The Rakshasa - Ravana & Vibhishana - Hindu - Extra Mythology

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 707

  • @extrahistory
    @extrahistory  3 роки тому +108

    The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/extracredits09211

    • @margaretkairu7418
      @margaretkairu7418 3 роки тому +2

      God save the Queen

    • @Danidan282
      @Danidan282 3 роки тому +2

      Can you do an episode about the ten royal martyrs (עשרת הרוגי מלכות) legend? It's a Jewish legend described in the poam "ele ezcera" (אלה אזכרה)

    • @gursimarsingh5505
      @gursimarsingh5505 3 роки тому

      You may find it interesting to read and make an episode about baba deep singh ji.
      Trust me. Search it. You will definitely find the battle which he fought very interesting. I'm not telling here because you may think I'm joking.

    • @jastiwana1391
      @jastiwana1391 3 роки тому

      After years of commenting and requesting videos on the subcontinent, you guys finally delivered after the saragarhi vids.. i hope more will come too. Thank you

    • @Wintermute909
      @Wintermute909 3 роки тому

      They're " *mighty* incisors!"

  • @अजिङ्क्यगोखले

    3:00 Elaborating, Kumbhakarna actually wanted to ask for "Indraasana" (Indra's throne, where Indra is the chief of the deities), and the Gods knew this. So they asked Saraswati (Goddess of learning and speech) to occupy his tongue so he may mispronounce his wish. As a result, Kumbhakarna mispronounced "Indraasana" as "Nidraasana", literally meaning "sleeping couch". Brahma was more than happy to grant that.

    • @thomasfoster4370
      @thomasfoster4370 Рік тому +35

      divine dyslexic episode ftw

    • @Ornzora
      @Ornzora Рік тому +21

      But bro, imagine if he's actually ask for Indra's sleeping couch just because he's petty and salty, so he just want Indra to have backache everytime they meet 😂

    • @claudius3359
      @claudius3359 7 місяців тому

      ​@@OrnzoraNow that's a big brain move

  • @pavarottiaardvark3431
    @pavarottiaardvark3431 3 роки тому +327

    3:52 like at this point Shiva is like 90 thousand years into a 100 thousand year enlightenment process and the interruption forces him to start again, so he's kinda mad about it.

    • @LocalHeretic-ck1kd
      @LocalHeretic-ck1kd 3 роки тому +45

      I see. In this case makes his reaction much more sense.

    • @yashcharanmahenthiran8989
      @yashcharanmahenthiran8989 3 роки тому +9

      Shiva is already enlightened.

    • @generalalduin9548
      @generalalduin9548 3 роки тому +6

      How can you be more enlightened when you’re literally one of the three most powerful gods of the universe?

    • @alexanderkarvos6728
      @alexanderkarvos6728 3 роки тому +25

      @@generalalduin9548 enlightment ++

    • @ValkyrieTiara
      @ValkyrieTiara 3 роки тому +11

      @@generalalduin9548 Maybe power doesn't necessarily lead to enlightenment

  • @abcdef27669
    @abcdef27669 3 роки тому +674

    Zahhak finding Ravana in Hell: "I just wanna say that I'm a huge fan..."

    • @apeman9238
      @apeman9238 3 роки тому +9

      It is pronounced Rawan

    • @lordbelou7279
      @lordbelou7279 3 роки тому +19

      XD
      Zahak have more style tho
      Snakes on shoulders is better than 10 heads

    • @sumanthganapathibasavapatn141
      @sumanthganapathibasavapatn141 3 роки тому +35

      @@apeman9238 Nope! The Sanskrit original is pronounced Raa-va-Na (ˈraːʋɐɳɐ).

    • @apeman9238
      @apeman9238 3 роки тому +3

      @@sumanthganapathibasavapatn141 I learned to say Rawan.

    • @srikrishnak196
      @srikrishnak196 3 роки тому +10

      @@apeman9238 That's for Hindi speakers maybe, they don't pronounce the schwa

  • @AlokAwasthii
    @AlokAwasthii 3 роки тому +417

    A small correction-Rama didn’t hit Ravana in the heart, he shot him in the neval instead, thereby soaking his immortality nectar. Vibhishana told Rama about his brother’s secret that Ravana can’t be killed except by that particular way. 😝

    • @motirpahas
      @motirpahas 3 роки тому +21

      The navel story you are telling is absent in "Valmiki Ramayan"

    • @AnshuSingh-oq9go
      @AnshuSingh-oq9go 3 роки тому +7

      @@motirpahas great
      Us Indians have been fed lies then

    • @motirpahas
      @motirpahas 3 роки тому +44

      @@AnshuSingh-oq9go Not lies. There are many stories that are retelling of ramayan in various local texts. Like Ramcaritamanas, Krittibasi, Kamb Ramayan etc.
      But those stories are absent in Valmiki Ramayana.

    • @caliburn1123
      @caliburn1123 Рік тому +8

      ​@@AnshuSingh-oq9go there are many versions of the Ramayana, there are even ones where Sita is Ravan's daughter

    • @pratikmandal1350
      @pratikmandal1350 Рік тому +1

      @@motirpahas Out of curiosity, do you know which version mentions the naval weak spot? It is the Ramcharitamanas? Or some other local version? I googled and didn't get any clear answer.

  • @vatsalsrivastav5175
    @vatsalsrivastav5175 3 роки тому +158

    there is a saying in hindi, "ghar ka bhedi lanka dhaaye" which roughly means, "your own kin will be the cause of the fall of your home" just as vibhishan was the fall of ravana's home

    • @saahiliyer11
      @saahiliyer11 3 роки тому +11

      That does seem to be the running theme in most myths. Lookin at you Kauravas.

