First time heard too close and honest review about sikhs history of 20th century from Pakistan We learnt a historical lesson for future to never trust any political promise from hindu leaders. Khalistan is our future. Khalistan and Pakistan will rise in future as a good neighbors. Khalistan will play a role as buffer zone between Pakistan and india. Thanks for sharing information
Off course after Khalistan and Kashmir India have only few borders left with Pakistan always India take advantage of their more population majority and they attack from 7 or 8 borders if they can attack from 2 or 3 borders then India nows very well we Pakistanis will fuck India very badly like 1965 when we was in kumkaran which is inside India then Naru run toward UN and ask for help...
@@zindagiahmed4600 tu kon sa Arab Shaikh ki pahchan he ? Tere baap dada bhi to convated Musalman he . Muje mat samja Lahore , Multan , Peshawar , gujranwla sab sikho ka tha lootliya tum lootero ne . Jaake path mohenjo daro jo Sindh me he .
Bro Sikhs has problems with Muslim rulers but a common Muslim people is like brothers to us, that why more than 1lakh Muslim brothers live in malerkotla and more than 6lakh in total Punjab likes brothers because most of Muslim brothers respect our religion and we respect them, our tenth guru request Miya mir to lay foudation of golden temple by there hands and pir buddhu shah help guru gobind Singh g in battle also, so we never forget contribution of Islam and Muslims bro,s in our religion
Sikh got killed in the partition, we lost our lands because of bad leadership and trusting the people who our gurus said are blind. Trusted india got a genocide because of that. Hindu and Sikh were not closer Sikh and Muslim have been close in the history of Punjab. it was pushed into the minds of many people by politicians. Sikh had lost real leaders in the fight for freedom for the subcontinent. Leaders like Bhagat Singh, Sardar Udham Singh, Sardar Kartar Singh Sarabha were lost in name of freedom.
one mistake all sikh nation suffering from last 72 years as well as kashmiris also because if sikh can decide with pakistan or our seprate nation kashmir was also part of pakistan because kashmiri sikh raja is also geting bad decision to support india
Not only Tara Singh, my brother. Also, the Maharaja of Patiala, Yadavinder Singh, is to blame. He was very powerful and could've changed the situation.
Being a Sikh I thanks to the documentary maker , very honest and correct facts shown in this video, we Sikhs believe that we did historic political mistake to reject offer of Jinna Saab to stay in Pak Punjab and bcos of this we are living slaves of Hindus in India , our human rights were/are demolished by Hindus , BJP, RSS and we feel we need our Sikh home land for our survival
افسوس اور معزرت میرے سکھ بھائیوں کے بڑوں نے یقیناً غلط فیصلہ کیا تھا۔ موجوہ پاکستان میں سیکھ بھائیوں کو بہت عزت ہے اور انڈیا میں آج سب واضح ہے۔ شکریہ محمد علی جناح آپ ہندؤں کے نفسیات سمجھ کر ھمیں الگ ملک بنا کے دیا۔ الحمدللہ پاکستان زنداباد پائندہ باد 🇵🇰✌️🤲
jo jo b us vakt sikh leadrs te ya maharaja patiyala ye sbh gdaar hen.... inho ne e punjaab ko india ke hwale kr diya ... ye gdaar bnde the jo real sikhs the vo to apna alag raaj chahte the kyu k alrdy sikh punjab alag raaj tha... master tara singh gdaar maharaja patiyala gadaar inhe sikh mat kaho bhai....🙏
@@braveheart8318 kis ne kaha bro k muslimo k saath dushmni thi muslimo k saath to sbse acha rishta tha bro i think tusi hstry Nu chngi tra prhya ni darbar sahib hermndr sahib d neeh SAI MIYA MEER G ne rkhi c BABA NANAK G De naal 50 saal tak BHAI MARDANA G RAHE PEER BUDHU SHAH JI ne GURU GOBINDSINGH JI da jung vich saath dita or to or GURU GOBIND SINGH g k janam sbse pehle milne unhe SAI BUDHNN SHAH JI gye the ... bro ldayi jung muslimo k saath nhi thi GLT SYSTEM OR DHARMIK TOR PR JO HINDU JULM KR RAHE THE US PR THI OR US VKT KI GVT K SAATH THI JO GLT KR RAHI THI .... rahi baat btware ki btwara punjab k logo k dilo ka hua tha dhrti ka to bs ek bahana tha ...
@@buttfoundry bro nuksaam to aam jnta ka hua tha ... vo chahe sikh ho hindu ho ya muslim hege ta punjabi hee sare ... maharaja ranjit singh g de punjab vich jo sada bhaichara c aps ch osto sari dunia wakif c ..ese krk sanu todya gya
@@harmeetsingh8611 jaan bojh ke qatle aam krayaa gya c rawalpindi vich jithey a qatl e aam hoya c otho army hq 20 mint di drive te c pr army te police 7 din baad ayi c us to baad Muslims te Sikhs de vich nafart peda hoggai te ek dosry de dushman ban gye
I love speaking Punjabi with Sikh brothers. Infact their Punjabi is more shudh. Always give me my missing vocabulary. Thanks to them for keeping Pujabi culture alive and nourished, even though they are small in numbers. Love and peace! Wish I can visit Ferozpur, the galian bazar of my late grandpa (Rub bakhshay).
Very funny ek punjabi ko dusre punjabi se punjabi me baat karke acha lagta he. Why? Kunki apne mulk me Punjabi ko dehati maana jata he or school me to padhayi bhi nahi jaati..
100% correct. had there been independent Sikh state between India and Pakistan, there would have not been war of 65 or 71, as India Pakistan never had a common border.
It is a well researched, based on facts and well presented report. I have not watched this sort of comprehensive report before. We share language, living style and values with Sikhs. It would have been better for both communities if remained united. We Punjabis might have not suffered what we went through a traumatic situation during the partition of 1947.😢. Whatever happened we can't reverse but we all can work hard to live like good neighbours and good brothers. Pakistani Punjabis respect Sikh community a lot in spite of the incidents of 1947. That was unnecessary killing and harming of some irresponsible hate lovers. Punjab is a land of Babas (holy men from Muslim, Skih and Hind communities) who always spread peace, love, harmony, patience, human dignity, and excellent values of humanity we all share. Thanks
8:58 Menu lagda aey ke kisey ne aey pindi de fasadat jan buj ke karwaye san ta ke Sikh Hinduwan wal aa jan, kyune jad pehle fasadat nahi howey te bilkul ous waqt kyun howey jadun Musalmana nu Sikhan di pehle tun zyada lod si, ae panga vi Hinduwan ne ousey tara karwa howe ga, jidan ouna Hinduwan nu Pakistani army ke kapdey pawa ke te Bangali ourtan da rape kita, loki mare ta ke Bangalian ich nafrat peyda howey tey o Pakistan to elehda ho jan. Aey gal sochan aali aey.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 kaya gall yad kara dee Bangladesh wali laken hamari Army nay us bhotoo ko phansi dee the gis nay Bangladesh k bandy ko prime minister nahe bany deya or kud najez Bhoto prime minister ban gaya laken phir Adalat or Amry nay Bhoto ko phansi dee Sadi Muslims dee history ha wada kare ty wafa kardy han bhaly Nuksan ho jaye history dak loo sadi ty Hindu doka ty frad apss which he lardy nay haran han k pass which kayun lardy nay ty duran nu security ketun dan gay Hun Bangladesh ha satu alag ho gaya thek ha laken A k surwy kar loo sanu Bangladesh de tarake tay taqat wekh k kuah hondy han k chaloo Muslims tay han alag ho gaye laken kush rahen ma matrick pass keti ha un ty koi gall ghlat howy tay mafi mari koi bara banda naii han Bake Hun pajabi sadi zaban ak ha balke Sade kol ty Kaye kesem de Punjabi boli jande hage kuah rahu sardar jee
آپ کی بہت عذت کرتا ہوں۔۔۔میں سِکھ فیملی میں پیدا ہوا اور اب agnostic ہوں۔۔۔ سب درست فرمایا لیکن میرا خیال ہے کہ پاکستان میں بھی سِکھوں کے مسائل ایسے ہی بنے رہتے۔۔۔۔۔آپ کی ہر ویڈیو کا انتظار رہتا ہے۔۔۔
It was never 14%.there were more hindus in East pakistan/Bangladesh. % wise population of Pak sindhi hindus has increased compared to sindhi Muslims in da last population census
Great informational video, Indian media never tell this they are busy brainwashing sikhs. Waheguru di meher naal ek din Sikha da apna ghar khalistan hovega.
don't listen to this propaganda, we punjabi hindus are also native to punjab , how can you make khalistan, we both are brothers, my grandfathers' s brothers converted to sikhism. we are one same group.
