twilight from charlie's perspective

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2022
  • Check out the links below for an exclusive offer on your first pair! 👇🏽
    Ottoto Arno: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_OttotoArno
    👓 OPEN ME 👓
    Others pairs I’m wearing in the video👇🏽
    Revel Star: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_RevelStar
    Ottoto Lautaro: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_OttotoL...
    Shop over 10,000 styles at GlassesUSA.com 👇🏽
    Eyeglasses: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_Eyeglasses
    Sunglasses: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_Sunglasses
    Hope y'all enjoy the video! (p.s. this is according to the books)
    Business Inquiries: amanda.todhunter@thestation.io
    My Social Media Links:
    TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@amanda.todhun...
    Instagram: / amanda.todhunter
    Description: twilight, new moon, eclipse, breaking dawn, kristen stewart, taylor lautner, robert pattinson, bella swan, charlie swan, edward cullen, jacob black

КОМЕНТАРІ • 754

  • @AmandaTodhunterOfficial
    @AmandaTodhunterOfficial  Рік тому +176

    Check out the links below for an exclusive offer on your first pair! 👇🏽
    Ottoto Arno: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_OttotoArno
    👓 OPEN ME 👓
    Others pairs I’m wearing in the video👇🏽
    Revel Star: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_RevelStar
    Ottoto Lautaro: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_OttotoLautaro
    Shop over 10,000 styles at GlassesUSA.com 👇🏽
    Eyeglasses: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_Eyeglasses
    Sunglasses: glassesusa.me/AmandaT_Sunglasses

    • @Diona8772
      @Diona8772 Рік тому +1

      The video is amazing🤩🤩

    • @arellaramos7745
      @arellaramos7745 Рік тому +1

      Wait Amanda are you not interested in miraculous anymore damn

    • @lahlybird895
      @lahlybird895 Рік тому

      Well that works too I totally never shipped her with Angela ;)

  • @trinaq
    @trinaq Рік тому +8405

    Yes, this franchise would instantly turn into a psychological horror if it was told from Charlie's perspective. He's a nice, normal guy thrust into a strange situation, yet he's constantly kept out of the loop. I wonder if he ever found out that Jacob imprinted on his granddaughter, who aged many years overnight?

    • @onyourleft5648
      @onyourleft5648 Рік тому +561

      At the end the audience is left to wonder if Charlie is safe, if Bella is taken against her will, what is the baby, and why is Jacob so weird around it.

    • @lexxchinchillaa
      @lexxchinchillaa Рік тому +418

      Charlie's just like "huh, odd how my grandchild was only born a couple days ago and already looks like she's six years old but I don't think it's THAT weird. Or the fact my child hasn't aged. Perfectly normal."

    • @ae2688
      @ae2688 Рік тому +436

      towards the end of the last twilight installment, charlie adapted the "i won't ask bc maybe ignorance really is bliss so long as bella is safe and alive" mentality. bella even said something along the lines of "can you stop asking questions if i promise you im fine?", he agreed. so despite Reese's Pieces unnaturally quick growth spurts, he's probably already exhausted from seeing a boy he's known for 10+yrs turn into a wolf and his own daughter is now two shades paler with ice cold skin and red eyes. let him rest 😅

    • @Ace-fo6me
      @Ace-fo6me Рік тому +133

      @@ae2688 Reeses pieces growth spurts😭😭

    • @martinjames6431
      @martinjames6431 Рік тому +33

      He is so pissed on beer all the time he does not care

  • @grapesonnnn
    @grapesonnnn Рік тому +1845

    legit forgot how much the entire hot cast of twilight gaslit my boy charlie

    • @vanb8797
      @vanb8797 Рік тому +76

      Wow...just realized that he was totally being gaslit the whole time. After she was turned Bella should've told him that his hunches about things being strange were true and apologized for dismissing him. Maybe making the statement that, "It's not my place to share everything about the Cullens and the culture I am in now, but you should know that I value your concern and you were right in thinking things were abnormal with me.

  • @vanguardbreaker8826
    @vanguardbreaker8826 Рік тому +4612

    I had absolutely zero context for twilight other than 'edgy werewolves + toxic relationships' so this was a trip

    • @chocolateiguess1613
      @chocolateiguess1613 Рік тому +251

      I know of the basic plot from all the memes but i was still like "huh???lol" through out this whole thing. My favourite meme has to be "YOU NICKNAMED MY DAUGHTER AFTER THE LOCKNESS MONSTER!!!??" peek comedy😭

    • @leaf9286
      @leaf9286 Рік тому +149

      @@chocolateiguess1613 What about "BELLA! Where have you been loca?!"

    • @chocolateiguess1613
      @chocolateiguess1613 Рік тому +8

      @@leaf9286 omg😭that's a good one too. "Hold on tight spider monkey"💀

    • @leaf9286
      @leaf9286 Рік тому +86

      @@chocolateiguess1613 BAHAHAH I FORGOT ABOUT THAT ONE "You're like my own personal brand of heroin."