    • @saahiliyer11
      @saahiliyer11 3 роки тому +9

      @Aadi jain Greek gods: *murders kin ever other week.
      Also greek gods: ORESTES, HOW DARE YOU KILL YOUR FAMILY

    • @Schizoidsafin
      @Schizoidsafin 2 роки тому +6

      In bangladesh or kolkata there is a saying ghorer shotru bibishon. ( there is no v in bangla)

  • @MohitPJoshi
    @MohitPJoshi 3 роки тому +204

    Yeah, one thing, Hanuman wasn't the Monkey King, it would be Bali and then Sugriva.

    • @turgonysmir5632
      @turgonysmir5632 3 роки тому +17

      And then Angad, although Hanuman ji is clearly the most powerful

    • @F2_CPB
      @F2_CPB 3 роки тому +19

      @@turgonysmir5632 Definitely. But he still technically wasn't the king

    • @FishBoneD14
      @FishBoneD14 3 роки тому +24

      Second thing Sita was already in exile so no guards at time of kidnapping.

    • @यतोधर्मःततोजयः
      @यतोधर्मःततोजयः 3 роки тому +4

      *NONE* of them were monkeys guys.
      All of them were *Neanderthal Men*

    • @MohitPJoshi
      @MohitPJoshi 3 роки тому +11

      @@यतोधर्मःततोजयः yeah Neanderthal used to have tail which Raavan threatened to burn in case of Hanuman ji
      Matlab kuch bhiii????

  • @JustinWahlne
    @JustinWahlne 3 роки тому +245

    EC: Hanuman, the Monkey King
    Sun: Did someone say...
    EC: No, not THAT Monkey King!

    • @shubhambhalekar9743
      @shubhambhalekar9743 3 роки тому +41

      Funnily enough hanuman also almost ate Sun when he was child 😂.

    • @arbuz_kawon
      @arbuz_kawon 3 роки тому +39

      Sun Wukong is actually based on Hanuman

    • @yasharthrathore3087
      @yasharthrathore3087 3 роки тому +11

      @@shubhambhalekar9743 they are not talking about that sun. They are talking about Sun Wukong from journey to the west. who also happens to be a monkey king.

    • @vishalprajapati3651
      @vishalprajapati3651 3 роки тому +24

      Hanuman isn't monkey king cause they aren't monkeys they are kapi vanar plus hanuman isn't their king its sugreev the vanar raaj

    • @yasharthrathore3087
      @yasharthrathore3087 3 роки тому +4

      @@vishalprajapati3651 Actually these stories have many versions. Some are familiar some are completely different. There is no fact checking in mythology. Maybe the version they went with had Hanuman as the king. And the more common version has sugreev as the king.

  • @GEOTHERMALHEAT0
    @GEOTHERMALHEAT0 3 роки тому +104

    Ravana did commit many sins and his ego was the reason for his downfall
    But he was a very wise and just ruler, he was a Brahmin with very good knowledge of the scriptures

    • @pratikmandal1350
      @pratikmandal1350 Рік тому +6

      Plus was very skilled in many arts.

    • @anonymous-d5s
      @anonymous-d5s Рік тому +7

      he not a wise and just ruler , but yes was a mahapandit with knowledge of everything , with a big ego , and his ego leading him to do evil things.

    • @Delllatitude7490
      @Delllatitude7490 Рік тому +1

      i don't think you consider him just ruler if you actually read Uttara Ramayam(it's like an extra for Ramayana, which details the events before and after actual Ramyana) 50% of it is about Ravan's evil rule.

    • @achintyanaithani889
      @achintyanaithani889 5 місяців тому

      So what if he could quote some antique texts?

  • @natalkumar6132
    @natalkumar6132 3 роки тому +229

    Also, the appearance of Rakshasas you have selected is from the Indian Artform Yakshagaana or the Dance and singing of the Yakshas .

    • @MegaGun2000
      @MegaGun2000 3 роки тому +2

      Ikr! I as so impressed!

    • @sahastraanshu6143
      @sahastraanshu6143 3 роки тому +2

      funny thing is yaksa is adversaries of rakshasha

    • @puneetmishra4726
      @puneetmishra4726 3 роки тому +2

      And this is actually the oldest art form of India, tracing its origin back in the day of Natya Shastra

  • @shubharthidutta979
    @shubharthidutta979 3 роки тому +481

    Extra credits : make a video on ancient Indian culture
    Their Indian viewers: we have been summoned

    • @dark._.water._.reflection-og
      @dark._.water._.reflection-og 3 роки тому +9

      true

    • @danand75
      @danand75 3 роки тому +14

      We all are crying tears of joy
      The sheer amount of Indian mythology along with upcoming series on India
      My heart can't take it

    • @Cheshire1501
      @Cheshire1501 3 роки тому

      FGO Players: Can we have a seat?

    • @ohlesi910
      @ohlesi910 3 роки тому +1

      Berserk fans 😈

    • @FlaviusBelisarius-ck6uv
      @FlaviusBelisarius-ck6uv 3 роки тому +5

      Like hell. This video was awful, so much inaccuracy and many things said out of context.

  • @ppsaha1994
    @ppsaha1994 3 роки тому +95

    5:02 Okay I'm not sure if this is from a local Ramayana, but the Valmiki Ramayana and most mainstream ones portray Ravana as a very just king. He would never willingly harm the people of Lanka and would just take his shenanigans elsewhere.

    • @sealofapoorval7437
      @sealofapoorval7437 3 роки тому +22

      agreed. I have also always heard that Ravan was very educated, smart and a just king who performed many sacrifices. Never heard him oppress Lankan people.

