Timber Frame vs Conventional Stick Frame

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @ShelterInstitute
    @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому +189

    Take Your First (FREE!) Step Into Timber Framing with our Online Mini Course - tinyurl.com/u4ty9nm
    We have taught thousands of ordinary people how to build their own timber frame structure, starting with raw timbers & ending with a beautiful 24' x 24' structure. Also check out our 5-day, in-person intensive Purely Post-And-Beam class - shelterinstitute.com/course_offerings

    • @randyrussell6246
      @randyrussell6246 5 років тому +6

      I have built for many decades, hundreads of structures , most every type of log home, post and beam to include conventional . There is a a time and place for each type and method with the many products that go with them. It takes months or years just to master even one of the trades but much longer to be a qualified builder. Having to meet the different codes of each state, county and or city and the codes for ever and ever changing will take far more than a five day course. I do agree that one can build their on house and save lots of money but that depends on the person and their circumstances. I disagree totally about the structural integrity part of this video. I would suggest learning all conventional carpentry first and then move on to beam works and or log works.

    • @j.r.millstone
      @j.r.millstone 5 років тому +16

      @assassinlexx look into ancient Japanese beam construction. ancient Japanese buildings were made with wood-to-wood joinery and no nails and still stand today even though it's a highly earthquake prone area.

    • @CASH-TO-THE-MERE101
      @CASH-TO-THE-MERE101 5 років тому +3

      Shelter Institute 👍

    • @davidbeppler3032
      @davidbeppler3032 5 років тому +1

      @assassinlexx modern earthquakes require modern solutions? Build underground on high ground. No more problems. Immune to earthquakes, tornadoes, and fires.

    • @randyrussell6246
      @randyrussell6246 5 років тому +1

      @ Grant Johnson. Surely you are not saying that I'm a shill for big construction ? I have had many home owner / build it their selves come to me halfway through building their homes or additions to help them, major works in place needing to be taken out from the roof down to the footings, two homes on unstable soil and sinking, dozens of issues. Most of these good people had one common denominator - a person who knew enough to be dangerous for them, a Carpenter or Carpenters helper or another tradesman . People that meant well but found themselves in a world of shit! I have helped a few in my life , worked for low wages for the best and nothing for the worst. I love the can do rugged spirt of American individualism but don't be a penny wise and a pound foolish or bite off more than you can chew. If you have the help and know how to permit and build your house like many do then go for it ! Maybe you have the ways and means to do parts of the work, say the finishes such as drywall ,painting, finish trim and or cabinet's , maybe set windows and installation of the siding or building the decks. There are no codes for the paint job or if your window trim doesn't fit perfectly and most would never know it but you. I am not for big construction when it comes to residential and for those that have or will bite off more than you can chew remember this " you will be stronger for what doesn't kill ya"

  • @Heraclitean
    @Heraclitean 3 роки тому +2591

    I'm starting to get the feeling this guy prefers timber frame construction.

    • @miles11we
      @miles11we 3 роки тому +38

      @@adropintheocean6282 it was a joke, you knob

    • @youngillinoisan4270
      @youngillinoisan4270 3 роки тому +44

      Probably because that’s the best way to build a house that will last

    • @Chris-iz2zh
      @Chris-iz2zh 3 роки тому +5

      Gee i wonder why...

    • @Filmikowe
      @Filmikowe 3 роки тому +34

      @@youngillinoisan4270 I wonder why Americans don't often build brick houses. In my country stick construction is basically unknown and mostly brick houses are build covered with styrofoam for isolation.

    • @youngillinoisan4270
      @youngillinoisan4270 3 роки тому +43

      @@Filmikowe my guess is cost, people don’t want to spend the extra money for a sturdy timber frame or brick house, even most new brick houses in America are just stick frame with a cheep brick façade.

  • @75blackviking
    @75blackviking Рік тому +451

    Is it just me, or are those small model frames the coolest coffee table centerpiece? They're like artwork.

    • @Broken_robot1986
      @Broken_robot1986 Рік тому +25

      I think every house should have a tiny replica house inside.

    • @75blackviking
      @75blackviking Рік тому +9

      @@Broken_robot1986 "Houseception"...

    • @PurpleMonkeyDishwasher88
      @PurpleMonkeyDishwasher88 Рік тому +6

      @@75blackviking Xzihibt - "I heard you like houses inside houses"

    • @steamhelsing9440
      @steamhelsing9440 Рік тому +3

      architecture and scale modeling are indeed, art

    • @sullysullivan1282
      @sullysullivan1282 Рік тому +3

      I used to have one. I just ended up with it somehow, I don't even know. I enjoyed having it around (it was huge though, like a 2' cube) until my former stepmom chucked it into a dumpster because she sucked.

  • @mtpocketswoodenickle2637
    @mtpocketswoodenickle2637 5 років тому +688

    I've spent the last thirty + years doing barn and historical building's restoration.
    Nothing matches the elegance of a hand hewn, timbers framed structure.
    I live daily with the satisfaction knowing my work will be enjoyed and utilized for generations to come.
    Leaving my mark, and preserving the iconic American landscape of the pioneers and our ancestors have left me blessed.

    • @bb-sd8eg
      @bb-sd8eg 5 років тому +17

      MTpockets Woodenickle I tip my hat to you sir. 10 years in the business and working I get a deep sense of satisfaction when handling 100 year old timbers. Even when hung as aesthetics in mc mansions in Vail / Aspen.

    • @pixelatedmushroom
      @pixelatedmushroom 5 років тому +3

      Not with all those SIP panels on it

    • @meatsmell8639
      @meatsmell8639 4 роки тому +4

      @àsper Sounds kinda like you're proposing that lots of people should be killed off, specifically anyone you deem materialistic/don't agree with... treadin on dangerous ground there friend.

    • @mbabcock111
      @mbabcock111 4 роки тому +1

      @àsper your notions are simply a myth.
      overpopulationisamyth.com/episode-1-overpopulation-the-making-of-a-myth/

    • @mbabcock111
      @mbabcock111 4 роки тому +1

      @àsper have an open mind; you may be wrong in your assumptions.
      www.humanprogress.org/topic/dead-wrong-series/

  • @Chris11249
    @Chris11249 Рік тому +196

    Also fire resistance. Thick wood takes longer to burn through, whereas 2x4 are quick to burn through and you have a collapse sooner. Also less salvageable. Great video.

    • @oftin_wong
      @oftin_wong Рік тому +7

      You'd be surprised how quickly a fire consumes a building

    • @oftin_wong
      @oftin_wong Рік тому +4

      @crispycream6882 once you've see how quickly a building goes up because of the containment of the heat inside the space you'd understand

    • @kickittillitworks5357
      @kickittillitworks5357 Рік тому +14

      As a firefighter, from experience and from the book. Heavy timber frame (Type 3 construction) with stands heat so much better than the modern houses today. The modern homes today are so scary, and once they catch fire, they’re done

    • @nhitc6832
      @nhitc6832 Рік тому

      it still doesn't negate the fact that thicker woods are better at fire resistance. @@oftin_wong

    • @oftin_wong
      @oftin_wong Рік тому

      @@nhitc6832 sure...buy think about how often you've seen buildings that are still used with charred timbers inside them ...can you remember seeing even one ?

  • @--Paws--
    @--Paws-- 5 років тому +254

    I remember watching a home renovation show and it showed this method of "timber framing". I asked myself why that house had less materials used compared to the "stick framing" method, I often see in other renovations. Thank you for the explanation.
    The timber frame method reminds me of the cabin style houses and even the traditional Japanese houses.

