No clear post-war plan for Gaza as Israel ramps up its ground offensive | DW News

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
  • Update from Gaza, where hundreds of thousands of evacuees have fled Rafah as repeated international calls urge Israel to exercise caution before launching a ground offensive on the city. Israel has been fighting Hamas across Gaza since the militant group carried out the October 7th terror attacks on Israel. But now Israeli soldiers are returning to the NORTH of the strip where Hamas forces have regrouped in areas Israel said it had cleared.
    Meanwhile, sirens sounded across Israel in somber ceremonies to mark Memorial Day. This year's commemoration is dedicated to the more than 1,200 people killed last fall by Hamas, as well as the soldiers who have died during the ongoing war in Gaza. Israeli citizens are still struggling to deal with the fallout of last October's attacks. With reporting from DW’s Israel correspondent Tania Krämer and Middle East Analyst Shani Rozanes.
    00:00 Intro Gaza update and report
    02:14 Interview Tania Krämer
    05:52 Intro Memorial Day and report
    09:37 Interview Shani Rozanes
    #gaza #israel #memorialday
    Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
    For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
    Follow DW on social media:
    ►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
    ►Twitter: / dwnews
    ►Instagram: / dwnews
    ►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
    Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch

КОМЕНТАРІ • 176

  • @nuqwestr
    @nuqwestr 24 дні тому +22

    There's been a "power vacuum" in Gaza since June 14, 2007.

    • @jdotsalter910
      @jdotsalter910 24 дні тому

      Because Bibi allowed funding of Hamas to prevent negotiating sovereignty.

    • @HagenKocksch
      @HagenKocksch 24 дні тому +2

      I don't understand what you mean! obviousely israel is and was in charge? don't tell me they pulled out and gaza was selfgoverning... with a 100% dependecy from the apartheid state!

    • @jfern6673
      @jfern6673 24 дні тому +1

      ​@@HagenKocksch what? Gazas population were free to leave by boat or through Egypt's border.. The wall stopped them entering Israel, like thats too hard to understand for you.. Wheres the apartheid?

    • @nerighal2889
      @nerighal2889 23 дні тому

      ​@@HagenKocksch..what a nonsens...what about the border of egypt?..100% dependency?
      ..wake up little dreamer..

    • @nerighal2889
      @nerighal2889 23 дні тому

      ​@@HagenKocksch..and..it's also not a prison if you have a backdoor to leave at any time over egypt...

  • @MrPeters1962
    @MrPeters1962 24 дні тому +24

    Palestinians want to see Hamas as their government it is unfortunate and inconvenient truth ;

    • @rodcamp4472
      @rodcamp4472 24 дні тому +6

      They voted them into leadership. Hamas are the Gazan politicians.

    • @tarunarya1780
      @tarunarya1780 24 дні тому

      Israel authorised Hamas so they could keep the status quo and continue settlements etc and not make peace with Palestinians. IDF killed those in 2018 peaceful Hamas organised marches

    • @wh8787
      @wh8787 23 дні тому +1

      The last election was in 2006. More than half the population of Gaza are children. I'm not really sure by what standard "they voted them in". When you're talking about a government that has not held elections for literally more than the lifetimes of over half the population, saying "oh well, the people of Gaza want this" is disingenuous at the very least. If a European country hadn't held elections for 18 years, and had those demographics, we wouldn't even be having a conversation about how democratic or socially responsible the population was for the actions of the government.

  • @philgriffin8687
    @philgriffin8687 24 дні тому +5

    Loved your video about Egypt joining South Africa in the Genocide case with the ICJ. The sound of crickets comming out of DW's speakers was deafening.

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 23 дні тому

      And yet Egypt did everything to prevent Gazans from escaping the bloodshed.

    • @philgriffin8687
      @philgriffin8687 23 дні тому +1

      @@erikthomsen4768 Your point is? Let me guess its Egypts fault for not giving Israel an excuse to say the land was abandoned so its ours now after their genocidal rampage.