    • @chocolateiguess1613
      @chocolateiguess1613 Рік тому +60

      @@leaf9286 good lord i forgot about that one. Edward is so embarrassing bruh😭"It's the fluorescents"

  • @londynhunter2469
    @londynhunter2469 Рік тому +2894

    I’m not team Edward, or Jacob. I am team Charlie 💖💖😭😭✨✨

    • @demonqueen3886
      @demonqueen3886 Рік тому +76

      I was team Jacob when I was a kid but now I'm all team Charlie

    • @atomic_artist1
      @atomic_artist1 Рік тому +9

      Same

    • @meldoesntwanttotellyouthei7012
      @meldoesntwanttotellyouthei7012 Рік тому +100

      Used to be team Jacob before he IMPRINTED ON A FETUS so now I’m team Charlie

    • @akelaanimation8934
      @akelaanimation8934 Рік тому +67

      I'm team Alice, shes just underatted and awesome

    • @marlyd
      @marlyd Рік тому +37

      Charlie still wanted Jacob to keep pursuing Bella even when he kissed her without consent and she tried to punch him in the face. He should have been upset at all these awful men, not picking one as a favourite.

  • @shawnamiller191
    @shawnamiller191 Рік тому +3582

    Can we all agree a 107 year old man sneaking into a 17 year old girl's room to watch her sleep is super creepy?

    • @deen7530
      @deen7530 Рік тому +558

      Can we all agree a man sneaking into a girls room to watch her sleep is super creepy?

    • @tempjones3155
      @tempjones3155 Рік тому +122

      Yes but he's a vampire and vampires are creepy and they do sneak into your room at night 😂
      Dracula did that, except he didn't come and stare at you, he was there to feed. But ya know, Edward is ✨ vegetarian ✨

    • @pissapocalypse
      @pissapocalypse Рік тому +87

      He's 119, which is worse

    • @heszedjim9699
      @heszedjim9699 Рік тому +135

      Can we all agree this series was some woman just reliving some shitty vampire childhood fantasy and is 100% sus no matter what way you look at it
      Jacob looked at a baby and decided he was going to marry that baby because imprinting. Literally every cullen was more interesting than edward. Hell, jasper would have had a good story about how a vampire who can barely control his urges is stuck trying to live "vegetarian" is a whole series on its own

    • @deen7530
      @deen7530 Рік тому +125

      @@heszedjim9699 Rosalie hunted down her abuser in her bloody wedding dress! Leah is the first female werewolf like ever! There's an ancient vampire mafia! These concepts are awesome! Why couldn't we get stories about stuff like that, instead of focusing on toxic romance between Blandy McReaderInsert and Vampire Creep Boy?

  • @drewberriesandcream
    @drewberriesandcream Рік тому +1209

    This felt like Charlie met up with the moms of the neighborhood for tea and finally got the chance to talk about himself. I'm totally picturing the other moms responding like "Mm, teens." and "My Melissa is the same way with her boyfriend!"

    • @chisakiaiko6678
      @chisakiaiko6678 Рік тому +82

      This is made so much funnier for me by the fact that I have a friend named Melissa who acts EXACTLY like Bella, in big part bc she’s a fan of twilight and other vampire movies.😂

    • @drewberriesandcream
      @drewberriesandcream Рік тому +19

      @@chisakiaiko6678 i’m crying 😂

    • @ASMRmemee
      @ASMRmemee Рік тому +5

      💀

  • @renoodle5554
    @renoodle5554 Рік тому +3834

    Tw: discussion of abuse and sexual assault
    Something that really struck me in the movies specifically was how clearly it would have seemed to Charlie that Bella was in an abusive relationship. The "falling down the stairs" excuse is used a lot by victims of abuse to explain bruising (and as an officer, im sure Charlie saw his fair share of that). The "abandonment in the woods" thing followed by a months-long depression spiral... it could have looked like something so much worse than a breakup to a concerned father. It makes me so sad for him- he does everything he can to protect her from this boy who's clearly hurting her emotionally and physically (regardless of intention, again im looking from charlies perspective) and watches her relationships with her friends deteriorate. He does everything he possibly can, and she still chooses the man who seemingly hurts her endlessly. I really feel for Charlie. He is the true victim of the series imo

    • @maximillian1109
      @maximillian1109 Рік тому +364

      Well, she was in an abusive relationship. Just not in the physical way, mostly.

    • @dawnriddler
      @dawnriddler Рік тому +53

      I mean to be real, Bella was a drama queen, which is probably why he didn't look too much into it.

    • @cc.8805
      @cc.8805 Рік тому +217

      @@dawnriddler She was a child

    • @dawnriddler
      @dawnriddler Рік тому +16

      @@cc.8805 so? children can't be overly dramatic?

    • @cc.8805
      @cc.8805 Рік тому +207

      @@dawnriddler A child going through violent trauma and abuse. Yeah, no. She can't be "overly dramatic".

  • @lunarapocalypse9341
    @lunarapocalypse9341 Рік тому +1811

    Just imagining Charlie making these video diaries and Edward hearing from the other room 😂

  • @sierrajohnson717
    @sierrajohnson717 Рік тому +344

    I want twilight from Jessica’s perspective, fully pissed the hot guy chose her new friend but also weirded out, especially by the second movie, and guessing she’s pregnant at her wedding

    • @jordy13xoxo17
      @jordy13xoxo17 Рік тому +5

      YES

    • @annabourbon
      @annabourbon Рік тому +46

      This 😭😂 like "oh dang I really dodged a bullet there!"

