Did you know we have a gaming channel where you can ask us questions?! Check out Super Carlin Gaming :: ua-cam.com/channels/or_9jRnNNZVzTuQ92PKsaQ.html
Gaunts son only served 6 months in Azkaban I believe before being let out. We learn that in half blood prince when we view his memories in the penceive
wouldn’t it be more so expulsion,death,detention, then Azkaban mainly because of the commonly known quote in sorcerers stone when she says “i’m going to bed before either of you get us KILLED OR WORSE EXPELLED” which is saying that expulsion is worse i’m a nerd if you can’t tell
Sirius also made it out because for whatever reason the dementors don’t do anything to animals only humans. He change into his animagi form. Which I am now wondering if Peter Petegrew were to be in Azkaban would he have escaped as a rat?
@@Ignasimp she did. After the second wizarding war Kingsley becomes the minister for magic and puts Umbridge on trial for the muggle borns she sentenced to Azkaban and for those that died there as well as service to Voldemort. She was found guilty and sentenced to life in Azkaban.
@@Ignasimp no Dumbledore rescued her. She then became the head of the muggle born registration committee and had stole Slytherin's locket in deathly hallows
The rising Gamer it was the same night they died, Sirius went to the house, saw it was destroyed, that’s when Hagrid came, Sirius gave Hagrid his bike, then Sirius went and searched for peter and “killed” him. All happened in the same night. 31 October
My friend told me they have the dementors torturing prisoners at azkaban so they dont go around torturing random people. So I've sort of just believed him in the idea that the Ministry is casually sacrificing prisoners to the dementors to keep them happy and given how horrible the ministry is, i still believe it lol
My head canon: Dementors can't be killed or destroyed. They don't NEED to eat, but they hunger constantly like vampires. In my mind, they probably had a lot of conflict with wizards (and muggles) for a long time. I think they probably made a deal with them to keep them under control. They would provide prisoners for them to feed upon in order to keep them sated because the alternative is much worse: they'd be roaming around uncontrolled, killing lots of innocent people. Sacrificing prisoners does seem barbaric and cruel, but it's preferable to everyone in the world living in fear forever, never knowing when dementors will come for them or their children, as well as exposing the world of magic to muggles which would undoubtedly lead to muggle vs wizard conflicts on top of that.
Muggles can't see Dementors though. In the presence of Dementors, Muggles just have the same vague feeling of unhappiness that Wizards do, but they don't understand why. Also, for most people being in the presence of Dementors isn't likely to cause any serious harm. Unless you've had some truly awful things happen to you like Harry or Dudley, you'll be fine.
@@macon8638 He basically forced to realize what a horrible spoiled brat he was to everyone for all this time when he faced the Dementors in Book 5. Introspection can be painful, and that's doubly true in the Harry Potter universe when magic is involved.
@@coolnerdlll6053 he was sentenced to azkaban twice. Once for attacking Tom Riddle senior because Merope was in love with Riddle. He was sentenced a few months for this. Years later he received a life time sentence for killing the Riddle familiy. A crime which he did not commit.
I just remembered that in The Restaurant at the End of the Universe, they introduce a character who is spending a year being dead, "for tax reasons." Heh. That's weirdly similar.
The thing with Grindelwald and Nurmengard was that he eventually just accepted what he did and repented and made no attempt to escape from Nurmengard. When he was detained in America, he was a completely different wizard.
@@OriginalPiMan Maybe they aren't reliable enough, even the Hogwarts express takes extra safety measures like a secret passage leading to a secret train platform. The wizards in America were also supposed to be especially paranoid about detection by muggles.
I actually believe that Grindelwald didn't want to escape. I believe he was waiting for the right moment, which he knew would come with his transfer to the UK
I have always thought that dementors was actually the physical manifestation of depressions in the wizzarding world. What they leave behind of you after a dementors kiss have always sounded very much like extreme depression to me. Am I the only one?
How to solve the dementor problem: epic 3 month wizard party at Azkaban. Comedians, theater, quidditch on the roof, Helena’s food magic, and barrels of firewhiskey. Before you know it, the dementors will be overwhelmed with fun and whimsy, causing their numbers to evaporate. Dementor genocide rave at Azkaban!,
Sirius wasn't able to escape because of him being an animagus, it was because he knew he was innocent. Not a happy thought, just not a bad one either. That's why the dementors could not detect him.
Small correction: The Ministry of Magic does NOT only give out life sentences to Azkaban. For example, I refer to Bagman's trial in the flashback scene of Goblet of Fire, where Crouch starts to recommend a sentence of several years.
@@starrchild254 there's an old video, in which he talks about the 42 uses of a towel and he called the comment section the "towel section" and it stuck 😄
Grindelwald escaped the Macusa. He switched himself with Abernathy while under their guard. Convinced Abernathy to get his tongue cut out without blabbing too (hence why Grindelwald had to fix Abernathy's tongue post escape). Cant imagine that trick works on a dementor.
@@Illier1 sure. But saying the dementors shouldn't be used because they are in league with you enemy is a different argument than saying that the dementors weren't necessary because wizards were able to hold Grindelwald in a normal prison. They weren't.
Wait, now the big question: If Azkaban was still used as a prison after Voldemort, where the heck did the dementors go? It wasn't all sunshine and rainbows afterwards. Where did they go?
''only seem to be handing out life sentences?'' Hagrid? gets told it will only be ''a short stint'' plus what about Marvolo Gaunt and his son? they both got out after a few years...
@ULGROTHA oh yeah 100% they seemed to just go by how they feel at the time, i was just pointed out that he said there were no denominations in time and it was only life sentences being handed out
Hagrid only gets told it'll be quick if they catch someone else. “For a short stretch only,” said Fudge, not meeting Hagrid’s eyes. “Not a punishment, Hagrid, more a precaution. If someone else is caught, you’ll be let out with a full apology -” So yeah, Fudge once again being the worst. If they wouldn't catch anyone or don't get some kind of answer as to what has been going on Hagrid would just have to stay in Azkaban.
@@ricocarpenter2189 so because it wasn't mentioned it never happened in any other cases? im just saying he knows they dont ONLY hand out life sentences so confused why he said it
vaishali mathur, have you seen sarcastic fringe heads fight? It ain’t quite like that. It’s like they’re screaming into each other’s mouths, and it’s hilarious.
The carriage scene wasn’t a “body switching power”, it was polyjuice that they each took at the same time, so it wore off at the same time. The proof is that at the beginning of the movie, Picquery says they cut out Grindelwald’s tongue. Later, Grindelwald replaces Abernathy’s severed tongue with a forked one. Also, during the escape scene Abernathy doesn’t speak once. (Maybe he does after he gets his tongue back, I’m not sure)
I was saying the same thing not only that but if you look at the wand the he uses to aperate to the bottom of the carriage it's the elder wand and I don't think grindlewald would ever give that wand to someone let alone to someone who has not proven themselves yet even if it was to break them out
Ah yes it’s so obvious that it was polyjuice potion... that’s why grindewald went through this weird convoluted plan to free his follower from prison. For some reason. Instead of just leaving him there. And escaping by himself with the blood pact. Makes sence...
sarah sahara I don’t remember Arthur being there. As Jay mentioned, Harris was sent there in Chamber of Secrets but I only ever remember Arthur staying at Saint Mungo’s after that bite.
