Taurus 605 Polymer .357 Mangum Revolver - Two Year Review - I Now Own TWO of Them!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 жов 2024
- I have owned my Protector Poly for two years now and I have put about six hundred rounds through it so far. How is this plastic magnum revolver holding up? I like it so much that I bought a second one. Do you really need a polymer .357 mag revolver?
No one can ever claim you are a gun snob. Keep doing what you are doing.
This review was so good I can't wait for the 30 year review. That revolver looks great.
My son will probably be doing the 30 year review 😁👌
@@mixup98You'll only be 90-sonething. We'll all chip in, and by you a Hoveround. 😂
@@tylermorrison7051 Umm, I wonder if I can mount a gun rack on a Hoveround? 😛
@@mixup98 I like the way you think.
@@mixup98 I hope I will be here to watch... or not ! 🤔 😂
I picked up this poly pocket rocket at a pawn shop, maybe 4 or 5yrs ago. it's my only wheel gun in my collection.
It's still part of my EDC rotation when making a quick trip to the corner store or checking the mail . It's one Hella Lil pocket rocket.
No -issues what so ever.
I only shoot 110 grain and the heaviest I go is 125grain. In .357mag.
Very pleased with this Lil pistol over the years that I acquired it.
I got one of these last week at my local gun store for $300 plus tax, love it! Its a tractor gun, slides right into my pocket...
Just picked mine up used, but not much!!! For 245 OTD!!! Previous owner didn't even shoot enough to wear the finish on the recoil shield!!!
At one time you could not give me a Taurus. Now they are an excellent weapon. The new CEO turned that company around!
That is one reason why I like three inch barrels better than two inch. A longer ejection rod. That extra barrel inch also gives better muzzle velocity and energy. The big problem I have with snub nosed .357 Magnums is there is a lot of recoil with lower muzzle velocity and energy so might as well be shooting .38Spl. +P with less recoil for close to the same velocity and energy. The lighter weight like with the poly plastic a revolver is the more felt recoil. Thanks for sharing.
3” (at least for me) balances better as well
@@lewis45acp I agree and an ever so small increase in sight radius but its there.
The "357 snub might as well be .38 +p" thing just isnt true. A .357 out of a 2 inch barrel will almost always be SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful than a .38 +p out of even a 4 inch barrel.
Paul Harrel has proven this many times. Stop spreading misinformation. It's not "close to the same velocity." There is generally over a 50% increase in energy with .357 vs .38+p in a 2 inch barrel. A LOT more powerful.
Shooting 125gr .357, and .38+p out of a 2 inch barrel, Paul got the following results
.357 - 1258 FPS average
.38+p - 841 FPS average
That's a staggering difference.
@@cameronnorton5898 "The "357 snub might as well be .38 +p" thing just isnt true. A .357 out of a 2 inch barrel will almost always be SIGNIFICANTLY more powerful than a .38 +p out of even a 4 inch barrel.
Paul Harrel has proven this many times. Stop spreading misinformation. It's not "close to the same velocity." There is generally over a 50% increase in energy with .357 vs .38+p in a 2 inch barrel. A LOT more powerful.
Shooting 125gr .357, and .38+p out of a 2 inch barrel, Paul got the following results
.357 - 1258 FPS average
.38+p - 841 FPS average
That's a staggering difference and bonafide proof that you are 110% full of shit."
Cor Bon 110 gr. DPX .38Spl. +P from a 2 inch barrel is 814fps. Cor Bon 110 gr. JHP .357 Magnum from a 2 inch barrel is 928fps. So don't try to sell me your garbage.
Except you get 200 fps more than 38 plus P. Its not nearly the same. Thats a myth.
As you stated, Mixup, the 5-shot Taurus revolvers featured in this video are OK. 👍 However, it's my point of view that the 6-shot Taurus 856 with a 2-inch barrel is even more OK! 👍
You're right Noah, the Taurus Model 856 is a great revolver and as you probably know I own two of them. Here is a video review that I did on one of them: ua-cam.com/video/mdtLdEQ2X90/v-deo.html
@@mixup98 Like you, Mixup, I'm also happy to be a 1712 guy!