    • @patdud
      @patdud Рік тому +14

      we dont have access to the mass amounts of virgin and old trees to create homes of this type anymore as its almost all been logged

    • @justalonelypoteto
      @justalonelypoteto Рік тому +4

      ​@@patdud that's the trade-off, I'm no expert but I would trust what was said in that 2x4s are likely not the most insulating thing out there. Timber will use much less wood in many cases, I'm sure, but as you said, 2x4s are much easier to make and come by in your average tree than a massive timber framing piece due to continuous size requirements. That said, timber framing looks awesome, and surely a part of this cost increase can also be attributed to the fact that stick framing is almost certainly much more common on the prefab market than a timber, and that likely lowers the average cost of stick framing by a significant amount
      (what I mean is that it seems like the fact that if a hosue is timber-built, it's much more likely to be a custom job than if it's a stick one, and custom jobs have inherently significantly higher costs)

  • @daveatfullcircleutub
    @daveatfullcircleutub 3 роки тому +86

    I took the home builder class back in the late nineties. We helped to frame up one of the sons home and another project further up the coast. I bought a few of the best Japanese pull saws and chisels I’ve ever had.
    Back then I got a room at local landscaper’s house.
    It was a special trip.

  • @stevebilliter
    @stevebilliter 5 років тому +121

    I worked as a carpenter for over 25 years and never had a chance to build a timber frame home. It really looks like it would be fun to build. I built one post and beam, we called it, where the trusses on 2' centers lined up with 2x6 studs on exactly the same layout--it was quite a strong structure.

  • @Ididerus
    @Ididerus 5 років тому +827

    Cost, cost is the reason we build with dimensional lumber. You can get a whole bunk of 2x4s for the cost of one timber

    • @Luckingsworth
      @Luckingsworth 5 років тому +170

      Yup. Timber makes sense if you own the trees as he said. But out here in the midwest where 90% of land is plains. 2x4s are the way to go.

    • @brogcooper25
      @brogcooper25 5 років тому +39

      Thought there must be a reason.

    • @vii7031
      @vii7031 5 років тому +89

      Do americans mostly build their homes with 2x4s? That seems far too flimsy and uninsulated for my liking.

    • @johnthiessen4749
      @johnthiessen4749 5 років тому +114

      Иван VII.
      2x6 exterior walls, sometimes 2x8.
      Interior is 2x4.
      Usually 2x8 - 2x12 floor joist and a mixture of 2x4 and 2x6 for the trusses.
      Cover that with cheap 1/4” - 3/8” OSB and you’re set.

    • @OldNew45
      @OldNew45 5 років тому +8

      So go somewhere and get them.

  • @jtltet
    @jtltet 5 років тому +146

    There's a lot more wood that goes into the timber frame than what is shown in this video. Before the SIPS go on the roof it would have t&g boards spanning across the trusses to support the SIPS panels depending on how far apart they are spaced. Of course the big factor when deciding between timber frame vs traditional stick frame is cost. Timber frames are much more expensive than traditional framed homes.

    • @Zardoz2293
      @Zardoz2293 Рік тому +9

      Yes, but in his models displayed neither has a roof. Even on a stick home you can use SIPS. Perhaps the major problem with timber frame is having access to the dimensions of lumber you need to build it, many homes now use 6x6 as 2x6@3 due to costs and availability.

    • @scottsthaname1
      @scottsthaname1 Рік тому +14

      Don't forget you will still have to frame in windows and doors and any vent/plumbing/electrical... and to frame that in you'll have to fill in those voids to attach it to the structure... this is like when people try and tell you shipping container homes are cheap... then you go to make one and realize it cost about 3x as much unless you just want a tin can with bed in it and black mold on the walls... the reason everyone builds houses like they do is because it's better.

    • @justalonelypoteto
      @justalonelypoteto Рік тому +2

      ​@@scottsthaname1 ...which wouldn't even be allowed for all I know. Maybe this is just a California thing (I'm European so I don't know a lot about how y'all build), but I eagerly watched "The Modern Home Project", a guy making a few AirBnB's out of shipping containers back when that was the cool thing to do, and was surprised at the fact that they had to basically build an entire house inside the container. Seems like construction laws will require you to make something that cannot simply collapse on itself due to owner neglect, as in if you sold this thing on and the new owner didn't know (or care) to repaint the steel every once in a while, and as a result the roof caved in on them after 3 years because the welds rusted

    • @luke2806
      @luke2806 Рік тому +4

      its expensive because nobody does it.

    • @737smartin
      @737smartin Рік тому +1

      @@luke2806 Maybe nobody does it because it is expensive.

  • @ZacchaeusNifong
    @ZacchaeusNifong 4 роки тому +28

    I don't know how UA-cam knew that I wanted to see this, but I'm so happy that it did. I'm hooked.

  • @chrisguevara
    @chrisguevara 5 років тому +2800

    Can someone please tell him that no one can live in a house that small!!! It has to be at least 5 times bigger. My god.

    • @danemccloskey1290
      @danemccloskey1290 5 років тому +32

      Shaaron Elisha lol I’m dying 🤣

    • @slothmarathonpromotions2470
      @slothmarathonpromotions2470 5 років тому +164

      A home with a floor area of 2 sq. ft. Is. a little cramped but you get used to it.

    • @theycallmefrench
      @theycallmefrench 5 років тому +69

      @[The] White Rabbit It's a Zoolander quote. He is surely joking.

    • @kayalex5940
      @kayalex5940 5 років тому +22

      Hence the Tiny House craze.

    • @gooddrugsfarm9105
      @gooddrugsfarm9105 5 років тому +10

      Hahahahahaha I don't know why I can't stop laughing at this comment!

  • @jhosk
    @jhosk Рік тому +14

    Our barn is oak timber framed and the lumber was harvested off the farm almost 100 years ago. Something about seeing those old beams that warms your heart

    • @SamClemens-n9q
      @SamClemens-n9q 2 місяці тому

      Check out Dwight Eisenhower’s farmhouse in Pennsylvania. You would not believe the size of the hand hewn timbers. I have no idea how men lifted something so big and so heavy without modern machinery. It is just jaw dropping to see in person

  • @musamor75
    @musamor75 5 років тому +11

    Your arguments are very convincing. This is a very informative video. However, I have my doubts about learning timber framing in five days. I live in France, where the cathedral builders go through a ten year intensive training. They live in dormitories, work ten hours a day, study technical drawing at night, and work in their specialised internal workshops until midnight. All weekends are devoted to preparing their first apprenticeship piece- not before 4 years. 2 weeks off a year. If they are accepted they continue their Tour de France- very gruelling. Then they prepare their grand masterpiece, always of mind- boggling complexity. These are the Master Builders. An extreme elite; they are called upon to do the most complex and difficult restoration and building across the whole globe. They are called the "Compagnons du Devoir". They date back to Medieval times.
    Thank you for posting this video. I am a humble cabinet maker myself. Best regards.

    • @jtltet
      @jtltet 5 років тому +3

      I don't think he is implying that you will be an expert in 5 days. Rather, you would learn the basic skills and process.

  • @joshgastin
    @joshgastin 3 роки тому +23

    This is so cool. I have always admired timber framed buildings but had also assumed that they were no longer possible, simply due to the prevalence of stick-framed houses. Now I can dream again!

  • @2nd-place
    @2nd-place 5 років тому +40

    You’ve sold me on building myself a timber frame house. Someday I want to build a retirement home for my wife and I in the mountains and I want it to be off the grid with well water and solar power. This seems like it would meet our needs nicely. We wouldn’t need anything large and I’m fairly handy. I’m sure with a few more decades of experience that I could build the entire thing myself. I would save money on materials, construction, and utilities and I could put those savings towards buying a large plot with good views.

    • @thistles
      @thistles 2 роки тому +6

      I hope you attain your dream. I also prefer to put my money into land rather than a house

    • @nanwuamitofo
      @nanwuamitofo Рік тому

      .... for my wife and (for) ME....

    • @UnskilledGrappler
      @UnskilledGrappler Рік тому +3

      @@nanwuamitofo Hay man. I’m sure your a nice guy butt this dude doesnt even no you . Why would he want too build a house for YOU and youre wife?!
      😬

  • @wadeshimojo
    @wadeshimojo 5 років тому +93

    Ever since I saw that movie Witness with Harrison Ford I've always wanted to build a timber house. Super cool!

    • @Crusader1815
      @Crusader1815 5 років тому +5

      When you're Amish, you don't need things like wiring, plumbing, and HVAC, so, enjoy.

    • @rawkinghorse
      @rawkinghorse 5 років тому +5

      @Da Squirrel D'oeth!

