12/09/01: Why Did She Do It?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 290

  • @agapeeternal
    @agapeeternal 2 роки тому +91

    Rusty literally tried to keep her out of hospital. He talked hrr into having another baby knowing she would become sick. He’s so selfish.

  • @jaylenfourier9292
    @jaylenfourier9292 2 роки тому +260

    We covered this case in my college class. When the psychologist/doctor warned them that another baby would "guarantee" her falling into a severe depression, their response was "we will have as many babies as possible." This was truly a preventable tragedy. Shame on the husband for bearing little to no responsibility for what happened. He was the level-headed one but wanted to be a "traditional" family. It really infuriates me. The logic he is using of "do we regret having our previous children" is flawed. Just because you don't regret your previous children does not mean you should have more and does not mean you are "wronging" your future, unconceived children. The husband really infuriates me.

    • @kimthomas8717
      @kimthomas8717 2 роки тому +16

      I agree ! He infuriates me too
      He knew she was a danger to herself n the kids !! Then to ignorantly have Mary against medical advice is just inconceivable

    • @mejhon6592
      @mejhon6592 Рік тому +2

      Depression about what!i think someting happen to her in thr paat to do something terrible to her kids.

    • @andresmattos7541
      @andresmattos7541 Рік тому +7

      So now it a the husband's fault? What's next blame the taxi driver or kanye west?

    • @ananonymousanemone4125
      @ananonymousanemone4125 Рік тому +21

      @@andresmattos7541Yes it was. He one hundred percent killed the kids. If he took her depression and psychosis serious enough, then he would’ve known.

    • @sandramolina1177
      @sandramolina1177 11 місяців тому

      A mi tbm yo creo q el esta feliz

  • @pookieb1612
    @pookieb1612 4 роки тому +267

    My acting all supportive now. He knew what she went thru and did nothing but encourage more kids

    • @heatherkline749
      @heatherkline749 4 роки тому +13

      Exactly!

    • @TheRmjr
      @TheRmjr 3 роки тому +16

      Which is so sad...and kept wanting to have kids instead of helping her. Children are wonderful with healthy parents.

    • @godsfavour5012
      @godsfavour5012 2 роки тому +3

      @@TheRmjr true talk

    • @ASIIIULKA91
      @ASIIIULKA91 Рік тому +3

      Maybe that’s why he doesn’t hold it against her because he feels partly responsible for their death.

    • @updownstate
      @updownstate Рік тому

      They belonged to a religion that believes God sends you as many children as he wants you to have. It's also a religion that doesn't recognize divorce. So ha ha, divorce, remarriage, out with the old kids and In with the new.

  • @user-rx2uz4kq9x
    @user-rx2uz4kq9x 3 роки тому +137

    Andrea Yates LEGITIMIZED POSTPARTUM DEPRESSION/PSYCHOSIS. She gave it a face,a voice and proved to us that PPP is real and EVERYONE needs to be educated about it and signs/symptoms taught to look for because this is an ongoing mental illness in the world.

    • @kristiedesmond8639
      @kristiedesmond8639 Рік тому +4

      Tragically it didn’t spread enough awareness because it has happened again. However I feel, and hope, that Lindsays situation will finally give the push to make change.

    • @kingayy9267
      @kingayy9267 Рік тому +5

      Women's issues are almost always overlooked.
      They're assumed to be exaggerating or "drug seeking" when they tell doctors they're in pain, et cetera.

  • @martynotth7640
    @martynotth7640 5 років тому +76

    She was depressed and abused by her husband! He would not let her take her medications so she could get pregnant again.

  • @christinayates2496
    @christinayates2496 4 роки тому +236

    Even in these interviews he shows ZERO signs of being hurt.... he doesn’t realize the crazier he makes her look the more of a monster he looks like for even leaving his kids alone with her having all this knowledge on her mental state.... that’s negligence no ifs ands or buts!! He probably set it up so that he didn’t have to take care of 5 kids and she would take the fall..... you’d be surprised at how people abuse mentally ill, homeless and elderly people. I’ve never seen him shed a single tear.

    • @butterflymustfly_1232
      @butterflymustfly_1232 2 роки тому +15

      Yes he doesn't look unhappy at all.

    • @atiana27
      @atiana27 2 роки тому +17

      Yes that’s what I always thought too mentally abuse her impregnated her again in her fragile state of mind taking care of six children very sneaky on his part poor Andrea and her children!

