistan In 1970s | Untold Stories of The War & Surrender | General Yahya Khan
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- 60s Mein Kiya Huwa? - • What We Didn't Know Ab...
50s Mein Kiya Huwa? - • After 1949 The Untold ...
40s Mein Kiya Huwa? - • From Independence To 1...
On December 16, 1971, the fall of Dhaka and the subsequent surrender marked a turning point in history, reshaping the region and its future. In this Podcast with Mr. Naveid Siddiqui, we delve into the events that led to this momentous day, exploring the intricacies of the war and the concealed surrender that defined it. We uncover the political maneuvers and hidden agendas that played a crucial role in this historic event, shedding light on why the surrender was kept under wraps for so long. Join us as we navigate through the untold aspects of the 1971 war and its profound impact on Pakistan's history.
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
UA-cam
/ @raftartv
UA-cam
/ @raftarnewsofficial
UA-cam
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
“Never won a war
Never lost a election”
-Pak Army
Says a Hindu who lost 1962, 1987 in Sri Lanka and then in 2019 in an utter humiliation lost a pilot but more importantly, brought down own helicopter by own missile
Every force has its share of glory and humiliation
We still hold around 40% of Kashmir and our brother China also has 12% of Kashmir you couldn't even take that back lol.🤡
Nothing beats the feast that eyes enjoy , witnessing 93k full grown men Surrender downing their F'in trunks 😂
And yeah a decorated photograph hangs in our Presidential House 😂 @@markralph4739
There is no evidence of it. 1948 war, Afghan war and many other wars won by Pak Army. Not sure what do you smoke.
dont watch Pakistani media otherwise u will keep seek asylum in Europe even at the cost of ur life 😢😢
Story of Pakistan after 77 years...50% Mulk Bangla ho gaya aur Baaki 50% Kangla ho gaya 🫢
The story of Pakistan is despite being a 4 times smaller country, taking 1/3rd Kashmir from pajeetistan in 1948, making Nehru run to UNSC to beg for a ceasefire on the advice of his CnC (per Butcher papers). Then, capturing territory after defeating the Indian army in Rann of Kutch in April 1965. Despite the Indian army's achievement of total strategic surprise on the eve of 6th September 1965 when it crossed the IB and invaded Pakistan, not only pushing the invaders back but ending up capturing Indian territory, which was retained till the end of the war and used as a bargaining tool. The only triumph in p*jeet army's 1,000 years of history of c*ckoldery to their betters came in the shape of 1971 when Pakistan was in the midst of a civil war in which the ethnic majority (Bengalis constituted 51% of Pakistan's total population) was in open rebellion, there were mass defections of Bengalis from Pakistani armed forces who had fed all details ranging from Pakistani war plans to vulnerabilities, beneficial terrain/conditions for military operations to the Indian military planners and executioners of mil ops. 45,000 Pakistani army regulars (augmented by auxiliary paramilitaries and volunteers) faced an invading force with a 15:1 ratio in East Pakistan (according to Manekshaw). The supply lines were cut off due to no land or air link with West Pakistan (the main base of power). Own population and military personnel of Bengali descent were up in arms. The Lone (incomplete) squadron of PAF faced 11-15 IAF squadrons in the East. It mostly stayed intact and only stopped flying once the main airfield was rendered inoperable after 5 days of taking extreme attrition at the hands of this PAF squadron by the IAF cucs. Despite being 1,000 km away from the main base of power with no possibility of relief or reinforcements, being surrounded by Indian territory on three sides and Indian controlled bay of Bengal on the 4th side, the Pakistani army gave battles like Hilli Bogra, which continued even after the declaration of general surrender. Even in this war, we annexed Chamb from you in the Western theatre. Took strategic peaks in 1999 during the Kargil operation, many of which remain with us to this day. Contrast the war performance of my nation of chads that not only took each war fought to a 4 times larger country's land (capturing and retaining it till the end of each war) with your own cuc nation's against a peer adversary in the shape of China, which absorbed a territory the size of Switzerland (Aksai Chin) in 62 and declared unilateral ceasefire after all its objectives were met with the entire war fought on your land and you not even being able to capture 1 sq inch of Chinese territory. Then since 2000 alone, you have lost over 1,650 sq km to the PLA without as much as firing a shot in the Laddakh sector and along the McMohan line. Cux like you should sit silently in a corner. 🤣😂
Bhai Bhai 😝