    • @Banryu95
      @Banryu95 5 років тому +1

      I grew up in Lancaster, a couple miles from where that movie was filmed. The Amish are not as idyllic as they were once portrayed to be, and most have taken up more traditional construction methods. Most newly built barns and homesteads are quite sleek and modern. I guess they are still maintaining their traditions, but "Amish" is a very commercial term now.

    • @aparks8244
      @aparks8244 3 роки тому

      good movie

    • @oe542
      @oe542 3 роки тому +1

      @@Banryu95 you’re right. They’re not as behind the times as their initial appearance leads you to believe.

  • @Omlet221
    @Omlet221 3 роки тому +384

    UA-cam algorithm: “You wanna learn the difference between timber and stick frames?”

    • @dodgeguyz
      @dodgeguyz 3 роки тому +6

      I know, where was this when I was researching building my shed? No where,. but 4 years later it shows up!

    • @gyrotech777
      @gyrotech777 3 роки тому

      Hell ya!

    • @Blank3tM0nst3r
      @Blank3tM0nst3r 3 роки тому

      I legit tapped on this video thinking it was from the Onion. The channel icon got me

    • @dcm4n261
      @dcm4n261 3 роки тому +1

      YES
      I
      DO

    • @WallesWillerWalla
      @WallesWillerWalla 3 роки тому

      It's interesting though, because I'm just about to tear down my old kitchen (standalone building) and build a new stick-framed building. I haven't done any related searches.

  • @r.a.mcgeoch7669
    @r.a.mcgeoch7669 4 роки тому +31

    The timber frame is just so beautiful once finished, plus the craftsmanship is just mind blowing

    • @youngillinoisan4270
      @youngillinoisan4270 3 роки тому +6

      And the durability can’t be overstated, I live in a house built by my great great great grandfather in 1873, still standing strong, even after a pipe burst and the house was abandoned for 10 years, I doubt any newer stick frame house will be standing nearly as long without an incredible amount of maintenance and money.

    • @GodActio
      @GodActio Рік тому +9

      @@youngillinoisan4270 There are some timber frame houses nearly 900 years old still in use. I hope your children and great grandchildren and distant descendants get to enjoy your family's legacy home =)

  • @ElAnvaBar
    @ElAnvaBar Рік тому +7

    I absolutely love the warmth of timber frame houses!
    Wood has lived years before it finally became a timber frame house. I think it's an ode to the tree itself to show its magnificent lines and colour, and a warmth you'll get nowhere else.

  • @ZezimaTruth
    @ZezimaTruth Рік тому +2

    I appreciate your completely unbiased comparison.

  • @xxcurtisx21x
    @xxcurtisx21x 5 років тому +286

    "Gypsum palace" I died. lol

    • @boracay12
      @boracay12 5 років тому +4

      Yup ,true too wall to wall gypsum

    • @dangerdavefreestyle
      @dangerdavefreestyle 5 років тому +6

      heavy ass panels of chalk all over the place, uy vey!

    • @thomag1776
      @thomag1776 5 років тому

      xxcurtisx21x Also know as a vinyl palace.

    • @livedandletdie
      @livedandletdie 5 років тому +7

      J Sev, gypsum isn't toxic... it's a fucking food additive... Gypsum boards are dumb due to other reasons, but toxicity ain't one.

    • @jhart7304
      @jhart7304 4 роки тому +1

      @@livedandletdie sure it is.
      try breathing the dust for a while and get back to me.

  • @nikoscuatro7251
    @nikoscuatro7251 3 роки тому +3

    this man looks like an excellent teacher and person.

  • @GadgetEyeGuides
    @GadgetEyeGuides 4 роки тому +52

    Really quite fascinating. There is a definite allure to building structures that could last centuries. I'll keep this in mind when I have the opportunity to build a home.

    • @HawkGTboy
      @HawkGTboy Рік тому +3

      Absolutely. The average modern American home is just a slapped-together pile of building materials that will last for 60-80 years, tops. I wonder what will happen in the coming decades when they start reaching the end of their lives.

    • @truantray
      @truantray Рік тому +3

      Most homes will be torn down in the future because of fashion, not because of construction. 60s bungalows are perfectly fine but being replaced with massive two stories people suddenly want.

    • @truantray
      @truantray Рік тому

      ​@@HawkGTboy they will be replaced with something better.

    • @markoshun
      @markoshun Рік тому

      @@HawkGTboy What do you think will happen to these slapped-together piles of building materials? I do renovations and work on that age of house all the time. Seems to be plenty of life left in them.. On the other hand, the looming problem I see is the steady loss of people who want and know how to do repairs and upkeep.

  • @waynes.2983
    @waynes.2983 5 років тому +5

    My buddy bought a woodmizer sawmill and we not only built our first timber frame, we also milled every part of it. It is a huge barn with hay loft, horse stalls, tack room & an entire house all in one.
    It is going to last hundreds of years.

    • @IamChrisL712
      @IamChrisL712 4 роки тому +1

      Great to hear. How satisfying.

    • @Painfulwhale360
      @Painfulwhale360 14 днів тому

      Thats awesome! Ddi you guys have to season the timbers or did you start building with them as soon as they wrestle cut on the woodmizer?

  • @OnlyNotes
    @OnlyNotes 5 років тому +34

    Just curious, how do you wire a thing like this? Where do your device boxes go... Would they all be surface mount and run with exposed conduit?

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому +22

      Jack Duno GREAT question! You could surface mount in conduit. More typically it is run through the hung wall in chases or run through a chair rail mounted on the inside of the exterior wall. And then too run through the first floor platform and any interior partition walls.

    • @tennesseetexan1957
      @tennesseetexan1957 5 років тому +10

      The SIPs have pre drilled channels in them for electric and plumbing so they are hidden from sight

    • @Johnconno
      @Johnconno 4 роки тому +2

      Everything wireless.
      Chinese!

    • @kaptein1247
      @kaptein1247 2 дні тому

      You can drill through the wood, ofcourse. Wires are often run under the floor or through the ceilings too.

  • @expediter99
    @expediter99 5 років тому +351

    4 bents at 10' is a 30' building. same as fence posts

    • @kickssass
      @kickssass 5 років тому +10

      smort haha

    • @seamusriley3532
      @seamusriley3532 5 років тому +5

      Ikr I caught that too

    • @expediter99
      @expediter99 5 років тому +9

      @doc hall no, look at the model- there are only 3 spaces or bays between the 4 bents, = 30'

    • @unitygroove3118
      @unitygroove3118 5 років тому +26

      Eh, well you, mnh, know... unh, it must be hard to concentrate in between clearing your throat every ten seconds.

    • @jrstf
      @jrstf 5 років тому +18

      I never could understand why each of my houses came up 10 feet short.

  • @kaniphish
    @kaniphish 5 років тому +1066

    Seems to me this guy loves wood so much, he has wood dust coursing through his lungs.

    • @richardspiegel9002
      @richardspiegel9002 4 роки тому +18

      That can also be caused by a mild allergy to his high blood pressure medicine.

    • @timhofstetter5654
      @timhofstetter5654 4 роки тому +11

      Except, of course, that he doesn't actually know very much about real-world framing.

    • @mthomas8338
      @mthomas8338 4 роки тому +13

      Maybe he enjoys to hit a few joints from time to time. Have a couple smokes. Couple beers. Eh

    • @jazzy_cats
      @jazzy_cats 4 роки тому +9

      Doesn't sound too healthy

    • @jamesbondo5895
      @jamesbondo5895 4 роки тому +9

      Is that a 2x4 in your pocket or do you just like wood

  • @PurpleMonkeyDishwasher88
    @PurpleMonkeyDishwasher88 Рік тому +1

    Seeing those models reminds me of back in high school when in one of my elective classes we were given a model kit to build a home of about similar style in size. The material was balsa wood, and we used mainly a miter-box with a small hand saw to fit the frame. Small pins and some wood glue to put it all together. It was incredibly fun to learn how to build a home on a smaller scale, but also learning the techniques and proper spacing of the material.
    I will say there's something immeasurably satisfying about putting/making something with your bare hands.

