TalkTV host blasts trans activist over the use of gender pronouns

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 кві 2024
  • TalkTV host Julia Hartley-Brewer clashes with journalist Shivani Dave after Dave accused the host of misgendering.
    Brewer’s interview with Dave started when the latter introduced themselves and their pronouns.
    The TalkTV host immediately hit back at the journalist's pronoun announcement, saying she would refer to Dave as she or her.
    During the journalist’s appearance on TalkTV, Dave and Brewer spoke about the Cass review.
    The Cass review follows Dr Hillary Cass’s research which found that there was no evidence to support the prescription of puberty blockers to those under 18.
    On Wednesday, a National Health Service (NHS) review found the field of medicine that enabled children to change gender was “built on shaky foundations”.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 242

  • @stevep9041
    @stevep9041 Місяць тому +145

    She gave her pronoun faster than an activist could tell you they’re a vegan.

    • @AsMr-km6ex
      @AsMr-km6ex Місяць тому

      You told everyone real fast that you dont give a sht about animal cruelty. But thought you ate. Stfu

    • @GG_Booboo
      @GG_Booboo Місяць тому

      Vegan are actually much nicer than these people!

    • @theauntofdragons
      @theauntofdragons Місяць тому +2

      Lolol that was a good one.

    • @user-ov6kj1li3j
      @user-ov6kj1li3j Місяць тому

      She is an activist. She does activism to indoctrinate and groom children into her cult.

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      The beginning was cut out on purpose to trigger people like you

  • @jackturpin7828
    @jackturpin7828 Місяць тому +132

    Children would not be questioning their gender if it was not being pushed on them all the time.

    • @gtaveteran
      @gtaveteran Місяць тому

      Very true - they wouldn’t… they would just see people as boys & girls and men & women… until some purple haired freak waving a rainbow flag told them otherwise.

    • @timwannell6477
      @timwannell6477 Місяць тому +6

      It all started from the horrific failings of Dr John Money and the Reimer case in the 80s/90s. Check that out, but beware…it is not for the feint of heart

    • @DarkMasterJo
      @DarkMasterJo Місяць тому

      @@timwannell6477yea sick shit

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      Maybe actually look into it more. ​@@timwannell6477

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      Or... maybe it's more complicated than what you assume.

  • @blackrocks8413
    @blackrocks8413 Місяць тому +87

    the whole trans things is a little too cult-y to me

  • @user-dl4dn5th3c
    @user-dl4dn5th3c Місяць тому +56

    Good on HER😂

  • @zinniagarden
    @zinniagarden Місяць тому +44

    Thank you, Julia.

  • @FranciscoAssis-kl7hs
    @FranciscoAssis-kl7hs Місяць тому +71

    XX or XY PERIOD

    • @susivarga7303
      @susivarga7303 Місяць тому +6

      Sorry, you're wrong.
      It's the XX with the PERIOD.

    • @vascobrighton1364
      @vascobrighton1364 Місяць тому

      @@susivarga7303 LOL...But yeah you are right.
      Anyway, he is right. There are only 2 genders XY(male) XX(female) PERIOD!
      This time in the right place

    • @sleepyjessie
      @sleepyjessie Місяць тому +3

      But there's so many more variations? Your statement is just blatantly wrong

    • @FranciscoAssis-kl7hs
      @FranciscoAssis-kl7hs Місяць тому

      @@sleepyjessie XX and XY. Ok

    • @vascobrighton1364
      @vascobrighton1364 Місяць тому

      @@sleepyjessie What variations? There is no possible variation by science,either one born with XX chromosomes or XY chromosomes,there is no other way no matter what people say. In human kind there those with XX chromosomes and therefor they are women and there those with XY and therefor they are men. By science you can't argue with this reality,everything else people say come from their minds because they don't want to see the reality.

  • @outsider8059
    @outsider8059 Місяць тому +84

    So-called misgendering comes down to setting the record straight as far as human biology is concerned.

  • @truefactjack
    @truefactjack Місяць тому +62

    Forcing others to participate your delusions with your [special..] language sorry but I'm not participating..

