Butterfly era was complicated because of the divorce and also because people started doubting about her voice and her potencial, and as we all know confidence on stage is everything, but the whisper tone are everything in this era! ♥️🦋✨
TEOM era, especially in 2006, had a lot of tired vocals, you can easily identify watching the Adventures of Mimi with the songs: Vision of Love, My All, those belts sounded like sick a little bit, but the whistle, she killed them! ♥️
But I can’t get off the credits she deserved, the 2004/2005 performances she was killing it, like the Blueprint performances of We Belong Together, Vision of Love and etc. That performances was perfectly executed ✨
Yees but tired only in the beginin of the tour, but 2005 was perfect also the beginin of 2006 like the grammy performance and the end of the tour 🙌but butterfly was tired on every years, i think the vocals were perfect too♥️
Pls don't be mad, just saying, but for B4 you should use Perth 1998, for Eb5 u should use to FLAAAYYYYYYYYYY from David Letterman, and E5 from My All 1997, just saying
While Butterfly era is one of my favorite eras because i really love her soulful and sexy tone, i should admit that TEOM 2005 mid belts were stronger and more consistent. 2005 as a whole was a really good year for her voice. But she "ruined" it in 2006 with TAOM Tour. That tour (along with Rainbow and All The Hits Tour, which are totally unrelated to the video, but i just want to mention them) should've never existed.
I agree that TAOM Tour sucked with her voice and got a lot of tired vocals, but in my opinion, the Rainbow Tour was very good, she gave looks, good changes in her runs and riffs that allowed she to sing the songs, she was very smart because she adapted the songs to her voice btw. 🌈✨
Butterfly album is my favorite album of all time, but I think the tour itself shouldve never be existed. She was super tired phisically and mentally in that era. And (maybe) because the raspiness and lipping in that tour made public assumption about her voice
Stop to judge everything because of the voice condition, i was in the Teom tour new york and was unbelievable good and amazing, not because of the voice she is just a human omg how lunatics🤦🏽♂️
Technically speaking Butterfly was superio in every way. However, there are some aspects of the teom era that allowed her more soulful sultry sound to come throug much more, and she was much more confident of a person in teom which really showed through her stage presence. It’s not all about vocals.
They sounded a little bit identical, but the Butterfly one is very husky and raspy as Mariah’s vocals on that time. The TEOM one you can see her hand “controlling” her runs, she hits the same note and in the same time that her hand makes a movement. ✨
I'm just thankful that I got to live in the same lifetime where we literally got to experience this womans evolution not only lyrically, musically but also spiritually. Every album is a piece of her life. Thank u #mimi #lambily
A4 - TEOM (resonance!!!) Bb4 - Butterfly (great vibrato) Bb4 - TEOM (more stability and support) B4 - TEOM (stronger and more powerful) C5 - TEOM (one of her best C5 ‘s ever) C5 - TEOM (i love her husky resonanting tone) C#5 - TEOM (i think it was little bit more comfortable) D5 - Butterfly (great tone, support and emotional quality) D5 - Butterfly (she sounded almost like DAYDREAM! Amazing!) Eb5 - Butterfly (TEOM was very good, but Butterfly was still little bit better) Eb5 - TEOM (personal choice, i adore Fly like a bird song, its so emotional and powerful...!) Eb5 - Butterfly (more ease and support) E5 - Butterfly (her tone...!) E5 - Butterfly (absolutely lovely vibrato!) E5 - TEOM (i love her growls, but i have to say both of them were not so good, Butterfly and TEOM was throaty) F5 - Butterfly (it was awesome peaked supported F5!) F5 - TEOM (Butterfly was incredible, but TEOM had little bit more control) F#5 - Butterfly (great raspy high belt!) F#5 - Butterfly (one of her best performances!!!)
People like to act as if the Butterfly era was the "downfall" of Mariah vocally and I've always felt that was a load of crap. Her voice did change, but her ability to do everything was still there. Mind you, her voice was still healthy enough to support her upper belts. Not the greatest era of her voice, but certainly better than TEOM era. TEOM era had really standout moments, but only because she brought back her confidence to the stage. Her voice in 2005, compared to the Charmbracelet era, was truly on the decline and not very consistent.
