Untold Truths by Shabbar Zaidi Part 2, PIA, Railway, Steel Mills & Why Pakistan Failed?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 гру 2023
- Untold Truths by Shabbar Zaidi Part 2, PIA, Railway, Steel Mills & Why Pakistan Failed? @raftartv Podcast
Explore the in-depth discussion on Pakistan's economic challenges and the fate of its key institutions, including PIA, Pakistan Steel Mills, and Railways. Shabbar Zaidi delves into the historical decisions, policies, and their impact on the nation's economy. Gain insights into the complexities surrounding talent in Pakistan and the issues related to charity and donations and how woman empowerment can change Pakistan's economic inflation from the former chairman Federal Board of Revenue.
#shabbarzaidi #podcast #pakistan #pia #piaflights #northamerica #karachi #toronto #flight #houston #woman #empowerment #pakistanipolitics #pmln #ppp #mqm #pti #imrankhan #pmpakistan #anwarulhaqkakar #pakistaneconomy #pakistaneconomiccrisis #fbr #federalboardofrevenue #pakistanipolitics #pakistaneconomynews #shabbarzaidiinterview #shabbarzaidipodcast #pakistanissues #pakindia #nehru #regionalpolitics #untoldtruths #institutions
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
UA-cam
/ @raftartv
UA-cam
/ @raftarnewsofficial
UA-cam
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Shabbar Zaidi's take on PIA, Railways and Steel Mill was spot on. The way he explained these issues, no newspaper or article has been able to do so.
⚡⚡Emirates service fleet customer service cannot be compared to PIA. Shabbar is trying to defend an incompetent airline and balming it on the other international airlines. He himself said Lufthansa KLM etc used to land in Karachi then how PIA was in profit back then? Also Qatar and Emirates fly to multiple destinations in US , Australia Germany etc. So shabbar argument is faulty.
S. Zaidi was the Chairman of FBR once upon a time, why did he not say and do the things he advocates now?
i dont think so, he has no idea what he is talking about, just shooting off his hip. He is just an asshole, who has served mafias all his life and when TV discusses his character as FBR chariman he just wants to divert discussion on his totally pathetic run as FBR chairman who could not hold not even 1 member of his own team responsible for bribery and corruption.
@@zaf7794 not only faulty, totally non-sensical as well.
F@@zaf7794
As an ex PIA employee I believe Mr. Shabbar has understood PIA more than anyone else i have known. He has nailed it to the point that its a policy failure (lack of will by the govt to create a policy thats state friendly) & many such comments especially the one with its not the fault of employees. Good work thank you.
In my 13 years of service as pilot for PIA the only thing observed was inaction by the governments whenever there was time to do something productive. It was almost timed correctly to self destruct PIA by helping foreign airlines & by giving them additional freedom to operate in & out of Pakistan. Moreover, his comments about hatred against Karachi is accurate and i always felt more racism in Pakistan than anywhere else in the world. We basically can’t work together. Thats a major problem. Liking & disliking based on provincial & cultural background.
PIA was great in the old days when Karachi was a great HUB for all major airlines in the world until long range jets started doing direct flights in between EU & the far east thus a slow growth until the mid 90’s after when the loses started. That was the time when gulf airlines kicked off & sucked PIA out even further until our PCAA (under defence) allowed additional policies to help the gulf airlines grow.
Then came PPP government with Zardari. This is the time when further damage was done by killing PIA’s supply chain leading to shortages of parts. This lead to buying parts from then onwards on AOG (aircraft on ground) basis. There again a lack of continuity in effective policies that protect PIA. Rather only helped destroy it further to the point no one wants it anymore.
Good luck to PMLN who always tried eradicating the problem rather than fixing it.
AirArabia still refers Karachi as the Hub of the region. Check their website.
100000% correct and brutal truth about how PIA and Karachi as Hub was destroyed. Feel ashamed to have handed over Emirates $$$ in last 20 years instead of my own country.
