What Is Palestine? Who Are The Palestinians?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лис 2019
- Israel - History
In this Video you will find out about
Thank you for watching this video on everything related to Judaism history, and teachings of our Rabbis.
Please connect with us through our social media channels:
Twitter: @KosherTube
Instagram: @KosherTube
Facebook: @KosherTube
on Wed Jul 19 05:28:06 EDT 2017
Imagine what could have been achieved, if they were able to work together, have shared ownership of the land and resources, respect each other's rights and religions, and bring peace and prosperity to its citizens instead of continuous conflicts.
This comment should have hundreds of likes!
Share your home with someone who has been killing you for 70 years and claiming otherwise
@@nadashaker6037 I believe that Israel is currently committing genocide in Gaza, unforgivably. But Hamas, all militant groups, all those Muslims who call for jihad, who threaten to convert all infidels, are doing immense harm to the Palestinians. I understand anger, powerlessness, despair, after everything that happened in Iraq, Libya, Syria... I live in a country where 90% are Christians and people are afraid of that aggressive, militant Islam. Before, people from Libya, Egypt, and Syria used to come to study here. Some stayed, some returned to their countries. They were well received. Today, people are afraid of migrants. The above comment about peaceful coexistence seems impossible and idealistic and should actually be normal in the 21st century.
@@mirjanamitrovic9096 If you know Arab countries that are not only Arabs, there are Kurds and othersAnd different religionsFirst, the Arab peoples want Jews of Middle Eastern origin to return to their sources. But most of them call themselves the people of ancient Palestine on non-scientific grounds and a history based on the Holy Books.
@@nadashaker6037 The Kurdish story is also a tragedy, but no one talks about them, no one creates a state for them and no one defends them. I don't believe in holy books. I do not believe that God has revealed himself to anyone, chosen any people, or ordered any people to kill those who do not believe in him. God is ineffable, indescribable and everyone must develop their own personal relationship with him. The former Prime Minister of Israel Benett legitimized the Jewish right to the territory of Palestine with references from the Bible. It's out of my mind.
I wish more people would visit UA-cam sites such as this one. History is important. Thank you so much for this video. It was short but to the point.
@@Nclk619Really?..... Would please tell me what in this video's information was inaccurate.
@@andrewmiller4885 its a long video, and it would take a lot of references which you wouldnt have time to go through. it cherry picks quotes to fit a narrative that is false and misleadig at its root, things like it was sparsely populated and mostly barren. to make it sound as though european jews arrived in an empty space and made it viable, then the arabs got jealous. what actually happened was a peaceful land where arabs jews and christians lived peacefully, was targeted by a movement to rebuild the state of israel. which obviously sounds ok, but the movement always intended to take all the land, so when land owners far away sold the land from under the farmers whod lived there for hundreds of years, the ottomans ruled for 600 years i think? anyway, under ottoman rule there was no name for a nation, it did however contain people, think the ottomans called it syria, the point is, the name is not important, it was a place, people lived in that place, a small number by modern standards but a very normal number by the standards of the time. so when foreign jews started arriving and were backed by foreign jewish money, they always had a plan to make a jewish state. the colonial mentality of the time makes this a bit less crazy than it seems to our modern ears, nations were being declared all over the middle east, so european jews thought it was just a matter of numbers and they could declare a state. the arabs and even the jews who lived there did not like the idea of foreigners coming and creating a new state, who would? but, the arabs were weak both as a social organisation and militarily. muslims remained the majority of the population even with zionist movement getting more popular, not wildly popular, jews from other arab nations werent interested in moving to israel, the middle east did not suffer from antisemitism, really only the west and russia who suffered from that. zionists began meeting with other states to try and get jews to move to israel. a lot came from europe but not so much from neighbouring countries. zionists made efforts to persuade countries to make life more difficult for jews so they would come to palestine and add to their numbers, i've even heard that zionists bombed a synagogue in iraq to scare jews into leaving. but thats the picture i want to paint, zionism backed by western money always intending to take all of palestine, in fact british documents show britain was promising zionists all of palestine and some of jordan to the zionists in secret, while at the same time pretending to palestinians there would be one non jewish state of palestine. as the truth became clear anger grew among the arabs. britain didnt create an arab state, and the zionists who already had militias again backed by western jews money, became more open about claiming the land as their own less than 30 years after zionism started. they were still completely outnumbered but much better armed, made up of russian and european jews who fought in wars before arriving there. can i recommend two jewish men who have spoken out against zionism, they can give you a much bigger view than i can here. ilan pappe and gabor mate.
In my opinion the FACTS are that there is ALOT of RACISM and SUPREMACY in the Jewish government and in Jewish special interest groups🤮🤢👹💩 Also...there are WAY TOO MANY RACIST JEWISH SUPREMACISTS AND JEWISH RACISTS AND JEWS WHO SUPPORT JEWISH RACISM AND JEWISH SUPREMACY IN THE WORLD😡
@@andrewmiller4885 They never identify the inaccuracies because there are none. I have tried to find "History of Palestine" timelines, but so far no luck.
@@KelliAnnWinkler Agree with you. there were no errors in this15 minute documentary It was short but absolutely accurate. People just throw all sorts of silly comments out there, and while I'm interested in everyone's opinion, I expect their opinion to have some validity. He didn't answer because he had none.
I'm afraid you will not find a Palestinian timeline. There isn't one.
There has never been a Palestinian nation or state. They were never an ancient people that lived in the land known as Israel today. The term "Palestinian People" in terms of historical timelines is a recent construct.
Thank you for your response.