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      Look up the definition of Delusion. It doesn't apply here

  • @unofficialkevmcgev1442
    @unofficialkevmcgev1442 Місяць тому +35

    Trans is now a social badge. How are you trans switching sides and also not identifying as either?

    • @credenza1
      @credenza1 Місяць тому

      And presumable a female who becomes a '"trans man", then later returns to her right mind, is still able to identify as trans because, according to the trans cult, she was formerly a man.

  • @daveabbott
    @daveabbott Місяць тому +14

    My stock answer to that is 'Pronouns are only of use when I'm talking about you, not to you, and you really wouldn't want to know how I talk about you when you aren't here, so we'll park that and continue'. Really works!

  • @stevewiles7132
    @stevewiles7132 Місяць тому +46

    Refer to them as nothing, don't address them as anything, just speak politely with yes, no, hello, goodbye etc.

  • @stevewiles7132
    @stevewiles7132 Місяць тому +49

    Gender dysphoria/ normal teenage hormonal confusion.

  • @awc900
    @awc900 Місяць тому +26

    Go Julia!

  • @user-qr6ih6jx9x
    @user-qr6ih6jx9x Місяць тому +17

    No more delusion being pushed onto others

  • @hilarymeyerov2934
    @hilarymeyerov2934 Місяць тому +26

    THEY THEM FOR A SINGULAR PERSON THEY NOW WANT TO CHANGE ENGLISH GRAMMAR?😂😂😂😂

    • @Brads-strung-out
      @Brads-strung-out Місяць тому +2

      Its not being changed, it's being added to, and subtracted from. (1984)

    • @credenza1
      @credenza1 Місяць тому

      The trans cult is a weapon against all social institutions. It has long been understood that if you want to control and demoralize people you start with language, getting people to deny the evidence of their own eyes.

    • @i_wouldprefer_not_to1196
      @i_wouldprefer_not_to1196 Місяць тому +1

      Yes...and this woman reckons she's a journalist!

  • @alexandermenzies9954
    @alexandermenzies9954 Місяць тому +26

    Shivani Dave appears to be in love with...herself. The rictus grin looks very forced and heading towards an implosion, what fun that will be! 🤭

    • @richardmacey3619
      @richardmacey3619 Місяць тому +1

      @alexandermenzies9954- Funny how Shivani Dave and Imarn Ayton both top notch ‘race baiters’ both have the same arrogant, sneering superior attitude when being interviewed. Truly awful women.

    • @androidemulator6952
      @androidemulator6952 Місяць тому +1

      "rictus grin" ,, i hadn't known about this, but i can see it in alot of "diversity" types. ;)

    • @ChopperCindy
      @ChopperCindy Місяць тому +2

      Rictus! I thought it was a spelling mistake! I learnt something today…very apt description. They must practice in front of a mirror.

    • @credenza1
      @credenza1 Місяць тому +1

      There is a certain element of spectrum about many trans cultusts.

    • @user-oi6ln4eq7b
      @user-oi6ln4eq7b Місяць тому

      A very forced Village Idiot grin. She/he/it/that should take better acting lessons.

  • @anonglakmoonwicha2726
    @anonglakmoonwicha2726 Місяць тому +9

    The mistake Brewer made was to allow the obsessive person to carry on taking part in the show. The moment someone disqualifies themselves from reality is the moment they should not be entertained any more.

  • @hilarymeyerov2934
    @hilarymeyerov2934 Місяць тому +17

    MY PRONOUNS ARE YOUR MAJESTY 😅😅😅😅😅😅

  • @richalderson6069
    @richalderson6069 Місяць тому +18

    Julia is BOSS!

  • @andsands3601
    @andsands3601 Місяць тому +39

    Well done Julia for not putting up with such nonsense. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      Yah. Respecting people is such nonsense

    • @andsands3601
      @andsands3601 Місяць тому

      @@Christpuncher138 wear a helmet!