2:24 منٹ پر آپ،اورپاکستان کا سب میڈیا پاکستانی یوٹیوبرز بڑی بے شرمی کے ساتھ آج کل کشمیر کو انڈیا کے نقشے میں دکھا رہے ہیں. سب دیکھنے والے پاکستانی اس طرف نشاندہی کروایا کریں
Mr Faisal kashmir belongs to Pakistan and InshAllah it will become part of Pakistan. Don't ruin kashmiris sacrifices by showing this a disputed treatory or part of India.
سکھوں کو کیا ملا یا کیا نہیں ملا تو نہیں معلوم مگر ایک بات سارے پاکستان کو معلوم ہونا چاہیئے کہ پاکستان زمین پر پاکستانیوں کے اجداد نے 1761 میں پانی پت کے میدان میں منوا لیا تھا۔ مگر جب احمد شاہ نے ایک بھنگی سکھ کو لاہور کا گورنر بنایا تو ہند کی مسلم قوم کی سب بڑی بد بختی یعنی سکھوں کا اندھا راج معرض وجود میں آیا۔ اور ہم نے 1857 میں انگریزوں کا ساتھ سکھ چوپٹ راج کو ختم کرنے کیلئے دیا۔ 1947 میں انگریز کی تحصیل میں پاکستان کی سرزمین پاکستانیوں کو قطعی انتقال کی گئی۔
Very informative video especially for the young generation of both Sikh as well as Pakistan. Well explained. Was glued to the video till end. Wish u all the best for future researches. Stay blessed.
Mere Khayal SE Sikhon ny Bharat ky Sath Rehnay ka Faisla Theek Kiya hai ...... Q KY Hamara Mazhabi Ikhtlaf Bohat Wazeh hai ....... Hm Kisi B Soorat Mai Allah Or Usky Rasool PBUH ky Sath Kisi Ko Shareek nahi KR Saktay ...... Or Phir Unki Trf Naach Ganay ko b Kisi Hadh tk Acha Samjha jata hai ..... Jabky Yahan aisa Kuch b Nahi Hai ......
humagill gill kaka tu mama lagandeya haan asi kio ghalt kaam nai kitta minorities astay hun apay wad gaye musalmaan te tohadi phudday che keeray q laran de ne. Te apnay Shia haan Alhamduliallah musalmaan haan khuda da wasta saday batwara na karao penyako
Well Kashmir situation is not complex just political un have given orders that 1 pakistan will remove thier army from Kashmir then india will remove their army from Kashmir then voting will happen nd Kashmiris will decide to join india pakistan or stay independent why is no one following it why is not pakistan removing it's army if they r so sure Kashmir wants to join pakistan then remove the army rather then gifting china kashmirs lands
I hope it is not misunderstood as against any community or in favour of any other so I will find better words to describe a saying that was very common in per-partition India that "Hindus always plan far ahead for a pending stormy issue, Muslims react when the storm is on the head and Sikhs think about it when the storm is over". I hope and pray that Khalistan comes into existence hopefully in peaceful way. Sikh community deserve this.
@@sirajtanoli8682 BRO AZADI MELA GE MUT BHOLO KERNAL SHER KHAN LALA JAN HIMERE KOM KA LOG THA AB WO HA JINO NA ISRIAL RUSSIAN AMERICA KO BEAT KAR DEYA HA HIM WO HA JINO NA HAMSHA MOR TOR JAWAB DEYA HA BHARAT KA HAMLKA SO SAWAL HE PADA NAHI HOTA KA KASMHIR BHARAT KA RAHE GA
@abhi manyu randian Balochistan main 70 percent hum pashtun Baloch to sirf 2 district main Hain hahaha pahla fact check kar hum pathan tumhari gand hamesha Marta thain aur Marta rahanga
Sikhon ko sara hindostan mila. Sikh sabhi States mein basse hue hain aur bahut shan aur izzat se rehte hain. Han yeh shi hai ke jo Pakistan mein reh gaye unhen aaj bhi beizzat kya jata hai.
@@samarpreetsingh1052 Sikh regiment fired bullets on jallianwala crowd Sikhs regiment suppressed 1857 revolt Your bravery list starts with udham Singh and ends with bhagat Singh 😂😂😂
Sikhism PurAman mazhab hai??? What a Hippocratic statement faisal .... azadi k time Hindus se ziyada sikhon ne qatal e aam kia tha Muslims ka... Plz facts ko samny rakhin
@@arslanarshadakber bro......hr chez k 2 side hoti he..........sikh muslim na kro...........1947 mrne wale 95% punjbi the..........mgr sara credit dusre le jate he
In short at that crucial time muslims were very very lucky to get a honest, intelligent and far sighted leader in Qaid E Azam. Unfortunately Sikhs with all their bravery lacked leadership that had for sight to think beyond their time or maybe their personal gains. This world is very unforgiving if you don't make right choices, as muslim supporters of United India are finding in Kashmir and India.
I think the best option for Sikhs was a separate state at the time of partition... They could protect their identity history and geography. In my vlg there were many Sikhs shelterd and protected during riots and handed over safely to military in 1947.
This option was not given by Britishers to sikhs because there population was less and scattered all over Punjab. Only option was Either join India Or Pakistan.
@@parambirchahal6355 check history British gave option to join either india pakistan or remain independent master tara singh choose india but not the people they wouldh have chosen anything but india nd pakistan didn't want voting to happen like it happened in junagadh but jinaah wanted like junagadh voting to happen in Kashmir but not punjab west punjab was given to pakistan east punjab was given to india by master tara singh
Sikho ko alag country leke vahi milta jo Pakistan ko alag country leke mila. Shyand usse bhi kam milta kuki vo chota or landlocked country hota. Sikho ko Pakistan ke saath reh ke vo milta jo Aaj Balochio ko mil raha he..
@@southasianking2856 WELL! I THINK YOUR A NICE PERSON,THAT'S WHY YOU SEE INDIA LIKE A FAIRYWORLD OR YOU DID'NT SEEN SOME SICK AREAS OF IT CUZ IT IS VERY BIG 7TH BIGGEST COUNTRY OF THE WORLD.
پاکستان میں مسیحوں کا کردار excellent ہے جو سونیرے حروف سے لکھا ہے۔ ان کا کردار پاکستان میں ایجوکیشن کے لحاظ سے بہت ہی قابل تحسین ہے۔ اس کے علاوہ سیسل چوہدری اور اُن جیسے بیشمار فوجی افسران جنہوں نے جان پر کھیل کر اس ملک کا دفاع کیا ہے اور انڈین جہازوں کو نزدیک نہ آنے دیا۔ہم پاکستانی قوم اُن لوگوں کی ان لازوال خدمات پر انُ کی عظمت کو سلام کرتے ہیں۔ اور آج بھی یہ لوگ اس ملک کے لیے سیسہ پلائی دیوار ہیں۔ یہ لوگ سیدنا حضرت عیسی علیہ سلام کی امت میں سے ہیں۔ اور یہ لوگ ہمارے بھائی ہیں۔ ہم سیدنا عیسی علیہ سلام پر اور مقدس انجیل پر ایمان رکھتے ہیں۔ اور اُن سے عقیدت و محبت رکھتے ہیں۔ اور اپنے عیسائی بھائیوں کی عظمت کو سلام پیش کرتے ہیں🌹🌹🌹💝💝💝🌹🌹🌹
Punjab ki dividion Christians ki waja se hee huwi thee. Voting process ma Punjab ma Christians ne majority Pakistan ko vote diya tha jis ki waja se Punjab ki division huwi warna refrendum voting ma Punjab India ma shamil ho jaata.
