I wish that they kept Thrawn around until after the Battle of Endor, so that they could make a canon version of them. But hey, they kept his guard guy around. I forgot his name
@@and8091 Always correct, always outsmarts everyone, always five steps ahead of everyone, never makes mistakes, never gets overconfident, is so OP other sources are needed to defeat him like space whales, etc.
@@VinVonVoom no, blue screens are only used more when moves use a film camera instead of a digital camera because film cameras are more sensitive to blue although sometimes they use blue with digital and green with film, it all depends on the effect you're doing
@@elijahvelasco8963 I think the less training is the point. The Jedi and the Sith as we know it is dying. The teaching they taught is lost, much like many of the teachings before them. Even the Jedi in the prequels are pathetically weak compared the force users of the Old Republic just due to the amount of knowledge lost in all these wars. I think now is the time of both orders to die and then be re-birthed into their new re-incarnation, whatever that may be.
@G Ren I don't find the character development. for all three movies she just wants a parental figure and be trained. The one that truly got character development and should have been the main character is Ben Solo/Kylo Ren. He actually had some attempt at character development.
Luke Skywalker is one of the GREATEST and MOST BELOVED heroes in cinematic history. The treatment of Luke in TLJ was beyond defamatory and remains disgusting to this very day. Rian Johnson should NEVER have been let anywhere near a Star Wars Film, just a TERRIBLE person he is.
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 While the comment above is formatted and written in a very odd way, this is simply untrue. If he was, he would've understood the characters and fleshed them out properly. His writing helped play a part in the failure of the sequel trilogy.
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 the casting, sound design and vfx are amazing it's literally just the writing of the trilogy that let all three movies down, so yes, RJ did play a part in making the sequels the way they were, mediocre nostalgia bait cash grabs.
Unlike others, I don't despise how Luke is portrayed in the sequels. It could work, if there was more context on what happened between ROTJ and the sequels. I could totally see Luke growing disillusioned if several of his jedi pupils turned dark, and caused havoc. The problem is the conplete lack of information we have about that time period.
Completely agree. It's not that Luke is disillusioned; its that we have little to no background as to how this happened. I want to see the tragedy, hardship, and utter defeat that led to this outcome. The single flashback we got? Sorry, not enough. Maybe if they had the flashbacks interspersed throughout the movie and him trying to kill Kylo Ren was the last straw, but it was a growing danger and darkness that pervaded his life.
I wish More star wars channels are like you. You don't see star wars for what it did and what Will become, you see star wars for what it Is and how Will change in years to come. One wise turtle once said "Quit? Don't quit. Noodles, don't noodles. You are too concerned about what was and what Will be. Theres a saying: Yesterday Is history, tomorrow Is a mystery, but today Is a gift, thats why its called the present"
I agree. Even if there are problems and controversy’s as history has shown many times, hopefully the fan base will come back together as best as it can be. I talked with my mom about it and even she agreed with the statement.
This guy does a great description of these behind-the-scenes however in the trilogy box set you can get all of this and much much more. Kudos to the narrator for compiling this information.
William Katt, the same actor who played Ralph Hinkley in "The Great American Hero" was another actor who had auditioned for the role of Luke Skywalker, just like they'd considered having Kurt Russell and Perry King in the role of Han Solo, as well as considering Cindy Williams and Teri Nunn (The Lead Singer of Berlin) for the role of Princess Leia
I love your videos! These characters are also deserve a video like this, such as han solo, princess leia, obi wan kenobi, qui gon jinn, or lando calrissian
He does do a Jedi mindtrick, but on the Twi'lek guy that speaks to Jabba. Not the Mandela effect. From what I can remember, the two pig lookin dudes have always been force choked lol
Man I love your essays! ! Looking forward to seeing this!! Yes, I'm commenting before watching... coz I KNOW it's gonna be good! 😉😉 O.O.K 👌💙 #onlyonekenobi #BehindStarWars
I'm not sure I'd call Dark Empire and Luke's marriage to Mara Jade a "disaster". Mara Jade is one of the best Legends exclusive Star Wars characters there is, and I and many others really enjoyed her and Luke's love story. I'd hardly call that a "disaster".