    • @SaraLovelace1
      @SaraLovelace1 3 роки тому +8

      Same. And he was respectful of Sita as well; he wanted her for his wife but wouldn't force her, nor force himself on her.

    • @vishalprajapati3651
      @vishalprajapati3651 3 роки тому +25

      @@SaraLovelace1 that's another story he didn't forced Mata sita cause of a curse that he got nulkuber

    • @sahastraanshu6143
      @sahastraanshu6143 3 роки тому +12

      LOL Ravana eradicated yakhsha nagas slaughter danav clan kings and nobles

    • @mythicalsoulz4709
      @mythicalsoulz4709 Рік тому +6

      @@SaraLovelace1 thats because of a curse, ravana was learned and scholarly but twice as lusty, he just couldnt force himself on an unconsenting woman due to a curse.

  • @warmachineuk
    @warmachineuk 3 роки тому +86

    That cuts out a huge amount from the Ramayana. Unavoidable considering the book's epic length.

  • @shreyasom9751
    @shreyasom9751 3 роки тому +212

    I am surprised how close this comes to the original story. But, being an Indian I will like to correct some facts:
    1. Ravana asked for "Amrit" or the elixir of eternal life, but it could be drank only by gods. So Ravana placed the pot of the elixir in his belly button and would be granted invincibility till the pot is intact.
    2. Ravana conquered with Lanka after getting only his first boon and not the sword.
    3. Ravana didn't grow heads like a hydra, he was so knowledgeable that the information could not be stored in 1 head. But when he asked for a boon from Lord Shiva, shiva told him that his heads did not represent his knowledge anymore rather represented his arrogance, on which Ravana chopped all his head and in return god shiva's sword. He proceeded to become shiva's devotee. He also got a "panchshool" or a 5 pronged trident which protected Lanka from any harm from outside.
    4. He once asked shiva to come to his mansion and reside there as staying at a mountain like Kailash was not fit for such a divine being. But Shiva was deep in meditation then Ravana decided to pick the hole mountain and take it with him. But when shiva set his foot down, the mountain crashed on Ravanas hand. When he asked for another chance, he was given the task to take a shivaling (a representation of lord shiva) to Lanka without setting it on the ground once. But was tricked by the gods into doing so.
    5. Ravana got angry and swore vengeance on the gods, he went and captured every god (Not supreme gods aka Brahma Vishnu Shiva) and petrified them like a statue in his palace halls.
    6. Sita was not being protected by guards rather was in exile for 14 years with his husband Ram and hid brother Laxman. The brothers were tricked by Ravana into following a golden deer(which Sita demanded) and took the form of a beggar to capture her.\
    7. Hanuman although strongest was not the king rather a minister in the court of Monkey King Sugreev, and along with an army completely compromised of beasts and vanars(they were not complete monkey-like nowadays, rather were trained monkeys that wielded weapons and armours).
    8. In the battle the arrow was shot in Ravana's belly button(as Vibhishan told them the secret about the elixir pot) and hence died.

    • @shreyasom9751
      @shreyasom9751 3 роки тому +42

      One more fact, Hanuman once went inside the lanka set the city on fire, as a result, destroying the city from inside and removing the protection from the 5 pronged trident or panchshool.

    • @sealofapoorval7437
      @sealofapoorval7437 3 роки тому +9

      Very well summarized. I hope they address this in their "Lies" episode

    • @radiatoram8187
      @radiatoram8187 3 роки тому +11

      In Indonesian version, Rahvana can't die in any way so Hanuman butchered him and put a mountain above him.

    • @tentathesane8032
      @tentathesane8032 3 роки тому +16

      @@radiatoram8187 that's the demon king Bali in Indian mythology, not Ravana.

    • @aashutoshnair5500
      @aashutoshnair5500 3 роки тому +4

      @Shreyas Om you forgot to mention Shurpanaka(pardon for spelling mistake), Ravana's sister whi was obsessed with Ram but when she found out that he was already married to Sita, tried to kill her and got her nose and ears chpped off by Laxman. Ravana had kidnapped Sita to get revenge for his sister

  • @rudrakshgupta6028
    @rudrakshgupta6028 3 роки тому +62

    5:34 sidenote here hanuman isn't the monkey king, thats sugrieve, he is just a god-ish monkey (kind of like Sun Wukong) who just gained the blessing of some gods, which is why he is so powerful. Correct me if im wrong

    • @turgonysmir5632
      @turgonysmir5632 3 роки тому +16

      Hanuman is a god himself, he is a rudra incarnation of Lord Shiva, but yes he also has blessings of other gods as well.

    • @burnlikethephoenix
      @burnlikethephoenix 3 роки тому +4

      As per the mythology I have been told and read, Hanuman is a Demi-god or a miracle child from the essence of the God Vayu (this I feel is a very subtle or mystical way of saying that he procreated with a human 😅).

    • @walterwhite8229
      @walterwhite8229 3 роки тому

      @@burnlikethephoenix
      From what I've heard:
      Shiva and Parvati born into the world of mortals as monkeys, and had a child.
      They couldn't keep that child, so they gave them to Vayu.
      Vayu raised Hanuman in the heavens, then sent him back to Earth. He was born to a mere mortal woman, which explains his human features.

