Review: Stromer ST5 - The New Swiss Super Ebike

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @iancharless
    @iancharless 6 років тому +6

    You guys are killing it. Keep it up. Great videos. All of them

    • @gusulises1758
      @gusulises1758 3 роки тому

      I know I am kinda off topic but do anyone know a good website to stream new series online ?

    • @byronkaiden9188
      @byronkaiden9188 3 роки тому

      @Gus Ulises Flixportal

    • @gusulises1758
      @gusulises1758 3 роки тому

      @Byron Kaiden thanks, signed up and it seems like a nice service :D I really appreciate it !

    • @byronkaiden9188
      @byronkaiden9188 3 роки тому

      @Gus Ulises No problem =)

  • @videosforcatsanddogs214
    @videosforcatsanddogs214 4 роки тому +5

    This bike is so beautiful. It would be perfect if they could make a full suspension system that looks both minimalistic and integrated into the design.

    • @nyahhbinghi
      @nyahhbinghi 2 роки тому

      agreed - I got a suspension seatpost, but would love full-suspension!

  • @enderlebrave2
    @enderlebrave2 6 років тому +1

    happy to see you in my country :)

  • @omegamarshallzero
    @omegamarshallzero 4 роки тому +3

    funny, you are in Oberwagen but the image is from Nydeggbrücke in Bern. :D

  • @MichaelJosephJr934
    @MichaelJosephJr934 5 років тому +3

    I test rode this bike and I was blown away. Although for 10 K I would like a few more MPH. I hit about 33 max.

    • @racerx2095
      @racerx2095 4 роки тому

      I know this is a nice bike but my ebike hit 35 today and I paid $1700 for my bike

  • @raymondbarraclough1003
    @raymondbarraclough1003 4 роки тому

    Hope it goes long range like 280miles and needs to come to uk please

  • @WaveGlydr
    @WaveGlydr 6 років тому

    I'll be coming into your SF store for a test ride when they arrive!

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому

      Fantastic. Can't wait to get you out one!

  • @markmckinney6490
    @markmckinney6490 6 років тому

    Great video, Brett!

  • @amaryllschwertner7106
    @amaryllschwertner7106 6 років тому

    wow! I am closer... great presentation of the bike

  • @roadpanzir
    @roadpanzir 6 років тому

    Very nice! best headlite available but still a derailleur, and where do you carry the emmentauler on your cheese run?

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому +1

      Very good point. A rear rack is essential! We've passed this on to Stromer. It will be available but we think it should come with the bike. Your point about the derailleur is a good one, though I still love a Shimano Di2 shifting system the best over all others. Personal preference.
      -Brett

  • @jorb8572
    @jorb8572 5 років тому +2

    In my country Holland in Europe it’s forbidden to ride on bicylce lanes inside cities. Only outside you are allowed. This bike is under the our law the same as motors. So in rush hour in cities you have to join the cars ect in traffic jam while the bicycle lanes are empty at that time.

  • @8hundred790
    @8hundred790 2 роки тому

    Background music Name? Sounds so nice.

  • @verocimil
    @verocimil 2 роки тому

    I test drove this bike yesterday, and without suspension it was way too hard and uncomfortable for me even when riding over very minor bumps. The chain on the minor gears was aslant in such a way, making considerable noise, being louder than a normal Mid Drive geared bicycle. But the power was incredible, I reached 48 Km/h on plain routes with ease and 33 Km/h on a long considerable hill. Only when the climb got very steep, I couldn’t surpass the 10 Km/h.
    Surely a nice e-bike, but not for me. I was very relieved, when I went back to my Mid Drive bike with fork suspension and a good leather saddle.

  • @raymondbarraclough1003
    @raymondbarraclough1003 4 роки тому

    Can test keep this bike

  • @nyahhbinghi
    @nyahhbinghi 2 роки тому

    29 inch wheels please! :)

  • @charlesd9949
    @charlesd9949 6 років тому

    How would it operate in a Canadian Winter?

    • @gulli2356
      @gulli2356 5 років тому

      William Lauzon I have winter tires on mine haha

    • @Mindsi
      @Mindsi 3 роки тому

      Or India roads!

  • @JohnHuffel
    @JohnHuffel 5 років тому +1

    Vandaag opgehaald en vind het waanzinnig, wat een ervaring , zeker een aanrader, en niet altijd naar geld kijken hoor.