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 23 дні тому

      @@philgriffin8687 Egypt acts like she cares about the Palestinian people. But she seems more interested in the land from what you are saying.
      If everyone dies then there won't be much left to fight for.

    • @philgriffin8687
      @philgriffin8687 23 дні тому

      @@erikthomsen4768 yeah definatly Egypt is the one Gaza stealing land and killing tens of thousands....Israel is just showering the place with rose petals and love right?

    • @philgriffin8687
      @philgriffin8687 23 дні тому

      @@erikthomsen4768 yeah definatly Egypt in Gaza stealing land and removing tens of thousands from life....Israel is just showering the place with rose petals and love right?

  • @legostud
    @legostud 24 дні тому +4

    Has anyone looked at which areas the IDF is focusing on in Gaza? I wonder how large the Gaza Strip will be after the war. Will Israel take the north a west lands that were being used for farming to expand settlements?

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 23 дні тому

      There is no proof of that happening. The last thing Israel did about illegal settlements was tearing them up and evicting thousands of Israelis from Gaza.

  • @Photoshoplilli
    @Photoshoplilli 24 дні тому +2

    Isreal has committed over 40 October Sevens in Gaza since October 7. Why do you have compassion for Israelis and not for Palestinians? I'm so tired of it.

  • @ntme9
    @ntme9 24 дні тому +33

    Everything gets deleted.
    If protesters got their way and Israel just left that would leave hummus and charge and that would ultimately be a bad thing for all gazans.

    • @second2none914
      @second2none914 24 дні тому +2

      Hummus is a tasty and healthy snack. 😊

    • @patay168
      @patay168 24 дні тому

      Failure of UN. They should allow Israel first to govern the whole of Gaza. Without proper separation. Expect turmoil in Gaza.

    • @user-fm4ri3iz4c
      @user-fm4ri3iz4c 19 днів тому

      deleted because marxist youtube hates free speech!

  • @Video2Webb
    @Video2Webb 24 дні тому +14

    "We are tired. We are sick of moving from one place to another." Understandable. BUT, did DW insist on the following question to be asked for this report: "Do you agree that your suffering has been caused by Hamas and its attacks on Israel?¨? Did you make that a requirement of paying ANYONE inside Gaza to collect material for this report? If not, shame on you. We are sick of the pity parties. Ask the Gazans to speak out freely for the world to hear. Some of them, many of them perhaps, WILL condemn Hamas and that is what we need to know.

    • @georgekung2003utube
      @georgekung2003utube 24 дні тому

      DW cannot regard as media. DW is a member of the geocide group

    • @IschiVezon
      @IschiVezon 24 дні тому

      i think youtube blocked my comment. just know that you are wrong, your understanding of it all is wrong, and you will not escape the consequences of israel’s deliberately killing of a secular democratic palestinian state

    • @IanG99
      @IanG99 24 дні тому

      For the ordinary Gaza, they just wanna survive. They don’t care about Hamas or the Israeli gov. Why are you pushing the agenda “it’s all Hamas fault”. It’s as if that ordinary Gazan has a Hamas hiding in her robes

    • @nvmtt1403
      @nvmtt1403 24 дні тому

      maybe they did ask. maybe they didnt show it to you because the answer was: "It is not hms that has been kidnapping children from west bank for years. so no, I do not agree. Because without them, idf would just walk into our homes and drag our kids to prison camps."

    • @viclee1878
      @viclee1878 24 дні тому

      What’s the difference?? Let’s say they do , what’s your point??

  • @roboldx9171
    @roboldx9171 23 дні тому

    There has not yet been a single Frenchman indicted before a French court of justice for the murder of an Algerian
    in Indochina in Madagascar or in the other colonies. The native has always known that he need expect nothing from the other side. The settler's work is to make even dreams of liberty impossible for the native the native's work is to imagine all possible methods for destroying the settler.
    Frantz Fanon

  • @afterglow5285
    @afterglow5285 24 дні тому

    "That was the plan all along", really?.

