Just picked up the mod 2 osp fee weeks ago. Threw 150 rounds through it with no issues at all,, and for me.. the new grip safety didn't bother my hand one bit. Great pistol ran flawless and very comfortable in the hand. Great video, happy shooting!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸
The XDS Mod.2 in 9mm is the first Springfield pistol I've ever purchased, but I liked it so much a bought a second one. I got the gear up special on both, so with three free 8 round magazines for each gun it was a pretty good deal overall. I find the gun a great fit in the hand and it shoots very well with modest recoil for a small pistol. I've also found it to be totally reliable so far with no problems in either pistol. I do find the 7 round magazine with pinky extension to be poorly designed as it cramps my hand between the bottom of the extension and the trigger guard, but I prefer the eight round magazine anyway as I can get a full grip with those. A really solidly built, reliable gun that I would highly recommend for those looking for a small single stack 9mm.
Randy Giedrycz I have the XDS Mod. 2 but in .45 ACP. You’re right about what you wrote here. These guns are very comfortable in my hands and the recoil, though it’s more than a 9mm, is very manageable. I love the safety set up because pulling a gun to use in an emergency situation should be as free from confusion and anxiety as possible. Thus, not having a safety lever to flip down is a big plus. Instead, these guns have the very simple yet functional safety in the grip and the trigger. Pulling the gun in a fast emergency, one doesn’t have to remember to take the safety off. Instead they grip the gun and pull the trigger.
Same here. I bought the Mod 1 in 9MM and liked it so much I bought a Mod 2 in .40. Would have bought one in .45 but they were unavailable - and still are. I find myself carrying the 40 for EDC but like both of them very much. The grip safety is a love \ hate thing with many shooters and I'm usually in the latter crowd. However, I have large hands and don't even notice it with either model. IMO, Springfield got it right.
I have the original XDS 3.3 in .45 A.C.P. The recall was for the grip safety. Apparently the grip safety caused issues with trigger not functioning properly allowing some guns to fire without being depressed. New internal changes and an extra roll pin was added. As to the change in grip safety design it was because people complained they couldn't tell or were concerned they were not depressing the safety because they couldn't feel it when they gripped the pistol. Wasn't a problem, people are weird and complain either way, I don't feel it, I don't like that I feel it-LOL. I prefer the old style grip safety. I just love a small .45! I sold my Detonics .45 which I regretted and wanted another small .45 A.C.P.
I bought the XDS mod 1 about 4 years ago and really liked it. Very ergonomic and a great shooter, but it was a bit heavy. I replaced it with the popular Sig P365 and it's great. I passed my XDS down to my brother who is newly licensed for his first gun. He likes it a lot better than the S&W 9mm Shield EZ that he ordered for his girlfriend. Although the Shield EZ was really made for new shooters, and people with less hand strength, he doesn't like the ergonomics, and is less accurate with the EZ. Even though the XDS is not the latest, it's still a very competitive well made accurate gun, and you can't go wrong with it.
I had an XDs 9 a few years ago. A lot of the guys I worked with were getting Glock 43s, so I sold my XDs & got the 43. I have to say, though I am a self proclaimed Glock fanboy, I liked the XDs better. IMO, the XDs has a crisper trigger break than the 43, though I believe it’s a tad heavier on the pull. The trigger is still very smooth. I have since sold the 43 as well. I am wanting to get another single stack & I keep getting drawn back to the XDs. As always, great review. One of these days, I want to get my hands on a Steyer. The gun stores in my area do not have them in stock.
@@Nick-sz6xb As soon as he said it I was watching the video and I was like dang. He means that mostly all you can see is a hand with no arm and the guy talks with his hands so much.
I'm going to be honest I have a xds mod 2 9mm and YES I know it's a Springfield but it's one heck of a little shooter!! My wife carries it everywhere. I have fell back to carrying the G43 daily which I also really like. Both are very accurate and never a hiccup through either. Great video bro and God bless!!👍🇺🇸🇺🇸
I have a friend that owns the mod 1 and he is not gun knowable and when he tried fire it, nothing. He ask me to look at it. The first thing I noticed was the grip safety. Then I knew he wasn't activating the grip safety. I show that to him and he then starting shooting it after that, Great video!.
James Reeves from TFBTV is fond of saying we are in the golden age of conceal carry. It is great that we have so many options, including the little tank XDs. And even though the P365 has problems, Sig's innovation with the magazine alone on the 365 will have a big impact. Assuming we keep our rights, the future of conceal carry from a product choice standpoint is very bright.
I bought my daughter the XDS-9mm Mod 2 with a Crimson Trace Red Dot Laser Sight on it & she loves it. The only thing is the slide release was really hard to press down. So after shooting about 100 rounds at the range I broke it down cleaned & oiled it pretty good. It's a little better, but I'm sure it'll get better the more she fires it. I like her XDS-9mm so much I'm gonna get me one in a .45 ACP. Great video & keep up the good work.
Fantastic comparison! Best wishes with the New Year! Love the mod2 grip zone texture. Not to crazy about the shape of the grip safety, although the XDS mod 2 in 45 cap has the old shape. I've asked them why the exchange up, they replied that it resembles ones on the 1911s.... oh well - they call it memory pad...Still I'm with you on that one. I'm sure there will be a aftermarket replacement soon.
I love my xds9 mod 1 never have had any trouble. I chose it over the mod 2 because the grips and sights. These are my favorite single stack 9mm I shot all the others and more compacts at my local range but was most accurate with this one.