    • @chethanveena613
      @chethanveena613 3 роки тому

      Hunuman did not get blessed by lords by was the son of God viua the God of wind so naturally se had powers

    • @maximaldinotrap
      @maximaldinotrap 3 роки тому +1

      That might as well make him the Monkey King

  • @vishnuvardhan9372
    @vishnuvardhan9372 3 роки тому +65

    Though the story is correct, some visuals are wrong.
    When Sita was kidnapped, she was in the forest. I was pleasantly surprised you covered about Shiva punishing Ravana. Shiva gave the boon of "Huge Strength" to Ravana, not sword. Also, Shiva wasn't pleased by Ravana's head offering, Ravana screamed for 100yrs due to the punishment. Those screams disturbed others, just for sake of others, Shiva freed Ravana.
    Wish your team could review this script with some Indian experts on these topics. TBH, I am happy with the level of detail from a foreigner, it's just that I feel these gaps would also have been fulfilled.

    • @lucidnonsense942
      @lucidnonsense942 3 роки тому +6

      There are many versions of this story, before they coalesce around the current version most Indians know. Their take is more like the OG scripts.

    • @divyanshushete5772
      @divyanshushete5772 3 роки тому +4

      Ravana got the Sword "Chandrahas" by Shiva. Those were not only screams he also composed "Shiv Tandav Stotra" when he was crushed under the mount Kailash.

    • @vishnuvardhan9372
      @vishnuvardhan9372 3 роки тому +1

      @@lucidnonsense942 yep true, but Valmiki ramayana is considered as the proper source. While writing his ramayana, he had a blessing that not only he would know the true story, but he will also know the intentions of that character while doing that task. So, I prefer Valmiki Ramayana as a primary source and rest others as prone to writer's imagination.

    • @vishnuvardhan9372
      @vishnuvardhan9372 3 роки тому +1

      @@divyanshushete5772 I will try to go through my sources, probably you are correct. Ravana got boons from Shiva many times.

    • @vishalprajapati3651
      @vishalprajapati3651 3 роки тому +1

      @@vishnuvardhan9372 he is called maha shiv Bhakt for a reason after all

  • @ritheshofficial
    @ritheshofficial 3 роки тому +323

    I love how you stayed true to the complexions, It's really sad and heartbreaking to see people in India white washing our own legends and mythologies all the time.

    • @shrutivsec
      @shrutivsec 3 роки тому +6

      Ram is blue..what complexion is that??

    • @liamsawyer8193
      @liamsawyer8193 3 роки тому +46

      @@shrutivsec Divine complexion

    • @yj9032
      @yj9032 3 роки тому +6

      @@shrutivsec ravana and Sita are dedicated by fairest actors in indian tv

    • @gardenhead92
      @gardenhead92 3 роки тому +7

      @@shrutivsec he blue himself

    • @anybody1325
      @anybody1325 3 роки тому +16

      @@liamsawyer8193 thats no divine complexion he was dark skinned so was krishan we are simply ashamed to admit our gods are dark skinned so we paint them blue

  • @nhienleminhhue6605
    @nhienleminhhue6605 3 роки тому +43

    i did learn about this epic in grade 10. We Vietnamese are really fascinated with Indian Myths and epics

    • @ManabDasiammanab
      @ManabDasiammanab 2 роки тому

      These aren’t Myths actually. It’s history. Abrahamic religion calls it myth because they wanna destroy the Dharmic religion. But the truth is Abrahamic religions are real myth. There was no Adam and Eve.

    • @ManabDasiammanab
      @ManabDasiammanab 2 роки тому +1

      Rakshasha are Dravidians (South Indians) Yakshasha are Indian Tribals and Asuras are Persians.

    • @hellomoto2084
      @hellomoto2084 Рік тому +5

      ​@@ManabDasiammanab hahhahaaa rakshaas had divine powers so did asuras
      Oh wrong you are, linking mythology with european influenced racial theory

    • @MrGhostTheBigRoast
      @MrGhostTheBigRoast Рік тому

      @@hellomoto2084 yes. magic is real. and also btw india actually invented everything thousands of years ago, everything from smart watches to cold fusion existed in india back then before the muslims and british stole them 😤😤😤

  • @JackWolf1
    @JackWolf1 3 роки тому +61

    … wow, talk about timing. I just fought Ravana in Final Fantasy 14 two days ago, and I was curious what myth he was drawn from. Looks like I got my answer.

    • @xenonnboy
      @xenonnboy 3 роки тому +4

      REJOICE IN THE GLORY OF COMBAT

    • @nataliekennedy4646
      @nataliekennedy4646 3 роки тому

      it’s a religion called Hindu ism have some respect

  • @Rakshasa1986
    @Rakshasa1986 3 роки тому +47

    One of my favourite D&D monsters.

    • @SuperParkourio
      @SuperParkourio 3 роки тому +4

      What? There's no way! No one can just deflect the Eldritch Blast!

    • @brendanrivers4737
      @brendanrivers4737 3 роки тому +2

      Oh hell yeah!

    • @mcpeguru4060
      @mcpeguru4060 3 роки тому

      What is D&D ???

    • @kaltaron1284
      @kaltaron1284 3 роки тому +2

      I love them in Exalted. Basically formless energy beings roleplaying at being real.

    • @SuperParkourio
      @SuperParkourio 3 роки тому +3

      @@mcpeguru4060 Dungeons & Dragons, in which rakshasas are a type of monster notoriously immune to all but the strongest spells.

  • @Funlawyer1106
    @Funlawyer1106 3 роки тому +17

    Ravana did not offer Shiva his head but rather tore the sinew from his arm strung it to his fingers to make a harp and sang his praises and hymns. It was upon witnessing this act of devotion that Shiva gifted Ravana with the immortal blade and further boons.

  • @claypye
    @claypye 3 роки тому +29

    You’ve left us on a cliff hanger in Celtic mythology for over 2 years please give us part 3 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @marcmcdonnell6586
    @marcmcdonnell6586 3 роки тому +68

    I read about these guys from a books known as the Serpent’s Secret except that loosely based on Bangladesh folklore and some elements of cosmic science. But hey I’m a grown man whose getting back to reading good books on Indian inspired fictional books accusationaly other fantasy books and sometimes Disney.

