Why Do Mirrors Flip Left & Right (but not up & down)?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 гру 2019
- Go to nebula.tv/minutephysics to get access to Nebula (where you can watch MinuteBody) plus you'll get a 20% discount on an annual subscription.
Support MinutePhysics on Patreon! / minutephysics
Link to Patreon Supporters: www.minutephysics.com/supporters/
This video is about why words flip left & right (aka horizontally) in a mirror but not up & down (aka vertically). The answer has to do with specular reflection, mirrors being like windows into another world (alternate universes, just with in and out flipped!), and transparency of the things we write on.
REFERENCES
Specular Reflection
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specula...
PhysicsGirl video about mirrors
• Why do mirrors flip ho...
Fermat’s principle
electron6.phys.utk.edu/optics4...
Thomas-Fermi screening
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas%...
MinutePhysics is on twitter - @minutephysics
And facebook - / minutephysics
And Google+ (does anyone use this any more?) - bit.ly/qzEwc6
Minute Physics provides an energetic and entertaining view of old and new problems in physics -- all in a minute!
Created by Henry Reich - Наука та технологія
I know lots of people have made videos about this before, but I felt I still had something to add, so, well, here you go! Also, I'm working on a video about CP violation (aka mirror symmetry violation) in particle physics, so I've been thinking more about mirrors recently. That video should be out soon!
Physics Girl made a pretty good video on this.
Can you also explain why when you're short-sighted, you look far away is blur, when you look at the mirror, the reflection was blur too for far distance, but your eyes muscle are being strained at short distance instead of long. This bugged me.
Im pretty sure CP violations are just felonies, not too complicated
It’s brilliant. The examples made it way easier! Thanks for forever turning complex into simplex
I've seen some other videos too, but I do think you explain it better than the others I've seen. The writing on transparency was a great way to dispel the flipping notion.
That transparant card you used really made it click for me!
Me too
If you somehow don't have one, you can still reproduce the result by looking at the inside of a cheap tshirt with printed text on the front.
Yeah, that was something that I hadn't seen before that I'll definitely be using when I explain it to people.
I aaaaaalmost got it when he said depth is flipped, but it really only clicked with the transparent card for me, too
me three :)
I’ve seen a lot of videos attempting to explain the mirrors flipping images, and this is the best explanation I’ve ever seen
Definitely!
Using the transparent foil with writing on it was genius.
Science Asylum is a close second.
aidan balac same
The explanation was more simple than I thought, when he showed the visual experiment of how this worked I was like oh duh that makes sense
You took something really simple that I took for granted, and made me realise that actually, I know nothing at all. Well done. Flipping brilliant!
Of course. But it's a common enough phrase here in the UK to mean what it says, too.
I think the main problem is that our brain has such a strong focus on the distinction between Left/Right.
I had a philosophy professor who talked about this, in the context of "how would you explain left/right to an alien who had no concept of left/right", I guess a similar issue to explaining color to someone who was born blind.
Some cultures (Idk some island natives somewhere) don't use relative direction (left/right) but instead they use only absolute direction (North, East, South, West). To someone who sees their hand as not a "right hand" but a "north hand" if they're facing west, would observe no horizontal flipping in an object's reflection (provided the text or image being reflected is parallel to the mirror). I just think that's super interesting, and I wish I could better understand that way of thinking. But left/right is so deeply ingrained in most of our brains and in our society, we use them every day and in almost everything we do. Isn't it weird that one of your hands does many things much better than the other?
@@coryellis1877 You should check out "Death and the Right Hand, by Robert Hertz! Its kind of a dense text but it analyzes exactly what you are talking about and presents some interesting theories on it.
Yyu
I feel the same way. Nice pun
I love it when things are so "trivial" that you don't even think about them, but are very interesting the second you start to study them.
Nothing is really trivial
@@lowlize That's ... Actually very true indeed
Yeah like your mom lol sorry
lowlize Exactly.
You see things move and you study them... Boom we have physics
Mirrors are really fascinating. I really needed some time reflecting on this topic.
M
You are really everywhere
And here you are again
True and punny. You have polished your skills to a specular sheen
Found ya
I feel like an idiot for not understanding how words are reflected earlier
Saaaame 😩😂
The explanation was more simple than I thought, when he showed the visual experiment of how this worked I was like oh duh that makes sense
Producing mirrors must be super fascinating and exciting
I could really see myself doing that
One technic to make sure that glass for windows and mirrors is flat and smooth is to float the glass on molten metal. While your joke was great, it actually is super exciting.
If I'm getting overly excited while looking at myself it starts to feel weird
@@ltericdavis2237 what's a technic?
@@Jimmeh_B Technique
That was awful. Five stars.
I love the addition of transparencies! I knew that the "flipping" mirrors do is in "z" axis, but imagining it mentally is 10 times easier with your transparency idea. Excellent!
Feynman talks about this magic. Actually all that Feynman talks about is magic. Beautiful work, once again @minutephysics
The transparency was absolutely brilliant. Thought about this for years and now it makes sense. Thank you, one of my favorite UA-cam channels!!