Same. I have an 856 and what closed it for me was the 6 round capacity. Over 1,000 rounds later and no issues.
I own a 606 taurus in stainless. A 6 shot .357, it's my edc. Love it.
Nice gun. I have the 605 in stainless steel and like it a lot. I use it as my truck gun.
I've been toting this gun for years. Very concealable and controllable. Accurate for me
.
Very enjoyable return look at the Protector Poly. The zombie version was pretty cool, as well. Barnes solid copper projectiles usually perform better than that - might have been that the short barrel didn't allow them to reach a more optimal velocity for expansion. Another fun and engaging episode. All the desert critters scored on pumpkin guts and seeds! Stay safe out there. Cheers.
Taurus has definitely stepped up their game. Love the video thank you
They've come a long way with their quality control recently.
That Punch ammo was great. The guns are ok, but seeing how well that Punch ammo performed was the unexpected gem of the show, for me.
Good morning, Mix! I enjoy our Sunday morning video visits. It's like a weekly appointment.
Good morning John. I should have another video posted next Sunday. Stay tuned my friend.
Love my 605 poly had mine a year no issues other the cost of 357 pawpaw 😊
I have two of these as well. One of them developed a problem that causes the hammer to feel like its getting caught on a "snag" when being cocked to shoot in single action. It does not affect its function but I still retired it out of an abundance of caution. I contacted Taurus and they told me that I would have to pay shipping both ways and I wasn't doing that. The other one still works like it did out of the box, no problems at all. They both are fairly accurate. I can put 5 inch groups at point of aim on paper at 15 yards, more than acceptable considering these guns are meant to be used in "get off of me" type of self defense situations. The double action trigger leaves a lot to be desired, both of my samples feel like a 25 pound pull.
Nice review. I have a SP-101 Ruger all stainless in .357 it kicks enough. That Taurus must kick worse ouch 🦅🇺🇸
Another great vid! And I agree with you - the 605 Poly is OK but I chose the all steel 605 myself. These are great revolvers for the money. Oh and I do carry 38 Spcl +P handloads with 140 grain Lehigh Defender bullets at about 1000 fps.
As always, another great, informative, and entertaining video. Thanks!
I have one too. I love it! It's a great backup carry in any pocket. BUT do not load it with full house 357s. Mild to midrange is what I suggest. I sent it in because I bent the cylinder/ejection rod from a full house load. They fixed it and its back to running 100%. Another thing. Loctite that screw near the trigger. If not, it will back out a tiny bit and cause the cylinder to lock up. The front sight also flew off. Easy fix. I put a large shot gun sight in its place. They simply screw in. Very inexpensive fix. Other than that, it serves its purpose very well!
My Taurus 605 is still running good only had the ejector rod get loose and needed tighten. That zombie one you have is different, I've not seen one before. Might have to try out that ammo if I find some , have shot different calibers of the punch but not 38 special. Thats for the video and taking us along
I’ve have a protector poly for about 5years put almost 500 rounds through it no problems
I have an older 606 it's a six shot .357 from taurus in stainless steel. I carry it everywhere. Taurus really has stepped up thier game. I bought it used and have put a couple hundred rounds through it of good Hornady. 357 hollow points and cheap-O Armscor .38 special. Not one malfunction. I trust my life to it for sure. Keep spreading the good word!
Hello Terry. You're right, Taurus really has stepped up their game over the years and I own a handful of their handguns. My son and I thank you again for watching our videos and have a safe and Happy Thanksgiving!
Interesting, we actually didn't know this in pistol existed. Would be a nice revolver for the tackle box.
Thank you for sharing this information. God bless 🙏
I have a Taurus 22lr Ultra Lite and it holds 9 rounds. It is my go to gun for carry around town. It is a fun revolver and Taurus is not making it any more. I found it in a gun store ,used and bought it for 125.oo. A bargain. It never has had a missfire and it is a great pocket gun. It is single or double action.