    • @Pierced93
      @Pierced93 2 роки тому

      how about how the doctors told him she can come home but SHE ABSOLUTELY CANT BE LEFT ALONE and then he thought it would be a good idea, against doctors orders.. to give her a hour a day alone with them to make her independent to wean her off of always having someone there. like wtf. he knew she had a long history of mental issues

    • @Faisey648
      @Faisey648 2 роки тому +5

      Same thought just a little bit weird.

    • @corbini.n.c6807
      @corbini.n.c6807 2 роки тому +1

      Exactly there’s no way I would trust somebody with my children who had recently attempted to commit suicide that automatically is a sign something isn’t right and perhaps she shouldn’t be raising her children if she’s in that type of mental state

  • @acs6785
    @acs6785 3 роки тому +49

    He was warned this could happen and he forced her to have more children.. she begged for help over and over.

  • @mmendoza2128
    @mmendoza2128 4 роки тому +99

    He shouldn’t blame her, and he doesn’t because he knows he’s responsible too. Should’ve listened to the doctors!

    • @leeanneginton50969
      @leeanneginton50969 5 місяців тому +1

      Please it's her it's called evil ok. There is nothing I wouldn't do for my 3 kids I couldn't imagine walking in to see what he did that day .how he is able to go on after that it heart breaking..

    • @notsureiL
      @notsureiL 4 місяці тому

      ​​@@leeanneginton50969Rusty is evil. Doctors told them not to have more kids. They didn't even want to let Andrea home. He didn't care about Andrea or the kids. He only cared about having more kids.

  • @christinayates2496
    @christinayates2496 4 роки тому +140

    I’m sorry but the husband is just as much fault if not more than her and should face charges too.. he acknowledges that she was mentally unstable, there’s evidence going years back of her mental illness, he was told by doctors to stop getting her pregnant its causing postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis... she TOLD her husband, actually she BEGGED her husband NOT to leave her alone with the kids, he was told by the doctor to not leave her alone with the kids.. and what does he do? He leaves her alone with the kids 🤦‍♀️ How is that NOT negligence? Idc if she’s their mother or not, anyone with half a brain a BIT of *common sense* KNOWS to NOT leave their children in the care of someone who’s unhinged. 🤦‍♀️

    • @ANDELLARIA
      @ANDELLARIA 4 роки тому +4

      He only cares about sex I can tell and having a cult about kids so later he can tell his kids to follow his foot steps

    • @ayatientut8662
      @ayatientut8662 4 роки тому +2

      He not leaving andrea alone with kids as i know from another source. He leave andrea with his mother but andrea make sure to his mother and rusty that she’s okey . Them believed it

    • @anonamos9102
      @anonamos9102 4 роки тому +6

      How do you know she begged him? And if she did then she knew it was wrong to do yet she did it. Sorry. He isn't guilty of his kids deaths

    • @AllAboutPurple
      @AllAboutPurple 3 роки тому +9

      @@ayatientut8662 actually he left her alone with the kids for an hour and his mom was supposed come take over after an hour. In the span of that hour she drowned her kids. So yes he did her alone and even before that day, he was doing against doctors’ orders. After her multiple suicidal and psychotic events in 1999, he still convinced her to have their last child Mary in 2000. Absolutely negligent and selfish.

    • @zwebackshyper
      @zwebackshyper 2 роки тому +2

      "told by doctors to stop getting her pregnant" you say that as if he would force himself onto her and get her pregnant without her consent she knew the consequences as well and was just as negligent both are at fault for her being pregnant not just him acusing a man for his wife killing their kids without his knowledge is completely ignorant

  • @schmetterling9277
    @schmetterling9277 4 роки тому +106

    He is guilty, he knew it. And then married another woman. He should be in prison.

    • @mmendoza2128
      @mmendoza2128 4 роки тому +21

      Well, the second wife divorced him in 2015

    • @michaellovely6601
      @michaellovely6601 4 роки тому +24

      @@mmendoza2128 Smart move on her part.

    • @gomogomez7300
      @gomogomez7300 3 роки тому +17

      @@mmendoza2128 Probably because he ask her to have many, many, childrens.... He was the one who needed psihiatrical suport long time ago, I think. RIP little angels!💙

    • @explorer0213
      @explorer0213 3 роки тому +2

      @@gomogomez7300 psychiatric

    • @707MK
      @707MK 2 роки тому +2

      This husband is Guilty for shure he let Andrea down when she needed so barely help.