  • @mikeschlup6886
    @mikeschlup6886 Рік тому

    20 years in Florida as a carpenter. I have helped build both frames.
    The quality of build is the most important part.
    Both frames can withstand a hurricane. As long as you use a good contractor. I have rode out two hurricanes. Opel and Aron. I traveled rebuilding afterwards to. After Andrew I was in Miami for year.
    I have seen streets where you could spot good construction practices for corner cutters easily. The well built homes were still standing. Building codes are there for a reason.

    • @keithcanfield3251
      @keithcanfield3251 4 місяці тому

      This is a really old post but you sound like the guy to ask.
      I moved from California to Tennessee several years ago. I bought a house with a 40 by 40 shop. I'm a retired cabinet maker. A couple of years later a large pine tree fell across it and I had a new shop built by a reputable company.
      Being from CA. I had never seen timber frame construction. When I saw 2 by 4 studs going up on 2 foot centers and 2 by 4 prefab trusses on 4 foot centers I began to question the builder's ability. That's when I realized that's how structures are built back here.
      My new shop was built on my existing concrete slab. There was no joinery that was different than any stick building. There is no diagonal wall braving or shear wall. The outside is clad in metal as is the roof.
      My question is this: is this structure a stick built or timber frame? Does the metal sheathing give this structure adequate rigidity.
      The company did a great job and it's a beautiful building. I'm quite happy, but I really don't know what I have.
      Thanks in advance for any reply.

  • @davidbrogan606
    @davidbrogan606 5 років тому +252

    A stick-framed house can be insulated on the outside of the framing just like a timber-framed house. That being said, timber framing is certainly an elegant way to build a house.

    • @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7
      @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7 5 років тому +3

      i added foam to mine easily...just ask

    • @MsElijah16
      @MsElijah16 5 років тому +1

      How do you insulate on the outside?

    • @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7
      @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7 5 років тому +7

      @@MsElijah16 just nail on foam board

    • @davidbrogan606
      @davidbrogan606 5 років тому +8

      @@MsElijah16 Virtually the same procedure. The house must have no overhangs then sheath the exterior With any number of products and seal the gaps, again many ways. Here is a video by Matt Risinger. This one of many he has on this topic. ua-cam.com/video/7YO0t1FtyCg/v-deo.html

    • @Sunblocker101
      @Sunblocker101 5 років тому +5

      As you said, it's not a nice look with 24" inch studs on the inside. Wider gaps with wider timber is what makes that aestetic possible :D

  • @GarmanyRachel
    @GarmanyRachel 5 років тому +32

    I didn’t know how much I want a timber framed home

  • @joshuasingletary9703
    @joshuasingletary9703 4 роки тому +6

    Thanks UA-cam, I didn’t know I needed to know the difference between timber framing and stick framing

  • @christianheyn
    @christianheyn Рік тому

    I have a barn, about 150 years old, which is made of oak beams, all pegged, and has stood against many Hurricanes/Tropical Storms...just now survived Tropical Storm Lee...with the huge surfaces it has, it's truly amazing that it doesn't yield, though it shakes and creaks during such tough tests. I love the building and feel grateful to the builders every time it toughs out another storm! I'm a woodworker, so, maybe I'm 'biased'...haha! Cutting joints in a heavy beam is just so much fun!

  • @TheBinoyVudi
    @TheBinoyVudi 3 роки тому +1

    The man is an enlightening Guru of construction

  • @unacceptableviews1505
    @unacceptableviews1505 5 років тому +54

    I may have been admiring the model house on the left too much and missed it but there may be another factor you could add to strengthen your cause for this building method: Longevity.A timber frame house can last for hundreds of years whereas conventional framing will be lucky to last 100,especially with contractor shortcuts and lack of inspectors.There was a timber framed barn from Germany that was 500 years old in my town in British Columbia,Canada.The owner had German carpenters label and dismantle it,crate and ship it to Canada and reassemble it for him as a home upstairs/restaurant downstairs.Imagine building a house on your own land and out of your own trees that your great grand-kids could live in one day.That's special.It also makes the high initial building cost very affordable over the long term.

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому +8

      Timber frames are adaptable and durable!

    • @Sunblocker101
      @Sunblocker101 5 років тому +11

      There are a lot of old timberframes and they are truly beautiful and I hope to build one myself one day.
      But conventional framing lasts as long, there is nota difference there, wood is wood.
      Issue as you are describing is bad workmanship and bad techniques, My old house in sweden was from 1925 and it had a conventional frame, after refreshing most of the interior of it while I lived there I found no issues att all with the structure, if moistrue is propperly planned and everything is done right the conventional frame will last just as long as a Timber frame.
      In sweden we learned the hard way with -30c winters and +30c summers and become moisture experts tbh, and now with full mechanical ventilation that controls moistrue too it's going to be even easier.
      So it's not the frame that doesnt last, it's the surrounding systems that make or break it, you can as easily fuck up a Timber frame, enclosing it with no moistrue transportation and airing and if a timber frame rots then you have a 10 fold bigger problem then if a conventional fram would rot, just saying

    • @MrDanisve
      @MrDanisve 5 років тому +5

      @Linus Surface area has alot to say as well, thats why a log lasts so much longer than a small stick. Conventional frames here are Timber frames? 99% of the houses i se in this area is timberframes. Ive renovated a few houses, never came across anything else than timber frames. Greets from your neighbor :P

    • @DGDG0000000
      @DGDG0000000 5 років тому +1

      from your own trees ? you need first to remove resin, then make it dry... do tou have a river ? then do you have 7 years to wait for dry wood ?

    • @unacceptableviews1505
      @unacceptableviews1505 5 років тому +5

      @@DGDG0000000 Cut the trees down in the spring,peel them,and stack them up off the ground.Go back the next spring and build with them.That's how my friends built log cabins.I know some that sent their logs to mills to be kiln dried so they could start sooner but most are willing to wait the year and save the transport and kiln cost.As for building a timber frame house,I would have to hire someone and do what they recommended.

  • @zacksaykawlard1300
    @zacksaykawlard1300 5 років тому +870

    Who else has never watched anything related to this and doesn't know why this is in their recommend?

    • @ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4
      @ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4-ZrSiO4 5 років тому +27

      Idk what it’s here but I sure did enjoy it

    • @tornado649
      @tornado649 5 років тому +8

      Im actually interested now tho

    • @deathbornium
      @deathbornium 5 років тому +6

      @@thinkfirst6431 most buildings here in Germany are mostly bricks and concrete. They are very solid and mostly well isolated. I thought that other countries have picked up but well . Old structures that are built with bricks and wood are also not hard to find, but I have never seen a house made completely out of wood/drywall. This concept is very foreign to me and I am blown away how easy it is to build these.

    • @champxgnee
      @champxgnee 5 років тому +1

      So whats better? Concrete houses? or Wood houses?

    • @JakeTheBeast4Prez
      @JakeTheBeast4Prez 5 років тому

      Here!

  • @apollo3679
    @apollo3679 5 років тому +3

    I’m beginning to design my home. I don’t have property yet, and I know I want to build it myself. I can’t believe how useful this was!!

    • @ZachFish-
      @ZachFish- Рік тому +1

      How is the plan going, and how much experience do you have

    • @gumecindogarcia1070
      @gumecindogarcia1070 Рік тому

      I did a basic pole barn with an elevated floor, I got the experience while in Southern Africa. 32x24 three level and around 9k in materials

    • @ZachFish-
      @ZachFish- Рік тому +1

      @@gumecindogarcia1070 That is solllid!

  • @jonathankerner2094
    @jonathankerner2094 2 роки тому

    I don't think I can resist. I am fortunate in that I have a friend who is a very successful Timber Frame builder. His four port equipment garage is beautiful. He will be a terrific resource if I go deeper into this.

  • @bobrambo6900
    @bobrambo6900 4 роки тому +23

    I’m from Lancashire England & there are thousands of timber built houses hundreds of years old, many 500 hundred years old mainly built of oak

    • @johnnymcblaze
      @johnnymcblaze 3 роки тому +1

      Well that's where the old growth forests went.

    • @gcranston83
      @gcranston83 3 роки тому +2

      @@johnnymcblaze also the navy.