  • @user-zb9rn9vl9q
    @user-zb9rn9vl9q 23 дні тому

    "No clear post-war plan" was the same thing that was told about Iraq! And somehow "magically" the result is different.

  • @evelynconahan3894
    @evelynconahan3894 24 дні тому +34

    Complaining ....ask Hamas to surrender then war will end

    • @generalkhalid1192
      @generalkhalid1192 24 дні тому

      Apartheid supporter, typical.

    • @SkepticalMantisCHANNEL10
      @SkepticalMantisCHANNEL10 24 дні тому +5

      Why would they surrender when they haven't been defeated?

    • @generalkhalid1192
      @generalkhalid1192 24 дні тому +2

      They deleted my comment saying some stuff about israel 🤣

    • @SkepticalMantisCHANNEL10
      @SkepticalMantisCHANNEL10 24 дні тому +1

      @@generalkhalid1192 censorship

    • @philgriffin8687
      @philgriffin8687 24 дні тому

      @@generalkhalid1192 Anything with that word in it that isn't glowing praise or fully on message gets deleted by this completely unbiased 'news' organisation. Who never ever take sides or spouts propoganda.

  • @richardab
    @richardab 23 дні тому +1

    "The fate of Palestinians in Gaza is not on the agenda for Israelis." Says it all at the end of the report. This should not be normalised or acceptable.

    • @militant_pacifist
      @militant_pacifist 23 дні тому

      That generally tends to happen when one party invades another party to start a new round of a war.

  • @nokchatsungbakichu1854
    @nokchatsungbakichu1854 24 дні тому +1

    Where is south Africa🇿🇦?

    • @grandparick2444
      @grandparick2444 24 дні тому +2

      Located on the southern tip of the African continent. I can recommend some maps if needed.

    • @coolkavish
      @coolkavish 24 дні тому

      ​@@grandparick2444 😂😂😂

  • @SheepofTheShepherd-nu3lz
    @SheepofTheShepherd-nu3lz 24 дні тому +3

    Power vacuums am different from regular vacuums

  • @robertlange5587
    @robertlange5587 24 дні тому +1

    Oh I'm sure American Tax Dollars will somehow make their way there...

  • @jfearondasparky
    @jfearondasparky 24 дні тому

    Gary lineker has aged quickly

  • @SenChandan
    @SenChandan 24 дні тому +2

    Shalom Israel!😊

  • @PerceivedREALITY999
    @PerceivedREALITY999 24 дні тому +5

    75 year long apartheid, 16 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide. Evil

  • @user-po8cf5rp6q
    @user-po8cf5rp6q 24 дні тому +7

    They know what they are doing. Do you think the Israel are dumb?

  • @user-ib4ut6vy2g
    @user-ib4ut6vy2g 24 дні тому +11

    Allah is not going to save them. Neither is FJB😮

  • @jonjuan1955
    @jonjuan1955 24 дні тому +6

    I would imagine that you would treat it as any other war. You take the land and exile or imprison any remaining dissenters.

    • @tethergobrrr
      @tethergobrrr 24 дні тому +6

      Your imagination is full of war crimes

    • @mac7040
      @mac7040 24 дні тому

      Indeed and some kind of de-radicalisation program for the population like they had in Germany after world war two.

  • @k9k9k9er6
    @k9k9k9er6 24 дні тому +4

    But I thought u can’t destroy Hmas?!?!?
    So now u can?!?!
    🤣😂🤣😂

  • @tommytam3208
    @tommytam3208 24 дні тому +21

    Netanyahu should know he is fighting an unwinnable war against Hamas!

    • @CharlesHallESP
      @CharlesHallESP 24 дні тому +14

      Lol

    • @theshieldhero7062
      @theshieldhero7062 24 дні тому

      You are making as if Israel is fighting a real war like Ukraine is fighting a real army like Russia with drones, mines, sophisticated assault riffles and latest weapons made in the US and europe . Israel is literally fighting one-sidedly against civilians namely children and women just to get a few terrorists who are fighting with outdated and home-made weapons.

