Google Nest Cam Battery VS Eufy SoloCam E40 - Which ONE is Better?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- Today, we are going to compare the newly released Nest Cam Battery and the also new Eufy SoloCam E40. We will see if the 3 year hiatus of Nest makes them still a contender on a highly competitive wireless battery power WIFI camera segment of home security. This video will focus on video and audio quality and the camera's performance as I run them in a battery of tests that this channel has been known for. I consider this new Nest Cam battery and together with also the new Nest battery doorbell - "Quirky" because it has some subtle features that makes me say "WHY?" Watch the video on its entirety to find out.
**There is actually a setting in the Google Home app in the "device information" where it says camera mount which is dafaulted to made for Google or Nest mount and when you click on it, it will give you an option for other mounts which will turn OFF the magnet camera off feature. The settings on the app is not really user friendly.**
Shop: (Paid Links)
Eufy SoloCam E40 - amzn.to/3ElsP2l
Nest Cam Battery - Check product page on lower left of the video
Nest Cam Battery Review - • Nest Cam Battery Revie...
Eufy SoloCam E40 Review - • Eufy SoloCam Pro E40 R...
Nest Battery Doorbell Review - • Nest Doorbell Battery ...
Eufy SoloCam S40 Review - • Eufy SoloCam S40 Revie...
00:00 - Introduction
01:27 - How these cameras record video?
01:59 - Recorded Footage Access | Subscription
02:40 - Video & Audio Quality Daytime
04:35 - Night Vision | Night Footage Comparison
05:46 - Side by Side Comparison
06:05 - Motion Alert Notification Speed
07:23 - Notification Cool OFF | Cool Down
07:56 - Maximum Detection Distance
09:43 - Towards the Camera Recording
10:31 - Audio Quality Comparison
11:04 - Google Home Demo (Nest & Eufy)
11:46 - Amazon Alexa Demo (Eufy)
12:02 - Power & Internet Outage Recording
12:42 - Nest Cam Battery Quirks or Issues?
#lifehackster #nestvseufy #nestcambatteryissues
Shop WiFi Security Cameras - www.amazon.com/shop/lifehackster
My Camera/Studio Gear - kit.co/lifehackster/video-cre...
Don't forget to sign up for Sale notifications @ lifehackster.com
- enter your email on the right upper corner - Join Notification List
Lifehackster is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com - Розваги
***There is actually a setting in the Google Home app in the "device information" where it says camera mount which is dafaulted to made for Google or Nest mount and when you click on it, it will give you an option for other mounts which will turn OFF the magnet camera off feature. The settings on the app is not really user friendly.***
I heard Google is killing the Nest app and forcing Google Home on users...
They upgraded their hardware, and downgraded their software. Genius stuff here.
I just got a Eufy pro 2k cam system because of your review. I definitely will be looking forward to more content and reviews from you. Your detailed showcasing of each systems strength and weaknesses is game changing 🕊👍🏿
Thank you.
Fantastic review! The Eufy has the edge on so many things. The cool down notification is incredibly important. What if a burglar goes from walking up to the house to breaking in the door. You would never know for 5 long minutes. The walking towards the camera on the Eufy was very impresssive. The camera caught you almost immediately. The video and audio are pretty close, but the notifications, alarm, and going towards the camera make all the difference. Thanks again for these comparison videos!
Thank you.
The walking towards detection is the reason I ordered one yesterday
Wow!, audio quality and video at daytime of Nest Cam is really good .
As usual, great and detailed video!
LifeHackster, what anti-theft device do you recommend to install with a Eufy SoloCam S40? I have seen chains for other cameras, but I have not been able to find something for my S40, yet.
Such a well made video. Very helpful, thank you.
In the settings you can disable it from switching off when removed from magnetic mount. No need to stick the magnet to the back.
Thanks for the info..I have to dig around in the settings again which is not really user friendly..you don’t know which items have options..on the device information you can select if you are using a google approved mount or not…why they have this option in the first place? I really see no reason of turning off the camera if you take it off the approved mount.
Enjoy all of your reviews! Do you use or recommend a WiFi/Router booster to keep your signal strong for enhance video quality?
Great work again on your videos.
You are welcome.
Hi, thank you for your wonderful review! I just wonder whether you could tell us about 24/7 support information of NEST. Is the subscription plan for all cameras or just for one camera? Thank you!
I bought two of the eufy solo cam e20 in November 2021 and set each up...one for the front of the house, one for the back. They each worked wonderfully until May, 2022. It was odd, but within a couple weeks of each other, both cameras died.