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      @@andsands3601 learn to respect other humans

    • @BobMarley-zu5sc
      @BobMarley-zu5sc Місяць тому

      ​@@Christpuncher138 Respect needs to be deserved

    • @Christpuncher138
      @Christpuncher138 Місяць тому

      @BobMarley-zu5sc so, you disrespect everyone until they give you a reason no to? Thats asinine

  • @baz7055
    @baz7055 Місяць тому +8

    Thank you for telling her the truth. You were boldly brave.
    Was impressed with both of you as you disagreed but kept your voices controlled and not full of anger.
    As you kept stating truth you gained a fan

  • @user-oe9go7wb7j
    @user-oe9go7wb7j Місяць тому +4

    Bravo Ms Brewer..this nonsense has gone far enough

  • @Hannah-rl5lt
    @Hannah-rl5lt Місяць тому +22

    Thank goodness..hopefully more people take her lead❤🇦🇺🙏

    • @Galerak1
      @Galerak1 Місяць тому +2

      I already had a conversation with my daughter's school about this a couple of months ago. I raised my concerns that, even though I only dropped one of her off in the morning, the schools consistent use of referring to her as 'they/their' in school reports or correspondences made me think she was suffering some form of mitosis once she went into class.
      I also informed them of my disappointment that, what was once known as the best grammar school around when my mother attended, they had now lost all concept of what grammar actually means.
      Oh, and I told them they were supposed to be there to teach facts, not support fantasies.

    • @jaysky2000
      @jaysky2000 Місяць тому

      @@Galerak1 Time to remove your daughter from that unhealthy environment!

  • @thedukeofduchess2168
    @thedukeofduchess2168 Місяць тому +6

    Finally some push back - maybe some other journalists in the msm should grow a spine and do the same

  • @johngraham8257
    @johngraham8257 Місяць тому +13

    She has a goofy f****** smile

  • @nhamilton4399
    @nhamilton4399 Місяць тому +5

    The smug arrogant perma-smile says it all.

  • @frankie9747
    @frankie9747 Місяць тому +4

    The host is right. There is no reason whatsoever to condone lunatics.

  • @joerogan3079
    @joerogan3079 Місяць тому +3

    *THIS IS THE FUTURE SCI-FI WRITERS WARNED US ABOUT* 👏

  • @misterl0gic
    @misterl0gic Місяць тому +7

    My pronouns are I/Me/My.
    I literally just used two in this comment.

  • @TheNorthernUnicorn
    @TheNorthernUnicorn Місяць тому +21

    Straight Jacket

    • @markfox1545
      @markfox1545 Місяць тому

      *straitjacket. Simpleton.

  • @TheWaynos73
    @TheWaynos73 Місяць тому +4

    Tells her her pronouns then asks her how she is. That says it all really.
    Here’s a fact: if an employer sees a resume where the person has included their pronouns as part of it - they will certainly not get the job.

    • @user-ov6kj1li3j
      @user-ov6kj1li3j Місяць тому

      is it? there are many woke companies that have activists infiltrated, these activists are there to make sure their cult takes over and that as fewer white people as possible will get the jobs

  • @siskothekid4620
    @siskothekid4620 Місяць тому +6

    how about, show it instead of describing it??? 🙄

  • @julienewman1761
    @julienewman1761 Місяць тому +3

    Julia is a legend. She always put these people in their place.
    As for that woman, you should have watched the whole interview. Let's just say she is unhinged.

  • @92804dv
    @92804dv Місяць тому +8

    The response for Julia would have been simple: "If I am talking to YOU, why would I use a third person pronoun (they/them, he/him, or she/her)?" "I will call you Shivani."

  • @blackenreed1425
    @blackenreed1425 Місяць тому +9

    Does no one have a cure for the reality dysfunction I (or everyone else?) is experiencing?
    I vaguely remember reading fiction about everyone in Britain wearing animal helmets/masks and being totally cuckoo (Michael Moorcock?). Or was it just a dream? Either way, aren't we due for the promised return of King Arthur?

    • @TheWaynos73
      @TheWaynos73 Місяць тому

      She also mentioned in the interview that she is ‘special’ and should be treated as such. Spoilt, entitled, self important brat of a woman.