    • @dubsar
      @dubsar 24 дні тому +18

      Is Hamas going to keep fighting from the afterlife?

    • @nokchatsungbakichu1854
      @nokchatsungbakichu1854 24 дні тому +1

      Blame South Africa

    • @thiphan264
      @thiphan264 24 дні тому +7

      Hamas is a problem for the Palestinians too. Even when Palestinians could get an own country, there is no future with Hamas and the Sharia state. Please look at Afghanistan with Taliban and Yemen with Houthis.
      There are a lot of Palestinians who studied in the Western countries and cried "Free, free Palestine".
      Why don't they return to Gaza and help the Palestinians build a democratic country?

  • @eldeesantos1167
    @eldeesantos1167 24 дні тому +4

    Hamas resurgence..??? Nope they are civilians who supported and symphatized with Hamas..same civilians who are in Rafah.

    • @NoobGamer-sc9lt
      @NoobGamer-sc9lt 23 дні тому

      you mean people who lost their loved ones and want revenge, they're not sympathizers any human who face injustice and abandoned will has his own version of justice, that's why civilized society start with laws

  • @mikevalentino2225
    @mikevalentino2225 24 дні тому +9

    The Palestinians complaining sounds so mild compared to the people they kidnapped tortured and murdered. "Omg i had to leave one area and go to another is was horrible!" While at least you didn't have your baby decapitated in front of you lady.

    • @luisdagobertoserrano8029
      @luisdagobertoserrano8029 24 дні тому +1

      That didn't happen

    • @theloniousm4337
      @theloniousm4337 23 дні тому

      @@luisdagobertoserrano8029 Do you deny the holocaust as well?

    • @luisdagobertoserrano8029
      @luisdagobertoserrano8029 23 дні тому

      @theloniousm4337 absolutely no, not at all. The holocaust happened, and it was a genocide that no one should deny. Unfortunately, that was not the first genocide and more Unfortunately was not the last. We learn little out of it as we continue killing innocent people.

  • @schlafcomandante5662
    @schlafcomandante5662 24 дні тому +6

    🔻🔻 B D S 🔻🔻

    • @imisstoronto3121
      @imisstoronto3121 24 дні тому

      I'd prefer to see the UN and UNRWA dissolved. Stop giving them the ability to skim money from donor countries and make them stand up on their own two feet.

    • @schlafcomandante5662
      @schlafcomandante5662 23 дні тому

      @@imisstoronto3121 Better to just kick out the rouge states Israel and the US out of the UN and make the UN democratic.

    • @schlafcomandante5662
      @schlafcomandante5662 23 дні тому

      @@imisstoronto3121 Make the UN democratic. Let the US sit alone in the world.

  • @electrolytics
    @electrolytics 24 дні тому +12

    As long as Israel is safe that's all that matters. These others had a chance to build a wonderful home by the sea.
    Instead they chose radicalism and terror. Reap what you sow.

    • @tarunarya1780
      @tarunarya1780 24 дні тому

      Israel has no moral authority to be supported by anyone

    • @nvmtt1403
      @nvmtt1403 24 дні тому

      yeah, and i guess you paid for the construction? lmao. you aint building any homes without a job. and no company will invest in a territory where their workers may not show up the next day because they were kidnapped. see west bank as an example. no protection, no investment, no jobs, no wonderful homes.

    • @user-vj5ml8hy8m
      @user-vj5ml8hy8m 24 дні тому +1

      yeah, that's what people who oppose genocide don't get. They are just getting what they asked for. Europeans settlers went to their land and took their land and they asked for this?

  • @TruthRules2
    @TruthRules2 24 дні тому

    Kramer is the IDF or M055@d spokesperson too?

  • @kbram7363
    @kbram7363 24 дні тому

    DW is weak

  • @stanfreetour
    @stanfreetour 24 дні тому +1

    The pain of the occupier and the colonizer is always deemed more important & emphasised upon by their colonial allies above those of their victims!