‼️My opinion‼️ A4 - TEOM (more stability) Bb4 - Butterfly (I adore her tone here) Bb4 - Butterfly (vibrato) B4 - TEOM (I think it was better supported) C5 - Tie. Butterfly charming vibrato, TEOM fantastic resonance. Point each! C5 - TEOM (more resonanting, better tone) C#5 - Tie. Both eras effortless. Point each! D5 - TEOM (more ease and resonance) D5 - Butterfly (more comfortable, very nice belts!) Eb5 - Butterfly (same reason + more pleasant tone) Eb5 - Tie. Both performances were amazing. Very emotional and soulful. Point each! Eb5 - Butterfly (so much easier, awesome!) E5 - Butterfly (more support, TEOM was a little bit throaty) E5 - Butterfly (supported + very good vibrato) E5 - TEOM (stronger and more powerful) F5 - Butterfly (TEOM was almost a voice crack, Butterfly had a lot more control) F5 - TEOM (wow that was beautiful! Less raspy and with better technique!) F#5 - Butterfly (supported) F#5 - Butterfly (What a wonderful performance! Amazing!) ‼️RESULTS‼️ Butterfly: 13 points TEOM: 9 points 💋BUTTERFLY WON💋
The different is TEOMRiah using more growls while ButterflyRiah still use the copied of DaydreamRiah, that's why TEOMRiah had stronger high note while ButterflyRiah cracked it because she wanna does the high note spesifically like the Daydream era
The one thing TEOMriah would have is confidence, she was already sick in some 2005 performances like Live 8. Butterfly in all aspects especially if we consider 1997 😋
It's complicated with these eras. Technically 1997-1998 had better vocals since her decline was just starting. However, she was still singing like she had in 1995-1996 and was adjusting, which made her vocal change very apparent. With 2005-2006, her voice was in better condition for most of 2005 than the butterfly era, but her singing style was more accommodated to her voice then. She didn't have the same confidence she had in the 90's, so she held back in some ways. I would say both are great overall. Butterfly takes the edge.
Aku suka lagu meriah carey dari umur 14 tahun,sekarang aku umur 29. Tiap hari aku mendengar lagu itu itu aja. Yang tidak pernah bosan aku dengar lagu I still belive
I love butterfly but teom really dose beat it in a vocal battle I don’t really like the tone but that’s me but the confidence and consistency dose it let’s not bash either album there both amazing 🤩
The F5 and F#5 of TEOM are both live! You can clearly see the difference of live and the studio version, the BET Blueprint performances of 2005 are all LIVE, you can hear the rasp of the F#5 in It’s Like That, you have to review your statements dahling. ♥️🦋✨
![Mariah Carey’s "Butterfly" [LIVE on Letterman 1997] - SINGER REACTS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/O3e4I2BkVNM/mqdefault.jpg)
butterfly = tone
teom = confident
Shepherd's Chapel Network !!!!!!! Pastor Murray is an Anointed Servant of GOD who teaches the Word of GOD with Authority!!!!!!!
Her voice sounds more resonant during TEOM, TEOM whistles are perfect too, but butterfly whispers omg
3:35 is more resonant than 3:26? Sure 😒🤢🤮
@@musicboxtour5854 Oh honey please we all know 2006riah was tired asff! 2005riah can literally sing butterflyriah under the table period
@@onepleiadian K SURE
@@musicboxtour5854 why you hating on TEOM lmao it's one of my favorite eras
@@moaiaera63 but its not for me
Butterfly era was complicated because of the divorce and also because people started doubting about her voice and her potencial, and as we all know confidence on stage is everything, but the whisper tone are everything in this era! ♥️🦋✨
And in Sydney on Butterfly World Tour she was stunning, she performed great belts, great whistles, I mean, this is all so underrated 🦋✨
Where you from?
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy I’m Brazilian, so I’m from Brazil
@@augustoleal9382 sou brasileiro também🙈
Butterfly: Tone, Techniques and Agility
TEOM: Confidence, Resonance and Growls
Both eras are amazing and beautiful
Butterfly has more resonance
These eras are so similar, Butterfly sounds like a tired Daydream and TEOM sounded like a tired Charmbracelet.