@@loveland852 yeah I was wrong, it says somewhere that he visited Azkaban, and in the German version it sounded as though he had been sent there at some time (to me)
Marvolo and Morfin were released after serving their sentence for hexing Tom Riddle Sr and then fighting the Aurors. Morfin died in Azkaban after being sent there by Tom's machinations, while Dumbledore was trying to get his case appealed.
Something I’ve always wondered was how more wizards haven’t escaped Azkaban. So you know how Sirius’s wand has runes all over it? Well he supposedly carved them into his wand while he was at Azkaban, which means he must have his wand while at Azkaban. And what creatures guard Azkaban? Dementors. What spell can deflect Dementors? The Patronus Charm. And there is no way that not one prisoner knows how to make a patronus. And the only thing I can think of that would disprove my theory is if there is some spell or potion or something that makes a wand not usable in that location or makes it so that a person can’t cast a spell in that location. Also I know you may be thinking ‘but wait if there are so many dementors someone may not be able to cast the spell.’ Well actually no. In Prisoner of Azkaban Harry deflects 100+ dementors. So there may be more that 100 dementors at Azkaban but if there are multiple people who can produce a patronus then I bet they could do it.
Well it not 100% success rate more like 99.999999999999857% as Sirius black and Barty Crouch Jr escaped then a few year late it just became a failure with a mass breakout
All of which happened in the span of just a handful of years. With a tiny bit of rounding, relatively speaking, it was still around 300 years of 100% success.
Wait wait wait could Azkaban be the Bermuda Triangle? Not based on any facts/research, it's just that it's a triangle and ships were "lost" there and it wasn't on any maps. Just throwing it out there
Cool idea. Sadly the geography doesn't quite work, as the Bermuda triangle is the area between Florida, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico; and Azkaban is located somewhere in the North Sea (East/North-East of England).
I could've sworn the ministry was able to control the dementors. Which is why Hogwarts was told a fair warning that the dementors would be playing host for a while until they're able to find and capture Sirius. Also in Order of Phoenix, when Harry gets brought to the ministry, he asks why the dementors were even there in the muggle world, and the ministry comes back at him by saying dementors weren't stationed there in the first place
Big flaw man. Grindelwald was waiting there. He wasn’t held as a prisoner since he was posing as the macusa agent. He wanted to make a dramatic escape with the minister of magic there. Most of his stuff his just for show in order to manipulate.
Samuel Musser, I agree. The only way this breakout tactic makes sense is if Grindelwald is making decisions in order to build the legend of his own power, making himself into a perceived unstoppable foe. Dumbledore's continued existence is the biggest threat to this plan in two ways; First: Albus is a very talented and powerful wizard in his own right and Second: He is essentially the only person alive who truly knows what Grindelwald is actually capable of accomplishing.
In a Scorose fanfiction, She suggested killing Dementors for slippers instead of bunnies because she thought they were killing bunnies for slippers and that was wrong.
I thought the same thing. Bad weather means less muggles out and harder to see clearly. We know from the HP series when Hermione made Harry's Quidditch googles impervious to rain that wizards have a way for seeing better in rainy weather.
MACUSA wasn’t successful in holding Grindelwald. He switched places with Abernathy through transfiguration. Thus, why he had to give Abernathy a new tongue in the flying carriage.
"Yes, members of the enemy army, you may guard your former allies! That seems like a really good idea." - Just point #394 why the Wizarding world makes no freakin' sense.
you should do a video on magical creatures/plants, and how muggles never see them/be able to use the plants and potions, especially if they live on the same universe
The People vs Ilai’s Magic: Ilai’s Magic, you have been accused of making a horrendous joke. Should you plead guilty, you are consigned to the depths of heck (2:14). Should you plead innocent and be found guilty, you shall be given a life sentence in Azkaban. How do you plead.
This is crazy, I discussed the ethics of Azkaban on my channel just a few weeks ago. Awesome timing! I kind of answer your question to Ben in that video, but ultimately what it comes down to, I think, is one's philosophy of what a prison is meant to do. Azkaban's success rate during the era of the dementors is undeniable.
I'd say prison is supposed to be for reform really. if someone is never going to be let out you'd be better off just excuting them. well unless you're particularly sadistic or prone to miscarriages of justice.
Reform vs keep locked up is a very grey area, some people can be reformed and some people trick you into thinking they are just so they get out again. Best would be if you could reform everyone, but that is not the case
@@TGPDrunknHick Except dying is easy. There's no punishment there. Your life ends and that's it. The punishment in prison is knowing you will never escape, never achieve anything else, and being completely devoid of all hope.
@@lyntonfleming and your point? unless you intend to reform someone all you do by putting them in prison is waste resources. it's pointless. to leave someone to rot isn't justice. it's revenge and all it does is blacken the heart and waste food and manpower better off somewhere else in society.
There is evidence that suggests that there are other sentences of time in Azkaban. “If the Ministry and Voldemort are behind Snape it’ll be a choice between staying and teaching, or a few nice years in Azkaban - and that’s if they’re lucky”(Deathly Hallows, p. 226). This proves that life isn’t the only known sentence in Azkaban because even Harry, known for needing Ron to provide wizarding world facts, thought of time in Azkaban in terms of years. (Sorry if someone else quoted this. I’m not trying to copy)
I think that if the people in Azkaban really deserved it, then the dementors were worth it. But then again they do trap some pretty innocent people so maybe they should have a prison for “Not so Bad Prisoners.”
Agreed, remember they sent Hagrid there in Chamber of Secrets in the ministries (usual) imcompetent attempt to control the situation at Hogwarts. I feel bad for him everytime i think about it, poor cuddly Hagrid probably crying about Hermione petrified, people blaming Harry and Fang all alone wondering where he is.
There may be different amounts of ‘guarding’ at Azkaban depending on your crime; Sirius was one of the most heavily guarded prisoners, so I always imagined Dementors basically posted outside his door. That said, no, pretty sure that nothing is worth having Dementors around, especially when they don’t effect the most horrible people the same as normal people! Great video 😁
I think Grindelwald just let them keep him there, and thought he was being kept at MACUSA because he's 'special.' Edit: **I** thought they kept him ...
Azkaban isn’t solely used for life sentences. The Gaunts (marvolo and morphin) were sent to Azkaban for a few months(marvolo) or a few years (morphin) but not life.
I really dig the idea of an elite force of wizards landing on the island full of dementors, summoning charms and powerful defensive magic, only to then engage in the sorts of frolicking and merrymaking carefully calculated to cause their numbers to wane. “We are just ending our water-balloon fight, then we begin the hide and seek, just before the ice cream Sunday party and snuggles with puppies, sir.”