  • @rara-xq5nn
    @rara-xq5nn 4 роки тому

    It does not have SUSPENSION, why

  • @Karel.C
    @Karel.C 5 років тому +10

    Stromer, make longer front fenders, they're useless!

    • @billbanche4605
      @billbanche4605 5 років тому +1

      YES, in the rain that front wheel will produce a rooster tail of dirty water all over the rider.

  • @noonster55
    @noonster55 6 років тому

    what's the range

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому

      Depends on many many factors, but we say between 40 and 100 miles

  • @josealvarado3243
    @josealvarado3243 6 років тому

    why the apron? are they making a 10k cake!!! joe from nyc

  • @rook-tv
    @rook-tv 6 років тому +1

    Beautiful

  • @moos7005
    @moos7005 6 років тому

    No give away 😊?

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому

      I wish!

    • @vannbrownvb
      @vannbrownvb 6 років тому

      Time to talk too my bank

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  3 роки тому

      @@henryrooyakkers797 With enough heat after extreme climbing, the system will start restricting power so as to not overheat. You have to be doing a lot of climbing at full power. Honestly, in most cases you won't run into this, although on a hot day with a lot of climbing you may notice a bit decrease in power after some time

  • @Visser2800
    @Visser2800 5 років тому +3

    Very beautiful bike BUT... 10.000 euros!!! These speed pedelecs are way overpriced, but they sell. So why drop the price, hey Stromer? Although a very beautiful bike, it has some cons. 1) Price 2) Expensive parts3) Not adjustable (modifiable)Just as a comparison:I have a 3700 euro ST1 (slightly modified suspension seat post and new saddle) . Did my first chain and chain wheel and cassette replacement at 12.000 km (after 1.5 years). If me riding position is not optimal, I change the stem to an adjustable one to sit more up straight. The parts on my bike are standard bicycle parts which have "normal" prices, and are not exclusive (read: expensive) parts.Maintenance and service costs after 12.000 km:Tires: 4x 20 euros = 80 euros (winter and summer tires)Cassette / chain / gear wheel : 230 euros (placement included)And top of the bill:While riding with boost mode activated and wind calm (or tail wind), the speed goes to 50+ km/hr with extra paddling. That's faster then the ST5.Only downside is range. With a 522 mAh battery, I get 35- 40km on maximum support with a full charge (afer 1.5 years)Up to you to make the choice ;-)

  • @tanjamaes6381
    @tanjamaes6381 5 років тому

    Joseph Maes : Its a pitty, i drove 13years with an normal bike to my work in Antwerp(28km/day), now on pension i don't yet need such a sofiticated bike. Is there no design planned for bike loving pensioners?

  • @omegamarshallzero
    @omegamarshallzero 4 роки тому +3

    I love all the people bitching around Stromer's price.
    Same people that enter a Ferrari's showroom yelling:
    "hey, I can get a Ford Fiesta for a fraction of that price" :D :D :D

  • @lashesfordaze
    @lashesfordaze 6 років тому +2

    No mention of estimated cost?!?

    • @mjakob2004
      @mjakob2004 6 років тому

      The Bike cost 9999$

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому

      Good point. $10k for the ST5!

    • @ArthurDentZaphodBeeb
      @ArthurDentZaphodBeeb 6 років тому

      The New Wheel Electric Bikes Only $5K overpriced - but I guess they need that fat profit so as to fly dealers in for junkets :)

    • @Ropetable
      @Ropetable 6 років тому

      for 5k you cant get quite the same standard. but for 7k you can, kind of but not really. actually is there even a comparable pedelec with hub motor like this?

    • @sfwom1
      @sfwom1 6 років тому +3

      The bike is cheaper than a car. You get exercise without a gym ($$) and how much money do you pay for your car's gas, insurance, tickets and repairs?

  • @ahkl77
    @ahkl77 6 років тому +1

    Heavy rear end though. This being 2018, they could have gone for Bosch Performance Line CX and the benefit of a sprung mid-drive unit.

    • @Leynad778
      @Leynad778 6 років тому +1

      With a hub-motor you get recuperation and less stress on the transmission. Even without motor i had to replace chain and cassette after about 2500 km with my XT-hardtail. With XTR this is even far more ridiculous expensive. And the CX is less efficient without electric power because of more friction.

  • @purpledreams7
    @purpledreams7 6 років тому +5

    Holy shit i love it but i cant probably afford it.

