The Quest for Guybrush Tall Tale Guide (All Commendations) | Sea of Thieves

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 471

  • @jrsimeon02
    @jrsimeon02 Рік тому +112

    one nice thing about these tall tales - you don't have a random player ship firing at your ship during the middle of the tall tale

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +13

      It is nice that we get to be secluded in our own little world for these Tall Tales. It helps become so much more immersed in them!

    • @noxidus4925
      @noxidus4925 Рік тому +2

      true

    • @negativeTypezero
      @negativeTypezero Рік тому +5

      Remember when tall tales didnt have checkpoints? Jesus that was rough

    • @Captain_greybeard
      @Captain_greybeard 9 місяців тому +2

      Fortunately we now have safer seas :)

    • @Scopedninjapc
      @Scopedninjapc 9 місяців тому +1

      @@Captain_greybeardobviously less rewards but it’s soo chill tbh my pc plays everything on mythic settings at almost 200fps on 1440p res it’s 🔥

  • @cheeseburgermike8406
    @cheeseburgermike8406 11 місяців тому +15

    Thanks man, I came here after ConCon failed to mention the treasure map section. Im glad you went by this in an informative step by step guide.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  11 місяців тому +1

      No problem! Happy to help :)

    • @waldo2600
      @waldo2600 7 місяців тому +1

      Here after concon failed me also

    • @Landon-lc5kd
      @Landon-lc5kd 7 місяців тому +1

      Same

    • @Epik-e-360
      @Epik-e-360 4 місяці тому

      Me 2

  • @Supersell69
    @Supersell69 5 місяців тому +3

    thank you for being the ONLY walkthrough youtuber to correctly and easily show the combination to Stan's safe!

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  5 місяців тому +1

      Happy to help! Enjoy the rest of the tale!

  • @AlostenAlt
    @AlostenAlt Рік тому +24

    In the quest, when you summon the beast, this epic melody comes. Then i was laughing at what i saw!
    Great vid, i salute you

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      We were cracking up as well!

  • @23C_YT
    @23C_YT 10 місяців тому +2

    Bro I wouldn't know what to do or find the journals and memoirs without you, ty so much for these guides I really love them 👍👍👍👍

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  10 місяців тому +1

      Glad you like them! Happy to help :)

  • @wendyhurford8269
    @wendyhurford8269 4 місяці тому +1

    Thank you so much for sharing out in the screen 46:17 I was having so much trouble in that pod

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  4 місяці тому +1

      Happy to help!

    • @wendyhurford8269
      @wendyhurford8269 4 місяці тому +1

      You really helpful you deserve a like and subscribe😁👍

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  4 місяці тому +1

      Aww, cheers! Thanks for the support, pirate!

    • @wendyhurford8269
      @wendyhurford8269 4 місяці тому

      You're welcome

  • @captainbones1964
    @captainbones1964 Рік тому +58

    I felt so bad after pushing Stan into the water and just watching him float away helplessly 😢

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +6

      Haha! Poor guy!

    • @DignifiedArmenianGato
      @DignifiedArmenianGato Рік тому +16

      I hated Stan with every fiber of my being

    • @charliekill88
      @charliekill88 Рік тому

      he deserves it hes so annoying

    • @kelitu8834
      @kelitu8834 Рік тому

      @@DignifiedArmenianGato same

    • @NazoART_
      @NazoART_ Рік тому +4

      If you'll follow the cupboard, you'll see that Stan actually drowned. Cupboard starts sinking and disappear in the ocean. This is so cruel, why Rare making us to do such things, like stealing Pendragon's watch from Olivia or that?

  • @mccheese4413
    @mccheese4413 6 місяців тому +2

    This still took me 7 hours even with this tutuorial 💀 🙏

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  6 місяців тому

      It’s a long one! Glad you completed it :) On to LeChuck!