The problem is simple yet can never be solved. The Pakistani Army has big business interests in Pakistan. They will not give a free hand to the persons you named as there will be a collision of interest. Zaidi saheb in this interview has hinted this matter. He refers to it when he talks about the steel mill. The Army imports hugely from China and sell it in Pakistan. It is converting all arable lands into profitable housing projects. Pakistan was made for the Elites and if you are an Elite there is no better place to live in than Pakistan. You don't have to pay taxes and you can live virtually like a king. The Elites are hell corrupt and the only things that have saved their skins are India hatred, Kashmir and some potent dose of religious touch. For a poor man the only dream of becoming an Elite is to join the Army and reach to the higher echelons. Once he reached that rung, he starts to oppress and suppress. The Army has thus become the gateway to become the Elite. The low paid soldiers are not Elite though. To become Elite you need to climb to higher posts. There is no meritocracy for these higher posts.
Here are the names of Pakistan's finest Economists:
Uzair is a Gujarati Vohra muslim (originally from the state of India's Gujarat), Atif Miyan is a Qadiani and Zaidi is a Shia immigrant muslim from India. Atif is a fantastic scholar and Imran Khan brought him to his cabinet. He has thrown out soon enough. His only fault was that he was a Qadiani. Pakistanis could even tolerate Jews but not Qadianis. Merit is not a criteria in Pakistan but religious identity is. Have you heard the name of General Akhtar Rehman Malik ? Do you know the reason why General Malik was replaced by Yahya Khan in 1965 war? Have you read the letter of Gen Malik's son? Have you heard the name of Abdus Salam? Abdus Salam, who won the Nobel Prize in physics in 1979. Do you know what happened to the grave of Pakistan's only nobel prize winner? He was a Qadiani too.
you will regret paying your own country's airline. Just this month, many of my relative's PIA flights were delayed, rescheduled, or cancelled. My aunt was stuck at Madina airport for 2 days because there was no PIA plane to take them to Pakistan.
🙄 یہ محترم 👈🏿 شبر زیدی صاحب ((( بذات خود ))) ------ کتنی بار ،، کتنی حکومتوں کے ساتھ کام کر چکے ہیں ❓❓❓ 😡😡😡 آج موصوف خود ((( جب حکومت سے باہر ہیں اور حکومت کا حصہ نہیں ہیں ))) تو فر فر فر سچائی و حقیقت بیان کر رہے ہیں 😡😡😡 اور جب خود حکومتوں کا حصہ ہوتے ہیں تو 🤔 ------ تو تب یہ سچائی و حقیقت پر مبنی بیان / انٹرویو کیوں نظر نہیں آتے 😡😡😡 یہ محترم شبر زیدی صاحب ،، اگر ❗نہ بھی ایسی سچائی و حقیقت بتائیں تب بھی پاکستانی 🇵🇰 عوام جانتی ہے کہ 👈🏿 قومی ائیر لائن ((( پی آئی اے ))) / پاکستان اسٹیل مل ((( کراچی ))) / پاکستان ریلوے اور دیگر بھی سرکاری و قومی ادارے تباہ و برباد کرنے میں خود کرپٹ پاکستانی 🇵🇰 ہی شامل تھے اور اب بھی ہیں 😡 باہر سے آکر کسی غیر ملکی نے پاکستان 🇵🇰 کے بڑے سرکاری اداروں کا ستیاناس / واہی تباہی نہیں کی ہے ------ گھر کو آگ لگی ،، گھر کے چراغ سے ------ 😡😡😡
📶 کرپٹ سول جمہوری سیاست دانوں ++ انکی سیاسی جماعتوں سے ------ نہ تو پاکستان 🇵🇰 چلایا گیا اور نہ ہی پاکستان 🇵🇰 کے سول سرکاری ادارے 😡😡😡 میرا کھلا چیلنج اور دعویٰ ہے کہ " اگر ❗آج ہی پی آئی اے / اسٹیل مل / ریلوے اور دیگر سرکاری اداروں کے وزیر سے لے کر تمام اعلیٰ افسران ((( غیر ملکی انگریز ))) لگا دیئے جائیں تو پھر پاکستانی 🇵🇰 اپنی آنکھوں سے ان زوال پزیر / خسارے میں ڈوبے اداروں کی شاندار عروج و ترقی دیکھیں گئے ✅ جب تک گندی سیاست ،، اور کرپٹ عناصر ان اداروں میں موجود ہیں --- سوال ہی پیدا نہیں ہوتا ہے کہ " یہ اہم ملکی اثاثے واپس اپنی اصل حالت میں آجائیں ✅
⚡⚡Emirates service fleet customer service cannot be compared to PIA. Shabbar is trying to defend an incompetent airline and balming it on the other international airlines. He himself said Lufthansa KLM etc used to land in Karachi then how PIA was in profit back then? Also Qatar and Emirates fly to multiple destinations in US , Australia Germany etc. So shabbar argument is faulty.