Good info, I've used the XDs for my summer carry for several years now. It's a perfect fit for me, great texture grips,slim and F.O. sight and I shoot it well. Nice to see the comparison, so I don't get FOMO thanks for posting!
Another good comparison, and quality show. I've yet to hold the Mod 2 XDS, but it looks very nice. However, I owned the original in all three calibers and was happy with them all. I just moved away from single stack pistols a few years ago. The only SS pistol I have now is my Walther PPQ in 22LR. :) Have a great weekend brother, Cheers!
I'm new-ish to firearms so when I got interested in them, all I read about Springfield was about their politics so I never paid attention to them. Having said that, I did buy a 1911 Range Officer Elite in 9mm and really like it. I have never shot any of their polymer pistols. Thanks for the videos and the new format rocks. Happy New Year and cheers!
Happy New Year my good man. I have to admit i miss the music LOL. Some hate it and some love it. What matters here is that this was a great video and i look forward to what you have for us this year. Peace be with you
To be honest, I like the XD-S .45 ACP mod 2 for one reason. It allows me to carry easily with my shirt tucked in or when I’m wearing a suit. I prefer to carry my SIG P320 Compact in .45 ACP, but it’s nice to have a slim gun for different kinds of wear.
I picked up a lightly used XDS-45 Mod 1 about a year ago. It’s been my favorite carry gun since. In my hand it has the best ergonomics and fit, it is reliable and accurate. I upgraded my sights to XS F8 sights and I love the setup on a combat pistol. I also got a great deal on a bunch of used magazines a guy offloaded at my local gun shop. I carry it 6+1 and a spare magazine. I have several other pistols, but the XDS-45 is my favorite. My Shield Plus 9 is a close second and gets some carry time also, but this one feels and shoots better for me.
Thanks for this review. Rumors are I buy a lot of guns, but you know how rumors are. The first XD I shot was 45 and I thought I had a misfire because the recoil was hardly there. Since that time I found many of them in my hands. The XDs fits well in my posket, even with the extended 8 round mag + the chambered one (9 shots total). This review was great. I asked a gun selling store what the differences were and he was totally dumb. SO I made notes and now I know.
I love my XDS mod I, and it’s a perfect compliment to my Kel Tec 9mm rifle. While neither one is top of the line, I like that they both shoot 9mm and that the Kel Tec folds in order to fit in a back pack.
Just got my Springfield XDS mod 2 and I love it! However have smaller hands so I feel like the mod 2 works perfect! When I shot it at the range I had no problems with the back safety and it felt quite comfortable while I was shooting at the Target. In my opinion I love my XDS mod 2 and I think it's overall the better conceal and carry gun.
I just purchased the Springfield XDS mod two and 45 ACP. Mine came with a six round magazine and a five round magazine. The only thing that this does not have is the indicator on the top for being loaded and cocked it does not have that. Also, I did not get The hard case or anything like that with mine. Mine just came in a simple box and I paid $475 out the door for mine.
Great video on both versions. I purchased a mod 2 and love it. It is my main carry gun. Then with the extra free items I received man was it worth it. Thanks for the video.
I bought my XDS 45 mod 2 when it first came out about 3 1/2 years ago. And the cocking serrations are sharp, deep and crisp like the original. I switched out those sucky sights with a good set of Trijicon night sights and added it to my carry rotation. Next to my Sig P938 SAS it is the easiest to conceal EDC I own. Mine came in a zip up Nylon carry case with 4 mags and a funky kydex holster that I wouldn't consider using.
The XDS mod 2 is the best single stack pistol I have ever purchased. It is extremely ergonomic, well balanced, and feels just right. It looks well built and points spot on. The u notch rear sight is a significant improvement and it is more well rounded compared to the first mod. The texture on the grip feels perfect. It is much less aggressive than the Taurus. The weight of the pistol is manageable and it doesn't weigh me down for concealed carry. I love the mod 2. I've had the mod 1 and I didn't care for it. The mod 2 is worth the trade. Call me crazy, but it is. Plus, I'm a Glock guy and I'll tell you the mod 2 is much more well built and refined compared to any Glock. It is worth the money.
I’ve got the mod2 45acp and I like the grips better…I’ve got the 10mm in full size and I wished it had the mod2 style grips I may put Talen grips on the 10mm. Good video
I just purchased the mod 2 with optics. So far I love the gun. Being in New York State the 7 round mag fits the law requirements perfectly. Love the grip safety feature when carrying.
My interest in the XDS was due to the exact same size gun came in 45. Firing the mod 1 would be described as a painful experience for the web of my hand. Thankfully that was remedied with the mod2. I almost never carry anything else.
Extended magazines are identical, just use appropriate sleeve for your application. You failed to mention the Mod 1 has changeable backstraps for a tailored fit to your hand. For most purchasers of these models, it is going to be how the coarse aggressive texturing of the Mod 1 feels in there hand, as opposed to the finer GripZone, of the Mod 2.
I've carried a XDS-9 for a couple years now and love that gun. I have no desire to upgrade to the Mod 2. I recently purchased a Gen 5 - G26 and have been carrying that.
1776 thanks for the side by side I would never have guessed there would be so many slight differences and it is good to know that interchangeability is very limited between the 2 models.
I bought the .45 ACP version of this model. It does the job but it's nothing to write home about so to speak. It conceals very well even in the Wright Leather Works OWB holster that I bought for it. At times I forget I have it on. The only draw back with it that concerns me, and it's only a minor issue, is it almost seems that it wasn't designed for .45 cal. I get the impression it's trying to tear itself apart. The 9mm is probably the better choice on this one.