    • @mccheese4413
      @mccheese4413 6 місяців тому +2

      @@RareThief just finished lechucks lair yall are my lord and savior

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  6 місяців тому

      💙

  • @imtooclueless7202
    @imtooclueless7202 Рік тому +4

    You needed to warn us how scary The Beast was going to be.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Haha! True! We are sorry for the fright it caused.

  • @meinechickennuggets
    @meinechickennuggets 8 місяців тому +2

    The best Channel on the seas for guides! ❤

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  8 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for the kind words, pirate! Cheers!

  • @CaptLogun
    @CaptLogun Рік тому +14

    I won't watch this so I can do a blind playthrough later but I love you two!

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +4

      Haha! It's so much! You are going to love it :) Cheers!

  • @iranassassin72
    @iranassassin72 11 місяців тому +1

    Wow man.. youre so organized and very understandable. Not confusing or anything. Youre great. Thanks

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  11 місяців тому

      Happy to hear that! Cheers!

  • @serdaroran01
    @serdaroran01 Рік тому +7

    you guys are best thanks for every staff

  • @Sledger5
    @Sledger5 Рік тому +3

    I know this is late but thank you for such a straightforward guide. I’m trying to get the shanty it sounds awesome

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      Glad it was helpful! Good luck :) You got this!

    • @Sledger5
      @Sledger5 Рік тому +1

      Thanks have a good day!

    • @Landon-lc5kd
      @Landon-lc5kd 7 місяців тому

      @@RareThief It wouldn’t let me talk to Stan after the memoir and 4th journal spot. He just stood there and looked at me. What should I do?

  • @matrixstyles
    @matrixstyles 7 місяців тому +1

    I aced the commendations thanks to your help. Love your content!

  • @swegotman6857
    @swegotman6857 Рік тому +1

    Iplayad this on an atari 1990 and wow, this realy blows my mind. Now in sea of thiefs its just a loveletter to this amazing game.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      They did such a wonderful job! Knocked it out of the park!

  • @chaunceyandrews5064
    @chaunceyandrews5064 8 місяців тому +1

    49 minute video still took me 5 hours lol. thank you

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  8 місяців тому

      Glad we could help! Have fun in the third chapter against LeChuck!

  • @aquietdragon5671
    @aquietdragon5671 Рік тому +7

    Make sure you're not wearing your skeleton curse...
    There's no vanity chest at the circus tent, so you can't put on the costume, which means walking ALL the way back to your ship...
    Fortunately some of the invisible barriers are gone so you can at least cannon yourself back over to the circus tent in one shot after you change.

  • @captaincrunch93
    @captaincrunch93 11 місяців тому +1

    best video game guid ive came across

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  11 місяців тому

      Cheers! Glad you found it helpful!

  • @Robatron360
    @Robatron360 Рік тому +3

    Thanks for the guide it helped me get all the journals & viewing spots. Well done 👍

  • @Zoey_710
    @Zoey_710 Рік тому +2

    FYI When pushing Stan into the ocean follow through with it all the way, if you push it and then knock on the door of the cabinet it WILL soft lock that accomidation and you'll have to do the begininng again to get back there,
    dont follow in my footsteps, just push the guy into the ocean, dont bother knocking again to see if there's any funny comments.

  • @PVSilchuk
    @PVSilchuk Рік тому +7

    Like always, Rare Thief gives the best guide

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Thanks for the kind words, pirate! Hope it helped!

  • @danielwest4272
    @danielwest4272 4 місяці тому +1

    You were so helpful! Thank you so much!

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  4 місяці тому

      Happy to help! Cheers!

  • @camsmith7827
    @camsmith7827 Рік тому +9

    Thank you

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +3

      You're welcome! Have fun!

  • @Braggzi
    @Braggzi Рік тому +4

    I think the trial of the sword part is way too hard and drawn out.......2nd day and Im already hating this TT... GJ Rare -_- Better nerf this so people can actually enjoy the TT, instead of them rage-quitting over spending way too long time on insult/retort game...

