Reimagining the Periodic Table
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2024
- Go to Brilliant.org/MinutePhysics to gift Brilliant Premium for the holidays, and for 20% off!
This video is about cutting, taping, and rearranging the periodic table into the Left Step form, the Mendeleev's flower form, the cake form, the wide form, the standard form, and so on. A great holiday craft!!
REFERENCES
Alternate Periodic Tables
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alterna...
Electronegativity
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electro...
Atomic Radius Radii
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_...
First Ionization energy
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ionizat...
Support MinutePhysics on Patreon! / minutephysics
Link to Patreon Supporters: www.minutephysics.com/supporters/
MinutePhysics is on twitter - @minutephysics
And facebook - / minutephysics
And Google+ (does anyone use this any more?) - bit.ly/qzEwc6
Minute Physics provides an energetic and entertaining view of old and new problems in physics -- all in a minute!
Created by Henry Reich - Наука та технологія
As a chemist, I do not condone this behaviour
You should stick to cooking meth lol
Feynstein 1000 Ok highschooler
No, don't make meth, that stuff is nasty. Make LSD instead.
@@cyancoyote7366 much harder to make, but with many unresearched interesting properties, like luminescence - according to Nick Sands.
Yep, the synthesis is horribly complicated and requires so much knowledge and experience.
Everytime you cut into the periodic table a chemist somewhere screams in pain.
Jups... Can confirm.
I'm a student but still screamed.
Same. It was already perfect
I'm an 8th grader, but chem is my life and I was like : The periodic table has no cuts , the periodic table needs no cuts!!!
something died within me today
big vihart vibes
You beat me to the comment
If only she would upload
Shoot, guess I'll go delete my comment. =)
@@tbird81 “Waaaaaah, people smarter than me have different opinions, and choose to state those opinions!”
@@MisterAppleEsq You are trying to act smarter than him for stating a different opinion than yours. You are doing exactly what you criticized him for doing.
I'm not ready to memorize one more song for this
_There~'s_ 🎶
_Antimony, Arsenic, Aluminium, Selenium..._ 🎶
There's
Malichevsky, Rubinstein, Arensky, and Tchaikovsky...
Helen Arney did it for you a couple years ago with newly named elements
Me: * sings elements in order to tune of ‘yakkos world’ music *
@@AeroQC And hydrogen and oxygen and nitrogen and rhenium,
And nickel, neodymium, neptunium, germanium,
helium is just so annoying
Unless you inhale it - then it's cool again!
He He He
I read that in a high pitched voice.
H is even more so.
HeHeHeHeHe
Not gonna lie, they had us in the first half.
I wanted to like, but you already have 314 likes. #pi>tau
@@hmahama1 hol up
hmahama1 E that’s epic
What do you mean tho
@@hmahama1 bruh u used an b in eat
Dimitri Mendeleev : *SO YOU'VE CHOSEN DEATH*
Kok kayak pernah ngeliat lu ngomen di kok bisa
It is Dmitri Mendeléev
@@shambosaha9727 *Дмитий Менделеев I think
@@pmj_studio4065 Sorry, I can't read Russian.
I would have gone with the Palpatine line from Revenge of the Sith: It's treason, then.
1:35 Looks like a nice Chemistree hehe
u deserve a pat on the back 👏🏻
ИО
THIS COMMENT IS UNDERRATED. I ALMOST CHOKED😂😂
Lol
It's like an evolutionary walk that wanders back to the original situation. Neat.
Doxie Lain It's almost like… the video is periodical
i concur
@@YourMJK 😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳
Was that an AI joke?
I'm not one for "tradition for tradition's sake", but there's often a reason the traditions exist, be the reason good or bad. The "traditional" periodic table has a good reason to be that way.
Periodically, I wonder why videos like these weren’t made several years before, like when I was still in chemistry class.