The cause of death? Not sure, but they each started refusing to connect or stay connected to the network. I tried everything and even walked through troubleshooting with Eufy. This happened to both cameras within a few weeks of each other and I immediately went through the steps of trying to fix each when it happened. That means I dealt with all of this twice.
Anyway, the end result for each situation was Eufy sending replacement cameras because I was still under the 1 year warranty.
So...May/June 2022, I have two new eufy cameras back up and operating great. I was happy with Eufy support. They're great and seemed to stand by their product. No hassle on the replacement process.
Now, we are in April 2023. Guess what happened? One of the cameras is doing exactly what happened to the original cameras....refusing to connect to the network. It's out of the blue, too. It was working fine and it was time to charge it so I put it on the charger and got the notification that charging was done. Suddenly it won't connect. It won't even beep if you try to go through the steps to uninstall the camera altogether and reinstall. I can't even factory reset it. I tried going through the steps with Eufy customer service to make sure I wasn't losing my mind. Sure enough I was doing it right. The camera has just decided it's not going to work anymore.
I asked Eufy if these cameras are intended to be disposable, and they assured me they are not, however I find the evidence to suggest otherwise. This is now three cameras which have died when they are less than a year old.
I am no longer under the 1 year warranty which only applies to the original purchase date. Eufy does not warranty the product to last a year. They promise to replace faulty products that die within a year of the original purchase. That's a big difference, and to be fair, that's industry standard as far as warranty practices go.
However, what the heck, Eufy? The evidence shows that your products are meant disposable cameras that are thrown away and replaced once you use for 6 months to a year. At least the Eufy solocam e20 is.
Let's see how much longer the back yard camera lasts. If I'm correct, it won't last more than a few more months.
Anyone have suggestions on a camera brand without a subscription they would recommend?
Awesome review. Thank you.
Worked well for a week!
I bought 3 eufy e40 solo cams.
At first all worked well with the pre configuration settings and I was amazed how good the camera’s were and how good the app was.
After using it for a week all 3 cameras one after the other went from good to garbage in performance.
All started having faults like not detecting or detecting but not sending any notifications or not detecting humans but parts of motions that was not relevant.
You could also setup zones which does not work at all!!!
I started to put the sensitivity higher and higher on each camera but this maybe worked for 10 min. and then gave up totally sending notifications.
All in all it’s a garbage cheap built camera if you ask me. I can say this since I had 3 of them and all had similar issues up-to not sending any notifications at all.
Didn’t want to bother longer and sent them all back.
Now I ordered the nest and have higher hopes that will hopefully perform better.
If you ask me pay a bit more and hope it will work properly otherwise you might end up missing the 14 days return limit and have deal with a support that never ends and never probably get solved.
This is indeed a problem for the Eufy IP camera's. It is caused by the algo software, wich is really bad.
I have Google nest with solar panel been working good, haven't seen my battery drop for a few months, max video quality and high sensitivity
Updates?
Quick question, if we're looking for a setup to stream live feed only to a phone to check on the animals, do you have a video or recommendation of a camera to just do live check ins throughout the day? Thank you in advance!
Hello
I give a video suggestion, when your showing the camera samples on the back yard
It would look nicer if you started in the back and work your way into the front that way you don’t need to walk backwards and down as you do when walking backwards and look even more professional
;)
I love your channel !
LifeHaster, what is a alternative to Nest cameras where I can get 4k resolution? I want a camera system where I can plug each camera into an outlet for power supply (so I don't have to route all camera wiring to the receiver box), and use WiFi for connecting to my router. Is the nest the only camera system with that setup?
You should be able to plug the Eufy wireless outdoor cameras into a USB wall charger, and have it charge on a set schedule... does it allow a normal charger and is it waterproof?
Still rocking the Arlo here but really liking the wyze v3 it’s amazing at night for the money
I just wanted to say that I liked the thumbnail!
@LifeHaster - have you done testing of the EUFY streaming to NAS (Synology)? I am new to the 2C Pro Cam and whilst it has vision of teh street area I want to record it is not activating with motion detection at the range needed. Using my NAS I want to stream to it 24/7 instead of Motion Detection. I have the camera connected to a solar panel.
Is this possible or something that EUFY could be approached to implement? NAS systems are common in homes and it would be extremely useful.
I was wondering if you can do a review or if you have done a review in kittyhok cameras? Or your opinion on them thank you!
I only get 2 weeks max battery life from Nest on the middle (default) record level. I think it's because there are wind blown palm trees in the camera's view. I tried deleting the default notifications and using a limited zone with not much difference in battery life.