  • @ekoliger
    @ekoliger Рік тому +5

    The best! Thank you you are doing a great job!
    🏴‍☠

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      No problem! Happy to help :) Cheers!

  • @NeTworKiinG
    @NeTworKiinG Рік тому +5

    you always on time.. Thanks

  • @pala120
    @pala120 Рік тому +9

    Thank you men,youare the best

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Cheers! Thanks for the kind words!

  • @xxlordjimixx7539
    @xxlordjimixx7539 Рік тому +2

    Thx for helping me though the forest maze, and with the memories and books. Very well done.

  • @Blue_Anzu
    @Blue_Anzu Рік тому +2

    I got to the part at 21:46 and got a bug where i would walk up to Stan and nothing would happen. Couldn't interact with him either. I tried leaving the area and coming back, and even drowning myself didn't fix it

  • @dafobraced295
    @dafobraced295 Рік тому +5

    Idk what i would do without y’all

  • @computerman900
    @computerman900 Рік тому +2

    Awesome easy to follow in depth guide! 👏👏👏

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Glad it was helpful! Cheers!

  • @shmirie666
    @shmirie666 Рік тому

    Quick shortcut to the top of look out point is going up part way and jump off the side. It'll teleport you to the top

  • @yleniamart
    @yleniamart Рік тому +3

    Thanks for the punctual guide I always look forward to 😁 I forgot to pet the animal how can I get the commendation? do tall tales all over again?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      Happy to help! You'll need to clear the fog again and then work on just the Trial of Thievery. Do the first part of Stan so then you can help Meathook catch The Beast. Good luck!

  • @mgroovetime9528
    @mgroovetime9528 Рік тому

    What's so funny is I think Stan stealed the black pearl from Jack Sparrow.
    Looks like he will be coming back for his ship.

  • @tugez7571
    @tugez7571 Рік тому +2

    TY

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You’re welcome! Happy sailing!

  • @Captdev96g
    @Captdev96g Рік тому +3

    For the stantastic voyage DO NOT KNOCK this will make it not possible to push him off the ledge.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      Is that what is tripping some pirates up? When do you get that option? If you try to interact with it from the front after you lock him in? We've only ever tried interacting from the side right away.

    • @charliekill88
      @charliekill88 Рік тому

      i knocked and it worked still

    • @tord6725
      @tord6725 Рік тому

      Yeah I knocked as I was moving him and now there is no prompt to push him over the edge. He’s sat right there and I can’t tip him over

    • @sploofsoloof
      @sploofsoloof Рік тому

      so what do i do i cant push him off

    • @tord6725
      @tord6725 Рік тому

      @@sploofsoloof do the tall tale all over

  • @kristiansandvold6073
    @kristiansandvold6073 Рік тому +2

    23:47 when you go up to meathook i cant get the 4 option when you speek to him :(

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +3

      Did you choose the fourth dialogue option with Stan twice? You need Stan to tell you that Meathook owns the ship.

    • @kristiansandvold6073
      @kristiansandvold6073 Рік тому

      @@RareThief i am a f..g idiot, thank you

  • @Poofster011
    @Poofster011 8 місяців тому +2

    i know im really late, but the game wont let me present my sword at captain smirks house i left on my first try in the house but now i cant get back in, i left because i hadnt met the ghost pirate yet, i couldnt give responses, he would only tell me to block with my sword for infinity and he locked the door behind me. can i please get an answer?

    • @Poofster011
      @Poofster011 8 місяців тому

      i found out its because it saved at the start of the circus...

  • @paeron585
    @paeron585 27 днів тому +2

    Thx a lot bro

  • @maxvitale7159
    @maxvitale7159 Рік тому

    Make sure to sit on the 9th memoir spot in the sword dudes hut before leaving it, the door locks after and i could not get it.