Just Some Guy without a Mustache You can still learn ;)
Well cutting up the periodic table takes away the benefits chemistry needs from it like ion charges, valence electrons, the trends stated in the video with electronegativity and atomic radii, electron configuration and the list goes on and on. The periodic table was made very intentionally "weird looking" because of all the properties it needs to communicate
This would be technically useless and rather hurting for chemistry classes.
Though it gives you a better perspective of the table
But it loses the pereodic properties of the table like radius, electronegativity, ionisation enthalpy and so on which are really important for chemistry classes
@@pranavmoghe3192 This video was basically a circular (no pun intended) way of explaining that the way the table is organized now is the best way. There isn't any real information other than that.
I am in chemistry class, though
Beginning of the video: Complaining about how the periodic table is unorganized
End of the video: Explaining how the periodic table is literally perfectly organized in every way
+
Not perfectly but optimally. Not the best at everything but better at more things than any other possible arrangement.
@@willythemailboy2 *found yet
Hear me out.. the standard model😌
Frfrfr
I can hear chemists screaming when you cut the periodic table.
Can confirm
Pissing off chemists is one of the favorite passtimes of physicists.
Chemists upon learning that physicists want to break an atom.
It definitely hurt.
It was torture until he put it back together.
“Put helium above beryllium, where it so obviously belongs.”
... okay, I’ll bite, what’s the catch?
“Put helium above neon, where it so obviously belongs.”
DEAD 😂
😂😂😂😂
The periodic table really is put together very specifically. It’s amazing someone could arrange it like that.
Glory to Arstotzka!
All the elements: Lets be normal and arranged in the correct way!
Helium: *no*
what that profile pic
Nc profile pic
Hydrogen: I don't even know who I am anymore.
That profile pic tho
@@aathish04 Hydrogen: Guys, I'm still alive.
Me, a biochemist, calling the police
All you need is H, C and O 😭😭
Along with O N P S ...
i want to become a biochemist when i grow up😲 is it hard? and if i may ask, did u have you masters or your bachelors when you first applied for your job? Also if it's not any trouble what did u major in and do you work at a lab or a facility or is it remote?
This is like if Vi Hart did chemistry videos
How to make hexafluorigons...I'd watch
When I was taking high school chemistry, I thought that I could make the table better. I work through out the semester trying to make a better one, but the more I learn about the table in class and the more I thought about I realized time and time again that the table doesn't need to be change at all because it was already perfect... except for the tables in the text books because they were outdated.
What about the island floating off the bottom of most of the periodic tables?
The "Island" are the lanthanides and actinides, which are the purple coloured ones in the 1st table, they're seperated to make the periodic table a little more compact horizontally
(They are the elements that start populating their f-orbitals)
That's the "f" block and it's technically attached after the second vertical column, but we move it to the bottom to make the whole table easier to read
If you look at the periodic table he started with it included those elements in the correct spots not cut out of the table
Lol give me some slack dudes. He was literally asking me XD
@@depeltenburg6916 I love how none of them noticed the pause text, but I thought it was pretty funny
And especially funny how he himself included it at the very end
I used the periodic table to create the periodic table
Two elements left (Likes),
Helium has a full electron configuration, just like the rest of noble gases. Would you mind to elaborate on why it belongs above Beryllium? Or was it just a joke?
EDIT: I get it. It has a full electron shell. More than 20 people already told me. Shut up.
Joke
Both of them have 2 electrons in the last electron shell. It's not a joke.
WeissM89
The real question is whether hydrogen should be above the alkali metals or the halogens. Of course, it really belongs in both places.
It makes sense from a "filled-orbital" perspective; putting it above beryllium matches it with the other elements whose highest-energy orbital is a filled s-orbital.
It just happens that the p-orbital, which starts existing after the first shell, has only a very slightly higher energy than the s-orbital; hence, the "filled-orbital" column with the largest energy gap to the next orbital (i.e. the "noble gas" from a reactivity standpoint) now shifts over to the filled-p-orbital column, headed by neon.