  • @sonsofliberty3081
    @sonsofliberty3081 5 років тому +203

    Amish do this. They're so many of them on the job they look like ants devouring a sandwich. They are just everywhere at once. Once it's up, the youngest get on the roof and start and then a group on each corner working one direction, and a crew framing out windows and doors and a crew in the inside, it's amazing.

    • @JustinL614
      @JustinL614 5 років тому +35

      If ever society collapses the Amish may be the only ones left lol

    • @Matachilangos
      @Matachilangos 5 років тому +12

      Can I pay the Amish for them to build me a house?

    • @vwjetta0000
      @vwjetta0000 5 років тому +11

      @@Matachilangos yes you can, at least in the upstate NY area near watertown you can

    • @robertebersold3817
      @robertebersold3817 5 років тому +9

      Lancaster PA has a number of Amish construction companies who do barns, homes, outbuildings, etc.

    • @jinyow5581
      @jinyow5581 5 років тому

      Nope, cause they won't fight .

  • @bradevans7107
    @bradevans7107 5 років тому +20

    Its kind of nice to know that even though the exterior walls on timber frame have to be stick framed to simply have nailers. At least the question of what is load bearing is an easy question to answer.
    Makes for easier remodeling.

    • @Natedoc808
      @Natedoc808 5 років тому +3

      Brad Evans yup! Big timber frame and you can stand whatever walls you want, can even use soffits to run the mechanicals so it’s even easier to change interior configurations.

  • @ryankinzel7608
    @ryankinzel7608 5 років тому +4

    I would love to come try this course someday if my finances would allowed me to build a new home. Great Video and Amazing Work, I love seeing the timber used in construction be an aesthetically pleasing feature of any home. Peace and Love from Canada

  • @ThisReckless
    @ThisReckless 3 роки тому +2

    Yessss this is what I’ve been looking for and he answered a lot of questions in that short time.

  • @koyonnaanizkatzi
    @koyonnaanizkatzi 4 роки тому

    after seeing this video, I now know that I'm very passionate about the excellence of timber framed buildings. Thank you. I would love to be a student.

  • @scikick
    @scikick 4 роки тому +19

    It's 3am and I'm never in my life going to need this info.

    • @disklamer
      @disklamer Рік тому

      0930 and I knew all this. Still watched for no good reason. Life’s a ride.

  • @williamoverton7265
    @williamoverton7265 5 років тому +91

    Cough drops will fix that.I have trouble with that too. Great presentation.

    • @markthompson4225
      @markthompson4225 5 років тому +4

      I had a professor that did that all the time... his was a nervous tick... brilliant man just had a tick... they both are very smart men and have great knowledge to share

    • @williamoverton7265
      @williamoverton7265 5 років тому +4

      @@markthompson4225 For me it is from years of wood working with poor dust collection ans dry air in the shop?

    • @markthompson4225
      @markthompson4225 5 років тому +2

      @@williamoverton7265 honestly it could be his also... He is not a personal friend or anything... just from what I seen from him here and on the other channel he has been on... Pure Living for Life... it looks like a tick to me... just like the professor I once had... both being very smart men with great knowledge that they like to pass on to other people... which seems like a great thing for people to do... I have a bit of the cough and hack from my youth for the same reason, along with smoking (my parents and my own)

    • @SillyOmega
      @SillyOmega 5 років тому +1

      @@williamoverton7265 the one big down side to power tools over hand tools.

    • @altergreenhorn
      @altergreenhorn 5 років тому

      wouldn't help this guy have a chronic problem with his sinuses.

  • @gsettlemyre
    @gsettlemyre 5 років тому +24

    Jesse and Alyssa with Pure Living For Life is we’re I first seen the timber frame concept in place...and you were there!

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому +6

      We were there! What a busy week that was!

    • @Natedoc808
      @Natedoc808 5 років тому

      You must be a timber farmer otherwise that’s where you would have “first saw the timber frame concept”.

    • @gsettlemyre
      @gsettlemyre 5 років тому

      Natedoc808 No, not a timber farmer, nor a timber framer, just a guy that got hooked on the Timber Frame concept through Jesse. and Alyssa’s build...and yes I picked up on your witty remark right away....because I saw what you did...😬😬

    • @javabeanz8549
      @javabeanz8549 5 років тому

      Jesse and Alyssa did a great job of showing off their class, and Levi did a great job filming the Idaho class! I really enjoyed watching all of it.

    • @honeybadgerisme
      @honeybadgerisme 5 років тому

      aw! Thought you were making a reference to those middle school history reinactment videos thatalways ended with, "And YOU were THERE!"

  • @Dylfunkle
    @Dylfunkle 5 років тому +1

    I was working as a timber framer for a while, favorite job so far.

  • @Jbk_03
    @Jbk_03 4 роки тому

    I just found this video this company. I am in love with this channel. I can't stop watching!! & Listening. All day at work to if I Kept my phone paired to my milwaukee speaker just blaring across the shop. I love these homes so much!!! I ask my significant other!! If we could please change our home build to this. We just got started on developing the land. Thank goodness I found this. 🙌
    Absolute beauty WE love this. So....I am excited to say. Timber frame here we come.

  • @bullpaxton2001
    @bullpaxton2001 3 роки тому +17

    Love how this video is just subtly dropping shade on modern construction.

    • @mikebeasley553
      @mikebeasley553 3 роки тому

      Modern construction is coded for one reason only and that is to enrich the largest lumber companies that have huge budgets for lobbyist. There are numerous practical ways to build your home but you will not be approved by the code. Many techniques have been used for centuries and are still standing. In my coastal NC town the codes have become ridiculous and let's not forget that they are interpreted by some local jackass who has never built a doghouse. Some older homes here (100 years or more) are standing on stacked stones and are ballon framed for cooling. They have been through all the same damn hurricanes as all the rest of the homes in the area. Just saying that building codes are necessary to weed out the idiots but you should be able to build by other methods if you desire. There is more than one way to build a home.

  • @junskey
    @junskey 5 років тому +493

    kind of bummed he didn’t go into the advantages of stick framing. makes this just an ad instead of an informative video

    • @Hawkins-etc
      @Hawkins-etc 5 років тому +92

      I mean, it *is* an ad

    • @dennisnelson1602
      @dennisnelson1602 5 років тому +59

      advantages of stick framing? more job site waste? More lumber? more seams in the envelope? what exactly are the benefits you are describing?

    • @deerkiller61
      @deerkiller61 5 років тому +39

      @@dennisnelson1602 Those are disadvantages, ya dum-dum

    • @danm3780
      @danm3780 5 років тому +72

      @@deerkiller61 lol, no shit? That's his point.

    • @Divertedflight
      @Divertedflight 5 років тому +82

      The advantage of 'stick' framing is that there's far less constraint to the size and proportion of the rooms within the house. One doesn't need to be concerned as to the alignment of the timbers to the edge/corner of an internal divided space. Because of this, some Timber frame homes have hybrid (so called stick frame) interiors.

  • @buildingwithtrees2258
    @buildingwithtrees2258 5 років тому +10

    I built a timberframe/ full scribed log home hybrid once. A very beautiful alternative to cip panels on the walls.
    You can also use full logs instead of square timbers. There's more math and work involved, but can be quite visibly rewarding.

  • @gunner678
    @gunner678 5 років тому +1

    I live in an 18th century solid stone built barn (actually a sheepfold or bergery) with a beautiful exposed timber beam roof. All heated with a wood burner and reciprocating ducts. Life in south West france!

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому

      That sounds beautiful! Pat Henning, one of our founders is originally from France!

  • @DSD
    @DSD 5 років тому +1

    Wow I have no idea why UA-cam recommended this video but damn that was REALLY COOL and now I want a timber framed house!!! That’s also really cool that you do classes teaching this! VERY neat!!!

  • @Sharklee4
    @Sharklee4 4 роки тому +28

    While I love the tradition of timber frame construction I have a problem with the concept of using sips panels for insulation. Sips panels are structural. You can build a very strong house just with sips. A timber frame house with a sips exterior is a double built house, a luxury that few can afford.

    • @commentarytalk1446
      @commentarytalk1446 Рік тому +1

      Another option as said in the video is Straw-Bales (multiple benefits including excellent insulation) when building Timber Frame.