TEOM era, especially in 2006, had a lot of tired vocals, you can easily identify watching the Adventures of Mimi with the songs: Vision of Love, My All, those belts sounded like sick a little bit, but the whistle, she killed them! ♥️
But I can’t get off the credits she deserved, the 2004/2005 performances she was killing it, like the Blueprint performances of We Belong Together, Vision of Love and etc. That performances was perfectly executed ✨
@@augustoleal9382 2004 was charmbracelet era, but i'm agree that Teom was more consistent and the 2006 grammy's performance too
Yees but tired only in the beginin of the tour, but 2005 was perfect also the beginin of 2006 like the grammy performance and the end of the tour 🙌but butterfly was tired on every years, i think the vocals were perfect too♥️
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 yes I know 2004 was Charm, but the TEOM album was released on Jan 1st, so it was like 2004/2005
Pretty sure it was released in May.
Y'all H03s better wait until someone release Butterfly World Tour Tokyo first night and every note there will defeat Teom 😌
Totally agreed! 🦋✨
First night might even compete with daydream
@@TheBritneyMinajSpearsQuartz true af
@@TheBritneyMinajSpearsQuartz dare i say she hit like at least 5 F#5 from that date
@@musicboxtour5854 k
Pls don't be mad, just saying, but for B4 you should use Perth 1998, for Eb5 u should use to FLAAAYYYYYYYYYY from David Letterman, and E5 from My All 1997, just saying
yes, butterflyriah served a lot 🦋✨
While Butterfly era is one of my favorite eras because i really love her soulful and sexy tone, i should admit that TEOM 2005 mid belts were stronger and more consistent. 2005 as a whole was a really good year for her voice. But she "ruined" it in 2006 with TAOM Tour. That tour (along with Rainbow and All The Hits Tour, which are totally unrelated to the video, but i just want to mention them) should've never existed.
I agree that TAOM Tour sucked with her voice and got a lot of tired vocals, but in my opinion, the Rainbow Tour was very good, she gave looks, good changes in her runs and riffs that allowed she to sing the songs, she was very smart because she adapted the songs to her voice btw. 🌈✨
Butterfly album is my favorite album of all time, but I think the tour itself shouldve never be existed. She was super tired phisically and mentally in that era. And (maybe) because the raspiness and lipping in that tour made public assumption about her voice
Stop to judge everything because of the voice condition, i was in the Teom tour new york and was unbelievable good and amazing, not because of the voice she is just a human omg how lunatics🤦🏽♂️
Better than daydreamriah 4:25 it was more than perfect, eargasm. I'm in loop.
Agrião
@@flyingbaloon6358 ? Q'é isso?
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy agree****
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy celular doido oxe
@@flyingbaloon6358 lol
Butterfly's C5-D5 is way raspier than her E5-F#5 tbh
True Lmaoaoo
Wrong 😹they were grainier
It's how nodules works tho.
Probably she mixed more on upper belt
Caution vs rainbow might be good
Yes, please!
mkayy
Don't do that to rainbow, it's bulliyng
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy it’s okay dahling✨💅🏻
@@rainbowriah you’ll be perfect, I prefer you, but don’t tell it to cautionriah 🌈🦋✨
Her technique changed a lot. She sounds more natural in butterfly era and more technical in TEOM
I think TEOM was really more consistent (except for the tour)than butterfly but butterfly's runs and melismas are everything 🤧❤
Technically speaking Butterfly was superio in every way. However, there are some aspects of the teom era that allowed her more soulful sultry sound to come throug much more, and she was much more confident of a person in teom which really showed through her stage presence. It’s not all about vocals.
why did her C#5s sound somewhat identical ?
Time travel ✨
They sounded a little bit identical, but the Butterfly one is very husky and raspy as Mariah’s vocals on that time. The TEOM one you can see her hand “controlling” her runs, she hits the same note and in the same time that her hand makes a movement. ✨
Because she is the same person lmao
@@axelito6342 lol i had no idea
Butterfly >>>>>
@@butterflyera4628 u too-
I'm just thankful that I got to live in the same lifetime where we literally got to experience this womans evolution not only lyrically, musically but also spiritually. Every album is a piece of her life. Thank u #mimi
#lambily
Could you do e=mc2 vs memoirs of an imperfect angel next?