    • @greensavant2573
      @greensavant2573 6 років тому +5

      That is what I said until I test rode an ST2S. Kept my car (236,500 miles on it now) and instead got the ST2S. I basically swapped a new car payment for a bike that I love, and do not regret it at all.
      I don't think that I should test ride the T5 however!

  • @BobiR-bl9fc
    @BobiR-bl9fc 6 років тому +4

    I love it but I dont have money

  • @truthbespoken7750
    @truthbespoken7750 6 років тому +14

    Nice bike but still way over priced. ... remember when plasma tvs were average $3k but now the same if not better for $600 ...once everyone (makers) jumps on this fad it will drive the prices way down for us normal folks

    • @benegasi
      @benegasi 5 років тому

      overpriced???? wheni drive with this to my work over 4 years i buy me ml350 for free of20000 euro

    • @benegasi
      @benegasi 5 років тому

      long live bike leasing

  • @hmzakin4086
    @hmzakin4086 5 років тому +1

    10k euros pour rouler sur le trottoir car les gens en voiture marche sur la piste cyclable; mais très bon vélo mais dans les pays comme France ou Belgique faut oublié

  • @beck4218
    @beck4218 3 роки тому

    or any 85nM Bosch or Shimano bike that weighs 40% less.

  • @RoyMcAvoy
    @RoyMcAvoy 6 років тому

    Still using hub motor? I don't think it is worth it to pay that much.

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  6 років тому +1

      Just wait to critique until you give it a try. Not all hub motors are equal and Stromer’s is phenomenal. Not for everything and everyone, but for a bike like this you wouldn’t want anything else.

    • @siclmn
      @siclmn 4 роки тому +1

      Most people who are looking at electric bikes can be sold on the mid drive models. What they don't know is that the mid drive is crap. It will wear out the chain sprockets and chainring and then you will be back at the bike shop for a yearly replacement of those parts. That will keep the bike shop in business and they are counting on that. The mid drive also makes noise that you don't need to listen to. There are a lot of cheap bikes out there and if everything in your life must be cheap and kind of a deal then go for it, but if you desire the best then there is Stromer.

  • @droydrida7541
    @droydrida7541 3 роки тому +1

    bon vélo , mais pas de suspension et trop cher , autonomie de batterie moyen , après pour du plat , j'avoue c'est un bon

  • @JoLe1991
    @JoLe1991 4 роки тому +1

    48Nm is a joke, it won't get you up a hill in its optimal speed range by far.. which means it will heat up, a bad situation, especially considering that the controller is built into the hub motor. electronics are heat sensitive, much more than motor windings. if it were in the 2000-3000$ range all these drawbacks would be ok... by the way, these bikes are full of proprietary parts which means, repairs will cost you a fortune! for the money of a replacement motor (for all those that cook on extended hill climbs) you can buy an entire bafang mid drive kit which has triple the torque and will not overheat ever, all you need to take care of is the drive train wear. living in Switzerland I can guarantee it is very hilly

    • @andrewhilger7370
      @andrewhilger7370 4 роки тому

      I have the Stromer ST3 with a max of 44Nm and it's more than enough up hills. It seems to have far more high end torque (even up hills) than the Bosch Performance CX (that I have on my cargo ebike) --the Bosch seems to have far more lower end torque than the Synodrive II on the Stromer.

    • @JoLe1991
      @JoLe1991 4 роки тому

      @@andrewhilger7370 well then you haven't compared it to a bafang mid drive (up to 160Nm @ 1:1 gear ratio) or even a emtb mid drive like bosch performance cx (85Nm). even if electric motors can produce torque up to 0rpm, doesn't mean it's a good idea to run them at lower than rated speed under full load. the efficiency drops drastically at full load (max assistance) below 30km/h for the stromer motor, since it's wound to achieve 45km/h. while the argument of regenerative braking does save brake pads downhill, it doesn't account for the lack of drive efficiency uphill (anything >5% gradient). with a mid drive and a wide gearing ratio you can climb any hill to the point where you must fear to burn your disc brakes downhill, while any hub motor will heat up dramatically and let you do most of the work before eventually cooking the winding insulation or even the controller if it's integrated inside the hub motor like on many Stromer models.

    • @andrewhilger7370
      @andrewhilger7370 4 роки тому +1

      @@JoLe1991 I don't have any disagreement with anything you say here. I'm just saying my ST3 with 44Nm has, for me, plenty of torque going up steep hills. And no mechanical problems from overheating. Not yet anyway.