@@tehseenkhan3503 Blue Star operation ke piche Indira Ghandi- Khan ka hath tha. Mat buliay, uski shohar ka naam Feroze Khan tha. Ab vowhi niti Rahul Khan chala raha hay.
West Punjab Muslims or east Punjab Sikh bilkul same culture h... Ma Punjabi jutt Muslim hu Mager ma jaab inki Punjabi movies dakhta hu to asa laagta h humaray ghar ki baat h humare gaou ki baat h.... Laagta he nahi ya koi orr loog hain.... Jo hona tha wo to ho giya... I respect Sikh veerji...
I have a friend who is Sikh. One day he cried and said "we don't have our own dharti" that's why we are being divided and govt of India prefers to go to Canada rather living in India. He expressed so many bad things being happing to Sikhs in India.
@@wanderingmanz punjab is our land also, we punjabi hindus also died in 1947, there were 23 lakh hindus in pak punjab as compared to only 1.3 lakh sikhs .
Being a sindhi Hindu, i feel sorry for those delusional Sikhs who are commenting in this video. We very well know how the land of ancestors Sindh was taken away by jinnah. Sindh was the heart of Hinduism, hindustan india. But Jinnah took it away by fooling Gandhi. We were 21% yet we lost our land. Hadn't we parted from Bombay presidency, we could have been later on become like gujratis of gujrat. Jinnah took Sindh from Bombay presidency and Bombay took jinnah's daughter in return. Punjab ka toh pata nhi par jab tak Sindh wapis na aaye, tab tak hind adhura rahega. Jai jhulelal...
no baby no woh adhura hi rahay Sindh or hind mai humesha Faraq raha hai or rahay ga lindians jo kahay humay farak nhi padhta civilization hi alag hai jao Sindh ek Islam ka gaadh hai tum apnay ghar mai raho or Shukar hai hum alag hai khaap sy tumhari or zameen humari hai india independent act dekh koi kabza nhi kiya asay bol raha hai Pak mai hai or rahay ga
@@OsamaKhan-si8hv india se kashmeer janay walay saray rastay "Pakistan" k pass hotay. Ager sirf gordaspur "Pakistan" k pass hota to india kabhi bhi kashmeer mein dakhil nahi ho sakta tha.
Sikhs decided very smartly, otherwise they could have been treated even worst than Bengalis & balochs, practically they took 100 percent right decision, hats off to their smart leadership.
Never Forget 1984. Only Solution Khalistan. Sikh angreja lai lade (fauji) Sikh india di azadi lai lade ( krantikari) Sikh army ch lade (veer jawan) Sikh apne lai lade ( terrorist) Khalistan is the Right of Sikh community. Khalistan is the identity of Sikh Community. Khalistan Zindabad.
A.O.A sir I am big fan of you videos.... Please make video on Indo-pak Christians and its contribution to making Pakistan. I have research about Christian community at partition time but not satisfied about this information. I believe your information about the history is very nice and without any biasness.
Hassan baloch Ho sakta hai k un k pass nai (barber) na ho ...just joking 🙃 ... Wesy ye un k mazhab ka part hai is ley is ko follow krty hain.... But they r friendly & loving people’s .... 😊
@@vipsindhar5884 احمدی نام سے باقائدہ ایک مرزا ملعون کے پیروکاروں کا فرقہ ہے جن کے عقائد کچھ مختلف ہیں لیکن انہیں بھی کافر قرار دیا گیا ہے لہذا اس نام کا دفاع مت کریں
@@AliAhmed-eb8sw bro......gulam mirza us knjr ka name thaumaturge........ahmedi to bad me lga.....jb us knjr ne khud ko nabi kha........qadyani wajib ul qatal he
Kindly make a video on Kashmir issue , many people still don't know the real issue of Kashmir , Respect for Pakistan from indian illegally occupied Kashmir
Are wah agr sikh 2 percent sa 13 percent ho jata ho to aaj tk Hindu religion ko Pakistan m 40 precent ho jana chaia tha pr bo to km ho kr 1 percent pr aa gyi h
If sikhs decided to come with Pakistan then mass migration and subsequent riots wouldn't happen which caused millions of deaths and untold numbers of missing person. It would have also stabilised the region as no one country would have more economic or military power thus paving way to cooperations and peaceful co existence without wars and nuclear weapons.
That then also happen miggration because hindu was second population in Punjab. In bangal don’t have sikh but you see there also happen riot even they happen before punjab
भारत में सिख प्रधानमंत्री, राष्ट्रपति, थलसेना प्रमुख, वायुसेना प्रमुख, सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश, क्रिकेट और हॉकी टीम के कप्तान बने हैं। पंजाब राज्य का मुख्यमंत्री लगभग हर बार सिख ही होता है।सिखों ने हर क्षेत्र में अपना सिक्का जमाया है। लेकिन पोरकिस्तान में ऐसा मुमकिन नहीं है।
Pakistan was created based on Islamic faith but independent India was not created as per Hinduism….ok?…This is a secular country and everyone has equal rights
I was about 10 years when we heard that Indian forces attacked on Gold Temple and great leader killed brutally - it was the promise Nehru done with Sikhs in 1947? ,
First time heard too close and honest review about sikhs history of 20th century from Pakistan
We learnt a historical lesson for future to never trust any political promise from hindu leaders.
Khalistan is our future.
Khalistan and Pakistan will rise in future as a good neighbors. Khalistan will play a role as buffer zone between Pakistan and india.
Thanks for sharing information
Off course after Khalistan and Kashmir India have only few borders left with Pakistan always India take advantage of their more population majority and they attack from 7 or 8 borders if they can attack from 2 or 3 borders then India nows very well we Pakistanis will fuck India very badly like 1965 when we was in kumkaran which is inside India then Naru run toward UN and ask for help...
Donot forget 1984 khalistan zindabad
One day Indian Punjab and pakistni paunjab together again
Singh Sahib well said but it will start happening when Sikh Jawan will quit the Indian army and fight to liberate their own country Khalistan.
In shaa Allah. We will support your cause.
excellent review by Pakistani scholars nice to see it.
Thanks
Bol Sardara Pakistan banega Khalistan
@@BvG9683 akal kr kisse kehen naal assi nhi mnde jadj lodh peni assi app faisale krde saradara naal kis tarah gl krni sikh pehle
@@BvG9683 lol
Pakistani Punjab is muslim , check facts and history before commenting
@@zindagiahmed4600 tu kon sa Arab Shaikh ki pahchan he ? Tere baap dada bhi to convated Musalman he . Muje mat samja Lahore , Multan , Peshawar , gujranwla sab sikho ka tha lootliya tum lootero ne . Jaake path mohenjo daro jo Sindh me he .
بہت زبردست تحریر ہے ۔
ہندوؤں نے بڑی چالاکی سے سکھوں کو بہت سارے خیالی حقوق کے خواب دیکھائے لیکن آج نتائج کچھ اور ہیں جو کبھی پورا نہیں ہوسکتا ۔
Very well researched!!!
Thanks. Please share with others.
ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
11
Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰💗
You are getting trapped in Islam and Christianity . Foolishness has no limit.
Mene Muslim Sikh group join ker k jis mein 50k members Facebook par us mein is video Ka link share krdiya hai. Abb heart Chahiye.
Meny bhi link copy kia hua he bs dondh rha hun kaha dalon.