  • @bathman3713
    @bathman3713 4 роки тому +116

    The empty look in the guys eyes tell you he's much as monster as the woman maybe she didn't want 5 kids taking care of 1 is already bad enough the guy and his "traditional family" of 5

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 3 роки тому +15

      Oh they lived in RV for most of pregnancy's and brought this street preacher in who talked about end times, Satan and other things, and he never let her get treatment for post partum depression. I blame him for this

  • @acolley2891
    @acolley2891 3 роки тому +136

    😭 It is so obvious that he is a controlling narcissist!

    • @707MK
      @707MK 2 роки тому +5

      Absolute

    • @TheDizzleHawke
      @TheDizzleHawke 2 роки тому +4

      You’re really going to blame the victim?

    • @karenlouks3480
      @karenlouks3480 2 роки тому +5

      Why in the world did they even listen to this man

    • @addorsubtract650
      @addorsubtract650 2 роки тому

      Of course he is a man so he must be evil right by ur feminist logic? F OFF.

    • @jatticusfancypants9624
      @jatticusfancypants9624 2 роки тому +1

      @@TheDizzleHawke OP wasn't blaming the children, they were blaming the husband who is not the victim.

  • @mandthere2258
    @mandthere2258 5 років тому +97

    He is a loser. He should take some of that responsibility of her crime

    • @maricedixion3357
      @maricedixion3357 5 років тому +11

      He should had help her get treatment but he didn't do that

    • @AnimatedBlast
      @AnimatedBlast 9 місяців тому

      She was mentally very ill. He didn’t respect this.

  • @jennief7114
    @jennief7114 2 роки тому +56

    My mother was on Haldol. You cannot expect them to take their medicine on their own. The only way she ever became better as it was given to her in a shot form once a month. She did great and the last portion of her life was wonderful, and she was such a sweet grandmother!

    • @daniellex51484
      @daniellex51484 Рік тому

      What are the side effects? And why is someone prescribed this medication if you don't mind answering?

    • @MichaelLovely-mr6oh
      @MichaelLovely-mr6oh 7 місяців тому

      ​@@daniellex51484A quick Google search will help you find the answer with regards to finding out the side effects of Haldol.

  • @giulianacr2638
    @giulianacr2638 4 роки тому +110

    I have had depression episodes throughout my life, but I was so lucky to be in love with my babies when they were born, breastfeed, bathed, changed and stared at them while they slept. I enjoyed every moment of it. I feel bad for mothers who go through depression after delivery. It must be really hard to cope with :(

    • @gregzgurl2004
      @gregzgurl2004 3 роки тому +27

      Many women are “in love” with their babies but still suffer terribly with depression and anxiety during and after pregnancy.

    • @kingayy9267
      @kingayy9267 Рік тому +1

      @gregzgurl2004
      Right that was a nasty way for OP to word that but it probably wasn't meant in a rude way, just sounded bad.

    • @theimprovedmama3288
      @theimprovedmama3288 Рік тому

      Yea I’ve had severe postpartum
      Depression with 2/4 of my children. You love them more then life itself. It’s not about not loving them it’s like you don’t love yourself, you have all these negative thought that the baby would be better off without you, you should just end it, etc. it puts you into like a cationic where you can’t even do anything. I was able to get through it because I had a good husband and a good support system who helped me. Some women aren’t so lucky.

  • @Carpenterdane
    @Carpenterdane 2 роки тому +26

    He pushed her over the edge! Encouraged her to have kids, then not help her with anything, housework, taking care of the kids, and she was probably just exhausted!.

  • @nevergiveupfitness4710
    @nevergiveupfitness4710 5 років тому +66

    Mental illness is a reality. Postpartum psychosis and depression is a sad living. Sometimes the individuals don't even know they have it, just like in this case.

  • @search5819
    @search5819 2 роки тому +37

    THAT'S WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU HAVE MORE KIDS THAN YOU CAN HANDLE WITH ABSOLUTELY NO HELP...

    • @mariec3527
      @mariec3527 Місяць тому

      Its a wonder how the Duggar mom even survived past 5 kids knowing her husband probably has the same mentality as rusty

  • @goldensprite3373
    @goldensprite3373 4 роки тому +52

    It was very foolish and irresponsible to have another child knowing this risks.
    As nice as it is to have a child, they can't make you happy and a lot of people have babies wanting that.

    • @j4kgang921
      @j4kgang921 3 роки тому +4

      They can do the total opposite

    • @dab7271
      @dab7271 3 роки тому +5

      Agreed. If a professional psychiatric doctor is giving you a written warning not to have more kids, it is for a reason. And he has admitted it was a planned pregnancy, which means they knowingly went against the doctor’s advice.

