Ali is so conspicuous, he is a very dangerous personality in a relationship. Unfortunately, young women often don’t have the experience it takes to recognize the personality. They often think that they can fix the relationship by cooperating. Victims are typically sympathetic personalities, they forgive again and again. If they get out alive, they are most likely traumatized by a person like Ali.
@@ManuelaCircowhen you’re married to a narcissist, it’s ten times worse trying to get a divorce for a start. They are like leeches, they control and manipulate, you’re the one who seems crazy. But, hey, you have to have lived with one to know. I don’t expect people to know what a snake Ali is. 😔🙏🏽
Not to shame her but IMO, the husband deserves his sentences. Why did she encourage Ali to move to San Diego? It look like she was trapped in a dull life in VA and if he was abusive there, she could’ve not let him come. Where did the drug abuse come from. I doubt he abused drugs in front of his family. I guess it came from her friends. Sounds like a toxic and immature pair who don’t deserve their child.
He killed 2 innocent victims because she left him and he got jealous, I hope he gets life.. he did nothing but blame everyone and everything for what he did never took responsibility
Ali is a conspicuous narcissistic misogynist. The most dangerous time in an abusive relationship is in the leaving. Often victims listen to the voices around them, saying to just leave, don’t let him push you around. They underestimate the potential for violence. The victims risk their lives for their freedom.
get a g_n. Most people never have any courage to fight or defend themselves. That’s why these types are always so abusive because people enable them. The reason why he brought a gun was because he was afraid to fight ray. So he ambushed him.
My heart pours for this little girl due to the trauma she endured because of her father's actions. My thoughts and prayers are with Ana and Ray's loved ones.
It's beyond sad. Losing both your parents simultaneously and finding out your own dad killed your own mom. The daughter should of been given to Ana's family not Ali Babba
The amount of people in the comments who have absolutely no idea about dv and what its like to be in a dv relationship is astounding. Unless you have been in a relationship with a controlling, violent narcissist and have been a victim of dv you have no idea what you're talking about! "Why didnt she do this" "why did she do that" "it takes 2 to tango" "why did she provoke him" 🙄. With men like this making their food too hot or too cold, forgetting an innocent task and any insignificant thing can set these men off they will always find an excuse. So please unless you have been in a dv relationship you can not possibly understand the coercive control and manipulation and fear so please stop blaming the victim! 💜💜
Victims are always living by their abusers rules, it is self preservation. Not only can you not control the outcome by your movements they will abuse you for outside events. There is no rationale to why they abuse, it has nothing to do with the victim.
@@amills9261 literally. To an abuser nothing you do will ever be enough or okay for them. Idk how people are siding with that devil Ali. He’s getting his in prison now though thank the lord.
@@Kaykayu98 were you there??? How dare you? She's not alive to give her side of the story because he killed her. He also was on the stand for 3 days and admitted to the several times he beat her up. He's dangerous. I don't care how mad you are male or female- you don't shoot that person or batter them!!!!
@@lucindalynnxoexactly & there is spot deep down in hell for anybody justifying his actions. Any of these people playing the victim blaming game would want support if this was their situation.
@@lucindalynnxo he should’ve got a heat of passion trial, it’s literally the definition… she didn’t deserve to die and he didn’t deserve to see her being a hoe with their friend
Justice for Ana and Ray ❤ also sending good healing vibes to their daughter who essentially lost both of her parents in this tragic, senseless act of violence.
Not blaming her. Just saying she was stupid af for bringing a dude up to her apartment hours after her enraged violently jealous husband had trashed it.
Wow shows what kind of women Ana was, befriended a girl that had sexual acts with her husband and had no ill will towards her, she seemed like a kind soul
Why on earth was this extremely important trial not fully televised!🤷♀️ the rising dv across the world is requiring as much spotlight on it and the consequence as it can be given
Agree. I wrote to both courttv and law and crime. It is a disgrace case was not fully live streamed. Men calling the shots downplayed how critical this domestic violence case is. My guess too many men running the networks are abusers and voted fully live streaming. Disgusting.
@@Ms.truecrimebuff not all of it. I cannot find the part where the defendant and the plaintiffs present their case, thus we get presented with a one sided case - this is why I refuse to defend either sides. I knew something was off - her being already married in Okinawa, I read he was in the Philippines air force. She was in Japan on a tourist visa as her dad worked there as a contractor. She also supplemented her income as a waitress when Ali was there. She came to the US on a green card. The drug taking in San Diego, I assume it came from her and her friends. Was there any of it in VA? I also assume Ray is a low level drug dealer. I read he does not have a house of his own nor has a job he currently is in. I don’t buy the fact Ana and Ray are friends, there is a photograph of the two together, it looked as they are dating. It may looked as if Ana did this and the sax to provoke Ali. Look at how she dresses to in the photos, everything showing off her cleavage like she is going to a red light district. Why Ali is doing nothing about that? If Ali is a Muslim as claimed by some, why is she allowed to dress like that? Is his self-esteem this low?
Ana was stupid af to bring man up to her apt knowing enraged violent husband had just trashed the place four hours earlier.This isn’t trashing her. This is warning others not to be dumb like her.
I am agree with you. He is a killer, but she’s a player. She loved to play with men’s sorry that’s what she gets she should take marriage time serious not a joke just to come to America, they using American kids as a ladder to get whatever they want again don’t take me wrong. He’s a killer, but she’s a. She’s a player.
This guy is so arrogant that he thinks he can get away with shooting two people in the head - because the female made it fully clear that she didn’t want to be with him anymore. That it’s ok he literally executed them. No, dude. No.
This trial will go down in history as the example of how and why you should not take the stand. Such a great example of what to avoid in a partner. Justice for Ana and Ray.
The 1st lady is a good friend but I have to acknowledge that it’s extremely dangerous to help a DV victim. I’ve heard of stories where the friends and/or family members are taken out by the abusers. It might seem mean but it’s best to direct them to the Police and a DV shelter. FYI for anyone in a similar situation.
from the picture that was shown their bodies were together.. sooooo.. it could have been if they were scared . but i think he went in.. gun drawn and saw them together... we will never know.. this deranged guy chases his tail when he talks.
This is just making me so sad for all victims of domestic violence. Such a terribly upsetting state of being, to be around an abuser, and dealing with this horrible existence.😪😪😪 Poor Ana, and poor all people who suffer at the hands of miserable partners.