@@junaidhassan9768 hahaha
Group ka link mjy b dedo
@@junaidhassan9768 😁
mujhy bhi fb group ka link bhejo please
آپ کی کامیابی کا راز صداقت اور بیان کی جدت ہے الله آپ کو مزید بیان کا ملکہ عطاء فرمائے آمین۔
Jnb kindly make video
3سمندروں کا بادشاہ سلطنت عثمانیہ کا جرنیل خیرالدین باربروسہ
Wait for video bro
Brother attuman empire ki series may bun gaiye ha un per episode
seprate video banani chaey barbrosa pe
Bro Sikhs has problems with Muslim rulers but a common Muslim people is like brothers to us, that why more than 1lakh Muslim brothers live in malerkotla and more than 6lakh in total Punjab likes brothers because most of Muslim brothers respect our religion and we respect them, our tenth guru request Miya mir to lay foudation of golden temple by there hands and pir buddhu shah help guru gobind Singh g in battle also, so we never forget contribution of Islam and Muslims bro,s in our religion
Dharm ki afeem
veer what is condition of indian musmlim s have in india
@@maninderchandi4420if Indian Muslims have problems in India they can leave and vacate to move to Pakistan or Bangladesh.
Sikh,hindu ,jain are sanatani ❤️😊
Khalistani left the chat.
@@saifanrahman7052tu bhai, arabiyon ki ZEHNI GHULAMi kar
@@Priya19365 Alhamdulilah we are Blessed to be a Muslim...Islam is Not only Arab Religion
@@Priya19365 tu irani o ka kar
Sikh got killed in the partition, we lost our lands because of bad leadership and trusting the people who our gurus said are blind. Trusted india got a genocide because of that. Hindu and Sikh were not closer Sikh and Muslim have been close in the history of Punjab. it was pushed into the minds of many people by politicians. Sikh had lost real leaders in the fight for freedom for the subcontinent. Leaders like Bhagat Singh, Sardar Udham Singh, Sardar Kartar Singh Sarabha were lost in name of freedom.
Agree
But bro why still slkh don’t understand most of sikh still want to live with India
@guru Singh,
Be optimistic,
KHALISTAN ZINDA BAAD.
one mistake all sikh nation suffering from last 72 years as well as kashmiris also because if sikh can decide with pakistan or our seprate nation kashmir was also part of pakistan because kashmiri sikh raja is also geting bad decision to support india
Jot Singh . Wakt wakh k Faslai hoti hain. Allah kari ki sikhon ka appna watan Azad Khalistan ban Jai. Azadi k liay musalsal struggle kani parti hi. 💐🌹
Big mistake of Tara Singh
Not only Tara Singh, my brother. Also, the Maharaja of Patiala, Yadavinder Singh, is to blame. He was very powerful and could've changed the situation.
Love you ❤️😊🙏
Jo ho gya o ho gya..
Kasmri na raal jao..
R sath mil k laro....
Tuno apni jaan deni apy gie..
Fir hi kuj hosi veera
Tara Singh was hindu not sikh he was fake sikh
Fudua tenu asli sachai da kuj v ni pta
Being a Sikh I thanks to the documentary maker , very honest and correct facts shown in this video, we Sikhs believe that we did historic political mistake to reject offer of Jinna Saab to stay in Pak Punjab and bcos of this we are living slaves of Hindus in India , our human rights were/are demolished by Hindus , BJP, RSS and we feel we need our Sikh home land for our survival
No auctually we are better in india
Sikh community is hard working if they had their own territory they would have been in better position.
Like Bangali of Bangladesh 😂😂
Don't comment with fake IDs
@@omchaturvedi9404 shutup you bhagwa bridage of RSS
Bilkul sahi documentary ji
Veer g asi v punjab sanjha he chahndy sa wandya mulk nae gya bal k punjab wandiya gya...
Asi rab dy shukar guzar hn k sady pakistan ch her mazab dy logon nu azadi ae te ohnu mulak dy mamlat da bolan da pura haq ae
Tusi apna mulk bna lo khalistan zindabad
@@ayazashraf1238 😆😆 dharm ki afeem
JUTT KHA EANKER NE
A sikh scholar one said-" The Sikhs never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity"
Thanks to GOD, SIKHS missed that so called opportunity to join the hell called pakistan. Really
😂😂😂,no bro say it a historical mistake,may be......
😂😂😂
atta miss kar diya
افسوس اور معزرت میرے سکھ بھائیوں کے بڑوں نے یقیناً غلط فیصلہ کیا تھا۔ موجوہ پاکستان میں سیکھ بھائیوں کو بہت عزت ہے اور انڈیا میں آج سب واضح ہے۔ شکریہ محمد علی جناح آپ ہندؤں کے نفسیات سمجھ کر ھمیں الگ ملک بنا کے دیا۔ الحمدللہ
پاکستان زنداباد پائندہ باد 🇵🇰✌️🤲
Love u frm Kashmir
Allah tum logo pr apna reham kre
ALLAH kashmir ko jald az jald azad kre. Ameen
From Lahore💖💖
@@ibrahimkhawaja307 Allah Pakistan ko Hidayat de
@@ibrahimkhawaja307 insha'Allah ameen
bbi kesy ho ap sb?? Allah tala muslim ummat ko ittehad nxeb kry,, jis din saudia iran pak afghan sb aik ho jaye or lashmir azad ho jaye amen,,
Kya Maltb occupied Kashmir... Aazad Kashmir Se ho ya India Ke cortrol hone wale Kashmir se
jo jo b us vakt sikh leadrs te ya maharaja patiyala ye sbh gdaar hen.... inho ne e punjaab ko india ke hwale kr diya ... ye gdaar bnde the jo real sikhs the vo to apna alag raaj chahte the kyu k alrdy sikh punjab alag raaj tha... master tara singh gdaar maharaja patiyala gadaar inhe sikh mat kaho bhai....🙏
Mir Jaffar aur Mir Sadiq har qoom me hote h🙏🙏🙏
Bhai g the to sikh hi na achy the ya bury yr alag baat hy
Ab hm khe k meer jafer ko muslim na kaho
@@braveheart8318 kis ne kaha bro k muslimo k saath dushmni thi muslimo k saath to sbse acha rishta tha bro i think tusi hstry Nu chngi tra prhya ni
darbar sahib hermndr sahib d neeh SAI MIYA MEER G ne rkhi c
BABA NANAK G De naal 50 saal tak BHAI MARDANA G RAHE
PEER BUDHU SHAH JI ne GURU GOBINDSINGH JI da jung vich saath dita
or to or GURU GOBIND SINGH g k janam sbse pehle milne unhe SAI BUDHNN SHAH JI gye the ...
bro ldayi jung muslimo k saath nhi thi
GLT SYSTEM OR DHARMIK TOR PR JO HINDU JULM KR RAHE THE US PR THI OR US VKT KI GVT K SAATH THI JO GLT KR RAHI THI ....
rahi baat btware ki
btwara punjab k logo k dilo ka hua tha
dhrti ka to bs ek bahana tha ...
@@buttfoundry bro nuksaam to aam jnta ka hua tha ... vo chahe sikh ho hindu ho ya muslim hege ta punjabi hee sare ...
maharaja ranjit singh g de punjab vich jo sada bhaichara c aps ch osto sari dunia wakif c ..ese krk sanu todya gya
@@harmeetsingh8611 jaan bojh ke qatle aam krayaa gya c rawalpindi vich jithey a qatl e aam hoya c otho army hq 20 mint di drive te c pr army te police 7 din baad ayi c us to baad Muslims te Sikhs de vich nafart peda hoggai te ek dosry de dushman ban gye
I love speaking Punjabi with Sikh brothers. Infact their Punjabi is more shudh. Always give me my missing vocabulary. Thanks to them for keeping Pujabi culture alive and nourished, even though they are small in numbers. Love and peace! Wish I can visit Ferozpur, the galian bazar of my late grandpa (Rub bakhshay).
Sir, sabh to mithi Punjabi Amritsar Lahore di e. Majja aa janda Lahore aa k.
Very funny ek punjabi ko dusre punjabi se punjabi me baat karke acha lagta he. Why? Kunki apne mulk me Punjabi ko dehati maana jata he or school me to padhayi bhi nahi jaati..