The British carved up Palestine by giving 80% of its UN mandate to Jordan (Transjordan at the time) in 1921. The people living there at the time were, by definition, Palestinians. It didn't include the holy sites of Jerusalem etc but it was a fair-sized homeland. Interesting that when five Arab countries invaded Israel and Palestine in 1948, Jordan avoided Jewish land, kept to its treaty with Israel and seized only the West Bank which it annexed (East Jerusalem too but that was international territory so did not break the treaty). Egypt occupied, but did not annex, the Gaza Strip. So Arab countries controlled the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the next 20 years and did nothing to solve the Palestinian crisis. Go figure.
And true to form, now will not allow Palestinian refugees safe haven in their countries.
Jordan never respected anything Jewish. They didn't gain more land because they were stopped. They declared they'd throw the Jews in the sea but they failed. They never had any treaty with Israel in 1948. Where did you dream this up?
@@victorblock3421 Jordan invaded - and annzed the West Bank which was one of their two main goals. They fought Israel over Jerusalem but that was agreed too. I'm not saying Jordan was being particularly magnanimous but they wanted the West Bank more they wanted to annihilate Israel and they shared Jerusalem. Egypot occupied the Gaza Strip. So what. The rest got nothing. The fact Israel could concentrate on only (!) four enemies might have made the difference.
The sad part is those who need to see this the most will never give the time of day. Never-the-less thank you for all your work and a fine presentation.
😅So true. All these people whose knowledge comes from TikTok and were home schooled by irrational parents with grudges against mainstream society, they don't have a clue.
One of the very best videos I have ever heard in breaking down the origins of the term ‘Palestine’
Well, as per true history 3150 years back King David(Jewish King) built Jerusalem as his capital and holy city for Jews That time there was not even Palestine word existed, no Christianity existed, No Islam existed.
@@lynx777 why cuz he using facts?
There is no historical nor archeological evidence for a great kingdom of David or Solomon.
Great kings go to war with neighbours or form treaties, leave monuments, tablets, writings, stamps, drawings etc etc.
The Bible and The Quran are books of fairy tales that caused and still causes so much destruction around the world.
@@doyouknoworjustbelieve6694 theres both archeological and physical object from those times in SEVERAL museums in Israel.
Why u clowns are always so sure about the bs u spittin tho?
We believe in Prophet David so what are you on about? This isn't some religious conflict dummy.
@@zocon6Triggered?
Great Stuff, Thanks!!
I am a Palestinian I was born and raised in Hebron my grandfather was born and lived in hebron, my great great great grandfather was born and lived also in hebron. I don't know who is my ancestor before 2000 years and I can't possibly find out.
However let my ask you a question if you someone knocked on your house door and asked you to leave because his ancestors were here 2000 years ago what would you think of him.
Assuming if thats true since many many civilization occupied this land from the romans, Persian, macdonians, mongols,...., etc
That people of Judah and samaria are the ancestors of the Israeli people who are diverse such as French jews Russian jews Ethiopian jews (who most of them can't speak hebrew and I can have a bigger chance of jewish more than them),.....,etc how is that biologically possible for these guys to have the same ancestors?
One more thing
Ask any Israeli where was his grandfather was born
He will say in his american or Russian or europian or african accents Not from here
You fool, do you not know what diaspora means?! We came back to our homeland, which was occupied many times under different rulings and of course Jews stayed here while most were exiled. We have a right here, we will stay in our homeland forever. Am Israel chai 🇮🇱
Actually your great-great-great-greatfather came from Saudi Arabia.
@@Shani.m. Middle Eastern Muslims and Christians, and North African Muslims frequently share the same ancestry as ME Jews. A person’s religion, culture, name, clothes, language etc may change but DNA is the same.
@@Andre.felipe84DNA doesn’t lie. Middle Eastern Muslims and Christians, and North African Muslims often share the same ancestry as ME Jews. DNA ancestry videos on YT will prove my point. Therefore, a person’s religion, culture, name, clothes, language etc may change but DNA is the same.
I have more questions about this video and its intent. It tried to show that there is no such a thing as a Palestinian, but trying to prove the Jews are the only true heirs of Judea. They didn't evict Muslims, Jews simply bought the land from greedy Arab land owners. Not buying this one bit. Best to do your own research on this topic. He can quote and he can quote...best to do your own research. Take Pravda with a grain of salt.
is there a part 2 to this? This was good and i was waiting for you to carry on 😮
Such a great History Lesson and I learned so much about this everyday question about the area and it reinforces the fact that The Jews didn't steal any land from the so called Palestinians and why Netanyahu says The Palestinians are Hamas also. Thanks for giving us the lesson and I'm glad to be a new subscriber~!!
🤡
Nice video. Right.
Actually, Israeli sovereignty over Judea and Samaria is enshrined into international law.
The notion that there is any moral equivalence between Jews building homes in their homeland that they won back in a defensive war (after it was illegally occupied by Jordan) and brutal terrorists illegally occupying land that was never given to them, is reprehensible.
But first, a brief history lesson …
The only binding resolution of international law, a resolution which has never been countermanded to this very day, is the July 1922 Mandate for Palestine.
Adopted by the League of Nations, that resolution recognized the “historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine and to the grounds for reconstituting their national home in that country.”
It called for the creation of a Jewish national homeland anywhere west of the Jordan River.
Once the League of Nations was disbanded and the United Nations formed in its stead, the international community agreed to maintain all agreements and not “alter in any manner the rights whatsoever of any states or any peoples or the terms of existing international instruments to which Members of the United Nations may respectively be parties.” [Article 80, UN Charter, emphasis added]
This provision wasn’t inserted by accident; it was known as “the Jewish People’s clause” at the time it was adopted in 1945 in order to enshrine the 1922 Mandate into international law.
The Mandate for Palestine adopted by the League of Nations was the last legally binding document delineating regional borders.
In Article 5 of the Mandate it explicitly states “The Mandatory shall be responsible for seeing that no Palestine territory shall be ceded or leased to, or in any way placed under the control of the Government of any foreign Power.”