  • @Monz805
    @Monz805 Місяць тому +2

    Was fantastic to watch..truth and reality prevail✌️🇬🇧🇮🇱

  • @elmalo5851
    @elmalo5851 Місяць тому +7

    Kudos to Ms. JHB for not checking her morals in at the front desk! 👏👏👏

  • @zereimu
    @zereimu Місяць тому +2

    She did not "misgender" her guest, she correctly gendered her. We have to call out this "misgendering" word play to prevent them from gaslighting and manipulating the narrative.

  • @grash4435
    @grash4435 Місяць тому +3

    We shalt never baw to atention seeking individuals...

  • @ginapereira8948
    @ginapereira8948 Місяць тому +5

    Ya, just screw everything else that's going on thats way more important!!
    Good on her!❤

  • @nedbaker4129
    @nedbaker4129 Місяць тому +2

    Really maybe that person needs to be referred to at it

  • @alaakela
    @alaakela Місяць тому +3

    This is not socialism. You can't force me to call you comrade or use your pronounce.

  • @invisible1785
    @invisible1785 15 днів тому

    A forced smile is always an indicator that something’s wrong with the person

  • @jaysky2000
    @jaysky2000 Місяць тому +1

    Bravo Julia! Hearing you speak the truth is music to my ears!

  • @dorothywhite1595
    @dorothywhite1595 Місяць тому +1

    3 cheers, Julia.

  • @XxTheAwokenOnexX
    @XxTheAwokenOnexX Місяць тому +1

    People should ask Enoch Burke what happens when people refuse to use pronouns 🤦

  • @AliWallace-tf4eu
    @AliWallace-tf4eu Місяць тому +1

    Call IT an IT!!! If IT doesn’t know what IT is then how else can I describe IT?

  • @tonic8945
    @tonic8945 Місяць тому +4

    She belongs on the 'Special bus' 😊

    • @Coltnz1
      @Coltnz1 Місяць тому

      Or under it.

  • @jokabjo1694
    @jokabjo1694 Місяць тому +2

    Those people are very confused.
    And they want to confuse everybody's children.
    Someone has to stop the insanity !!

    • @Shivelpuff23
      @Shivelpuff23 10 днів тому

      Shivani doesn't strike me as confused at all, and I've never met a trans person who wants to 'confuse' a child, have you?

    • @jokabjo1694
      @jokabjo1694 10 днів тому

      @@Shivelpuff23 So you are defending that they are confusing children ? Shame on you. Children have to grow up, before being able to decide what sexuality they have. That's what we are talking about, right ?

    • @Shivelpuff23
      @Shivelpuff23 10 днів тому

      @jokabjo1694 I'm not defending it, I'm saying it isn't happening.
      And no we're not talking about sexuality we're talking about gender, I knew I was a girl a long time before I knew I was straight.

  • @childensstorytime
    @childensstorytime Місяць тому +1

    Good on her…

  • @hanyasvagytediszno
    @hanyasvagytediszno Місяць тому +2

    nobody comments on the crazy smile of this creature? like straight out of a horror movie

  • @theauntofdragons
    @theauntofdragons Місяць тому +2

    The way she inhaled and said, "yea" made me laugh out loud lol. It doesn't show it, but the guest said, "it's to show that i am special" *ding ding ding*! They/them/xer/xim are a bunch of ppl who want us to bow down to their delusion.

    • @Shivelpuff23
      @Shivelpuff23 10 днів тому +1

      They said they were 'special' because that's how the host referred to transgender people just before Shivani went on air.

  • @yoojin-oi8ij
    @yoojin-oi8ij Місяць тому +1

    Well, well, well,...... ya' don't say. ENOUGH OF THIS MADNESS !!!

  • @RemoanersRtossers
    @RemoanersRtossers Місяць тому +1

    The world where feelings matter more than facts and reality. 😂

  • @trevormccreary117
    @trevormccreary117 Місяць тому +3

    “😬 yeah……” lol

  • @scratchdog2216
    @scratchdog2216 Місяць тому

    Great job SNA. You just gave these people the attention their looking for.

