JK Rowling’s savage transgender takedown
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 тра 2024
- JK Rowling is on a mission to stand up to the trans agenda.
The author of the iconic Harry Potter series and darling of the literary world has come under fire in recent years for refusing to give lip service to the woke trans agenda.
Sky News ALl Stars Liz Storer, Clabe Bond and Esther Krakue ask will JK Rowling face dire consequences for her courageous anti-trans stance?
She's not anti-trans, she's just anti-bullshit.
She is anti trans as she should be
Thats where the west got it wrong.
How can you prevent an idiology without banning the people that spread it?
Well the trans agenda is a load of bullshit so technically....
JK is a leftist and a feminist, so not anti-bullshit. She is just not evil or batshit crazy.
I love that quote😊
She’s pro women’s rights not anti trans. She’s a hero.
Do you mean that men can be women? Why are you supposing that it's wrong to oppose trans ideology? Who decided that it's beyond disagreement?
Every fem ceI and their beta orbiting male feminist is pro women. Few people are pro equality
Agree, she not anti trans.... she pro woman and free speech
I came here to say that.. the first comment I saw was yours and exactly what I was going to say
@@altal2993 Its the same thing at this point
Thank you J.K. Rowling for standing up for women
Transgender ARE NOT BIOLOGICAL Female
Why? But why?
Biology.
And no matter how much hormones they take or how many body parts they mutilate they will NEVER NEVER BE WOMAN; because you need a pair of x chromosomes, a uterus, fallopian tubes, milk producing breast weather they give birth or not. I can't believe we are seriously having a conversation about this...what a global infection of lies.
You should see Jammidodger and eveyone hating her when she states biological facts and they cry like she’s killed them, these people are so sensitive and try to compare a book to real life when it’s a fantasy about wizards people
She's not anti-trans, she's pro truth and is calling out bs
I’m sick of my friends committing suicide because of “pro-truth”/anti-trans people. Are you pro-suicide too?
@@andreastveitdal9508 I have trans friend who didn't commit suicide, and don't care about Al the peoples who don't like them they don't pretending being born as female, they know who they are, they love being considering as women but they don't always asking to change theirs identities, I think people who are committed suicide do cause transgender or not they are only not happy, and I never liked the argument or recuperating dead peoples for an ideology
@andreastveitdal9508 of course not, that's ridiculous. I highly doubt you have multiple friends committing suicide, but if they are, it's because of the confusing messages they are receiving and a lack of proper guidance. It's natural to Not question the body you're born in and focus rather on changing and improving what you can. It's not a physical sickness, it's a mental one. If you think the whole world should lie to each other and you so a few people have their delusions pampered, you are just as sick. Your sex is a basic part of reality that cant change. Focus instead on improving yourself, your situation, and the situation of the people around you. I know this is a bit harsh, but if peoples lives weren't so easy, they'd have no time to bother with this sickness, and it wouldn't bother them either. Whatever doubts you have about your body, trying to chemically or surgically alter it, or force other people to call you different pronouns, is not going to address the root of the problem. It will keep your existing problems and add to them. The problem is society indulges these people and tells them they can change their bodies when in reality they are taking a healthy body and and inducing a lifetime of medicalization, hampering their ability to have and enjoy sex and reproduce (and ultimately have a stable family), and pushing them further into mental illness instead of trying to ground them. I think this is a symptom of a greater societal collapse in shared values and community relationships.
@andreastveitdal9508 I tried to respond to you but apparently youtube auto deleted or censored my reply. Smh if we use these platforms but can't even have honest conversations on them, then we are the ones being used.
@@andreastveitdal9508 Of course not, that's ridiculous. I highly doubt you have multiple friends committing suicide, but if they are, it's because of the confusing messages they are receiving and a lack of proper guidance. It's natural to Not question the body you're born in and focus rather on changing and improving what you can. It's not a physical sickness, it's a mental one. If you think the whole world should lie to each other and you so a few people have their delusions pampered, you are just as sick. Your sex is a basic part of reality that cant change. Focus instead on improving yourself, your situation, and the situation of the people around you. I know this is a bit harsh, but if peoples lives weren't so easy, they'd have no time to bother with this sickness, and it wouldn't bother them either. Whatever doubts you have about your body, trying to chemically or surgically alter it, or force other people to call you different pronouns, is not going to address the root of the problem. It will keep your existing problems and add to them. The problem is society indulges these people and tells them they can change their bodies when in reality they are taking a healthy body and and inducing a lifetime of medicalization, hampering their ability to have and enjoy sex and reproduce (and ultimately have a stable family), and pushing them further into mental illness instead of trying to ground them. I think this is a symptom of a greater societal collapse in shared values and community relationships..
They say "anti-trans", I say pro-reality.
PRO REALITY 100%
Comment of the decade, mate!!!!! ❤❤ I will be shamelessly copying that!!
Anti-trans IS pro-reality
Spot on. I love this
Since the dawn of humanity, the reality was what the majority voted ... it did not mean it was just nor moral ... it was a simple wish of the majority so they burned the witch and danced around fire feeling so good about themselves that they burned the evil! because they were in the majority who could tell them they were the ones who were evil!
How a biological fact can be a hate crime is beyond me!
Because today logic is out the Window Only feelings matter….. I miss the 80-90s
@@bjorngadd8647 You mean times when you pretended all intersex people did not exist either , and you let doctors chop chop them as babies rather than waiting to see what actual sex they identify as ... so you bigots were happy making sure the world is all set in zeros and ones, absulutly ignoring the biological fact that one in thousand babies is born neither and both , and maybe just maybe would be moral to wait and hear them tell what they identify as rather than JKR deciding it for others ... pure evil
...