@Daniel Laricella The OP was calling Legends Luke`s general arc "a disaster",not the relationship with Mara-Jade in particular.Granted,I still disagree but both Legends Luke and Sequel Trilogy Luke in different ways betray the promise of The Character at the end of "Return of the Jedi".
@@alexrobertson1472 No, clearly you didn't watch TLJ because you can see at the end of the movie, he accepted the weapon he was given at the end of the movie when you see him wield the saber.
"Convoluted" and "complex" are not the same thing. While Luke's journey in Legends novels is complex, his characterisation is amazingly consistent! (along with the rest of the main cast) This is the mark of *good writers* who *understand the characters!* Something that modern writers really seem to struggle with, no matter the IP.
Please fix that mins information about Luke walking into the sunset,Gary Kurt's is a pathological liar. Hes just but hurt he was fired by Lucas. Why would George sell out for money when that money was going to his ex wife during that divorce and he was handing out 6 figure bonuses to his actors,hammil included!!
Have you read The Art of The Last Jedi? It's a very awesome book! Phil Szostak posted an image from the book on Twitter a while back. mobile.twitter.com/PhilSzostak/status/1065290694930063360
Sean Connery could have starred as General Skywalker if you read that descriptive paragraph at 1:02 it's Connery he would have been great as an older Jedi General.
Anakin redeemed himself in episode 6, Han redeemed himself in episode 7 (failing to be there for his son earlier in life), Luke redeemed himself in episode 8, Leia redeemed herself in episode 9 (again failing to be present for her son), and Ben Solo redeemed himself in episode 9. Star Wars is about good and evil, hope, failure, redemption and family. Say what you will about the sequel trilogy, but they understood this.
What absolute horse shit. You haven't got a clue what you're talking about. Han and Leia didn't fail to be there for him. Go learn about this stuff before your ass muscles fail to hold in any more liquid shit and it splats onto the comments section.
@@vaguelyawareofstuff2955 FYI I used to work on a ranch and I can tell you that 99.9% of horse shit is actually incredibly firm, sometimes straight up solid. So idk how you can sit there and tell me I'm spouting liquid shit AND horse shit when you obviously don't know shit about equine feces
Had she been written right I would but she was written to be the most powerful Jedi within hours of finding out she had the force. Unlike Luke, she never loses or faces adversity. She beat Luke in a lightsaber duel with no formal training for gods sake! She beat Kylo Ren every time. I love Luke and hate the entire Rey trilogy. It needs to be erased from Star Wars cannon, Legends and erased period!
If anyone is looking to learn more about behind the scenes and making of the original trilogy I recommend the book Star Wars FAQ by Mark Clark. Very nice video by the way.
Mark Hamill also rebutted those comments because he was still under contract to appear in The Rise of Skywalker, so another words take those comments back or you don't get paid LOL he absolutely Fuckin hated what they did to his character.
@Aeternalis Armentarius you forget that after emphatically telling his father "I will not fight you." He not only fights him, but nearly kills, after his sister is threatened. In ESB Luke abandoneds his Jedi training to "save" his friends after seeing one possible future. Knowing full well that the path he's chosen could lead to Dark Side. "If you end your training now, if you choose the quick and easy path, as Vader did, you will become an agent of evil." So Luke sees a vision of his sister dying, he sees the destruction of everything he ever loved, and he reacts to it and draws his lightsaber, this is completely within character. And this is the important part, Luke doesn't carry through with the attack, he stops himself. But Luke like is father before him ends up causing the future he was trying to prevent. And Luke arc follows a mythopoetic structure as well as paralleling many mythic heroes. "If you look at any classic hero's myth that is actually worth its salt, at the beginning of the hero's journey, like with King Arthur, he pulls the sword from the stone and he's ascendant - he has setbacks but he unites all the kingdoms. But then if you keep reading, when it deals with the hero's life as they get into middle-age and beyond, it always starts to get into darker places. And there's a reason for that: It's because myths are not made to sell action figures; myths are made to reflect the most difficult transitions we go through in life." - Rian Johnson
@@lukerope1906 He got shafted. Besides the fact there was no real reunion in the movie of the original cast in either Ep. XVII or XVIII, Luke's screentime was minimal, he had less screentime than Rose. Some of us have been waiting 40 years to see Luke again on the screen, he comes back, has an unimportant role, less screentime than side characters and dies on the same movie. This is what pisses me off the most, we will never see Luke again, we will never see Han, Luke and Leia on the same movie together.