The Palestine Mandate (and Iraq) was given to Britain to serve as a temporary trustee based on the resolution between the four principle Allied Powers in April 1920 at the San Remo Conference in Italy, which was signed by 51 nations.
It was at that conference where the world powers adopted the 1917 Balfour Declaration (which originally allocated the eastern part of the Mandate for a Jewish state as well) creating a Jewish state.
This same conference that created the Jewish state west of the Jordan River also created Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and Iraq as Arab states.
The legality of the 1922 Mandate was adopted that same year by the U.S. Congress in H.J. Res. 360 and signed by President Warren Harding.
The newly created Arab country of Jordan attacked Israel in 1948 seeking to annihilate its inhabitants and illegally occupied Judea and Samaria until 1967.
That year, Israel won back the territory originally allocated for a Jewish State as part of the 1922 League of Nations agreement.
There is no such thing as “’pre-67 borders.” They were merely 1949 armistice lines between Israel and neighboring countries after they launched an illegal war of extermination.
It has nothing to do with the notion of a unique Arab “Palestinian” entity west of the Jordan River.
There was never any internationally recognized legal sovereign occupying Judea and Samaria from the time the British Empire fell until 1967.
Jordan’s occupation of the area west of the Jordan River was never recognized.
To the extent there is an Arab Palestinian state it is the modern state of Jordan, which already sucked up 77% of the original Mandate of Palestine allocated for a Jewish State under the first plan of the Balfour Declaration.
By: Daniel Horowitz, December 27, 2016
Brilliant response.
Informative, thank you
Very concise and clear. Definitive proof that Arabs don't know their arse from their elbow.
Keep dreaming. Nothing is enshrined into international law, when Israel itself doesn't recognize that same law. And they don't. If Israel did, they would have had to grant civic/legal rights, private property rights and citizenship to the indigenous civilian population that live/lived on the land when it was conquered. They do not and they will not.
I do not understand the history enough to say … but I am trying to understand. It’s so sad to me that the most atrocious crimes occur on what is called “holy land”.
There is nothing holy about it, it’s just a land with a history full of holes
"Holy Wars" are because in Revelation, it says there is war in heaven with the sins of man by force reaching into heaven.
@@avalosalex1993 "Holy" means separated for God, or set apart for service. The land of Israel, if you can receive it, is separated, or set apart for service in that God has ordained that the Jews have their homeland restored to them in part.
Full of ass wholes =holy
God took the territory away from them in 70 CE by the hand of the Romans, prior to this though, the Covenant that was made with them via Moses was fulfilled some 37 years prior, this was foretold by Jerimiah with the writings regarding a new covenant with Israel and Judah that was to be not the same as the one that was made with their forefathers. Any physical representation of Israel or Judah was finished with at the commencement of the new covenant, consequently there is no need for a physical "homeland" anywhere on the planet! Ask yourself, as no one seems to do; Why did God have Jerusalem and its temple destroyed, the inhabitants en masse slaughtered to the point of almost extermination, with the remainder expelled to the nations if he was going to keep them as his people in perpetuity? @@ralphowen3367
Thank you so very much for this concise, succinct video.
History is important. This History should be broadcast by the American News Media and on every Social Media platform.
😎🙂A DNA TEST WAS MADE AND IT SAID THAT THE MODERN DAY JEWS ARE NOT EVEN GENITICALLY FROM ISREAL!!!...ISREAL WAS SIEZED BECAUSE OF A ZIONIST MOVEMENT💩🤢🤮😡
Very informative vlog and video 👍,
Wow!!!
The statement by the PLO is just soo concerning. How ill-fated modern Arabs fail to learn their own history
KosherTube Thank you for posting this.
Italian historian
Excellent video
Thank you. Brilliant.
According to the Quran, Allah liberated the Israélites from Egypt "and gave them the land to them in posession even to the last day when they will return to the Land"
Surah 17:100-104
In the Quran, the Israelites were cursed for not appreciating the help that they got and for betraying GOD Almighty after they were saved and in the Quran it says that the holy land was blessed for everyone and it will be inherited eventually, by the good righteous people and this promise was and is not fulfilled yet and so please DO NOT take things out of context in order to change the meaning of things please DO NOT try to change the meaning of everything because the Palestinians have suffered a lot for too long by the Jewish Zionist movement and the traitors who help them and so we do not need to try to justify all the evil that was carried out by the Zionist movement by taking things out of context and by mixing things up alright?
@@mohammedsaad6872
Show me a "palestine" mail stamp from 1930...or 1910...or maybe a coin???
In 1932 they were 9000 arabs in Israel...in 1946 they were 200,000. They came for jobs. That's all. They never existed before . NEVER.
All arabs migrate for jobs.
..and they don't know the Quran....A book that says the Sun goes to sleep every night in a pond of mud....where people lives...!
@@Tony-rf1vo Sorry to say but this problem will only be settled through an epic world war 3 with nuclear and hydrogen bombs now world wars 1 and 2 their results were in the favour of the Zionist Jewish movement but hopefully the next epic world war 3 shall exterminate the Zionist Jewish movement because there is no more space and no more room for useless talk and I mean that in the nicest possible way.
@@mohammedsaad6872
''The People of the Book''.....wrote Muhammad.
First meaning:
There's only one people of The Book. Only one.!...and it's not you.
Second meaning:
There's only one The Book: Only One.....and it's not yours.
Note:
I am not reading anymore your jihadist comments.
@@mohammedsaad6872 Of your don't that you said not to do, you might apply one to yourself: Don't tell just half of the story of the Lord God letting the Jews go for their unfaithfulness. He also promises in the scriptures that He will cause them to return to their original blessings as the elect of God after they learn their lessons.