I know that it's not related but will you guys please please please make a video debunking the "Ginny slipped Harry a love potion" theory??? #Please I will comment it until you make one, please don't get annoyed. Love your videos
@@SuperCarlinBrothers omg....thanks for replying.....I know this theory is ridiculous and mostly based of the films but some people argue for this one very much! they even bring up Molly mentioning love potion in Prisoner of Azkaban too. Apparently Harry having a loving family with Ginny is not enough! I love your videos
@@pan-opticon Me neither...I have always wanted #Hinny #Romione and #Nuna that's why I want the theory debunked so bad....I don't see how the story would play if Harry was with Hermione...the whole Deathly Hallows would be different.
Jannatul Shoilee also like, Ginny doesn’t even need a love potion, besides, it doesn’t add anything good to the story, quite the contrary...And yes, Ron and Hermione are too cute! Her and Harry, i feel, are just like siblings.
I'm not a huge Harry Potter fan but your enthusiasm is contagious and I love your videos! The perfect tonic for the weirdness of the real world. So glad I found your channel :)
Abadon is actually pronounced avadon.. the Hebrew letter for b' can be pronounced like v' so... Also this word is actually derived from the word אבד (avad/abad) which is another Hebrew word for loss so abadon can also mean a great loss. But yeah it also means doom or dimise And dont @ me my first language is Hebrew 😂
Love your theories and how detailed you go. I have a question that I think needs an answer. How often does a wizard go dark? Obviously it often enough that teenagers need to be taught to defend against it. And then there's a whole department of the ministry for dealing with them.
@@sentinellj He was persuasive, very... So you know, he talked to the security and talked and talked and got the potion done by them, and delivered. After all he had quite a while to make them do it before they silenced him (although, they thought it was him, he changed before that). There had to be a reason they did it so why wouldn't it be potion making stuff?
Umm, people aren't sent to Azkaban forever. Sure, murdering someone and using any of the unforgivable curses on another human will give a one-way ticket there but people like the Gaunts was there for only some years.
it's not only life sentences in Azkaban, on page 592, it says, "Ludovic Bagman, you were caught passing information to Lord Voldemort's supporters," said Mr. Crouch. "for this, I suggest a term of imprisonment in Azkaban lasting no less than-" The fact that he said, "I suggest a TERM" and "imprisonment ...of no less than-" suggests that he was not about to sentence him for life. Besides, I can't imagine Crouch saying; "for this, I suggest a term of imprisonment in Azkaban lasting no less than LIFE." That's just way too sassy for Crouch. But I'm not a hater. You guys are awesome.
Another thing I've been asking myself for a while now: where even is Grindelwald from? ... We know he's from somewhere in Europe and Grindelwald is a German name.. So in my opinion the possibilities could be: .. well Germany, Austria because Nurmengard is located there or Switzerland because there is an actual city named "Grindelwald" there. But he could also be from somewhere around eastern Europe because he attended Durmstrang.. This question is bothering me for quite some time know and I hope to get a (canon) answer soon (maybe/hopefully in the next part of fantastic beasts...?)
Lina the only possibility I’ve thought of is Bulgaria, or somewhere nearby. We know that Krum attended Durmstrang and played for Bulgaria during the World Cup. While it sounds like Hogwarts serves just the UK, it’s possible that Durmstrang serves multiple countries in eastern/Central Europe. Since no other country was ever mentioned, I always assumed that Durmstrang was in Bulgaria, but I could be wrong. In keeping with its "dark arts leaning" persona, I would guess that Durmstrang could be located in Transylvania. This part of Romania would make sense both symbolically and practically as a German and Bulgarian student could both live close enough to attend. So your assumption that Grindelwald could be German seems spot on. But now the question is.... If Durmstrang is so landlocked, why do they decide to use a ship to travel to Hogwarts? It almost seems like they mixed up their transportation methods with Beauxbatons. At least France has coastlines.
@@masha7377 nope, he survived. also, Grindelwald escaped before they cut the tongue off, Abernathy had his toung cut off by macusa EDIT: Abernathy's page on the harry potter wiki said that he is an expert in transfiguration, and it was his transfiguration skills that were used to switch with Grindelwald. (he wasnt manipulated like other guards, he was actually loyal to Grindelwald) Original text: The screenplay just says "transforming", doesnt tell us whether it is polyjuice or transfiguration. grindelwald isnt listed as a user of polyjuice on the harry potter wiki (newt is listed there).
@@robk5969 that's clearer but one thing I really dislike is when you need to lean heavily on pottermore to understand or explain something in the books or films. The books were much better for this. If it's not in the texts it's not canon for me so the move to just fixing explanations in post, essentially, is really jarring. And I actually didn't hate the movie. Fantastic beasts needs to get better though. They could start by renaming it and not wasting time on adding beast scenes that add little to the story to justify the title.
My interpretation of Grindlewald's escape is that he'd actually escaped weeks before and was using polyjuice or some other spell to impersonate his guard, who was now trapped in Grindlewald's cell without a tongue. Why didn't he just escape then? I have no idea. Maybe he thought a midair escape would be more impressive, and that it would muddy the waters of when he'd actually escaped and who was responsible, causing a rift between magical law enforcement agencies who now blamed each other for his escape. I think the movie suggests that he actually wants to leave his guard behind and escape, but he's forced to hand the bloodpact over and so has to return for it. Either way, I don't think MACUSA is actually successful in imprisoning him.
I mean with Hagrid and Dumbledore the Ministry was EXTREMELY corrupt. Part of the reason Hagrid was sentenced so harshly was because he is a minority. A half breed. And for Dumbledore the people in the ministry loved him or hated him and both sides influenced the other. I.e Lucius manipulating the school board or the minister letting Dumbledore get away with questionable school decisions.
![The Knight Bus's BIG SECRET [Harry Potter Theory]](/img/n.gif)
Did you know we have a gaming channel where you can ask us questions?!
Check out Super Carlin Gaming :: ua-cam.com/channels/or_9jRnNNZVzTuQ92PKsaQ.html
SuperCarlinBrothers Thank you so so much for getting me through hard times keep up the good work
I love the gaming channel!
Gaunts son only served 6 months in Azkaban I believe before being let out. We learn that in half blood prince when we view his memories in the penceive
Awesome content guys thank you for all the hard work
I love you guys your amazing keep up the good work smile more
"No one has ever escaped from Azkaban."
Sirius: Hold my butterbeer
A year later: *multiple death eaters* That's cute
@@Spectralyzed *a few years later*
Everyone in Azkaban: *Escapes*
Dumbledore: "I could break out, of course - but what a waste of time, and frankly, I can think of a whole host of things I would rather be doing."
Barty Jr: I'll take that butterbeer, thanks
they had help from he who must not be named
Snooty Wizard: "We do play golf, on broomsticks! We call it.. Brolf!"