Thanks for the info as nice comparison as I know they are good guns but all those safeties drive me nuts on those guns.....Good detailed info as I appreciate that....Good stuff....
I have the mod 2 in 45acp. I think they have improved the trigger on it from mod1. However, for my hands, I feel the size of the grip, front to back, is too wide. Also, the undercut on the trigger guard I do not find comfortable. But still the best cc gun for 45 cal in my opinion
I bought the XDS mod 1 in 9MM and liked it so much I bought a second in .40, but it's a Mod 2 and *IMO* the new grip sucks. Feel is subjective and I know many who feel the change was an improvement. I'm just not one of them. Ergonomics are still great but the surface is on par with the Glock or Shield. However, they are still built like a tank and I like that. For anyone on the fence about having a grip safety I'd say don't overlook the gun until you have held it. It's way better than any other I've held and I really don't even notice it.
I purchased a Smith and Wesson SD 9 a few years back and I really enjoy but I've been looking to purchase my second hand gun. Would the XD S be a good choice to add or should i go for the XD?
Depends what you want double stack vs single stack. I personally only have 1 carry single stack left which is the shield 4inch. Summer carry only but mostly I still carry double sracks
Hi man, great videos. I can't seem to find this information anywhere, can you check (if you have the opportunity of course) with which of the magazines (flush, pinky, 8 rds, 9 rds) does the Mod 2 fit into the IDPA BUG box? There is nowhere on the internet where I can find this information. I would like to buy one but in my country we (me) are not allowed to carry guns, so I can only use them for IDPA and range time. So I would like to buy one that I could use in the BUG division. Thanks. OR ... to please measure exactly the height of the gun with the 4 options: flush magazine, pinky extension, 8 rounds, 9 rounds. The maximum allowed height for BUG division is 4.625 inches (or 4 5/8 inches)
When they first came out, I owned both the M&P Shield as well as XDS-9. The Shield had a superior trigger release but I could shoot the XDS more accurately so I sold the Shield. I would love to handle and shoot the XDS mod2 to compare directly with my mod1 and upgrade or stay the course depending on outcome. Unfortunately, I called one of the area's largest handgun dealers with an indoor range and they don't have the mod2 in stock. And if they did, they wouldn't allow any comparison shooting on the range, although they do have a mod1 for range use. Bummer. Guess I stay with my mod1 for now.
Wow! Thats crazy my brother owned the shield a few years ago an i shot it an everything an i jus bought the XDS an to me its wayy better. Nicer appeal, nicer feel in hand. And i shoot it better never had a problem with either though just my opinion the xds is way more appealing an it handles very well so its currently my #1
Ive used the xds mod 1 9mm as my edc for years now. I'm about to trade it in for the sig p365. Nothing against the xds I love it. At this point though I think the 365 is just an upgrade. It's fixed all it's problems at this point. And it holds 10+1
Xds had an issue with discharging upon racking the slide without pulling the trigger. At least that’s what some had claimed. I had one and never had an issue and I remember watching videos of people trying to replicate the issue but couldn’t.
Well one's better for carrying and hiding if you're buying it to be able to put inside your waistband I put it in your pants pocket or something like that the XDS definitely where to go that's the one you want
@@danielmcbride4828 Thanks man. Decided to go with both lol. XD40 was hard to find since it's a discontinued model. I shoot better with a double stack. Great gun/s regardless
Love the mod 1, really considering the mod 2. In the hand it feels a lot better plus the mod 2 now comes OSP ready. Thinking it would be better option than the 26 and 365 I have. Neither of those feel as good in the hand.
Great review. I just sent my new XDs 45 mod 2 back to Springfield today 9/2020. Turn around time is 4-6 weeks for repairs. The first box of ammo was Winchester white box 45 acp. After 50 rounds I had six. (6) failure to feed issues. I literally had to clear the jams with my pocket knife. Whenever it’s returned I will sell it and go back to Glock or Sig for my EDC
OH yes the Gen 1 XDS Remember wen they first came out great price point Big Hard case loaded with goodies.Very impressive the guy at the gun counter down in Tombstone AZ.was pushing these First Iv heard of these He let me shoot his out back and was sold.After shooting a while realized I hated the grip I called it the Alligator it was very aggressive and pinched my palm when inserting Mags ended up getting rid of it and picking up an XDM series 3.8 45 Loved that thing Cerakoted it OD green shot the heck out of it then ended up trading that off as well you know how that goes kind of kick myself but it was a bit bulky and heavy.Years later picked up first generation mod 2 40 S&W wen .40 was popular down by the border I really like that the grip was much better but losing a little on the bald spots so I picked up Talon grips made it more better then traded that off for something else as well.Now this is years later ran across a guy wanted to trade me a Mod 2 XDS 45 Grey was looking for a sub in this cal.So traded 350 value on My end I feel really made out these are great fire arms and will be doing Vid Soon on a few Mods.and Range Time. Anyone know if they have come out with extended Mags for the .45 beyond 9rnds yet?
I own the XDS-9 Mod 1 and love it. There’s nothing about it I don’t like. I may buy the Mod-2 eventually just to own both but if I do buy the Mod-2 , it’s not because I do not like the Mod-1. They did great with these guns!
Low-effort Springfield outrage is everywhere. An antigun law is working it's way through Illinois legislative process, and Springfield's lobbyist defends Springfield's interests and gets a carve out for all gun manufacturers in Illinois. That sounds like a win. Yet people are outraged, why? Because they didn't continue to pay their lobbyist to fight for FFLs in Illinois? That is the only other thing that they could have done, and it definitely isn't their responsibility to pay expensive ass lobbyists for FFLs in Illinois.