  • @jesssoucy4976
    @jesssoucy4976 Рік тому +1179

    Poor Charlie. Things really went from 0 to 100 for him 😂

  • @ae2688
    @ae2688 Рік тому +848

    here's why i think charlie didn't question further about Resume. towards the end of the last twilight installment, he adapted the "i won't ask bc maybe ignorance really is bliss so long as bella is safe and alive" mentality. bella even said something along the lines of "can you stop asking questions if i promise you im fine?", he agreed. so despite Reese's Pieces unnaturally quick growth spurts, he's probably already exhausted from seeing a boy he's known for 10+yrs turn into a wolf and his own daughter is now two shades paler with ice cold skin and red eyes. let him rest 😅

    • @mitchierainbow7353
      @mitchierainbow7353 Рік тому +136

      Not Resume and Reese's pieces💀😂

    • @sketchyghost_6271
      @sketchyghost_6271 Рік тому +45

      @@mitchierainbow7353 the whole comment is so valid but my mind will never let go of Resume

    • @annafromhsm
      @annafromhsm Рік тому +11

      i giggled

    • @amanix10
      @amanix10 Рік тому +10

      reece's pieces T_T

    • @morgancohen2475
      @morgancohen2475 Рік тому +4

      resume & reeses pieces im literally deceased

  • @hel616
    @hel616 Рік тому +1391

    charlie is defenittly team jacob and alice,anything is better than edward. Honestly i am team alice cuz she at least seems somewhat reasonable and sees her as an actual person unlike some other people

    • @kiora1947
      @kiora1947 Рік тому +151

      Alice also tries to be supportive of Bella’s interests and proactively protects her

    • @sickcrabfactz
      @sickcrabfactz Рік тому +95

      team alice she’s nice and pretty and not a freak like those other two guys

    • @HeavenlyEchoVirus
      @HeavenlyEchoVirus Рік тому +20

      Though she did totally ghost Bella when Edward convinced his whole family to run away. Until Edward’s life was on the line.

    • @lahlybird895
      @lahlybird895 Рік тому +5

      Please don't do jasper like that
      How about Tyler

    • @heszedjim9699
      @heszedjim9699 Рік тому +19

      Jacob whole ass says pulls the "i want to groom your child because thats how werewolves works" i feel like charlie would not be down with his granddaughter being groomed

  • @pantropicalouxwaevheart4567
    @pantropicalouxwaevheart4567 Рік тому +474

    he sounded too sane for all that to happen in a year

    • @lahlybird895
      @lahlybird895 Рік тому +18

      To be fair it was more like almost two

    • @geeking424
      @geeking424 Рік тому +1

      A year??

    • @lahlybird895
      @lahlybird895 Рік тому +4

      @@geeking424 it was at least a year and a half possibly more than that

    • @rebeccaboyd5190
      @rebeccaboyd5190 Рік тому +5

      ​@geeking in the book she moved to forks in January, then turned 18 that September and that's when the cullens left. Then the cullens came back in march, then they graduate in June. Then they get married and preggo in August and she's turned three days before her birthday in September haha

  • @Black_pearl_adrift
    @Black_pearl_adrift Рік тому +856

    I was actually working on a short story about some random student in forks falling for Bella and being jelous of Edward starts looking into stuff waaaay too much. I just find it funny how insane the plot would look like from an outsider’s perspective

    • @lampyrisnoctiluca9904
      @lampyrisnoctiluca9904 Рік тому +57

      i have read somewhere on the internet the similar description of Hamlet. it was a horror story. similar thing. exactly the same things were happening just like in the play. for anyone lacking some crucial information only known by major characters, it was a horror story. and when you add that the story starts with a ghost sighting... yeah... Hamlet is a horror story.

    • @aansherina4536
      @aansherina4536 Рік тому +10

      @@lampyrisnoctiluca9904 Damn I need to read that

    • @lahlybird895
      @lahlybird895 Рік тому +18

      Do Eric I think he's the only one of the three boys in her school who had a crush on her who didn't end up in a long-term relationship afterward

    • @forrest9881
      @forrest9881 Рік тому +5

      Ok where can we read lmao

    • @Black_pearl_adrift
      @Black_pearl_adrift Рік тому +6

      @@lahlybird895 I actually wanted to make it a wlw story 😅 but I agree about Eric esp in the books

  • @Kayizcray
    @Kayizcray Рік тому +573

    I really love how obsessed the internet has become with charlie in recent years... especially since, upon learning this, my dad just casually dropped a "oh yeah in school I was friends with billy burke" which really took me out 😂

    • @avet9413
      @avet9413 Рік тому +6

      That’s wild :0

  • @mariem8705
    @mariem8705 Рік тому +187

    Charlie should’ve shipped bella back to her moms when she went into a depression after Edward abandoned bella in the woods and demand that she be put in therapy to deal with her issues.

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +24

      If I remember right, he tried to do both in New Moon, and she threw a huge fit. When he tried getting her to a therapist, she rejected to go because she thought she'd be put in an asylum.

  • @JackedThor-so
    @JackedThor-so Рік тому +905

    Wow, hearing all of this from Charlie's perspective really highlights how crappy of a person Bella truly is. She plays emotional yo-yo with her dad, tells him nothing, and uses him and his home purely transactionally to be close to Edward. She brushes off his concern, doesn't involve Jim in her life, and generally doesn't seem to care that much about him whatsoever. Like, the trend I've seen some people making Charlie Vampire Hunter AUs makes a hell of a lot more sense now.