@@SunilSharma-uz9yku r right from pakistan
Punjabi zainda bad
There they force urdu on Punjabis@@SunilSharma-uz9yk
Kartar Pur corridore is new opening for Sikh & Muslim (Brother hood lets Stand Together for peace.
O mulle sara pak sada si je bharaa kehnde o phir dayo sanu punjab nahi deyo ge e gandi chal e tuhadi
ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w9/v-deo.html
@@atulchawla100 ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
But Modi find a fake excuse of Corona to shut it. They do not want Sikhs and Muslims openly meet each other.
@@atulchawla100 shame on you we loves sikh community and you are behaving like that ☹️
I wish Sikh state was created then! It would have created a buffer zone between Pakistan and India to avoid many conflicts.
100% correct. had there been independent Sikh state between India and Pakistan, there would have not been war of 65 or 71, as India Pakistan never had a common border.
gujarat te rajsthan ch ta pak na border hi ni lagde na
@@mittiputtmajhail2960Bro India could also have attached Pakistan through the Rajasthan and the Gujarat border
@@denyoellamcy8251No India became oversized. If it was cut to its natural size it would not have been a threat for peace.
@@zia83 try harder lundnamazi abdool the more u try to destroy us the more we will rise
Salam Sat shri akaal Mere Pyare Veer Aap Nu ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍👍👍👍🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
Muslim kiled sikh and raped their daughters in March 1947.
Therefore sikh leader MASTER TARA SINGH rejected Jinnah demand to join Pakistan
Thanks for the very well researched information about Sikhs and Panjab
It is a well researched, based on facts and well presented report. I have not watched this sort of comprehensive report before. We share language, living style and values with Sikhs. It would have been better for both communities if remained united. We Punjabis might have not suffered what we went through a traumatic situation during the partition of 1947.😢.
Whatever happened we can't reverse but we all can work hard to live like good neighbours and good brothers. Pakistani Punjabis respect Sikh community a lot in spite of the incidents of 1947. That was unnecessary killing and harming of some irresponsible hate lovers. Punjab is a land of Babas (holy men from Muslim, Skih and Hind communities) who always spread peace, love, harmony, patience, human dignity, and excellent values of humanity we all share. Thanks
Sikhs have got the answer to this question very well in 1984
@@ajaykashyap4868 yeah they are thankful to God that they are not in India they are In Pakistan.
Hinduism the extremist religion
سکھو نے اپنے دور حکومت میں کشمیر اور ملتان میں لوگو پر ظلم کی انتہا کردیا تھا
@abhi manyu Cat dreams of teens.
@abhi manyu Tell me, bahadur, China, who has sent baraat, to marry your 7 sisters, when you are leaving them all.
@abhi manyu balochistan ki trf ankh utha k dekha tw tere bharat mata k 40 tukry kar den gy begherat qoum
بہت خوب صورت طریقے سے تاریخ سمجھائ گئی ہے ❤
ہم پنجابی سکھوں کے الگ ملک کی حمایت کرتے ہیں
Lkn sikh ni kr skty inn pr presure ha
@Abdul Rehman Mughal kingdom Ka band bajaney Mey Sikh sabsey aagey rahey hai.
Don't misguide about history.
ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
@@sajidali9093 ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
@Abdul Rehman ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
8:58 Menu lagda aey ke kisey ne aey pindi de fasadat jan buj ke karwaye san ta ke Sikh Hinduwan wal aa jan, kyune jad pehle fasadat nahi howey te bilkul ous waqt kyun howey jadun Musalmana nu Sikhan di pehle tun zyada lod si, ae panga vi Hinduwan ne ousey tara karwa howe ga, jidan ouna Hinduwan nu Pakistani army ke kapdey pawa ke te Bangali ourtan da rape kita, loki mare ta ke Bangalian ich nafrat peyda howey tey o Pakistan to elehda ho jan. Aey gal sochan aali aey.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 kaya gall yad kara dee Bangladesh wali laken hamari Army nay us bhotoo ko phansi dee the gis nay Bangladesh k bandy ko prime minister nahe bany deya or kud najez Bhoto prime minister ban gaya laken phir Adalat or Amry nay Bhoto ko phansi dee
Sadi Muslims dee history ha wada kare ty wafa kardy han bhaly Nuksan ho jaye history dak loo sadi ty Hindu doka ty frad apss which he lardy nay haran han k pass which kayun lardy nay ty duran nu security ketun dan gay
Hun Bangladesh ha satu alag ho gaya thek ha laken A k surwy kar loo sanu Bangladesh de tarake tay taqat wekh k kuah hondy han k chaloo Muslims tay han alag ho gaye laken kush rahen ma matrick pass keti ha un ty koi gall ghlat howy tay mafi mari koi bara banda naii han
Bake Hun pajabi sadi zaban ak ha balke Sade kol ty Kaye kesem de Punjabi boli jande hage kuah rahu sardar jee
Good
Paji tusi great o ❤️👌
Gal waqai sochan wali a....pindi dey fasadaat karwan walayaan baray tahqeeq di lorr a
Great analysis.... Paa ji... ❤️👍
If our leadership would made to come Pakistan that’s the good decision
Then u forget ur existence
Perhaps it would have been better if it hadn't split
Pakistani Makkaar Qoam h , Guru Govind singh ji ko bhi vishwas nahi tha in munafiq logo par
@@Devkayasa or munfak hindu nikla jo sikho sa kartarpur la gie gurru nanak la gaie or sikho ko bi akl gaie aba rota rho hiduo k hato
@@musaddiqhassan9683 its still split becuase second populaiton is hindu just like bangal there no Sikh still split
آپ کی بہت عذت کرتا ہوں۔۔۔میں سِکھ فیملی میں پیدا ہوا اور اب agnostic ہوں۔۔۔ سب درست فرمایا لیکن میرا خیال ہے کہ پاکستان میں بھی سِکھوں کے مسائل ایسے ہی بنے رہتے۔۔۔۔۔آپ کی ہر ویڈیو کا انتظار رہتا ہے۔۔۔
نہیں میری جان مسلمان بہت رحم دل قوم ہے کاش ہمارے پنجاب کے دو ٹکڑے نہ ہوئے ہوتے
nhi mery khayal mein 13% hona bht powerful hai, ap apni manwa sakty ho influence kar sakty ho
مسلمان اور سردار ایک دوسرے کے natural allies ہیں
کیونکہ مقابلے میں ہندو ایک تنگ نظر قوم ہے
You did not listen offer of Jinnah carefully I think.
Current situation of minorities in Pakistan is very worrying 😭😭😭
It is reduced from 14% to 2% .🙏🙏
It was never 14%.there were more hindus in East pakistan/Bangladesh. % wise population of Pak sindhi hindus has increased compared to sindhi Muslims in da last population census
@@kathika945 pak is not secular state whose pm will be a non Muslim pak
Sikh got nothing just blisters in their heart 🇺🇸🚜🇺🇸🚜
From pakistan and pakistan part of Punjab
@ yeah punjab contained in India & indian buffer state Pakistan.
Only freedom of Punjab is solution
Great informational video, Indian media never tell this they are busy brainwashing sikhs. Waheguru di meher naal ek din Sikha da apna ghar khalistan hovega.
don't listen to this propaganda, we punjabi hindus are also native to punjab , how can you make khalistan, we both are brothers, my grandfathers' s brothers converted to sikhism. we are one same group.
Khalistan is only solution for sikhs..
@@tanejasaab3358 true veere
Let us try it. Sadat most sweet loving people. " Long Live Punjab."
Pakistan bna to aaj tk bheekh maanng rha hai
یہ جبر بھی دیکھا ہے تاریخ کی نظروں نے :-: لمحوں نے خطا کی ہے ۔ صدیوں نے سزا پائی ہے۔
ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
Shock for me,,,, very good i am Impress 👍
Zbrdast
love 5ab
like 5abi
100ganda
ty
100chhiter
best effort on this subject i watched
2:24 منٹ پر آپ،اورپاکستان کا سب میڈیا پاکستانی یوٹیوبرز بڑی بے شرمی کے ساتھ آج کل کشمیر کو انڈیا کے نقشے میں دکھا رہے ہیں.