Of course Memoirs would win
not an Einstein set up
make Einstein vs Rainbow instead
Memoirs will wash TEOM2😂
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 yes
Teomriah was good in 2005 but in 2006😬
Agree
A4 - TEOM (resonance!!!)
Bb4 - Butterfly (great vibrato)
Bb4 - TEOM (more stability and support)
B4 - TEOM (stronger and more powerful)
C5 - TEOM (one of her best C5 ‘s ever)
C5 - TEOM (i love her husky resonanting tone)
C#5 - TEOM (i think it was little bit more comfortable)
D5 - Butterfly (great tone, support and emotional quality)
D5 - Butterfly (she sounded almost like DAYDREAM! Amazing!)
Eb5 - Butterfly (TEOM was very good, but Butterfly was still little bit better)
Eb5 - TEOM (personal choice, i adore Fly like a bird song, its so emotional and powerful...!)
Eb5 - Butterfly (more ease and support)
E5 - Butterfly (her tone...!)
E5 - Butterfly (absolutely lovely vibrato!)
E5 - TEOM (i love her growls, but i have to say both of them were not so good, Butterfly and TEOM was throaty)
F5 - Butterfly (it was awesome peaked supported F5!)
F5 - TEOM (Butterfly was incredible, but TEOM had little bit more control)
F#5 - Butterfly (great raspy high belt!)
F#5 - Butterfly (one of her best performances!!!)
Mid Belts
Butterfly = Teom
Upper Belt
Butterfly >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Teom
This
upper belt
teom: non existent
@@whenxmascums true 🔪
Mariah even in Butterfly Era supported up to F#5. TEOMRiah mostly didn't support above E5.
1:11 that C5 😍😭
People like to act as if the Butterfly era was the "downfall" of Mariah vocally and I've always felt that was a load of crap. Her voice did change, but her ability to do everything was still there. Mind you, her voice was still healthy enough to support her upper belts. Not the greatest era of her voice, but certainly better than TEOM era.
TEOM era had really standout moments, but only because she brought back her confidence to the stage. Her voice in 2005, compared to the Charmbracelet era, was truly on the decline and not very consistent.
People expected the excellence that she had in Daydream.
*I* *Love* *Teom* *But* *of* *course*
*Butterfly* *is* *a* *superior*
butterfly’s tone alone>>>>>>>>>> constipation of mimi
LMFAOAOAO
constipation of mimi 💀! how tf did you you think of that?
are you a butterfly stan 🦋? (me too)
@@butterflyera765 i'm a butterfy stan too
@@musicboxtour5854 HEYYYY😙!
People be disrespecting TEOM in the comments. No blaspheming will be accepted.
‼️My opinion‼️
A4 - TEOM (more stability)
Bb4 - Butterfly (I adore her tone here)
Bb4 - Butterfly (vibrato)
B4 - TEOM (I think it was better supported)
C5 - Tie. Butterfly charming vibrato, TEOM fantastic resonance. Point each!
C5 - TEOM (more resonanting, better tone)
C#5 - Tie. Both eras effortless. Point each!
D5 - TEOM (more ease and resonance)
D5 - Butterfly (more comfortable, very nice belts!)
Eb5 - Butterfly (same reason + more pleasant tone)
Eb5 - Tie. Both performances were amazing. Very emotional and soulful. Point each!
Eb5 - Butterfly (so much easier, awesome!)
E5 - Butterfly (more support, TEOM was a little bit throaty)
E5 - Butterfly (supported + very good vibrato)
E5 - TEOM (stronger and more powerful)
F5 - Butterfly (TEOM was almost a voice crack, Butterfly had a lot more control)
F5 - TEOM (wow that was beautiful! Less raspy and with better technique!)
F#5 - Butterfly (supported)
F#5 - Butterfly (What a wonderful performance! Amazing!)