    • @militant_pacifist
      @militant_pacifist 23 дні тому

      You mean like women in Arab countries?
      Or LGBT individuals in Gaza?
      Or guest workers in Qatar?

  • @dubsar
    @dubsar 24 дні тому +2

    8:19
    "Nothing will ever be like before that day."
    ESPECIALLY NOT GAZA.

  • @patrickbureau1402
    @patrickbureau1402 24 дні тому +10

    ...Like an empty space where a society & culture once existed?
    Occupping a wasteland iz genocide - sorry !🇨🇦

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr 24 дні тому

      No genocide, the population of Gaza tripled since 1967. How is that a genocide?

  • @okkkSS-rg3tq
    @okkkSS-rg3tq 24 дні тому

    Chocolate pigm

  • @bobbydennis8333
    @bobbydennis8333 24 дні тому +5

    Just making sure if we see something we’re still supposed to say something!
    “Been that way for 30 years.” - U.S. Justice Department on the lack of Human Rights in Oklahoma County Jail, 2020
    “Makes me feel human again after this place.” - Oklahoma City Art Museum review after life in the local shelters (20+ years in the making), 2024
    “It is said that no one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.” - Nelson Mandela 🥂🥂

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr 24 дні тому +1

      cut and paste cut and paste bot

    • @bobbydennis8333
      @bobbydennis8333 24 дні тому

      @@nuqwestr cut and paste country cut and paste country

  • @EthanLomas
    @EthanLomas 24 дні тому

    Thank you Jesus 🙏

  • @inekeaknoeff7761
    @inekeaknoeff7761 24 дні тому +9

    I see no malnurished people... Rafa was already crowded always.

    • @dodo-og2ss
      @dodo-og2ss 24 дні тому

      I believe majority of people is short of food. But war provoked is war provoked.

    • @saidlbd2958
      @saidlbd2958 24 дні тому

      you are evil

    • @judieg.7945
      @judieg.7945 24 дні тому +1

      Did you see the video of them partying on the beach? So many untruths about this area.

    • @dodo19961375320
      @dodo19961375320 24 дні тому +1

      Yeah the whole world is lying! They r having the time of their life

  • @rodcamp4472
    @rodcamp4472 24 дні тому +2

    After the war, they need to develop Gaza & West Bank for the Israeli's who will be purchasing homes and land.

    • @seanmurphy2365
      @seanmurphy2365 23 дні тому

      Is this a pro palestine or pro Israel comment? I can't tell

  • @PerceivedREALITY999
    @PerceivedREALITY999 24 дні тому

    Saying netanyahu is not a war criminal is like saying biden can run up the stairs without stumbling.

    • @militant_pacifist
      @militant_pacifist 23 дні тому

      HANDLERS, update the bot, he's stuck on one phrase again.

  • @dilmaarora5316
    @dilmaarora5316 24 дні тому +3

    It's terrible what happened to Israel in October, but what's happening now to thousands of Palestinians dying will never have any memorial they will go down without anyone remembering them except their surviving relatives. They were human beings too...

    • @RS-uh7rz
      @RS-uh7rz 24 дні тому +1

      Unquestionably awful. But who is more to blame - Israel or Hamas?

    • @musajallow5710
      @musajallow5710 24 дні тому

      Palestinians have beeen undder this for 75 years oct 7 was just one of those terrorible events of the occupation

    • @RomyullIslam
      @RomyullIslam 24 дні тому

      Last 75 years Israeli doing same think in Palestine. when they fought back it become a problem for whole world ans supporting Israel for doing genocide.
      Killing people in there own land and capturing there labd and everything is right of Israeli people?