سب دیکھنے والے پاکستانی اس طرف نشاندہی کروایا کریں
Bilkul sahi
یہ کونسا نقشہ ہے کبھی نہی دیکھا بس اتنا سنا تھا کے تپسی تے ٹھس کرسی اگر سب کچھ پاکستان نے ہی کرنا ہے تو تم بھی کچھ ہاتھ پیر ہلاؤ
Yes delete and then edit scene
Mr Faisal kashmir belongs to Pakistan and InshAllah it will become part of Pakistan.
Don't ruin kashmiris sacrifices by showing this a disputed treatory or part of India.
Yes agree
We support Sikh community and khalistaan from our Heart.
Love from Multan, Pakistan
🤣😂🤣🤣
We support baloch community and balochistan from our heart.
Love from Mumbai, India 🇮🇳
@@aniketthakur8295 tüm HOTA kon ho bolna wala 🤣 Balochistan Ka bare ma wo to Muslim majority ha Tum Tum Tum Muslim Ka bare ma kab SE Socha lga
@@immovlogs08 Aur tum hote kon ho sikh aur kalishtan k bare me bolne wale, wo toh sikh majority hai, agar tum bolega toh ham 100 gunna bolenge....
@@aniketthakur8295 karta Raho phir bakchodia 😂 100 bar bolo humai Kya
میں مسلمان ہوں اور سکھوں کی ایک علیحدہ ریاست کی حمایت کرتا ہوں
نفرت ملی
جو ظلم مسلمانوں پر کیا وہ بھولتا نہیں 1947 نقلل آبادی کے موقعہ پر
Nice Post Love from Punjab India 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇳
pakistan zeendabad
I'm Pakistani Punjabi
سکھوں کو کیا ملا یا کیا نہیں ملا تو نہیں معلوم مگر ایک بات سارے پاکستان کو معلوم ہونا چاہیئے کہ پاکستان زمین پر پاکستانیوں کے اجداد نے 1761 میں پانی پت کے میدان میں منوا لیا تھا۔ مگر جب احمد شاہ نے ایک بھنگی سکھ کو لاہور کا گورنر بنایا تو ہند کی مسلم قوم کی سب بڑی بد بختی یعنی سکھوں کا اندھا راج معرض وجود میں آیا۔ اور ہم نے 1857 میں انگریزوں کا ساتھ سکھ چوپٹ راج کو ختم کرنے کیلئے دیا۔
1947 میں انگریز کی تحصیل میں پاکستان کی سرزمین پاکستانیوں کو قطعی انتقال کی گئی۔
Very informative video especially for the young generation of both Sikh as well as Pakistan. Well explained. Was glued to the video till end. Wish u all the best for future researches. Stay blessed.
Mere Khayal SE Sikhon ny Bharat ky Sath Rehnay ka Faisla Theek Kiya hai ...... Q KY Hamara Mazhabi Ikhtlaf Bohat Wazeh hai ....... Hm Kisi B Soorat Mai Allah Or Usky Rasool PBUH ky Sath Kisi Ko Shareek nahi KR Saktay ...... Or Phir Unki Trf Naach Ganay ko b Kisi Hadh tk Acha Samjha jata hai ..... Jabky Yahan aisa Kuch b Nahi Hai ......
nice words delivery sir thanks for the information regarding sikh community
this is the real journalism - well done FW.
سکھ قیادت کا فیصلہ حیران کن تھا ان کے تقریباً تمام مقدس مقامات ادھر ہے حیران ہوں انھوں کیسے یہ فیصلہ کیا
We love and respect sikhs... from pakistani punjab
You killed Sikhs in 1947 in pakistans Punjab.
@@sandipanbhattacharya8269 sikh hmary bhai the, hi aur rahn ge...
@@sandipanbhattacharya8269 u guys killed muslim in 1947
@@amnaanwar5296 you also killed Hindus and Sikhs in 1947.
@@tehseenkhan3503 Sikhs and Muslims are totally different religion.
Maharaja Ranjit Singh and all Sikh warriors freed Punjab of Maharaja from Mughals and Afghanis.
Ranjit Singh Hero ❤
What a great presentation. Hats off to you !
انسان اپنی حیر سے کہاں واقف ہوتا ہے پاکستان ان کے لیے اچھا تھا
kaya muslman Shia..Christian...hindu..sikh..yahan mhfooz hain 24feesad Aqleat 5 feesad kassay ho gai muslman to khud yahan khush.nahi
humagill gill kaka tu mama lagandeya haan asi kio ghalt kaam nai kitta minorities astay hun apay wad gaye musalmaan te tohadi phudday che keeray q laran de ne. Te apnay Shia haan Alhamduliallah musalmaan haan khuda da wasta saday batwara na karao penyako
@@abdulmunaaf677 yeah aap ka assl chara hay jawab nahi too gallian sharoo...Thanks uncle God bless you
@@humagillgill2364 east or west Pak ko Mila Kar 23% minorities thi Google karlo Hindu population in Pakistan 1950 to 2020 jaake search Karo
Nhi inn ko khalistan milna chaye .khalistan best then pak fro a sikh
Individual mistakes cost definitely but Leader's mistake is paid by the whole Nation.
I think we might not have complex situation of Kashmir as of right now if Sikh leaders decided to join Pakistan and they had a better chance.
why??
Well Kashmir situation is not complex just political un have given orders that 1 pakistan will remove thier army from Kashmir then india will remove their army from Kashmir then voting will happen nd Kashmiris will decide to join india pakistan or stay independent why is no one following it why is not pakistan removing it's army if they r so sure Kashmir wants to join pakistan then remove the army rather then gifting china kashmirs lands
An excelent research work with historical facts. Bravo bravo. Jinnah was a great visionary
I hope it is not misunderstood as against any community or in favour of any other so I will find better words to describe a saying that was very common in per-partition India that "Hindus always plan far ahead for a pending stormy issue, Muslims react when the storm is on the head and Sikhs think about it when the storm is over".
I hope and pray that Khalistan comes into existence hopefully in peaceful way. Sikh community deserve this.
Im sikh and i love my india ..s
ua-cam.com/video/23wTnVGZGlI/v-deo.htmlsi=mNNgxJ8hcyyzFDWL 🤣🤣🤣
sikhon ko un ka haq milyega our pakistan ko kashmir inshallah kashmir banega pakistan our ban ke rahe ga khalistan Gill is Best
Jahil hi rhogy
@abhi manyu 😂😂😂
@@sirajtanoli8682 BRO AZADI MELA GE MUT BHOLO KERNAL SHER KHAN LALA JAN HIMERE KOM KA LOG THA AB WO HA JINO NA ISRIAL RUSSIAN AMERICA KO BEAT KAR DEYA HA HIM WO HA JINO NA HAMSHA MOR TOR JAWAB DEYA HA BHARAT KA HAMLKA SO SAWAL HE PADA NAHI HOTA KA KASMHIR BHARAT KA RAHE GA
Bhai panjab me bhi 45%se Jada Hindu hi h aisa na ho ki pura Sikh abadi hi Nast ho Jay
@abhi manyu randian Balochistan main 70 percent hum pashtun Baloch to sirf 2 district main Hain hahaha pahla fact check kar hum pathan tumhari gand hamesha Marta thain aur Marta rahanga
بہت اچھی نالج والی ویڈیو ہے جی جزاک اللہ آپ کے دونوں چینل پاکستان کا فخر ہے میرے پاس الفاظ نہیں سر بہت شکریہ 🇵🇰❤
Thanks a lot sir.
@@BigSocho ❤🇵🇰
Sikhon ko sara hindostan mila. Sikh sabhi States mein basse hue hain aur bahut shan aur izzat se rehte hain. Han yeh shi hai ke jo Pakistan mein reh gaye unhen aaj bhi beizzat kya jata hai.