The Angriest Puppy I also heard their lobbyist did something Springfield didn't go along with but didn't find out till it went public and when they found out fired them. Their CEO made a public apology but no one heard it. For those interested here is Springfield Armory story, watch it to the end. ua-cam.com/video/0ZZGFdcx3E0/v-deo.html
@@ckim6400 Yeah, that is 100% accurate. Despite their original actions of the lobbyist being justifiable in my mind, it would have been a public relations shit show if they didn't respond. So, they've been on a pro2A spree since then. They fired the lobbyist, and were one of the only manufacturers to stop selling to Dicks Sporting Goods when Dicks stopped selling to people ages 18 to 21, in addition to writing an open letter slamming Dicks Sporting Goods and Field and Stream.
I figure it’s Illinois. It’s heavily anti gun and if I were facing a losing battle and owned a business there, I too would try to save my company and employees. I’m not a Springfield fanboy. I’ve owned XD/XDM/XDS in the past but always sold or traded them off, but I can understand what’s it’s like getting backed into a corner and trying to salvage what you can.
Exactly. No one is holding the citizens of Illinois accountable for there anti gun laws. How is Springfield more at fault than the state of Illinois? 🤔
@@ckim6400 Look at the Springfield apologists. lol. Anything for the excuse huh? FYI the apology came later. As a stop gap measure after their sales tanked and the press release that they were unaware wasn't being bought by the public. The CEO knew full well what was going on. As for the "deal" what a crock. It was an exemption while screwing others. Far as I'm concerned those who think the actions of the lobbyists and Springfield were a win or justified are proof that you are nothing but a low down piece of crap fudd. Oh, and if the deal was so great? The only choice in a fight against bad legislation in an effort to save the company and whatnot. Then why did Springfield immediately relaunch effort to fight the same bill they agreed to stand down on once they were caught for selling out? Simple. And if you weren't some Springfield fanboys looking for an excuse you'd see it and have the balls to admitt it
I like my old XDS, but going forward, all companies will need to have a slim small grip P365 style or a full grip G43x. They will all fall into that range with at least 10 rounds of 9mm in a slim gun. Prior to the P365, the XDS was better in round count when compared to most other slim pistols. Many were only 6 +1 and they will sell for cheap very soon. Just need a couple more competitors to P365 and 43x.
I have the XDS 9. I enjoy shooting it. I don't carry it that much. Between my Vp9sk ,with the 13rd magazine and my Beretta APX compact. I see no reason to carry it anymore.
Just picked up the mod 2 osp fee weeks ago. Threw 150 rounds through it with no issues at all,, and for me.. the new grip safety didn't bother my hand one bit. Great pistol ran flawless and very comfortable in the hand. Great video, happy shooting!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸
The XDS Mod.2 in 9mm is the first Springfield pistol I've ever purchased, but I liked it so much a bought a second one. I got the gear up special on both, so with three free 8 round magazines for each gun it was a pretty good deal overall. I find the gun a great fit in the hand and it shoots very well with modest recoil for a small pistol. I've also found it to be totally reliable so far with no problems in either pistol. I do find the 7 round magazine with pinky extension to be poorly designed as it cramps my hand between the bottom of the extension and the trigger guard, but I prefer the eight round magazine anyway as I can get a full grip with those. A really solidly built, reliable gun that I would highly recommend for those looking for a small single stack 9mm.
Randy Giedrycz I have the XDS Mod. 2 but in .45 ACP. You’re right about what you wrote here. These guns are very comfortable in my hands and the recoil, though it’s more than a 9mm, is very manageable. I love the safety set up because pulling a gun to use in an emergency situation should be as free from confusion and anxiety as possible. Thus, not having a safety lever to flip down is a big plus. Instead, these guns have the very simple yet functional safety in the grip and the trigger. Pulling the gun in a fast emergency, one doesn’t have to remember to take the safety off. Instead they grip the gun and pull the trigger.
Same here. I bought the Mod 1 in 9MM and liked it so much I bought a Mod 2 in .40. Would have bought one in .45 but they were unavailable - and still are. I find myself carrying the 40 for EDC but like both of them very much.
The grip safety is a love \ hate thing with many shooters and I'm usually in the latter crowd. However, I have large hands and don't even notice it with either model. IMO, Springfield got it right.
I love how you say you hope we all have a good new year (looking back at 2020!)
I love that grip safety.
Purchased the model 1 before I knew the model 2 had came out after seeing your video I'm glad I have the model 1
I have the original XDS 3.3 in .45 A.C.P. The recall was for the grip safety. Apparently the grip safety caused issues with trigger not functioning properly allowing some guns to fire without being depressed. New internal changes and an extra roll pin was added. As to the change in grip safety design it was because people complained they couldn't tell or were concerned they were not depressing the safety because they couldn't feel it when they gripped the pistol. Wasn't a problem, people are weird and complain either way, I don't feel it, I don't like that I feel it-LOL. I prefer the old style grip safety. I just love a small .45! I sold my Detonics .45 which I regretted and wanted another small .45 A.C.P.
I bought the XDS mod 1 about 4 years ago and really liked it. Very ergonomic and a great shooter, but it was a bit heavy. I replaced it with the popular Sig P365 and it's great. I passed my XDS down to my brother who is newly licensed for his first gun. He likes it a lot better than the S&W 9mm Shield EZ that he ordered for his girlfriend. Although the Shield EZ was really made for new shooters, and people with less hand strength, he doesn't like the ergonomics, and is less accurate with the EZ. Even though the XDS is not the latest, it's still a very competitive well made accurate gun, and you can't go wrong with it.