It’s a true nightmare that you cannot wake up from. The amount of psychological and emotional damage the abuser causes makes one lose themselves. It’s so difficult to explain. This case is a good example of how sickening the cycle is.
Ana underestimated how dangerous and violent Ali is. When she came home and saw the apartment they used to share trashed, with the pumpkin he had thrown still visible in the crime photos, she knew he had a key. Yet, she still invited Ray over, the one man Ali hated, knowing he could burst through the door at any moment. Influenced by her friends, Ana seemed to provoke Ali, possibly because she wanted revenge for the pain he had inflicted on her. With Ray there to protect her, I can't help but wonder if she was setting the scene for an ultimate confrontation with Ali, not realizing she was playing with a homicidal monster.
@@Roobz2000because Ray was everything Ali wasn‘t.Kind, empathetic & could get along with people.Narcissists hate those that are comfortable in their own skin.
i absolutely agree she did not seem to understand the danger she was in. When she saw the apartment trashed, the first thing she should've done was call 911, change locks. Can't blame her for inviting Ray, I think she wanted some sense of safety with him there rather than setting up any kind of confrontation. Um this woman was TIRED of his sh*t. She did not want nor need to be the subject of Ali's rage once more. Regardless he was going to unalive her one day or another. Ana was never going to get out of it alive and Ali made sure of that. The most dangerous time in a DV relationship is when you are leving. Or did you not also hear of the Florida killer who took a plane from miami to serbia, then drove from serbia to spain to unalive the ex. so not even if you move continents are you safe.
they get it, but they're willing to engage in victim-blaming and misogyny, in order to make their predatory groomer of a client look less loathsome. they know a lot of society is just as gross as Ali, i mean look at these comments
That's a stupid, shitty thing to do........to willing engage in sex and drugs and then cop out by saying she was vulnerable and later it felt "icky". Even if that's the case, you can't use that as the basis of condemning someone later and berating their character. Ali was shitty for alot of things and a narcissistic, abusive, selfish POS but Miss Sanchez is fking disgusting and needs to stfu and blame herself for what happened.
Lif e in prison without parole. It was premeditated, even if he only premeditated the murders on the drive over. He's a dangerous man. The prosecutor did a great job! I think the defense attorney did a good job considering she had very little to work with. However, she should have never let him take the stand!
Every woman needs to read more books on domestic violence and stalkers etc. Never mess with them. Flee quietly and safely. Find shelter. You can't mess with them. Don't even think of a boyfriend unless you want to be murdered.
Both of them wrong a lot of women from overseas they try to get married from American kids just to come to America not because she love her husband and this what happened they want to live in America dream
This is not a production of court tv. Cameras are not allowed in California courts. This is the court’s feed that is then released to court tv by the judge. This is not a movie.
Now I understand what he had over her head. Her citizenship. My god what a horrible monster. Couldn’t treat her well could he. She was to listen to him not talk back. Bow to him and not have any opinion’s. poor little girl. Wonder where she is now staying. Back in the mother land of her mom .
@@casadelmaghreb but we r all assuming because he said she was cheating. She told her best friends she was just friends. Until I heard from her own mouth she was cheating I wouldn’t believe a thing he said. He had trashed her place maybe he was there because he was worried about him coming back and hurting her which he did. My ex thought I was also cheating and I had one good friend male who spent many a night in the spare room because I was so scared of my ex. Until he was caught and put in jail over something not to do with me did I feel safe. And quess what my friend married someone else and I remarried someone else. We r still very good friends to this day. It happens. But if she was cheating he did too. So WTF. She still didn’t deserve to die nor ray. I think he is demented and crazy
@@SharonBrown-yn6fz Well why was Anna too scared to tell her friend (Rays Ex) that they were even speaking if it was all innocent. Obviously there was more to the story than they are letting on here. Either way it doesnt matter if she was cheating or not 2 have died and a little girl lost both her parents. But Anna could have prevented all this by leaving, i would have ran to his fathers so he could have followed and the father could have slapped some sense into him.
@@SharonBrown-yn6fz 1. Wasn't "her" place. It was still LEGALLY Ali and her daughters HOME. 2. Ray Had no right to be there. 3. There is professional help for DV victoms and legal procedures one must talke. 4.Ana shoud have ,sobered up, and relocated for the sake of he rdaughter. But we know she said "she didn't want her kid, and didnt care i she ended up in foster care" 5. If one must cheat before divorcing or while 'seperated dont bring a man to your childs home and at least go elsewhere. Or just stop hanging out with men and partying.. , failing to adult. I think, her bevaior was crazy and reckless..
I was just watching his Instagram & UA-cam channels as JinnKid where he did impressions and skits and the guy truly was a star in the making. Hes going to get what he deserves but it doesnt make it any less a tragedy. The real victim here ultimately is the daughter. Its hard to believe what happened and so many lessons to be learned.
He had the talent for imitation for sure, I agree, if he was smart about it he could have gone far. But he sabotaged himself when he live streamed his treatment of Ana. He would have lost any mainstream audience and forget about any sponsors. No company’s going to associate with DV. In the end, I don’t think he had the maturity or mental stability to be a success as an influencer. He’s one sick puppy..
He was indeed genuinely talented. The only "TikTok star" I actually paid any attention to. I found him long before the TikTok days on IG I think around 2017-2018. He seemed like he was on his way to legitimate stardom and Ana was featured in a lot of his videos. As were a number of other people who appeared to be his friends. Who knows if he kept it together most of the time and San Diego was just the boiling over point but from testimony it sounds like he always had issues. Just shows once again that social media isn't real life.
I can’t send messages in live chat. I just wanted everyone to know I’m going to have to leave and go to ER as I’ve gone deaf. Hopefully if I get cured I’ll be back in time to see them sack whoever messed everything up 😂
This relationship was as toxic as it gets this was never going to end well, he was a ticking time bomb, he would never accept she didn’t want him anymore, sadly Anna had no way out he would never allow his possession to be free of him if it wasn’t Ray it would have been another guy. He’s a very sick guy if he really cared about her he would have gotten professional help I think he like abusing Anna. I have no words. Life in prison no possibility of parole.