    • @takiranayaki7870
      @takiranayaki7870 3 роки тому +3

      hindus believed those characters are factual not fictional lol

    • @kayleigh0711
      @kayleigh0711 3 роки тому +3

      @@takiranayaki7870 EC and EM have done vids on Christianity too, so is chill

  • @arthurrafra9576
    @arthurrafra9576 2 роки тому +12

    I miss this series so much, please we need more extra mythology content 😢
    (and not just some youtube shorts)

  • @ayushbhardwas
    @ayushbhardwas 3 роки тому +27

    Umm, some pieces where... Ah misinterpreted to say the least, but that's understandable. I'll just mention a few... Ravan's weakness (and yeah that how we pronounce it Ravan and not Ravana 😅 but yeah we add an "a" in the end probably because of some complexities with Sanskrit to Hindi to English.) was his navel and that's where he was shot. There was no one with Seta when Ravana came, also he came as a wandering sage and not exactly beggar, asking "Bhiksha" umm kinda different from begging. And there are others but that would make this long. But in all honesty it was interesting :)

  • @abhi_survase
    @abhi_survase 3 роки тому +48

    The tangents and narrative of the Ramayana this videos goes into, I've never heard about them. Can I get a source to read about it myself.

    • @RishabhSharma-rs2ez
      @RishabhSharma-rs2ez 3 роки тому +1

      Do you wanna read ramayana ? Or the story of the video about rakshasa?

    • @abhi_survase
      @abhi_survase 3 роки тому +6

      @@RishabhSharma-rs2ez Specifically about the past of Ravana and his father
      Also the origin of Rakshasa being Brahma's breath

    • @turgonysmir5632
      @turgonysmir5632 3 роки тому +2

      @@abhi_survase The rakshasa and devas were born to the same sage, weren't they? But there's also a term called Brahma-rakshasa, maybe they are different groups

    • @walterwhite8229
      @walterwhite8229 3 роки тому +2

      @@turgonysmir5632
      Puranic stories and Vedic stories differ.

    • @MohitPJoshi
      @MohitPJoshi 3 роки тому +3

      @@turgonysmir5632 devas and asuras were born of the same father albeit different mother, rakshasa are separate from Asuras

  • @msadityakumar1
    @msadityakumar1 3 роки тому +63

    I appreciate your efforts to make a video on Ramayana. But there are so many things you missed or wrongly said in this video. Although thanks for making this 😃

    • @ritheshofficial
      @ritheshofficial 3 роки тому +12

      There are many different interpretations and versions of the story throughout the subcontinent and across the extended Dharmic world(not sure if that's an actual term ^^') from India to Indonesia to Japan, kinda hard to please everyone if you ask me. Tho I agree they could've done bit more research on some things.

  • @davidillarretasolans6970
    @davidillarretasolans6970 3 роки тому +61

    Pffft, you are joking, it's not that Ravana was vulnerable to humans.
    He just had vulnerability to magical piercing damage dealt by creatures of good alignment.

    • @Mikeyfromtheblock1
      @Mikeyfromtheblock1 3 роки тому +6

      +100 holly damage weapons are tight

    • @zyzz9780
      @zyzz9780 3 роки тому +3

      @@Mikeyfromtheblock1 ahh I see you r a man of culture

    • @kushchronic697
      @kushchronic697 2 роки тому

      He can be kill by human because he dont event think of human as an insects that why he naver want protection from human

  • @veseti2
    @veseti2 3 роки тому +33

    The ending leaves much to be desired... Ramayana had a very sad and profound ending than a simply a human slaying an evil king.

    • @Phhase
      @Phhase 3 роки тому +2

      True. But that's a legend for another time.

    • @SaraLovelace1
      @SaraLovelace1 3 роки тому +5

      Well the Ravana's death is definitely not the ending of the Ramayana and this was about Ravana....

    • @sahastraanshu6143
      @sahastraanshu6143 3 роки тому +3

      @@SaraLovelace1 ravana death and ram darbar is end of valimiki ramyana ....... others stories belong to utherkand which is added in very late period

  • @kullen1041
    @kullen1041 3 роки тому +11

    Left the religion behind a long time ago, but still gotta enjoy the mythology for what it is ❤️

  • @finnmchugh99
    @finnmchugh99 3 роки тому +6

    Regardless of what culture, I love hearing about mythology it peeks into the culture it comes from

  • @wezza668
    @wezza668 3 роки тому +12

    How amazing is it to have such an ancient story to be told to us today? Anyone know a good (fun) book to read old Indian myths for a total dummy on the topic?

    • @divyanshushete5772
      @divyanshushete5772 3 роки тому +7

      You can search for Amar Chitra Katha Comic books for this they have alot of Indian myths in form of comics. For Specific normal reading you can go with Devdutt Patnaik's "Sita" and for Some OG feel you can try Ramcharitmanas by G. Tulsidas in english this was written in 17th century. Original text by Valmiki is much older than this all.