I had an XDs 9 a few years ago. A lot of the guys I worked with were getting Glock 43s, so I sold my XDs & got the 43. I have to say, though I am a self proclaimed Glock fanboy, I liked the XDs better. IMO, the XDs has a crisper trigger break than the 43, though I believe it’s a tad heavier on the pull. The trigger is still very smooth. I have since sold the 43 as well. I am wanting to get another single stack & I keep getting drawn back to the XDs.
As always, great review. One of these days, I want to get my hands on a Steyer. The gun stores in my area do not have them in stock.
Followers never prosper.
Answered all of my questions. Nice review.
I feel like I'm watching the Hand from The Adam's Family....
Nick Unger LMFFBO!!!!
@@midnightRider8428 LMFFBO ? LOL what's that mean ?
@@Nick-sz6xb As soon as he said it I was watching the video and I was like dang. He means that mostly all you can see is a hand with no arm and the guy talks with his hands so much.
*Dun Dun Dun Dun* °•Snap•° °•Snap•°
I'm going to be honest I have a xds mod 2 9mm and YES I know it's a Springfield but it's one heck of a little shooter!! My wife carries it everywhere. I have fell back to carrying the G43 daily which I also really like. Both are very accurate and never a hiccup through either. Great video bro and God bless!!👍🇺🇸🇺🇸
Thanks and that's all I was trying to say in the video
I have a friend that owns the mod 1 and he is not gun knowable and when he tried fire it, nothing. He ask me to look at it. The first thing I noticed was the grip safety. Then I knew he wasn't activating the grip safety. I show that to him and he then starting shooting it after that, Great video!.
James Reeves from TFBTV is fond of saying we are in the golden age of conceal carry. It is great that we have so many options, including the little tank XDs. And even though the P365 has problems, Sig's innovation with the magazine alone on the 365 will have a big impact. Assuming we keep our rights, the future of conceal carry from a product choice standpoint is very bright.
I bought my daughter the XDS-9mm Mod 2 with a Crimson Trace Red Dot Laser Sight on it & she loves it. The only thing is the slide release was really hard to press down.
So after shooting about 100 rounds at the range I broke it down cleaned & oiled it pretty good. It's a little better, but I'm sure it'll get better the more she fires it.
I like her XDS-9mm so much I'm gonna get me one in a .45 ACP.
Great video & keep up the good work.
Fantastic comparison! Best wishes with the New Year! Love the mod2 grip zone texture. Not to crazy about the shape of the grip safety, although the XDS mod 2 in 45 cap has the old shape. I've asked them why the exchange up, they replied that it resembles ones on the 1911s.... oh well - they call it memory pad...Still I'm with you on that one. I'm sure there will be a aftermarket replacement soon.
The mod 2 grip safety works way better than the original it's easier to use and it's way more comfortable
I love my xds9 mod 1 never have had any trouble. I chose it over the mod 2 because the grips and sights. These are my favorite single stack 9mm I shot all the others and more compacts at my local range but was most accurate with this one.
I jus grabbed a brand new XDS i like the looks way better then the second one forsure. Love the way the xds looks an feels plus very reliable
Good info, I've used the XDs for my summer carry for several years now. It's a perfect fit for me, great texture grips,slim and F.O. sight and I shoot it well. Nice to see the comparison, so I don't get FOMO thanks for posting!
I just bought a brand new XDS mod 2 9mm, I’m very happy so far, and excellent for daily CC. Thanks for the information Sir.
Another good comparison, and quality show. I've yet to hold the Mod 2 XDS, but it looks very nice. However, I owned the original in all three calibers and was happy with them all. I just moved away from single stack pistols a few years ago. The only SS pistol I have now is my Walther PPQ in 22LR. :) Have a great weekend brother, Cheers!
I like the hands over the guns view point and the comments about Adams family; just so funny.
Can you refer me to an aftermarket gun site where I can try to locate a Springfield MOD one chambered and 45 ACP I’m looking for the XDS model
I'm new-ish to firearms so when I got interested in them, all I read about Springfield was about their politics so I never paid attention to them. Having said that, I did buy a 1911 Range Officer Elite in 9mm and really like it. I have never shot any of their polymer pistols. Thanks for the videos and the new format rocks. Happy New Year and cheers!
You do some great work on these reviews. The clarity in the videos is excellent. Happy New Year.
Happy New Year my good man. I have to admit i miss the music LOL. Some hate it and some love it. What matters here is that this was a great video and i look forward to what you have for us this year.
Peace be with you
thanks man I appreciate it
To be honest, I like the XD-S .45 ACP mod 2 for one reason. It allows me to carry easily with my shirt tucked in or when I’m wearing a suit. I prefer to carry my SIG P320 Compact in .45 ACP, but it’s nice to have a slim gun for different kinds of wear.
I had an XDS in 45 as several years ago, pre Springfield brain fart. It actually shot nice to be so small and chambered in that caliber.
I picked up a lightly used XDS-45 Mod 1 about a year ago. It’s been my favorite carry gun since. In my hand it has the best ergonomics and fit, it is reliable and accurate. I upgraded my sights to XS F8 sights and I love the setup on a combat pistol. I also got a great deal on a bunch of used magazines a guy offloaded at my local gun shop. I carry it 6+1 and a spare magazine.
I have several other pistols, but the XDS-45 is my favorite. My Shield Plus 9 is a close second and gets some carry time also, but this one feels and shoots better for me.