    • @monicacreator3168
      @monicacreator3168 Рік тому +110

      She truly emotionally abused her dad

    • @strawberryfox8819
      @strawberryfox8819 Рік тому +70

      It makes sense though. She's in a toxic relationship and even the most amazing people can turn horrible in those.

    • @majora5651
      @majora5651 Рік тому +62

      She‘s basically aweful to everybody except maybe her daughter. She threatens to kill herself left and right which is absolutely a no-go in each and every relationship ever

    • @mrmosbyslefttit
      @mrmosbyslefttit Рік тому +56

      I cried a little when I read the scene of her using her moms words as ammunition to hurt him so he would let her leave, all under the guise of keeping him safe…

    • @AxelBain
      @AxelBain Рік тому +36

      Also like…his daughter seems to have settled into her new town, has a group of mostly good friends (Jessica being the exception), is going on outings with them, but then becomes obsessed with a guy who has no friends, is part of a family that dates their adopted siblings, and while I love his dad, is really weird. My daughter then goes to some event at their family home, rushes home to tell me that she’s broken up with her boyfriend and literally says the same thing that my ex-wife told me when she left me, is gone for several weeks (iirc in the book they’re in the hotel for several weeks) then comes back with a broken leg and tells me that she and her boyfriend are back together. Immediately, there are going to be some VERY big alarm bells going off. Now she goes to ANOTHER event at his family’s house, comes back injured, and the next day the boyfriend and his entire family ditch town and he leaves my daughter in the forest, where I have to organize a search party for her. She goes into a months long depression and wakes up screaming and crying but then starts hanging out with a kid I’ve known his entire life, and begins feeling happy and hanging out with her friends again, although this time, it’s only her good friends (Jessica having left her for Lauren’s side). She then departs for Italy for two days, and comes back with her boyfriend. She stops hanging out with Jacob, and it’s all Edward again. She goes on a camping trip, and emerges injured once more. She gets married at EIGHTEEN, disappears for several weeks, I’m told that she has a suspicious viral illness that I can’t visit her for, but I see Dr Cullen around town. Weeks later, a boy I’ve known his entire life strips down and turns into a wolf, and I visit my daughter’s house. There’s a child whom I do not know who is there, my daughter looks healthy but last time I heard she was on her deathbed. As someone who is likely trained to recognize the signs of domestic abuse, there are likely SO many alarms going off in my head.

  • @linkLoverAG
    @linkLoverAG Рік тому +123

    Speaking on Alice "The girls an angel. Nothing but the best vibes for her."
    Same Charlie, Same. Fuckin love Alice.

  • @sunnni_
    @sunnni_ Рік тому +133

    I always thought Charlie was lowkey stressedddddd because of all of this. Like nobody really asked him if he was okay after his daughter almost died, kept him out the loop numerous times, saw Jacob become a werewolf, etc. I just know I would have given him a bottle and month away lol

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +18

      Same. Dude probably has more gray hairs from dealing with Bella and her supernatural pals than being a damn cop. I wonder how stressed out he'll be when he finds out his granddaughter is dating his friend's 35 year old son at the age of 18 if not younger. I don't see Charlie approving.

  • @yearlywise8003
    @yearlywise8003 Рік тому +650

    Charlie was and is literally the only character I could resonate with in this stupid series…. Your videos are GOLD bahahahaha

  • @Hazeljv3
    @Hazeljv3 Рік тому +324

    Last time I rewatched the first Twilight movie with my friends, I realized that in EVERY SINGLE SCENE Charlie is in he has at least one tallboy beer can with him. Every scene. Idk if that continues in the other movies, but it is definitely my favourite part of the series.

    • @iamcool544
      @iamcool544 Рік тому +58

      My man needs it.

    • @princessamethyst9312
      @princessamethyst9312 Рік тому +13

      Its mentioned because he loves beer, and that beer he drinks in the movie was his favorite brand I googled finding out that answer when I wanted to buy the same beer brand
      but it doesnt exist nowXD

    • @schoo9256
      @schoo9256 Рік тому +5

      @@princessamethyst9312 isn't it Rainier Beer?

    • @princessamethyst9312
      @princessamethyst9312 Рік тому +9

      ​@@schoo9256 yes :3 its no longer brewed locally for people to buy everywhere but in certain places it still exists I guess I just googled more info lol

  • @Zelologist
    @Zelologist Рік тому +27

    “we fell into a routine of her cooking my meals and i pretend not to hear her crying at night” you said that so nonchalantly 😭

  • @dazzlingdexter5060
    @dazzlingdexter5060 Рік тому +259

    I always felt like this looked bad from Charlie's point of view, but having you spell the entire incident out... I feel so bad for Charlie. He just so confused

  • @cece8638
    @cece8638 Рік тому +303

    This man has to be too tired for Bella's antics😭

  • @noneofyourbeezwax7284
    @noneofyourbeezwax7284 Рік тому +47

    Up until the Jacob wolf reveal, Charlie has got to be thinking Bella’s in an abusive relationship. All the red flags are there and he’s in police work so it would be a familiar topic

  • @whatalsaid
    @whatalsaid Рік тому +16

    If the Cullen had never lived in Forks, twilight would probably be one of those quirky romantic comedies where the manic pixie dream girl helps the lonely main character come out of their shell, but the Manic Pixie Dream Girl just happens to be a werewolf.

