My Rewrite of Secret Invasion
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Get Nebula using my link for 40% off an annual subscription: go.nebula.tv/n...
Watch my video fancasting Booster Gold right now on Nebula nebula.tv/vide...
If you watched my Why I stopped making One Small Change videos video, you'll know that as a treat I decided to make on last Rewrite video. So here it is. My take on Marvel's Secret Invasion.
The Nando v Movies Merch Store - store.nebula.a...
MOSTLY NITPICKING PODCAST
iTunes I apple.co/2lMcoVv
Google I tinyurl.com/y6...
Stitcher I bit.ly/2NbZFZ4
Spotify I spoti.fi/2Oc5Qg4
OTHER STUFF
Patreon I / nandovmovies
Discord I / discord
Reddit I / nandovmovies
Twitter I / nandovmovies
Facebook I / nandovmovies
Instagram I / nandovmovies
Music by Epidemic Sound
The most remarkable thing about the show for me was that in a show entirely about whether or not aliens could live peacefully on Earth, they did not even say the word 'Asgard' at any point. You'd think they would talk about the one successful and peaceful alien colony on Earth, if only to say why the Skrulls couldn't do the same. It felt like the showrunners must not have known about the end of Thor: Ragnorok, which is kinda wild given the film came out in 2017. Secret Invasion ends with the US declaring war on Asgard, and it seems like it was entirely accidental. I bet we never hear about that again.
O snap thanks for the Dimension 20 timestamps! And yea I don't see how they could sustain the anti-Asgardian plot point, just based on the tone set in Th4r. Especially given how they went so deep into the idea of Asgardians as gods i.e. Omnipotence City, as opposed to aliens like Skrulls and Kree
White aliens are always ok
But in definition they are alien . Beings from outside of earth . Just not Norma biological beings. They are powerful but marvel chooses to call them gods ….. they aren’t gods just very powerful beings . And everyone in the multiverse experiences an afterlife. Asguardians specifically go to Val hala . It’s explained in moonkight
To be fair, they didn't confirm Asgardians settled on Earth until 2019 during Endgame. They might have been developing by then, but delayed by COVID. Then again ... that's still more than enough time to rewrite it.
It's more than possible a New Asgard cameo was dropped during the massive reshoot process. Heck, one of the shots from the trailer shows Nick Fury walking in a park while being stalked by a pair of ravens. I was SO sure New Asgard was going to play a part in this show from that shot alone. Imagine, Fury contacting an Agent of Asgard for information or an alliance in case of all-out war!
One thing I'd add is that for the title credits sequence, instead of the gawd awful Ai mess they used, have newspaper clippings and news segments conveying exposition about important story stuff: ross getting elected, thanos , the snap, the blip, the avengers.. But have them slowly change as the series goes on, adding news reports that are in the show.
Also (and more importantly) changing news articles to reveal skrulls in photographs that (in earlier episodes) just had humans in, maybe even having news anchors in the news clips delivering their stories in later episodes *as skrulls*. This way, as the show is revealing the secret invasion the credits are slowly getting invaded (and displaying that they've always been here)
that would be SO COOL!!!
This is why Marvel should hire people that actually are creative
Nah
Nando please keep doing the rewrites or “without studio constraints” as someone else commented. Genuinely among the best essay-esq videos on the platform
I think this was a pretty strong, respectful way to do a rewrite. Pick only the media that massively failed for a variety of unexpected circumstances and it still feels respectful
It was never disrespectful to begin with imo. He was never "This is bad, trash movie, I'm here to correct it... yadda yadda." It was always, "I like/appreciate the movie, but there's this part that I did not like and here's why it doesn't work for me..."
@@casualpotato44 My comment was more a response to Nando's reluctance to do more rewrites, not this one in particular. It's not that Nando is being disrespectful at all -he's always been great. It's more about that, because art is subjective (we assume everyone is making the best art they can), any rewrites are inherently "disrespectful" in big quotes (by implying the artist's best subjective opinion is a bad one, at least to the re-writer).
Point being Nando can and should do more rewrites without feeling like he's disrespecting original writers as long as he focuses on movies whose failures are beyond the writers' control.
dont stop the rewrites! it sounds like you're stopping bc you feel they come off as disrespectful to the writers but they are such cool though experiments it would be a huge loss if you stopped doing them!
Yeah these are easily your best work and the sole reason I subscribed. Just do one once in a while if the spirit moves you!
If the writers feel disrespected, maybe they should reach out and offer this man a job. Nando needs to write for Marvel officially!
i agree, it was this exact kind of content that brought me into his channel, he's great at it. You can tell it comes from a place of love for the characters and storytelling.