Ana had several options as a way out, and opportunities to Relocate, change her circumstances, better herself, file for TRO and file for divorce. WHO stopped her from getting 'professional' help? She could havee stopped partying or hey here's a htought not bring a man to Their home and go get 'professional' help /support for DV.
Ana was allowed to do whatever she wanted, as was Ali. So Ali could bring a women to the apartment and sleep with her but ana couldn't talk to a friend on the couch? She deserved to die for that? It's her fault that Ali didn't like her talking to anyone else? The moral of the story is don't try to be nice, just ghost and leave 💯 she was trying to be cordial with him but he couldn't take a hint. That's why I say to ghost. Because to men like this any attention is good attention. Ana and Ray did not deserve to die and they were not provoking him. He provoked himself 🤡
Ana did not talk him or show up uninvited anywhere. He was the one that kept pursuing her. She kept trying to get away from him, but her mistake was she kept giving in to him because he was promising her fairytales but then beating her a** so the cycle kept going intil she tried to break the cycle but he just couldn't let go.. on his own two feet he ran to that apartment and with his own two hands and eyes he killed those people. It's disgusting and there's no excuse
@casadelmaghr That's what we call victim blaming. So easy to play Monday morning quarterback. I'm sure everybody involved wished they would have done things differently. It's a cautionary tale.
we tend to forget how dv puts the lives of friends/family/colleagues/etc. in danger too. he would've done this to her regardless. dude refuses to be told 'no' smh
Ana didn’t deserve death Although she must have known that bringing Ray into their home, in Alis state of mind, mental instability and coked out of his mind…. It was Suicidal 😢
@thebighouseencaattendancer478 ... I've been with two Arabs and with one now (been 6 years). And yes, that's so true what you said! So far so good though that I've not experienced the cheating part and pray I never do. They're way worse than Latin and Italian men by far at least from my past experience.
@EmeraldJade66 why would anyone choose to be with a Muslim, shari law will come into ur relationship and he will ask for back passage sex soon. I have studied them for forty years and run as fast as u can.
Right! He seems like a nice guy. Was really trying to be there for both of them. Other people wouldn’t have been nearly as helpful. I mean he even left his door open so she felt safer! He gave Ali benefit of the doubt and even tried to be a friend to him! Gets grilled by defense 😮
I think Ana returned to the apartment with Amira by design. Ali wanted her back there, away from friends, where he would be able to stalk her and gain access.
Exactly what I was thinking. The friend she was staying with lived on a military base so he knew better than to show up there and mess with her. He knew if he let her move back into the apartment that he could have easier access to her.
@@casadelmaghrebgrow up. inviting ray, bob, joe, whoever does NOT mean you can 3xecute people. you are just like him. this is NOT how society works. with your logic, ana should've done him like that when he invited someone over and she'd be here.
@@casadelmaghreb Whether or not she brought Ray over he was always going to torment and abuse her. He was abusing her LONG before there was any Ray in the picture. There was zero proof of her actually cheating on him otherwise he would have been sure to mention it, he however bragged about cheating on her. He was going to keep making her life hell one way or another. There was no peaceful exit from this situation, he would have stalked her no matter where she went even if there was a TRO in place. She was a POSSESSION to him that he refused to part with.
This idiot didn’t think about his daughter for 1 second all is about me, me and me. With a whole life ahead of him and threw it all away. The entitlement and arrogance is so creepy!
This man is such a psycho smh the girl from the apartment whom he slept with… even with her, his behavior was so stalker-ish. She’s lucky he didn’t kill her too. Can’t imagine how terrified Anna was during those last moments.
I really feel that the defense attorney was so sick in how she questioned that girl. I know it's her job to defend her client, but she could at least have been courteous & a decent human to her.
@@yeetnama9094 she had a lapse in judgement when she was 19 years old. Please tell me how that gives people the right to make her feel small & treat her so poorly.
Inviting Ray over after Ali had just thrown a fit/trashed the apartment while he still has a key was a horrible idea. She knew he had a gun I just don’t understand.
What are you saying then? That she knew or should have known that he would murder her and her friend? Simply become he owned a hand gun? As ex military.. You might want to look into the details of this case a little more
@@tyola23 First off Ray was NOT just a friend. He was a romantic interest and had been for awhile. Ali was sick enough to punch his wife repeatedly in the face, Anyone who is capable of that kind of abuse is surely capable of murder. He showed that gun off to everyone friends, fans, neighbors, as well as his own DAUGHTER. Maybe you need to research the case a bit more if you think he didn’t show signs prior.
Testimony of building manager really bugged me . She said the next day Hannah called for access to dumpster as her husband dumped her expensive belongings in the trash shut an$ when she realized that she can’t retrieve them asked if she can remove her husband from the lease . Lady manger says to come to office to be assisted and in brief tell her that both needed to sign in order one to be removed from the lease or she has to break her lease . But at no point this lady who feels sympathy for Hannah about her husband disposing never tell or suggest to Hannah that she could reprogram her apt fob card . Hannah told this lady that her husband has moved out and handed the fob key to her . If the management would had changed the fob key they would had saved the lives of two victims that fatal morning
Right. If you watch his testimony later in the trial, he played the victim and said nobody liked him in the military and none of their friend group wanted him around. He got uninvited to a birthday party and wasn't invited at all to a wedding, because nobody wanted him there. He seems so clueless as to why he was disliked. SMH
Why didn't ali get charged with coke in his jeep or driving under the influence. Or carrying a concealed weapon without a permit. Also in dangering a minor will under the influence of drugs. The cops should of pilled on the charges. His brothers also is in prison for shoting at cars now too
@childofthemosthighyah8145 he went to a gun range that he been a regular at. Did a run out with a gun. Then, he was shooting at cars driving past him. Sammy wasn't mentally well at the time and wanted to die by cop most likely. But he looks like Ali same nose,eye, and a big fella, too. Goggle it
There's definitelly something wrong with the audio - when I put my headsets on yesterday, it was like I was hearing the prosecution speak in one ear and then Ali in the other ear, so irritating!
#CourtTV - What do YOU think?
She drove him to do this, but he should had controlled himself. Anyone can black out in a case like this so tragic!!!
He’s toast!
What do I think about what exactly?
Guilty of 1st degree murder
We think we can't hear anything
This whole trial should be a PSA on how tragically domestic violence can end.
And what not to do like Anna in this case.
And what not to do like Anna in this case.