The d-orbital, which starts existing at the third shell, is much higher energy than the p-orbital (to the point where it's comparable in energy to the fourth-shell s and p orbitals), so the least-reactive column doesn't shift (with a similar situation for the f-orbital).
To fit the nice stepping shape of course.
That twist at the end, we were using the right table THE WHOLE TIME
0:59 This scene really killed me.
Actually, I love left step periodic table. Even though it breaks a lot of periodicity here, it has several advantages:
1) reflects the electron configuration of the elements
2) is regular; looks nice
3) do not establish many false|dumb patterns
4) is easier for counting and predicting certain properties
5) shows that there's more to elements, than just how near noble gases they are
6) is better at explaining amphoteric properties
7) do not break that much when adding new elements
So if you know it's limitations you can use it pretty much equivalently to the traditional one and if you are thinking about electrons, shells, subshells, etc. it will work just great.
Honestly yeah , that looked hella neat , also you can just put them on a cylinder to show how it's a loop ,
I think that is the version that breaks the table the least , while having a lot of utility
Let's rearrange the Periodic Table
Dimitri Mendeleev: *wait, that's illegal!*
as he did all the other times we changed the table.
Well at least he didn't remove anything, like the zeroth particle.
Well his arrangement was different than the periodic table we all know
He rearranged it himself every edition of his book, and so did all other early table creators ua-cam.com/video/83RSwczyyRY/v-deo.html (Periodic Videos)
Lol, true! The Periodic Table at it's best is based on Quantitative data and is invariable. There is 1 true Periodic Table and that is the Periodic Table which provides the maximum amount of accurate Element information in an unbroken arrangement. Check out the Genesis Periodic Table at facebook.com/thegenesiscreation.
mendeleev : creates periodic table
Minute physics : hold my elements
And then they descend into Mendeleev's rosette and arrive back at what he created.
My chemist sense was tingling so hard, when you said He belonged above Be. God no, it does not.
Well..... technically it is a s-block element. It has the configuration of 1s2. Be has [He] 2s2. Mg has [Ne] 3s2 and so on and so on.
It does make some sense to put it above Be.
The reason we put it above Neon is that it is obviously a classical nobel gas on chemical properties side of things. But Helium is NOT a p-block element like all the other noble gases.
@@GenosseRot I'm a chemist, i know. Still its chemical properties do not at all resemble those of earth alkalite elements, so it feels so damn out of place there, even if its a s element. There is a reason it is not above Be and it should stay where it is.
When did he say that ? He said it belonged above Ne.
@@onemadscientist7305 0:59 "[...] where it so obviously belongs."
Its a joke, because like GenosseRot said, its technically a s element and is just not directly next to H because it is obviously chemically a noble gas.
@@GenosseRot Helium's two electrons aren't ionizable in the way that the two valence electrons of the alkaline earth metals are.
2:13
*They did surgery on a periodic table of elements*
Lol 😂😂😂👏
I loved how he said mendeleyev's flower like it was a thing
Its mendeleevs
This hurt. From a chemist perspective, the periodic table is one of the most beautiful and elegant representations of data I've ever seen
Mendeleev's flower😂👏👏
periodic table:
you cant live with your own failures look where it brought you, back to me.
Elon Musk and now I’m on a horse
People are saying that Helium is annoying while in reality Hydrogen is the most annoying of them all
its not people, it is mainly "gnochhuos"
@@kartikeya9997 who is gnochhous?
@@aditidasgupta8913 you migth see him in comment section with 1.6K likes
When you flash words on the screen for 1 frame, I can't read what it says.
tilde next time split the message over three frames to really mes with this guy
If you are using a laptop or desktop, you can pause the video and use the period or the comma to step frame by frame.
(and don't get me started on the "island" of elements floating off the bottom of most periodic tables)
You can pause the video
this blew my mind, seriously, amazing presentation.
I was screaming the whole time, don't mess with the table. Lucky for my health the periodic table was rearranged in the correct order. It was painful to watch, but this video showed us how the period table is arranged just right
I'm working on an app involving atoms and the periodic table and you just made me rethink on my design. Thank you!