Imagine the wealth and prosperity that could be blessed on both sides if they worked together and quit fighting...🤔
Exactly man! Human stupidity:(
Wealth and prosperity like apartheid South Africa
You need to study the jewish history and the conflict in order to under why this can never happen
@@2times347 The jews should study world history in order to understand why it is a good idea.
@@MrRoyalbeers it's not a good ideal. The Palestinian are not looking for peace they looking for the termination of the State of Israel and the Jewish people.
Interesting
The term Palestinian was invented in the 60's by Jasser Arafat
I am thankful for your post. This is exactly what I signed into here. but I will keep looking into it but this was a great start
If we all read the bible well we see that God gave Abraham the land for his generation to so the Lind rightfully belongs to the Israelites y they are suffering read the bible they turn away from God and bigin to worship idols and live away from God promise that's why they are in this position to day allover the world but God Christ promise them that one day he's going to put them to there rightful land
@@carolsmith9381
did the prophet Isiah tell the Jews that God will force them out of the land?
The Jews are the same Israelites so they are God chosen they were one in slavery in Egypt under bandage by pharo leadership if we all read the bible starting from gennises right back then we will firmly know why God loves the Israelites so much
The Jews are the same Israelites
@@carolsmith9381 fuck you and your fairytales
Theodore herzl invented Zionism and herzl said it is a EUROPEAN COLONIAL PROJECT
you are a European NOT a semite
The truth is we are all brothers and sisters. Hatred is from the evil one.
That's besides the point. First the truth...then your finding.
No one is interested in unity. Both sides are interested in war.
Amen ♡
This war between all of us in the world started from Kane and Amel, so we will fight each other until God himself comes down to earth.
@@mavisradebe5334 No...evil shall devour evil. The Holy One Of Israel is not part of that vain ideology.
Where is chapter two of the tape? Thank you
Thank you for the video please make more if possible!
Excellent video
Thanks
Great history. I wish more young people can see this and understand history of Israelis and their homeland
I have never heard this information before
This channel has a great "erase undesired comments" team...
If your neighbor comes to take your house and has it's own will you live in peace with him.please this is common sense, Arabs should settle in their lands and let the Jews keep theirs...the land belongs to the Jews...unless you want to rewrite history...the prophet Muhammad met Jews living in Jerusalem...so stop your ignorance,the world knows the truth but want to twist it to flavour the Arabs.
@@luberry342 The world knows the truth. Arabs have been living continuously, without break for more than a thousand years in Palestine. Ancient history where tribes and kingdoms pillaged and conquered each other at will , before history ran its course and settled on a contiguous steady narrative cannot be used as the basis for claims to any land! European Jew settlers started arriving only at the turn of the 20th century. And the modern man's memory is teeming and alive with the injustice that followed as the Zionist state took shape.
Butthurt much?
@@arifabd Uneducated taqiyya boy, Allah is a zionist, the quran says in surah 5 and 7 that the children of israel will return to their land and stay there. Plus, it is proven that jews have lived in what is today`s Israel for 3500 yrs, while the cult came into existance only 1400 yrs ago.
@@arifabd That's untrue. Jews have been living continuously for over three thousand years. Most of the Arabs came in during the British Mandate, and have been there less than a hundred years. The only injustice is, the Brits kept Jews out of their land, while bringing in countless Arabs. Then, they used the Arab population, that they had built up, as a rationale for tearing 70% of Jewish homeland off of Israel, and giving it to the colonizing Arabs to form Jordan.
Thank you for sharing this video. Very informative
The Palestinians have been defeated by Western powers, British & Americans. Itzhak Rabin was a terrorist of the Stern group against the British who later became Prime Minister.
This is Jewish Propaganda. Jews were 5% to 10% of invthe 1880's with the others being made up of Christians, Muslims & Arabs. This video is a simplification of a complex history...
Judaism is a religion, not a race
How do you become a Jew? Just marry a Jewish woman and you will become a Jew and your children will become Jews. How are they racing? Genetics says that race is limited by a man having xy and a woman having xx, and race depends on y.
Quran:17:104.... states" and We said thereafter to the Children of Israel, Dwell securely in the Promised Land" how many Islamic followers know this?
Just a few, who can read, their holy leaders tell them the"only truth"...
The quran is false your religion came 600 years later after christianity.
I do but it's not what you're trying to imply. Don't speak of my religion if you don't understand the context of the meaning
I like this
There were people living in that region before the Arabs arrived. No one ever talks about nor do they mention this.
Before it is called Meggido.
And neither did you.
Palestinians have more cannaniet dna
If Palestine shake hand with Israel, honestly,, there will be prosperity for both nation's.If terrorism is a business for some leaders and groups become tools of others , then, poor civilians will suffer.
The very first step would have to be getting completely rid of Hamas. Hamas are useing ordinary Palestinian folk for their own goals and mainly sponsored by IRAN who does not care one bit about Palestinians,
Taliban did it with the U.S., as they trained many of the fighters.
When has the Hawk, Netanyahu, ever made a peace proposal? For the record this Hamas attack happened on his watch. What a failure of leadership. But he will redeem himself from his failure by unleashing grave vengeance upon the Palestinians.
That's like saying the indigenous people of america should have let the american take their lands peacfully and live under their rule. There is no way in hell any people let's an outsider come and tell them to give up their land and be subjugated to their inhumanity.
@@fallasleep9472 great analogy. I only can wonder why so many feel that the Israelis are wronged. They are the victims. This is a case where you just throw up you hands and say, I give up. Or just simply ignore that type of intellect. There's no hope for that crowd.
Isrselis may have historic links with Isrsel just like Arabs can have hisotric links with UN defined Palestine but
links are not roots
Which makes both parties equal residents .
Well done video, thank you very much! God bless Israel! 🇮🇱🖖
This is an excellent video presentation.
Cheap Ziopropaganda.
Well, this will never see the light of a Harvard Day.