I really wanted to like mine, but I had two issues that required sending them back to Taurus....the 2nd was irreparable and it took a good 3-4 months to get the new one. I clearly received a lemon and with budget firearms that's more of a reality than it is if you spend a couple hundred more. I knew that going in though. IF you can save the couple extra hundred for a snub I'd do so, if not I'd go for the steel version which can be had at the same price. I really liked pocket carrying the 605 Poly, I really did to the point where it was my main edc simply b/c it was so easy to pocket carry, but it was a huge let-down for it to have so many problems considering the fact that I only had about 250 rounds thought it (95% of those rounds being soft .38 special range ammo).
That being said, I'm not a Taurus hater in that I can't rave enough about my 6", 7-round, Taurus 66. No problems whatsoever regardless of how cheap, soft or hot the round to the point where I'd have no problems with making it my "nightstand" gun.
I like the Federal Punch, that’s what I carry in my LCR
I bought a Taurus 605 Polymer .357 magnum about 10 years ago. I use it as a nightstand gun for quick access.
I saw several of the same kind of revolvers in the gun show and was tempted to buy one.
Love your videos. I watch every one start to finish. Cool revolvers for a fair price. Im partial to s&w but can't hate affordable and functional options giving more people choice for defense
👍😎 😎👍
Brother, I love watching you shoot!
Greeting from Northern Nevada. Absolutely enjoy the videos, keep up the great work!
Awesome! Thank you and hello from southern Nevada!
A retired cop gave my mom one of these in .38 after my dad died, I'm really not sure why as she already had his S&W .38 and sort of knew how to use it. I think it was his backup gun at some point, he'd had the hammer tail ground off so it was basically DA only. She ended up giving it to me and I ended up selling it, to me it seemed pretty bulky for being a "light" gun and I didn't like not having the option to cock the hammer.
That Federal Punch looks like effective ammo. 👍
I had a Ruger 2.5” barrel and never cared for the recoil. I prefer a 4” magnum but am looking for a Taurus 605 with 3” barrel to add for more
manageable shot placement and recoil .
Punch is such a good choice.
Thank you for the video
You are very welcome Anthony and I hope you find a 3" 605. I own a Taurus Model 856 with a 3" barrel and I love it but it is chambered in .38 Special +P.
Went out with a bang! Good stuff my Friend. Thumbs up ~John
I have the zombie green model 85 too! Will definitely seek out some of the punch ammo for it! It pretty much is my fishing gun, because the grips match my power bait.
Good shot with the rock....I got so much dang arthritis I probably couldn't even throw it that far!
I bought the 38 special version of this for my wife. After a couple hundred rounds of target ammo, a really tiny washer rolls out of the barrel, so tiny it was tough to find. I hope Taurus comes thru!
@@melissasmess2773 Their new G-series pistols are pretty solid but the revolvers are still iffy.
I pick up my Taurus poly 65 Protecter 357 revolver at my local GUN shop used for $300 about a year ago still carry mine loaded with 357 just a great shooting little revolver.
Tulster makes a badass IWB holster. More than worth it
I LIKE MY SNUB NOSE S&W 357 BEST OF ALL MY HANDGUNS.
Very accurate & easily carried!
Really enjoying my 4 inch Taurus 66. Not sure about a 3 inch. Maybe one day
Great video and as usual, excellent shooting. Thanks!
Good shooting there my friend. That looks like a very unique pistol. I've been on the fence about purchasing that pistol for quite sometime now but for some reason haven't pulled the trigger yet? Thanks for the video.
I'm carrying the Barnes in my Taurus 66 right now. Seems those cartridges are not really good .
Had to put my plans for the Taurus 44 on hold as those have gotten really expensive.
Instead, stumbled over a S&W bodyguard with laser that I could grab new for 320$. Fine little revolver. Will put the Federal punch in there as by your recommendation.
Thanks for sharing the video 🤙👍
Actually the Barnes bullets did expand very nicely. I have reviewed several different calibers of Barnes ammo and I carry Barnes in my EDC 9mm pistol. I recommended the Punch mainly because of the reduced recoil in the relatively light weight Taurus poly revolver.
The pumpkin approves of your shirt.
P.S. That green Taurus is the perfect template for an afternoon with a couple beers and a rattle can or two.
Awsome as always. Many thumbs up to your videos. Stay well & safe out there.