You can’t blame yourself for other people action babe, I hope you get out of your situation real soon!
Ali is so conspicuous, he is a very dangerous personality in a relationship. Unfortunately, young women often don’t have the experience it takes to recognize the personality. They often think that they can fix the relationship by cooperating. Victims are typically sympathetic personalities, they forgive again and again. If they get out alive, they are most likely traumatized by a person like Ali.
@@ManuelaCircowhen you’re married to a narcissist, it’s ten times worse trying to get a divorce for a start. They are like leeches, they control and manipulate, you’re the one who seems crazy. But, hey, you have to have lived with one to know. I don’t expect people to know what a snake Ali is. 😔🙏🏽
He’s ego and huge arrogance is still the same!! This 3 years in prison hasn’t change this guy at all!!!😡😡😡😡
Still arrogant. Just not violently insane
No drugs.@@andrewgonzalez6208
I hope someone makes him their bi#$h in jail.
@@andrewgonzalez6208he was violent then, not insane. And it’s very apparent that his capacity for violence is still alive and active.
He has money and fame probably lives like a king in prison. Why would prison change him lol? Hes got the life has everything.
Her friend who testified first seems like such a genuine soul and friend to Anna. May she find peace during this time.
He said Claire was here safe haven
they use to do coke at the bars every weekend
@@Daygosd619did you see them? Bc Claire clarified (no pun intended 🤭) that she did NOT use cocaine. IJS
I believe her.
Not to shame her but IMO, the husband deserves his sentences. Why did she encourage Ali to move to San Diego? It look like she was trapped in a dull life in VA and if he was abusive there, she could’ve not let him come. Where did the drug abuse come from. I doubt he abused drugs in front of his family. I guess it came from her friends. Sounds like a toxic and immature pair who don’t deserve their child.
He killed 2 innocent victims because she left him and he got jealous, I hope he gets life.. he did nothing but blame everyone and everything for what he did never took responsibility
@@yagovmolotov5127 really that’s your take away from this.
@@yagovmolotov5127looks like the incel boys are checking in! 🤦🏼♂️😆
Ali is a conspicuous narcissistic misogynist. The most dangerous time in an abusive relationship is in the leaving. Often victims listen to the voices around them, saying to just leave, don’t let him push you around. They underestimate the potential for violence. The victims risk their lives for their freedom.
get a g_n. Most people never have any courage to fight or defend themselves. That’s why these types are always so abusive because people enable them.
The reason why he brought a gun was because he was afraid to fight ray. So he ambushed him.
This comment is so satisfying after his sentencing 👏
My heart pours for this little girl due to the trauma she endured because of her father's actions. My thoughts and prayers are with Ana and Ray's loved ones.
mine as well...poor little Amira....she lost her mother at such a young age
@@robinsmith3987 She lost both parents. One from murder, and two, the dad is incarcerated. He is going to spend the rest of his life behind bars.
@@brianwhite284Crazy how he didn’t think about his daughter but of course after he did what he did he thought about his daughter.
It's beyond sad. Losing both your parents simultaneously and finding out your own dad killed your own mom. The daughter should of been given to Ana's family not Ali Babba
@@ChrisCornell420 Ali babba?
The amount of people in the comments who have absolutely no idea about dv and what its like to be in a dv relationship is astounding. Unless you have been in a relationship with a controlling, violent narcissist and have been a victim of dv you have no idea what you're talking about! "Why didnt she do this" "why did she do that" "it takes 2 to tango" "why did she provoke him" 🙄. With men like this making their food too hot or too cold, forgetting an innocent task and any insignificant thing can set these men off they will always find an excuse. So please unless you have been in a dv relationship you can not possibly understand the coercive control and manipulation and fear so please stop blaming the victim! 💜💜
Two words: reactive abuse. Study it.
@@robertsolorzano4207 Again it’ll never be justifiable.
So true. It’s actually hard to comprehend that someone could be such a monster until you’ve dealt with one personally.
Victims are always living by their abusers rules, it is self preservation. Not only can you not control the outcome by your movements they will abuse you for outside events. There is no rationale to why they abuse, it has nothing to do with the victim.
@@amills9261 literally. To an abuser nothing you do will ever be enough or okay for them. Idk how people are siding with that devil Ali. He’s getting his in prison now though thank the lord.
He finally gets to be in a real movie
Are you counting prison as a movie?
I think the court tv drama unfolding is what they mean.
Bubba has a good role for him hell be a prison princess
@@Bigbubba3031yeah with that long hair!
Any chance they make a sequel? Maybe a redemption arc ? Lol
Is Ana on trial or her MURDERER because this victim blame game from the defense is nothing short of nauseating.😣
She insinuated most of it
@@Kaykayu98 were you there??? How dare you? She's not alive to give her side of the story because he killed her. He also was on the stand for 3 days and admitted to the several times he beat her up. He's dangerous. I don't care how mad you are male or female- you don't shoot that person or batter them!!!!
@@lucindalynnxoexactly & there is spot deep down in hell for anybody justifying his actions. Any of these people playing the victim blaming game would want support if this was their situation.
@@lucindalynnxo he should’ve got a heat of passion trial, it’s literally the definition… she didn’t deserve to die and he didn’t deserve to see her being a hoe with their friend
@@lucindalynnxoshe was cheating?? Thats pretty obvious. Karma is a beautiful thing.
i can’t imagine how it would feel to try to save your friend so many times and still lose her in the end. and she’s still here trying to save her.
@@Jacqueline888 this made me cry
Justice for Ana and Ray ❤ also sending good healing vibes to their daughter who essentially lost both of her parents in this tragic, senseless act of violence.
He'll be in prison until his next parole officer is born and gets hired by the judicial system.
Nice original comment 🙄
The victim blaming is off the charts.
Not blaming her. Just saying she was stupid af for bringing a dude up to her apartment hours after her enraged violently jealous husband had trashed it.
@cancandoit no it isn’t it’s telling people not to act retarded.
@@markusrose9667nice gaslighting and victim blaming there Marko…🤦🏼♂️
@@edf9682 nice use of trendy words ed.