  • @justsomeferalminor
    @justsomeferalminor Рік тому +251

    I wish instead of Edward there was just Robert Pattinson being himself, growing increasingly disturbed and confused by the people around him and their absurd actions. It would be comedy gold.

  • @genera1013
    @genera1013 Рік тому +161

    Never been a Twilight fan, but I would totally read a version of it from Charlie's point of view. Imagine him calling Bella's mom and trying to explain this sh!t lol

  • @fatmanobby4329
    @fatmanobby4329 Рік тому +22

    Charlie taking off his moustache because it’s annoying to talk with is now cannon in the twilight universe

  • @renaissancewoman3770
    @renaissancewoman3770 Рік тому +300

    I want to start writing my own ones of these, like Mulan from Shang's perspective.

    • @lucamara6424
      @lucamara6424 Рік тому +23

      I love that idea! Would make a good UA-cam series or something else

    • @lolaaakaypeanutbrittle9213
      @lolaaakaypeanutbrittle9213 Рік тому +10

      This sounds like a awesome idea!! Would love to see how it goes!

    • @theawesomegamebox513
      @theawesomegamebox513 Рік тому +3

      YES

    • @umi6233
      @umi6233 Рік тому +11

      I bet you Shang was annoyed af that he had some weird feeling for Ping, that why he traew a tantrum when he found out about a drag show that Mulan put up😅

    • @geeking424
      @geeking424 Рік тому

      that would be great!

  • @anthonyebony3464
    @anthonyebony3464 Рік тому +64

    The weirdrst part was Charlie not wanting to know more 😂 you heard about Werewolves snd Vampires but you just gonna turn over and go back to sleep 😂😂😂

    • @mariakhan7986
      @mariakhan7986 Рік тому +6

      If someone hinted at you that it's dangerous to know then I'd probably prefer ignorance too. Bella straight up said she'd never be able to have him in her life unless he asked no questions and just accepted their 'truth'.

  • @dustymuffincop2481
    @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +345

    I always felt bad for Charlie. Call me a weirdo, but I use to ship him with Alice for some reason. I think the reason why was because the only people that cared about him was Alice and occasionally Bella. I was so worried that he'd pass out or have a stroke or something with all the things Bella put him through intentionally or not. Imagine having a daughter that got dumped and ended up depressed, got injured multiple times, screams every night after getting dumped, and running away to go after the guy who caused her so much pain. I honestly want a book telling his side of things. Poor man.

    • @saintshrooms9424
      @saintshrooms9424 Рік тому +37

      Alice was in the body of a teenager though…
      I know she’s old asf but it’s still weird

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +68

      @@saintshrooms9424 Like I said I use to. It was back in middle school. I agree it would look weird since Alice looks young even though she is old enough to be Charlie's grandma or mother.

    • @monicacreator3168
      @monicacreator3168 Рік тому +27

      Weird that you say that since people say that Edward is too old for Bella even though hes in a teenager's body

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +33

      @@monicacreator3168 I meant it's weird based on appearances alone. I'm probably explaining this wrong, but I'll try. Edward gets away with being with Bella (in the books anyways) is because they physically look alike in terms of age. I'm not condoning their romance. I'm just saying without context, Edward and Bella LOOK normal while Charlie and Alice would look weird since it's usually frowned upon that someone that looks as old as Charlie would date someone that claims to be around his daughter's age.
      When it comes down to the age gap, Alice and Charlie's age gap is better than Edward and Bella's.

    • @vanb8797
      @vanb8797 Рік тому +15

      @@monicacreator3168 From my recollection, Alice was actually a young woman in the books (not a teenager) when she was turned.

  • @strawberryfox8819
    @strawberryfox8819 Рік тому +56

    What I think is especially weird in the movie is that when Jacob tells Charlie that Bella broke her hand punshing after he forcefully kissed her, he doesn't react negatively to him. Like I was hoping he'd try to break his nose, too, judging from how he reacts to Edward. But no. And he doesn't even take her to the doctor for her Hand.

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +16

      He does the same thing in the Eclipse book too. It was really out of character for him. He thankfully apologized for later. I'm thinking the intention was to show that Charlie hates Edward so much that Charlie allows Jacob to get away with what he did because he prefers Jacob. After sitting on, he realized he was wrong for not responding the correct way which is good on him.

  • @MogamiKyoko13
    @MogamiKyoko13 Рік тому +50

    The older I get, the more I think that if I had to be any character in a fantasy novel, I'd probably want to be Charlie. Dude gets to eventually be in on the supernatural hullabaloo without having to know the nitty-gritty. He's like, "does it affect my daily life in any way? No? Then I don't have to know. Just tell me the important details in the event that I'm gonna die, you're gonna die, or you're gonna leave forever never to be seen again."