    • @shambhav9534
      @shambhav9534 3 роки тому +1

      Wikipedia, tbh. 😂

  • @acdc3730
    @acdc3730 3 роки тому +18

    Let's not forget that Ravana kidnapped Sita as retribution to Lakshman(Rama's brother) cutting off his sister's nose. Also he did not mistreat Sita while in captivity.
    I'm a Shaivite Hindu and if I had lived at that time, I'd probably be in Ravanas army. 😅
    He was not a cruel ruler, and the Tamil Hindus of Lanka venerate him to this day in their oldest Hindu temple (the most Ancient temple in the island 2600+ years old) to this day. This temple was build by Ravana for Shiva, and there is a prominent Ravana statue at the front of the temple
    He was also a scholar and a musician (he created Ragas that are popular to this day in south Indian Carnatic music) and while on his deathbed Rama learned the art of statecraft and good governance from Ravan, as he was considered the most learned person at the world at that time.
    Here is a video of him engaging in a musician competition (from a old movie)
    ua-cam.com/video/i7VzRz931aU/v-deo.html

    • @heyquitstealingmymoves6538
      @heyquitstealingmymoves6538 3 роки тому +5

      So you are side of a person whom Shiva didn't forgive even though he was his devotee and Shiva is easily forgive full..... Even Ram was also devotee of Shiva.....

    • @acdc3730
      @acdc3730 3 роки тому +1

      @@heyquitstealingmymoves6538 bro, Hinduism is vast, and many traditions make it what it is now. A lot of Puranas and other stories connect gods and others later in various ways, esp the story of Shiva forgiving etc.
      Also I'm pretty sure that Shiva was cool with what Ravana was doing. I've been to Ravanas temple(The Shiva temple) in Lanka, and standing on that hill, right next to the sea, seeing this amazing historical temple brought chills to me. I will chose Ravana if I have been given the choice. It's not that one is wrong or right..it's like the situation between Karna and the Pandavas
      Unfortunately the Buddhists in Lanka are trying to take over the temple and it's land. They want to hide the pre-buddhist history of this island, and claim Ravana was a Buddhist.lol

    • @RishabhSharma-rs2ez
      @RishabhSharma-rs2ez 3 роки тому +2

      @@heyquitstealingmymoves6538 he isnt taking side of ravana.bevause he is devout to he says he wasnt evil and but yes as in the video showing the overall intent of war was wrong as ravanas grandpa sumali wanted to use his grandson to challenge god for taking power and taking over with evil forces on the earth

  • @avinabaenator
    @avinabaenator 3 роки тому +4

    Can't believe how strayed this video is from the actual story

  • @bookdragon9987
    @bookdragon9987 3 роки тому +7

    This is another great video I really love mythology and this is one of my favourite ways to consume the media of myths

  • @tyrant-den884
    @tyrant-den884 3 роки тому +8

    Reminds me of a Piers Anthony novel where a Rakshasa and a Deva get in a contest over if a deva can get a young man laid a ton of times before the Rakshasa can kill him.

  • @widespirit7648
    @widespirit7648 3 роки тому +2

    Yes, Indian mythology. Thank you very much Extra Credits!

  • @susanthafonseka8078
    @susanthafonseka8078 3 роки тому +7

    This story has many interpretations where Lankans have their own which is very different from the mainstream story. So I am not worried about the story much. Anyway good to see south Asian mythologies on this channel.

  • @ericmcgill6300
    @ericmcgill6300 3 роки тому +1

    Forget about the video, the intro is fire

  • @anybody1325
    @anybody1325 3 роки тому +39

    This version is too weird man you left lots of part untouched. Ravan wasn't vulnerable to humans or else anyone would have killed him. Not mentioning shurpnakha and lakshman and not really explaining the Ram's situation makes it even more weird. Nice try though

  • @samiraperi467
    @samiraperi467 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks a bunch, Vishnu.

  • @lakshmikanthpadayachi508
    @lakshmikanthpadayachi508 3 роки тому +9

    What A Great Being That Nothing Short Of A God Can Kill Him😍🙌🏽

  • @arkmarine4806
    @arkmarine4806 3 роки тому +1

    Thankyou for covering Indian Mythology

  • @utkarshdubey3435
    @utkarshdubey3435 3 роки тому +14

    Wait! their are many interpretations of Ramayan and Ravan's story but I'm pretty sure Ram and Sita's vanwas(forrest dwelling) is common in them all, so Sita can not "underguard by soldiers" 😶 is he talking about Lakhsaman Rekha that kept her safe?
    Which Ramayan or any Of Itihass is this taken from, what's the source?

  • @Ramschat
    @Ramschat 3 роки тому +9

    Did we just gloss over a monkey king with a monkey army!? I'm sorry, rewind that and tell me more!

  • @acdc3730
    @acdc3730 3 роки тому +5

    Video of Ravana playing the Veena in a competition
    ua-cam.com/video/i7VzRz931aU/v-deo.html
    Ravana was also an accomplished scholar and musician ..as well as a Veena player. The Ragas he composed are still used to this day, in the south Indian Carnatic musical tradition. He was also considered the most educated person in the world at that time, and the people of his country lived him as he was a very kind and just ruler(what extra credit said about his cruel rule is not found on the Ramayana). In fact after the battle while he lay on his deathbed, Rama sat down by his bed to learn from him the art of statecraft and governance

  • @ameowmeowwe
    @ameowmeowwe 11 місяців тому

    YOO! the timing of this vid is impeccable! We just had a puppet show today in class about Sita and Rama. Thanks for the vid!👍

  • @thecatwithatophat4069
    @thecatwithatophat4069 3 роки тому +29

    Wow, Rakshasa are really cool, its a shame that they had to go and give their name the Battletech Rakshasa, one of the worst heavy mechs in the universe.

    • @majaaaaya
      @majaaaaya 3 роки тому +2

      Well they were worst too

    • @mcpeguru4060
      @mcpeguru4060 3 роки тому +3

      Some rakshasa are good but most are bad

    • @sahastraanshu6143
      @sahastraanshu6143 3 роки тому

      well ravana is not trurly rakshasa is was more danav or asur

  • @TheCreepypro
    @TheCreepypro 3 роки тому +1

    always heard about these guys it was nice to finally learn about them this is why this channel is great

  • @GreenAstro-if2fi
    @GreenAstro-if2fi 2 дні тому

    Pretty sure what the author meant by 10 heads is that Ravana had a great regeneration ability, it doesnt last forever but it was really sophisticated.