@@markusrose9667 you can just say you don't understand the word, it's ok
Wow shows what kind of women Ana was, befriended a girl that had sexual acts with her husband and had no ill will towards her, she seemed like a kind soul
Which woman.? Sanchez? I missed that bit
@@sheilakammoun1673 yes
That wasn’t the reason she befriended her…
Oh you mean she was a cokehead 😂
That's not what OP is saying
Why on earth was this extremely important trial not fully televised!🤷♀️ the rising dv across the world is requiring as much spotlight on it and the consequence as it can be given
Agree. I wrote to both courttv and law and crime. It is a disgrace case was not fully live streamed. Men calling the shots downplayed how critical this domestic violence case is. My guess too many men running the networks are abusers and voted fully live streaming. Disgusting.
@@Ms.truecrimebuff not all of it. I cannot find the part where the defendant and the plaintiffs present their case, thus we get presented with a one sided case - this is why I refuse to defend either sides.
I knew something was off - her being already married in Okinawa, I read he was in the Philippines air force. She was in Japan on a tourist visa as her dad worked there as a contractor. She also supplemented her income as a waitress when Ali was there. She came to the US on a green card. The drug taking in San Diego, I assume it came from her and her friends. Was there any of it in VA? I also assume Ray is a low level drug dealer. I read he does not have a house of his own nor has a job he currently is in. I don’t buy the fact Ana and Ray are friends, there is a photograph of the two together, it looked as they are dating. It may looked as if Ana did this and the sax to provoke Ali. Look at how she dresses to in the photos, everything showing off her cleavage like she is going to a red light district. Why Ali is doing nothing about that? If Ali is a Muslim as claimed by some, why is she allowed to dress like that? Is his self-esteem this low?
Trying to blame the victim is just sick
Ana was stupid af to bring man up to her apt knowing enraged violent husband had just trashed the place four hours earlier.This isn’t trashing her. This is warning others not to be dumb like her.
He was born to kill. It just took him 3 decades. The tik tok gig was just a Hobby
I don't understand why such an important case in terms of the rising levels of DV in the country was not televised in it's entirety by Court TV.
DIDNT find DV IMPORTANT !!
I think it was race of the victims and perpetrator
Perhaps costs?
This is California...San Diego, no TV allowed live in California Court's. But afterwards Court TV picks it up. And here we all are.
@@rosered103did you forget OJ Simpson case⁉️
100000% put this man jailed for two lives
I am agree with you. He is a killer, but she’s a player. She loved to play with men’s sorry that’s what she gets she should take marriage time serious not a joke just to come to America, they using American kids as a ladder to get whatever they want again don’t take me wrong. He’s a killer, but she’s a. She’s a player.
This guy is so arrogant that he thinks he can get away with shooting two people in the head - because the female made it fully clear that she didn’t want to be with him anymore. That it’s ok he literally executed them. No, dude. No.
51:47 Camera zoomed in 😂😂
This trial will go down in history as the example of how and why you should not take the stand. Such a great example of what to avoid in a partner. Justice for Ana and Ray.
Exactly
The dirrrttty DA got owned along with the adulterer
If he is a true narcissist she didn't initially see this side of him. They love bomb in the beginning.
See the Mica Miller case.. that scumbag of a “pastor” is even more devious and manipulative that this scumbag here.
Ali’s enormous ego insisted that he betray his lawyers and speak anyway. He’s a true narcissist. 😢
Judge cleaning his desk, he's clearly not interested in the first young ladies' testimony,very disrespectful
What a nightmare he was to live with.
Horrible….he is a reckless, dangerous, maniac. Would be miserable to be around him. 😪
She was worse, clubbing, drugs, sleeping around, mind games etc... She's the one that introduced him to cocaine too
Both were toxic.
@@Kaykayu98oh, were you living with them?
@@Kaykayu98You need help
The cousin lost me ! Your cousin present , “ no I don’t see him .” 😮😮
The 1st lady is a good friend but I have to acknowledge that it’s extremely dangerous to help a DV victim. I’ve heard of stories where the friends and/or family members are taken out by the abusers. It might seem mean but it’s best to direct them to the Police and a DV shelter. FYI for anyone in a similar situation.
You're correct, gotta help from a distance sadly
Police and DV shelters… useless.
I think Ray was there to protect Ana from that fly off the handle monster after he trashed the apartment and his history of violence.
from the picture that was shown their bodies were together.. sooooo.. it could have been if they were scared . but i think he went in.. gun drawn and saw them together... we will never know.. this deranged guy chases his tail when he talks.
They showed that?
Ray was there to smash
@hooaah5561 was she cheating on him before he cheated on her?
@hooaah5561 is there anything else worth note? I didn't really watch
This is just making me so sad for all victims of domestic violence. Such a terribly upsetting state of being, to be around an abuser, and dealing with this horrible existence.😪😪😪 Poor Ana, and poor all people who suffer at the hands of miserable partners.
It’s a true nightmare that you cannot wake up from. The amount of psychological and emotional damage the abuser causes makes one lose themselves. It’s so difficult to explain. This case is a good example of how sickening the cycle is.
Ana underestimated how dangerous and violent Ali is. When she came home and saw the apartment they used to share trashed, with the pumpkin he had thrown still visible in the crime photos, she knew he had a key. Yet, she still invited Ray over, the one man Ali hated, knowing he could burst through the door at any moment. Influenced by her friends, Ana seemed to provoke Ali, possibly because she wanted revenge for the pain he had inflicted on her. With Ray there to protect her, I can't help but wonder if she was setting the scene for an ultimate confrontation with Ali, not realizing she was playing with a homicidal monster.
Why did he hate Ray so much?
@@Roobz2000because Ray was everything Ali wasn‘t.Kind, empathetic & could get along with people.Narcissists hate those that are comfortable in their own skin.
@@stardustboy94 That makes a lot of sense 🤔.
Thank you!
Good synopsis of the crime scene!
i absolutely agree she did not seem to understand the danger she was in. When she saw the apartment trashed, the first thing she should've done was call 911, change locks. Can't blame her for inviting Ray, I think she wanted some sense of safety with him there rather than setting up any kind of confrontation. Um this woman was TIRED of his sh*t. She did not want nor need to be the subject of Ali's rage once more. Regardless he was going to unalive her one day or another. Ana was never going to get out of it alive and Ali made sure of that. The most dangerous time in a DV relationship is when you are leving. Or did you not also hear of the Florida killer who took a plane from miami to serbia, then drove from serbia to spain to unalive the ex. so not even if you move continents are you safe.