  • @awesomemb546
    @awesomemb546 Рік тому +94

    "He has other friends, unlike some people" GIRL-

  • @laurenc4138
    @laurenc4138 Рік тому +21

    Ya know I was a teenager when the books/movies came out I was a teenager and while I love Charlie cause he reminds me of my dad, all I could think was “ugh parental obstacle to true love” as an adult I’m like “I would’ve constantly thought she was being near murked by her teenaged brooding bf”

  • @Blueeyesthewarrior
    @Blueeyesthewarrior Рік тому +77

    “Team Jacob…. For me” 😂

  • @LaVozdelSilencio1000
    @LaVozdelSilencio1000 Рік тому +38

    13:00 is such a typical parent reaction, you nailed it!! XD Even a minimal interaction between your daughter and a guy is interpreted as "WOW I'd betterget my suit ready for the wedding!" XD

  • @dreamiinotdream730
    @dreamiinotdream730 Рік тому +134

    I’m still waiting for the Charlie Vampire Hunter fic where he sees how badly Bella is being affected by being with Edward and just goes “fuck it, I’m killing everyone.”

    • @endTHEhegemony_Today
      @endTHEhegemony_Today Рік тому +16

      Yes, and there's an alternate cut where Billy Burke plays the whole movie out of character, as purely himself, no attachments to Bella, pure confusement and not-dad logic
      Ohhh I would live to see a Charlie Swan Vampire Hunter Saga
      🖤💜💙💚💙💜🖤
      Much love!!

    • @claire.chiste
      @claire.chiste Рік тому +14

      Charlie the vampire slayer

  • @katlynh1289
    @katlynh1289 Рік тому +55

    Honestly poor Charlie, everything is so chaotic from his perspective

  • @VladDraculaIII
    @VladDraculaIII Рік тому +39

    Charlie finds out she is a vampire and had a half vampire baby : YOU ARE GROUNDED FOR LIFE!!!

  • @vivivalley
    @vivivalley Рік тому +66

    watching this as someone who hasnt seen the twilight movies is so insane

  • @DanielaMedina-jg2kk
    @DanielaMedina-jg2kk Рік тому +21

    Poor Charlie he didn’t have a second of peace since Bella moved in with him😂😂 things kept becoming weirder and weirder

  • @monicacreator3168
    @monicacreator3168 Рік тому +51

    Vella is literally the worst daughter?? No communication, threaten to run away anytime her father talk, gaslight the S*IT out of him, does not care for the poor man...
    Shes the worst!

  • @saradoutre9457
    @saradoutre9457 Рік тому +19

    I was always team Jacob too! He was the one who she didn’t have do die to be with, he didn’t stalk her, the relationship wasn’t obsessive

  • @sylve2474
    @sylve2474 Рік тому +114

    As someone who never read past the first book,,, this was thoroughly entertaining despite my lack of context apart from whatever has come up through, like,, text posts and comments mentioned in other videos I've watched over the years

  • @sonia230898
    @sonia230898 Рік тому +64

    It's so easy to see how toxic Bella and Edwards relationship was through Charlie's eyes

  • @enkaizero
    @enkaizero Рік тому +12

    I feel like this is a pov if we went out drinking and chilling with Charlie to a point he starts spilling from little funny stuff to a full vent about Bella and her entire weird ass life and I'm either too invested or in a chokehold to listen all about it. love the guy

  • @strelitziamystery21
    @strelitziamystery21 Рік тому +23

    So Charlie doesn't even know that she is a Vampire, just that she is now *something* supernatural?
    You would think you would let the Chief of police know about these kinda things not just to protect the town and the secret, but for his daughter's safety too.

  • @Flufferz626
    @Flufferz626 Рік тому +16

    Charlie was the best developed neglected character in modern young adult fiction. If that makes sense.

  • @AmandaTodhunterOfficial
    @AmandaTodhunterOfficial  Рік тому +49

    any character suggestions y'all 👀

  • @patiencearchuleta7254
    @patiencearchuleta7254 11 місяців тому +4

    Charlie is every good parent that's been kept in the dark about their child's supernatural shenanigans

  • @kvngjae6185
    @kvngjae6185 Рік тому +15

    This really reminds me of what the parents (at least the ones who aren’t selling you to 1D) in fanfics povs would be

  • @patyluna821
    @patyluna821 Рік тому +12

    Charlie's POV just makes it sound like Bella got physically and emotionaly injured by the Cullens whenever she was found on the edge of dying. If i had no bg i would guess the Cullens were some sort of witchcrafters abusing the girl.

  • @amynguyen4116
    @amynguyen4116 Рік тому +80

    I follow your channel for Miraculous Ladybug, and when ML wasn't updating often enough, I started re-reading Midnight Sun just to consume more trash romance. I literally finished the reading with the thought, "I would love to read Twilight from Charlie's perspective". Boy do you deliver

  • @Veronica-pz4gw
    @Veronica-pz4gw Рік тому +43

    I most certainly would not call Bella and old soul lol. But yes, Charlie, you are my spirit animal.

  • @AwesomeOstree
    @AwesomeOstree Рік тому +104

    Loved this and all your other "Perspective of" videos! I think an Attack on Titan from Levi's perspective would be pretty cool as your next in the series :)

  • @tiny-goldfish4556
    @tiny-goldfish4556 Рік тому +8

    Being told my Charlie’s perspective, I can really see how young Bella acts 😢 like she’s just a baby

  • @moonlisa5992
    @moonlisa5992 Рік тому +72

    Just watched the full saga these days i think for the first time and felt really bad for charlie, i wouldnt want to be in his place. Both Edward and Jacob are dumb, but i think Jake, not to excuse him just in comparison, is a kid and loved Bella much more, at least in the first movies. And Bella is kinda evil imo.