So just overthinking and arrived to nothing
so basically a thought experiement
dudeee you just defined half of science
I literally watched a video about how overthinking is bad before this
No, showing that the periodic table is optimally arranged.
It is about the traveling and not the finish line or something
I kinda want a nice 3D version of the flower table...
I might make a nice desktop version on my 3D printer or something... that's super cool.
0:35 - You can get maps that have the Pacific and Indian Oceans in the center along with the ring of fire and Australia, although Iceland gets cut in half and Greenland gets a shave.
Question:
What elements should be under Sc and Y
La Ac or Lu Lr???
Lu Lr
La and Ac because they're d block elements. Even though the Lanthanide and Actinide series are named after them, they don't belong there. Our chemistry professor taught it as the friends living in a person's home threw him out of his own house.
.
.
.
F
La and Ac. They are numbers 57 and 89, respectively, and the f block elements start with numbers 58 and 90. Lu and Lr are 71 and 103, which come before Hf (72) and Rf (104), not La and Ac.
My problem is why did he colour Lutenium and Lawrentium as transition metals?
ナオト
All of them. Lanthanum and lutetium - and everything between them - have equal claim to be “eka-yttrium”.
All the good jokes Argon.
I’ll see myself out...
Reference to Regiraw Comparisons?
@@kidssyed2213 nah just a --common-- carbon joke among nerds
Thank you for putting the sponsor in the end..u are a good person
I actually started laughing out loud at the end of this when you made it back into the normal table. Thanks for all of these excellent videos!
I said that to my 8th grade teacher 15 years ago, she just told me it's how the table looks
0:10 it says (and don’t get me started on the “island” of elements floating off the bottom of most periodic tables)
#teamtrees
Thanks. It annoys me when UA-camrs flash text on the screen for a fraction of a second. It's really hard for me to pause at exactly the right time, so I end up watching part of the video over and over at 0.25 speed, trying to pause on the right frame and getting more and more frustrated. (I know that on desktop there are ways to go forward one frame at a time, but that doesn't seem to be an option on mobile.)
At school, in Costa Rica, we used a locally designed periodic table based on the electronic structures and I always felt it was so much easier to read through than the standard one (it was designed by Gil Chaverri, in case someone is interested)
This is the best video I've ever seen.
Hey man love the video as always, but can you keep the sidenote at 0:11 on screen a bit longer? It's very hard to catch it, for those of us who want to read it. Edit: Hard to pause the video at that exact frame.
And while we're on it, could you please move it on the side? Some of us have subtitles on the bottom. (BTW, thanks so much for always adding subtitles!!!)
Evaneos 17 I meant to say it's very hard to pause at that exact frame
you can use , and . to move left and right by 1 frame in the video respectively
Mrgglock Too much hassle to read a single side note
@@glock6916 It took me forever to work out that you have to actually pause the video first for that to work, because no one ever included that bit in their instructions
As a chemist, my first reaction to this was 'What??' immidiately followed by 'Physicists...'
Don't get me wrong, I'm all for changing the periodic table if it makes more sense. In fact, I think the periodic table has a problem in that it represents physics better than it represents chemistry. But what you did there just makes no sense at all except arguably in an aesthetic way.
Mendeleev's Flower is the most elegant way of organizing the periodic table, even if it is a bit inconvenient.
I agree with the different model of the periodic table you did its makes more sense to me and Is really well done
If the periodic table was a cake.... I'd eat it for breakfast
Delicious uranium you got there
@@Aphelia. 😂😂
Mendeleev: Creates Periodic Table
MinutePhisics: This is Brilliant! But (pointing to some flower) I like this.
Beautifully done, thank you
Awesome
2-minute chemistry!
More chemistry videos please:)
1:51 what's that?
The Periodic Penis? The Penis Table?
Hacking the Periodic Table
"Im in"
dissolved into elements.
This is wonderful. Thank you.
Thanks for making these awesome videos
Oddly entertaining and OCD satisfying...