    • @dilmaarora5316
      @dilmaarora5316 24 дні тому

      @@RS-uh7rz politics and the power driven heads in that society,

    • @dilmaarora5316
      @dilmaarora5316 24 дні тому

      @@musajallow5710 I am aware. It's sad

  • @judieg.7945
    @judieg.7945 24 дні тому

    An artificial peninsula out in the water. Infrastructure, housing, schools, water desalination facilities. The Palestinians would have something nice for once. Security would be provided by the Israeli's with a large attractive gate for those approved to travel. For those who will accept a two state agreement to live in peace with Israel, housing on old Gaza footprint. For those who still want to support the fellas, they get to live with them on the peninsula. A public denunciation with monetary reward for those denouncing hummus. Solution is, peace and safety for Israel. Housing and security for the Palestinians. For those who still want hummus to govern them. they will have the opportunity to live with them on the sea.

    • @dodo19961375320
      @dodo19961375320 24 дні тому

      You think they would select Hamas if there was no apartheid, no blockade on Gaza for 14 years, settlements in the occupied west bank, occasional bombardments, and zelouts thinking somewhere is given to them by GOD?

    • @philgriffin8687
      @philgriffin8687 24 дні тому +1

      Lol Israel does not want a two state soloution, Netenyahu himself said it. They want a single state with no palestinians in it. Hence the years of land grabs and ethnic cleasining.

    • @countyrealestate4273
      @countyrealestate4273 24 дні тому

      Israel is not into a two state solution... Will never recognize the legitimacy of Palestinian population.....
      and so would most Palestinians. This conflict will never end until one party is vanquished , if that is even possible .

  • @rickeygooden6713
    @rickeygooden6713 24 дні тому +11

    I feel bad for the people of gaza but I really think that they should pick different leaders in the future that wont run into someone else's country to kill and kidnap innocent civilians. Hamas was the cause of all of this in my opinion but it still doesn't justify what is happening to these poor people 😢😢

    • @tayloreverard2039
      @tayloreverard2039 24 дні тому +3

      ah yes the privilege of real democracy

    • @inekeaknoeff7761
      @inekeaknoeff7761 24 дні тому +1

      The people in Gaza never had anything to choose! It was a big mistake of Israel to leave Gaza to Hamas.

    • @RomyullIslam
      @RomyullIslam 24 дні тому

      what happening in west bank?? whenever Israeli want they capture their land, kill then any time they want. You think what hammas did only because of that it is happening??
      Israeli killings thousands of people since last 75 years. when hammas fought back, they became the reason behind the war!!!
      So you think Israel have right to kill and capturing Palestinians land but Palestinians can no protests???
      True hypocrisy....

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr 24 дні тому +2

      @@inekeaknoeff7761 False, there was an election, Hamas won, then had a civil war with Fatah. Learn about June 14, 2007.

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr 24 дні тому

      @@RomyullIslam Jordan occupied the West Bank and started a war with Israel in 1967. No one is getting "killed" any time. nonsense.

  • @CanadaRocks4U
    @CanadaRocks4U 24 дні тому +2

    ONLY ABOUT 6000 LEFT. BB NETANYAHU IS DOING AWESOME, EVEN HELPING CIVILIANS, BUT SOME WONT LEAVE AND WHAT TO ...

  • @simonpeterokiror1799
    @simonpeterokiror1799 23 дні тому

    Condemn Hamas o Palestiniand

  • @PerceivedREALITY999
    @PerceivedREALITY999 24 дні тому +1

    We must not be silent while witnessing injustice. More than 35,000 Palestinians have lost their lives, mostly women and children.

    • @militant_pacifist
      @militant_pacifist 23 дні тому +2

      That tends to happen when you start a war and refuse to surrender.
      Go and look up how many German civilians died in WW2.

  • @tomhenry897
    @tomhenry897 24 дні тому +1

    River to sea
    All,you see
    Are Israelis
    🇮🇱

  • @nublex
    @nublex 24 дні тому

    1:00 did you vote for HAMAS?

  • @razahussainshah8173
    @razahussainshah8173 24 дні тому +12

    DW!!! Your story is about twelve hundred people. Do you care about thousands of innocent Palestinians?