Thanks for this review. Rumors are I buy a lot of guns, but you know how rumors are. The first XD I shot was 45 and I thought I had a misfire because the recoil was hardly there. Since that time I found many of them in my hands. The XDs fits well in my posket, even with the extended 8 round mag + the chambered one (9 shots total). This review was great. I asked a gun selling store what the differences were and he was totally dumb. SO I made notes and now I know.
I got both of these guns, but the mod 1 I have it in 45 acp and mod 2 in 9mm love them both :)
very cool
@@1776orbust great video keep it up man!!!
@@Erick-cf6pm thanks
I love my XDS mod I, and it’s a perfect compliment to my Kel Tec 9mm rifle. While neither one is top of the line, I like that they both shoot 9mm and that the Kel Tec folds in order to fit in a back pack.
Just got my Springfield XDS mod 2 and I love it! However have smaller hands so I feel like the mod 2 works perfect! When I shot it at the range I had no problems with the back safety and it felt quite comfortable while I was shooting at the Target. In my opinion I love my XDS mod 2 and I think it's overall the better conceal and carry gun.
Will a mod 1 holster work on a mod 2? Looks like it should
I just purchased the Springfield XDS mod two and 45 ACP. Mine came with a six round magazine and a five round magazine. The only thing that this does not have is the indicator on the top for being loaded and cocked it does not have that. Also, I did not get The hard case or anything like that with mine. Mine just came in a simple box and I paid $475 out the door for mine.
What about barrel swaps? Will the mod2 barrel work in the mod1? Seems to be a shortage in mod1 barrels out there
Great video on both versions. I purchased a mod 2 and love it. It is my main carry gun. Then with the extra free items I received man was it worth it. Thanks for the video.
thanks for watching
I bought my XDS 45 mod 2 when it first came out about 3 1/2 years ago. And the cocking serrations are sharp, deep and crisp like the original. I switched out those sucky sights with a good set of Trijicon night sights and added it to my carry rotation. Next to my Sig P938 SAS it is the easiest to conceal EDC I own. Mine came in a zip up Nylon carry case with 4 mags and a funky kydex holster that I wouldn't consider using.
Excellent comparison!
Thanks
Nice review. It is interesting how all the firearms manufacturers are going into the single stack market, when I think of single stack I think 1911.
Its just thinner and prints less I think. More marketed to concealed carriers. I ooen carry mine alot though.
@@dthompsont3796 So true!
Great video. I thought I heard you say Ulster County NY. I live in Greene County but from Ulster.
The XDS mod 2 is the best single stack pistol I have ever purchased. It is extremely ergonomic, well balanced, and feels just right. It looks well built and points spot on. The u notch rear sight is a significant improvement and it is more well rounded compared to the first mod. The texture on the grip feels perfect. It is much less aggressive than the Taurus. The weight of the pistol is manageable and it doesn't weigh me down for concealed carry. I love the mod 2. I've had the mod 1 and I didn't care for it. The mod 2 is worth the trade. Call me crazy, but it is. Plus, I'm a Glock guy and I'll tell you the mod 2 is much more well built and refined compared to any Glock. It is worth the money.
Great video !
That ameri glo sight is wonderful
I’ve got the mod2 45acp and I like the grips better…I’ve got the 10mm in full size and I wished it had the mod2 style grips I may put Talen grips on the 10mm. Good video
Thanks for the comparison vid , thinking of pickin up the mod 2 when it becomes available in Massachusetts .
I just purchased the mod 2 with optics. So far I love the gun. Being in New York State the 7 round mag fits the law requirements perfectly. Love the grip safety feature when carrying.
What's the most you can have in NY? I love in TN so they're basically no gun restrictions here and I love it
@@D-A-1776 7 rounds in the gun while carrying is NYS law. Can have 10 while at the range
@@paulcorter1997 . Oh okay just didn't know. I know Cali and NY have some strict laws. I just saw where ny is trying to ban AR style guns
I love my xdm so I can’t wait to grab an xds. I would really like to see the xdm with the “grip zone”style stippling
They should make a Xdm mod 2 dont know when they will but I can feel that it will come out on the market one of these days
I want the xdm 3.8 compact.. its discontinued..uhg
My love XDS Mod1. Nearly 10,000rds without a single issue, and just decided to send it off Powder River Precision for some TLC.
Excellent review! ...love the Mod.2 and XDM lines :)
Are the grip safeties interchangeable?
Adam
My interest in the XDS was due to the exact same size gun came in 45. Firing the mod 1 would be described as a painful experience for the web of my hand. Thankfully that was remedied with the mod2. I almost never carry anything else.
Extended magazines are identical, just use appropriate sleeve for your application. You failed to mention the Mod 1 has changeable backstraps for a tailored fit to your hand. For most purchasers of these models, it is going to be how the coarse aggressive texturing of the Mod 1 feels in there hand, as opposed to the finer GripZone, of the Mod 2.
I've carried a XDS-9 for a couple years now and love that gun. I have no desire to upgrade to the Mod 2. I recently purchased a
Gen 5 - G26 and have been carrying that.
Which one shoots better
1776 thanks for the side by side I would never have guessed there would be so many slight differences and it is good to know that interchangeability is very limited between the 2 models.
thanks for watching I appreciate it
my mod2 9mm xds didn't come with an extractor spring... anyone can explain if it's normal or an error in manufacturing?
I bought the .45 ACP version of this model. It does the job but it's nothing to write home about so to speak. It conceals very well even in the Wright Leather Works OWB holster that I bought for it. At times I forget I have it on. The only draw back with it that concerns me, and it's only a minor issue, is it almost seems that it wasn't designed for .45 cal. I get the impression it's trying to tear itself apart. The 9mm is probably the better choice on this one.