Did Vihart write this video or something? Y'all did a great job on it!
Original periodic table just vibing
Minute physics *cuts to make a better one*
Original periodic table “where did that leave you right back to me”
Minute Physics actually really likes the periodic table.
This is hinted at the fact that all sentences in the script end in a period.
I did not see that end coming at all - good job, great show. keep it up!
*Nobody* :
*Me* : We are gonna hack and learn the whole periodic table
*Minute Physics* : _Cutting the periodic table_
*Mendeleev: Woah, wait!!* That's _my flower_ , this is not called as _hacking_ ................
The irony is there probably is a really elegant way to organize all the elements according to some property we dont yet understand, or with elements we dont yet know about.
Or just in 4 dimensions.
Have been waiting for new video❤️❤️❤️
minutephysics: Hacking the Periodic Table
Mendeleev: Am i a joke to you?
This doesn’t work on the 1.14 patch update. Please help
I had a really good feeling this would show a really cool new way to CONSISTENTLY use the periodic table, but all this did was prove that the current version is the best design, which, in my opinion, is cooler
Love this idea 💙
Am I watching the new Vihart video?
Overkillius no
underrated coment
*Tapping on the Elements*
"I'm in"
This is where our brains need for patterns both excels and fails. We excelled at making this based on recognition, but fail to see it properly with means of visually displaying it that meat our visual information capacities.
We had a chem project about rearranging the periodic table, and I think we came up with the best solution:
Arrange it in accordance with the orbital diagram
Very cool! I had never heard of Mendeleev's flower.
It is helping me to love inorganic chemistry
Don't know why physicist are better explainer
Thanks for the video
minutephysics shocks the world by showing that the periodic table is periodic
transitions were on point today
THE PERIODIC TABLE IS INEVITABLE!
*Everyone Gangsta until Helium changes Political Parties.*
2:28
Math, science, history
Unraveling the mystery
That all started with the big bang
*BANG*
The man is a genius
ViHart wants to know your location
Wish you made it couple of years ago when i was in High school.
Dmitri Mendelev is surely proud of you!
I saw a concept to present the elememts in a circle. With each period occupying a ring of fixed radius, with hydrogen and helium at the center. This way you get the "looped" like continuous structure, and the elements with similar properties lines up.
0:10 (and don't get me started on the "island" of elements floating off the bottom of most periodic tables)
@@blank6604 No
Wait....that escalated quickly
I will be periodically checking this channel.
Great vid, you had me periodically for a moment then.
him: #teamtrees
also him: *uses paper*
Just remember: Nature is under no obligation to make sense to you.
You just said a really awesome sentence..
@@SanjivanPal That was Neil deGrasse Tyson. I take no credit.
@@BlackEpyon Oh, That's why I felt like I've heard it somewhere before.
Beautiful
Leave the Periodic Table in its Wide form and put Helium in Group 2. The Left Step Periodic Table does not highlight Periodicity and the Octet rule as well as the Standard Wide Form does. If some minor adjustments are made to the Wide Periodic Table, a complete and Accurate numbering system based on Quantitative data can be applied to all the Elements.
The S and P Orbital type Elements being on the outside of the Table makes sense because these Elements add Outermost Valence Electrons. The D and F Orbital type Elements being on the inside of the Periodic Table makes sense because they add Core Electrons.
The easiest, most logical and accurate way to teach/learn the Periodic Table, is by plotting the Elements 1 by 1 based on Quantitative data according to the Periodic Law, rather than showing all the Elements at once. After all, Elements were created from smallest to largest, they did not all come into existence at once.
Here is the Periodic Table at it's best, providing the maximum amount of accurate and useful Element information in 2 dimensional space. Check it out at facebook.com/thegenesiscreation.
Minute chemistry?
trevor aboussafy Chemistry is just applied physics
1:35 Hooray! It's already above 20 Millions! #teamtrees
Ngl I felt that that three minutes can never be taken back
Periodic table is the best it can be.