    • @strawberryfox8819
      @strawberryfox8819 Рік тому +7

      Bella isn't evil. She's a teenager who had a complicated home life with divorced parents, is in a new town with basically zero friends and ends up in a toxic relationship that nearly gets her killed more than once. Of course she'd be fucked up.
      Meanwhile, Jacob is a classic nice-guy (in the movies) who sexually assaulted her and is now grooming a child and Edward is a total creep that (even though he may mean well) is toxic as shit.

  • @analia19
    @analia19 Рік тому +25

    He is so confused bout everything imagine getting two phone calls all of the sudden that your daughter is in the ER

  • @lahlybird895
    @lahlybird895 Рік тому +10

    Skipping right over Charlie's reaction to Jacob's forced kiss I see

  • @vanb8797
    @vanb8797 Рік тому +14

    I always empathized with Charlie. Honestly, I thought in the books that Bella was kind of a bitch to her family and her "friends". When she got to Washington, the persons at her school were very welcoming and friendly, but her inner monologue was very judgemental and snobbish towards them. I think she is pretty disrespectful towards Charlie. I think part of Bella's attraction to Edward and the Cullens' world was the secrecy and exclusivity. She liked tagging along to these ancient, beautiful people. If she had met Edward a little older (provided he was no longer masquerading as a 17-year-old High School Student) I wonder if she would have fallen for him and rejected her human life so easily. A lot of it sounds like teen angst and boredom.
    Despite Bella actually being the least interesting and the most annoying person in those books, I have to give it to Stephanie Meyers that she keeps her readers curious and involved...I read these in my late 20s--lovable garbage. I just hope young people do not read these books/watch the films and actually base their choices from this codependent mess. For the record, I am "Team Jacob" in the books---I wish he wouldn't have gotten more involved with Bella and the Cullens and just lived his life. Jacob definitely settled.

    • @dustymuffincop2481
      @dustymuffincop2481 Рік тому +5

      I thought so too. Within her first day of school, she compares a guy to a dog for being nice and said one guy was overly helpful when he wasn't. Meanwhile she isn't upset that a guy she barely knows watched her sleep but she is upset that she talks in her sleep. Could be me, but she was way too mean to Mike sometimes. Edward thinks she's so sweet and pure, but her thoughts are straight up nasty sometimes for no reason. And she calls Jessica mean. I can handle a character being a b*tch but I don't like it when people swear she's a sweetheart in the story. She's not.
      As I've gotten older, her attitude towards Charlie makes some sense as teenagers can be disrespectful towards adults. Not saying it's right, but it's a thing some teens do. However her thinking about running away with Edward in book 2 is just upsetting. I know she "loves" him but running off with his family and leaving Charlie alone is cruel.
      I honestly don't think Bella would've fell for him if either looked his real age or wasn't a vampire. She seems to only take interest because he's handsome and a vampire.
      I'm also Team Jacob for New Moon mostly. Meyers ruined him in Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. I know he had his bad moments in New Moon, but he was still a sweetheart at times. More than I can say for Edward. Jacob would've been better off if the writer let him split away from Bella and gave him a girl that wasn't Bella or her kid.

  • @nichelleniks4526
    @nichelleniks4526 Рік тому +16

    This is everything. I haven't had the urge to consume any Twilight content since middle school, but this is *chef's kiss*

  • @redactedvt7873
    @redactedvt7873 Рік тому +15

    This is perfect because this is exactly how I would like to remain in regards to this show, out of the loop. Never seen twilight, not planning to, but this was enjoyable.

  • @LaVozdelSilencio1000
    @LaVozdelSilencio1000 Рік тому +26

    The amount of EFFORT put into this, THE DETAIL!! Just, outstanding work, loved every second hahaha

  • @ruiqing7
    @ruiqing7 Рік тому +23

    rip to charlie, the number one team jacob supporter

  • @sisterbeautyful
    @sisterbeautyful Рік тому +7

    GODDAMN is this premium youtube? girl this was amazing, a rollercoaster, I will even binge twilight again because after this the movie is not the same to me, you opened my charlie's third eye *chef kiss*

  • @accioenchiladas
    @accioenchiladas Рік тому +18

    it's 1 am and i can't sleep because i have a cold so thanks for giving me something to watch in the meantime :)

  • @owlgirl1067
    @owlgirl1067 Рік тому +10

    Look, I do not like twilight. But THIS, this peaked my interest and did not disappoint. I think I just like high school parent drama. Thank you for making this, I like twilight 2% more now

  • @victoryv116
    @victoryv116 Рік тому +8

    Charlie is the most relatable character to me

  • @AdrianasWonderland
    @AdrianasWonderland Рік тому +26

    I appreciate your commitment and I admire your acting skills. Twilight is my life, and also you are my life too. girl, i adore you

  • @norawolohan5753
    @norawolohan5753 Рік тому +11

    I'm Team Alice, who needs Team Jacob or Edward when we got Alice with her amazing pitching skills

    • @strawberryfox8819
      @strawberryfox8819 Рік тому +2

      This. Let's just ditch Jasper, we don't need an Ex-Confederate soldier from the wrong side here.