  • @vengefulgaming2368
    @vengefulgaming2368 Рік тому

    Anybody find it funny how they charged people for the chef and circus outfit with the mighty cutlas now we can earn them lol

  • @awilchesss4538
    @awilchesss4538 Рік тому +1

    Hello, quick question, in the trial of sword do u have to go to every single place marked in where to find fighta, ur can i just stay where murray is? Ty for these guides btw

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      You can stay in one spot and wait for the cooldown if you want. The cooldown is about 5 minutes.

  • @jacoblowe3203
    @jacoblowe3203 Рік тому

    New Items - Now in Stock!
    • Mad Monkey Ship Collection
    • Mad Monkey Ship’s Crest
    • Mad Monkey Weapon Bundle
    • Mad Monkey Concertina
    • Guybrush Costume Set
    • Elaine Costume Set
    • Carla Costume Set
    • Spiffy Pet
    • Paradise Garden Cutlass (free!)
    • Sea of Sands Sailor Bundle (Microsoft, Xbox and Steam Stores only)

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Aye, the Pirate Emporium is incredible this month!

  • @patrickmccoy635
    @patrickmccoy635 Рік тому +1

    lost the battle against the ghost pirate because i didnt have the correct dialog, now i cant even duel anyone and i cant learn anymore insults

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +3

      None of the other fighting spots around the island work for you? There is a cooldown of about five minutes for each spot.

  • @DatzBunz
    @DatzBunz Рік тому +2

    Fun tall tale for sure. Loved this one other than the insult and retort part which my group wasn't too thrilled about. Best part was the time trial. Broke the 18 second mark !

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      That’s fast! Bravo!

    • @charliekill88
      @charliekill88 Рік тому

      aww cmon man the insult sword fighting was funny

  • @B1g5t1nk
    @B1g5t1nk Рік тому +1

    im redownloading the game tonight, ive been getting a lavenderbeard for the past 3 days

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Good luck! Hope you get to try it out!

    • @ErenJDwyer
      @ErenJDwyer Рік тому +1

      you have to log out and log back in in the main menu

  • @solarfox1542
    @solarfox1542 Рік тому +1

    When do you think tall tale three will come out for this

  • @alineo07
    @alineo07 Рік тому +4

    thanks

  • @blackzack1810
    @blackzack1810 10 місяців тому +3

    In my case, Meathook just have 3 options, is there something that i have to triggere before? I replay my Tall tales cuz I forgot to tickle the Beast, and I open up his door before first checkpoint :(

  • @charliekill88
    @charliekill88 Рік тому +3

    BEST TALL TALE TO DATE
    also thanks for helping me finish the trial of thievery, i was stuck on that

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      It is incredible! No problem :)

  • @fireandice9738
    @fireandice9738 Рік тому

    The parrot is the Beast I laughed at how adorable it was

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      It was so cute and so funny!

  • @chriscole2057
    @chriscole2057 Рік тому +1

    Big thanks 💯

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      No problem 👍 Happy to help!

  • @Voxler660
    @Voxler660 Рік тому

    I had finished the tall tale to the defeating ribbsy part and thought ill complete the rest tomorrow, now when i resume the tall tale, after bob and lechuck speak their lines, my ship gets teleported to the monkey island area as usual, but my screen is completely greyish. I can hear my ship and the music but can't see anything. I couldnt find anything online so im just gonna leave this comment here

  • @Raxcooner
    @Raxcooner Рік тому +1

    Ngl the fettuccine twins look like mario and luigi

  • @gooses___
    @gooses___ Рік тому

    Mr Stan the salesman doesn't want to speak to me so I had to restart

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Oh that’s weird. When? The first time or after Meathook?

    • @gooses___
      @gooses___ Рік тому

      @@RareThief I spoke to meathook then I went back to speak back to Stan and the option to speak didn't come up

    • @joshwilliams8298
      @joshwilliams8298 Рік тому

      Meathook I can’t ask him the 4th option it ain’t there 😂😂

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Did you ask Stan who owns the Headless Monkey? You need to ask Stan two questions back to back after you talk to him about the four ships.