Shabbar Zaidi is a Legend and a National Treasure... Alhamdulillah! Thank you for the sensational podcasts. Love from Toronto 🍁
Personally I have had honour to serve him for 10 years directly. To the moment, SHABBAR Sahab knows me personally. I personally saw him 10 days ago in his personal firm.
How come every man who has served in some sort of capacity under these corrupt people knowingly that their activities were corrupt, served them for 40 odd years and they are owned as national treasure by us?
@@AMMARTRAVELS This gentleman has nothing to do with 'national' rampant corruption of Pakistani government hierarchies. He is a qualified veteran Chartered Accountant in Pakistan. And socio-economic analyst in his own right.
Majedaar aadmi hai yeh😅😅😅
@user-mk1mm2bl2y AmmarTravels wants us all 240million+ people to commit collective suicide because our ruling elite is corrupt... lol what a simpleton 🤣
Dear raftar please bring Mr shabbar zaidi again & give him freedom to speak his mind & keep up the good work thank you.🎉
Hi Raftar,
Thank you for bringing Shabbar Zaidi sahib. We love listening to him. Please bring him again.
All power is centralized in the hands of our establishment. They should listen to what this wise man is saying.
They would not listen to him or any wise piece of advice as they are corrupt, hungry and deliberate to serve their own corrupt vested interest. Simple is that. One Muslim Male Citizen from Karachi PAKISTAN. 🙏
@@user-mk1mm2bl2y Gen Musharraf was from Karachi and he was a good leader of Pakistan
Dear all power lies in the hand of America and it's American establishment or to say international establishment who runs Pakistan and they will never wanted Pakistan to grow and become prosperous. IK is fighting with these mafia's and international establishment including there puppet's
@@muslim_first I am afraid he could fall into the category of somewhat controversial figure. From Karachi PAKISTAN.🙏
🙄 یہ محترم 👈🏿 شبر زیدی صاحب ((( بذات خود ))) ------ کتنی بار ،، کتنی حکومتوں کے ساتھ کام کر چکے ہیں ❓❓❓ 😡😡😡 آج موصوف خود ((( جب حکومت سے باہر ہیں اور حکومت کا حصہ نہیں ہیں ))) تو فر فر فر سچائی و حقیقت بیان کر رہے ہیں 😡😡😡 اور جب خود حکومتوں کا حصہ ہوتے ہیں تو 🤔 ------ تو تب یہ سچائی و حقیقت پر مبنی بیان / انٹرویو کیوں نظر نہیں آتے 😡😡😡 یہ محترم شبر زیدی صاحب ،، اگر ❗نہ بھی ایسی سچائی و حقیقت بتائیں تب بھی پاکستانی 🇵🇰 عوام جانتی ہے کہ 👈🏿 قومی ائیر لائن ((( پی آئی اے ))) / پاکستان اسٹیل مل ((( کراچی ))) / پاکستان ریلوے اور دیگر بھی سرکاری و قومی ادارے تباہ و برباد کرنے میں خود کرپٹ پاکستانی 🇵🇰 ہی شامل تھے اور اب بھی ہیں 😡 باہر سے آکر کسی غیر ملکی نے پاکستان 🇵🇰 کے بڑے سرکاری اداروں کا ستیاناس / واہی تباہی نہیں کی ہے ------ گھر کو آگ لگی ،، گھر کے چراغ سے ------ 😡😡😡
شبّر زیدی بھائ زندہ باد... کراچی والے ہی پاکستان کا دماغ ہیں.. آفتاب عالم خان کراچی والا
Hats off to shabbar sahab and the interviewer he didn’t interrupt him professionalism :)
Shabbar Zaidi is partially right about Indian railways. Yes we used to have two budgets, one for railway and other national budget but not anymore. Freight earning of Indian railways compensate towards passanger earning as passanger earning is low compared to freight earnings.