    • @JoLe1991
      @JoLe1991 4 роки тому

      @@andrewhilger7370 a friend of mine just recently cooked his st1 motor. it was a hot day, around 34°C, he pulled the child trailer in the back, the bike was probably preheated from standing in direct sunlight (plus it has a black frame finish), and after a short time it stopped working for ever. he first thought the battery somehow produced overcurrent (which is impossible), but it was clearly controller failure due to excessive heat inside the motor (black aluminum is an excellent IR absorber and emitter, but if the sun is pounding on it, the absorbtion clearly dominates the emission.

    • @JoLe1991
      @JoLe1991 4 роки тому

      one more criticism about stromer: for this price, other brands will put high end suspension forks and a high end rear shock on the bike, whereas I see countless Stromer bikes with a stiff fork that is horribly uncomfortable and costs next to nothing to produce. a high end air fork alone has a retail price of at least 500$

  • @mickalinjezerx7104
    @mickalinjezerx7104 6 років тому +1

    1-250 thousand dollars every day easy convert ebike.

  • @fx02zbn
    @fx02zbn 5 років тому

    Nice bike but crazy money. You have to register it and tax and insure it just like a moped. Why not spend a third of the money and buy an e Scooter with twice the range and much better equipment?

    • @joerivankallo
      @joerivankallo 5 років тому +1

      I think, and then speak for Belgian customers, it is more profitable to drive an ebike, than an electric scooter. First, with a pedelec you have some movement, with a scooter you are lazy. And second, most of these stromer models are on a leasing through our employer, which give a compensation for these pedelecs making it profitable when using it to drive to work. In my case it is break even, and I have a nice pedelec to use in my private time for free.

  • @johnsylvan8600
    @johnsylvan8600 3 роки тому

    I purchased one of these. Nice bike but purchased with a Shumplf front gear hub even though this should be a robust gear it failed after 1000 miles. Pulled gear and discovered gear is horribly designed. My $3000 Strommer is now out of action and Schumplf won't honor 5 year warranty. @

  • @YoWassupFresh
    @YoWassupFresh 6 років тому +3

    ten. thousand. dollars.

    • @omegamarshallzero
      @omegamarshallzero 4 роки тому +1

      not very much really. A Stromer's engineer can earn up to $150 an hour. Minimun wage in Switzerland is £25.5 per hour. Cost of work is higher if compared with the US.

  • @tsmith3139
    @tsmith3139 5 років тому +1

    For 10 thousand it should fly! Way too much money!

    • @thenewwheel
      @thenewwheel  5 років тому +1

      You'll have to pay a bit more for something that can fly :). The Stromer isn't for everyone, but the value is high and if you have the budget for a really nice vehicle, this is one of the best you can buy.

  • @drs-Rigo-Reus
    @drs-Rigo-Reus 5 років тому +1

    11.500 euro's.

  • @siriosstar4789
    @siriosstar4789 4 роки тому

    I love your bike shop and the people are wonderful but you guys have swallowed the hype .
    Apologies but i can't begin to tone it down .
    I live about twenty minutes from switzerland so i have a feel for why the swiss have been convinced that this is a super bike , in one word - Presitge.
    The swiss as well as the germans are enamored with presitige to the extent that it blinds them to the reality of the situation .
    Motor- FORTY EIGHT NMs ? that's pathetic compared to mid drives like bosch, brose , tQ ,
    shimano , sachs etc . It's the NM, on a geared mid drive that provide power for hills and increased range . And Switzerland definetly has some hills .😂
    The bike is very heavy and the components are nothing special .
    The price is absurd. one could get a Riese &Muller for that price or a high end full-suspension
    MTB with top of the line components . both would be far and above the Stromer .
    Sorry but this company has shown master ship in presentation not engineering .

  • @patriotone755
    @patriotone755 5 років тому +1

    10k...nope.

  • @truckhighwayshop
    @truckhighwayshop 4 роки тому +1

    Hahahaha what???? For that amount of money i buy a car 😂😂😂😂

  • @iancharless
    @iancharless 6 років тому

    It's a 10,000 dollar bike

  • @pdotterw
    @pdotterw 6 років тому +2

    $9,999.99

  • @mickalinjezerx7104
    @mickalinjezerx7104 6 років тому

    Lest than 30 mph

  • @mickalinjezerx7104
    @mickalinjezerx7104 6 років тому

    Less than 30 mph at max average in eBikes

  • @dagdagdag
    @dagdagdag 4 роки тому

    over priced ebike, 👎