@@muneebtahir9810 Well i tell you the real history and not the distorted one that you were taught, you attacked kashmir in 1947 and captured large part of it but when indian army started responding and started pushing you back to where you are today, yes our PM Nehru made a mistake by going to UNSC but you know what did we gain out of it, we captured the source of 5 main rivers of Kashmir, now we decide how much water will go to Pakistan and when we have to open the gates of various dams😆, Now come to 1965 , you started 1965 war with the motive of capturing Kashmir, did you get it ??? Our Army raised Indian flag in Govt school in lahore and took one double decker bus with them which we praded in Amritsar, we captured strategically important Hajipir pass which was given back to you in Tashkent, in 1971 we made your 90000 soldiers surrender and take off their pants in the prade and broke your country into two parts, we captured important heights in siachin in 1984 from you which we still own, in 1999 when you tried to do siachin with us in kargil our Army responded in a way that your PM Nawaz had to run to USA for the ceasefire, again you were defeated there too, UA-cam is full of your generals and colonels' opinions on kargil, you can check each every thing that i said here on google if you have any doubts, you fought 4 wars for our kashmir but didn't get even an inch of it but ended up breaking your country but you still have the audacity to troll us, bravo😆😆😆
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Wah Wah 😂😂
Yahya was drinking his favourite whiskey, while dreaming to romance General Raani, on the night of 15th December 1971
Both he and FM Manekshaw drank Black Dog. Please do not say anything bad about Jernail Rani, I love her.
@@gautamsarkar3294 NO. You are not informed, cultivate the habit of reading, my brother. In a quote in the famous book, "And now Sheikh Mujib is destroyed!" He then left with his partner, the famous singer Noor Jehan, Dewan Barindranath wrote in his 2016 book "Private life of Yahya Khan".
When the Liberation War began, he became paranoid with fear; a fear of losing, perhaps. He would regularly suffer from hallucinations about Bhutto, Indira Gandhi, and Jagjivan Ram.
Journalist Amir Taheri of Iranian newspaper Kayhan International lived close to the Presidential Guest House in 1971. In an issue published on 27 February 1972, he wrote that during the war, Yahya Khan would drink two to two and a half litres of alcohol every day to calm his nerves. Sometimes he would apparently wake up at night, screaming, "Take Mujib away from here and hang him!"
Your country was not divided by India but by Yaya khan. Our Chief of Army Sam Manekshah knew Yaya very well cos both of them served in British Indian army. He designed the strategy in such a way to beat Yaya by brain. After the operation search light same Tikka khan was sent to Baluchistan. In pursuit to control the country and power, your army has become cannibal and they’re not going to give up on power
Actually from 14th August 1947 from the freedom day when THE WEST BENGAL PRIME MINISTER HUSSAIN SHAHEED SUHARWARDI were not appoint as a PRIME MINISTER but LIAQUAT ALI KHAN WERE appoint as PRIME MINISTER of PAKISTAN , so it were MILESTONE for libration of BENGAL , then when JINNAH went to DAHKA UNIVERSITY in 1948 and announced there that URDU will be the NATIONAL LANGUAGE OF PAKISTAN so it were PETROL BOMB which leads this matter to 1951 bloodied protests , and then ONE UNIT IMPOSED in 1955 so again BENGAL were practically separated by Pakistani establishment then 1958 AYOUB DETAINED THE MILITARY COUP as a first PAKISTAN MARTIAL LAW and finished 1956 CONSTITIUTION and then they stands with new MOTIVE and all the west Pakistani elites civil and military both gather together to opposed BENGALIES and BENGALI also came openly opposed to WEST PAKISTAN ELITES and 1970 FLOODS OF EAST PAKISTAN which destroyed EAST PAKISTAN INFRASTRUCTURE and then after 1970 GENERAL ELECTIONS and SHAKIH MUJEEB UR REHMAN 6 POINTS had done openly the burning woods to PETROL drowning , and both WEST PAKISTAN ELITES and BENGALIES came to front against each other openly .
YAHYA KHAN were just the one character he is less culprit then AYOUB KHAN and ZULFIQAR ALI BHUTTO and PUNJAB MILITARY AND CIVIL ELITES.
@@MushtaqKhan-yb9sz these events are well known but still Shaikh mujeeb asked for little autonomy which was not given. Operation searchlight was started when ‘great’ Yaya said mein in bangalio ki nasle badal dunga and leashed his soldiers onto women to assault them. Last straw. Irony is same tikka khan was sent to Baluchistan so one can only shudder to think what they would have done in Baluchistan. India doesn’t share the border with Baloch else. Khan of kalat had asked Nehru to take them in India but he refused so please together help those guys.