Wow, using a transparent card was such a simple but mindblowingly powerful idea! I can't imagine the feeling of happiness that came when the person who thought of that had the idea. This was by far the best explanation about mirrors I've seen, short, simple and clear (pun not intended).
When I read the title I was like "well this is pretty obvious" in my mind.
And then I saw the part about the word in plastic film and was like "well thats obvious too, why tf didn't I think of that?!"
The more we think we know all about a subject, the less we get to learn about different ways of looking at it.
Great video!
When you did the word on the clear glass I was like “oh wow” and then when you explained that we flip it, I was like “son of a bitch” I literally said that. In a very sincere way. I hope you know this is a huge compliment
I'm in!
The very best video on the subject out there, bar none!
That transparency / rotation demo really proved it in the best and simplest way possible. Fantastic!
1:11 hide the pain Henry Reich
Lmao
I would like this comment but it has 111 likes for 1:11
Whoa! This is a deep concept. I need some time to... reflect.
Go to your room
Ahaha
stop
Hello Therion-sama. It's been a while lol
@@feynstein1004 Hey! ^_^
The way he says mirrors in the end sounds like Hermione Granger saying its leviosa not leviosar
Yeah
I have thought about this a lot before and have come up with reasons why in order to explain it but I have never seen such an intuitive way to understand it until you held up the transparent word
I may have known and understood all of this before. But this is probably the cleanest and best explanation I've ever seen of this effect! Well done! - Using transparent slips was a great idea
Beautifully explained, as always!
This video makes me feel I've circled the youtube once, because years ago the first video i watched of Physics Girl was mirror flipping as well.
I've somewhat learned about this before, but this is the first time someone explained the concept to me so succinctly. Thank you for this video and everything you do.
It always seemed impossible to explain because it was so natural and "obvious", yet you gave a perfect explanation. Great job 👍
me on a date: hey nice to meet you. how are you? oh im great! did you know that mirrors...
This is so simple, I can't believe I have never figured it out myself. I feel very humbled 😂
Seeing you happily making a video in the video really made me happy. Thanks again for the great work!
This video title jumped out from under my chair and battered my brain with a sandwich toaster.
I want all physics textbooks to remove the stupid "lateral Inversion"
Omg!
Omg!
0mg cholesterol!
@@DarkJMKnight nice
@@DarkJMKnight rip vines
Concise. Precise. And very very clear. One of the best videos on this subject.
I'm a physicist and a photographer, and this is by far the simplest explanation of this phenomenon that I've ever heard. Bravo!
[2:23] When you come home and find food in your fridge
Lmao
I'm not sure how to feel right now: I wondered the mirror thing for ages and couldn't figure it out my whole life... until today, at the age of 30, a UA-cam video just pointed it out and suddenly it makes sense.
The explanation with the transparent card is so helpful. Thanks for the video.
Most precise video on the topic I have seen so far. Thanks!
lol, didn’t know I needed to know this. Always though I somehow knew the answer
Made me reflect a lot...
I’ll see myself out.
I can't tell if the second sentence is part of the joke...
Only if you use a mirror while you do it.
Don't let the door, hit ya, where the good Lord, split ya!
@@the8flo1 I think it is
I've seen the explanation for this on another channel, but I didn't understand it. The way you presented here with the transparent card makes it perfectly understandable.
Wow. So much insight packed into so little time. Well done
I came thinking “well, duh” but I actually learned something new!
When talking about 1 mirror
me: Okay cool
Talks about multiple mirrors
Me: *Thousands of ideas manifesting simultaneously*
This by far the most clearer explanation than any other videos I saw. The use of transparent object was useful for understanding!
This is the best explanation of this phenomenon i've seen, I love this channel
Mathologer already told us why
Something something LIVE EVIL
Mirrors "sort of" do flip left and right. Left and right have to be defined in relation to front and back. When a mirror flips front and back which is taken for granted, that gives the appearance that left and right are flipped.
Exactly! This is why when you raise your right hand, the person in the mirror raises their left hand -- because front and back are switched, even if "absolute" left and right are not, so relative to the reflected person's front it did flip left and right.
This was one of the questions I had at my Oxford Uni interview for undergrad Physics. Thanks for bringing it back to mind all these years later. :-)
Oh god. Thank you so much!
I watched PhysicsGirl’s video on this a couple of times but still didn’t understand. I just watched yours and with your explanation and demonstration, it’s now perfectly clear how it works!! Thank you!
1:46 Redrum
please, put your * comments a bit heigher in the frame - when I pause to read the UA-cam controls are getting in the way
I have always wondered this... this was really informative and intuitive. Thanks a lot!
Thank you for making a good explanation and actual words out of what I can never explain to anyone
THANK YOU THIS HAS BEEN MY SECRET SHAME QUESTION FOR YEARS AND YEARS!!!!
This always confused me as a kid because everyone around me was like "The MiRrOr FliPs ThIngS" and I was like... no it doesn't... it just reflects it... and people called me stupid because I didn't understand what they meant..
You do look stupid, and they probably meant flips the images "horizontally" but they didn't know the word or something.