  • @GabeAceves
    @GabeAceves 8 місяців тому

    Nice job explaining that you had to use every retort and insult for a commendation real helpful 🤣🤣🤣🤦🏼‍♂️

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  8 місяців тому

      You should unlock it by default. It’s impossible to continue the Tall Tale without using every one. Did it not unlock for you by the end of the Trial?

  • @AlexandruCarjan
    @AlexandruCarjan Рік тому +2

    The sword fighting is THE DUMBEST EVER thing they've done

    • @DoctorTex
      @DoctorTex Рік тому

      It's more of a puzzle than a fight, which is in line with the Monkey Island series.

  • @c_olton
    @c_olton 7 місяців тому

    whenever i go to the sign to the log that moves up so i can fight ribsy, there’s no interaction button and i have the commendation for all of the insults and the other things. any idea why?

  • @ch0zbine
    @ch0zbine Рік тому +1

    i cant pick up the idol but it is there in the opened safe

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Hmm…that’s really weird. Maybe try dying and then trying to pick it up again?

  • @w3bbbz
    @w3bbbz 4 місяці тому

    For the Spectacular Superstar commendation, do i have to beat it within 25 seconds in the first try?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  4 місяці тому +1

      No, you can try as many times as you want.

  • @DaniZero3
    @DaniZero3 Рік тому +1

    Thanks!

  • @hellawave9095
    @hellawave9095 6 місяців тому

    is that first accommodation not a thing anymore???

  • @ashdsf_
    @ashdsf_ Рік тому +1

    I like how it broke so I can’t push stan

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      So you got him to step inside and then locked him in? You don’t see a prompt on the side of the cupboard?

    • @ashdsf_
      @ashdsf_ Рік тому

      @@RareThief no it won’t appear

    • @catherinedenman8859
      @catherinedenman8859 Рік тому

      I was only able to push him once. After that the prompt doesn’t show up. Also, there is a prompt after the first shove knocking on the doors. I don’t know if this is why I couldn’t push him into the water or not. 😅

  • @Chimera936
    @Chimera936 Місяць тому

    do you get to keep all insults and retorts you have learned? :P

  • @Ghorrn809
    @Ghorrn809 Рік тому

    The 0.01 percent that has the painting of guybrush, cherish this moment for its going to fade away and when you have it on your ship in about a month your going to be looked at as a tall tale lover

    • @dawidscheffler7152
      @dawidscheffler7152 Рік тому

      I'm already a "tall tale lover" not enough to hang the paintings in the little space I have in my sloop but, the idol and action figures are welcome additions

    • @DoctorTex
      @DoctorTex Рік тому

      Nothing wrong with being a tall tale lover.

  • @InSolitude917
    @InSolitude917 5 місяців тому

    I am unable to get the potion from Corina at the end, she just says do you bring news

    • @TuanAnh-eo1gu
      @TuanAnh-eo1gu 5 місяців тому

      I have the same error as you. Is there any way to fit?

  • @clubultrascz
    @clubultrascz 6 місяців тому

    Yo im so stupid i just dont know what to do im stuck on the sword trial or how its called cuz i only won 1 fight from 8 and i dont have 10 of the talks i need what should i do?😂

  • @garension8653
    @garension8653 6 місяців тому

    THAT'S WHY HE IS THE GOAT!!! THE GOOOAT!!!!

  • @pmcg2189
    @pmcg2189 9 місяців тому

    45:40 i have read Elaine’s book but the hidden trigger isn’t appearing

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  9 місяців тому

      The trigger for the bridge? You need to make sure you completed all the Insult Sword Fights necessary.

    • @pmcg2189
      @pmcg2189 9 місяців тому

      @@RareThiefsorry😂 I realised this earlier and I was stressing, amazing video tho u deserve a follow

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  9 місяців тому +1

      No problem! Cheers!