@Asad jiskani Je tuhade naal rehnde eho jihi badtamizi sikhde jo beta toon apne jawab vich likhi hai. Baaki jo tusin Pakistan ch reh gaye sikhan naal karde rahe ho oh jag jahar hai.
Golden temple mea b india ne bhtttt izat ki thi Indian army ne
Nice
1 sikh was shot dead in KHYBER PAKHTUN KPK
@@Priya19365ap Hindu Roz muslmano ki killing krte ho India main
True Sikhs lost their identity by supporting Hindus... And also lost their rich history of bravery.
bravery??
jallianwala bagh
@@johnjacobastoriv688 General dyer was killed by a Sikh despite not everyone who died in 1919 jallianwala bagh was a Sikh.
@@samarpreetsingh1052 Sikh regiment fired bullets on jallianwala crowd
Sikhs regiment suppressed 1857 revolt
Your bravery list starts with udham Singh and ends with bhagat Singh 😂😂😂
@@johnjacobastoriv688it was gorkha regiment who fired at jallianwala, so
relax mate.
Sikh history is preserved only in India.
فیصل بھائی لداخ کے معاملے پر وڈیو بناؤ پلیز
Chinese troops movement in LAC
ua-cam.com/video/s3_kH8Djgp8/v-deo.html
Yesssss
Sikhism PurAman mazhab hai??? What a Hippocratic statement faisal .... azadi k time Hindus se ziyada sikhon ne qatal e aam kia tha Muslims ka... Plz facts ko samny rakhin
@@arslanarshadakber janab faisal bhai ne ye bhi to bataya he ke rawalpindi division me pehle sikhon per hamle hue the
@@arslanarshadakber bro......hr chez k 2 side hoti he..........sikh muslim na kro...........1947 mrne wale 95% punjbi the..........mgr sara credit dusre le jate he
Excellent documentary bhai jan💗
In short at that crucial time muslims were very very lucky to get a honest, intelligent and far sighted leader in Qaid E Azam. Unfortunately Sikhs with all their bravery lacked leadership that had for sight to think beyond their time or maybe their personal gains. This world is very unforgiving if you don't make right choices, as muslim supporters of United India are finding in Kashmir and India.
I think the best option for Sikhs was a separate state at the time of partition... They could protect their identity history and geography. In my vlg there were many Sikhs shelterd and protected during riots and handed over safely to military in 1947.
This option was not given by Britishers to sikhs because there population was less and scattered all over Punjab. Only option was Either join India Or Pakistan.
@@parambirchahal6355 check history British gave option to join either india pakistan or remain independent master tara singh choose india but not the people they wouldh have chosen anything but india nd pakistan didn't want voting to happen like it happened in junagadh but jinaah wanted like junagadh voting to happen in Kashmir but not punjab west punjab was given to pakistan east punjab was given to india by master tara singh
Sikho ko alag country leke vahi milta jo Pakistan ko alag country leke mila. Shyand usse bhi kam milta kuki vo chota or landlocked country hota.
Sikho ko Pakistan ke saath reh ke vo milta jo Aaj Balochio ko mil raha he..
Great work brother
اچھا ہوا جو سکھ لوگ ہمارے پاکستان میں شامل نہیں ہوں Am very happy
@Mha PAK wo kese????
Khalistan mtlb punjabio ki alg state ......
Mera bhai jb punjab ek hota to ap jante ho kia hotair???
@Mha PAK punjabi 82% se ziada musalman he......agr hm ek hote to punjab aj 99% musalman hotair....
@Mha PAK first bro........ye sari dushmani 1947 k bad ail.......aurengzab ko gali ye sb bad me aya..........
All nation should live peacefully with each other.Hindus Sikhs and Muslims.
It is only possible in India.....it is happening here......!
@@southasianking2856 😆😆😆
@@southasianking2856 😂😂😂😂😂
@@zaramalik1422 haslo dear
@@southasianking2856 WELL! I THINK YOUR A NICE PERSON,THAT'S WHY YOU SEE INDIA LIKE A FAIRYWORLD OR YOU DID'NT SEEN SOME SICK AREAS OF IT CUZ IT IS VERY BIG 7TH BIGGEST COUNTRY OF THE WORLD.
Sir,
Very informative reporting to know.
♥️🇵🇰
سر مہربانی سے مسیحیوں کا پاکستان میں کردار پر ویڈیو بنا دے
Christians are part and parcel of Pakistan and have always played vital role in the development of Pakistan especially in the field of education.
پاکستان میں مسیحوں کا کردار excellent ہے جو سونیرے حروف سے لکھا ہے۔ ان کا کردار پاکستان میں ایجوکیشن کے لحاظ سے بہت ہی قابل تحسین ہے۔ اس کے علاوہ سیسل چوہدری اور اُن جیسے بیشمار فوجی افسران جنہوں نے جان پر کھیل کر اس ملک کا دفاع کیا ہے اور انڈین جہازوں کو نزدیک نہ آنے دیا۔ہم پاکستانی قوم اُن لوگوں کی ان لازوال خدمات پر انُ کی عظمت کو سلام کرتے ہیں۔ اور آج بھی یہ لوگ اس ملک کے لیے سیسہ پلائی دیوار ہیں۔ یہ لوگ سیدنا حضرت عیسی علیہ سلام کی امت میں سے ہیں۔ اور یہ لوگ ہمارے بھائی ہیں۔ ہم سیدنا عیسی علیہ سلام پر اور مقدس انجیل پر ایمان رکھتے ہیں۔ اور اُن سے عقیدت و محبت رکھتے ہیں۔ اور اپنے عیسائی بھائیوں کی عظمت کو سلام پیش کرتے ہیں🌹🌹🌹💝💝💝🌹🌹🌹
Christians na Pakistan bnanay ki himait ki thi aur Quaid e Azam Ka sath bhi Dia tha aur jo sikhu na sath nhi dia tha
Punjab ki dividion Christians ki waja se hee huwi thee. Voting process ma Punjab ma Christians ne majority Pakistan ko vote diya tha jis ki waja se Punjab ki division huwi warna refrendum voting ma Punjab India ma shamil ho jaata.
اگر مسیحی کردار نہیں بھی ہو تو بھی ہم ان کی عزت کرتے ہیں وہ ہمارے ہم وطن ہیں
best wishes for sikh community. They are our Punjabi Brothers.
So why were these Sikh brothers murdered after partition?
Ravi Sharma bcz brahman hundu put oil on fire of dividing brotthers
@@ravisharma167 1984 mn ap ne kya keya sikhu k sath...
@@tehseenkhan3503 Blue Star operation ke piche Indira Ghandi- Khan ka hath tha. Mat buliay, uski shohar ka naam Feroze Khan tha. Ab vowhi niti Rahul Khan chala raha hay.
@@ravisharma167 mean k ap rahul ko hindu he nhe manty?? Aur na indra hindu thi?? Ksi bat krty ho ap?? Gandi khandan hi ye to......
West Punjab Muslims or east Punjab Sikh bilkul same culture h...
Ma Punjabi jutt Muslim hu Mager ma jaab inki Punjabi movies dakhta hu to asa laagta h humaray ghar ki baat h humare gaou ki baat h....
Laagta he nahi ya koi orr loog hain....
Jo hona tha wo to ho giya...
I respect Sikh veerji...
wonderful analysis of past, present and future of Sikhs .
I have a friend who is Sikh. One day he cried and said "we don't have our own dharti" that's why we are being divided and govt of India prefers to go to Canada rather living in India. He expressed so many bad things being happing to Sikhs in India.
may be he does not know the name Manmohan singh the ex prime minister of india and late Arjan Singh commander of the entire indian airforce
@@sijut1515 dear I expressed his views. If you wanna be in debate, let's do it.
@@wanderingmanz punjab is our land also, we punjabi hindus also died in 1947, there were 23 lakh hindus in pak punjab as compared to only 1.3 lakh sikhs .