@@matheus.bueno47 and? Star Wars is a saga split into 3 trilogies. Each trilogy has its group of main characters. Han, Luke, and Leia where main characters of the OT. Now they are secondary characters. There are a new generation of characters now.
Joe Kerr they are yes, but that does not mean shafting them to side like they are expandable. Directors can’t change characters just because they want the plot to go somewhere. Unfortunately this is where we are at.
@@Theratron Luke didn't try to kill him just like he said in the movie. It was from Kylo's perspective that he wanted to kill him. Luke had a dark instinct from a horrible vision he had, and I mean truly horrible, way worse than the thought he had in ROTJ which almost caused him to kill his own father which he had wanted to save for the entire later part of the movie.
@@aerophine_66 He didn't try to kill his nephew, he saw what he could become and acted upon impulse, but realized what he was doing was wrong and did not go through with it. He didn't act upon it.
Considering his most recent tweet thanking Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni for bringing back hero Luke in the way they did in "The Mandalorian" is proof he wasn't happy with the way Johnson saw Luke. There's a video out there where Johnson is talking about the film and Mark just has this look of utter disbelief.
@@Edax_Royeaux there’s a 25 minute video of him hinting at the fact that he doesn’t like it. And one video where he is “complimenting” Rian but really he’s just kinda throwing shade for how badly his character was treated
Then came Mandalorian. Also while it is hard to tell who is responsible I may have an interesting Idea. I asked Ivan Orgtea about doing a proof of concept special editons for the films using elements of his re-edits. I even talked with UA-camr Star Wars Rebel Leader prior to it and he liked the ideas I gave him. Ivan said he was interested though first he was going to take a break.
As a blonde haired man I’d be him when he’s younger 19-23 and go on Adventures. My name Lukas comes from Luke and I’m 6 feet 2 inches tall but would not mind being 5 feet 8 inches being him is a dream
Really should have gave Luke more to do in the sequel trilogy. I don’t care what anyone says, Johnston made a terrible film and totally threw a wrench in the trilogy
@@DontDisapPyrrha It being his plan doesn't really make it a good choice. Somebody can plan to mainline heroin, but that doesn't make it a good choice.
What you meant to say is, Luke’s story arc and ending was completely squandered to give Rey the finale. Luke should have been there, alive to support her. Rey had no business facing multiple with lords alone and it made absolutely no sense.
I'm in the middle when it comes to the argument of whether or not Luke was ruined in TLJ. On one side, I don't see Luke as ruined (or completely ruined) in TLJ because years have gone by and he's learned more about the Jedi Order's past. Why would he be the exact same as in ROTJ except in age? At the same time, I can see why some argue that his character is ruined, because he did stuff that he wouldn't have done in the past, like attempting to strike down Ben Solo because of the Dark Side. At least he realized his error in judgement, but it was still too late
I'll be honest, the only parts of TLJ I liked were the parts with Luke. Most of what he said was just stuff the fans have been saying for years; i.e. the Jedi are a bunch of sanctimonious failures who are too narrow minded to survive. And I mean, he tried to strike down his own Dad in anger, it's not impossible that he would be nudged by the dark side again.
0:22 Ah yes, the senior members of the Jedi Council. Yoda, Ki-Adi-Mundi, (looks at smudged writing on hand) . . . Mace Windy??
Annikin Starkiller?
I live near where they shot the Endor Scenes, I’ve hiked on Endor. A couple hours away.
Henderman1 nice would like to go
Henderman1 my grandparents went
@Dark Star there's always one
Did you see any Ewoks??
Nice, I live in Redwood City. What park is that exactly? I would love to check it out
The “Heir to The Empire” books, in fact, EVERYTHING written by Timothy Zhan are all Fantastic books and handles the OT characters PERFECTLY.
I wish that they kept Thrawn around until after the Battle of Endor, so that they could make a canon version of them. But hey, they kept his guard guy around. I forgot his name
Thrawn is a Villain Sue
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 He is just smart.
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 Evidence?