Also Railway hiring at executive level is via IRS (Indian Railway Service) so a professional cadre.
Now with dedicated freight corridors the logistics will improve in terms of time and cost. Will also decongest the passenger network.
Also the upcoming high speed corridors ( bullet train) are the next iteration for high paying passengers.
Sir Shabbar Zaidi's analysis on PIA, railways and PSM was spot on. Detailed and comprehensive explanation.
I m in love with Mr Shabbar, I wish I had one teacher like him in my university.
Good intellectual discussion.
Respect from London Ontario
I am amazed by Shabar Sahab. He clearly told the root causes of the problem. Our country is dealing with fanaticism. Pakistan itself lost a lot due to hate against Karachi.
Really enjoyed your conversation with Zaidi sahib in both parts. Zaidi sb is a true asset.
Thank you Shabbar Zaidi bhai for the information about 365 days of flights landing in Karachi. Star Gate Airport, 1st flight from London to Australia.
Keep it up !
Rafter you should make shabber zaidi as your permanent member. He is very intelligent and speak very true. I respect him a lot for speaking truth and exposing the hypocrisy of our devastated System
@11:50 : Regular flights from KHI to Toronto and regularly PIA staff goes missing in Canada. No such thing happens with Emirates, Etihad, Qatar airways etc.
Woh toh aapko b moqa milay ga toh aap b miss ho jayein ge wahan ja k 😂😂😂
Cricketers footballers Olympics k log miss ho jatay hain. Her Pakistani asylum le k baitha hai ya Marzayi ho k ya jhoot bol k. Bhai Emirates or Ittehad airline employees ko aik status detay hain. PIA toh employee ko tankhwa waqt pe nai deta
@@alifarhann no. It's not the case. Pakistani people are also working in other airlines and travel globally. They don't go missing. Every year I have at least 2 trips to Switzerland and I don't go missing. Many Pakistani work for multinational companies and travel regularly to western destinations and they never go missing.
@@alifarhann the issue of going missing is with the mist third class or lower class uneducated People. This shows that PIA employees the most third class people. Everyone sensible guy knows without proper documentation you can't do a job or business. Only low level jobs in remote areas which are even worse than Pakistan. No sensible guy will opt for this.
⚡⚡Emirates service fleet customer service cannot be compared to PIA. Shabbar is trying to defend an incompetent airline and balming it on the other international airlines. He himself said Lufthansa KLM etc used to land in Karachi then how PIA was in profit back then? Also Qatar and Emirates fly to multiple destinations in US , Australia Germany etc. So shabbar argument is faulty.
As an Indian, I enjoy the deliberations of Shabbar Zaidi sahab on matters of economy… I fail to understand why Pakistan is in such dire straits economically in spite of such luminaries like him, Atif Mian, Uzair Younus etc… They should be empowered to shape your economic policies…. Pakistan is doing the same things over and over again and expecting different results… That is stupidity… We are not complaining though…
Atif Mian and Uzair Younus are not Pakistani but Americans.
My dear friend, Mr. Shabbar Zaidi's parents are from your ALLAHBAAD, India. He is Urdu speaking Shia Muslim. I personally know him as I served under his direct control as an Accounts Manager. We know each other. I saw him in person some 10 days ago in his personal, consultancy firm. From Karachi PAKISTAN.
@@vinsin328 But they are your A-team…
@@user-mk1mm2bl2y Shia, sunni, sikh, hindu, christian… it’s immaterial… He seems a patriotic Pakistani with clear worldview unadulterated by religion or sectarianism…. Good man who is not afraid to call a spade a spade…. Empower these people and stick to their policies for a substantial amount of time to see the real benefits… Regards, from Durgapur, West Bengal, India; employed in a profit making state-owned integrated steel plant in India…
@@123abhijnan By mentioning his Shi'ite Muslim sect alongside his origin in India, I felt myself under compulsion to speak to my audience how personally I know this gem of person as well as he knows me personally as his once deputy and now as one of his aquantances.