@@anuchugh31
Again i am telling you that YAHYA KHAN were just a one character of the sequence events which are much more than i pointed in my reply comment you, for example i don't mention the 1964 presidential election between AYOUB KHAN and HOUR ARABLE. FATIMA JINNAH youngest sister of MR. JINNAH AND MR. JINNAH NEAREST FREEDOM MOMENT PARTNER , sheikh MUJEEB UR REHMAN were her CHIEF POLLING AGENT AT EAST PAKISTAN (BENGAL) and SHE GOT OVERWHELMING MAJORITY from EAST PAKISTAN but AYOUB KHAN show her LOOSER and HIMSELF as a WINNER so in that time MUJEEB UR REHMAN DID LARGE protest against AYOUB KHAN in EAST PAKISTAN and create a WORSE LAW AND ORDER SITUATION for LAW ENFORCEMENT DEPARTMENT and much more i.e in 1964 before Presidential elections HUSAIN SHAHEED SUHARWARDI THE FOUNDER OF AWAMI LEAGUE were poisoned at (BEIRUT LEBANON HOTEL) THE DEAREST LEADER OF BENGALI THROUGHOUT THE WEST AND EAST BENGAL BY PAKISTANI MILITARY INTELLIGENCE AGENCY latter MUJEEB WERE CHOSE AS PRESIDENT OF AWAMI LEAGUE .
Also sheikh MUJEEB raise after his assassination and there is controversy that MUJEEB AND AYOUB WERE IN ONE PAGE AT THIS POINT BECAUSE HE WERE THE NON OBJECTIONABLE LEADER OF THE BENGALIES EVEN IN WEST BENGAL A STATE OF INDIAN TERRITORY. MAY LORD BETTER KNOW BUT HE RAISE AS A POLITICAL LEADER AFTER SUHARWARDI assassination.
Their country was not broken by Yahya or Bhutto.
It was broken by this false sense. That they must have one nation, one language, one religion and one everything. Absolute disregard for diversity and diverse points of view.
There is a lesson for modern day India in that
hidden surrender? 🤣🤣🤣 it was pretty open surrender of 95000 soldiers 🤣 not just a surrender but a humiliating surrender 😂😂😂
Emotional Damage 😂😂😂
What about 1962 humiliation or jubilation?
@@rajindersingh463 and an return gift in 1967 to chinese
@@rahulbanerjee2363they did again in 2020 and still in possession in ladakh?
Do you see 1962 humiliation with 1967 on same page? Insane person 😂😂
How can anyone say India badniyati... India jumped in this war only to support Bangadeshi..& not snatch it under their rule from Pak..
West Pak didn't deserve Bangladesh.. & they haven't learnt their lesson yet..can be seen in Balochistan etc etc.
Introspection is needed guys!!
Badniyati , Besharmi and Behayaii toh inke DNA mai hai...
If India had bad intentions she would have made Bangladesh a state under India and 93000 POW would have been left to be slaughtered at hand of Mukti Bahini...
By grace of Field Marshal Sam Maneckshaw these POWs were treated humanely by India.
India and RAW are indeed involved in Balochistan distress too, proof was the arrest of Kalbhoshan Yadav and its connections with Indian intelligence agencies.
Please its politics and both countries have ugly interference to weaken each other.
@@antipghosh exactly. Badniyati hoti toh kabza karte. Saunp k nahi aate
He has to say these nahi toh inke Hidarey inhe utha le jayenge
Dushman se larna hamari Fouj k bas ka kaam ni hai
Haan apney mulk ko bar bar fatah krtey hain
I was 17 years old at the time of Bangladesh liberation. I am witness to Mukti Bahini training. The surrender ceremonies by the Pakistan Army lasted severel days. My father who was an Indian Army Officer, went there for one of the surrender ceremonies of the Pakistan Army.
I have seen your POWs in army barracks converted to temporary jails. The prisoners were given full respects. Some of them had grown long beards. I have heard that that they would shave it only when they would return to Pakistan. I will not disclose the place where I had been because of the security reasons.