Me: Thank god JK didn't call Quidditch, 'Brootball'
Also, broomball
Ballbroom (ballroom get it)
Nahh, would have be Brugby. >:)
IdleLancer 🤣😂👍👍
if they call it brolf then why did he say he was going to play golf first
4:00 I'll have you know that the order of badness goes "Detention, Death, Expulsion, Azkaban" (thanks Hermione)
Oscar Jessup no no no it’s detention, death, wand breaking, explication, Azkaban
And the worst is Dementor's Kiss..
wouldn’t it be more so expulsion,death,detention, then Azkaban
mainly because of the commonly known quote in sorcerers stone when she says “i’m going to bed before either of you get us KILLED OR WORSE EXPELLED” which is saying that expulsion is worse
i’m a nerd if you can’t tell
@@nateepperly5246 I think they had it in ascending order of terrible, which would place death before expulsion.
Good thing Hermione was there for me when I asked. She’s always there for you when you need it!
It’s strange, actually.
Can Hermione teleport?
I just imagined a family of dementors on vacation at the beach
Wizards and Witches on the beach Running and screaming from seeing the dementors-
Dementors- I JUST WANT A BREAK!!!1
Bruh
LOL, that would be an interesting sight🤣
Lol
Aww lil baby demontors! Imagine twins, they'd be a terror I bet lol they sound cute though
“No one has ever escaped from Azkaban”
Sirius and Barty crouch jr.: “hold my escape plans”
Barty Crouch Jr didn't escape, he was smuggled out by his family. Sirius actually escaped, on his own, without anyone helping him. Huge difference.
@@limiv5272 muggled out*
Sirius also made it out because for whatever reason the dementors don’t do anything to animals only humans. He change into his animagi form. Which I am now wondering if Peter Petegrew were to be in Azkaban would he have escaped as a rat?
No one deserves a life sentence in Azkaban...
except Umbrige
She didn't though.
@@Ignasimp she did. After the second wizarding war Kingsley becomes the minister for magic and puts Umbridge on trial for the muggle borns she sentenced to Azkaban and for those that died there as well as service to Voldemort. She was found guilty and sentenced to life in Azkaban.
@@sentinellj i though she died when the Centaurs captured her.
@@Ignasimp no Dumbledore rescued her. She then became the head of the muggle born registration committee and had stole Slytherin's locket in deathly hallows
@@sentinellj it's been so long since I read the books so I don't remember it.
I did my waiting! Twelve years of it, IN AZKABAN!!
13
Michael Martinez
Harry Potter was 13 in year 3
His parents were killed when Harry was 1 Year old
13-1=12
Sjoerd Mooi we don’t know the date how do you know it was the same year l+j died
The rising Gamer it was the same night they died, Sirius went to the house, saw it was destroyed, that’s when Hagrid came, Sirius gave Hagrid his bike, then Sirius went and searched for peter and “killed” him. All happened in the same night. 31 October
Tom Body can you tell me the page number that is stated
My friend told me they have the dementors torturing prisoners at azkaban so they dont go around torturing random people. So I've sort of just believed him in the idea that the Ministry is casually sacrificing prisoners to the dementors to keep them happy and given how horrible the ministry is, i still believe it lol
Yeah I think I heard a similair story.
I believe that 'harry potter folklore' did a video about that.
You should check it out
it's not a horrible thing to do, if you're mostly sending rather horrible criminals there it's an extremely easy thing to justify
@@xilrondo2907 But they don't seem to have another prison. Overdue broom-parking ticket? Life sentence in Azkaban
That was a robot chicken sketch
@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 Really? I've gotta go find it now
SuperCarlinBrothers: “like, uh, kinda precious cargo, could u not wait until morning?
Jack sparrow: people aren’t cargo, mate.
I mean the USS Iowa considered FDR cargo.
That quote is from a cut scene but I love it anyway.
I love this comment SOOOOOO MUCH!!!
This is the most liked UA-cam comment I’ve ever written. Thanks, guys. :)
*captain jack sparrow
My head canon: Dementors can't be killed or destroyed. They don't NEED to eat, but they hunger constantly like vampires. In my mind, they probably had a lot of conflict with wizards (and muggles) for a long time. I think they probably made a deal with them to keep them under control. They would provide prisoners for them to feed upon in order to keep them sated because the alternative is much worse: they'd be roaming around uncontrolled, killing lots of innocent people. Sacrificing prisoners does seem barbaric and cruel, but it's preferable to everyone in the world living in fear forever, never knowing when dementors will come for them or their children, as well as exposing the world of magic to muggles which would undoubtedly lead to muggle vs wizard conflicts on top of that.
Muggles can't see Dementors though. In the presence of Dementors, Muggles just have the same vague feeling of unhappiness that Wizards do, but they don't understand why. Also, for most people being in the presence of Dementors isn't likely to cause any serious harm. Unless you've had some truly awful things happen to you like Harry or Dudley, you'll be fine.
Hunter Stiles what truly awful thing happened to Dudley?
@@macon8638 He basically forced to realize what a horrible spoiled brat he was to everyone for all this time when he faced the Dementors in Book 5. Introspection can be painful, and that's doubly true in the Harry Potter universe when magic is involved.
I don't understand why they can't be destroyed
Whose up for a round of BROLF!?
I AM!! But can you use magic
LOL
SURE THING!
ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SuperCarlinBrothers I AM FAIR GENTLEMAN
"Why Azkaban uses Dementors."
What I got from this video: Because wizards are lazy, basically.
WiccanRai and mean
XD
It's sadly very accurate though for why terrible systems in our real world sometime get left unfixed for ridiculous amounts of time.
@@moonstonepearl21 what?, Is it weird I don't get anything that you just said (take this as a joke pls)
There is a lot to be said about the pervasive powers of lazyness.
Being send to azkaban doesn't have to be for a life time. Marvolo Gaunt and his son were convicted for only a period of their lives
Simon Van Berlo Oh yeaahhh
Oooo yeah
But Morfin died just as he was about to be freed, so he technically got a life sentence.
@@coolnerdlll6053 he was sentenced to azkaban twice. Once for attacking Tom Riddle senior because Merope was in love with Riddle. He was sentenced a few months for this. Years later he received a life time sentence for killing the Riddle familiy. A crime which he did not commit.
@@escaper59 true
So the worst prison in literary history was a result of a cost-cutting measure.
Sounds like something out of Douglas Adams.
I just remembered that in The Restaurant at the End of the Universe, they introduce a character who is spending a year being dead, "for tax reasons." Heh. That's weirdly similar.
The thing with Grindelwald and Nurmengard was that he eventually just accepted what he did and repented and made no attempt to escape from Nurmengard. When he was detained in America, he was a completely different wizard.
Maybe they travelled in that weather so muggles couldn't get a clear look at them in a flying carriage?
luke Hodge that's a good thought!
Lots of spells available to conceal that, even in clear weather.
@@OriginalPiMan Maybe they aren't reliable enough, even the Hogwarts express takes extra safety measures like a secret passage leading to a secret train platform. The wizards in America were also supposed to be especially paranoid about detection by muggles.