Yes it wil. The Zionist donors got rid of the Schwarza
wow
The ancient Philistines, originally a Sea People from Crete called Peleshet, worshiped a Merman fish god, half fish half man (named dagon). They ceased to exist during the Assyrian Conquest around 650 bce.
Ceased to exist like ancient egyptian??
What a hillarious
@@baikorg No. Ancient Egypt's influence declined but the country has remained until today and the people-group called "egyptians" remains. There is a single thread of history which connects ancient to modern egypt (just as there is for ancient and modern israel). The Philistines, on the other hand, ceased to exist as a separate people-group millennia ago, much as did the moabites, hittites, canaanites, girgashites etc etc. Those individuals who were not annihilated by one conquering army or another would have intermarried and been absorbed into other people groups, notably the modern-day Arab peoples. In fact, this is not a hillarious at all.
Bull Shit!
@@cosmincasuta486: swearing is not an argument. Unless you can counter one argument with another reasoned out refutation of whatever you disagree with, then your words belong in a playground
You are right they are seaside settler along Mediterranean, hence the Jews was in 🇪🇬 Egypt the Philistines occupied Gaza, They dont have a land on their owned, Israel was given to Israelite by God. Thats why they reclaimed it back.
John 3:16-18
Yeshua loves you
Fuck any God that supports killing innocent civilians by the thousands.
Oh sure, I'd believe anything said about Palestine on something called KosherTube. Right.
🤣
Kosher Tube says it all really.....
Thou shall not kill.
Wolves in sheep's clothing.
who are the wolves?
@Barry Allen No the Romans & their descendants did! WHY change who the BIBLE said he was?
Great video, great format, very informative.
This video is nothing but shameless propaganda going from one lie to another. The name Palestine was known yet to ancient historian Herodotus, centuries before the Romans formed a province with that name. The Philistines - Phoenicians weren't extinct by then, even the Canaanites were still around in Christ's time. They lived mostly along the coast while the Hebrews dwelled in the inland hills. Half of Jews were living in the diaspora by the time of Jesus and the rest could have continued living there even after wars and prohibitions. The Samarians hung on. But the Jews decided that life in Israel was too difficult (forget the milk and honey tale) whereas living off of others through trading and monopolizing certain trades was more lucrative. There was a constant non-Jewish native population in Palestine through history, this is attested to in travelogues to the Holy Land and biographies of native saints. They were not imported Greeks. For 19 centuries Jews stayed away save for small groups that never numbered more than 10 thousand. By 1800 there were a half million inhabitants in Palestine - Muslims and a large number of Christians. In fact the video hides that at some point in the 1800s there were more Christians in Jerusalem than Muslims with Jews far far fewer. Jews were not persecuted by the Romans for fictitious support of the poor. Only in Jerusalem were they the subject of Roman wrath for rebellion. In fact even then many writers wrote poorly of them for their dishonest transactions and exploitation of the poor. Palestinians didn't have a strong separate identity until modern times similarly to most Middle East groups since the Ottoman Empire suppressed such with Muslim identity being supreme. A Palestinian government with that name was formed yet in the 1940s but was disbanded by Jordan and Egypt. Jews started to return when farm machines appeared as a result of the industrial revolution in agriculture. It's a fat lie that most of the land had been sold to Jews by 1948 - it was less than 5 percent. The destruction of hundreds of Palestinian villages, mosques (many were turned into theaters or clubs), farms, is a testament to the enormous injustice Palestinians have suffered even though the Zionists had committed themselves in the Balfour Declaration to do nothing that would infringe on the rights of the Palestinians. The list of violations they have since committed is very lengthy. The lies promoted here can be debunked easily by doing some research even though Israeli propaganda and a Soros funded group have purged websites like Wikipedia.
The answer is all in the Bible.. Beyond that, everything are just a self thought and research to prove their thinking, and is in vain..
To Love one another is a comandment not just spirituality, but by nature of man, one must do in order to make a more acceptable behavior of being different trom animals..
The key to a long lost paradise we are searching for, is to "Love one another". To break the difference and open up each hearts to feed the hungry to help the homeless and care for whos in sick and to respect each other, love the nature who's GOD created for us..
Then, there we will be in Paradise.
The Israelis, have lived in the area for over three thousand years.
What's the name of this methodology movie?
Thanks for the history lesson, l have always wondered about this. 😊
There's very little history or fact in this video...
@@Paul-fm4iz It's all FACTS you lying snake!
I have a lot of things to sell to you since you believe that you were given a history lesson.
@@Paul-fm4iz That's what sheeple would think
Bf
This was a Great Video.. If you Blind!!!!
😎🎥😎🎥😎🎥😎🎥😎🎥😎
Great video! This clears up a lot of misconceptions.
Lies
3:49 he said that because at the time before 1948 ''Palestinian'' meant ''Jew'',
& no one would dare call an Arab living there a ''Palestinian'', which would gain the caller a slit throat pronto.
Yes. That's true. I've been told the same thing by Yerushalmim, can trace their family's history in Jerusalem, to prior to the Ottoman Empire.
Not true at all. The Arabs of Palestine identified as Palestinian. They travelled with Palestinian passports. They were no more or no less Palestinian as the Arabs of Lebanon transitioned from calling themselves Syrians to Lebanese. And it was not a problem because the Ottoman province for that territory was called Palestine. It was a widely used term and not at all used by Jews until after they immigrated into Palestine from Europe. The Jews did not arrive to the land as Palestinians. They immigrated into the land of Palestine. So let's stop all of the lying shall we?
@@mtolives no they had Palestinian passports because the area was ruled by the ottomans and then the British, who referred to the region by that name.
So let's watch the actual video before making comments, shall we?
@@mtolives A great example of the taking of a single fact out of its historical context in order to support an incorrect proposition.