What a shallow person with an absolute lie. Wouldn't disclose a top secret location that's over 5 decades old
We kept that rates at Jabalpur
@@markralph4739 Asli naam se aao abdul
No army in the world can fight from four directions. Left right and back sides were Mukti bahini trained by Indian army. On front was Indian army having advantage of of local support and 100 to 200 km away from their base camp. Pakistani army was fighting 1500 mile away from their head quarter west Pakistan. They were only 38000 in numbers while Indian army was more than two hundred thousand. Pak army was in shortage of arms and ammunition also but they fought very bravely. According to Gen. Manak Sha Indian commander in chief.
@@AbdulMalik-z4c when General Niyazi was offered to surrender by Indian Army we have only 3000 soldiers in Dhaka and Niyazi had 27000 soldiers total strength of Pakistan army was about to 93k and it was a bold move by Indian Army and we observed that we get a tough fight but Niyazi surrendered, and that's history was made and Pakistan's geography was changed by India.
Why didn't you mention operation Chengiz Khan?
Pakistan started the war of 1971 by attacking Kashmir with airstrikes. That's how 1971 officially began
@@TheLowsofSolipsism Story of Pakistan after 77 years...50% mulk Bangla ho gaya aur Baaki 50% Kangla ho gaya🤣🤣
Incorrect. The Indian army was making bridgeheads by invading East Pakistani territory as early as October 1971 alongside Mukti Bahini. India had already started the war.
@@HarshKharwar-jp6nf the story of Pakistan is despite being a 4 times smaller country, taking 1/3rd Kashmir from pajeetistan in 1948, making Nehru run to UNSC to beg for a ceasefire on the advice of his CnC (per Butcher papers). Then, capturing territory after defeating the Indian army in Rann of Kutch in April 1965. Despite the Indian army's achievement of total strategic surprise on the eve of 6th September 1965 when it crossed the IB and invaded Pakistan, not only pushing the invaders back but ending up capturing Indian territory, which was retained till the end of the war and used as a bargaining tool. The only triumph in p*jeet army's 1,000 years of history of c*ckoldery to their betters came in the shape of 1971 when Pakistan was in the midst of a civil war in which the ethnic majority (Bengalis constituted 51% of Pakistan's total population) was in open rebellion, there were mass defections of Bengalis from Pakistani armed forces who had fed all details ranging from Pakistani war plans to vulnerabilities, beneficial terrain/conditions for military operations to the Indian military planners and executioners of mil ops. 45,000 Pakistani army regulars (augmented by auxiliary paramilitaries and volunteers) faced an invading force with a 15:1 ratio in East Pakistan (according to Manekshaw). The supply lines were cut off due to no land or air link with West Pakistan (the main base of power). Own population and military personnel of Bengali descent were up in arms. The Lone (incomplete) squadron of PAF faced 11-15 IAF squadrons in the East. It mostly stayed intact and only stopped flying once the main airfield was rendered inoperable after 5 days of taking extreme attrition at the hands of this PAF squadron by the IAF cucs. Despite being 1,000 km away from the main base of power with no possibility of relief or reinforcements, being surrounded by Indian territory on three sides and Indian controlled bay of Bengal on the 4th side, the Pakistani army gave battles like Hilli Bogra, which continued even after the declaration of general surrender. Even in this war, we annexed Chamb from you in the Western theatre. Took strategic peaks in 1999 during the Kargil operation, many of which remain with us to this day. Contrast the war performance of my nation of chads that not only took each war fought to a 4 times larger country's land (capturing and retaining it till the end of each war) with your own cuc nation's against a peer adversary in the shape of China, which absorbed a territory the size of Switzerland (Aksai Chin) in 62 and declared unilateral ceasefire after all its objectives were met with the entire war fought on your land and you not even being able to capture 1 sq inch of Chinese territory. Then since 2000 alone, you have lost over 1,650 sq km to the PLA without as much as firing a shot in the Laddakh sector and along the McMohan line. Cux like you should sit silently in a corner. 🤣😂
@@muneebtahir9810Learn 1971 war from your own Air Chief Marshal interview available on UA-cam not from the pseudo scholars. Your own people have given multiple interviews to your media about all the wars against Bharat. Dekh lo, Dil ko sukoon milega… 😂😂😂😂
@@Sahil-Exm which interview? Share link. Have you watched Manekshaw's interview? 🤡🤡🤡
One of the unbiased show of Pakistan ❤❤❤
Its highly biased, carpeting heinous crimes of pak army against own citizens.