Don’t be silly it’s because the next day they were going to play brolf
I've always assumed that MACUSA conjured that thunderstorm for extra cover.
I actually believe that Grindelwald didn't want to escape. I believe he was waiting for the right moment, which he knew would come with his transfer to the UK
@LanaC brexit
He was waiting for the opportune moment.
I thought grindelwald was imprisoned in his own fortress?! I dont remember him ever being mentioned in going to azkaban.
@@ZorgerBergg I never claimed he was imprisoned in Azkaban.
@@jenstewart105 they’re talking about when he was imprisoned in New York by MACUSA, not when he was sent to Nurmengard
The real question is what do the prisoners eat? Do the dementors cook?
yes
The dementors call in an Uber eats
Obvs!
Argus Filch uses a porch key!
I love the thought of the Dementors cooking. I can picture them in Chef's hats and ruffled aprons.
This would be an awesome show. "Dining with Dementors"-prison fare with a deadly flair!
Wizard: *Jaywalks*
Ministry: LIFE IMPRISONMENT AND TORTURE!!!!
Why is jay walking illegal? I do it like everytime i cross a road (if there are no cars)
Jaywalking isn't illegal in the UK. In fact it isn't really a thing over here, the first I heard of it was when I visited New York
@@ghostcookie21 so you don't get run over by a car or obstruct traffic
Wizard: Enters the Ministry of Magic without a mask.
Ministry: Life in Azkaban, torture and death!!!!!
Don’t you mean J-walks?
I have always thought that dementors was actually the physical manifestation of depressions in the wizzarding world. What they leave behind of you after a dementors kiss have always sounded very much like extreme depression to me. Am I the only one?
How to solve the dementor problem: epic 3 month wizard party at Azkaban. Comedians, theater, quidditch on the roof, Helena’s food magic, and barrels of firewhiskey. Before you know it, the dementors will be overwhelmed with fun and whimsy, causing their numbers to evaporate.
Dementor genocide rave at Azkaban!,
Perfect.
👏
That and patronus-bomb the place once or twice before and after the party just to make sure.
It’s brilliant.
Helena don't you mean Helga Hufflepuff
Also, they're easy to fool. "One dying person entered, one dying person left"? Kind of a major oversight, don't you think?! (Also, Animagi.)
Sirius wasn't able to escape because of him being an animagus, it was because he knew he was innocent. Not a happy thought, just not a bad one either. That's why the dementors could not detect him.
@@Tiny_24 actually when he escaped he transformed into his dog form and slipped through the bars of his cell
@@sentinellj he was only able to do that after he starved himself.
@@Tiny_24 he didn't starve himself he was malnourished and it allowed him to slip out as a dog as he could slip through the bars of his cell
@@sentinellj he was able to escape because he refused to eat. The dementors still tried to feed him.
Small correction: The Ministry of Magic does NOT only give out life sentences to Azkaban. For example, I refer to Bagman's trial in the flashback scene of Goblet of Fire, where Crouch starts to recommend a sentence of several years.
Why does he call it the towel section?
@@starrchild254 there's an old video, in which he talks about the 42 uses of a towel and he called the comment section the "towel section" and it stuck 😄
Also for Morfin and Marvolo Gaunt, they only spent a few years there after attacking the ministery wizard
Sturgis Podmore was sentenced to 6 months. I'm sure there are more examples.
@@krisztinadoncseva1047which video? I’ve always been curious out it
"what is that body switching power? Sadly i dont think we'll ever know the answer"
*2 days later
"The Body Swap Scene Explained!"
They transport by night because you know... Muggles would see a flying carriage in the light?
The bodyswitching powers... polyjuice potion?
They'd have charms to prevent Muggles from seeing it
If Mr. Weasley can charm a flying car (er, not well, but still) Aurors could mask a carriage.
Have you seen their breakdown of the opening scene? If you have then you would know why both if you solutions are still wrong...
Why, during this, did the relationship between seagulls and dementors cross my mind? Dementors are basically dark magic seagulls.
Haha I made it 69
@@leozero_ maybe that's why Patronis (plural of Patronus) take the form of an animal. It's symbolic.
That is AWESOME. I will never be able to unsee that. I have an image of them nicking people's chips on Brighton Beach now.
Grindelwald escaped the Macusa. He switched himself with Abernathy while under their guard. Convinced Abernathy to get his tongue cut out without blabbing too (hence why Grindelwald had to fix Abernathy's tongue post escape). Cant imagine that trick works on a dementor.
Didn't Voldemort just end up taking them all over and using them as soldiers? As I recall Dementors ran rampant on England during the last book.
@@Illier1 sure. But saying the dementors shouldn't be used because they are in league with you enemy is a different argument than saying that the dementors weren't necessary because wizards were able to hold Grindelwald in a normal prison. They weren't.
We do play golf ,on broomsticks ,we call it BROLF!
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂 Best thing ever!!!!!!
Kate M literally was just about to type this!!! 🤣🤣🤣
@@zwhitaker great minds think alike
Liked the video because of that
Wait, now the big question: If Azkaban was still used as a prison after Voldemort, where the heck did the dementors go? It wasn't all sunshine and rainbows afterwards. Where did they go?
I just wrote a similar comment. I've always wondered about this.
@@limiv5272 Put them in a shipping container and sink it in the ocean
@@TheRaidenLP How do you seal a dementor inside a container though? Locomotor Dementor?
@@limiv5272 That‘s the better question
Dementors faded heavily after the defeat of Voldemort because they require suffering and dread to exist.
It’s not always a life sentence like that dude from the 6th book got out and then got framed
Sturgis Podmore, 5th book - OotP
2:14 THE DEPTHS OF HECK
How to keep it family friendly but still get your point across
''only seem to be handing out life sentences?'' Hagrid? gets told it will only be ''a short stint'' plus what about Marvolo Gaunt and his son? they both got out after a few years...
@ULGROTHA oh yeah 100% they seemed to just go by how they feel at the time, i was just pointed out that he said there were no denominations in time and it was only life sentences being handed out
3 cases out of how many oh yeah A TON so yes I think his statement is accurate
Hagrid only gets told it'll be quick if they catch someone else.
“For a short stretch only,” said Fudge, not meeting Hagrid’s eyes. “Not a punishment, Hagrid, more a precaution. If someone else is caught, you’ll be let out with a full apology -”
So yeah, Fudge once again being the worst. If they wouldn't catch anyone or don't get some kind of answer as to what has been going on Hagrid would just have to stay in Azkaban.
@@ricocarpenter2189 so because it wasn't mentioned it never happened in any other cases? im just saying he knows they dont ONLY hand out life sentences so confused why he said it
@@cosmodewit yeah but we all know fudge is the worst anyway haha he knew Hargid didn't do it but he ''had to be seen to be doing something''
"Accio Niffler"
Would of been really useful in the first fantastic beats.
Teufel i'm sorry Whats the accio spell again? (Btw are you german?)