@@and8091 Always correct, always outsmarts everyone, always five steps ahead of everyone, never makes mistakes, never gets overconfident, is so OP other sources are needed to defeat him like space whales, etc.
5:00 “Had Han jump in the garbage chute before him, whereas in the film Han goes first”
Mega oopsie
Han was the last one to jump into the garbage chute
I was wondering was it my imagination, or did he indeed said it like that, lol.
And it's 4:56 not 5:00 ;p
@@secretblue0290,
Eh, minor oopsie. 🤪
"He's my brother"
Robot chicken:"that was so wrong"
9:13 ahhh yes a GREEN screen
Blue screen. He made so many fuckups
@makutamaster doesn't mean that they are the same
It's fnny how green screen is the more popular phrase despite blue screens being used way more in movies.
@@VinVonVoom no, blue screens are only used more when moves use a film camera instead of a digital camera because film cameras are more sensitive to blue although sometimes they use blue with digital and green with film, it all depends on the effect you're doing
@@BeeBeau Most of AOTC and ROTS's screens are blue. Those are both shot digitally, regardless, they still see more use as far as I can tell.
"an older version of Rey" 😂 Rey is just a half assed version of Luke.
With way less training to boot
@@elijahvelasco8963 I think the less training is the point. The Jedi and the Sith as we know it is dying. The teaching they taught is lost, much like many of the teachings before them. Even the Jedi in the prequels are pathetically weak compared the force users of the Old Republic just due to the amount of knowledge lost in all these wars.
I think now is the time of both orders to die and then be re-birthed into their new re-incarnation, whatever that may be.
You're being generous with Rey , she wasn't even interesting . Not daisys fault but lazy writing ...no character development .
@G Ren We failed to find character development because of shit writing.
@G Ren I don't find the character development. for all three movies she just wants a parental figure and be trained. The one that truly got character development and should have been the main character is Ben Solo/Kylo Ren. He actually had some attempt at character development.
Finally a new behind the Scenes History Episode!!
Luke Skywalker is one of the GREATEST and MOST BELOVED heroes in cinematic history. The treatment of Luke in TLJ was beyond defamatory and remains disgusting to this very day. Rian Johnson should NEVER have been let anywhere near a Star Wars Film, just a TERRIBLE person he is.
He's a bigger Star Wars fanboy than you
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 Bruh
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 While the comment above is formatted and written in a very odd way, this is simply untrue. If he was, he would've understood the characters and fleshed them out properly. His writing helped play a part in the failure of the sequel trilogy.
@@MisterSandmanAU Not really
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 the casting, sound design and vfx are amazing
it's literally just the writing of the trilogy that let all three movies down, so yes, RJ did play a part in making the sequels the way they were, mediocre nostalgia bait cash grabs.
Dark Forces... man does that take me back
Yeah,he acts like going to the dark side was bad,but idk if he read it. He was only doing it because there was no other way to end sidious.
@@fridaynightnicktoons6885 Did you mean to reply to me? That just seems like you were talking to someone else, though Im not sure 😅
Unlike others, I don't despise how Luke is portrayed in the sequels. It could work, if there was more context on what happened between ROTJ and the sequels. I could totally see Luke growing disillusioned if several of his jedi pupils turned dark, and caused havoc. The problem is the conplete lack of information we have about that time period.
Completely agree. It's not that Luke is disillusioned; its that we have little to no background as to how this happened. I want to see the tragedy, hardship, and utter defeat that led to this outcome. The single flashback we got? Sorry, not enough.
Maybe if they had the flashbacks interspersed throughout the movie and him trying to kill Kylo Ren was the last straw, but it was a growing danger and darkness that pervaded his life.
I wish More star wars channels are like you. You don't see star wars for what it did and what Will become, you see star wars for what it Is and how Will change in years to come. One wise turtle once said "Quit? Don't quit. Noodles, don't noodles. You are too concerned about what was and what Will be. Theres a saying: Yesterday Is history, tomorrow Is a mystery, but today Is a gift, thats why its called the present"
I agree. Even if there are problems and controversy’s as history has shown many times, hopefully the fan base will come back together as best as it can be. I talked with my mom about it and even she agreed with the statement.
Also in the novel, obi wan slices the alien in the cantina down the center from head to crotch instead of just the hand and he falls into 2 pieces
Well there goes the PG rating if that came to pass.