Bro really put a listening device on his daughter’s tablet with ears like that smh. 🤦🏼♂️
😂
The defense doesn't understand that once you go home and process things you can change how you feel, things can feel icky later.
They do understand, they're just doing their job defending ali
they get it, but they're willing to engage in victim-blaming and misogyny, in order to make their predatory groomer of a client look less loathsome. they know a lot of society is just as gross as Ali, i mean look at these comments
That's a stupid, shitty thing to do........to willing engage in sex and drugs and then cop out by saying she was vulnerable and later it felt "icky". Even if that's the case, you can't use that as the basis of condemning someone later and berating their character.
Ali was shitty for alot of things and a narcissistic, abusive, selfish POS but Miss Sanchez is fking disgusting and needs to stfu and blame herself for what happened.
@@adminRQ😒😒😒😒🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Oh no ! Can't hear the volume is almost 0 ....so disappointing
I Can't hear it either.
I put in both of my earbuds and turned up the volume. So maybe headphones 🎧 will help.
DFX Audio Enhancer.
it seems strange that the police precincts and the courts cannot figure out how to adequately record these events. It’s always so frustrating.
@@John-kv7jo Is That A Mobile App That Enhances The Sound Quality Within Other Apps? Orrrr? & Is It Available On All Devices?
Ali looks like and reminds me of Jafar from Aladdin 😆
And his name similar to “Prince Ali” “ Ali Abuabua “ lol
Hahaha
@@janettepacheco3817omg 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Wait until you guys know what his surname means in Arabic. It's hilarious!
It means the "father of yoghurt"
@@roubanashabe3490 hashhshshs
This is so sad. Classic patterns of abuse. Get away from these abusers please! They're very sick.
Lif e in prison without parole. It was premeditated, even if he only premeditated the murders on the drive over. He's a dangerous man. The prosecutor did a great job! I think the defense attorney did a good job considering she had very little to work with. However, she should have never let him take the stand!
I don't understand your last comment. Clearly he should take the stand, so everyone can truly see how demented he is.
@@jazzyg530It always amazes me when people encourage deceit and subterfuge to beat Justice.....
It’s every defendants right to take the stand or not. A lawyer cannot force them either way
It was great that he took he stand. Why object to that? he hung himself even further. It was actually a great thing.
No but they mostly recommend against he obviously sunk his ship deeper
Every woman needs to read more books on domestic violence and stalkers etc. Never mess with them. Flee quietly and safely. Find shelter. You can't mess with them. Don't even think of a boyfriend unless you want to be murdered.
or VICE VERSA. with women abusers.
Life without parole. A demon Dark Triad Beast
Both of them wrong a lot of women from overseas they try to get married from American kids just to come to America not because she love her husband and this what happened they want to live in America dream
Fake news
She was not mentally stable either
@@TheDecider2024The only instability she had in her life was him
@@TheDecider2024There’s literally no evidence of that npd
Pre meditated for sure
No Sh1t 😂 it doesn't get anymore premeditated than this
1:43:01
Lawyer: Do you see Ali Abulaban in court today?
Witness: No
Lawyer: You don't see him in court today?
Witness: Oh! There he is.
what the ...??
😂😂😂😂
That ain't his cousin 😂
I looked up at the TV line wtf lol
I would be ashamed if either of my sons behaved like this *ss when it comes to the treatment of women.
Well, One is nominated by Republicans to be President of the United States😅😅😅
ali is finally a star on court TV for 1st degree murder
Dear court TV I’m glad I didn’t pay for a membership because I can’t even hear this 😢
This is not a production of court tv. Cameras are not allowed in California courts. This is the court’s feed that is then released to court tv by the judge. This is not a movie.
@@maryammosavi269 Mary, I have been watching this trial all along. This stream was ridiculous.
You think the 2 people got murder is ridiculous! What is wrong with you! This is not a show. This is real life!
He should have gotten a haircut…..
He actually had short hair when he murdered them so I think he wanted a different look… another of his many failures in life.
Jail for life 😮
No parole.
Now I understand what he had over her head. Her citizenship. My god what a horrible monster. Couldn’t treat her well could he. She was to listen to him not talk back. Bow to him and not have any opinion’s. poor little girl. Wonder where she is now staying. Back in the mother land of her mom .
@@casadelmaghrebYou understand you’re only repeating this monster’s paranoid delusions, right? There’s no proof of ANY of that.🤦🏻♀️
@@casadelmaghreb but we r all assuming because he said she was cheating. She told her best friends she was just friends. Until I heard from her own mouth she was cheating I wouldn’t believe a thing he said. He had trashed her place maybe he was there because he was worried about him coming back and hurting her which he did. My ex thought I was also cheating and I had one good friend male who spent many a night in the spare room because I was so scared of my ex. Until he was caught and put in jail over something not to do with me did I feel safe. And quess what my friend married someone else and I remarried someone else. We r still very good friends to this day. It happens. But if she was cheating he did too. So WTF. She still didn’t deserve to die nor ray. I think he is demented and crazy
@@SharonBrown-yn6fz Well why was Anna too scared to tell her friend (Rays Ex) that they were even speaking if it was all innocent. Obviously there was more to the story than they are letting on here. Either way it doesnt matter if she was cheating or not 2 have died and a little girl lost both her parents. But Anna could have prevented all this by leaving, i would have ran to his fathers so he could have followed and the father could have slapped some sense into him.
@@SharonBrown-yn6fz 1. Wasn't "her" place. It was still LEGALLY Ali and her daughters HOME. 2. Ray Had no right to be there. 3. There is professional help for DV victoms and legal procedures one must talke. 4.Ana shoud have ,sobered up, and relocated for the sake of he rdaughter. But we know she said "she didn't want her kid, and didnt care i she ended up in foster care" 5. If one must cheat before divorcing or while 'seperated dont bring a man to your childs home and at least go elsewhere. Or just stop hanging out with men and partying.. , failing to adult. I think, her bevaior was crazy and reckless..
@@casadelmaghreb imagine sinking to the level of being a "murderer groupie." Seek help. You're embarrassing yourself.
I imagine a big majority of influencers are probably clinical narcissists.
Social media “feeds” narcissists ! Everyone should educated themselves on how to see the red flags 🚩
He was so manipulative. Just Wow! Trying to look like a sicilian mobster doesn't help his cause at all.