If Nando really feel uncomfortable with the idea of "rewriting" , maybe he can change his approach to "what if I could write X without studio's constraints." So to not imply that he's better than the show writers, and merely a thought experiment on what one could write without outside influences.
Please don’t stop! I haven’t checked that video about why you intend to, but this series is literally my favorite thing on UA-cam, it’s why I subscribed and I love every episode
Nando: "I'm not going to do any more one change/rewrites."
*Secret Invasion gets released*
Nando: (Plays opening sequence of Spider-Verse) "Alright. Let's do this one last time."
Yessss
Personally I think the rewrites are better than just raw criticism. It’s at least constructive and fun and I don’t see how it is worse than a critical review.
Can we talk about how dumb it is that it's now canon that all you need to replicate a superhero's power is their DNA? The implications of this are a serious oversight IMO.
Yeah lol imagine is the final fight Giah used Ironman armor lol
@@RobertDownySeniorif marvel ever gets that ridiculous, I’d probably get invested in it again. The sheer absurdity would be some great brain dead fun
@@richyc.6465 lol
@@richyc.6465 anime vibes
It's even worse that most MCU characters don't have powers related to their DNA, Probably only Hulk and Spiderman
I love how you include small jokes and callbacks to other comics and movies, it shows that you really know all the source materials and wanted the tv show to succeed. 51:34 really got a chuckle out of me
Kingsley Ben-Adair going from a serial killer to a Ken doll in the span of EXACTLY a month is so iconic (Secret Invasion was June 21st, and Barbie was July 21st)
I know! I was so taken aback by that in the theater. I could not suspend my disbelief, lol.
I legit couldnt believe it was the same human. As far as highlights for a bad series go he is definitely near the top of the list.
I was giggling in the theaters
I'm sad there won't be any more rewrites. I enjoy these in the same manner I enjoy fanfiction and comic alternate universes. It's not a disservice to the writers if you enjoy envisioning different scenarios for beloved characters and fandoms.
What if the real Rhodie is alive/paralyzed, helping the skulls. "This way, I still get to be a hero." "He's not really you." "He's got my face. He's got my memories. He's got my suit. Some days I think he's more me then this version stuck in a bed."
i like this better, bc it feels so cheap Rhodey didn’t get to see iron man’s funeral
I loved the "you looking for this" line 😆
It was an awesome payback to Age of Ultron 🎉
I love how your pitches/rewrites are so in-depth and the quality of the editing. it always feels as if I'm watch the movie or show as it unfolds. great work as always!
This should’ve been an avengers movie. I hope this helps engagement metrics. Love your videos Nando!
Secret invasion honestly is a topic that needs more run time than your average movie. Ideally it would have been a series of movies or threaded through multiple projects.
The version Nando outlined was solid. There is little more that could be asked for in story designed to be told in less than 4 hours of content. By how large the cast he would want to use is I honestly do not think it could every have been run as a show budget wise but it was certainly would not have been enough to carry a movie.
They had the perfect setup for Secret Invasion in Far From Home. Literal Skrulls acting as Fury/Hill
“You looking for this?” No effing way 😭😭😭😭 I got chills. Dude thank you for writing this. So awesome
I don’t know why you are stopping the rewrites, but this 50 plus video helped me be entertained while putting my 2 month old daughter to sleep at 5 am. So thank you and please, don’t stop the rewrites !
Please dont stop the rewrites! I love them so much. You can do these rewrites respectfully, kinda like making fanfiction almost, you know?
I like how the channel has evolved over the years - I watch more Nando Cuts then the hard-work videos like these, but man... this reminded me how much I loved these from you. The Pitches scratch a lot of the same itch, but having the footage on hand like you do for these really makes them shine. Love it
I personally think this show should have been called "Fury: Agents of Sword" and been all about Nick and whole bunch of Agent characters doing spy missions, with the overall arc being the Skrull's invading. The show would eventually lead into a Secret Invasion movie. They could have shown more scenes up in Saber as well, with Monica, Agent Brand, etc.
Since WandaVision, SWORD has fallen off the face of the Earth. Maybe it was established that it was going away? I can't remember. But it seems odd. I'm sure there are a tonne of characters, old and new that could have shown up in this show, with Talos of course and how he's been doing down on Earth. Eventually, they'd uncover a conspiracy that an outlying faction of Skrulls are trying to invade Earth entirely too make it their own, and perhaps Fury does try to contact Captain Marvel, or other heroes by the time he finds out, but he gets captured or stopped somehow.