I'm so glad I came across your channel, your videos are always incredibly interesting to watch
This guy does a great description of these behind-the-scenes however in the trilogy box set you can get all of this and much much more.
Kudos to the narrator for compiling this information.
Nah, he did exactly what you said and is just giving us the jest of it through UA-cam 😂
William Katt, the same actor who played Ralph Hinkley in "The Great American Hero" was another actor who had auditioned for the role of Luke Skywalker, just like they'd considered having Kurt Russell and Perry King in the role of Han Solo, as well as considering Cindy Williams and Teri Nunn (The Lead Singer of Berlin) for the role of Princess Leia
I love your videos! These characters are also deserve a video like this, such as han solo, princess leia, obi wan kenobi, qui gon jinn, or lando calrissian
10:29 I always thought that he performed a Jedi Mind trick on the guards.
Tabulatelk15 yeah that’s the Mandela effect for you lol
Woah Yea mee too, what!?
He does do a Jedi mindtrick, but on the Twi'lek guy that speaks to Jabba. Not the Mandela effect. From what I can remember, the two pig lookin dudes have always been force choked lol
same here
I thought he just restrained them as those guards grabbed their chests, not their throats.
What a great channel, thank you for your content .
Man I love your essays! ! Looking forward to seeing this!! Yes, I'm commenting before watching... coz I KNOW it's gonna be good! 😉😉 O.O.K 👌💙 #onlyonekenobi #BehindStarWars
Christ.. the sequels really are a sad mess.
In the film, Han is the last one to dive into the compactor
What a great video. Thanks man.
I'm not sure I'd call Dark Empire and Luke's marriage to Mara Jade a "disaster". Mara Jade is one of the best Legends exclusive Star Wars characters there is, and I and many others really enjoyed her and Luke's love story. I'd hardly call that a "disaster".
@Daniel Laricella The OP was calling Legends Luke`s general arc "a disaster",not the relationship with Mara-Jade in particular.Granted,I still disagree but both Legends Luke and Sequel Trilogy Luke in different ways betray the promise of The Character at the end of "Return of the Jedi".
@@AspieMediaBobby In what regard does Legends Luke betray the Character from ROTJ?
@@NiteMaster117 He's overpowered and too competent. Luke's kinda a fucking loser
No she isn't, she's boring like they all are
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 You seriously think all Legends characters are boring?
Not even worth arguing with.
If Luke is a mess in the EU, then he's a far more entertaining & inspiring mess than what we got in the Sequels.
Make Leia organa behind the scenes👍
Just found your channel after this video im going to watch your video about count dooku but hey your videos are great! Keep up the work!
Some of these characters become a thing in the Star Wars lore, replacing different roles.
Starkiller was Vader's apprentice, breaking the Rule of 2
Luke in the last Jedi: throws lightsaber like he doesn’t care
Also Luke in the rise of skywalker: a jedis weapon deserves more respect
It's called character development
@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 More like JJ trying to fix rian johnson squat pissing all over star wars for shits and giggles.
@@alexrobertson1472 No, clearly you didn't watch TLJ because you can see at the end of the movie, he accepted the weapon he was given at the end of the movie when you see him wield the saber.
Thanks for this amazing channel with great and awesome videos!
~Justin♡
spectacular! thank u!
"Convoluted" and "complex" are not the same thing. While Luke's journey in Legends novels is complex, his characterisation is amazingly consistent! (along with the rest of the main cast)
This is the mark of *good writers* who *understand the characters!* Something that modern writers really seem to struggle with, no matter the IP.
Love these!
Same! Underrated UA-cam channel! 👍👍
Great video
love how they basically forgot anakin in the sequals
Luke is my childhood hero
Luke does return as a Force Ghost in Episode IX, and he is more like the one we see in Legends: one of the most powerful Jedi.
the man aged like fine wine. nice
Please fix that mins information about Luke walking into the sunset,Gary Kurt's is a pathological liar. Hes just but hurt he was fired by Lucas. Why would George sell out for money when that money was going to his ex wife during that divorce and he was handing out 6 figure bonuses to his actors,hammil included!!
Calm down Beyonce
Watch how the man who had faith in the most evil guy in the galaxy, decided to end his nephew for thinking of shooting the Jedi-school.