Shabbar you are bold
You should bring Shabbar Zaidi on a regular basis. I would love you to discuss spirituality and other non-economic and political topics as well. He has wealth of knowledge on those areas as well.
جس دن ھمیں شبر زیدی جیسے ذھین تجربہ کار روشن خیال اور مخلص لوگ پاکستانی اداروں سربراہ بن جائنگے تو پاکستان کو کوئ ترقی سے نہیں روک سکتا
شبر زیدی صاحب کو ایف بی آر کا چئیرمین لگایا گیا تھا عمران خان کے دور میں، لیکن انہیں کام ہی نہیں کرنے دیا گیا اور مجبورن انہیں استعفی دینا پڑا۔ اب کون لوگ یا ادارے تھے جو انہیں کام نہیں کرنے دے رہے تھے۔ شبر زیدی نے خود انٹرویو میں انہیں نام بتائیں ہیں۔
Hatsoff shabbar sahab for revealing hidden truth and facts.
The problem is simple yet can never be solved. The Pakistani Army has big business interests in Pakistan. They will not give a free hand to the persons you named as there will be a collision of interest. Zaidi saheb in this interview has hinted this matter. He refers to it when he talks about the steel mill. The Army imports hugely from China and sell it in Pakistan. It is converting all arable lands into profitable housing projects. Pakistan was made for the Elites and if you are an Elite there is no better place to live in than Pakistan. You don't have to pay taxes and you can live virtually like a king. The Elites are hell corrupt and the only things that have saved their skins are India hatred, Kashmir and some potent dose of religious touch. For a poor man the only dream of becoming an Elite is to join the Army and reach to the higher echelons. Once he reached that rung, he starts to oppress and suppress. The Army has thus become the gateway to become the Elite. The low paid soldiers are not Elite though. To become Elite you need to climb to higher posts. There is no meritocracy for these higher posts.
Here are the names of Pakistan's finest Economists:
Uzair is a Gujarati Vohra muslim (originally from the state of India's Gujarat), Atif Miyan is a Qadiani and Zaidi is a Shia immigrant muslim from India. Atif is a fantastic scholar and Imran Khan brought him to his cabinet. He has thrown out soon enough. His only fault was that he was a Qadiani. Pakistanis could even tolerate Jews but not Qadianis. Merit is not a criteria in Pakistan but religious identity is. Have you heard the name of General Akhtar Rehman Malik ? Do you know the reason why General Malik was replaced by Yahya Khan in 1965 war? Have you read the letter of Gen Malik's son? Have you heard the name of Abdus Salam? Abdus Salam, who won the Nobel Prize in physics in 1979. Do you know what happened to the grave of Pakistan's only nobel prize winner? He was a Qadiani too.
Right
@@piranha3037 kash unko smjh ajati tou kya baat thi tou kabhi mulk bhe nhi toot'ta.
Excellent discussion. We highly appreciate your insight and knowledge of Pakistan's economic situation. Best wishes from NYC
A very accurate assessment of why pakistan is a failed state, and why it will not recover. The system is all set for failure. I always admired his brilliance he topped in matric and Intermediate exams from Karachi board. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over-Pakistans' case, we don't need finance ministers or highly paid Harvard grads if policies are governed by incompetent politicians and not by professionals in their field--Jeeya Bhutto-Shareefs and the establishment let common men and the country go to ..crap
Mr Shabbar Zaidi looks like a very cute and innocent rabbit.
Well articulate with sense of realism which were never prevailed in Pakistan.
😢😢
Exactly my thoughts. Cute rabbit👍🤣🤣🤣
Mr. Zaidi _ we appreciate your insight and do hope that "the powers to be" are listening to you!!!
It was the same situation in India. Only Air India was allowed and foreign airlines had very small access. This resulted in a terrible situation for customers. Tickets were expensive and difficult to get. Once it was opened to other airlines, things are much better. You have to look at Customer side also.