  • @silaslizzie43
    @silaslizzie43 2 роки тому +14

    She didn't do this...THEY did this. A husband and wife indifferent to the responsibility of their children. He should be in prison or at the very least, prevented from having more.

    • @Navak_
      @Navak_ Рік тому +1

      Or at the very least, prevented from having more.

  • @maggiev9247
    @maggiev9247 Рік тому +13

    She was sick in her mind, yet he gets her pregnant. The knife story yet he gets her pregnant again! He knew she was suicidal.
    So why have more?

  • @Veronica81995
    @Veronica81995 2 роки тому +12

    5 kids.. a lot of responsability for a woman. Maybe he did not helped a lot..

    • @mary_puffin
      @mary_puffin Місяць тому

      Not a coincidence - it's the algorithm.

  • @marsha1758
    @marsha1758 2 роки тому +18

    He doesn't blame her because he would have to share that blame. They both knew the doctor's recommendation and decided to dismiss it.

  • @ramzigooding4945
    @ramzigooding4945 3 роки тому +25

    I love being a mom to a hyper, sweet and smart little girl, but I did suffer from PPD after giving birth to her this was almost six years ago, it made me think I was a horrible mom because of her upbringing (her dad wasn't around and I was still living at home) I thought she deserved better, I knew it was getting bad when I mentioned to my doctor I wanted to hurt or off myself because I felt like a failure to her, I still have my moments but not as severe like it was and I'm happy I'm still here to see her grow up into a wonderful kid💜

    • @davidmansell5986
      @davidmansell5986 2 роки тому +1

      Stick in there! The fact that you have the guts to write the above says that you are a good person and says so much more.

    • @cynthiaheart2021
      @cynthiaheart2021 Рік тому +1

      🙏🏻❤️🦋

    • @kingayy9267
      @kingayy9267 Рік тому

      @ramzigooding4945
      Thank you for sharing your very personal story.
      I'm glad you're doing better and please know that the fact that you're worried about your parenting means you *are* a good parent!
      I hope you and your kid are happy and healthy for years to come!

  • @echo-2417
    @echo-2417 2 роки тому +15

    The coincidence that I'm watching this exactly 20 years later. Wow

  • @elainepalamidis375
    @elainepalamidis375 3 роки тому +22

    This man is NOT inoccent!! He's creepy

    • @jeandixson5610
      @jeandixson5610 2 роки тому +2

      Just like that girl who helped the boy commit suicide, he’s guilty

  • @MsTinkerbelle87
    @MsTinkerbelle87 4 роки тому +24

    It sounds like she just stopped all of these hardcore anti psych meds cold turkey, that in itself is disaster!

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 3 роки тому +8

      He would make her stop Everytime they got pregnant. I think doctor's tried to keep her on her meds but he let her saying it would harm the baby

    • @MsTinkerbelle87
      @MsTinkerbelle87 3 роки тому +4

      @@Pinkranger87 That’s so maddening! Unfortunately Haldol makes you feel like you’re your old self again so you feel like you don’t need it anymore :( They should’ve listened to the doctor!!!🤬 She should have sectioned as soon as she refused to take them!!!

  • @jilla-dr9hu
    @jilla-dr9hu Рік тому +8

    Don’t blame it on poor mental health care. He’s is as much at fault for not following doctors warnings that having another baby could trigger psychosis. This could of all been easily avoided if they didn’t have a 5th child. Raising 1 is hard enough. He put expectations on her that wasn’t able to handle and it’s stressful enough. But had he not had a 5th child, the other four may still be alive and most likely would be. Stopping her anti psychotic and having another baby causing he pushed for it and woulda kept on having more and more cause he is selfish and as much at fault as her

  • @pachiecakes8467
    @pachiecakes8467 Рік тому +10

    And rusty didn’t think to get his wife some inside help with the kids?? It’s for sure his blame too!!!!

  • @lorrainehawkins123
    @lorrainehawkins123 3 роки тому +12

    He kept her pregnant and bare feet

  • @maggot1111666
    @maggot1111666 2 роки тому +6

    the pain in this man's face is obvious. the comment section of this video is despicable

    • @jenniferkhan3686
      @jenniferkhan3686 2 роки тому +10

      He was told that having another child would definitely cause her to have another psychotic break….he is responsible.

  • @j4kgang921
    @j4kgang921 3 роки тому +17

    If her meds worked ....WHy was she Taken OFF??!

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 3 роки тому +8

      She was pregnant. Some of the meds might have harmed the baby. But I'm sure her doctor would've monitored her even closer.