  • @DoctorTex
    @DoctorTex Рік тому

    Would I be able to just go to where the treasure huntery statue is if I already know it? Or do I have to go through all that again?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You can use a Checkpoint so you don't have to do it again. Have you used those before?

    • @DoctorTex
      @DoctorTex Рік тому

      @@RareThief I meant on repeat playthroughs. If I go straight to the statue after clearing the fog, will I be able to dig it up?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Oh, you need to get each set of directions along the way last we checked.

  • @AMV10069
    @AMV10069 9 місяців тому

    I didn’t get the circus superstar costume (last commendation) for some reason help???!?

  • @haongenius1982
    @haongenius1982 Рік тому

    DO NOT attempt to push stan into the water while his dialogue is still going on. I did it, the tall tale bugged out and I didnt get the commandation.i tried restarting with the checkpoint but now the thing and stan are not there at all. guess i have to start all over again

  • @zsebe9320
    @zsebe9320 Рік тому

    i cant even speak with Stan, he is just looking at me, but i've already done the other 2 quest and I even restarted the game and sat down on that barrel and ive aleady picked up the book next to him. What should I do? Start the whole thing over?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Did you interact with all four ship signs to get him to talk to you already?

    • @zsebe9320
      @zsebe9320 Рік тому

      @@RareThief in the bay yes, but he just lookin me. My internet went off 1 time, it can be the problem maybe and it bugged him or idk

    • @zsebe9320
      @zsebe9320 Рік тому

      I mean, i couldnt even ask him about the ships, just examine them

  • @cfeur
    @cfeur Рік тому

    completed everything up until you have to return to Corina for the potion. She only asks if I have any news... finally gave up and left. Now it says I have no checkpoints... I was basically done. :(

  • @FMGaming
    @FMGaming Рік тому +1

    The Murray and the fighting thing is so stupid like how am I supposed to know which insult to use… comebacks I get insults not at all

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      If you forget which one to use, you can check out the description or this article here: rarethief.com/sea-of-thieves-insult-sword-fighting-insults-and-retorts/

    • @solarfox1542
      @solarfox1542 Рік тому

      I just chose random insults

    • @DoctorTex
      @DoctorTex Рік тому

      You learn insults and retorts via fighting. It's okay if you lose, you're still learning more quips. When using an Insult, most likely they'll have a good retort.
      It's better to treat it more like a puzzle than a fight.

  • @Igloojames
    @Igloojames Рік тому

    When i knock on thats guys door he just shut the door on me and they is no option to give the sword to him

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Did you do the circus to get 404 Pieces o’ Eight yet?

  • @powdered-toastman8082
    @powdered-toastman8082 7 місяців тому

    How do you get to the path to the circus you just cut from stans to that spot

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  7 місяців тому

      From Stan's, go North back across the bridge and walk along the path a bit. The circus will be on your right to the East.

  • @harryaccorsi787
    @harryaccorsi787 2 місяці тому

    I am stuck on the meat hook there is no fourth option to talk to him about the monkey head

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  2 місяці тому

      Did you already do everything with Stan?

  • @ChrisJD75
    @ChrisJD75 6 місяців тому

    I did everything and got all the quest, even “The Quest for Guy Brush” commendation but didnt get the costume? Whys that

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  6 місяців тому

      Recently? The costume was added after the Tall Tale initially came out. It doesn’t unlock retroactively.

    • @ChrisJD75
      @ChrisJD75 6 місяців тому

      @@RareThief so I have to do the tale all over again? With the commendations also?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  6 місяців тому

      No, just complete it again. No need to 100%.

  • @Luke33324
    @Luke33324 Рік тому

    I had the sword out when I went to captain smirk and he wouldn’t let me in, is there a fix for this

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Do you have the 404 Pieces o’ Eight from the Circus?