@@loucw brings something to you
Can accio summon living creatures? I thought it couldn’t because otherwise Voldy could’ve just summoned Harry to him and😵
Little bit late but Accio can only summon small creature like Niffler
"Hey, America, where are your dementors?"
I can't say for sure, but I would probably hazard a guess at Guantanamo Bay
Here’s a question: what happens if dementors attack each other? Are they like Sarcastic Fringeheads, and just attack each other with their mouths?
Monroe Robbins they are the living embodiment of death kinda like a spirit with emotions or the ability to think
Harry Muskett, ah. So they arm wrestle.
They would be kissing then.
vaishali mathur, have you seen sarcastic fringe heads fight? It ain’t quite like that. It’s like they’re screaming into each other’s mouths, and it’s hilarious.
The carriage scene wasn’t a “body switching power”, it was polyjuice that they each took at the same time, so it wore off at the same time. The proof is that at the beginning of the movie, Picquery says they cut out Grindelwald’s tongue. Later, Grindelwald replaces Abernathy’s severed tongue with a forked one. Also, during the escape scene Abernathy doesn’t speak once. (Maybe he does after he gets his tongue back, I’m not sure)
I was saying the same thing not only that but if you look at the wand the he uses to aperate to the bottom of the carriage it's the elder wand and I don't think grindlewald would ever give that wand to someone let alone to someone who has not proven themselves yet even if it was to break them out
I thought it was so obvious it was polyjuice potion...
Ah yes it’s so obvious that it was polyjuice potion... that’s why grindewald went through this weird convoluted plan to free his follower from prison. For some reason. Instead of just leaving him there. And escaping by himself with the blood pact. Makes sence...
And how did he get the potion to Grindelwald?
Ohhh cool ok 👌🏻
Isnt Gaunt sentenced for a couple of years in Azkaban and then gets free?
Morfin spent 3 years in Azkaban, so yes.
isn't Arthur Weasley sent there for a short time too?... or am I imagining that?
sarah sahara I don’t remember Arthur being there. As Jay mentioned, Harris was sent there in Chamber of Secrets but I only ever remember Arthur staying at Saint Mungo’s after that bite.
@@loveland852 yeah I was wrong, it says somewhere that he visited Azkaban, and in the German version it sounded as though he had been sent there at some time (to me)
Marvolo and Morfin were released after serving their sentence for hexing Tom Riddle Sr and then fighting the Aurors. Morfin died in Azkaban after being sent there by Tom's machinations, while Dumbledore was trying to get his case appealed.
Can I swim? No.
Can I dance? No.
Do I know karate? No.
Am I ok? No.
Can I play “Brolf”? SURE! COULD HAVE ASKED ME EARLIER!
This is a mood
Could HAVE could've is the contraction for could HAVE
Edited!👌🏻 thx!
@@Sean-in9qi could'VE
@@juliadesoto7349 yeah, could've is a contraction for could have
Also Nuremgard, Grindelwald's prison castle, had *no* guards, and no one ever escaped either.
Something I’ve always wondered was how more wizards haven’t escaped Azkaban. So you know how Sirius’s wand has runes all over it? Well he supposedly carved them into his wand while he was at Azkaban, which means he must have his wand while at Azkaban. And what creatures guard Azkaban? Dementors. What spell can deflect Dementors? The Patronus Charm. And there is no way that not one prisoner knows how to make a patronus. And the only thing I can think of that would disprove my theory is if there is some spell or potion or something that makes a wand not usable in that location or makes it so that a person can’t cast a spell in that location. Also I know you may be thinking ‘but wait if there are so many dementors someone may not be able to cast the spell.’ Well actually no. In Prisoner of Azkaban Harry deflects 100+ dementors. So there may be more that 100 dementors at Azkaban but if there are multiple people who can produce a patronus then I bet they could do it.
Cool nice theory 0o0
To summon a patronus you have to have hope and faith. The presence of dementors takes that away.
They didn't want to pay benefits to their employees
Justin sir
Reporting fr duty sir
Justin Y.
Oh wow you don’t have much likes or comments on this video surprising
Wow Justin Y.!!
Justin Y. Sup dude!
Why are you doing this?
Well it not 100% success rate more like 99.999999999999857% as Sirius black and Barty Crouch Jr escaped then a few year late it just became a failure with a mass breakout
All of which happened in the span of just a handful of years. With a tiny bit of rounding, relatively speaking, it was still around 300 years of 100% success.
in the case of Crouch Jr, he got help from both of his parents, and Crouch Sr was a ministry official
But who knows how many others escaped undetected, like Crouch Jr. 🤔🤔🤔
@@masha7377 you might have just solved how credence exists!!!!!
@@evelynparsons2312, OMG! You're probably right.
Wait wait wait could Azkaban be the Bermuda Triangle? Not based on any facts/research, it's just that it's a triangle and ships were "lost" there and it wasn't on any maps. Just throwing it out there
KamThings it’s also built in the shape of a triangle
Never mind you said it was a triangle already. My bad
Cool idea. Sadly the geography doesn't quite work, as the Bermuda triangle is the area between Florida, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico; and Azkaban is located somewhere in the North Sea (East/North-East of England).
Well it could also be another spot using magic to hide/trap stuff
Maybe there are some Dark Wizards vanishing ships and planes for fun?
I could've sworn the ministry was able to control the dementors. Which is why Hogwarts was told a fair warning that the dementors would be playing host for a while until they're able to find and capture Sirius. Also in Order of Phoenix, when Harry gets brought to the ministry, he asks why the dementors were even there in the muggle world, and the ministry comes back at him by saying dementors weren't stationed there in the first place
A random person: breathes
The ministry:torcher for all time
Big flaw man. Grindelwald was waiting there. He wasn’t held as a prisoner since he was posing as the macusa agent. He wanted to make a dramatic escape with the minister of magic there. Most of his stuff his just for show in order to manipulate.
Samuel Musser, I agree. The only way this breakout tactic makes sense is if Grindelwald is making decisions in order to build the legend of his own power, making himself into a perceived unstoppable foe. Dumbledore's continued existence is the biggest threat to this plan in two ways; First: Albus is a very talented and powerful wizard in his own right and Second: He is essentially the only person alive who truly knows what Grindelwald is actually capable of accomplishing.
Those artists renderings were on point. well done Derek
They must really hate the prisoners
kremit the frog well they did use the unforgivable curses so...
You.are.everywhere
no questions. your going to ASCABAN
edit AZKABAN
yep
That "firey depths of heck" was so good😂
Also Voldy's uncle and gramps only got a few months to a year each.
In a Scorose fanfiction, She suggested killing Dementors for slippers instead of bunnies because she thought they were killing bunnies for slippers and that was wrong.
I'd wear dementor slippers
Pretty sure they used the storm as cover
No they were going to play brolf
@@ashburch4779 IKR it was explained at the start of the video
@You’re Late! I know I'm just sticking to it
I thought the same thing. Bad weather means less muggles out and harder to see clearly. We know from the HP series when Hermione made Harry's Quidditch googles impervious to rain that wizards have a way for seeing better in rainy weather.