"It was a moment of pure instinct"
I mean Luke was right as well
Except he didn't. He thought about it and almost acted on his fears, but in the end he stopped himself.
Starkiller...
You mean the third Death Star?
No he meant Galen Merik ;)
I wonder if it was a nod to the Other Starkiller by name.
When THE Luke Skywalker tells you the lack of involvement is shitty you should probably write him in more scenes.
Love that thumbnail.
@Behind Star Wars
pls continue to make more videos
Man,I don't know that you made video about Luke Skywalker,holy shit!
"obi wan killed your father"
well he's not wrong
*Excludes the continuity, and context for Luke in the extended universe*
Behind Star Wars: "So then i started trashing!"
What continuity and context? Everyone used to trash the EU lol
The idea of Luke being a hermit at the first Jedi Temple came directly from George Lucas himself. Lucasfilm decided to use his idea for the Disney ST.
Have you read The Art of The Last Jedi? It's a very awesome book! Phil Szostak posted an image from the book on Twitter a while back. mobile.twitter.com/PhilSzostak/status/1065290694930063360
that’s not true! That’s impossible!
Yea but he wasn’t running away and hiding .
@@billybenham4920 He was doubting himself and unsure about restarting the Jedi Order. He was reluctant to train Kira. It's similar.
Stuart Lugsden it’s not same as we are talking about George Lucas episode 7 - 9 not legends
Sean Connery could have starred as General Skywalker if you read that descriptive paragraph at 1:02 it's Connery he would have been great as an older Jedi General.
Interesting! I’ve been to the set at Ft Lewis
Wow! CM Smith, one of my all time favorites (see Never Cry Wolf, if you haven’t already) auditioned for Luke?
Han shots First
Han dives First
Han dies First :(
(great video, I've been excited for a new upload)
Nah Leia died first...😬
DefectiveMatrix no... she doesn’t die first...
'Less interest in the protagonist Rey'
Well that worked, didn't it!
Never expected that the kyber crystals were first started that way
The comments are gonna be spicy...😋
Thank You. Q.: How Can I Get A Copy Of Your Back Ground Music?
Anakin redeemed himself in episode 6, Han redeemed himself in episode 7 (failing to be there for his son earlier in life), Luke redeemed himself in episode 8, Leia redeemed herself in episode 9 (again failing to be present for her son), and Ben Solo redeemed himself in episode 9. Star Wars is about good and evil, hope, failure, redemption and family. Say what you will about the sequel trilogy, but they understood this.
What absolute horse shit. You haven't got a clue what you're talking about. Han and Leia didn't fail to be there for him. Go learn about this stuff before your ass muscles fail to hold in any more liquid shit and it splats onto the comments section.
@@vaguelyawareofstuff2955 FYI I used to work on a ranch and I can tell you that 99.9% of horse shit is actually incredibly firm, sometimes straight up solid. So idk how you can sit there and tell me I'm spouting liquid shit AND horse shit when you obviously don't know shit about equine feces
“He’d be an older version of Rey”...BULL...SHIT!!!
Try to a video about the behind the scenes history of the clone army of the republic or some expanded universe characters
What version of the of the Cantina theme was used the background for this video?
9:15 blue screen not GREEN SCREEN
can you do obi wan Kenobi next or Qui gon jinn
He should’ve HAD a bigger part in the Force Awakens, who cares about Rey
Had she been written right I would but she was written to be the most powerful Jedi within hours of finding out she had the force. Unlike Luke, she never loses or faces adversity. She beat Luke in a lightsaber duel with no formal training for gods sake! She beat Kylo Ren every time. I love Luke and hate the entire Rey trilogy. It needs to be erased from Star Wars cannon, Legends and erased period!
I believe I hear Dj AG
The should have just made Luke and Rey the Qui Gon and Obi Wan of this new trilogy. Eh, I guess what's done is done...
You must find the book Star Wars: Jedi Apprentice.
Thats a stories about young Obi-Wan being padawan of Qui-Gon Jinn.
If anyone is looking to learn more about behind the scenes and making of the original trilogy I recommend the book Star Wars FAQ by Mark Clark. Very nice video by the way.