@@shlogoff - Are you claiming that this territory was not commonly called Palestine prior to the British Mandate?
*Don't forget the Jewish refugees from World War II came on a boat to Palestine. The Palestinians accepted them.*
Many of them forgot once get on shore.
Don't forget that there have ALWAYS been Jews in every area that are now known as Gaza, the West Bank, Israel, Jerusalem,, etc. Many came back after WWII, but many had never left.
@@beacarr9652 Don't forget that us Jews were scattered all over the world, but had no right to take land from the Palestinians, it is forbidden in the Torah.
There is historical evidence, landmarks and sites. The Tora, the Bible, even the quran, yet many insist on calling the state of Israel an occupation of palestine. Ignorance is willful denial of truth, whatever the motivation.
I am neither Jewish nor Palestinian so I can see both sides, unfortunately I can also see there is no compromise 😔
I feel the same. Only Mother Nature can clear this up.
And still a huge part of the story missing.
How can you compromise with an immovable ideology that commands you have no right to exist?
Nobody is a Palestinian
@@MrLennybach isreal? notreal.
Thank you very much for this honest and clear statement that you published three years ago, that without any shadow of a doubt clearly states that there is no such thing as Palestine, and there are no such thing as Palestinians certainly not as an ethnic or community group that existed before at the very earliest the same time that Jewish people started returning to Judea.
The father of Zionism, Theodor Herzl, who fought for the establishment of a Jewish state, which included Argentina as an alternative, had a different vision from what has been happening until now, as he died before the state was being established. Please read the following excerpt from Wikipedia and imagine how he would have resolved the current conflict or avoided it in the first place:
In Altneuland, Herzl outlined his vision for a new Jewish state in the Land of Israel. He summed up his vision of an open society:
"It is founded on the ideas which are a common product of all civilized nations ... It would be immoral if we would exclude anyone, whatever his origin, his descent, or his religion, from participating in our achievements. For we stand on the shoulders of other civilized peoples ... What we own we owe to the preparatory work of other peoples. Therefore, we have to repay our debt. There is only one way to do it, the highest tolerance. Our motto must therefore be, now and ever: 'Man, you are my brother.'"[94]
"If you will it, it is no dream." a phrase from Herzl's book Old New Land, became a popular slogan of the Zionist movement-the striving for a Jewish National Home in Israel.[95]
In his novel, Herzl wrote about an electoral campaign in the new state. He directed his wrath against the nationalist party, which wished to make the Jews a privileged class in Israel. Herzl regarded that as a betrayal of Zion, for Zion was identical to him with humanitarianism and tolerance-and that this was true in politics as well as religion. Herzl wrote:
"Matters of faith were once and for all excluded from public influence ... Whether anyone sought religious devotion in the synagogue, in the church, in the mosque, in the art museum, or in a philharmonic concert, did not concern society. That was his [own] private affair."[94]
Altneuland was written both for Jews and non-Jews: Herzl wanted to win over non-Jewish opinion for Zionism.[96] When he was still thinking of Argentina as a possible venue for massive Jewish immigration, he wrote in his diary:
"When we occupy the land, we shall bring immediate benefits to the state that receives us. We must expropriate gently the private property on the estates assigned to us. We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our country. The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discretely and circumspectly ... It goes without saying that we shall respectfully tolerate persons of other faiths and protect their property, their honor, and their freedom with the harshest means of coercion. This is another area in which we shall set the entire world a wonderful example ... Should there be many such immovable owners in individual areas [who would not sell their property to us], we shall simply leave them there and develop our commerce in the direction of other areas which belong to us",[97]
I'm sure he did not foresee the people who claim to be heirs to the land refusing to admit the right of Israel to exist as a nation.
Israel belongs to the Jews. If the "Palestinians" would concede the right of Israel to even exist, things would be much different in Israel today.
@@BLFulle Do Palestinians have the right not to be bombed?
@@BLFulle اجل ولكن لن نتنازل عنها لو ابتلت الارض بدمائنا
فلسطين 🇵🇸 هي اصل البلاد لنا ولن نقبل بغيرها ولن نرضى الذل ولا المهانه
لا طعم للحياه بدون فلسطين وستكون حره بإذن الله الواحد الاحد يوما ما ❤️
واسرائيل هي دوله محتله وتمارس ضغوطًا ضد الشعب الفلسطينى بعد ما جعلوهم من افقر الشعوب
@@user-ex7dr1gj8n Israel has and always will belong to the Jews because God has given it to them. . It was prophesied in the Bible by Jesus. That will never change.
@@BLFulle British gave you opportunity to create a settler colonial state called Israel. If Britiah is your god, then you are crazy.
Judah does not mean home of the jews. The Romans did not attack the Jewish state because of a fear of rebellion. I couldn’t even watch the rest of the video. The funny thing about the Jewish Bible is that is an interesting epic piece of work. I often see that its used for deception and misquoted on the other end.
Effendi (Governor's Commissioned Officer) was the highest rank that a Black African could achieve in the British King's African Rifles (KAR) until 1961 (from then, promotions to commissioned officers became possible). They were equivalent to the Viceroy's Commissioned Officers in the British Indian Army.
Effendi or Uffendi just means someone who is elite. It's an arabic word.
@@1yogachrisCan you make it a contraction? As in, "you'ffendi?" Or "you'ffensive?"
Is there a sale on Ugucci and Uffendi bags?!?
Thank you, I'll be here all week! 🤣
15And he returned to the man of God, he and all his company, and came, and stood before him: and he said, Behold, now I know that no God in all the earth, but in Israel: now therefore, I pray thee, take a blessing of thy servant. II Kings 5:15
Title should be : What is Israel ? Who are Israeli?
jacob people ,black israelites,
so the name Palentine was just a political tool of conquest, I have always wondered who these guys were and where they came from.