MACUSA wasn’t successful in holding Grindelwald. He switched places with Abernathy through transfiguration. Thus, why he had to give Abernathy a new tongue in the flying carriage.
Lupin was great at brolf, he was well know for his howl in ones.
Groan
I wanted to add to the puns but i coldn't think of anything
Grindelwald broke out of the first prison eventually and Voldemort broke in to him in the second.
"Yes, members of the enemy army, you may guard your former allies! That seems like a really good idea." - Just point #394 why the Wizarding world makes no freakin' sense.
you should do a video on magical creatures/plants, and how muggles never see them/be able to use the plants and potions, especially if they live on the same universe
Why wasn’t the wizard allowed to play quidditch
He was azkabanned
Oooffff
But can he play some *brolf?*
😂👏👏👏👏
*ba dum tiss*
The People vs Ilai’s Magic:
Ilai’s Magic, you have been accused of making a horrendous joke. Should you plead guilty, you are consigned to the depths of heck (2:14). Should you plead innocent and be found guilty, you shall be given a life sentence in Azkaban. How do you plead.
This is crazy, I discussed the ethics of Azkaban on my channel just a few weeks ago. Awesome timing! I kind of answer your question to Ben in that video, but ultimately what it comes down to, I think, is one's philosophy of what a prison is meant to do. Azkaban's success rate during the era of the dementors is undeniable.
Kevin Lohmann I loved your video on Azkaban and prison ethics.
I'd say prison is supposed to be for reform really. if someone is never going to be let out you'd be better off just excuting them. well unless you're particularly sadistic or prone to miscarriages of justice.
Reform vs keep locked up is a very grey area, some people can be reformed and some people trick you into thinking they are just so they get out again.
Best would be if you could reform everyone, but that is not the case
@@TGPDrunknHick Except dying is easy. There's no punishment there. Your life ends and that's it.
The punishment in prison is knowing you will never escape, never achieve anything else, and being completely devoid of all hope.
@@lyntonfleming and your point? unless you intend to reform someone all you do by putting them in prison is waste resources. it's pointless. to leave someone to rot isn't justice. it's revenge and all it does is blacken the heart and waste food and manpower better off somewhere else in society.
There is evidence that suggests that there are other sentences of time in Azkaban.
“If the Ministry and Voldemort are behind Snape it’ll be a choice between staying and teaching, or a few nice years in Azkaban - and that’s if they’re lucky”(Deathly Hallows, p. 226).
This proves that life isn’t the only known sentence in Azkaban because even Harry, known for needing Ron to provide wizarding world facts, thought of time in Azkaban in terms of years.
(Sorry if someone else quoted this. I’m not trying to copy)
I think that if the people in Azkaban really deserved it, then the dementors were worth it. But then again they do trap some pretty innocent people so maybe they should have a prison for “Not so Bad Prisoners.”
Agreed, remember they sent Hagrid there in Chamber of Secrets in the ministries (usual) imcompetent attempt to control the situation at Hogwarts.
I feel bad for him everytime i think about it, poor cuddly Hagrid probably crying about Hermione petrified, people blaming Harry and Fang all alone wondering where he is.
2:48 ok now I really want a comic series of dementors as regular guards in their staff room
There may be different amounts of ‘guarding’ at Azkaban depending on your crime; Sirius was one of the most heavily guarded prisoners, so I always imagined Dementors basically posted outside his door.
That said, no, pretty sure that nothing is worth having Dementors around, especially when they don’t effect the most horrible people the same as normal people!
Great video 😁
I think Grindelwald just let them keep him there, and thought he was being kept at MACUSA because he's 'special.'
Edit: **I** thought they kept him ...
Trinka B Obviously not.
@@Ranger1812 why 'obviously'?
They didn't hold him. He escaped and made a body double from one of the staff and assumed that man's identity. Am I wrong?
@@BrunoLejdfelt True, but the guy who swapped with him was sitting there waiting, letting him be 'captured' until the wheels had turned.
@@BrunoLejdfelt They held him until it was a good time for him to escape = he let them hold him there
Azkaban isn’t solely used for life sentences. The Gaunts (marvolo and morphin) were sent to Azkaban for a few months(marvolo) or a few years (morphin) but not life.
I really dig the idea of an elite force of wizards landing on the island full of dementors, summoning charms and powerful defensive magic, only to then engage in the sorts of frolicking and merrymaking carefully calculated to cause their numbers to wane.
“We are just ending our water-balloon fight, then we begin the hide and seek, just before the ice cream Sunday party and snuggles with puppies, sir.”
I know that it's not related but will you guys please please please make a video debunking the "Ginny slipped Harry a love potion" theory??? #Please
I will comment it until you make one, please don't get annoyed. Love your videos
I am not familiar with this theory..
@@SuperCarlinBrothers omg....thanks for replying.....I know this theory is ridiculous and mostly based of the films but some people argue for this one very much! they even bring up Molly mentioning love potion in Prisoner of Azkaban too. Apparently Harry having a loving family with Ginny is not enough! I love your videos
Jannatul Shoilee I’m really not a fan of that theory🤪#Hinny
@@pan-opticon Me neither...I have always wanted #Hinny #Romione and #Nuna
that's why I want the theory debunked so bad....I don't see how the story would play if Harry was with Hermione...the whole Deathly Hallows would be different.
Jannatul Shoilee also like, Ginny doesn’t even need a love potion, besides, it doesn’t add anything good to the story, quite the contrary...And yes, Ron and Hermione are too cute! Her and Harry, i feel, are just like siblings.
"Obviously terrible people keep getting into positions of power"
Welcome to the world lol :)
2:14 I’m convinced J is speaking Parseltongue
What was he even saying? I couldn't understand him.
You mean J not ben
Sentinel LJ oops got em mixed up lol
@@framesofscreen lol
@@framesofscreen so after listening to that over and over I can confirm that J says "The depths of heck."
Sounds more like the prisoners are at Azkaban as food for the dementors, to make sure both the prisoners and the guardians stays on the island...
Arthur Weasley does talk about fining people
Love the new format and editing! Really brings out your creativity and special-ness.
I just finished binge watching your Harry Potter videos and then this came out! Great timing lol
Because they can demenTORMENT the prisoners
No.the puns are deadly
Naughty Niffler Well DADs a dad joke!
Off to azkaban you naughty niffler for making a terrible pun
That is the most bad pun
Okay everyone is hating on your pun but i'm just applauding it
I'm not a huge Harry Potter fan but your enthusiasm is contagious and I love your videos! The perfect tonic for the weirdness of the real world. So glad I found your channel :)
The body switching thing was also used in the first film, to get Grindelwald switched with Graves. It only works with a willing brainwashed minion.
11:45
That is my true beast within.👹
Click the time over and over. 😁
😂😂😂
😮😯😂😂😂😂😂😂🖤💛🖤
Elanor Allmann
I love this response, even though I have no idea what it means. 😅
Abadon is actually pronounced avadon.. the Hebrew letter for b' can be pronounced like v' so...