Should be one for Ventress, that would be cool.
That would be, especially if he included how she was originally Komari Vosa
Can you do Serpent of The Minds Eye.
Do obi wan next please
Do one on Jabba the Hutt.
Good video overall, well worth the "like"
Just one annoying pet peeve: Adaption is not a word. The word is adaptation
0:30 mace windi
mace windu is based of mace windy
*talks about luke and leia being siblings*
*also shows picture of them kissing*
me: SWWWWEEEET HOME ALABAMA
Spot the guy who was so eager to try and be clever in the comments section that he forgot to listen to the voiceover and ended up looking very silly.
4:46 well hello. 😏
Damn. They've should've used the early versions of Luke in the sequel trilogy
I agree and disagree
@@sowmithreddy8178 wow. That's pretty balanced. Nice
'An older version of Rey'
Exactly the problem.
Mark Hamill also rebutted those comments because he was still under contract to appear in The Rise of Skywalker, so another words take those comments back or you don't get paid LOL he absolutely Fuckin hated what they did to his character.
And?
I hope Mark doesn't get shafted again in episode 9, he's such a great and kind guy who loves Star Wars and he deserves the best
I wouldn't say he got shafted. George's and Rian's ideas just came out of left field and caught him off guard.
@Aeternalis Armentarius you forget that after emphatically telling his father "I will not fight you." He not only fights him, but nearly kills, after his sister is threatened. In ESB Luke abandoneds his Jedi training to "save" his friends after seeing one possible future. Knowing full well that the path he's chosen could lead to Dark Side. "If you end your training now, if you choose the quick and easy path, as Vader did, you will become an agent of evil."
So Luke sees a vision of his sister dying, he sees the destruction of everything he ever loved, and he reacts to it and draws his lightsaber, this is completely within character. And this is the important part, Luke doesn't carry through with the attack, he stops himself. But Luke like is father before him ends up causing the future he was trying to prevent.
And Luke arc follows a mythopoetic structure as well as paralleling many mythic heroes. "If you look at any classic hero's myth that is actually worth its salt, at the beginning of the hero's journey, like with King Arthur, he pulls the sword from the stone and he's ascendant - he has setbacks but he unites all the kingdoms. But then if you keep reading, when it deals with the hero's life as they get into middle-age and beyond, it always starts to get into darker places. And there's a reason for that: It's because myths are not made to sell action figures; myths are made to reflect the most difficult transitions we go through in life." - Rian Johnson
@@lukerope1906 He got shafted. Besides the fact there was no real reunion in the movie of the original cast in either Ep. XVII or XVIII, Luke's screentime was minimal, he had less screentime than Rose. Some of us have been waiting 40 years to see Luke again on the screen, he comes back, has an unimportant role, less screentime than side characters and dies on the same movie. This is what pisses me off the most, we will never see Luke again, we will never see Han, Luke and Leia on the same movie together.
@@matheus.bueno47 and?
Star Wars is a saga split into 3 trilogies. Each trilogy has its group of main characters. Han, Luke, and Leia where main characters of the OT. Now they are secondary characters. There are a new generation of characters now.
Joe Kerr they are yes, but that does not mean shafting them to side like they are expandable. Directors can’t change characters just because they want the plot to go somewhere. Unfortunately this is where we are at.
Vader: **Tries to kill Luke**
Luke: *Redeems him*
Mara Jade: **Tries to kill Luke**
Luke: *Marries Her*
And according to Ryan Johnson:
Luke: *Has a bad dream about his nephew*
Luke: *Tries to kill him*
Gee, I wonder where they went wrong.....
@Hans... exactly mate, how tf did Luke go from this badass guy who saw the good in everyone to a pathetic loner who tried to kill his nephew in TLJ???
@@Theratron Luke didn't try to kill him just like he said in the movie.
It was from Kylo's perspective that he wanted to kill him.
Luke had a dark instinct from a horrible vision he had, and I mean truly horrible, way worse than the thought he had in ROTJ which almost caused him to kill his own father which he had wanted to save for the entire later part of the movie.
@@aerophine_66 It was from Kylo's perspective.
@@aerophine_66 He didn't try to kill his nephew, he saw what he could become and acted upon impulse, but realized what he was doing was wrong and did not go through with it. He didn't act upon it.