You should read the book on Air India as Praful Patel when he was Aviation Minister did very much the same. Air India bled till it was bought by Tata
⚡⚡Emirates service fleet customer service cannot be compared to PIA. Shabbar is trying to defend an incompetent airline and balming it on the other international airlines. He himself said Lufthansa KLM etc used to land in Karachi then how PIA was in profit back then? Also Qatar and Emirates fly to multiple destinations in US , Australia Germany etc. So shabbar argument is faulty.
The days he is reffering to in competition PIA was the best airline. Please scroll through history. The corrupt policies made this airline go down.
@@fawadahmadqureshi2995 pia was the best when they didn't had competition. When it encountered competition the truth came forward.
@@zaf7794 Any government enterprise will look good only in monopolistic environment.
Keep up 😊
Shabbir zaidi is a very great patriot and honest persont .he left the chairman ship of fbr for his principle
Who can be more patriot than Shabbar Zaidi. He is an asset of Pakistan. May Allah Almighty bless him and his family. 🙏
شبر زیدی صاحب پاکستان کیے بہترین analysis کرتے ھیں۔ ویری گڈ مارننگ
Indian Railway budget has been assimilated in Union budget from 5 years
Shabar zaidi is a real diamond of today's Pakistan.Very intellectual and economic philosopher.May Allah live him long.Love from kpk❤
Hello sir I'm Dev from India . Your channel is so nice.The good Pankista ni Being human first . Best luck shubham bhavti!🙏
In 1979, I departed from Pakistan and established my residence in the United States. Over the years, I pursued a career as an economist, dedicating myself to the study and analysis of economic trends and policies. My professional journey has been enriched by diverse experiences and a commitment to contributing to the field of economics.
شبر زیدی صاحب گپیں اچھی ھانک لیتے ھیں، یہی ھماری قوم کا المیہ ھے
What a great man he is ❤
میری حیرانگی کی انتہا ہے یہ ادمی پاکستانی ہو کر پورا سچ بول رہا ہے ۔ پاک اریمی اسکو قتل ہی نہ دے سچی بات یہ ہے کہ اس ادمی نے مجھکو سوچنے پر مجبور کر دیا ہے
اللہ تعالیٰ بچائے پاکیستانی آرمی کے غنڈوں سے
Shabbar Zaidi is the Boldest Person I have seen in the Pakistan politics history . He is factful , logical ,Goes on to the grass root level in terms of explaining the causes . Absolute magnificent Personality to wtness in Pakistan . More people like him coming together can save Pakistan ...
The knowledge he posses & the way he does his research in understanding the problem is an absolute delight to watch & Listen to him .More power to him ❤💥
Mr. Zaidi explains in very simplistic terms the problems in Pakistan. Very impressed. One suggestion, make your studio look professional. Thanks.
Karachi was a tourist holiday destination well into the 1960’s
InshalaChodallah
❤❤❤
Srif punjab pakistan hai🎉🎉
wonderful. Shabbar zaidi sab is great indeed. candid and frank and realistic to the core.
I see this man in his interviews,
Pakistan people s must support him, Steel , railways and aviation.are basics....best wishes to him ,
Lage raho 👍
Such a knowledgable and straightforward person.
Amazing views, excellent analysis, agree with every word explained so well with historic perspectives, though heart touching but make one cry over what we have made of our beloved country. Appreciate Shabbar Sahib's candid opinion 👌👏
Facts and reality based podcast. Such a genuine person hShabbar bhai is. so knowledgeable and learned.
pak studies zindabad
Thanks for exposing the real stories of PIA, Railways and Pakistan steel Mill.
Sabhi pakistani young generation ko Jaidi sahab ko sunna chahiye
Ye podcast sunna chahiye... 🧕👳♀️
Mr Zaidi is very correct.....Same happened to Air India from 2004 to 2014
Pakistaniyon ke aage kyu ro raha hai fir tu
Excellent insight on the burning issues of the country's Economy.
Thought provoking facts by shabbar sb and excellent questions by the raftar team. These are some hard facts on which no one wants to talk. Thank you shabbar sb for enlightenment!!
Great podcast, please bring him back again.
Will all information which is given by you can help to improve situation in Pakistan?
