I love that Anette didn't try to copy Tarja, but put her own mark on this song. Her interpretation is very refreshing and has its own high level of quality.
2024 ❤❤❤Anette ist ein unglaublich offener lieber Mensch . Sie ist in meinem Herzen , und ich kann den Hate Jahre später nicht mehr ertragen . Ihre Stimme ist wunderschön ❤ Die beste singende Krankenschwester.. Denkt daran das es nicht nur Künstler sondern auch Menschen sind . Es gibt Grenzen
@@yayayeter42 can't argue that the style shifted. But I did like both of Annette albums with Nightwish. But with Sleeping Sun , Taja is still the best, but I actually prefer Annette over Floor
I like all three ladies Nightwish have had for singers, each for different reasons. That said, I don't think this song is a matter of range, or a matter of "this song was written for Tarja and not for Anette". It is maybe possible that the first half of the song happens where her voice would break from a chest to a head voice, but since she can belt the higher key change, I'm a bit iffy on that. She is flat for the first 2/3 of the song so I wonder if her in-ear monitors weren't working well or if there was a technical issue wherein she couldn't hear the melody. I do also hear some nerves, and who wouldn't be nervous? This poor woman received quite literal death threats just for taking a job. She utterly slayed that key change and last chorus and I wonder what it would have been like had she just belted the whole song. Anyway this is my manifesto on, "Anette isn't a bad singer, and she does admirably, especially since she's self taught and a mezzo soprano and there was probably more going on than we know." And also, she's doing amazing work in The Dark Element now so we have even more great music to listen to :)
3 роки тому
I totally agree with you, though she is a bit more than a mezzo... of course she's not a full lyric soprano like Floor but she said once that if she would have taken classes of classical operatic music she could sing in operatic too... I saw a video of her singing a classical song but even if she has the range she lacks of technique to sing operatic so it's kind of weird hearing her trying really hard to sing a classical song... and Mary z define her a soprano too...
They weren't songs written for Annete's tone, yet she does it very well and emotionally. Personally, I prefer floor jansen, by far the best voice, enormous versatility and a simply brutal stage presence.
People calling this performance awful. Of course it was. The song wasn't made for her voice. I don't know why they even tried performing it with Anette.
I didn't like this woman's voice. It was horrible. Especially in live. Tuomas has made a very big mistake when he took her as a leader singer. I wouldnt have any problem with that she didn't want to sing like Tarja but she wasn't enough well- taught to Nightwish songs. Her voice was very weak and she sang a lot of fake notes....... by the way she gave much more work for Tuomas and the guys . They had to rewrite the old songs into lower key and thats the truth she couldn't even sing them well ......... and another thing. .. The band had to play very weakly because of her...........and. thats all sounded horribly.......... and these beautiful songs lost their meanings in the lower key including the very weak singing as well.
She is so expressive, for me is the most emotional version. I really like it.
I always like Annette's version, I love how she improvises this song 😍
I love that Anette didn't try to copy Tarja, but put her own mark on this song. Her interpretation is very refreshing and has its own high level of quality.
La versión de Anette es muy hermosa. Muy emotiva !!!
La verdad yo me enamore de su voz y por ella empece a escuchar a Nighwish
🤦♂️
Maybe you find me strange person,but i love this version too. It's different from Tarja's but that doesn't mean it isn't ok.
No don't worry😊 i love some of Anette's performances too
I love this song with all three singers!!
@ exactly that!
You're not alone. I also love this version with all my heart.
So beautiful!! Wonderful Anette
Such an amazing emotional version! ❤
Just remember, Nightwish chose her to be the next lead singer of their band. Her sound is different, but it's clearly what they wanted.
I love her so much I could cry. Anette is just something else 🖤
Tarja is the master of this song, but enjoy each different version for different reasons but Tarja gave this song life.
2024 ❤❤❤Anette ist ein unglaublich offener lieber Mensch . Sie ist in meinem Herzen , und ich kann den Hate Jahre später nicht mehr ertragen . Ihre Stimme ist wunderschön ❤ Die beste singende Krankenschwester..
Denkt daran das es nicht nur Künstler sondern auch Menschen sind . Es gibt Grenzen
I especially like this longer keyboard intro, which seems to start with sort of an inverse intro before the normal intro, into which its morphs.
I’m a Floor fan but I love all 3. I like this version and Anette does just fine.
I like Floor too, but not on Nightwish. :(
4:02 and onwards 😮💨❤️ Her voice punches my spirit
Better version to me, fuck off all the haters, btw, emppu's solo rules 🤘
Very emotional.