‼️RESULTS‼️
Butterfly: 13 points
TEOM: 9 points
💋BUTTERFLY WON💋
Hi, i'm butterflyriah, thank you so much for this 🥺
Rainbow vs. Glitter next!
yess
mkayyy ofc i win
Love the intro. Gutted you didn't use the Eb5 from Butterfly in Sydney
Which one? The FLAAYYYYY one? That's lipped
That lord knows in Germany in 2005 was everything tho
Perth is more amazing
The different is TEOMRiah using more growls while ButterflyRiah still use the copied of DaydreamRiah, that's why TEOMRiah had stronger high note while ButterflyRiah cracked it because she wanna does the high note spesifically like the Daydream era
TEOM cracked more lol
Butterfly 🦋
Nah, in teom era Mimi didn't care how she sounded. She was like "Fck this sh!t, I'm doing me." "I'm a legend and already gave enough."
Easy. Butterfly.
Sydney show alone >>>
Agree
We also need Perth 1998 full concert 👁👁
@@musicboxtour5854 I don't know! Suddenly I can't read.gif haha. Couldn't make it into my house yet :S
@@theroof6538 👁👄👁 i will wait
@@musicboxtour5854 so happy you’re recognizing butterfly true worth 🥰🦋✨
*Y'all using "The Constipation of Mimi" insult because I made it*
Also Butterfly Won
K?
you can't even belt-
I only heard you belt on I Want To Know What Love Is and Obsessed -,-
@@me.iammariah9051 you rely on autotune daahhling
They took the same effort. I just believe Teom was less consistent and connected overall vocally because of her confidence and tired voice.
Teom was better vocals on my opinion.... Way more resonance and support
Mariah Vocally, I'll always choose the Butterfly Era.
❤️my favorite ERAS
Butterfly era vocals are very underrated tbh. 💟💗
Butterfly all the way just because of the fluidity💖💖💖💖
My OPINION
A4: TEOM
Bb4: TEOM
Bb4: TEOM
B4: Butterfly
C5: TEOM
C5: TEOM
C#5: TEOM
D5: TEOM
D5: TEOM
Eb5: TEOM
Eb5: Tie
Eb5: TEOM
E5: Butterfly
E5: Butterfly
E5: TEOM
F5: Butterfly
F5: Butterfly
F#5: Butterfly
F#5: Butterfly
The one thing TEOMriah would have is confidence, she was already sick in some 2005 performances like Live 8. Butterfly in all aspects especially if we consider 1997 😋
It's complicated with these eras. Technically 1997-1998 had better vocals since her decline was just starting. However, she was still singing like she had in 1995-1996 and was adjusting, which made her vocal change very apparent. With 2005-2006, her voice was in better condition for most of 2005 than the butterfly era, but her singing style was more accommodated to her voice then. She didn't have the same confidence she had in the 90's, so she held back in some ways. I would say both are great overall. Butterfly takes the edge.
TEOM!
From indonesia fans mariah carey
HAI LAMBILY INDONESIA,AKU JUGA!
Aku suka lagu meriah carey dari umur 14 tahun,sekarang aku umur 29.
Tiap hari aku mendengar lagu itu itu aja.
Yang tidak pernah bosan aku dengar lagu I still belive
@@indaharlojiserangkhairulwa2803 ❤️
Can you plz do rainbow vs emc2 they both were the low points in her vocal
mkayy
@@rainbowriah mm 👀
@@rainbowriah LMAOO
butterfly era sounds so much healthier and better.
This is my opinion:
A4: TEOM > Butterfly
Bb4: TEOM > Butterfly
Bb4: TEOM = Butterfly
B4: TEOM > Butterfly
C5: TEOM > Butterfly
C5: Butterfly > TEOM
C#5: TEOM > Butterfly
D5: Butterfly > TEOM
D5: TEOM = Butterfly
Eb5: TEOM > Butterfly
Eb5: Butterfly = TEOM
Eb5: Butterfly > TEOM
E5: Butterfly = TEOM
E5: Butterfly = TEOM
E5: TEOM > Butterfly
F5: TEOM > Butterfly
F5: Butterfly > TEOM
F#5: Butterfly = TEOM
F#5: Butterfly > TEOM
Butterfly - 10
TEOM - 14
✨TEOM ✨wins
Butterfree vs taom
Taom wins because idk the other one
cuz she left u? 🤣
you better get away from here, get over! Butterriah always will be free of your creep claws! 🦋✨♥️
😤🤫😡
BUTTERFREE 🧚♀️🧚♀️
@@luke-vo2tu 😒
Teom Madison square garden has left the chat... and hero from 1997 on Oprah show😅
I love butterfly but teom really dose beat it in a vocal battle I don’t really like the tone but that’s me but the confidence and consistency dose it let’s not bash either album there both amazing 🤩
both raspberries
A4- TEOM. More stable
Bb4- Butterfly. More relaxed
Bb4 2- TEOM
B4- TEOM
C5-TEOM
C5 2- TEOM
C#5 - Butterfly
D5- TEOM.