The 605 Poly is a solid shooter. Have the FDE version and have shot several hundred rounds. Gotta watch the screws that hold it together. Tighten them, they have some thread lock on them but .357 loosens them. Great firearm and light. Snappy but light and you have five rounds of Mountain Lion killing protection. Great boat gun or if you are a hiker in the lower 48.
I haven't had any problems with the screws coming loose, at least not yet, but thanks for the suggestion. 👍😎
@@mixup98 The one that holds the frame together came loose and caused the barrel to lock up. After tightening no issues
Good to know and I will keep an eye on it....thanks Chris.
I have this Taurus 357 , its a brown color. Thanks for including the holster information.
I have had mine about 4 yrs now.I love mine, I have had no issues with mine so far and have around 500 rounds of 38 special and around 400 rounds of mild and full house magnum rounds. its a solid little gun for the price. only issue I run into is with some full house loads they stick in the cylinder when trying to eject the cases so I stay away from any loads that cause this issue. I carry mine with underwood ammo 357mag xtreme defender and have had no issues shooting these rounds
Damn I'm old.
I still use my 2" Colt Agent, when I walk the dog at night!
I've got a Ruger Sp101, 357/38 special. I cant imagine the recoil on this gun. My Ruger is very heavy and that thing is a hand cannon!
I was always hesitant to buy one due to believing that the polymer offered very little in the way of recoil absorption. ( my reference is my Taurus Judge poly Defender: beastie recoil on that thing Mr Mix lol ) so I’ve avoided the poly .357. “ Looks good on though” lol Thanks, have a great day Sir.
I can honestly say that shooting magnum ammo through a poly revolver is no fun 😟 Thanks for watching my video and you also have a great day!
Great video Sir! Miss seeing your son with you tho 😊
You and me both! Unfortunately he had had to work yesterday when I shot this video. I promise he will be in my next video though.
I got a Smith and Wesson model 19 maybe a little older but I don't have any complaints about it so far
Yeah, a polymer .357 is probably going to kick like a mule for someone who doesn't have good ol' Mixup's strong hands and expertise. Sure does blow away those "zombies," though! 8D
Thank you for doing a gel-shoot and for the ammunition recommendation. =)
Thank you PantherPurr 👍👍
Hello and good day! I love the update on your 605 Poly however I do have a question, how are the fibre optic sights going? Normally fibre optics go loose or melt a bit after quite some time and knowing that the 605 poly is in .357 I was just curious if it held up well or if you had those issues.
Great video by the way! ❤
Hello and good day to you too. I haven't had any problems with the fiber optic sights on either of my revolvers. If I have any issues with my poly revolvers I will be sure to do an updated video showing and explaining the problem. Thank you for watching my video and I also appreciate the compliment.
Always informative and entertaining ❤
Thanks!!!
I suspect it's not the interest in the revolver as it is you doing a video. You've reviewed a million guns that I've no interest in buying,but you reviews are excellent
Thank you for the nice feedback, Steve. I appreciate it.
Thanks for sharing your knowledge and keep your videos coming please.
Thanks, will do!
I don't see the advantage of a poly body on the revolver if it still weighs 20oz. Looks like it is a bit thicker than the metal revolver at the same weight.
Another great video. Thank you.
You save 4 ounces on the poly vs the steel, which is probably not worth it.
I have the metal 605, and I like it quite a bit. Don't know how I feel about a polymer revolver....
I like all metal revolvers myself ! If I get another poly, it may as well be a semi .
I assume you've never pulled on 22LR LCR trigger.... Oooff 🤷♂️
I've an old 605 2.25" high polish SS 357 ,looks like cross between a Rossi and Smith, made in 1994 before they changed tooling.
It's a zero tolerance revolver .
I love my Taurus protector 605 .357. it is also the first magnum revolver i bought.
I have the 85 in 38 spl... Shoots high but reliable
Have the Poly Protector 605 in FDE , it is a solid little gun that should not be the only gun you have. Mine was 319.00 and a steal for hand cannon you won't mind getting stolen or confiscated should you have to use it. Got it cause love my Smith & Wesson 686 6" and know the round is quite enough all the way up to Grizzly bears. .357 penetrates 6 pieces 2" x 4" boards like butter. It is a great round and until the the.44 magnum most powerful handgun round. Taurus has become quite a contender, the new Headquarters in Bainbridge , Georgia makes a lifetime warranty and quick turnaround easy. Good stuff!