  • @nikhilrajput6191
    @nikhilrajput6191 3 роки тому +9

    This version seems super weird.

  • @santiagorios3477
    @santiagorios3477 3 роки тому +3

    Extra Credits, could you please make the video of Durga vs Mahishasura in Extra Mythology? 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @puffinmcpuffin9488
    @puffinmcpuffin9488 3 роки тому +3

    Looking at the Monkey King like, "Oh, you know what's up."

  • @amdreallyfast
    @amdreallyfast 3 роки тому +6

    My first experience with a Rakshasa in a story was in Critical Role, campaign 1. That was a troublesome devil. Not the same as in the original folklore, but the D&D version was still heavily influenced by it.

  • @Chick6n
    @Chick6n 3 роки тому +5

    I remember last year I watched this channel every day, but now im just really busy

  • @chandrapiyushbajpai5300
    @chandrapiyushbajpai5300 3 роки тому +1

    Well As far as I have read "The Ramayana" Written by Valmiki around 600 BCE and "The Ramcharitmanas" written by Tulsidas in 16th-century I find many differences in what you told and what was written in the books like When Ravana kidnapped Sita ji she was in exile with Rama ji and Lakshmana ji and they had gone to hunt for a golden deer (Which again was a Rakshasa), Ravana came as a mendicant begging for Food(not as a beggar) and she was not being guarded. Second one was that Rama Ji During the battle Shot at Ravana's navel and not at his chest.
    But as I see it, a legends only grows stronger and its message becomes more convincing to a variety of people as its different variations grow (well not in the case when the entire message of the legend is altered😅😅 but I see that its not the case in here)
    Anyway Loved your work.

  • @nitinsrinivasan9778
    @nitinsrinivasan9778 3 роки тому +4

    Actually, Sita was taken away when Rama was banished from his kingdom with no guards in the jungle

  • @jeffersonderrickson5371
    @jeffersonderrickson5371 3 роки тому +1

    Sita Sings the Blues.

  • @wulfboy_95
    @wulfboy_95 3 роки тому +4

    Linguisticly, Rakshasa might have derived from the Indo-European word (h)urksos which means "bear."

  • @siddhanttewari5147
    @siddhanttewari5147 3 роки тому +23

    Amazing video. BUT VERY SHORT. It's impossible to make a series on a major character from the Ramayana. I hope though extra mythology grows and is able to make more thorough videos.

  • @EpistemologicalYT
    @EpistemologicalYT 3 роки тому +1

    'Sita Sings The Blues' says hello 😜

  • @owenlove9878
    @owenlove9878 3 роки тому +2

    That child listing to this story going to have some Vietnam flashbacks of this during history class

  • @FlaviusBelisarius-ck6uv
    @FlaviusBelisarius-ck6uv 3 роки тому +6

    The pronunciation of the names is making me laugh. XD

  • @asmitkotnala1469
    @asmitkotnala1469 3 роки тому

    Finally some good hindu mythology

  • @NanoElite666
    @NanoElite666 3 роки тому +5

    Wait, hold up. What about the part where Ravana was a giant four-armed sword-wielding bug man who rejoiced in the glory of combat? That's my favorite part.

  • @TejasNarvekar1
    @TejasNarvekar1 3 роки тому +1

    Wow Sita's abduction was grossly misrepresented!

  • @gadhviviraj9172
    @gadhviviraj9172 3 роки тому +4

    I would love to know the sources you referred for this video.

  • @acdc3730
    @acdc3730 3 роки тому +17

    The Tamil Hindus of Lanka have a Shiva temple dedicated by Ravana who is held in the highest esteem and considered the holiest temple for them to this day. It has a history of more than 2600 years and while the original temple was destroyed by the sea, and a later one destroyed by a Buddhist king and later the Portuguese, a rebuilt one still stands to this day on a hill by the sea.
    en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koneswaram_Temple

  • @ObserverObserved24
    @ObserverObserved24 Рік тому

    This helps so much! Thank you!

  • @fireisawesome1466
    @fireisawesome1466 3 роки тому +7

    Can you cover story of (kumara sambahvam) or
    (Story of parushurama aka daddy kratos aka battle mage)

  • @eyok95
    @eyok95 2 роки тому +2

    We have this burmese Mythology too, Ravana is called Dathagiri in burmese.

  • @Tailikku1
    @Tailikku1 3 роки тому +6

    Hotis: "Some time has passed, Vax. And much of the world moves on to newer, greater threats. But true pain never really heals. You hurt me deeply. And continue to hurt. Agony, for weeks, months. Pain I had never experienced. (deepening to a growl) It’s all I can think about. It’s all I think about!"
    Sam Riegal: "RAKSHASA!!" *Jazz hands*

  • @Devesh-rr8tv
    @Devesh-rr8tv 3 роки тому +1

    Please make a video on narsimha

  • @shuvamchatterjee8611
    @shuvamchatterjee8611 3 роки тому +1

    Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva are the trinity.

  • @bobbagum
    @bobbagum 3 роки тому +1

    The earth rotating the that way really rubs me the wrong way

  • @BruhMoment-lh6hm
    @BruhMoment-lh6hm 3 роки тому +3

    You ahould make a video on zalmoxis a very special god in Dacian mytologie

  • @subhajitnandy6102
    @subhajitnandy6102 3 роки тому

    Smallest Ramayana we have ever heard. 😎

  • @GreatGloves
    @GreatGloves 3 роки тому +1

    Greetings from Finland!