The character in the move Scarface, was NOT Sicilian!! He was a scumbag Cuban, who escaped Cuba. K?
I have my earphones in but I still can't hear
Maybe it’s wax i cleaned my ears before and took out a lot of wax and then I was able to hear perfectly
@@Amt3983 oh good for you I'm happy that worked for you
Do not stick anything in your ears. It is dangerous to stick anything in your ear. Permanent hearing damage. Seek a doctor? ?
@@daophan3709 no
This trials going backwards, yesterday I watched closing arguments, today, its witness testimony? shouldnt it be verdict watch?
I was just watching his Instagram & UA-cam channels as JinnKid where he did impressions and skits and the guy truly was a star in the making. Hes going to get what he deserves but it doesnt make it any less a tragedy. The real victim here ultimately is the daughter. Its hard to believe what happened and so many lessons to be learned.
He had the talent for imitation for sure, I agree, if he was smart about it he could have gone far. But he sabotaged himself when he live streamed his treatment of Ana. He would have lost any mainstream audience and forget about any sponsors. No company’s going to associate with DV. In the end, I don’t think he had the maturity or mental stability to be a success as an influencer. He’s one sick puppy..
He was indeed genuinely talented. The only "TikTok star" I actually paid any attention to. I found him long before the TikTok days on IG I think around 2017-2018. He seemed like he was on his way to legitimate stardom and Ana was featured in a lot of his videos. As were a number of other people who appeared to be his friends. Who knows if he kept it together most of the time and San Diego was just the boiling over point but from testimony it sounds like he always had issues. Just shows once again that social media isn't real life.
He has extreme anti social disorder. So he wouldn’t have gotten far. He discusses how bad he is with all people during the trial.
He couldn't do anything but Al Pacino impressions. A "star in the making?" lol Even professional impersonators can do more than one impression. 🤣
He f-in sucked. His acting was horrendous.
Its either he is Jafar from Aladdin or Lord Faquaad /Shrek 😅😂
I can’t send messages in live chat. I just wanted everyone to know I’m going to have to leave and go to ER as I’ve gone deaf. Hopefully if I get cured I’ll be back in time to see them sack whoever messed everything up 😂
He grew his hair long to make it easier for his cellmates
lol😂
why does cameraman think this is an arthouse piece
"You didn't tell Anna about him having sex with you ... FOR 3 MINUTES" 😂😂😂
One of the worse camera guys I have ever seen
This relationship was as toxic as it gets this was never going to end well, he was a ticking time bomb, he would never accept she didn’t want him anymore, sadly Anna had no way out he would never allow his possession to be free of him if it wasn’t Ray it would have been another guy. He’s a very sick guy if he really cared about her he would have gotten professional help I think he like abusing Anna. I have no words. Life in prison no possibility of parole.
Ana had several options as a way out, and opportunities to Relocate, change her circumstances, better herself, file for TRO and file for divorce. WHO stopped her from getting 'professional' help? She could havee stopped partying or hey here's a htought not bring a man to Their home and go get 'professional' help /support for DV.
Ana was allowed to do whatever she wanted, as was Ali. So Ali could bring a women to the apartment and sleep with her but ana couldn't talk to a friend on the couch? She deserved to die for that? It's her fault that Ali didn't like her talking to anyone else? The moral of the story is don't try to be nice, just ghost and leave 💯 she was trying to be cordial with him but he couldn't take a hint. That's why I say to ghost. Because to men like this any attention is good attention. Ana and Ray did not deserve to die and they were not provoking him. He provoked himself 🤡
Ana did not talk him or show up uninvited anywhere. He was the one that kept pursuing her. She kept trying to get away from him, but her mistake was she kept giving in to him because he was promising her fairytales but then beating her a** so the cycle kept going intil she tried to break the cycle but he just couldn't let go.. on his own two feet he ran to that apartment and with his own two hands and eyes he killed those people. It's disgusting and there's no excuse
@casadelmaghr That's what we call victim blaming. So easy to play Monday morning quarterback. I'm sure everybody involved wished they would have done things differently. It's a cautionary tale.
@@casadelmaghreb I call it a cautionary tale.
Can't hear anything
No ones winning any Oscar’s for cinematography here
Oh him adjusting his clothes and hair, then looking directly at the camera. Wow.
sound so low we cannot hear very well
Try headphone 🎧
we tend to forget how dv puts the lives of friends/family/colleagues/etc. in danger too. he would've done this to her regardless. dude refuses to be told 'no' smh
Mics are off or something, can barely hear it
Ana didn’t deserve death
Although she must have known that bringing Ray into their home, in Alis state of mind, mental instability and coked out of his mind…. It was Suicidal 😢
I'm sure if she thought she was going to be shot to death she would have done anything else.
I don’t think his defense is going to work for him in the US. It might work in the Mideast but not here
His attorney is such a B, she has so much damn attitude.
So she got with an Arab and acts surprised that he's jealous, possessive, controlling, abusive, and a cheater? OKAY! 😂😂
He was her gate to the USA
Exactly
@thebighouseencaattendancer478 ... I've been with two Arabs and with one now (been 6 years). And yes, that's so true what you said! So far so good though that I've not experienced the cheating part and pray I never do. They're way worse than Latin and Italian men by far at least from my past experience.
@EmeraldJade66 why would anyone choose to be with a Muslim, shari law will come into ur relationship and he will ask for back passage sex soon. I have studied them for forty years and run as fast as u can.
cant hear the witness or the lawyer very well :(
Volumen is to low
I feel bad for their daughter. 😢
Me too. Don't understand why anyone thinks it's acceptable to take another person's life when they want to exit a bad relationship or marriage.
Been waiting for this to be released
The neighbor. ☹️ He just got dragged into it. I hope his wife hugged him extra tight after that testimony.
Right! He seems like a nice guy. Was really trying to be there for both of them. Other people wouldn’t have been nearly as helpful. I mean he even left his door open so she felt safer! He gave Ali benefit of the doubt and even tried to be a friend to him! Gets grilled by defense 😮
Turn the volume up please
Low volume
I think Ana returned to the apartment with Amira by design. Ali wanted her back there, away from friends, where he would be able to stalk her and gain access.
Exactly what I was thinking. The friend she was staying with lived on a military base so he knew better than to show up there and mess with her. He knew if he let her move back into the apartment that he could have easier access to her.