  • @endtimessupportgroup5685
    @endtimessupportgroup5685 Місяць тому

    The host got so triggered she forgot what she was there to talk about

  • @jasonvorheesss2622
    @jasonvorheesss2622 Місяць тому +3

    to much ATTRAZINE intake

  • @carolphillips682
    @carolphillips682 Місяць тому

    My programmes are:- Julia Kelly Mia Helen Kathleen Megan Kelly.

  • @markfox1545
    @markfox1545 Місяць тому

    That's what is so insane about this pronouns thing. They want you to be factually inaccurate about them when they're not even present!!

  • @stevenpower811
    @stevenpower811 Місяць тому

    My guess is it is middle class guilt she is confused about her position in life.

  • @jc7671
    @jc7671 Місяць тому +3

    I just call them by their name. Pronoun issue avoided.

    • @user-ov6kj1li3j
      @user-ov6kj1li3j Місяць тому

      Pronouns are used in languages for a reason, they make communication easier. If you avoid using pronouns, you are still playing into their game.

    • @DonnaBarnbrookMalletswinger
      @DonnaBarnbrookMalletswinger Місяць тому

      Or refer to her with correct pronouns (she/her). Delusion avoided.

  • @FrankFrankston-kj4sx
    @FrankFrankston-kj4sx Місяць тому +1

    No mistake was made. An individual demanding to be referred to I the plural and against science is misgendering themselves.

    • @Shivelpuff23
      @Shivelpuff23 10 днів тому

      And yet the science supports transitioning 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @MentallyGuitarded12
    @MentallyGuitarded12 Місяць тому

    This "yOu miSgEnDeREd mE!" absurdity is going to end soon, right? I mean, it's got to.
    ....right?

  • @dominicmckevitt4278
    @dominicmckevitt4278 Місяць тому

    Thankyou !
    About time some1 done this jhb knows she is right. If I could vote for her I would , no problem... ❤❤❤

  • @seriousmonkey5654
    @seriousmonkey5654 Місяць тому +1

    Dave's a funny looking fella.

  • @rhyno1740
    @rhyno1740 Місяць тому +3

    Hahahahahaha Hahahahahaha Hahahahahaha, great work. That's exactly what iwould say.

  • @MrMcnamex
    @MrMcnamex Місяць тому

    common sense are strong indicator of truthful moralities

  • @johnmclean1046
    @johnmclean1046 Місяць тому

    JHB didn’t “ misgender “ her, she identified her correctly, no misgendering, no hate crime, no threats or violence, infact JHB stated facts.

  • @BenHall289
    @BenHall289 Місяць тому

    I was asked by a medical professional what my pronouns were the other day. I replied that my adjectives are “handsome and brilliant” and that I expected her to use them at all times when addressing me or discussing me even in my absence. I think doing this highlights the stupidity. Language doesn’t work like that. I don’t get to choose “my pronouns” nobody does.

  • @chrishagler8848
    @chrishagler8848 Місяць тому

    The host was right. This denying reality crap has gone away too far

  • @gordiebrooks
    @gordiebrooks Місяць тому

    This pronoun issue is the sign of an issue. I prefer to use it.

  • @david853721
    @david853721 Місяць тому

    0:24 THAT SIDE EYE 🙄🙄

  • @thehazelnutspread
    @thehazelnutspread Місяць тому

    Too bad Sky News didn't follow Julia's lead. I remember way back when the Goth people all dressed alike to show how 'different' they were. The attention seeking insanity never ends.

  • @angeliquegoncalves827
    @angeliquegoncalves827 Місяць тому

    Love Julia, Well said

  • @lesteranddonna
    @lesteranddonna Місяць тому

    Love you Julia 💋

  • @nescionetizen295
    @nescionetizen295 Місяць тому

    In a convo you usually use "you" and pronouns you might use when talking to someone about someone. Or am i missing something?

  • @NhoxLittn
    @NhoxLittn Місяць тому

    So "normal" greetings now are good morning + pronoun identification introduction right away?