D5 2- Tie
Eb5 1- TEOM!!!
Eb5 2- Tie. Both perfection. TEOM vibrato was incredible and tone. Butterfly phrasing was divine
Eb5 3- Butterfly!!
E5- Butterfly
E5 2- Butterfly
E5 3- TEOM!!! Live 8 imperfect perfection
F5 1- Butterfly
F5 2- TEOM but it was dubbed.
F#5 1- Butterfly!! Best live post 1996 F#5
F#5 2- Butterfly. More bodied
butterfly belting seemed to be easier for her than TEOM.
well I'm late once again but not surprised 👁️👄👁️
Is F5 from "So Alive" really an F5? On my piano application and tuner, that's an E5 and can not be called a F5.
Same but i think it is a very sharp E5
TEOM wins
TEOM of course.
Lol ok
@@sonilika9555 nobody has the courage to admit that Bfly era live vocals were dry hoarse and strained. You included. LOL
@@marcomrc1594 how where they strained when teom is more strained? Lmao the F#5 from teom are literally squeak
@@sonilika9555 I give you a tip: Make it happen is the thermometer of every era. Make it happen GMA >>>>>> Make it happen Divas Live. Enough said.
@@marcomrc1594 AHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH sure 🤣🤣🤣. Make It happen sydney >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gma
Butterfly>>>>>>>>>> The flop of mimi
What??? Flop???
@@nycolassampaio9719 I’m crying
There are much better examples from Butterfly era, while you pick the best of TEOM.
True
No hate to quarantine
Butterfree wins
Butterfly tone>>>>>>>>TEOM tone
Butterfly > constipation
3.57 WAIT FROM WHERE THIS PERFORMANCE WAS?
Vision of Love Brisbane
Everyone thinks it is Melbourne but nope for me it's Brisbane
Music Box Tour okay thank you, musicbox
What’s the song of the intro?
#beautiful
So based on the comments everyone loves...a raspier tone ?
3:26
3:35
TEOM is great, TAOM is the worst vocal point in her entire career, tied with 2022 tho.
1:43 clear loss of fluidity compared to Butterfly here but good belt nonetheless
what is the song in 1:25 ??
hey are u alive? 👁👄👁
MoonGrande28 yes just busy
@@TheLegendofMariah waiting for u
Fourth
A4- TEOM
Bb4 - Butterfly
Bb4 2 - Butterfly
B4 - Butterfly
C5 - TEOM
C5 2 - TEOM
C#5 - TEOM
D5 - Butterfly
D5 2 - TEOM
Eb5 - TEOM
Eb5 2 - Butterfly
Eb5 3 - Butterfly
E5 - Butterfly
E5 2 - Butterfly
E5 3 - TEOM
F5 - Butterfly
F5 2 - Butterfly (TEOM is lipped)
F#5 - Butterfly
F#5 2 - Butterfly (TEOM is lipped)
the first Bb4 is totally to TEOM dahling 🤣
The F5 and F#5 of TEOM are both live! You can clearly see the difference of live and the studio version, the BET Blueprint performances of 2005 are all LIVE, you can hear the rasp of the F#5 in It’s Like That, you have to review your statements dahling. ♥️🦋✨
WBT F5 is live
@@kingjuicy3023 yes, that’s what I’m trying to say
You dont know what you talk about shout up!!! Wbt F5 is live but doub not in that not, and the F#5 too with so much resonance....
this is nonsense. The best of Butterfly is better than the best of Teom live BUT Teom is the better album for me
who’s TEOM?