Now i gotta buy one
Awesome mr.98😎🤓!!! Love the canyon echo as always!!!!!!!!
Right on!
@@mixup98 thanks MR. 98!! How about a long range rifle shoot in the canyon video sometime, focusing on zeroing a new scope/ moa, etc for a new rifle and owner 🤓thank you sir!!
@@christoFlair777 Hello Christopher. Unfortunately I don't have a sturdy shooting bench, which is why I don't do long range rifle shooting. I shoot on public land here in Nevada which means I couldn't leave the bench in place as it would either get stolen or destroyed. Perhaps I should buy a portable shooting bench and get into long range shooting, scope mounting and zeroing, etc. Thanks for the suggestion but it might be next spring before I can buy a bench and get it set up.
@@mixup98 thanks for responding Mr 98😎! I understand,, however I’m not saying 1000 yds or anything 😜maybe just 300 or so to hear some awesome echo on steel plates!! Thank you again!!!
@@christoFlair777 👍😎
Not a bad looking 357 mag and 38 special thanks for sharing mixup98
Sweet gun, and loving the semi exposed hammer too
Thank you for an awesome video Ray
You are very welcome my friend.
@@mixup98 it’s kind of nice to know your son’s first name too now I don’t have to refer to him as Junior wishes as far as I’m concerned is more pleasant than calling him Junior
I have the 6050 stainless double action! I love it!!!
I just got a Taurus 856 Ultra Lite Black. Put a Houge grip on it and keep Federal Punch in it. I carry Federal Punch in my S&W M&P Bodyguard .38 too. Shooting .357 Magnum in a two inch barrel and polymer frame is gonna kick quite a bit.
Ugly firearm, but as long as it performs,it’s a keeper. Personally, never been a fan of the looks with polymer revolvers, but I know there are people who say that about any polymer firearm. Thanks for the video sir!!
Cool that you beam in for these reviews. :)
🎃 great lookin piece, I kinda like the zombie 38spl+p 🧟♂️
Good morning pauliewalnuts. Here is my video review on my Zombie .38: ua-cam.com/video/GfZOvac5BXQ/v-deo.html
so do I, it is something different
I need to start working on increasing the view count for your CX4 Storm videos so that you make more of them. :-) Thank you for another great video.
Mix, as you know, I respect your opinions. I personally have had SO many issues with Tauri pistols (revo and semi), that I just could never recommend them. I do realize there are some decent Taurus designs (the Millennium/G2,3,4 designs), but...just punched too many times to go there....
You gonna put out some more Mix and son nature themed vids?
Sorry to hear about your problems with your Taurus firearms. I own a good handful of Taurus firearms and the only problem I had was with the Spectrum .380 semiauto, which I was able to fix myself. I do recommend the Taurus 856 revolver and the G-series semiauto pistols, which have been excellent.
I've had good luck with all my Tauri. I do know of problems with some of the revolvers, mostly related to poor metallurgy. The designs are good. The GX4 is a damn good offering. I carry it more than my 365XL (because the Romeo Zero is crap, I have a Holosun on the GX4)
Beam Me Up Mixup, I'll come shoot with you!
Cool Videos, and great personable attitude as always, great channel!
Awesome! You just made my day....thank you and have a great weekend.
Great video review 👍!!! Keep up the fight!!! Thank you!!!
That's got to be a handful!
Both impressive rounds. I would hate to be hit by either.
😎👍👏saludos mr mixup que excelente revolver con un muy buen poder de temaño adecuado para llevar oculto en el bolsillo o en el tobillo como arma secundaria excelente revision👏👏👏
Appears to be a hairline fracture or hopefully just a scratch in the model 85 just below the cylinder. The “scratch” runs horizontally and ends below the M in Model 85. Visible at the 3:00 minute mark.
Hello Brian. Fortunately it is not a fracture. The polymer frame is actually made from two pieces and you are looking at where the two pieces join together. You can see the other joint at the top of the frame just in front of the hammer. You will also notice two nuts at both of the joint locations, which hold the frame together.