Very 💩
Anette pek sevilmez ama She Is My Sin, Sacrament of Wilderness, Sleeping Sun gibi parçaları çok güzel yorumlamış zamanında hakkını vermek lazım 🙂
Nice love it
realmente amo esta versión nightwish suena mas rockera tiene sus matices propias
I'm i the only one who doesn't hate Annette? I think she did a fine job of this song and she is a fantastic singer , just different from tarja.
@@yayayeter42 can't argue that the style shifted. But I did like both of Annette albums with Nightwish.
But with Sleeping Sun , Taja is still the best, but I actually prefer Annette over Floor
Dios mío! Sin palabras!😳😬🤐😟
Es tan dulce y fresca la voz de Anette, me encanta.
I like all three ladies Nightwish have had for singers, each for different reasons. That said, I don't think this song is a matter of range, or a matter of "this song was written for Tarja and not for Anette". It is maybe possible that the first half of the song happens where her voice would break from a chest to a head voice, but since she can belt the higher key change, I'm a bit iffy on that. She is flat for the first 2/3 of the song so I wonder if her in-ear monitors weren't working well or if there was a technical issue wherein she couldn't hear the melody. I do also hear some nerves, and who wouldn't be nervous? This poor woman received quite literal death threats just for taking a job. She utterly slayed that key change and last chorus and I wonder what it would have been like had she just belted the whole song. Anyway this is my manifesto on, "Anette isn't a bad singer, and she does admirably, especially since she's self taught and a mezzo soprano and there was probably more going on than we know." And also, she's doing amazing work in The Dark Element now so we have even more great music to listen to :)
I totally agree with you, though she is a bit more than a mezzo... of course she's not a full lyric soprano like Floor but she said once that if she would have taken classes of classical operatic music she could sing in operatic too... I saw a video of her singing a classical song but even if she has the range she lacks of technique to sing operatic so it's kind of weird hearing her trying really hard to sing a classical song... and Mary z define her a soprano too...
Loved this version too although she was significently flat on some notes. Sleeping sun craves for the only angel Tarja's vocal.
Anette cannot reach the range Tarja can.
Yet Floor can sing everything that her predecessors could, and many things they could not. And do it well
sweet
They weren't songs written for Annete's tone, yet she does it very well and emotionally. Personally, I prefer floor jansen, by far the best voice, enormous versatility and a simply brutal stage presence.
The opera version own this tune. However, Annette was able to make out like her own!
Nahh no hay comparación.
People calling this performance awful. Of course it was. The song wasn't made for her voice. I don't know why they even tried performing it with Anette.
Most Nightwish fans love nightwish because of this song so i dont blame them why they performed this with Anette, she did the best she could i guess.
I like her version, sound isn't great because of video quality, but I think Anette's version is the best.
@@santlucas I think Tarja is still the best for this song, but Annette is a close second
She shouldn’t have changed the vocal melody but I like her improvisation :3
Su tono es muy suave
tbh im not a nightwish listener....nor do i particulary care....but anette just sounds like blunt axe on this song....especially compared to tarja...
Это просто отвратительно и обидно слышать после Тарьи
💯
Tarja Turunen is the reason why I fell in love with Nightwish
Anette is a good Singer. Just her voice type is not for Tarja's song
Anette is a very good singer but this is not for her.
@@francescobaratti8065 sorry for automatic correction
The previous half was a disaster. The latter half was awesome tho
Nahhh it was grest performance, isnt far from Floor version!
The entire performance was Amazing.
there are things that should not change. Sleeping Sun / Tarja
I dont like this version...
Floor &Tara metal Goddess’s she looks like a librarian
So beautiful song but I really don’t like when Anette is changing the melody. Should’t do that.
That was awful :x
omg that was terrible, such a disrespect to this song!
Awful pointless
Awful
I didn't like this woman's voice. It was horrible. Especially in live. Tuomas has made a very big mistake when he took her as a leader singer. I wouldnt have any problem with that she didn't
want to sing like Tarja but she wasn't enough well- taught to Nightwish songs. Her voice was very weak and she sang a lot of fake notes....... by the way she gave much more work for Tuomas and the guys . They had to rewrite the old songs into lower key and thats the truth she couldn't even sing them well ......... and another thing. .. The band had to play very weakly because of her...........and. thats all sounded horribly.......... and these beautiful songs lost their meanings in the lower key including the very weak singing as well.
I agree. The salvation came when Floor stepped into the band. From that day on they played better and sounded better than ever.
Floor version is awesome, but Tarja’s version is perfection. Sorry Annette you butchered this song.
Floor is the best!!
Floor is a true Goddess ❤❤