  • @cynthiar7350
    @cynthiar7350 Місяць тому

    “They/Them” is quite full of “themself” isn’t “they?” (No autocorrect either🙄)

  • @markmcgarry2876
    @markmcgarry2876 Місяць тому

    Refer to dave as she or her 😂😂😂😂

  • @peterd788
    @peterd788 Місяць тому

    JHB is only saying what nearly everyone thinks.

  • @lynnm6413
    @lynnm6413 Місяць тому

    How about not using they/them pronouns for that poser of a journalist and backing up Julia in her fight for reality

  • @CD-xn1su
    @CD-xn1su Місяць тому

    Facts

  • @stevenpower811
    @stevenpower811 Місяць тому

    Oh! And please could people refer to me by my personel adjectives,hansome and brilliant I identify as a 25 year old brad pitt .

  • @SuperModelLexi
    @SuperModelLexi Місяць тому +1

    What’s wrong with being just a lesbian 💁🏻‍♀️

    • @credenza1
      @credenza1 Місяць тому +1

      Trans cult ideology is designed to dismantle the social fabric. Part of this is to make fundamental ideas such as male and female meaningless - or dangerous to use. Lesbianism is based on the traditional notion of a woman. That is why trans men invade lesbian spaces and bully them into silence. It is why the trans cult was behind the recent Irish referendums which tried to redefine family and woman - and failed spectacularly, thank goodness.

  • @nedson6503
    @nedson6503 Місяць тому

    Adil Ray.

  • @jessemason9201
    @jessemason9201 Місяць тому

    nouns have genders, people have sexes

  • @Snowhite128
    @Snowhite128 Місяць тому +2

    Thanks for your pronouns 😂🙌

  • @scottcoley1906
    @scottcoley1906 Місяць тому

    No one has the right to tell you what to say. I don't play the pronoun nonsense. Cause that's what it is: nonsense and thought control in its simplest form.

  • @oldgoat142
    @oldgoat142 Місяць тому

    Pro nouns. Yeah. Right. Put that one under the heading of, insert in your ear laterally.

  • @RC-og1dp
    @RC-og1dp Місяць тому

    Sky News you’re just as bad by referring to that alphabet person by her ‘preferred pronouns’. (0.45) You’re just adding to the problem

  • @jij6444
    @jij6444 Місяць тому

    Oh no she got memento disease 😊

  • @mariaboczko3702
    @mariaboczko3702 Місяць тому

    No one introduces themselves like that.

  • @AsMr-km6ex
    @AsMr-km6ex Місяць тому

    Queen

  • @nellyfootlong
    @nellyfootlong Місяць тому

    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    Host is a legend

  • @johngardiner5206
    @johngardiner5206 Місяць тому

    Just another very ordinary individual trying desperately to be different/relevant with zero effort. Sad little narcissist.

  • @ErickeGallardo
    @ErickeGallardo Місяць тому

    0:45 "Brewer's interview with Dave startes when the latter introduced THEMSELVES and THEIR pronouns.
    These "Pronouns" are stupid. The use of these "proper gender" misleads us to thinking they're talking about more than one person yet it's just one.
    You don't use fucking PLURAL when talking about a SINGLE PERSON.

  • @Jeremycoxloa
    @Jeremycoxloa Місяць тому

    Why don’t we call people by there name! Hi my name is Jeremy I don’t use pronouns cause you can call me by my real name Jeremy. Thank you! It’s not okay to go out of your way to be rude to someone though. If you want me to use your pronouns I will. But if I know you name is say Jesse I’ll just call you by your name.

  • @regolith1350
    @regolith1350 Місяць тому

    Hey Sky News Australia, it seems an uber woke intern got hold of your UA-cam login.
    0:42 No, the guest did not "introduced ThemSELVES". The guest is not a plural.

  • @JC-lu4se
    @JC-lu4se Місяць тому

    Pronouns are only used in the 3rd person. You’re going to say “you” when speaking to someone directly. Why give pronouns in this case? Just trying to be special.