  • @robertebersold3817
    @robertebersold3817 5 років тому +140

    Timber frame: a.k.a. "the way the Amish have done it for centuries".

    • @SammytheStampede
      @SammytheStampede 5 років тому +2

      Robert Ebersold they build the best log cabins.

    • @jhart7304
      @jhart7304 4 роки тому +27

      -amish- Europeans.

    • @Dariet88
      @Dariet88 4 роки тому

      @@jhart7304 thank you.

    • @robincamps8469
      @robincamps8469 3 роки тому

      @@jhart7304 Jup, thanks!

  • @FlyWhistle
    @FlyWhistle 5 років тому +10

    My house been up since the the civil war. We even have the old deed for the land. The structures are all axe hewn still see the deep cuts. The old drywall or Masonite was made with plaster and horses hair. Crazy the history a house can hold

    • @googiegress
      @googiegress 8 місяців тому

      Horses running around naked and freaked out, buff dudes just flexing in their awesome houses.

  • @frotobaggins7169
    @frotobaggins7169 4 роки тому +1

    it's good to see people still promoting timber frame. it's an art form.

  • @beavis4play
    @beavis4play Рік тому

    i went with a (square) log home. it's been 23 years and i love it as much now as the day i moved in.

  • @carlosmontoya2485
    @carlosmontoya2485 5 років тому +85

    I love that style, my wife does to, exposed wood inside. Beautiful.

    • @wisconsinfarmer4742
      @wisconsinfarmer4742 5 років тому +21

      My beautiful wife likes my exposed wood inside.
      Same words different meaning.

    • @ThuhOthers
      @ThuhOthers 5 років тому +1

      The look of timber is very hard to beat!

    • @Network126
      @Network126 5 років тому +1

      @@wisconsinfarmer4742 LMAO! I was thinking the same!

    • @bermchasin
      @bermchasin 5 років тому +1

      you are saying your wife loves your exposed wood?

    • @ohlawd3699
      @ohlawd3699 5 років тому +1

      That's the only way my wife likes wood inside too. 😊👍

  • @theguy9234
    @theguy9234 5 років тому +154

    Id much rather have a timber house than a stick frame house.

    • @jminkvihubyb
      @jminkvihubyb 5 років тому +2

      Which is why so many trees are being cut. It's really bad for the environment but who cares about that, right

    • @Badassbowtie75
      @Badassbowtie75 5 років тому +30

      @@jminkvihubyb 00:35 ...

    • @davidbeppler3032
      @davidbeppler3032 5 років тому +27

      @@jminkvihubyb You are backwards. Rewatch the video.

    • @jminkvihubyb
      @jminkvihubyb 5 років тому +1

      @@davidbeppler3032 wasn't entertaining enough so I closed the video. I already am in trade work so I know exactly what I was saying. Everyone thinks wood is better than everything else and so much of it is wasted. Just looking at the frame, one had more wood than the other.

    • @davidbeppler3032
      @davidbeppler3032 5 років тому +25

      @@jminkvihubyb Yes, the traditional house uses more wood. You were backwards. Either way noting wrong with building using renewable resources. Not sure why you think we are running out of wood, in the US we buy most of our framing wood from Canada.

  • @spar8334
    @spar8334 5 років тому +20

    Almost 2am and this what im watchin

  • @GrannySoupLadle
    @GrannySoupLadle Рік тому

    I agree that if you have a few acres of good trees and a giant Wood-Mizer, skidder, front end loader, and either a really good friend or someone to help you for cheap, you could consider TF.

  • @theflatcat9250
    @theflatcat9250 Рік тому

    I had to search for this video, it popped right up, thank you so much, I thought I was going nuts trying to find a stub to hang anything on, and nothing! I know my dad taught me well, Rest his beautiful soul, and utter talent! Thanks for filling in the much needed gap in my life! Very well explained. I have to hang tapestries only haha
    I am also terrifies of fires, good thing we live literaly across from the fire station, and they are here in a heartbeat when the alarm goes off, and we have months inspections on everything.

  • @webbgroup
    @webbgroup 5 років тому +78

    Friendly reminder: Don't have ice cream before a presentation.

    • @samuelthomas8777
      @samuelthomas8777 5 років тому

      😆

    • @realgenxscott
      @realgenxscott 5 років тому +9

      @@afn-bd2ro frequent throat-clearing but that's probably just a mild nervous tick ... lots of people do it and don't realize it.

    • @HaloWolf102
      @HaloWolf102 5 років тому +5

      I noticed that too very early. I wish I was the person that didn't notice, because when you do, it's awful to listen to.

    • @BoopSnoot
      @BoopSnoot 5 років тому +6

      We played a drinking game where we took a shot every time he cleared his throat. I'm the only one that survived following a liver transplant.

    • @senatorjosephmccarthy2720
      @senatorjosephmccarthy2720 5 років тому +2

      @@realgenxscott, it's a sign of being quite dehydrated. Moreso than many will respond to.

  • @justinschuyler
    @justinschuyler 5 років тому +44

    fella inhaled too much sawdust

    • @jrmbayne
      @jrmbayne 5 років тому +2

      One of the drawbacks of timber framing

    • @TheGreyGhost_of43rd
      @TheGreyGhost_of43rd Рік тому +1

      Yeah he must be doing stick builds more than he lets on

  • @NeutronX101
    @NeutronX101 5 років тому +7

    What happened to using full bricks. Instead of plywood and paper (drywall). I want my house to be build from concrete and steel. Slightly expensive but it will survive.

  • @brianpollstergaard7143
    @brianpollstergaard7143 Рік тому +1

    A few years ago I built a small timber frame house/cabin out of wood logged off the forested property using only the Jack Sobon and Roger Schroeder book as a guide. It was quite a satifying acheivement, as someone with no real construction experience to speak of.

  • @HodZ77
    @HodZ77 5 років тому +2

    What are the issues with using green timbers? I always thought you had to used ‘seasoned’ or kiln/air dried wood, to prevent warping...

  • @varun009
    @varun009 5 років тому +14

    Wouldn't timber framing be traditional and stick framing contemporary?

    • @scottm4193
      @scottm4193 5 років тому +4

      Yes. Traditional = mortis and tenon joints etc with large timbers. Stick framing = modern timber framing with smaller but more timbers held together using nail guns. Much quicker, much cheaper. Often timber 'kits' are produced in factories these days on almost autonomous systems. Smaller timber sizes are cheaper because you can get more from smaller trees. Traditional framing is cool though, I have a lot of respect for the craftsmanship involved.

    • @varun009
      @varun009 5 років тому +3

      @@scottm4193 yeah, I have a 100 acre property in Wyoming (won't say where exactly) that I bought in '09. I've finally saved the resources to build my family retreat and was doing some costing. Land was cheap because its 3 miles in by dirt road from the main road. Pretty clean but could be better. A friend of mine who bought a property a few miles away made his home from a reclaimed barn in Kentucky. It's a fairly large house (500sqyd footprint) but cost way more than I can afford. He spent nearly $200k just finding, assessing, purchasing then transporting the timbers. He had us over for the raising and he told me it was cheaper to do it with timbers. It was pretty obvious why buy I didn't want to cut down any of the larger trees on my property. I have a basically unlimited source of new growth 2"x4" boards which I can get from a construction scrap yard for free. Gonna experiment trying to make my own glulam timbers and sips. I already found a great tutorial on making fireproof insulating concrete. If you have any ideas I can use I'm all ears. I'd like to build as large a home as I can with the money I have.

    • @scottm4193
      @scottm4193 5 років тому +2

      @@varun009Sounds fantastic, best of luck on the project. I work as an energy and construction consultant in Scotland so things are probably slightly different here in terms of codes etc. The standard timber kits here (in mm you'll need to convert to inches) are - timber wall studs 140mm x 38mm fully filled with mineral/glass wool insulation with 25mm rigid PIR insulation on inside face. Timber walls are usually finished with a brick outer leaf or render on blockwork. You can timber clad the kit panels but they don't perform as well in terms of energy efficiency as you have more ventilation in the cavity. Floor build up is usually a suspended concrete slab with 100 - 200mm PIR insulation below the slab. Roof is usually always a pitched 'cold' roof with approx 350mm mineral/glass wool between and over the ceiling joists. This is how 90% of new build homes in Scotland are made these days but our energy efficiency codes might be stricter or not as much where you're from. Cheap but energy efficient and warm in winter. Generally speaking using smaller timbers will save you more money. But you'll need more in terms of numbers to meet engineering structural requirements. My recommendation is to do as much research and watch as many videos as you can and things will start to come together in your head.