    • @Luke33324
      @Luke33324 Рік тому

      @@RareThief I didn’t, I found out the next day lol

  • @M..J..Pinkyy
    @M..J..Pinkyy Рік тому

    I don’t get the last part at £48:20

  • @GamerGirlAddict
    @GamerGirlAddict 11 місяців тому

    6:47 i dont have the signed sea charts what do i do how do i get it

  • @artattack5420
    @artattack5420 Рік тому

    Doing the Trial of the Sword. When I was doing the insults, my game crashed. Came back and i cannot get the lanterns to trigger. I cannot get the last insult. Am I missing something?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You rejoined or used a Checkpoint?

    • @artattack5420
      @artattack5420 Рік тому

      @@RareThief I used a checkpoint

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You probably need to do the Insult Sword Fighting tutorial again. There’s no Checkpoint after the tutorial. Once you meet with Captain Smirk again, you can trigger the lanterns.

  • @MrBlackKoolAid
    @MrBlackKoolAid Рік тому

    When me and my cousin finished the quest we went back home and we didn’t get a reward. Do we have to go to a specific place to claim it or? We were confused and we turned the game off

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      That's odd. You should automatically unlock it when you travel back through the portal.

    • @MrBlackKoolAid
      @MrBlackKoolAid Рік тому

      @@RareThief do you mind telling me what was your reward?

  • @leondipinto2624
    @leondipinto2624 9 місяців тому

    I died and the game bugged, i couldnt move or do anything, even press to leave the game was unabled.

  • @robya8513
    @robya8513 Рік тому

    I seem to always get the insult wrong against the ghosts. I don't know why. Can you perhaps give me some tips?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      If you see a notification saying you learned an Insult, you won't know the Retort just yet so it's okay if you get it wrong. If you have learned the Retort, you can reference the description in this video or this article to find the matching Insult/Retort pair: rarethief.com/sea-of-thieves-insult-sword-fighting-insults-and-retorts/ If you make an Insult and lose that is okay because you are learning the Retort. You need to learn them all to make progress :)

    • @robya8513
      @robya8513 Рік тому

      @@RareThief Thank you for the quick response. I didn't expect a reply that soon so thanks for the help 🙏. Hope you have a good day my fellow pirate :D

  • @UltimateGamerHub942
    @UltimateGamerHub942 Рік тому

    I cant get past the sword part where you block is there something youre suppose to say or what

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Just make sure you block all three swings. You should only have to do that twice before Smirk teaches you an insult.

    • @UltimateGamerHub942
      @UltimateGamerHub942 Рік тому

      @@RareThief oh ok thx

    • @dreoliraviolii
      @dreoliraviolii Рік тому

      @@RareThiefmine is still stuck on the blocking stage. Both my crewmate and I did the blocking 2 times in a row and it’s still going back and forth. No dialogue.

  • @ATKSKILLXB
    @ATKSKILLXB 2 місяці тому

    Any clues as to why stan just won’t give me the 2nd dialogue option?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Місяць тому

      So you inspected all the ship signs, asked him the last option, and then asked him the last option again?

    • @ATKSKILLXB
      @ATKSKILLXB Місяць тому

      @ Yeah I had to do the quest over from start three times for him to finally give the dialogue, I also came from cons vid lol but I’m using the rest of yours to finish the other tall tales when I’m able (I’m doing sunken pearl now at 3am the grind doesn’t stop when you have your spark relit)

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Місяць тому +1

      Oh no! Darn, well glad you finally got past it! Good luck on The Sunken Pearl! That is a beast of a Tall Tale.

    • @ATKSKILLXB
      @ATKSKILLXB Місяць тому

      @ I’m excited to do them all, even the games own ones I need to complete multiple times to get the comm :) day one returned!

  • @X83ZT
    @X83ZT Рік тому

    for some reason i didn’t get the fourth option about the headless monkey if anyone could tell me what i did wrong that would be nice cheers!

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You talked to Stan twice? You need to choose the last option once before to get him to tell you about the ship.

    • @X83ZT
      @X83ZT Рік тому

      @@RareThiefthank you

  • @twozzleweb
    @twozzleweb Рік тому

    i cant get the second option dialogue from stan, i can ask him about what is cheapest but i can ask him about outbidding.....