TELL HIM KHALISTAN ONLY SOLUTION!!🇵🇰❤🇹🇷🇵🇰🇹🇷🇵🇰🇹🇷🇵🇰🇹🇷🇵🇰
Ya , khalistan banao and lahore should be capital like old khalsa raj under gr8 Ranjeet singhji
Being a sindhi Hindu, i feel sorry for those delusional Sikhs who are commenting in this video. We very well know how the land of ancestors Sindh was taken away by jinnah. Sindh was the heart of Hinduism, hindustan india. But Jinnah took it away by fooling Gandhi. We were 21% yet we lost our land. Hadn't we parted from Bombay presidency, we could have been later on become like gujratis of gujrat. Jinnah took Sindh from Bombay presidency and Bombay took jinnah's daughter in return. Punjab ka toh pata nhi par jab tak Sindh wapis na aaye, tab tak hind adhura rahega. Jai jhulelal...
no baby no woh adhura hi rahay Sindh or hind mai humesha Faraq raha hai or rahay ga lindians jo kahay humay farak nhi padhta civilization hi alag hai jao Sindh ek Islam ka gaadh hai tum apnay ghar mai raho or Shukar hai hum alag hai khaap sy tumhari or zameen humari hai india independent act dekh koi kabza nhi kiya asay bol raha hai Pak mai hai or rahay ga
Don't worry Hinduism is growing fast in sindh,@@affaqmalik5876
😂tu sindh bhaag Jaa ..😂kaahe indian mein baitha hai
@@mastmalakpet we will take back sindh from radical Islam
Master Tara singh betrayed us!!
Absolutely sikhs were offered THIER own homeland but master tara singh betrayed sikhs who had their own empire at least they deserved a country
No he didn't
اگر سکھ پاکستان کے ساتھ ہوتے تو مسئلہ کشمیر بھی نہ ہوتا۔
How??
Please reply
@@OsamaKhan-si8hv india se kashmeer janay walay saray rastay "Pakistan" k pass hotay. Ager sirf gordaspur "Pakistan" k pass hota to india kabhi bhi kashmeer mein dakhil nahi ho sakta tha.
Sikhs decided very smartly, otherwise they could have been treated even worst than Bengalis & balochs, practically they took 100 percent right decision, hats off to their smart leadership.
Never Forget 1984.
Only Solution Khalistan.
Sikh angreja lai lade (fauji)
Sikh india di azadi lai lade ( krantikari)
Sikh army ch lade (veer jawan)
Sikh apne lai lade ( terrorist)
Khalistan is the Right of Sikh community.
Khalistan is the identity of Sikh Community.
Khalistan Zindabad.
Such a lovely brother are muslims of Sikh that remaining sikh fled to India and other countries 😂😢
😂😂
Bhai bohat piyari video banayi he ap ne good👌👌👍👍👍
Good work keep it up.
I always wait for ur latest videos.
They r brimful of knowledge & wisdom....
Thanks
A.O.A sir I am big fan of you videos.... Please make video on Indo-pak Christians and its contribution to making Pakistan. I have research about Christian community at partition time but not satisfied about this information. I believe your information about the history is very nice and without any biasness.
Bosnia civil war p ek documentary video
Like vedio without listing whole vedio
Faisal warraich is a brand❤️😍
Faisal Bhai nice voice over as always . Keep going same way . A lot of respect
ਵਧੀਆ ਜਾਨਕਾਰੀ
Sikh and Pakistan Are brothers 🇵🇰🇵🇰😘😘💕💕
Woh salay to baal bhi ni kaatay
@@hassan_Shx hahaha
Hassan baloch
Ho sakta hai k un k pass nai (barber) na ho ...just joking 🙃 ...
Wesy ye un k mazhab ka part hai is ley is ko follow krty hain.... But they r friendly & loving people’s .... 😊
18:34 sir قادیانیوں کو احمدی نہ لکھا جائے
احمدی ھم ہیں وہ تو قادیانی ہین کافر ہین
Ahmadi aur qadyani mai farq kia hai ye hi shasey ke dhale howe hai..
@@mustafahussain2476 wo kadiyani kaafir hn
@@vipsindhar5884
احمدی نام سے باقائدہ ایک مرزا ملعون کے پیروکاروں کا فرقہ ہے جن کے عقائد کچھ مختلف ہیں لیکن انہیں بھی کافر قرار دیا گیا ہے لہذا اس نام کا دفاع مت کریں
@@AliAhmed-eb8sw bro......gulam mirza us knjr ka name thaumaturge........ahmedi to bad me lga.....jb us knjr ne khud ko nabi kha........qadyani wajib ul qatal he
Majority of the facts told by u are completely true . Good analysis
Thanks
اللہ کا لاکھ شکر سکھ پاکستان کا حصہ نہیں۔ نہیں تو پنجاب میں شورش ہی رہتی۔
غلط بات
There is no country like India on the face of this earth and I am proud of being an Indian muslim.
india is not great country its a distarous stste
It's a dirty, stingy state.
o ja o bhai
Kindly make a video on Kashmir issue , many people still don't know the real issue of Kashmir , Respect for Pakistan from indian illegally occupied Kashmir
The presentation consists on very positive approach and appreciatabl.
Thank you for honest analysis.
Are wah agr sikh 2 percent sa 13 percent ho jata ho to aaj tk Hindu religion ko Pakistan m 40 precent ho jana chaia tha pr bo to km ho kr 1 percent pr aa gyi h
Badk😂😂 lindu JB partition hoi thi west Pakistan ki population 97 Muslim thi
If sikhs decided to come with Pakistan then mass migration and subsequent riots wouldn't happen which caused millions of deaths and untold numbers of missing person. It would have also stabilised the region as no one country would have more economic or military power thus paving way to cooperations and peaceful co existence without wars and nuclear weapons.
Sikhs would have been a second class citizen in Pakistan which is not secular
Yes, I agree with you.
That then also happen miggration because hindu was second population in Punjab.
In bangal don’t have sikh but you see there also happen riot even they happen before punjab
भारत में सिख प्रधानमंत्री, राष्ट्रपति, थलसेना प्रमुख, वायुसेना प्रमुख, सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुख्य न्यायाधीश, क्रिकेट और हॉकी टीम के कप्तान बने हैं। पंजाब राज्य का मुख्यमंत्री लगभग हर बार सिख ही होता है।सिखों ने हर क्षेत्र में अपना सिक्का जमाया है। लेकिन पोरकिस्तान में ऐसा मुमकिन नहीं है।
but not fredam kahlistan 😃
@@muhammadkamran2143 बलोचिस्तान और सिन्धुदेश आज़ाद होकर रहेंगे।
Pakistan was created based on Islamic faith but independent India was not created as per Hinduism….ok?…This is a secular country and everyone has equal rights
Wesay aik baat ha is video k comments section ma Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs, Christian, Qadiyani saray e Comments kr rahay Hain.
I was about 10 years when we heard that Indian forces attacked on Gold Temple and great leader killed brutally - it was the promise Nehru done with Sikhs in 1947? ,
i also thought the same that why sikhs did 1983 massacre
You make videos on critical questions. Keep it up
Excellent information
A very big thumbs up 👍 for this
Awesome reporting. JazakAllah
Warich is also Sikh, we 😍 u love from Punjab
Bro warich sirname Hai punjab ch jatta da But ohh sikh ne Muslim ah😄
Sikhan naalon bohaty warriach jatt Musalmaan nay....
Saday Rishta daar nay....Gujrat shahar warraich majority a....warriach poray Punjab wich phialay nay...
Sb Jatt castes...Sikh tey Musalman...dowaan wich nay...
ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
@@ragexteamgaming6249 ua-cam.com/video/bOjPJenzn1w/v-deo.html
@@TajamalGhumman aho I'm also Warraich. Love u bro❤️🖤
Balochistan ilegal occupied by pakistan
British never rulled nepal and balochistan in indian continment
So plz free balochistna
Kashmir ... Sikkim...Kerala...all Disputed
Sikhs got lara lappa. They were lured by bahman wad and banya.Though they were commanded naal kararaan dosti koura kouree hai.
Sikhs muslims ke saath rahte toh unki Babu Beti ko Muslims utha ke le jaate.