Thanks for the info as nice comparison as I know they are good guns but all those safeties drive me nuts on those guns.....Good detailed info as I appreciate that....Good stuff....
I have the mod 2 in 45acp. I think they have improved the trigger on it from mod1. However, for my hands, I feel the size of the grip, front to back, is too wide. Also, the undercut on the trigger guard I do not find comfortable. But still the best cc gun for 45 cal in my opinion
I bought the XDS mod 1 in 9MM and liked it so much I bought a second in .40, but it's a Mod 2 and *IMO* the new grip sucks. Feel is subjective and I know many who feel the change was an improvement. I'm just not one of them.
Ergonomics are still great but the surface is on par with the Glock or Shield. However, they are still built like a tank and I like that.
For anyone on the fence about having a grip safety I'd say don't overlook the gun until you have held it. It's way better than any other I've held and I really don't even notice it.
Great job. Thanks!
I purchased a Smith and Wesson SD 9 a few years back and I really enjoy but I've been looking to purchase my second hand gun. Would the XD S be a good choice to add or should i go for the XD?
Depends what you want double stack vs single stack. I personally only have 1 carry single stack left which is the shield 4inch. Summer carry only but mostly I still carry double sracks
Both are good más I'll just stay with my mod 1 happily
Hi man, great videos.
I can't seem to find this information anywhere, can you check (if you have the opportunity of course) with which of the magazines (flush, pinky, 8 rds, 9 rds) does the Mod 2 fit into the IDPA BUG box? There is nowhere on the internet where I can find this information. I would like to buy one but in my country we (me) are not allowed to carry guns, so I can only use them for IDPA and range time. So I would like to buy one that I could use in the BUG division. Thanks.
OR ... to please measure exactly the height of the gun with the 4 options: flush magazine, pinky extension, 8 rounds, 9 rounds. The maximum allowed height for BUG division is 4.625 inches (or 4 5/8 inches)
The mod 2 seems like it has a slightly longer beaver tail. That alone should help with keeping your hand meat out of the slide.
I have a mod 2 9mm, does anyone know if I can use the first gen mags in my mod 2?
When they first came out, I owned both the M&P Shield as well as XDS-9. The Shield had a superior trigger release but I could shoot the XDS more accurately so I sold the Shield. I would love to handle and shoot the XDS mod2 to compare directly with my mod1 and upgrade or stay the course depending on outcome. Unfortunately, I called one of the area's largest handgun dealers with an indoor range and they don't have the mod2 in stock. And if they did, they wouldn't allow any comparison shooting on the range, although they do have a mod1 for range use. Bummer. Guess I stay with my mod1 for now.
Wow! Thats crazy my brother owned the shield a few years ago an i shot it an everything an i jus bought the XDS an to me its wayy better. Nicer appeal, nicer feel in hand. And i shoot it better never had a problem with either though just my opinion the xds is way more appealing an it handles very well so its currently my #1
The sear housings are different. If you look.closely on thenstriker safety side of the sear housing theres a small.hump above the rail
I have the mod 1 with 7 8 and 9 round mags fits my hand perfect and it is my favorite pistol !
How often they come outh with new models? Every 5 years? Like how long it took for mod 2 come out?
Ive used the xds mod 1 9mm as my edc for years now. I'm about to trade it in for the sig p365. Nothing against the xds I love it. At this point though I think the 365 is just an upgrade. It's fixed all it's problems at this point. And it holds 10+1
Xds had an issue with discharging upon racking the slide without pulling the trigger. At least that’s what some had claimed. I had one and never had an issue and I remember watching videos of people trying to replicate the issue but couldn’t.
In your opinion which Springfield is better in 40 cal??? XD40 or XDs mod 2 40. I just ordered the xds online. Hope I don't regret it over the xd40
Well one's better for carrying and hiding if you're buying it to be able to put inside your waistband I put it in your pants pocket or something like that the XDS definitely where to go that's the one you want
@@danielmcbride4828 Thanks man. Decided to go with both lol. XD40 was hard to find since it's a discontinued model. I shoot better with a double stack. Great gun/s regardless
Have any one , had a problem with the bullets failing to feed ?
I have both but I prefer the mod1 due to the grenade style Checkering and the heavier barrel. You get a bull barrel for free with the mod 1
You can’t be serious? I have both guns the barrels literally identical
D Man I have both mod 1 and mod 2 3.3 9mm xds pistols and the barrels side by side are identical. You think I don’t know what caliber I have 😂
D Man I’m not arguing with you I have both guns here in front of me and both barrels fit in both guns and slides the same
excellent video!
much appreciated
Pps m2 great gun
1776 have you gone to the new range in Kingston?
No their range rules are not very 2a positive
@@1776orbust I agree with that in regards to ar type firearms. But very loose rules with pistols. I went last weekend it's very nice
Idk about the rifle rules, it's only a 25 yard range!
Are the mags for mod 1 and mod 2 the same?
yes
If you switch out the sleeves will the mags be interchangeable? I had a XDs that was stolen and have 8 extra mags, but now I want the XDs Mod.2!
Yes
Love the mod 1, really considering the mod 2. In the hand it feels a lot better plus the mod 2 now comes OSP ready. Thinking it would be better option than the 26 and 365 I have. Neither of those feel as good in the hand.
Great review.
I just sent my new XDs 45 mod 2 back to Springfield today 9/2020. Turn around time is 4-6 weeks for repairs. The first box of ammo was Winchester white box 45 acp. After 50 rounds I had six. (6) failure to feed issues. I literally had to clear the jams with my pocket knife.