  • @annewick3287
    @annewick3287 3 роки тому +11

    Why did you go against the drs advice??
    She should never have been taken off of her medication especially haldol. She would have been in reality at least

  • @radhasen.animalwelfare.5644
    @radhasen.animalwelfare.5644 2 роки тому +5

    This man is disconnected from all ther horrific events that occured..
    In his not his reality but hers alone.
    There is absolutely no emotion, no sadness nothing. I see no signs of any left over sorrow..
    He speaks so nonchalantly like it was somebody elses tragedy .
    And remarried and had another kid..
    This man has no feelings for anybody whatsoever...

    • @randomnessatitsfineness190
      @randomnessatitsfineness190 2 роки тому +2

      Thankfully, according to articles, his new wife divorced him in 2015 (which is the last time he’s been seen in public). It is presumed that she filled for Divorce after that trash 2015 interview with Oprah because there he said he was still married to her.
      Ever since then, he has had a SUPER LOW profile.

  • @jvsalas6915
    @jvsalas6915 4 роки тому +10

    I had postpartum depression when i had my second son ❤️but it was that i wasnt gonna make it ❤️then faded away now my babies are grown up

    • @dianastvarnik697
      @dianastvarnik697 Рік тому +1

      There is a big difference between pp depression and pp psychosis.

  • @ecebear3
    @ecebear3 6 місяців тому +2

    He’s just as guilty as her.

  • @Daphnse
    @Daphnse Рік тому +5

    Traditional family
    You mean Christian
    You mean the mom takes care all of the kids and serves the husband
    While putting herself last

    • @momof1150
      @momof1150 Рік тому +1

      I think you’re right ie: Rusty Yates’ definition of a traditional family is the mom doesn’t work outside the home, she takes care of and homeschools all the kids, serves her husband all while putting herself last. At the time of her arrest, Andrea was a thin, disheveled-looking robot. I don’t think Rusty was acting like a Christian at all! A Christian family is a loving family following Jesus. And Jesus came not to be served, but to serve and give His life as a ransom for many. A Christian husband loves his wife as Christ loved His church and gave Himself up for her. Rusty did neither.

  • @nedajoon
    @nedajoon Рік тому +5

    I can understand him being supportive of Andrea due to mental illness, what I don’t understand is how on earth he thought having the 5th child is ok???? He should have just hired help for her to relieve some of her stress. I think he should have been held responsible for not taking care of her the right way and instead he get her pregnant again.

    • @foxyroxytm
      @foxyroxytm Рік тому

      Seriously, and now instead of having 4 kids they have none.

  • @yeseniacanas5480
    @yeseniacanas5480 5 місяців тому +2

    He shares guilt because from other documentaries he was the one pushing her to have more babies. Also when she was quitting her medication he never reported or try to help out. Now he’s saying “if she would’ve proper help” really???!?!!

  • @bewills8247
    @bewills8247 3 роки тому +7

    Whatever he knew she was stressed his fault too

    • @jeandixson5610
      @jeandixson5610 2 роки тому

      Absolutely

    • @Du808-o8k
      @Du808-o8k 2 роки тому

      Well shouldn’t had kids that her fault no one didn’t tell her too open her legs…

  • @capslockasmr6295
    @capslockasmr6295 4 роки тому +19

    God bless those kids, Andrea and her husband didn't deserve them.

  • @lisakaler4121
    @lisakaler4121 2 роки тому +3

    I wonder what his diagnosis would be? He's not innocent in this matter.

  • @j4kgang921
    @j4kgang921 3 роки тому +12

    He stook by her side cuz HE'S GUILTY

    • @davidmansell5986
      @davidmansell5986 2 роки тому

      Yes. He is also a glory hunting, shameless criminal.

  • @brandyvaughn1
    @brandyvaughn1 4 роки тому +7

    Why would she be allowed to keep on having kids

    • @meagancooper4551
      @meagancooper4551 3 роки тому +1

      You can if you stay on your meds

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 3 роки тому +2

      @@meagancooper4551 Her husband wanted a large family. I think he's league with Duggar Family just keep having babies till your uterus says no more

  • @Iheartradioss
    @Iheartradioss Рік тому +4

    I was lead here bcuz of the duxbury case. This husband is an idiot. He knew his wife had serious depression and got her pregnant again just to torture her even more? He shouldve got charged for that. The doctor specifically said that another pregnancy would put her over the edge. He knew she wasnt right in the mind. Shame on him

  • @beckykent6674
    @beckykent6674 Рік тому +2

    The Husband doesn't seem that upset about all his children being dead!!!!