I just remembered Episode IX comes out at the end of this year! Woo!! :D
Han must really like to go first.
Fun fact I’m pretty sure Hamill still doesn’t like how Luke was written in TLJ. He hates the film lol
Just try quoting anything he said about that and a TLJ defender will say your taking him out of context...And not explain what that context is.
Considering his most recent tweet thanking Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni for bringing back hero Luke in the way they did in "The Mandalorian" is proof he wasn't happy with the way Johnson saw Luke. There's a video out there where Johnson is talking about the film and Mark just has this look of utter disbelief.
@@Edax_Royeaux there’s a 25 minute video of him hinting at the fact that he doesn’t like it. And one video where he is “complimenting” Rian but really he’s just kinda throwing shade for how badly his character was treated
@@diannebdee exactly. Oh and by the way how they heck did you get your Profile pic to move??
@@Edax_Royeaux More like Hamill is a moron. We don't pay actors to think
Does anybody know, the girl in the deleted scene with binoculars @4:50 is that Koo Stark? Sure looks like her!
Yep, that's her
Why no more vids?
In conclusion, we all wish Mark Hamill was used more and sadly Disney really fumbled the bag hard with how little he was used due to his age 😔
Then came Mandalorian. Also while it is hard to tell who is responsible I may have an interesting Idea. I asked Ivan Orgtea about doing a proof of concept special editons for the films using elements of his re-edits. I even talked with UA-camr Star Wars Rebel Leader prior to it and he liked the ideas I gave him. Ivan said he was interested though first he was going to take a break.
Star Wars; a cluster fuck before it started
Starkiller definitely works best as the name for an antagonistic force (i.e. sith assassin or planet-destroying space station)
As a blonde haired man I’d be him when he’s younger 19-23 and go on Adventures. My name Lukas comes from Luke and I’m 6 feet 2 inches tall but would not mind being 5 feet 8 inches being him is a dream
Han shot first, confirmed? 02:30
I know the background music
Organa Major has been destroyed. (apparently)
5:59 Mark Hamill with make up looks like Ellen Degeneres
Really should have gave Luke more to do in the sequel trilogy. I don’t care what anyone says, Johnston made a terrible film and totally threw a wrench in the trilogy
That was his plan, it’s his directing style
@@DontDisapPyrrha It being his plan doesn't really make it a good choice. Somebody can plan to mainline heroin, but that doesn't make it a good choice.
SonofSethoitae never said it was
@@DontDisapPyrrha I'm just extrapolating on what you said for anybody else who might be reading.
@@DontDisapPyrrha Rian's "plan" was to create a chaotic shit-fest of a film? Guess he succeeded.......
So starkiller kinda look like luck skywalker in star wars VIII
What you meant to say is, Luke’s story arc and ending was completely squandered to give Rey the finale. Luke should have been there, alive to support her. Rey had no business facing multiple with lords alone and it made absolutely no sense.
I'm in the middle when it comes to the argument of whether or not Luke was ruined in TLJ. On one side, I don't see Luke as ruined (or completely ruined) in TLJ because years have gone by and he's learned more about the Jedi Order's past. Why would he be the exact same as in ROTJ except in age?
At the same time, I can see why some argue that his character is ruined, because he did stuff that he wouldn't have done in the past, like attempting to strike down Ben Solo because of the Dark Side. At least he realized his error in judgement, but it was still too late
@@ItsAnIsaac He does have a distinct voice (in my opinion)
@@VersatileElement I do have a response if you want it, but I have to warn you, I ramble a lot and it's normally quite wordy....
@@MrSeals1000 Go ahead. As long as the comments aren't discrespectful, I have no problem with differing opinions
I'll be honest, the only parts of TLJ I liked were the parts with Luke. Most of what he said was just stuff the fans have been saying for years; i.e. the Jedi are a bunch of sanctimonious failures who are too narrow minded to survive.
And I mean, he tried to strike down his own Dad in anger, it's not impossible that he would be nudged by the dark side again.
He didn't actually try killing him though. All he did was turn on the lightsaber then immediately regretted it
So had Luke been in TFA, he might have overshadowed the character of Rey. I don’t see the problem here.
Mine b day is in may 19 soooooooooo