Whenever it’s returned I will sell it and go back to Glock or Sig for my EDC
Dremel the mod 1 sleeve slightly. Done
Awesome comparison video Sir. I love my XDM 9mm.
OH yes the Gen 1 XDS Remember wen they first came out great price point Big Hard case loaded with goodies.Very impressive the guy at the gun counter down in Tombstone AZ.was pushing these First Iv heard of these He let me shoot his out back and was sold.After shooting a while realized I hated the grip I called it the Alligator it was very aggressive and pinched my palm when inserting Mags ended up getting rid of it and picking up an XDM series 3.8 45 Loved that thing Cerakoted it OD green shot the heck out of it then ended up trading that off as well you know how that goes kind of kick myself but it was a bit bulky and heavy.Years later picked up first generation mod 2 40 S&W wen .40 was popular down by the border I really like that the grip was much better but losing a little on the bald spots so I picked up Talon grips made it more better then traded that off for something else as well.Now this is years later ran across a guy wanted to trade me a Mod 2 XDS 45 Grey was looking for a sub in this cal.So traded 350 value on My end I feel really made out these are great fire arms and will be doing Vid Soon on a few Mods.and Range Time. Anyone know if they have come out with extended Mags for the .45 beyond 9rnds yet?
GUN REVIEWS WITH SWAG!
I own the XDS-9 Mod 1 and love it. There’s nothing about it I don’t like. I may buy the Mod-2 eventually just to own both but if I do buy the Mod-2 , it’s not because I do not like the Mod-1. They did great with these guns!
Do they use the same holsters
2nd ??
@@TheSouthpawSharpshooter I have a mod 2.
MrLeewhite336 yeah I mean I’m curious too. But I did read somewhere today that the guns won’t fit in same holster.
@@TheSouthpawSharpshooter ok thanks
Low-effort Springfield outrage is everywhere. An antigun law is working it's way through Illinois legislative process, and Springfield's lobbyist defends Springfield's interests and gets a carve out for all gun manufacturers in Illinois. That sounds like a win. Yet people are outraged, why? Because they didn't continue to pay their lobbyist to fight for FFLs in Illinois? That is the only other thing that they could have done, and it definitely isn't their responsibility to pay expensive ass lobbyists for FFLs in Illinois.
The Angriest Puppy I also heard their lobbyist did something Springfield didn't go along with but didn't find out till it went public and when they found out fired them. Their CEO made a public apology but no one heard it. For those interested here is Springfield Armory story, watch it to the end. ua-cam.com/video/0ZZGFdcx3E0/v-deo.html
@@ckim6400 Yeah, that is 100% accurate. Despite their original actions of the lobbyist being justifiable in my mind, it would have been a public relations shit show if they didn't respond. So, they've been on a pro2A spree since then. They fired the lobbyist, and were one of the only manufacturers to stop selling to Dicks Sporting Goods when Dicks stopped selling to people ages 18 to 21, in addition to writing an open letter slamming Dicks Sporting Goods and Field and Stream.
I figure it’s Illinois. It’s heavily anti gun and if I were facing a losing battle and owned a business there, I too would try to save my company and employees. I’m not a Springfield fanboy. I’ve owned XD/XDM/XDS in the past but always sold or traded them off, but I can understand what’s it’s like getting backed into a corner and trying to salvage what you can.
Exactly. No one is holding the citizens of Illinois accountable for there anti gun laws. How is Springfield more at fault than the state of Illinois? 🤔
@@ckim6400 Look at the Springfield apologists. lol. Anything for the excuse huh? FYI the apology came later. As a stop gap measure after their sales tanked and the press release that they were unaware wasn't being bought by the public. The CEO knew full well what was going on. As for the "deal" what a crock. It was an exemption while screwing others. Far as I'm concerned those who think the actions of the lobbyists and Springfield were a win or justified are proof that you are nothing but a low down piece of crap fudd. Oh, and if the deal was so great? The only choice in a fight against bad legislation in an effort to save the company and whatnot. Then why did Springfield immediately relaunch effort to fight the same bill they agreed to stand down on once they were caught for selling out? Simple. And if you weren't some Springfield fanboys looking for an excuse you'd see it and have the balls to admitt it
I like my old XDS, but going forward, all companies will need to have a slim small grip P365 style or a full grip G43x. They will all fall into that range with at least 10 rounds of 9mm in a slim gun. Prior to the P365, the XDS was better in round count when compared to most other slim pistols. Many were only 6 +1 and they will sell for cheap very soon. Just need a couple more competitors to P365 and 43x.
I agree. I'm waiting for a 365 alternative without all the issues.
I just bought one but didn't realize the grip was so short.
Love the vid man! I just bought a Mod 2. Sub’d!
They said that the 1st Gen Xds was recalled.
I have the XDS 9. I enjoy shooting it. I don't carry it that much. Between my Vp9sk ,with the 13rd magazine and my Beretta APX compact. I see no reason to carry it anymore.
My EDC is the XDS Mod 2 in .45 caliber. 14 rounds and great and reliable handgun. Best one I've ever carried.
I can't believe how little the recoil on the mod 2 . Great gun
XDS mod2 9mm is actually smaller than the .45 the original was the same size with a barrel and mag change.
Wanted to hear about the XDs but listened about soft hands... 😮💨😆
Is the mod2 that much better than my old mod1?
Ergonomically I think so
@@1776orbust now I need one. Or a p365
Good comparison.
Mod 2 can fit on mod 1 kydex holster