  • @patriciaschuster1371
    @patriciaschuster1371 Рік тому +3

    I admire Rusty Yates more and more. A woman is not just a baby-making machine.

  • @schoomzer
    @schoomzer 11 місяців тому +1

    They had an evangelist preacher who spoke in tongues, wore a devil's mask and convinced Andrea that her children were going to hell unless she did something to save them. He was at the core of her psychosis, and it's swept under the rug.

  • @Morrisneuro83
    @Morrisneuro83 4 роки тому +7

    This is the worst child killing I can remember...not that the others aren't terrible..but my mind won't forget it! So horrific!

    • @thatgardeninggirl2864
      @thatgardeninggirl2864 4 роки тому +2

      Susan Smith case beats this one Andrea fully thought the devil was gonna take her kids souls Susan killed to be with another man

    • @kayknowles2350
      @kayknowles2350 3 роки тому +6

      octavia mckinney until Chris watts entered

    • @katiekarakondis3348
      @katiekarakondis3348 2 роки тому

      He is the sicko, what an idiot. He was warned. Cannot watch anymore

    • @MichaelLovely-mr6oh
      @MichaelLovely-mr6oh 7 місяців тому

      ​@@thatgardeninggirl2864Another mother killing her children due to wanting to be with a man who didn't like or want kids would be Diane Downs.

    • @thatgardeninggirl2864
      @thatgardeninggirl2864 7 місяців тому

      @@MichaelLovely-mr6oh Yep that's another Monster

  • @cdelane3335
    @cdelane3335 15 днів тому

    He was warned not to leave her alone with the children. He did anyway because his mother was coming to stay with her. She didn't come in time. He has some responsibility in what happened too.

  • @MakeBetterStuff
    @MakeBetterStuff 5 місяців тому +2

    Every Republican who voted to take away women's rights to choose abortion or birth control should watch this.

  • @gerardmcgovern1831
    @gerardmcgovern1831 Рік тому +1

    THE HUSBAND IS GUILTY

  • @cathywallace6990
    @cathywallace6990 Рік тому +1

    ALL HIS FAULT FOR THE DEATH OF THESE CHILDREN

  • @lindalilly1544
    @lindalilly1544 Рік тому +1

    What a liar

  • @andresmattos7541
    @andresmattos7541 Рік тому +1

    It took more than 5 min to drown a human to death while the person is actively fighting screaming and scratching and she did this systematically and methodically 5 times. This was premeditated you gullible people.

  • @Shaunte0620
    @Shaunte0620 10 місяців тому +1

    Because of him!

  • @karenlouks3480
    @karenlouks3480 2 роки тому +2

    Ridiculous no one asking direct questions he's just as much fault because he didn't think of his wife or his children

  • @auzziernvdl
    @auzziernvdl 8 місяців тому

    Rusty should have been charged for leaving her with those babies. He had been warned by doctors. That should have been enough to give him at least some responsibility for this tragedy.

  • @amaribilal2272
    @amaribilal2272 Рік тому +1

    Meds obviously help but it’s scary that they temporarily fix the problem. Like someone off meds could do something so heinous. It so easy for person to just not take meds

  • @danhosmer1401
    @danhosmer1401 Рік тому +1

    Andrea was mentally ill and for him to get her pregnant over and over was wrong even though they loved the children. Why did he keep impregnating her when he knew she couldn't handle it?

  • @williamrodriguez7248
    @williamrodriguez7248 2 роки тому +2

    That's he's foult poor woman I feel sorry for her end the doctor told him not to live her alone he didn't care now he's merried have a kid with another woman end poor woman in a mental hospital I hope she wake up one day the way her face end her eyes she looks like she's lost I hope end pray for her 🙏

  • @reneecook8701
    @reneecook8701 Рік тому +1

    Also the oldest ran away and she chased them down and drowned him so she was very guilty she knew what she was doing

    • @carlycane5566
      @carlycane5566 Рік тому

      All her supporters won’t acknowledge this. They need to read the court documents of exactly what she did to her children. She held them down and physically fought them with such force that their INTERNAL ORGANS were bruised. She also held each one under water for so long that their brains were swollen to the size of adult brains and weighed an extreme amount during the autopsies.

  • @floyd4826
    @floyd4826 19 годин тому

    Maybe instead of keeping his nentally ill wife barefoot & pregnant for 7 years, he could've helped at home and supported her treatment. He indirectly played a big part in this tragedy.