    • @varun009
      @varun009 5 років тому +1

      @@scottm4193 thanks for the reply. Research is basically all I'm doing right now. Recent financial gains have afforded me that luxury, but, unfortunately, little else. Our codes aren't strict in that they're not elaborate. This state happens to set energy efficiency regulations but is very lax on how you get to that point as long as your project is in compliance with other building codes (certain distance from trees and all that). Given how cold it gets here, market forces, more so than government regulations, dictate the extent to which one insulates and otherwise weatherproofs their home. I have an idea of what the footprint may be. I'm looking at about 1,200 sqyds built in three modules multi story. I live not to far from a mountain range so I'll be getting higher pitched roofs whose cost to the home's overall versatility should be sufficiently offset by the addition of a second-storey (first storey I on your side of the Atlantic) deck wrapping around and connecting the house. Thanks very much for the input. I'm very excited to get started but I have a long way to go before pouring the foundation. Thanks for the feedback!

    • @tip00former1
      @tip00former1 5 років тому

      @@scottm4193 Any modern prefab builder uses timber framing and not stick framing, its simply inefficient. Sure, they divide the walls which makes it slightly less efficient but still use timber-framing. The stick framing seems to me like something American. Instead of using battens they use 4 by 2 to do the same.

  • @waynefarley9101
    @waynefarley9101 5 років тому +7

    Does anyone know the cost difference vs, stick framing?

    • @jtltet
      @jtltet 5 років тому +4

      Timber framing is considerably more expensive. I don't know the exact dollar amount per sf but it is much higher.

    • @ThuhOthers
      @ThuhOthers 5 років тому

      Timber is much more expensive. The % difference will vary a little since lumber is a large market

    • @tennesseetexan1957
      @tennesseetexan1957 5 років тому +3

      Jonathan Trivette while timber-frame material costs can be higher, where you save money is in the construction time & labor costs. A precut timber-frame and SIPs can be erected in a matter of a week while a stick frame can take months. So therefore the price can be comparable.

    • @jtltet
      @jtltet 5 років тому +6

      @@tennesseetexan1957, the price is not comparable at all. I know because I am in the industry. The timber frame can be erected quickly but that doesn't mean the house is completed. There are still lots of work to be done and a good framing crew can easily frame and sheath a stick frame house in a matter of weeks as well. Timber frames are great, I'm not debating that, but there is also no debate about which one is a lot less expensive to build.

    • @tennesseetexan1957
      @tennesseetexan1957 5 років тому +1

      Jonathan Trivette I’m talking about the dried in shell. Using SIPs is much faster and much more energy efficient than a normal stick frame. With all the thermal breaks in stick framing it is hard to match. Of course it depends which state you build in. I’m in Tennessee and built a timber frame shell with SIPs. 1500 sq ft with triple pane windows for less than $100 a square ft. And the beauty of the frame to see every day is priceless

  • @dmack47yo
    @dmack47yo 5 років тому +3

    I have absolutely no idea why this was in my recommended, but I’m completely interested 😂

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому

      That is a riot!! the algorithms of UA-cam . . . . if you really are interested, check out online timber framing course onlinecourses.shelterinstitute.com/courses/purely-post-beam-online-course
      There is a free trial that might be fun to watch!

  • @tomkelly8827
    @tomkelly8827 4 роки тому +1

    I have done a number of timber frames and stick frames too. There is nothing more satisfying then making nice timber joints! I am building my own house now and I will frame it with 2x4's and trusses. It will be much faster and use much less wood. I am cutting my own trees and getting them milled up. The thing that he did not mention is that SIP's are also full of wood too and they make the timber framed home double framed in essence. The framed house in contrast is only framed once.
    When I frame my house I will sheet the outside with 3" of styrofoam, then strap it and do board and batten on top. It will be strong, natural looking and well insulated. I do plan to do some round log timber framing to add that big wood beauty to my front entryway and livingroom. Timbers are certainly beautiful!

  • @tde1873
    @tde1873 3 роки тому +2

    Lumbar has gone up over 200% in the last few months. Looks like he’s in the right business.

    • @croakingfrog3173
      @croakingfrog3173 3 роки тому

      Only if people keep buying.. if it gets too expensive theyll stop

  • @FreedomTalkMedia
    @FreedomTalkMedia 5 років тому +7

    Another consideration: Timbers are much harder to set on fire than 2x4s, which go up like matchsticks and are close enough to the next 2x4 to set it on fire too. A stick built house is like a bunch of perfectly spaced kiln dried kindling just waiting to go up on smoke.
    I see conspiracy theorists posting about California homes burning down where the trees around them don't all the time. These people don't understand just how hard it is to burn a live tree compared to kiln dried 2x4s. Sure, a timber would burn easier than a live tree, except that it doesn't have any branches to act as kindling. There is a reason why a fire door can be made out of wood. You can make a wood door that takes an hour for a raging fire to burn through.

    • @rollerskdude
      @rollerskdude 5 років тому

      Though, if fireproofing was the main priority you'd avoid wood in the first place.

    • @FreedomTalkMedia
      @FreedomTalkMedia 5 років тому +2

      @@rollerskdude Yeah, a concrete home with steel beams holding up the roof would be superior but I think a timber frame home with a metal roof would probably be sufficient to save most of the homes in california. Also preferably without plywood under the steel

  • @Namesi
    @Namesi 5 років тому +5

    "Changed to stick framing for reasons that had nothing to do with the building itself."
    Thanks a lot Steinberg.

  • @drcoolit
    @drcoolit 4 роки тому +3

    They are the cathedrals of home design. Absolutely beautiful structures. Timeless and everlasting.
    Very nice presentation. I'll have to look into your institute.

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  4 роки тому

      Thank you so much, we think so too. We have not been able to offer any in person courses since last March but we do have a an online course available now. Please let us know how we can help! onlinecourses.shelterinstitute.com/courses/purely-post-beam-online-course

    • @drcoolit
      @drcoolit 4 роки тому

      @@ShelterInstitute I went to your link. I'M IMPRESSED! You have certainly given me ideas. I'm glad I happened on to this video! And thanks for that "demo" link. Definitely looking forward to viewing that!

  • @huffinairduster
    @huffinairduster 5 років тому +1

    cool and all, but as a electrician, if it is exposed timbers how do you get any power anywhere?? without running it on the actual gypsum board on the inside? am i missing something??? a cavity like stud construction on the outside of the building?

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому

      That is a great question Glennmight! The wiring is typically housed inside the exterior wall (whether it is a SIP or a cavity-like stud construction. It could also run within a chase mounted to the inside of the exterior wall that is than trimmed out to look like a chair rail. And of course wiring is run in interior partition walls and within the first floor framing.

  • @Halfhyde
    @Halfhyde 7 місяців тому

    Years ago, Steve Thomas of This Old House," promoted a project with timber framing. He stated that the best wood for this type of construction was old growth Douglas fir from the Pacific Northwest. That was in the "This Old Money" phase of the show. It was amazing to me that many people then were very concerned about the old growth forests and their unique ecosystems disappearing in the Northwest. Now, I think that they are using second growth (or younger) trees. There are very few mills in the Pacific Northwest that can even process the big logs.

  • @Dr_Xyzt
    @Dr_Xyzt 4 роки тому +3

    "Gypsum Palace" LOL! Yes, most homes I've ever set foot into are painted gypsum palaces. Most post and beam homes I've seen are very open floor plans that give you a sense of free space and comfort. I've seen some very beautiful wood finishes on them. Plus, you can make timber frame styles out of square steel tubing for a super steampunk appearance, like a pavilion, but with monster windows to enclose it. Exposed water heaters, clearcoated copper plumbing, Stainless countertops. Stairs outside so you can get on the roof.