There's so many ways this show could have been better, and more fun, it's such a shame we ended up with what we got. Truly one of the worst MCU projects.
These rewrites help me realize what I found unsatisfying about a show and how much better it could have been
the first marvel show i actively avoided because i knew it was going to be disappointing. i’m excited to see how you make this work, nando >:)
I skipped a bunch of Marvel shows.. been trying to watch Loki S2 but I don’t see the hype
@@firstlast9846me either. especially since the teaser was at the end of ANT MAN 3. i rolled my eyes in the theatre
I avoided it because I was never interested in Nick Fury, but I'm glad I dodged this bullet.
how exactly did you know?
But what about She-Hulk???
This would honestly be the best marvel show. Please dont stop the rewrites
I really like how this makes Gravik more sympathetic and also more menacing.
I cannot believe you made a use of the "Boom, you lookin' for this?" line :DD That's actually genius.
nando i know you already made your decision but just for what its worth, your rewrites are brilliant and i hope you keep finding a way to suggest alternate paths things couldve gone and work thru what butterfly effects they couldve caused
Dude you connecting the one guy from black widow is so old MCU I love it. Your rewrites are becoming my head canon lol
Fury needed to lose the invasion, and then we should have gotten a following movie of the 'Avengers: Secret Invasion'. The show can be Fury discovering the invasion, and then the movie is them dealing with the fallout of Fury failing to stop it ahead of time.
This is awesome!! I love these rewrites! Helps me think through how to be intentional with themes and character arcs in my own writing! Thanks for the inspiration!!
Me too! Losing the rewrites feels like such a loss
I'm not someone who hates marvel or enjoys seeing them in a rough patch or even hope they fail forever, however this show really was a failure to me sadly, I love this rewrite and I love that you did this
Your re-writes are always thought provoking and entertaining. Hard to believe someone hasn't signed you by now. Question: is it easier for you to come up with a better storyline once a show has aired or have these ideas been in your head from the beginning. Regardless, you're doing a great job. Keep up the amazing content!
I'm sad this this is the last rewrite, but will admit that you truly saved the best one for last. Thanks for these Nando. Always looking forward to what you have going on next.
I still am not a fan of Rhodey being a Skroll since Civil War but the way you did it is definitely better than what the show did.
51:34 “Boom, you looking for this?”
"I don't think I'm a better writer than the people who actually wrote Secret Invasion." - No worries, Nando. We all do.
That’s not nice
I love this pitch. I think it's a wonderful way to learn about writing. And it's delivered in a great, friendly way. Gonna miss these videos. Thanks, Nando!
"Lookin for THIS?" Was the best friggin part. U write for the plucky marvel movie tide turn at the end of a battle so dang well it was perfect bruh 😂
Keep doing the rewrites. As long as Marvel aren't putting the work in to get full scripts before filming, I dont think anyone owes them any grace.
Your rewrites are the best.
You have an incredible understanding of the two most important parts of screenwriting - character motivations and how to ratchet up tension. This is an incredible story. Thank you for sharing it.
PS - I laughed out loud at least three times in this video with just your placeholder dialogue alone.
The Nick fury lines were spot on and hilarious you gotta keep these up bro
The line about Earth being so young compared to the rest of the galaxy is so fascinating and compelling, really adds an interesting perspective
...the fact that you Incorporated "looking for this?" into the mix as organically as you did is testament to your skill. And I wasn't ready!
Rewrites are the best nando videos plz don't stop it. 🙏
I love the way you set things up subtley, mentioning trask or shi'ar without it being significant yet. Also im sad armor wars isnt your rhodey now
Please Nando don't stop the rewrites/1 small change videos. They are some of my favorite. I start watching because of them.
This is phenomenal, these usually are. It's very different to write these retrospectively, but still. ❤
"This should be an avengers movie because it helps engagement metrics or something"
This pitch is great. Every beat works. I hope you continue with these because you are very talented and these are super entertaining.
Your rewrite is literally perfect, I am going to miss these videos. Thank you for everything you do!
This is a great re write - I wish the studio would pay more attention to posts like yours!
This is light years away from the source material and thank you. This is what this series was supposed to be.
They need to hire you. Your story is way more entertaining than what they produced.
38:47 Y2K was actually for real a problem -- it just got massively sensationalized AND it actually got solved, and between those two things, everyone who remembers it assumes it wasn't a big deal. But it *was actually a problem*! Ok, nitpick over.
This was really cool. Your analysis of why the tv show's premise fell apart was really helpful, and (among other things) you did a really effective job at editing together the discussion between Gravik and Talos -- the visuals you used for it were very effective.