It does not rely on holy books as evidence. How do you know that the person you are talking to is an idiot and is using texts as scientific evidence? You don't seem to know the basics of science.
@@nadashaker6037 It's interesting how you people refuse to recognize these ancient texts as historical documents when they are in fact the ONLY historical documents we actually have. You like to pretend that our modern textbooks are "historical documents" when they are NOT. The ancient texts are the real historical documents.
@@sheshotjfk8375 We have antiquities and do not rely on religious texts. For your information, even Jewish religious texts acknowledge that they are not a people
There are many (intentional?) errors: "Philistine" is not a Greek name but a Semitic one. "Falas/h" means entrance/arrival/invasion and "Teen" refers to "land of" or "soil". The proper pronunciation is with a PH not a P, by the way. During Roman occupation, the southern Half of the country was called "Provincia Arabia" and was ruled by Arab Nabateans. Also, the northern part of the country, the Galilee was ruled by Arabs - Yattorians, among others. Basic history. After the failure of the Judean rebellion in 138 Arabs managed to take control of the Country for 2 centuries under the Tanuchi kingdom. The name "Filistine" was in use for centuries and was never forgotten. Many historical documents show that. Under the ottoman empire, for example, there WAS an administrative government jurisdiction called Jond Filistine. So on. All of this information is basic and well knows to every reader of scholarly sources. Both Hebrew and Arabic cultures are indispensable parts of the history of Palestine. Ethnocide is not the way to go.
which you reference for this
Source: trust me bro.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
pls qoute source to back these clam or reference. thank you
@@cadtech8947 You didn't do that for this video.
Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
I wish I could give the video a thousand _likes_ but I will share it even more.
In the name of religion many people have taken advantage of this community. They are brilliant, capable and hard workers that is for sure. Long live jews
How do you become a Jew? Just marry a Jewish woman and you will become a Jew and your children will become Jews. How are they racing? Genetics says that race is limited by a man having xy and a woman having xx, and race depends on y.
Judaism is a religion, not a race
Countries built on race
If peace is to be truly achieved, perhaps a charter across the Middle East giving the Palestinians unrestricted settlement in the region outside of Israel: Jordan, Egypt, Qatar, Lebanon, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Libya, etc. So much land mass available yet so much squabbling over a postage stamp geographically speaking. The region is awash in oil revenue. Why not just pay these people to leave Gaza and settle elsewhere in comfort and protection?
This account of what transpired does not gel with the history commencing with the Balfour Declaration im 1928 or does It?
1917
Imagine if they live in Peace ✌ ☮
It will never happen, both are too stubborn.
they can not live in peace ,how the USA and Russia sell weapons to those rich oil country if they don't create a conflict .They are using both stupid people to get back the money that they spend on oil. The war will end when there no more need for the middle east oil
Fat chance. And, if that were to happen, there would be a population explosion that would lead to severe competition for resources and war.
Amen 🙏 Still have hope
@@mworldxyz5631 Abandon all hope.
Gd
That was very kosher.
Following the war between the Palestinian hamas and israel i had to come here
Never mentioned balfoyr agreement
That's because its quite obviously pro Israel. Its tantamount to saying " the Palestinians don't actually deserve anything because the Romans and Brits got their name wrong". This is ludicrous.
They didn't mention the Nazi Grand Mufti, who invented the lie that the mosque in Jerusalem was the one mentioned in the quran either.
How would you explain JERO. SALAAM. Jerusalem).
A lady comments me asking me who was the tribe I was in,and that she was a Danite.when Dan separate from he's brother's he live close to the people of the Philistines.i did my studying,and find out that they kept mixing with other's.they came to America change their name.the Danite became the Mormon.they turn lighter (skin.)oh Palestinian,Canaanites,Danite.Egyptian.(Gaza,Ashkelon,Ashdod Elton and Gath from Wadi Gaza in the south to the Yarqon river in the north.
Palestinians also known as Jordanians, Syrians, Lebanese, Egypitians
Back to eastern europe israhellii
Excellent!
Pray for the Pease of Jerusalem
I feel like if you're gonna start this story you have to start before the Roman Empire. The land was inhabited with Canaanites and Philistines. Both of them had 50% blood from Ancient Greece because of the conquest of Alexandria the great. So the people there were ancient Greeks mixing with ancient Egypt and with the people originally from Iran and Syria. The Canaanites were more semitic while the Philistines were more Greek. DNA tests in a recent study on Canaanite remains proved that modern day Jews and Arabs have the same DNA as Canaanites so both were descendent from the earliest people known there. This is before the Israelites united, left Egypt and conquered Canaan and Philistines and then built the first Temple of Solomon. After that Babylon conquered them, then Assyrians, and during this time the Jews were being exiled as people from Babylon and Syria came in, all people are mixing. Then the Persians come and bring back the Jews and mix up the gene pool same more. So the Palestinians are a mixture of all of these major world powers coming into the land. The Jews are the same.
@Kenneth this has always intrigued my curiosity. I will order your book right now. Many thanks!
Again as stated in the video the philistines were in the area of modern day Gaza and not the land of Judea-Samaria
Today Jewish don't have Middle East DNA.That was proven.The Ashekenazi DNA was from Europe .
As I said before, how many thousands of years you want to go back. Everyone all over the world will be thrown out where they are now living. 🔙🔙🔙🐝
@Kenneth McRae You can't solve a real world political problem between different nations by using your own religious beliefs as fact. To others, your book is false and your God is a myth.
Very informative. Love ancient history...thanks for sharing and long live Israel.
The video cherry picks data and strawmans to create a false narrative. It's hogwash!
Koyak Israel
@@TN43RIDERSdo you know the other side ? Let us know
@@TN43RIDERS Yes, give us the other side of the story.
Sources?
So... what happened after 1948?