I see what you’re saying but I’m talking about the silver metal piece just below the cylinder. The crack looks tiny and may be nothing. It actually ends right below the M. I had a hairline crack in the frame of a brand new S&W 638 which had to be returned for repair.
Academy Sports + outdoors is having a Black Friday sale on the Bronze colored version for $299.99
Thank you, Mix-Up. Try the 150gr 38spl hardcast wadcutter that UNDERWOOD AMMO HAS.
I will....thanks for the suggestion!
@@mixup98 Thank you for responding.
Not a bad choice for outdoors carry gun. Low price, light to carry, weather resistant. A nice boat or car gun. Small, powerful. Can take a scratch or scuffing. Do you know if the laser grips from Crimson Trace fit this model?
According to the Crimson Trace website they do not make any grips that fit this polymer revolver.
@@mixup98 Too bad.... Still, not a bad Summer carry choice. A 20 once gun without giving up effectiveness. Just wish they had added calibers like the Ruger LCRx. And the laser grip option.
Not really understanding the 'poly' thing? Structurally there's a metal gun inside so the plastic just adds unneeded bulk....unless it's for colorization which I'm not interested in. My daily carry is an 850 CIA Ultra-Lite which is basically the same gun minus the plastic covers and any more bulk is unwanted.
I also don't really get the whole "poly" revolver thing. I much prefer a stainless Ruger SP101 or S&W Model 60. Thanks for watching and commenting on my video.
The SP101 is an awesome weapon... thanks for the videos, very informative
@@terrancewilliams138YES, the SP101 is worth it.I'd never trust a Taurus, especially a light weight shooting ANYTHING!. RIA M206 I'd prefer.
Do you think the poly would be better for humid regions? Less corrosion from sweat/humidity. Just curious, and thanks for the video. You rock!
Mine is loaded with speer gold dot 38 special 125gr+p, and I have 4 speed strips loaded with the same load next to it. So, I have 25 rds of +p Gold dots!!!
As always great review.
Hey Mixup how many rounds would you estimate you have fired through the poly 357 protector?????
In the last two years I have fired approximately six hundred rounds through my poly without any problems. I would guess that about 300 of those were magnum rounds.
@@mixup98 Thats impressive. Thanks for answering I was leary of the poly. Not that I have a bias against taurus. Currently own 4 and have owned others which I have good service from
I put mine in a modified sticky holster, and it rides in my pocket!!!
A great video and review.
Support sir from Philippines.
Much appreciated my friend and greetings from the United States. I also want to thank you for subscribing to my channel.
for 5 oz. more i'll stick with my stainless 605 w/ 357 hp. i like the 2 " better than the 2.75 of my sp101 as the barrel doesn't poke into me.
I got the steel 605 for my Mom and put Crimson Trace grips on it for her. Grips cost as much as the pistol. She's getting too recoil sensitive to shoot it, now, at 80 yrs old, even with reduced power 38 Sp. reloads. I need to get her something smaller like a 22 mag or even a .22LR revolver. She doesn't care for automatics. I just can't see paying over $500 for a Ruger LCR, though.
.32 H&R Magnum! Most brands sell a SIX-shot compact revolver for not too much money. "Standard" ammo gives 220 ft-lbs of energy with little recoil, which equals low-power .38 Special! Much hotter ammo is available which does NOT damage the guns................................elsullo
The trigger pull on the 22LR LCR... well I would not recommend for most 80 year olds... It hurts my finger shooting 6 or 8 cylinders worth...
8:43 Hahaha ! Very good! Thanks for the video! 👍
Great video. I do not own a Taurus revolver. Would you trust the quality and functionality of. Taurus 44 magnum? Considering one.
I've never owned nor shot a Taurus .44 mag but they seem to get good reviews. I do own several Taurus model 856 .38 Special stainless steel revolvers and they are well made, accurate and reliable.
@@mixup98 if you could get your hands on a 44 mag would love to see you review it.
@@RichB804 Let's keep our fingers crossed 😎👌
For 245 OTD, this revolver got a lot more interesting!!!
That's a nice looking gun👍