@@jordienav5603 What you said would have stuck had she not boldy and insanley briought Ray into Ali and her daughters home...
@@jordienav5603yup, I agree. It was a way for him to maintain access to her smh he’s a sick twisted man
@@casadelmaghrebgrow up. inviting ray, bob, joe, whoever does NOT mean you can 3xecute people. you are just like him. this is NOT how society works. with your logic, ana should've done him like that when he invited someone over and she'd be here.
@@casadelmaghreb Whether or not she brought Ray over he was always going to torment and abuse her. He was abusing her LONG before there was any Ray in the picture. There was zero proof of her actually cheating on him otherwise he would have been sure to mention it, he however bragged about cheating on her. He was going to keep making her life hell one way or another. There was no peaceful exit from this situation, he would have stalked her no matter where she went even if there was a TRO in place. She was a POSSESSION to him that he refused to part with.
Can’t hear
He is angry because he think he didn’t do anything wrong..
he think he is the victim…
This idiot didn’t think about his daughter for 1 second all is about me, me and me. With a whole life ahead of him and threw it all away. The entitlement and arrogance is so creepy!
Can’t hear it well 😢
Wow, the neighbors testimony..
This is the perfect example of how drugs destroys lives and leads to mentall illness as well poor girl and guy who lost there lives
Ali eyes scared me 🤯
Thx for the upload! 😊
This man is such a psycho smh the girl from the apartment whom he slept with… even with her, his behavior was so stalker-ish. She’s lucky he didn’t kill her too. Can’t imagine how terrified Anna was during those last moments.
I doubt it she wasn’t anything to him, he didn’t care about that short fling what so ever only about Ana finding out.
I really feel that the defense attorney was so sick in how she questioned that girl. I know it's her job to defend her client, but she could at least have been courteous & a decent human to her.
@@-.-hyuga-.-882why? She wasn't decent or courteous to herself
@@yeetnama9094 she had a lapse in judgement when she was 19 years old. Please tell me how that gives people the right to make her feel small & treat her so poorly.
He looks like he got major ADD so annoying to watch him
whole murderer and you decide to insult people with attention deficit disorder for some reason?
@@anmyarchive who are you to decide what people can or cannot say ? smh
@@nadiamarieusaso many other things about him annoying , his a d d is wild though
He tries to blame her and make excuses for his bad boy behavior please he is a very bad actor he is so narssacisstic he thought he still owed her
Inviting Ray over after Ali had just thrown a fit/trashed the apartment while he still has a key was a horrible idea. She knew he had a gun I just don’t understand.
He willing came as an adult be so fkn fr. You weird victim blaming folks are the real ones to watch out for🤔👀
@@tyola23 I’m not victim blaming I’m just stating this guy was already showing signs of being extremely unhinged.
@@tyola23 Nah you just don’t got the common sense
What are you saying then? That she knew or should have known that he would murder her and her friend? Simply become he owned a hand gun? As ex military.. You might want to look into the details of this case a little more
@@tyola23 First off Ray was NOT just a friend. He was a romantic interest and had been for awhile. Ali was sick enough to punch his wife repeatedly in the face, Anyone who is capable of that kind of abuse is surely capable of murder. He showed that gun off to everyone friends, fans, neighbors, as well as his own DAUGHTER. Maybe you need to research the case a bit more if you think he didn’t show signs prior.
No volume?
It odd that when his lawyer is asking him questions he speak calm and softly but sure shows his true colors when the prosecutor asks him questions.
Oh my God for the little girl mom she is dead and dad in jail my heart with a little girl this is very sad
She’s better off without her dad but incredibly sad that her mommy isn’t here to raise her
Testimony of building manager really bugged me . She said the next day Hannah called for access to dumpster as her husband dumped her expensive belongings in the trash shut an$ when she realized that she can’t retrieve them asked if she can remove her husband from the lease . Lady manger says to come to office to be assisted and in brief tell her that both needed to sign in order one to be removed from the lease or she has to break her lease . But at no point this lady who feels sympathy for Hannah about her husband disposing never tell or suggest to Hannah that she could reprogram her apt fob card . Hannah told this lady that her husband has moved out and handed the fob key to her . If the management would had changed the fob key they would had saved the lives of two victims that fatal morning
Her name is not Hannah
nobody liked ali, his creeper vibes show strongly
Right. If you watch his testimony later in the trial, he played the victim and said nobody liked him in the military and none of their friend group wanted him around. He got uninvited to a birthday party and wasn't invited at all to a wedding, because nobody wanted him there. He seems so clueless as to why he was disliked. SMH
Ali's lawyer was not doing herself or her client any favors by being so authoritarian & strict
His poor x- wife domestic violence big time she would of never escape him
No court today until the jury comes to a decision right?
No court today at all. It’s a holiday.
Its really low.. please turn up the volume
Why didn't ali get charged with coke in his jeep or driving under the influence. Or carrying a concealed weapon without a permit. Also in dangering a minor will under the influence of drugs. The cops should of pilled on the charges. His brothers also is in prison for shoting at cars now too
Shooting at cars? Why was he doing that?
@childofthemosthighyah8145 he went to a gun range that he been a regular at. Did a run out with a gun. Then, he was shooting at cars driving past him. Sammy wasn't mentally well at the time and wanted to die by cop most likely. But he looks like
Ali same nose,eye, and a big fella, too. Goggle it
@@kirenjattan9885 thanks I most definitely will. The entire family is crazy!
There's definitelly something wrong with the audio - when I put my headsets on yesterday, it was like I was hearing the prosecution speak in one ear and then Ali in the other ear, so irritating!
you have to wear ear plugs and turn the volume all the way up to hear this.
She went upstairs to get a sex toy to bring back to a strangers apartment??
Wow.
And now the world knows and on youtube forever.
How embarrassing.
😂😂😂
Can you give me a timestamp please
Gonna be more embarrassing that the last time he ever had a chance to have sex with a chick he fucked up and now he’s only gonna have dudes now
@@Roadtolbsbenchpress1:28 onwards.....
@@Roadtolbsbenchpress
👀 its wild.
Defense talks about 'dlid0' and 'vibrat0r' masage 🤣
That apartment room is going to be haunted 😱
You can hear it better if you play it w ur headphones