One of the best things about the Indian government is that despite the horrific crimes done by the enemy in the battle, our forces always honor Geneva conventions and other International obligations. We even give burial with honor to the enemy.
Pakistan is yet to mature as a nation and that shows in their troubled past and present. Always short term thinking and ensuring long term damage. Even a lot of non resident Pakistanis engage in crimes and fraud when living abroad. Definitely the country's education system lacks moral teaching and lack of that permeates to every level of their society.
I do not say this to brag about any superiority of Indians but look around. Today India is far ahead in many fields compared to Pakistan. Are we the best? No, we still have a long way to go. But at least we are on the right path. But Pakistan seems to have lost its bearing decades ago.
But we did not held Pakistan army accountable for war crimes. The atrocities were nothing less that the Nazis. It was nothing short of a holocaust for them and the Pakistani generals should have been tried of their crimes.
First free and fair election caused break-up of the country. How fragile is Pakistan 😂
@@aanakrukavi bro you might be right but no reason to happy as Bangladesh is still a Muslim country. Just name is changed.
@@razaulmustafa52how is that relevant 🤔 ? even india got more Muslims than Pakistan, so ?
Pakistan army is making undergarments and running sugar industry 😂
95,000 PATLOONS, AIK WAR BHI NAHI JEETI AUR SIRF ELECTION JEETA HAI.
Hidden surrender ?😂
Pak Army openely surrendered in Bangladesh
Faisal sir i m from india and i want a separate podcast on indian history by shabar zaidi. Bcz to much indian want to see shabar zaidi in your podcast. Big fan of your podcast
Pakistan should thank India for saving 93000 armed forces. Because mukti gureelas demanded masscare of all 93000 armed forces, rajakars, biharis and all jamati Islamist. But it was rejected by indira gandhi and Field Marshal Sam manekshwa.
Haramkhori rag rag mai hai... Nahi jayegi
@@sitarampradhan8488 it was biggest mistake of Indira Gandhi , all garbage if cleared at that time would not have resulted in today’s situation of Bangladesh people . Now it seems a very big blunder by her and the general
i am amazed to see same people ruling Pakistan who have damage it most. Public of Pakistan are the most obedient to establishment. and for 100 years this will go on
Can’t take it anymore. This was a very painful for generation of that era. 😢
u guys r holding on something that is total lie so these pain r mend to face
What is painful in that musalman ( punjabi ) raped musalmani ( Bangai ) Beauty of islam 😅😅
Raftar that was historic open surrender in the history of world
Who wins the trophy for being the “maddest” remains an open question in the 1970s? Oxford-educated Teddy boy? Jihadi military general? “IM the DIM”: Malignant Buffoon? In wait. Great guest. For keeping up with the madhouse.
Next video on
1. 1906 Muslim league creation in Bengal....
2. Bengals contribution on creation of Pakistan
3. A. K Fazlul Hoque kaun thein - Lahore act
16:00
He wanted to say Rapes happened so many times...but didn't.
Liar
The 1971 Indo-Pakistani War, also known as the third India-Pakistan war, began on December 3, 1971 when the Pakistani Air Force (PAF) launched Operation Chengiz Khan. The operation involved preemptive strikes on 11 Indian airbases and air defense radars, including Amritsar, Ambala, Agra, and Srinagar. The PAF also launched artillery strikes on Indian positions in Kashmir. India responded by declaring war on Pakistan and entering the war on the side of Bengali nationalist forces.
آپ کہے رہے ہیں ملک کا بدترین دن وہ تھا جس دن ملک دو لخت ہوا مگر قوم سے زبردستی یہ اقرار کروایا جا رہا ہے کے نو مئی زیادہ بڑا دن ہے
I still not over from 16 December the fall of Dhaka whenever it comes I just upset and knows later what the west Pakistani elite people behaviour with east Pakistani who's made Pakistan actually.yahya was on driving seat and had power but he will remember always as biggest blunder in Pakistan history.
Unfortunate - same way Baluch’s have been treated for decades- abducted, butchered and marginalised-/ yet paki army haven’t learned any lessons
The west Pakistani elite was always get rid of east Pakistan.
Sir
I am surprised with comments by Pakistanis - example a comment below on comparison between Muslim Army and Hindu soldier.
This false superiority complex has led to your own regression.
Also led a moderate Indian fully supporting BJP’s stand of minimum contact with your country and society.
Also leads to fuller understanding and “appreciation” of Mr Jinnah’s two nation theory.
Much lesser headache for us.