  • @hitthebookswithneelimasing1078
    @hitthebookswithneelimasing1078 5 років тому +7

    No no she deserves to live.....in remorse....in helplessness... remembering her golden days and her innocent kids...

  • @zakariyamuhammed6066
    @zakariyamuhammed6066 Рік тому +1

    A woman killed her 5 little children in cold blood and almost everyone is here blaming the husband... like WTF.. is she the first to have 5 kids or did he forced her into having their last baby

    • @bateseanderson2667
      @bateseanderson2667 Рік тому +1

      If you look on her case she had some serious.mental issues going on and if you look at their background leading up to their kids death. Would you have married him? To literally serve him and have his kids while dealing with depression and a bunch of other mental issues. He legit when even let her wear shoes. It's funny how people who have no mental issues look at every situation the same when every situation is nowhere near the same

    • @zakariyamuhammed6066
      @zakariyamuhammed6066 Рік тому

      So he should be the one arrested instead...is that what u are saying?

    • @bateseanderson2667
      @bateseanderson2667 Рік тому

      @@zakariyamuhammed6066 he should have along with the pastor and all of her doctors. She's right where she needs to be ans surprising has not one time asked to be released

    • @zakariyamuhammed6066
      @zakariyamuhammed6066 Рік тому +1

      It wasn't his fault that she is mentally ill and neither did he force her to continue to be in the marriage with him or have children for him... divorce is always an option

    • @zakariyamuhammed6066
      @zakariyamuhammed6066 Рік тому +1

      But there is no excuse for killing 5 innocent little children

  • @sharonhughes7871
    @sharonhughes7871 20 днів тому

    If she was suicidal why was she even alone with the kids 🤷‍♀️

  • @AriMun782
    @AriMun782 5 років тому +13

    They could’ve waited to have another child. 😪

    • @Pinkranger87
      @Pinkranger87 3 роки тому +4

      She wanted to stop but he wanted more

    • @AriMun782
      @AriMun782 3 роки тому +1

      @@Pinkranger87 Yes, love. But she had been warned about her illness. I mean, her husband could’ve been there more often. Maybe her mother or mother in law or simply someone to keep an eye on her🥺 I don’t blame anyone.

    • @AnimatedBlast
      @AnimatedBlast 9 місяців тому

      They already has 4 kids. What the hell was the need to have more kids.

  • @nopenope1194
    @nopenope1194 2 роки тому

    He's as guilty as she is...

  • @Mel-by4ur
    @Mel-by4ur Рік тому

    He should have never left her alone with the kids.

  • @Mahi-nw5vh
    @Mahi-nw5vh Рік тому +1

    The husband is like a sociopath

  • @annechris2677
    @annechris2677 2 роки тому +2

    He looks scary . 5th kid ?

  • @LaV593
    @LaV593 Рік тому

    The husband is responsible for all of this to some extent...

  • @ktrn8160
    @ktrn8160 Рік тому +1

    So he wants more kids and I bet he didn’t help her raising these 5 boys . Boys are a handful yet 5

  • @gabrielanavarro2193
    @gabrielanavarro2193 2 роки тому +1

    He is gullty , she was Sick , he was not , he should be in jail 😡😡😡🎈

    • @X3AmySarah
      @X3AmySarah Рік тому

      Unfortunately you can’t put someone in jail for talking their sick wife into having more kids. This is America, not Iran.

  • @thevoidisshining
    @thevoidisshining 4 роки тому +2

    She believes things that arent real but he believes satan did it uh huh

  • @bernieheartdragon1888
    @bernieheartdragon1888 3 місяці тому

    I think she thought she needed to be perfect. And if she took the medicine it would mean she wasn’t perfect because she needed medicine. It’s so sad.

  • @lindalilly1544
    @lindalilly1544 Рік тому

    Why did he not get jailed? Hes responsible. Evil.

  • @coimindeburka7716
    @coimindeburka7716 5 місяців тому

    Rusty is equally guilty! R.I.P 💐

  • @Du808-o8k
    @Du808-o8k 2 роки тому +1

    They both faults not just the husband…

  • @garylefevers
    @garylefevers 4 місяці тому

    The husband is guilty of depraved indifference imo and should have time in prison himself. That poor woman begged for help and he just wanted to control her even more. The kids paid the price and Andrea is in a different way.