  • @stumccabe
    @stumccabe 4 роки тому +5

    There are large numbers of timber framed buildings here in England that have survived beautifully for many many centuries. Near my home is a medieval tithe barn dating to a little before 1300 with its original timber roof - it is in excellent condition.

  • @hotdog160
    @hotdog160 5 років тому +3

    5:41 MAFELL saw ! the one and only !

  • @Pad13
    @Pad13 Місяць тому

    In the UK we construct both systems. In the “stick” system we would insulate between studs and rafters but also the outside or the inside of the timber frame. This eliminates cold bridging.

  • @Whammytap
    @Whammytap 20 днів тому

    I think it would be so cool to build a house using mainly materials found on your own property. I see lots of older houses in my area with native limestone foundations, and have dug up enough chunks of it in my own backyard to do a little terracing on the property. The idea of digging one's own foundation out by hand greatly appeals to me.

  • @goldstandard3714
    @goldstandard3714 5 років тому +17

    3:44 "First we cover the whole building with fire coated drywall." Question: What exactly do we attach sad drywall to?

  • @TheLoneWrencher
    @TheLoneWrencher 4 роки тому +4

    Legend has it he is still clearing his throat

  • @KillaCaff1
    @KillaCaff1 5 років тому +3

    But can you build a timber frame less expensively than a stick build?

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому +1

      This is a difficult question because of the variables. Generally, if you are hire someone to build a timber frame it is more expensive. However, if you are doing the work yourself, it can be less expensive. The other obvious factor is the cost of lumber and large timber does not always cost more than smaller framing members depending on what type of timber you purchase (species, grade and finish). The actual construction process and speed is another factor. Because a frame is typically all cut ahead of time and then assembled all at once you can minimize site exposure and material loss if you plan well. Another factor is the location of the project and the building materials that are readily available. People do not choose a timber frame because it is less expensive. They choose it because it is what they want for aesthetic, because they have a wood lot or have access to one, because they like the style of construction. And then you may be able to build it for less depending on how you build.

    • @SomeGuy-vo7we
      @SomeGuy-vo7we 5 років тому

      You can buy a small mountain of lumber for the same price as one timber. The only way a timber house will be less expensive than a house built from stick is if you already have a woodlot and most of the equipment needed for processing logs into timbers.

  • @emjaygee4464
    @emjaygee4464 Рік тому

    I have been a builder for fifty years. Houses , boats of a 100 tons, and have renovated many houses from the eighteenth century as well as disassembled houses deemed historically insignificant. I found this video very informative in realizing that timber frame can be as strong as stick frame. I am about to start a community of houses and am going to use a frame and infill of either hemp or dustcrete. So my question is how will I stiffen the build, where I use a Crete and parge on the outside. Extra metal bracing or will mortised in do?

  • @TheGreyGhost_of43rd
    @TheGreyGhost_of43rd Рік тому +1

    Somebody get this man a glass of water 💦
    Hydration is the first step in timber framing

  • @chrjs90
    @chrjs90 4 роки тому +4

    In German this kind of craftsmanship is called "Zimmerei". Come here and study it for 3 years and after that you can study "Zimmermanmeister" and master It.
    You will get it for free, more than that you will earn some money, learn some new language and you will have some long holidays.

  • @RaferJeffersonIII
    @RaferJeffersonIII 5 років тому +3

    Thank you UA-cam recommended and happy Christmas

    • @ShelterInstitute
      @ShelterInstitute  5 років тому

      Thank you for watching! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you!!!! Please don't hesitate to reach out if we can offer ay additional information about our products or services.

  • @PersonMan1234
    @PersonMan1234 5 років тому +21

    Just saying, you can cover a stick frame building with all exterior insulation too, if you want to reduce thermal bridging. Also, now they have 2x6s that are a foam core between two 2x3s.
    Also, I would argue that there are certain advantages to stick framing that are not discussed here. Ease of renovation/modular modification of existing construction, reduced heavy equipment needs to get the real big timbers up and in place, and some other stuff. Not to mention, you don't have the kinds of trees you need everywhere to do timber framing everywhere.
    But yeah, for a places woth lotsa big trees, timber framing sure is awesome!

    • @tip00former1
      @tip00former1 5 років тому +3

      You are just living in the past. You can order laminated timbers everywhere, no big trees involved 😎

    • @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7
      @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7 5 років тому +1

      @@tip00former1 compare costs please....bottom line in about everything

    • @burgeryoufoundbehindthegrill
      @burgeryoufoundbehindthegrill 5 років тому +1

      Timberframing can be done with timbers as small as 4.5x4.5" if it's a single story building. And historic methods such as wattle and daub are exponentially cheaper and easier to renovate than modern methods

    • @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7
      @d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7 5 років тому

      @@burgeryoufoundbehindthegrill but not now

    • @burgeryoufoundbehindthegrill
      @burgeryoufoundbehindthegrill 5 років тому

      @@d.e303-anewlowcosthomebuil7 No, it's still true now, both statements. Check out Japanese traditional construction. They do it all the time. Stands up to typhoons well enough. And some of those buildings are older than the USA. Earth building is making a comeback in the West, and simply requires dirt, clay, straw, and/or dung (if you want, lol).

  • @billmccaffrey1977
    @billmccaffrey1977 2 роки тому +1

    I see great similarity with the housing and furniture industries. Mass production, poor construction quality and fewer skilled laborers. I have studied Japanese timber framing (far more detailed than western timber framing) and love the beautiful results that must endure earthquakes and high winds and are still standing after 100s of years. I learned to build traditional furniture many years ago, which is based on the same principles. I'm happy to see companies like this still providing quality construction as an option to mass production. My next and last house will be a timber frame.

  • @alejandrocantu4652
    @alejandrocantu4652 5 років тому +1

    Florida New York and California have the strictest building codes many other States do not have same requirements of strapping and tine a typical stick frame together making it susceptible to hurricanes and tornadoes

    • @anomilumiimulimona2924
      @anomilumiimulimona2924 5 років тому

      Alejandro Cantu, bullshit.

    • @alejandrocantu4652
      @alejandrocantu4652 5 років тому

      @@anomilumiimulimona2924 dumb ass have you ever work. Done any framing in California. It you could, think before reply.

  • @RyanJohnsonD
    @RyanJohnsonD 3 роки тому +3

    Great points about the heat loss and the tremendous amount of material used in a stick home. Does a timber frame meet California specs for earthquakes? Seems like the unions and economic factors didn't put energy and the consumer's pocketbook first: e.g., the amount of foam insulation, the "perfect wall" with radiant barrier all seem to have come out of the need to deal with inefficiencies from the stick home approach.

  • @lothean2099
    @lothean2099 5 років тому +7

    I really liked the info given in this video

  • @Noobificado
    @Noobificado 5 років тому +44

    This is an ad to sell timber framing course.

    • @chandick1092
      @chandick1092 4 роки тому +5

      An ad but contains useful information and something you can close at any minute vs some annoying sign on the street

    • @jbbolts
      @jbbolts 4 роки тому +1

      true but it was more information than ad and the information was useful and relevant.. win/win

    • @nullobject5943
      @nullobject5943 4 роки тому +1

      Could you imagine paying for something like this? I can't wrap my head around it. Anyone wanting to build a timber frame house is willing to put in the work. And if you are willing to do the labor, why in the world are you paying to learn? Just go work for free on a jobsite.. so absurd. Natural building schools do this too. Who falls for this crap?

    • @jbbolts
      @jbbolts 4 роки тому +4

      @@nullobject5943 well you are appropriately named ill give you that

  • @janwillem4045
    @janwillem4045 8 місяців тому

    Most old farms in The Netherlands (and rest of North Western Europe) are build hundreds of years ago using a timber frame, that's why they still stand today.
    Indeed by using trees from the site.
    I got confused by the title calling the stick frame " conventional".

  • @Rokkiteer
    @Rokkiteer 4 роки тому +1

    As an European, it's easy to think that American culture isn't developed that much. But I consider this to be a cornerstone of American culture. This working the land and building your home with the materials that are already there. Part of the go west idea as well. Living in a smaller country with lots of people can make me envious that I don't have the same option here.