Raftar is a good çhannel
You guys still haven't got it...
Sharmindgi instrument of surrender ke din nahi hua.. it should have been the atrocities carried out by west pak over general bang public.. khuda ka khauf karein!
یہ جس موضوع پر آپ آج بات کر رہے ہیں یہ اس ملک کے مظلوم کے دل کی آواز ہے
People of that country never learn by any subject ,Islam makes you mentally blind
Saqot e dhaka k roz awaam or students apne college or universities sy nikal k lahore or karachi ki sarko py dhar’en mar k rootay rahy
We want to see this series to 2020 from Siddiqui SB
East Pakistan me India inter fare kar dia
Yahan Balochistan or kpk KC ki Taliban ki interference ka intizar kar Rahe hen
Aaj kpk ki ground reality koi report kr rha hai ? Koi Ground reporting? Ya documentary? Haha
Not only Khyber Pakhtunkhwa but Sindh and Balochistan are also in the same condition hahaha
@@Lyari939 in punjab too haha
Pakistanis are happy with one Abhinandan.
Indians were 93,000 times happier than Pakistanis 😂
Pakistan is a confuse country so dont take them seriously 😂
why don't you guys get rid of notions of civilian supremacy and live happily everafter - democracy is too woke for your palates
Excellent narration.
All the kids in Pakistan should be made to hear this for a correct appreciation of history.
Well done .👍😊
Sach mein aj ehsas hua k hm to Ashfaq Ahmed, Bano Qudsiya wagera ko buhat bra samjhtay mgr wo b bus utna sach bolte thay jitna bardasht ho suaron ko. Unfortunately that generation is real culprit and may be shows why it was always no nation from the start. Had it been organically gained independence no nation would have had digested loss of half of territory.
Please upload other episodes soon. Desperately waiting for it..... you both are awesome and doing a great job ❤
Please Keep up the Series
Don’t blame India to supporting Mukti Bahini! We replied the same way that Pak did in 1965 by trying to instigate Kashmiris
Tumhare mulk me konsi sacchai state aur media bolti hai 4 war harkar jhoot bolne wale log jhoot padhne wale log
yeh kaum tab tak zinda hai jabtak jhoot ka sahara hai
1947 say 1971 tak bangladesh may kitnay profesor lectureer teachar hindu tay
All secrets of Balakot strike from Pakistan side will come out similar to Hamdur Rehman Committee Report may be after 20 year's 😂.
Ab b wohi kuch ho raha hai
Fouj ne ic surrender se kuch ni seekha
Invite Shabbat Zaidi...
Excellent well informed captivating discussion. I throughly enjoyed it
It was an "unconditional surrender" most humiliating thing for an army 😆
16:40 it’s the same thing Pakistan doing in blochistan today
This episode is going to be ❤❤❤
India didn't win the war. Pakistan lost. It was fighting India on its western border and eastern border and Bangladeshi freedom fighters. And to supply east Pakistan at the huge distance was problematic. Plus it's armed forces weren't well trained and prepared. Today it's a total different story. Pakistan has built an extremely powerful armed forces. Today although india spends billions of dollars on its armed forces, its stumbling paper tiger. Also the mental strength of muslims in Pakistan to fight is by far greater than a hindu soldier.
the youth is aware, know about past mistake but right now didn't change in Pakistan
Not fall of the Dhaka, it was rise of Dhaka
Great one hour narrative. Learnt and refreshed...
As far as intellectual response please refer to Jon Elya poem کیا اسقدرحقیرِ تھا اس قوم کا وقار. It was played on TV on the Dec18 on PTV
Why have you ignored the most important episode of the Bangladesh movement, which was unquestionably the unforgettable speech given by Sk. Mujib on 7th of March 1971 before lacs of people in Dacca Ramna Maidan. This speech inspired the whole Bnagladesh people to take head on the Pakistanis to clinch their rights. Set your facts correctly bro.
Ek martial race ne Hindu baniye ke samne surrender kar diya. Even today they think their army is the greatest in the world. They have not told their masses that it was the biggest surrender of an army after 2nd world war. At least these 2 are discussing the situation in a very Frank manner. Pakistan has proved again and again that it's the most uncivilized, barbaric illiterate and uncouth country in the world. Your pows in Indian custody instead of feeling humiliated or embarrassed were asking the Indian authorities to show Pakeezah movie at the POWs camp. That is the true calibre of this brave Pakistani army.