Really interested in the video comparing the nest cam battery vs plugged in. Is this out yet? You’re reviews are unmatched! 1:47
I was wondering if you planned on doing a review on the nest with powered? To see notification speeds.
I’m planning on it. Thanks.
you should do a nest cam wired review as well and compare it to Eufy indoor 2k or wyze cam v3
I just purchased the nest camera battery what third party mount did you use for this camera?
Hello there, I’m considering Eufy cameras specifically because they give you the option of decent storage and generous amount of length event recordings. I want to integrate (indoor & outdoor cameras, doorbell, wifi door lock and maybe a flood light) and I’m debating in a smart thermostat from other brand since they still don’t have one. My question is… should I go with home based or the newer solo camera solutions they offer? Thanks so much for informing us with your videos.
Are you talking about the base station that can save all recordings? If so then yes, in my opinion it's a safer option, but to each their own. If you're looking for a thermostat just get the ecobee smart thermostat, or the ecobee 3 lite (nearly the same thing as the smart)
@@jerry4012 Thanks Jerry
What’s the best overall outdoor wifi battery camera Note I won’t be able to use the any solar panels. Also with no sub fees
I’m debating between the nest or the eufy outdoor pro, want a 24/7 outdoor camera, do you think they are comparable during night? I have a lamp post so no problem with lighting.
Also, something important, do you have any idea is google will allow the best to be used as a trigger so I can make a routine to turn on some lights on my house during night and alert me about persons? I almost sure Eufy outdoor pro should be able to do this through Alexa but would love if you can confirm it
Hey, did you find anything?
Youve never mentioned about the Eufy SoloCam L40... And im wondering what i should choose. Eufy SoloCam L40 or the google nest cam. What do you think?
I still have a unopened Google Nest IQ cam cause it's just so inferior compared to it's competition. Sad to see that still hasn't changed with the battery version. Thanks for the review.
You are welcome.
Can you do the Simplysafe outdoor cam?
I don't own the E40, but the 2C motion detection range is lower than the video field of view. I was able to sneak past the detection.
A better test would be to try detection closer to the edge of field of view on all sides (on the 2D video image, top, bottom, left and right) and at different distances.
The Eufy also has a delay of < 1 sec before it starts recording, and another 1/2 sec until compression artifacts disappear. If at night, another 1/4 sec for the infra-red light to turn on. So max delay is quite long. The suspicious person might have already passed the camera's view, or is too far to see clearly.
The solocam series has way better detection than the homebase dependent eufy cameras.
Another great video mate...a hv a question,you said that nest cam needs a 5mins cool off period between events or notifications?I mean ,it will record in this time period or... cheers mate
It will record the event. It is just the notifications.
@@LifeHackster one more thing mate...I don't know if I'll make myself clear (barrier language)...can I give to someone access to the camera but ONLY TO CAMERA ,and NOT HAVING CONTROL /ACCESS to the rest of the options in the Google home app/nest app.i'm asking you this cz I have a neighbor (I'm living into a flat) apartment) and he wants also access to this camera and if will add it to my app...he will see /have access to everything that is installed...I hope I made myself understood.All the best from Romania!
Eufy all day every day! 🥰
I'm looking for a security camera system that will operate via Wi-Fi but without the internet. Do you know of such a system?
Perhaps I missed something, but if the nest cam turns off when you remove it from the mount, how did you get video recording when you took the cams to the park? You didn’t mention that you brought the mount with you and it didn’t look like it was attached in the brief shot of it in the bag.
If you take a look again, you will see I snapped it on the back of the camera before putting it in the bag. This is actually the test when I found out that the camera turns off when it is off the magnetic mount. Also, there is a setting in the app that you can choose if the camera uses the nest mount and you can change it to a non-nest, generic mount..and this setting is in the camera info…which I thought you cannot change anything on that setting…the google home app is really not user friendly.
@@LifeHackster Thanks for replying. I just installed the E40 yesterday. This video sealed the deal for me. I wanted the Google one to be good but there were just too many cons to outweigh the pros. I really appreciate all the work you do and your channel is the first one I check when it comes to these type of products and the one that I trust the most. Thanks again!
The biggest problem with nest camera is you can't view it on a web browser only the ap or Google device. It doesn't work with nest ap only Google home ap. And I haven't been able to figure out how to save video clips.... Google says they are working on the ap and in future to be able to view on browser... ... I have it plugged in and it works better then when on battery.