Another excellent rewrite. I'm definitely in the "just make this Avengers 5" camp (especially with the next Avengers film still years away), but this is an excellent re-working within the 6-episode streaming show framework, and showing the team in action at the beginning is a nice touch, plus the inclusions of Bolivar Trask and Sharon Carter. Picking up Sharon's thread really helps this feel like a vital middle chapter like CIVIL WAR, rather than the optional side-story it feels like now.
Also, you really nailed Harrison Ford's vibe with the President Ross scenes, it's enough to make me forget that we haven't seen him in the role yet.
This completely pulls in the old feel of the MCU while still feeling fresh, as well as the complexity of the comics and how there are constant overlapping settings and characters at times. I watched the entirety of Secret Invasion for some reason and hearing you rewrite it makes me think the writers just sit in a void or something.
On y2K as a programmer, we spent literal billions of dollars industry wide to take the needed steps to keep the digital world running smoothly, because at the heart, most of our calender systems could not track centuries, and thus everything interacting even remotely with dates, including but not limited to operating systems, and dependency management systems (how programmers reuse code from other projects) had to be reworked, and then everything using those systems had to be reworked. preparations started as much as 20 years before Y2K at some companies.
Not relevant to the topic of this video.
@@EclipsingTNT video blows it off like it was all a hoax.
I love that little "Boom! You lookin for this?" 😂
These are my favourite content you make and the level of detail and quality of ideas is absolutely unparalleled online. PLEASE DON'T STOP DOING THEM!!!!!
This would've been a fantastic show with this writing!! Don't stop with the creativity. You don't know how much pleasure it gives viewers to hear something more aligned with what would've best served the story amd characters overall. Excellent work my friend!!!!
"Which meeeeans..."
"😞 Yeah, I'm gonna go down there and punch him."
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Does anyone know the name of the music playing when Nick and Maria were talking and he said he took a chance on her? It’s absolutely beautiful
Dear lords, this is so much better. The little bits to reference the greater universe, the explanation for the lack of involvement of powered characters which has become part and parcel of the MCU because we suspend less disbelief as we do in comics, consideration of future installments like the Rhodey and Riri part (and Maria Hill), the Andrew Garfield in No Way Home style redemption for Sam and Rhodes. And probably my favorite, the Wolverine can smell Skrulls easter egg.
I cheered out loud at “you lookin for this?” I’ll miss these videos from you Nando.
This is amazing.
The only issue is Rhodes death. It still downplays him not being there for Tony's death.
Loved this! Great work. It's amazing that they couldn't pull off anything close to this. You intertwined the themes and made it work perfectly for this day and age. Furys speech at the end telling his enemy that he is worth defending, was beautiful. Having both Ross and Gravek be the antagonists - the authority and the terrorist, with both terrans and skrulls in the crossfire and the only solution is understanding and trust. And in the end it works. Perdect. You did callbacks to everything from Civil War to Thor Ragnarok to Captain Marvel and Falcon and the Winter Soldier, making it feel like a full aand coherent world and not like just random cameos. Please keep doing rewrite videos!
Well done. Your rewrite is brilliant and very true to the MCU we knew and loved. You make all the choices seem so natural, the reveals, the payoffs, and the ways it ties in with MCU past and present. Very satisfying show that should have been.
I LOVE that you put Riri and Sharon Carter into this show. I wasn't completely sold on Riri in Black Panther 2 so getting to see her one more time before her own show is great. And I suspect that Sharon Carter isn't necessarily gonna be in Captain America 4 so using her in this would have been awesome.
the whole sequence with Power Broker is so brilliant
Please keep doing the re-writes. they are what made me subscribe cause they just so interesting to watch and imagine else worlds. In a perfect world, someone would animate your re-waits and we actually get to watch them as shows
I agree with others I love the rewrites, as long as you acknowledge they aren’t meant to say the actual writers are bad people I don’t see the problem. I am sure writes at Marvel studios are always saying what they would do differently with a script what we see on screen is just the last guys take. Your videos are just one more guys opinion on a different direction. As an amateur writer, other writers do that to my work and I do it to theirs. I don’t always agree with their takes they don’t always agree with mine but it’s part of the collaborative process.
I understand if you don’t but I would love it if you keep doing these
I would love for you to keep doing rewrites. It’s the very thing that allowed me to find your channel.