Pakistanis are still not aware of the genocide carried out by Pakistani army in the then East Bengal as west Pakistani newspapers and journalists did not report the ground realities in East Bengal. Those who are interested may read a weekly Hindi Magazine called Dharmyug (Times of India Group) from June 1971 to February 1972. The magazine got closed long back, so it should be available with special efforts in libraries only. Reports on Mukti Wahini and East Bengal in Dharmyug were written exclusively by those, including editor Dharmveer Bharti, who were present on the spot. Reports appeared credible and may give numerous leads to researchers on the subject.
U cant teach shame to shameless
What an educational and informative narrative .
Don't take it as entertainment or just recreation.
Must read and get educated by all educated Pakistani people.
I am interested in knowing where this guy got his figures. Raftar should challenge the people they bring on their platform more. The figures he cites about military losses are inaccurate and highly exaggerated.
Bhutto nationalized the industrial sector, Benazir started to privatize, Zardari, Sharif’s and the armed forces decided to “familialize” the nation’s coffers.
I am indian muslim imran Khan ko wapas lao please
Abe tu apna dekh le kahi tujhe desh se na nikal de
No
Main abhi waapis laata hoon!
@@malikahmad8170😂 good , ab Anish Bhai ne bola h toh manna ho padega
@@RohitSharma-oh8qm yessir, I would comply
Only raftar is best❤
Reason I love Raftar!
Hotels of Dhaka University were targetted. Hundreds of intellectuals were eliminated 16:57
China USA meeting was arranged by Poland . While returning from USA, Chinese officials were landed at Any one of your airport and flew back to China . This is the only thing Pakistan did for Chinese officials. There was no more critical roll played by your country. Check the history in detail.
Ihmad Raza Qusuri was nor alone went to dhaka Bacha Khan and some other leaders were also there and they also had a good meeting with Sheikh Mujeeb.
Many Muslims demanded and created East and West Pakistan with use of force and violence,then didn’t know,what to do with 2 pieces of land.
Wonderful Sir, Naveed Siddiqui
Sir
I am surprised with the word ‘Niyat’ of India.
Please be factual.
It is well known that all wars, including Kargil, were started by Pakistan under hollow ‘superiority complex’.
3:46 There was devastating cyclone which resulted in floods
Pakistan can easily progress is by embracing democracy, enforcing accountability among the ruling class, removing Islam as state religion. If these are done with sincerity, eliminating terrorism will happen automatically. Since it's a relatively small country, bringing it back to track won't be difficult. Pakistan should stop depending on China as well.
Good knowledge.
Even this highly knowledgeable man says dushman mulk, aisa lagta hai paida hote he sikhaya jata hai kaun hai dushman mulk. Ya phir inhone galti se bol. Diya hoga.
Elections were not transparent but if we compare those elections to other elections held after those then we can say that those elections were transparent as compared to the laters ones
السلام علیکم۔ "رفتار" چینل کی انفرادیت یہ ہے کہ اس چینل سے طلباء و اساتذہ سمیت بہت ہی سنجیدہ طبقہ استفادہ کررہا ہے
لیکن بہت سے پروگرام ابھی باقی ہیں
ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد کی زندگی پر ایک بھرپور معلوماتی پروگرام درکار ہے
حبیب جالب کی زندگی پر پروگرام درکار ہے
محترمہ بے نظیر بھٹو کی زندگی اور ان کے قتل پر ایک سے زائد پروگرام پیش کیے جاسکتے ہیں
ذیشان ہاشمی ۔ لاہور
It was not fall of dhaka..it was fall of Pakistan & creation of Bangladesh. Dhaka never fell !
Sir one documentary on dua zehra case and expose the mafia pls.. More documentaries on tanker mafia, beggars mafia operating in Pak...
Bhutto's horoscope indicated that his life is only 51 years and the Hindu Astrologer had broken the nib of the pen at 52nd year.
Current problem in Bangladesh is Pak's involvement in regime change...
Just indian mentality according to indian's India key khilaf Jo bhi hoga vo Pakistan hi karega
@@arhammirza1205Pakistaniyon ko sachchai 30-40 saal ke baad hi pataa chalti hai. Itna time wo apne establishment ke narrative par hi jeete hain. Bangladesh regime change ki sachchai bhi apko 30-40 saal ke baad hi pataa chalegi.