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Hmm...that's odd. And you've talked to him about all four ships?

    • @twozzleweb
      @twozzleweb Рік тому

      @@RareThief yes i read all for signs and spoke to him, its no longer an option to ask about the ships so its confirmed ive done it. I had to start the tall tale again... just doesnt move past that option so i couldn't speak to meathead. Great guide as always though 👍4

  • @RichardBarclay
    @RichardBarclay Рік тому

    I missed the captain smirk interior memoir spot and stantastic voyage, is there any way to get them without restarting the whole tale?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      No, not that we know of. You’ll have to start it up again and work towards those two in particular.

    • @RichardBarclay
      @RichardBarclay Рік тому

      @@RareThief it's frustrating that you have to follow a guide on your first playthrough if you want all the commendations in one run, rather than being able to wait until just before the end and back tracking, especially since I have on more than 1 occasion been kicked off for inactivity for looking at a guide (why is that a thing on these single-player-friendly tall tales anyway?)

  • @WaywardTitan
    @WaywardTitan Рік тому

    My game kept glitching it wouldn't let me pet the bird or push him in the water

  • @hyperboi4077
    @hyperboi4077 Рік тому

    Nice I did all of this and for some reason the green portal is nowhere to be found to sail out.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Hmm, even after you jump onto your ship? You gave Guybrush the potion and his whole cutscene ended?

    • @hyperboi4077
      @hyperboi4077 Рік тому

      @@RareThief had to do it again but the commendations saved so it wasn’t that much of a set back. Thank You for the guide!

    • @lazychaos2707
      @lazychaos2707 Рік тому +1

      I had the same thing happen. I just sank my ship then the portal spawned

    • @hyperboi4077
      @hyperboi4077 Рік тому +1

      @@lazychaos2707 had to play through it again with a friend anyways. I’ll keep that in mind though if the game bugs and the portal is not there for whatever reason.

  • @reptile33x3
    @reptile33x3 Рік тому

    How do you get a faster time for the circus stunt? Also any advice is appreciated.

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому +1

      Make sure you have the cannon aligned before you start your run. Also, you can save a lot of time between the third bell and the cannon. Try to interact with the zipline from further away than you think you can. You should be able to skip a whole platform by grabbing onto the zipline sooner.

  • @wardenofnothing5368
    @wardenofnothing5368 Рік тому

    I have a problem i sat on every memoir spot az least 4 times still somehow one is missing

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Hmm...that's so weird. We haven't heard about that issue. You are sitting down and waiting for the whole memoir to speak?

    • @wardenofnothing5368
      @wardenofnothing5368 Рік тому

      @@RareThief yes of course

  • @Laloven
    @Laloven 9 місяців тому

    When I talk to Meathook, I don't show me the fourth option

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  9 місяців тому

      Did you talk to Stan twice?

  • @gntl8741
    @gntl8741 Рік тому

    when o go talk with meathook its just show me 3 thing to talk with him about not 4 can somebody help i did every thing i dont know

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      You asked Stan about the cheapest options AND who owns The Headless Monkey? You need to ask choose two different dialogue options back to back.

  • @Zykobuster
    @Zykobuster Рік тому

    I dont know what is wrong but i cant push stan into the water, is there something specific i need to do after locking him in?

    • @RareThief
      @RareThief  Рік тому

      Hmm…once you lock him in you should be able to interact with the side after he realizes he’s locked in.

    • @Zykobuster
      @Zykobuster Рік тому

      I tried, it doesn't give me the option, probably just a glitch though

    • @ChrisC-bc8od
      @ChrisC-bc8od Рік тому

      Same

  • @its_splash6043
    @its_splash6043 7 місяців тому +1

    Bro its been 5 hours i cant pass the insult part

    • @KingNate22
      @KingNate22 6 місяців тому

      Fr I want somebody to make a video on where every Insult part is