My one change from your thing is I wouldn’t have Rhodes be dead after civil war I would still have him be locked up somewhere and then have skrull Rhodes die at the end… personally wouldn’t like one of the original mcu characters just being a different guy… overall your rewrite was great
As one of the 5 people that actually liked and enjoyed Secret Invasion as is... I really liked your version too
I stand by my opinion that Captain Marvel should have taken place at the time Secret Invasion does. Captain Carol Danvers is working with Maria, they discover Rhodey was kidnapped and replaced by a Skrull a month or two after Sam becomes the new Captain America, so he was the one there in Endgame and he attended Tony's funeral. Nick Fury comes down from SABER, they investigate, expose the small group of Skrulls, which are the first wave of an invasion.
Then Carol gets her movie, and while hunting the last of the Skrulls on Earth, she encounters the Kree and gets powers, has her final fight out in the woods, and the fight is seen by Kamala Khan, who's on a school camp, so she gets a Peter Parker Iron Man 2 scene and she ends up idolising Carol, who no one else knows about, and then she gets her powers, and for the Ms Marvel Post Credit scene, Monica and Fury show up at Kamala's front door, and we'd know who Monica is, because she was in WandaVision.
Dont stop the rewrites sir! We all enjoy them!
This is the version I'm keeping in my head from now on
I encourage you to continue your rewrites, your Ant-Man and the Wasp and the Ant-Man was beyond brilliant!
That was actually a pitch, which he is going to continue doing!
Loved the "You looking for this?" line
This is amazing!! This feels like PEAK MCU, and I like how you actually made things from FATWS pay off! Sharon Carter, Flagsmashers, Karli, etc. And it ties into Cap4 and Thunderbolts instead of setting up a 2nd Season that no one wanted. Amazing!!
Yes!! This is brilliant, love the themes, the callbacks to other world building that's been happening in the mcu, the characters returning, and the setup for stuff we know is happening later down the mcu. Even most of the dialogue was pretty Awesome.
I hope you don't take this the wrong way but I often find your dialogue a little clunky, (which is understandable, you're more of a "story" guy rather than a "script" guy) but most of it was on point this time. :)
Love your pitch. My only gripe, which goes double for the original, is that we never seem to see the Skrulls' main power to switch between forms and identities. These seem more like Yeerks than Skrulls.
Great Rewrite! Only thing I would change is keeping Sonya the way she was in the og. She was one of the only bright spots and would hate to see her get killed off so early.
Another fantastic rewrite! I hope you do more in the future
This is dope! Your dialogue is super solid and fun
I have some reservations, though many of which may just be my own personal biases, but I like it a lot more than what we got. (Some of my reservations being that two of the only British characters we have not being British at all and instead being disguises of another American accented character in this already far too America-centric for a galactic-scale multiverse setting)
So sad this is the last rewrite, but great vid! Love all the content!
Call back to Rhodey's story in avengers 2 is pure genius
Your vision/rewrite is soooooooo SUPERIOR 🎉🎉🎉
my only gripe with this rewrite is it retcons rhodey to being dead since civil war, and the character we’ve been following since infinity war and endgame wasn’t the real rhodey, even if he had his memories
Yeah really don't like that part of it
Don’t stop the rewrites. It’s why I love the channel. Don’t care really about the casting vids but these excercises in what ifs are awesome
10/10 just for the "you lookin for this?" inclusion
I'm 3 minutes into the video and already it's a better retelling of the secret invasion story. I've never been so disappointed with a marvel show.
My biggest problem with this show is that characters always just trust that when a skrulls transforms into their actor they're talking to their ally. Like in episode 1 when Maria aimed at the Russian but then turned into Talos and she was like oh it's you Talos, ok.
What a way to go out. I hate the series coming to an end but this was great. Like Jordan in the 96 finals.
98*, then Jordan came back for some stinker years in the 2000s
I actually didn't hate secret invasion: sure, the script is mid at best, but it's the best acting I saw from Samel L. Jackson.
Loved the Harrison Ford voice, btw
I love your idea inter connecting the cinematic universe is exactly why i want to watch this cinematic universe.
Hey Nando, long time fan, fellow writer, and slowly working my way up to ever making a video essay. I hear and respect what you've said about these Rewrite videos and not wanting to come off as disrespectful.
But everything you do is COVERED in respect and nuance and self awareness. You always own and cover the circumstances and difficulties in the creative process and frame this as a 20/20 hindsight situation. That makes all the difference: You never lose empathy for the actual creatives!
I dunno, I like your casts and all but the One Small Change really why I subscribed
Was nando literally waiting for me to get nebula watch this video and then put it on UA-cam? I literally saw it like five seconds before the UA-cam fans. Oh well at least I can be a few minutes early on the next video
NANDO WE NEED THE REWRITES