  • @userthomash
    @userthomash 3 роки тому +2

    Veri nice

  • @sumantjaiswal3811
    @sumantjaiswal3811 3 роки тому +1

    This was so chaotic though😂

  • @Amitdas-gk2it
    @Amitdas-gk2it 3 роки тому +1

    Jai shri Raam 🙏

  • @ankitjoshi90
    @ankitjoshi90 3 роки тому +1

    Wonderful video

  • @zackcarl7861
    @zackcarl7861 3 роки тому +1

    This isssssss ssssoooooo much more simplified and compressed

    • @Jimera0
      @Jimera0 3 роки тому

      they have 10 minutes what do you expect

    • @zackcarl7861
      @zackcarl7861 3 роки тому

      @@Jimera0 buts it's good

  • @ninnusridhar
    @ninnusridhar 3 роки тому +5

    The most popular telling of the sita kidnapping myth is this,
    Rama and Sita were in exile(long story) in the forest. Rama told sita not to cross a magical circle he drew for her safety around their hut, when he went to hunt. That's when Ravana shows up. He disguises himself as a beggar and begs her for help. Being the nicest person in the world, she eventually agrees to step outside. And boom. She's gone.

    • @shambhav9534
      @shambhav9534 3 роки тому +3

      It was not Ram, it was Laxman, and that's why we call it Laxman Rekha.

  • @vihaandaiya651
    @vihaandaiya651 Рік тому

    Out of the those three supreme gods vishnu is my favorite 😍

  • @Eramiserasmus
    @Eramiserasmus 3 роки тому

    Really enjoy the episode. Rakshasa seem like a great warning.

  • @manasjain2034
    @manasjain2034 3 роки тому +1

    Great video, but
    There are some things I have heard from a different version of the stories, especially on the morality of the Rakshasa and the classification of Ravana as one. Ravana was not only a Rakshasa, his maternal grandmother was a Rakshasi, his maternal granddad was a Yaksha, another classification, his paternal grandfather was a Brahmin called Pulastya and his paternal grandmother was an Asura.
    All classifications can be equally good or bad, both Rakshasa and Deva. In some versions Ravana is a good person and the heads that he chopped off were returned by Durga, so he gained ten.
    As a side note, he was once captured by Sahastrarjuna, who was a king with a thousand hands, that particular story is also extremely funny where Ravana challenges the guy to a battle because he was upstream and stopping the pressure of a river Ravan was bathing in. In the end Pulastya had to bail him out as Ravan was still a Brahmin technically.
    And Pulastya his grandfather is one of the seven great sages and one of the 10 original songs of Brahma.
    Ravan himself is considered good sometimes and everyone did sacrifices, even Rama.
    Edit: one last thing, just a pet peeve of mine, Ram should be dark-skinned not blue, and shiva fair-skinned, only the neck is blue because he drank poison. Yes, this is how they are usually portrayed but colonialism may have something to do with.
    Overall great video, you did mention a lot of things people miss, so thank you and keep going.
    Love you guys

  • @djdinomighty5277
    @djdinomighty5277 4 місяці тому

    Will there one day be the myths of the nagas of Hindu folklore. I’d like to know something about em. Btw I really enjoy these extra mythology videos as well as extra history videos

  • @peytonreed937
    @peytonreed937 2 роки тому +1

    Y’all ever realize it’s been nearly a year since dthe last extra mythology.

  • @thekingofgreen1765
    @thekingofgreen1765 Рік тому

    this is the second time i've heard of gods needing sleep

  • @128bitpower6
    @128bitpower6 3 роки тому +2

    Rama did not shoot Ravana in the heart, he shot the arrow in the Navel !!!

  • @bruhingbruh9063
    @bruhingbruh9063 3 роки тому

    Can’t wait for another episode

  • @NSYami
    @NSYami 3 роки тому +1

    Yo how come it's been 2 months since an episode of Extra Mythology came out?

  • @conormccann2850
    @conormccann2850 3 роки тому +4

    Great video! Please feature a Yoruba myth at one point! They have such a rich pantheon and mythos, but you haven't featured any videos on them.

  • @smartbaba1321
    @smartbaba1321 3 роки тому +1

    Make on Abhi gyanam shakuntalam

  • @jasonmendelsohn6316
    @jasonmendelsohn6316 3 роки тому +2

    7:11 What is that book on the tree?

  • @yashcharanmahenthiran8989
    @yashcharanmahenthiran8989 3 роки тому +1

    There are a few inaccuracies that are different from the general tale:
    Ravana was a great devotee of Shiva and he wanted to bring Shiva with him along with Kailash so he tried to lift mount Kailash. Shiva pressed his big toe on the mountain and crushed Ravana below the massive mountain. Ravana then begged for forgiveness and was then pardoned.
    2. Vishnu became Rama just to kill Ravana because no regular human could do so. It wasn't by coincidence that they met.
    3. Sita wasn't guarded by a few guards. Rama was exiled from his kingdom because his stepmother wanted her son to become king of instead of Rama, the eldest. So they were exiled for 14 years and when Rama went out one day, Sita was left at home with Lakshmana (Rama's second younger brother). The Rakshasas played a trick to make Lakshmana leave and kidnapped Sita.

  • @LlywMiner
    @LlywMiner 3 роки тому +1

    Rakshasa 👋🏻Jazz hands 👋🏻

  • @adityanair6540
    @adityanair6540 3 роки тому

    yes do more indian myths

  • @OGNoNameNobody
    @OGNoNameNobody 11 місяців тому

    That would be something to see on a future Magic Card:
    "Protection from Everything except Human"