  • @winternightsky6945
    @winternightsky6945 5 місяців тому

    No, if she/her husband used birth control and sought mental health treatment and she actually put in the work to keep up with the treatment/followed the doctors orders. Then maybe she wouldn't have done what she did. But he saw her going through all that and just kept impregnating her🤨
    These people/communities that try to keep up a picture perfect lifestyle, will ignore common sense, warnings and advice. I know women who don't want more kids but say their husband( who doesn't help with the first one) wants more. They're drowning in stress, anxiety, depression but won't stand up for themselves because they don't want to be single/divorced.

  • @dawnedwards2320
    @dawnedwards2320 4 місяці тому +1

    Rusty should be in prison also

  • @marwatson7408
    @marwatson7408 3 місяці тому

    He is just as responsible for what happened to those poor kids they were told not to have any more children . If he is so innocent why did his second wife file for divorce maybe he does have control issues. 🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️

  • @hunterwilliams3981
    @hunterwilliams3981 Рік тому +3

    He wanted all these children and ignored doctors orders and now he has none of them because of his selfishness and unwillingness to take care of his wife.

  • @tenabruce3548
    @tenabruce3548 Рік тому +1

    If rusty would of listened to the doctors, not to keep getting her pregnant 🤰, and he didn’t, then to the doctors who should of Kepted her there , until she was totally well !!! I blame lots of people, for not doing enough, to get her better, and taking her off meds, that did seem to help!!! She should of had someone there with her 24-7, since rusty really didn’t help her very much either!!!! She took good care of her karma dhs, till she had more, and I feel she really in truly freaked out, and her psychosis took her so low, she couldn’t deal with life, so her demons took her too far, and she killed her kids, so they wouldn’t go to hell !!! RIP U 5 Little Kids, And Baby Mary !!!! Ur All Loved 🥰 And Missed!!! Amen 🙏!!! 5 ANGELS 👼 👼👼👼👼, WENT TO HEAVEN TOGETHER!!!!!! ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹💔💔💔💔💔✅💯✅💯✅💯✅💯✅💯☦️✝️☦️✝️☦️✝️🦋🌈🦋🌈🦋🌈🦋🌈🦋🌈🦋

  • @babylaylacottoharris9860
    @babylaylacottoharris9860 3 місяці тому

    he shouldn't blame her he should blame himself for leaving her by herself with the kids he knew she's was very ill and sick but he continued too ignorant and too have another child knowing the situation she's was in and getting off her medication was a red flag so he needs too be in her shoes it's not her fault for being ill yes she's done something wrong and she's have too live with that for the rest of her life.

  • @Melanie-vj6he
    @Melanie-vj6he 2 роки тому +1

    Elmer Fudd is smarter than him.

  • @whispersoftheafterlife1017
    @whispersoftheafterlife1017 Рік тому

    Antidepressants don’t work in a day. They take weeks almost a month

    • @adelekelly455
      @adelekelly455 Рік тому

      I think he meant the antipsychotic (Haldol) worked quickly. It can work instantly like that.

  • @kathycoons7922
    @kathycoons7922 Рік тому

    He should of stopped getting her pregnant

  • @sandrasiino8474
    @sandrasiino8474 4 місяці тому +1

    He’s the guilty one

  • @tubegirl25
    @tubegirl25 10 місяців тому +1

    ‘A more traditional family’. Religious zealotry

  • @CamrenWorthy
    @CamrenWorthy 5 місяців тому

    She started believing this when they met that weird cult leader. Rusty said they had similar beliefs.

  • @fitzyglam
    @fitzyglam Рік тому

    💯 his fault

  • @latonyajackson5698
    @latonyajackson5698 2 роки тому

    Any video of her? Maybe she don't wanna talk ab it tho. Eesh, she denies her own parole every year...

  • @katharina6865
    @katharina6865 2 роки тому +1

    The poor woman! So sad!

  • @buggiemara4902
    @buggiemara4902 11 місяців тому

    He's enjoying the attention.

  • @sandrapleasegettothestoryk6704
    @sandrapleasegettothestoryk6704 2 роки тому

    You could have stopped her

    • @Navak_
      @Navak_ Рік тому

      Kick her out of the house? Divorce her? She's getting back to those kids one way or another. Can't keep her away from them forever. How dare you blame him.

  • @Faisey648
    @Faisey648 2 роки тому

    Maybe he doesn’t or maybe didn’t want kids? Very strange but everyone deals a different way. 5 is just too many. Of course she was stress. I think they thought you little of reality and stayed in their world

  • @thevoidisshining
    @thevoidisshining 4 роки тому

    But she wanted to have more

  • @amaribilal2272
    @amaribilal2272 Рік тому

    Ended a bloodline smh