  • @hooddaddy7124
    @hooddaddy7124 Рік тому +8

    ive always been team Charlie 😂 Hes a quiet dood with a good paying job, he lives in the woods which i personally love, the towns folk are nice for the most part, and he is really caring. I can get why Renée and other women wouldn't be into a "boring" guy like him but me myself, love this type of person plus i have autism so having the same meal on specific days at set times, EVERY WEEK, love it sign me the fuck up. Im gonna fuckin marry Carlie 🤣

  • @estherriley6879
    @estherriley6879 Рік тому +22

    This is the first of your videos that I don’t know the franchise very well so it was an interesting experience

  • @eliseivanica
    @eliseivanica Рік тому +3

    in the end charlie really just accepted that some weird ass shit was going and went with it 😭

  • @arabellacarter1482
    @arabellacarter1482 Рік тому +93

    If you’re doing books, can I recommend Harry Potter from Draco’s POV.
    (Grishaverse from Nikolai’s perspective would also be wild.)

    • @mibbles2371
      @mibbles2371 Рік тому +10

      But Draco is a little slimy racist, would be better from like Oliver Wood's POV instead

    • @whitneyhenry5755
      @whitneyhenry5755 Рік тому +2

      What other books do you recommend!! I read most of the grisha verse books (crow) and the HP series. I read vampire academy, hunger games, divergent, house of night etc. What other books do you like

    • @arabellacarter1482
      @arabellacarter1482 Рік тому +3

      @@whitneyhenry5755 I’ve been binge reading the Shadowhunter books recently and I love them all. Unfortunately most books end up on my TBR ;P

  • @trashplant3471
    @trashplant3471 Рік тому +12

    One of my favourite things about these videos you do is that it feels like sitting down and catching up with an old friend you haven’t seen in years. There’s no fancy graphics or clips from the sources or anything. Just you telling a story as a character we don’t usually get to see the point of view of. I tend to have issues focusing on videos that are just people talking to a camera but your videos are so easy for me to sit through.

  • @yvonnest.pierre5963
    @yvonnest.pierre5963 Рік тому +4

    bro Charlie takes everything in silence.
    even though to him it looks like a fricking blood bath.

  • @nerd26373
    @nerd26373 Рік тому +56

    You seem very insightful. We all hope to see more great videos on this channel. Keep up the good work and may God bless you.

  • @scyntheachannel
    @scyntheachannel Рік тому +6

    Her poor dad though I always felt bad for him he lost literally everything

  • @erika-paigehutch3930
    @erika-paigehutch3930 Рік тому +14

    ive seen the first twilight and now i never have to watch any of the others because this explained it all perfectly

  • @Violet_the_cat-
    @Violet_the_cat- Рік тому +17

    Where’d the board go?
    Where’d the board go?????
    We need the board!

  • @alexavij
    @alexavij Рік тому +4

    “Bella looked nervous, she likes parties about as much as i do, so I drove off and left her in the DUST” 😂

  • @sickcrabfactz
    @sickcrabfactz Рік тому +8

    she put that man through so much grief 😭

  • @SamStPeter
    @SamStPeter Рік тому +5

    this video is so chaotic i love it

  • @alecbradley7579
    @alecbradley7579 Рік тому +12

    These are some of my favourite youtube videos ever made

  • @cloama
    @cloama Рік тому +9

    It's been Team Charlie's Mustache since day one.

  • @violeta7298
    @violeta7298 Рік тому +10

    all along, i think charlie was the biggest team alice actually

  • @eurovianmutt
    @eurovianmutt Рік тому +3

    I went to school with someone who has the last name Todhunter. They also wore glasses. I also went to school with someone named Tod. We all went to the school of bad insults.
    They best insult the insulters could come up with is “you last name is Todhunter. your name is Tod.” I think they might have added “you must hunt Tods then.”

  • @Aster_Risk
    @Aster_Risk Рік тому +3

    I had such a crush on Charlie as a teenager and now at 31. For me, the only team is Team Charlie.

  • @megdalena01
    @megdalena01 Рік тому +3

    OMG Poor Charlie! I never thought about what all that looked like from his point of view.

  • @zontiky
    @zontiky Рік тому +8

    charlie stans have been waiting for this

  • @dysmissme7343
    @dysmissme7343 Рік тому +2

    I LAUGHED AT LOUD AT THIS CONCEPT ALONE!! 😂😂😂

  • @alizamoon6842
    @alizamoon6842 Рік тому +4

    Stephanie Meyers give us a book where Jacob and Bella actually made it, for Charlie’s sake-

  • @jacksmith7660
    @jacksmith7660 7 місяців тому +1

    I like to watch this randomly from time to time. As a Native person Twlight is my guilty pleasure and Charlie Swan is one of my top favorite characters. You did amazing covering his pov. This video is awesome 😂

  • @bettyreads222
    @bettyreads222 Рік тому +4

    Poor charlie. His daughter is going through it and he's feels he can't do anything to help 😮 "don't tell me what to do bitch" 😅 Charlie's hatred of edward in this is so well deserved!

  • @one-onessadhalf3393
    @one-onessadhalf3393 Рік тому +4

    “This really set me off because the rest of the town, especially Billy, loves to talk shit about them, but they seem like a decent enough family!” Favorite sentence

  • @Annie-ri2tn
    @Annie-ri2tn Рік тому +7

    Thank you, this is just what I was looking for. I just had medschool midterms so a good dose of twilight is exactly what I needed.

  • @gothamtruecrime
    @gothamtruecrime Рік тому +12

    Charlie is Team Alice. Same.