Also this word is actually derived from the word אבד (avad/abad) which is another Hebrew word for loss so abadon can also mean a great loss. But yeah it also means doom or dimise
And dont @ me my first language is Hebrew 😂
Now l'm wondering if that's how we got "abandon".
@@TheDanishGuyReviews hmmmm
בדיוק
I was about to comment this
Accurate thanks.
How come in the books Nurmengard is a prison and in the movie, it's a cool castle that Grindelwald chooses to be his residence?
Yes, he built prison in his castle for his enemies, but it was used for himself
Can I just say how much I love the intro real quick? I don’t think it gets enough recognition.
Dumbledors father was sentenced to 3 years, but died. Sturgis Podmore and Mavolo Gaut got 6 months (?), Morfin also got 3 years i think, etc.
Imagine if the wizarding version of waterboarding is a giant pensive chamber filled with the inmates worst memory
In book six it says that Merope Gaunt
's family who attacked the muggles can a specific sentences. I think the brother got two years.
167 views
291 likes
It’s official the Super Carlin Brothers are magic!
the statute of secrecy is broken "obliviate"
Love your theories and how detailed you go. I have a question that I think needs an answer. How often does a wizard go dark? Obviously it often enough that teenagers need to be taught to defend against it. And then there's a whole department of the ministry for dealing with them.
“That no one can escape”
Until Sirius does
He used Polyjuice Potion to disguise himself and the person pretending to be him
How did he have polyjuice potion though
@@sentinellj He was persuasive, very... So you know, he talked to the security and talked and talked and got the potion done by them, and delivered. After all he had quite a while to make them do it before they silenced him (although, they thought it was him, he changed before that). There had to be a reason they did it so why wouldn't it be potion making stuff?
Umm, people aren't sent to Azkaban forever. Sure, murdering someone and using any of the unforgivable curses on another human will give a one-way ticket there but people like the Gaunts was there for only some years.
I was thinking the same thing and was looking in the comments for someone who pointed it out
@@tessvanroessel8045 same
and hagrid
Even Grindelwald was sentenced to house arrest for life
Sirius Black was sentenced to life in Azkaban
214 likes
3 views
Well done, UA-cam. You clearly have intelligence above our comprehension.
UA-cam first scans the views for bots
it's not only life sentences in Azkaban, on page 592, it says, "Ludovic Bagman, you were caught passing information to Lord Voldemort's supporters," said Mr. Crouch. "for this, I suggest a term of imprisonment in Azkaban lasting no less than-"
The fact that he said, "I suggest a TERM" and "imprisonment ...of no less than-" suggests that he was not about to sentence him for life.
Besides, I can't imagine Crouch saying; "for this, I suggest a term of imprisonment in Azkaban lasting no less than LIFE."
That's just way too sassy for Crouch.
But I'm not a hater. You guys are awesome.
Another thing I've been asking myself for a while now: where even is Grindelwald from? ... We know he's from somewhere in Europe and Grindelwald is a German name.. So in my opinion the possibilities could be: .. well Germany, Austria because Nurmengard is located there or Switzerland because there is an actual city named "Grindelwald" there. But he could also be from somewhere around eastern Europe because he attended Durmstrang..
This question is bothering me for quite some time know and I hope to get a (canon) answer soon (maybe/hopefully in the next part of fantastic beasts...?)
Lina the only possibility I’ve thought of is Bulgaria, or somewhere nearby. We know that Krum attended Durmstrang and played for Bulgaria during the World Cup. While it sounds like Hogwarts serves just the UK, it’s possible that Durmstrang serves multiple countries in eastern/Central Europe. Since no other country was ever mentioned, I always assumed that Durmstrang was in Bulgaria, but I could be wrong. In keeping with its "dark arts leaning" persona, I would guess that Durmstrang could be located in Transylvania. This part of Romania would make sense both symbolically and practically as a German and Bulgarian student could both live close enough to attend.
So your assumption that Grindelwald could be German seems spot on.
But now the question is.... If Durmstrang is so landlocked, why do they decide to use a ship to travel to Hogwarts? It almost seems like they mixed up their transportation methods with Beauxbatons. At least France has coastlines.
@@cgrimes34 we could say durmstrang is in bulgaria they have a coste line
Anyone else want to play Bolf?!
Body switching? I thought it was polyjuice potion.
I think that Abernathy is very skilled and will continue to play a part in the next movie. Perhaps Grindelwald taught him advanced transfiguration.
@@julieabrahamsen8637 didn't Abernathy die in the devotion-fire? I could be wrong, only watched the film once when it came out. 🤔😄
@@masha7377 nope, he survived.
also, Grindelwald escaped before they cut the tongue off, Abernathy had his toung cut off by macusa
EDIT: Abernathy's page on the harry potter wiki said that he is an expert in transfiguration, and it was his transfiguration skills that were used to switch with Grindelwald. (he wasnt manipulated like other guards, he was actually loyal to Grindelwald)
Original text: The screenplay just says "transforming", doesnt tell us whether it is polyjuice or transfiguration. grindelwald isnt listed as a user of polyjuice on the harry potter wiki (newt is listed there).
@@masha7377 It was Krall who died in the flames.
@@robk5969 that's clearer but one thing I really dislike is when you need to lean heavily on pottermore to understand or explain something in the books or films. The books were much better for this. If it's not in the texts it's not canon for me so the move to just fixing explanations in post, essentially, is really jarring. And I actually didn't hate the movie. Fantastic beasts needs to get better though. They could start by renaming it and not wasting time on adding beast scenes that add little to the story to justify the title.
Well the rain and stuff would be to hide them better
Also BROLF NEW FAVOURITE SPORT
My interpretation of Grindlewald's escape is that he'd actually escaped weeks before and was using polyjuice or some other spell to impersonate his guard, who was now trapped in Grindlewald's cell without a tongue.
Why didn't he just escape then? I have no idea.
Maybe he thought a midair escape would be more impressive, and that it would muddy the waters of when he'd actually escaped and who was responsible, causing a rift between magical law enforcement agencies who now blamed each other for his escape.
I think the movie suggests that he actually wants to leave his guard behind and escape, but he's forced to hand the bloodpact over and so has to return for it.
Either way, I don't think MACUSA is actually successful in imprisoning him.
2:09 the depths of heck. I’ve been dying of laughter for the past 5 minutes lol
_THE DEPTHS OF H E C K ! ! !_
BROLF is my new sport!
you merly adopted brolf I was born with it molded by it
I mean with Hagrid and Dumbledore the Ministry was EXTREMELY corrupt. Part of the reason Hagrid was sentenced so harshly was because he is a minority. A half breed. And for Dumbledore the people in the ministry loved him or hated him and both sides influenced the other. I.e Lucius manipulating the school board or the minister letting Dumbledore get away with questionable school decisions.
Macusa didn't hold Grindlewald "without issue". There was a line about them having to switch out people a few times due to his charisma.