@@MrCallofkill uhh
@@MrCallofkill Did you not watched damn video.
Aw you’re not stupid just because you have different thinking with other people
@@MrCallofkill uhh...Maybe watch the video before commenting?
Simple yet MARVELOUS video. Thanks
That was a very good way of explaining the concept!
The channel name is definitely justified 👍
"Just like a parallel world but with in and out reversed" So planets have their cores on the outside and the atmosphere at their core? Arthropods and non-arthropods are also reversed? Are my bowels dangling on the outside?
And this comment is thinking inside the box?
Why Do Mirrors Flip Left & Right (but not up & down)?
Short answer: They don't
Also, WTF is a mirrrrr :/
I felt like heard the cause of Big Bang when he said " mirrors and flip, we flip! "
Awesome video 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Awesomely explained !
I am your new subscriber! 👍👍👍
The only clear and thorough explanation on the whole internet. Thank you
Somebody's been watching old Richard Feynman videos
Or Physics Girl videos.
His quantum explanation to mirrors is amazing!
Physics girl already made a video on this. But still a great video.
palmomki I don’t know, it kinda seemed flipped inside out to me...
Thanksss!!!!
I was having this question too!
Now I can proudly slap this video to my Physics teacher!
Really, really great explanation! Well done!
Serial killer smile 🤪
Nothing like what I've seen lol
MKBHD: So guys, I've had this new mirror tech for a few weeks now, turns out they can flip up and down
That’s the best explanation I have ever seen for this. Thank you!
The best explanation so far! Thank you!
This video makes me feel mentally handicapped because I don't get anything.
What’s a solid 10/10 beard
What a neat explanation. Thanks for the video!
I have watched quite a few videos trying to understand this and I FINALLY do!! Thank you so much
"They turn walls into portals to another world" jojo reference?! Man in the mirror thinks the same
Didn’t physics girl talk about this forever ago?
ua-cam.com/video/vBpxhfBlVLU/v-deo.html yeah
What is the point of asking this? Many science channels have similar content between each other. Or if it was just a question, it literally took less than 10 seconds to find an answer. Yes, 4 years ago.
OMG! I have searched for the answer to this question for years! I needed a simple explanation for my simple brain. Thank you Soooooo much!
One of the best simple explanation to date!
Best video I've ever seen about this topic. I never understood why people describe the image in a mirror as a flip of left and right of the real world.
*The Science Asylum* channel helped me understand wat u explained abt mirrors "flipping words around" as well. Great job sir.
Very unique video bro. Keep up the great work.
Short, concise, and understandable. Amazing
Excellent, this is the easiest and best explanation i have ever seen... Thanks!
The best and simplest explanation for that phenomenon, nothing more than needed to fully show what is really going on.
This is the best of all the videos I've seen on this subject.
i love this video! never thought about lateral inversion this way.
I have never thought of it flipping depth, geez. I'm glad I found this channel
great explanation - there are soooo many other videos trying to explain the construct but they instead ramble about physics for 10 minutes without SHOWING the solution
I’ve seen another UA-cam video try to explain this and fail. With one simple piece of transparency you clarified everything (pun not intended, but welcomed)
Beautifully explained! In fact I'd go so far as to say: *_The Best Video, Yet, On This Subject!!_*
THANK YOU!!! I'VE WATCHED SO MANY BAD EXPLANATIONS OF THIS ON UA-cam AND IT MADE ME FEEL LIKE THE WHOLE WORLD WAS INSANE
life seems so simple in your videos. man you understand everything in these videos
I already knew that, but the transparency example is the most awesome and easiest visual explanation! :-)
Great video and explanation. As for the _psychological_ reason why we arbitrarily tend to think of mirrors flipping left right rather than up down I think it's because when you look into that window onto another world you naturally imagine your Doppelganger got there by walking around behind the mirror (which is a left/right flip) not by diving over the top like a sort of porpoise (because we tend not to move around like that).
Best explanation I have ever seen of this bit of physics.
Your best video yet, in my opinion!
Thank you so much. You explained it really well.
Splendid as always Henry. "Thumbs Up" from a long time subscriber.
Another quality explanation. Thank you :)
I’ve always wondered this. Thank you.
Every time I see something on this, I learn a little bit more. Thanks!
A third mirror, above those 2 at right angles, but closer to the observer and angled so that the rightangled mirrors can be seen via it, with a screen preventing direct observation of those 2 mirrors, allows for all combinations of left-right, up-down reflection, reversal or double reversal.. try it. I constructed this setup for an A level biology project in '76, here in the UK, showing how folks slowed in completing a reflected maze, depending on the combinations used.. :)
I agree with consensus here, you explain it better than most. And you highlight people's misconception of what they expect see when they look in a mirror. People expect to see themselves as if they were in front of the mirror looking at themselves instead of the a mirror flipping of themselves. You also, in much great detail, describe how I initially came to understand mirror images. My initial understanding came by imagining I had a glove on a hand and as you take off the glove you turn it inside out, resulting in the mirror image of my hand. But I like explanation better.Also i thing people describe the flipping as left to right or right to left only because they lack a better conceptual model to describe the flipping.