To save clips, while watching the clip go to event details then click the download button which looks like a down arrow.
Can you please review the new simplisafe outdoor camera?
Will do.. just purchased it.
My question is: If you could use a POE connection, would there be any benefit to opting for the battery powered unit?
I know Wasserstein is selling a PoE adapter for this and I’ll be checking it out.
@@LifeHackster updates?
Excellent video as usual. I had such high hopes for google video door bell and camera, now thanks to your camparison, how can i ever settle for google's offering..smh. Looks like i'll be buying eufy all the way. LifeHackester, are you saying the google video doorbell has the same cool down issue?
Yes..I think all nest cameras have this issue.
@@LifeHackster if you, can you please show us the video doorbell cool down time. Honestly I haven't seen any other youtuber talking about or even showing this, you've got it down to a science. Thanks.
Thanks for another great video! Eufy rocks - own tons of their cameras
You are welcome.
One key aspect that you fail to mention about Eufy, they can easily be unplugged and reset and used on a different account, when the device is reset the video is also deleted from the home base so you have no recourse . While the nest can also be stolen, there footage remains secure, Google has a free of charge replacement as long as a police report is filed and there is a secure cable accessory a available that will make a tad tougher to just yank it off the wall. So I'll stick with the nest
If people can only install their cameras 9-10 feet high so that it cannot be reached.
Thanks.
Good mutate you going to be reviewing the simplisafe outdoor battery camera?
Will do. Just purchased it.
@@LifeHackster I bought one but when I go to live view it won’t work all the time. My you’ll have better luck.
Reolink has out a new reolink duo.. should do a review on that
But if I have the plug in nest can is there a cool off period?
No cool off in recording when plugged in but there is still a cool off in the notifications.
How’s the live video delay on both is the real question ?
Check my individual reviews and you will see me open the camera to live view.
nice video
Google really screwed up Nest. They'll probably do the same thing to Fitbit. It's like they just tried to do everything completely wrong with the new camera releases.
Does the eufy support 30fps in 1080p mode?
Does EUFY give u 30 to 60 days of video storage? do they charge u per cam per sub??? Best Aware has unlimited cams for $10 a month
The fact that these you need to know if a google product sucks or not speaks volumes. Good luck.
Lol I see what you did there on the night view comparison.
Wow 😳 I'm very impressed with eufy 👌
Both are good but eufy wins because of free local storage and 50% cheaper i buy.
You have to have a bird brain to buy the Nest.. 5 min cool off time ? they crook already robbed your house and made him self dinner in that time.. Eufy for the win !
I got the nest cam battery , only last 3 days . Really disappointed. I also bought the Google hub max , which may be useless without nest cams.
Again, Nest is late to the party & not competitive. It was a great company until Google bought it.
Exactly!
I would say Nest is better but it could have been way better designed.
Impressive Siren 😂
:)
Why compare 2k vs 1080??
Because the 2K is cheaper.
@@LifeHackster I think it would be best to compare 1080 vs 1080 and 2k vs 2k, To me it doesn't matter the cost.
Is still like to see you kick a soccer ball across the yard and see if a camera picks it up as a person
I tried it and both cameras didn't trigger...but these are PIR based cameras initially, so I have to try these with plugged in cameras that have camera based detection and AI and we will see.
I'll keep my Wyze camera.
new nest cameras WILL NOT WORK WITH NEAST APP.. i sent everything back got myself a nvr
hahaha i love that you're starting to let loose a little bit.... hopefully i'm not rubbin off on ya, sometimes you get to a point like "okay this was fun at first, but now it's the same ole junk" like nest being what 5 years late to the party? same 1080 1/3" image sensors, crappy field of view, low frame rate, etc. ring still puts out updates every other week, and their app is a huge train wreck, if someone is new to the ring world, it will take hours to go thru the app. My ring elite will trigger when a cat walks slowly under the doorbell but won't alert when a live human pulls up in the driveway, gets out, walks up to the door, leans over to place a package under the doorbell, walks to their car and backs out... NO alert... WTF ring? So try this experiment if you're bored, maybe it's a good video topic: If you have it in "people only" mode and a car pulls up righ tin front of the camera, it will detect that it's a car and not a human and it will place the camera in some sort of cool off period and won't trigger human motion detection, i have to run my cam without smart alerts and then i get false alerts when there's movement outside of the motion zones , day or night. this is why i'm pissed at ring. their motion system has been a failure for 2 years now.