Bharat mein public ko sachchai saath ke saath pataa chalti rahti hai. Hame hamesha pataa thaa ki 1948, 1962, 1965, 1971 aur 1999 ki wars mein kya hua thaa aur kaun haaraa, kaun jeeta. Pakistaniyon ki tarah nahi jinhe 40-50 saal tak sachchai ka pataa hi nahi thaa. 🇮🇳
@@rakeshmamgaain5362 pheli baat keh kon raha hai jiske yaha pora media godhi media hai government ka narrative chalata hai government ka propaganda or haa Mr hamey pata hai 1948 mey kon jeeta Pakistan won 1/3rd of kashmir in 1965 their was indian army on doors of Lahore and Pakistan army captured whole run of Kutch region and we're on the doors of Amritsar then in 1971 India won on ground but Pakistan won on diplomacy tabhi 93,000 soldier's or 15,000 sq/km land india ney wapis dedi or badle mey Pakistan ney ek inch zameen bhi nahi di in Kargil according to wikipedia Pakistan army won militarily but india won diplomatically and Pakistan has to leave those check post due to global pressure Mr or haa India mey government key narrative key ilawa Kisi or ko bolne ki azadi taak nahi tabhi press freedom index mey india Pakistan se peche hai godhi media key pappu Whatsapp university graduate
You should have a backdrop of Pictures and videos running of what and who You are talking about with dates of Pictures of Persons you are talking. Not a Drawing Room discussion please
Don't mess with Pakistan or else they will surrender 💀🤣
Time stamps would be appreciated!
Raftar......😅😅😅😅😅 Heiden surrender what a joke maja aa geya soon kar , 95000 declare surrender 1971 , Pak Army ney Guard 💂♂️ of Honor bhi diya tha Indian Forces ki SHAN main 😅😅😅😅
1971 Nasoor hai Pak Forces par 😅😅😅😅 Love ❤️ India 🇮🇳 , From India 🇮🇳 Jai Hind
Elephant in the room,Do Kauhmi Nazariya,nobody want to recognise.
Bhutto have two great achievement after 1971 one was started nuclear weapons program and started proxy war started against India and Afghanistan
@@ShadowRipper-p3k the nuclear program was started in late 60's
@@najam067 nope that nuclear was for energy sector not for Defence
@@ShadowRipper-p3k that doesn't matter...
There were only 7 or 8 fighter jets in East Pakistan.
Kissinger went at the time of Yahya , not Zia
Virtually no navy and only 30,000 Army fighting men.
The surrender order was transmitted via the US embassy in Pashto.
Not just floods, rather a cyclone. With climate change, a large portion of BD will be under water.
Very big fan of raftar tv ist comment
Pakistan had just one squadron at Tejgaon. How is that half PAF?
The fact is that Pakistan was created a federation of two contrasting wings which were one thousand miles apart. Infact 1970 election was contested on the manifesto of 6 point demands of Mujeeburahman that straightway amounts to separation & Bangalis turn victorious in this. Therefore East Pakistan should have been left out amicably because of language, culture, long distance, hostile neighbour between East & the West wings, Bangali nationalism & other differences. But the only sorry state of affair is that it came at the cost of war with India.
You need to show what was printe din media during the wartime
Pakistan's history is marked by controversy, political manipulation, and violence. There has been a persistent power struggle between the elected political government and the establishment, with the Army often gaining the upper hand in governance. Unfortunately, the establishment, led by its self-serving generals and top officials, has treated Pakistan as their personal domain. They have successfully propagated a false narrative that the nation is in constant danger and requires strict control. Meanwhile, they have amassed wealth through corrupt means and accumulated personal assets for themselves. Perhaps, it was a deliberate attempt to keep its awaam uneducated so that they don’t question their authority. Hope Pakistanis realise this, sooner the better
Good podcast
Why pakistani people calls pak army a DOLLOR ARMY ????????
The permanent membership of UN was gifted by foolish Nehru (that time PM of India ) to China.
The Jamat e Islami's had stood most candidate from Mushraqi Pakistan now Bangladesh which we seen in these days too.
As long as your leaders are India centric this will continue to happen. Cross border terrorism , pls stop. This isn't helping you.
Floods came in Sep and not in July . I was administrator of Noakhli District .
Three characters are responsible for mayhem . Indra decided to invade.
It would be very enlightening to hear your thoughts, please speakup and let us know the unknown or undiscussed facts
What happened in Bangladesh... was the doing of one of the world biggest t..err...oist organization...jamaat e islami