? 4,000 years ago, The angel of the LORD proceeded: “Behold, you have conceived and will bear a son. And you shall name him Ishmael, for the LORD has heard your cry of affliction. He will be a wild donkey of a man, and his hand will be against everyone, and everyone’s hand against him; he will live in hostility toward all his brothers.” Later, Joshua was given a command that he did not follow; now we pay the price.
what is this got to do with the video?
@@LiteCoconut
everything as Ismael was ousted and the Esau/Jacob fight brought about selling ones birthright and being ousted....both of which joined and brought about the Arab nations.
Genesis 25:22-24 KJV
And the children struggled together within her; and she said, If it be so, why am I thus? And she went to enquire of the Lord. [23] And the Lord said unto her, Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels; and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger. [24] And when her days to be delivered were fulfilled, behold, there were twins in her womb.
Soon afterwards:
Genesis 28:8-9 KJV
And Esau seeing that the daughters of Canaan pleased not Isaac his father; [9] Then went Esau unto Ishmael, and took unto the wives which he had Mahalath the daughter of Ishmael Abraham's son, the sister of Nebajoth, to be his wife.
@@keithlucas6260 it's just a story. Now people still killing each other over it 🐝
Fantastic explanation 👍!
Fantastic as in _"fantasy",_ fiction that defies rational belief.
Wow, so basically Husaini was envious of how the Jews had developed the land.
I cannot find the word Palestine anywhere in History books prior to Roman invasion of the Holy.. Someone please enlighten me
I'm a newbie in interesting about this conflict. But don't tell me u displace palestinians coz u owned the land in 2nd century???? That is ridiculous.
It's almost comical.
yes they are !!! but my advice to you is to study yourself, here they don't tell the whole history.
@@bilalbataineh8367 i dont wanna go deep into the world history coz i'm not that interested. but people migrate. you can't just kicked people out coz they're palestinian and not jewish in that neighborhood. even if they try to evict them, did israeli government provided them a place as a substitute ? these families were given that place by UN under jordan mandate as far as i know. You think this eviction is ok? Maybe jews owned the land like hundreds of years ago. If they want that land back cropping out all events happened after that till now, i suggest they time-travel and live in that time when they did own that land. This eviction is just ridiculous to me. The younger generations were born there. That is their home. And some gov evict them coz they owned that land in their great grandparents time??? And any any people except muslim, especially jews, can go to Israel and settle down ? Hmmmm that's ethnic cleansing. Hope you don't have prejudice.
@@bilalbataineh8367 and besides Israeli gov won't evict if jewish were living in there illegally. Or if non-jewish non-muslim were living there, they might make them pay a fine and close the case. This is just so not right about eviction.
@@mayTK I asked you to read history, because even the historical rights they claim are mainly made up !! not to mention their sick-zionist logic in evictions, as you've just explained!
Why not do a historical check on the Jews and who they are and how they got back the land because according to the Bible they should be there until the return of Jesus
They did..and lots of history to prove jews
Good point and there are a lot of Jews that don't believe that the state of Israel should exist.
The ISRAELIS also were made by their God to wander in wilderness because they NEVER could OBEY him! They were always losing Jerusalem because of disobedience! They coerced the Romans to crucify Jesus!
@@TheAnnArnold They were but according to Bible scripture the last scattering and captivity they would lose knowledge of themself as a people. They wouldn't return to the land until Christ return and scripture says it shall be trodden down by the Gentiles
@@TheKumarImpressions The Bible says the knowledge of who they are would be destroyed so my point exactly they never claim of their history of self been been destroyed ever
You are forgetting the Saladdin chapter.
Finally a genuine history from start to finish! Now the Arab squatters need to watch it and accept the truth!
Give Caanan back to the Caananites?
Most of the population around those areas are either from cain or esau.
@@thestonecollector.3416 lol even the Hebrew bible, that deluded Jews into thinking it's their promised land, indicates that Israelites fled Ancient Egypt. They aren't Canaanites.
@@AJolie009 I didnt say Israelites were canaanites.
you seen a Canaanite lately ??LOL
@@tboss6689 Actually studies have shown that Lebanese are direct descendants of the Canaanites! Or how about give the country back to Palestinians, the rightful owners who were expelled from their homes in 1948?
Mr kamel you never mentioned anything about palestinians fighting the romans or even the british,israel fought both for their land , your long comment is all rubbish
Because there wasn't such thing as "Palestinians" back then when the Romans conquered Judea
Because the area was named “Palestine” by the romans after they conquered it. The Jews fought the romans. Palestinians (Arabs) weren’t even in the land back then because they spread into the land with the spread of Islam which was invented hundreds of years after the Roman conquest of judea.
@@SupaBloom right, so what are the palestinians fighting for?? For a land that was named by the romans even when they never existed. Rubbish.
@@maorgidony2565 if the romans named the land ginger bread the jews would be fighting gingerians.
@@rickyalvarez182 Palestinians are fighting for the arabization of the land essentially. They didn’t like that more Jews began to migrate to the land in the early 1900s so when Israel was established the surrounding Arab countries attacked with a genocidal goal against the Jews. Many Palestinians in Israel left during the war of 1948 thinking their surrounding fellow Arabs would win. Israel ended up winning and locked the door on the Palestinians on their way out. The Palestinian identity and flag didn’t even exist until the 60’s. They invented the Palestinian identity because they thought it would be beneficial to their goal and PR. Before they believed in pan-Arabism because they are Arabs.
Awesome, thanks.
Yes confirmed.
If I wanted to study Palestinian ancient history, where would I start?
Canaanities and Canaan country.
Time travel
@Yepajw DNA results from grave site found an ancient Canaanitie person match 93% to people of Lebanon.
Here!
Obviously Palestinian history isn't old enough to use the term "ancient".
God help us!
Special people jews 😂😂