Shabbar Zaidi is a very smart person. make use of him.
Amazing in depth analysis of Pakistan problems by Zaidi Sb. Never heard anyone talking with that much clarity.
He is a true legend. Hats off to him. Salute to you Sir
excellent interview . Zaidi shb is spot on.
Eye opening video for all Pakistani. 😮
Muhajir dushmani by lumber ones and ppp
Nice
What a intellectual he is .
Shabbar Zaidi:)
Karachi dushmani nahi thi ..it was Muhajir dushmani as ppp wanted sindhi vote..
Sabber sahib logistics cost is very important for the development of country's.
Behtareen potcast, Subscribed
Banda Sahi bat krrha hai Apne baron se hmne yehi suna tha
Great insight.
He should be encouraged by the system and Govt.
😊
Shabbat zaidi respected personality
Amazing insights.. Please do more such podcasts
Good discussion! But who will accept their failure & shortcomings?
ڈونیشن میں سے کمیشن کا سلسلہ کم سے کم تیس سال سے جاری ہے... زیدی بھائ سو فیصد درست ہیں.. آفتاب عالم خان کراچی والا
@35:49 probably best high lighted concern in this video. Our charity does not empower receiver instead encourage to be on charity for life.
Right questions lead towards the right answers, I was listening to the same shabbar Zaidi in Junaid Akram podcast but it was ridiculous, but you guys truly needed it.
Excellent analysis
What a Brilliant mind, Mr. Zaidi has explained-the facts very well
Your analysis is very amazing in this podcast Shabbar Sir
Zaidi sahab is teacher.... sir I am very happy listening you ....❤❤❤
Shabbar Zaidi Sahab u advises are very well. But in Pakistan nobody will care.Thanks
Raftar you are doing a great. This is what we need to know. Kudos to you Faisal Waheed Sir.
kash k yh koi PPP ka banda b dekh raha ho
S.z is well versed with the facts, May Allah keep him safe and successful in guiding the people towards awairness.
Kya bat hai Shabbar Zaidi Sahb Kamal Bat cheet..❤❤
Nyc pordcast
Excellent research work by shabber zaidi , But what about Institution like WAPDA , Karachi Shipyard , Cottage / Small Industries . As discussed about PIA during my studies on subject of "means of transportation" it was taught that in airline industry the plane has to be in air for at least 17 hours / day to become a profitable business . regarding Steel & Railway industry these industries are the USA back bone industries since 18th century of its success . Through railway cargo handling charges are cost only 3 times as compare to truck is 5 times , beside the heavy cost of fuel , road and truck mantinence charges , before partition of British India the cheeper means for transportation was through river & canal by boats and launches were used as a means of transportation between ruler and urban areas that can be restore again , as same system is still in use at Britain & Germany .
A request to All Pakistanies
Please please be good citizen , Har ksi ko apna farz nubhana chahie , chahie dosra jo khcuh bhi kr rha ho ..
Please we want to see Pakistan as developed country . Otherwise, we will die as our parents went away.
We need good politicians.
Allah aapko hidayat dee😅😅
Excellent discussion
Shabbar Zaidi you speak truth and feelings of our hearts
Great personality I love this man very clear and loud voice
Zaidi sahib, your analysis was brilliant.
I salute Shabber Zaidi sahab and agree with what he says.
Shabbar Zaidi is so informative and funny at the same time
Excellent summary.But who wants to own the truth here or admit their follies?
Excellent velog
طبقاتی نظام تعلیم کو زیدی بھائ نے سمجھادیا ہے... اردو کو سرکاری سطح پر پاکستان میں نافذ کروانا سیاسی جماعتوں کے منشور میں شامل کروائیں... آفتاب عالم خان کراچی والا
Dear Raftar Team Patreon prr apko boht log support krnay k liay tyaar hojain gay But Please aisay aur mazeed podcast lain jinki qaum ko zarorat hai sunnay ki... Esi personalities ko lain jinko lanay prr log dartey hain...You guys are doing great❤
One of the best interview in my life
ma aik ngo ma gya unhone kaha app hame itni charity lake den us ma se 5% apka. ye baat bilkul such boli shabbar zaidi saab na