I only have my spotlight cam wired in my backyard in people mode..and I get notification everytime when somebody gets out of the backyard.. I have my ring floodlight and pro 2 doorbell in regular motion detection..and I do have some alerts that are not in the zones but rarely. ( mostly slow moving cars at night…which I actually want to get notified because why they are driving slow?) I don’t use people mode on the front because I want to get notified of every movement…cat, dogs, possum..
@@LifeHackster yeah i agree, the flaw with people only mode is if it detects a non human and a human suddenly appears then it will not send a notification. smart notification will still record the motion events, i.e. slow moving vehicles, cats, dogs, etc but it will not alert you (you can customize it) but when it doesnt alert properly when a human gets out of a vehicle then smart detection is useless. so now were back to regular detection mode where it records AND alerts on everything, except this is also flawed in that it will detect motion outside of the motion zone, like headlights shining on a wall above the neighbors garage across the street when the motion zone is clearly my front steps, and theres not a drop of light change in the motion zone and it STILL gives a false notification, it's lose/lose with me and ring.
oof your backyard lawn might be getting some fungal issue. or just uneven watering.
Just uneven watering…hopefully..
Why don’t you comment or address the fact that the latency from nest to google is a second or two vs wife being over 12 seconds
This is exactly why I dumped Nest for the Eufy ecosystem. Google has ruined Nest products!
Well i want to know from LH what is his internet bandwidth he’s testing these with and what are the differences while the nest battery cam is wired over POE adapter because my clients most likely want 24/7 live video recordings otherwise what’s the point and ALL THE CAM COMPANIES MAKE $$$ on the backend with subscription services none of them offer FULL 30 - 60 day LQQKBACK OF RECORDINGS LIKE GOOGLE NEST - they all delete the vids after 7- 10-14 days so mr LH you should tell your viewers this FACT and. Most ppl i have asked have not had the cool off issue you are experiencing is it because it’s the battery trying to save power??? We need TRUE LONG BATTERY CHARGING AND USING CAMS but until then WIRED IS THE ONLY WAY TO ACHIEVE THIS
Does EUFY give u 30 to 60 days of video storage? do they charge u per cam per sub??? Best Aware has unlimited cams for $10 a month
Hard to justify the Google when wyze is way cheaper and has better quality
Eufy sucks. Never got any notifications for human or motion alerts when I actually set in settings. Just switched to Nest camera. Much better!
💐🌹🌷👍👏🌷🌹💐
Sorry, Arlo, it is no good. I will not buy additional Arlo camera. Wasted my money.
Eufy hands down best quality and price. Nest is way too old in technology and unreliable, Nest is not a "security" system.
You have to set zones on the nest camera someone who has hacker in their channel name should have at least know this simple bit of information
Pain to watch with adds didn’t watch all of video and don’t subscribe to add filled videos
For me Eufy is better in video quality and app speed (cam,doorbell etc.) than Google. I have two Eufy 2cPro's and the Eufy battery doorbell and 1 google cam with 24/7 recording. If Google would support 2K video, and improve the speed of their app, I would ditch all my Eufy cams and doorbell.
App Speed:
Eufy- Cheetah/Fast
Google- Snail/Slow
Live view:
Eufy - Cheetah/Fast
Google - Snail/spotty/slow
Motion Detection:
Eufy - Perfect in close range but does not notice people walking on the road, just the sidewalk in front of my house
Google- Perfect in close and far range. records motion all the way across the street and beyond
Eufy Doorbell - Spotty
Video Quality:
Eufy - Very clear 2K
Google- Very pixelated 1080p to the point that you can't recognise a thief if you have to zoom in on him/her
Wifi stability:
Eufy - Great in far range
Google - Hit and miss. It loses signal quite often even though there is nothing wrong with the wifi and the router is right next to it.
Battery:
Eufy - Battery does not last long let alone the marketed 6 months! I have one set on Human only and it only lasts 9 days on a full charge with about 50 notifications a day. If i set it on all motion, it will last me 4 days or so before i need to recharge. I live in a busy street but i have set my camera so that it doesn't film everything on my driveway which is maybe 3-5 notifications a day and that one lasts 13 days tops. The battery doorbell is mega bad and lasts only a week.
Google - plugged so no battery issues there
Customer Service:
Eufy - Really bad ( they simply don't respond)
Google - Neutral
My recommendation would be that you take Eufy 2K for clear view and app speed and Google to capture everything that goes on around your house which Eufy might miss if it happens too far out of Eufy's detection range. I saw your videos on Eufy detection range and mine does not detect that far at all. Maybe i have faulty ones?