@trinitybassguitar-ru6dz Hahahahaha please just go back under your rock.
@trinitybassguitar-ru6dz raised eyebrows!
@trinitybassguitar-ru6dzyes it is
Not only is she expressing her opinion -- she's saying THE TRUTH!
I’m sick of my friends committing suicide because of “pro-truth”/anti-trans people. Are you pro-suicide too?
@@andreastveitdal9508your friends obviously have major issues, take it out on someone else, get lost
They commit suicide because they are mentally ill @@andreastveitdal9508
@@andreastveitdal9508if that's how you wanna twist it. Then yes. Absolutely. Go cry about it.
@@andreastveitdal9508 i’m sorry people are being so horrifically rude to you when you deserve compassion. I’m sorry you also have friends who didn’t make it ❤️
This video is clearly catering to transphobes and think that’s the only OK way to think. That’s a nasty opinion.
There are "Transwomen" in sports but nowhere any "Transmen" in men's competitions? How come?
Biology. Women are pathetic compared to men. Even a sub-par man with hormone treatment to wore down his testosterone levels can outcompete the best female athletes.
Feminism brought this on itself, making transexual their allies to fight against "evil Patriarchy". Now they dominate Feminism from within.
Somehow, women forgot that male and female sports weren't set apart because of "mysoginy", but to actually give women the option to have a fair competition.
You wanna learn a funny fact?.
Only in women's Sports there are clear rules on the biology of the contestants.
Men's sports do not have "one gender policy", and never had.
FIFA, NBA, Men's Olympics, Rugby...
Not a single league of any male dominated sports ban women from competing with men.
"Men sports" are actually "EVERYONE sports".
The fact that all these teams are made of 100% men should tell us how good men are compared to women when it comes to athletic capabilities.
But women never got the hint, it seems.
There are. They don't do well enough. Point still stands: transmen are not biologically male.
Actually, I had the same question and somebody pointed out that there's a trans man that's a professional boxer. A flyweight or something, and there's a lot of talk that their opponents have been cherry picked to ensure the trans dude does well in the matches. But "he" was still apparently knocked out within a round or two in a recent match.
I think we all know why Biological women, aka TransMen, don't participate in men's sports..... They'd get destroyed.
I also think we all know why Biological Men, aka TransWomen, do participate in women's sports..... They'll destroy the actual women....
Trans men are more cruel I've noticed overall to be fair.... I don't think it's the only reason at all but it's also less popular overall tbh....
Putting a male raqist in a women's prison is the kind of insanity that should get you arrested.
It got the previous first minister of Scotland to resign
That made me so angry. The person who allowed that person to be with women by identifying as a women is the dumbest thing I ever heard in my life, like for goodness sakes man
I identify as a pig
@@metalcactuarjumpman7605 But, it is the ULTIMATE distraction from the reality that our countries are being burned to the ground economically and culturally all around us...
@@joelinasia8401why is it no matter how we scream against it it still is happening?
Putting a male rapist in a woman's prison was messed up
Not as messed up as identifying him as a female rapist but very, very close.
Judges who go along with these mad laws should be disbarred, jailed and transitioned.
In america the same thing happened and sure enough he managed to get 4 women pregnant .........
Hope they need to remove the body.
ITS SICKENING 😔🧐
It's not 'anti-trans'. There's no such thing as 'trans'. How insulting to real women.
There is for people with chronic gender dysphoria who do and need to transition as a last resort. That’s the whole point of calling it “trans”, but trans is a descriptor, not an identity as these activists claim. The original meaning was always a description, not an identity
@@cosmickilroy You can't 'transition' from a man to woman, or vice versa. It is patently and deeply dishonest.
How insulting to real women.
I know many ppl who actually transitioned...from both to both.... And yes trans ppl are Real and legit. I love them like family. I've met far more people who are non trans who are hateful and judgmental...few of them are actually sick ppl.... It's like 0.0001% of the population they focus on... The majority are like us all ...trying to live. Simple enough.
@@ShaneWroe Your contempt for real women is noted.
@@ShaneWroeDam I identify as "I am a retard" so if you want to call me just say "I am a retard". Thanks in advance boy if you have a penis or girl if you have a vagina
Go J.K! Someone has to take a stand against this insidious nonsense.
We ALL have to "take a stand."
I am with J.K. on this travesty of humanity.
straight men and women have committed heinous crime against children than transgenders put together.
violation on humanity are done by men and women at a much larger scale. than these people just trying to live their lives
I haven't read a book in 30 years but just ordered 5 copies of all her books to support her! Taking good idea on what I should do with them
@@user-pw4mi8fz4c she's a Slytherin, not a Gryffindor as she claims.
@@angel91485 "you were named for two headmasters of Hogwarts. One of them was a Slytherin and he was probably the bravest man I ever knew."
This Scottish bill needs to be removed.
The politicians who greenlit it as well.
Both the bill and the politicians proposing this bill need to be removed. JK Rowling is now a hero.
Amen.
Yes we need a global vote to show how many are opposed - the majority, and to send a clear message to the woke elites that such laws are not tolerated anywhere
Scotland needs to be removed from the UK more like! It's the biggest drain to the English taxpayer! Full of jumkies
Yes ma’am!! We are with you! We are sick of it as well.
I’m sick of my friends committing suicide because of “pro-truth”/anti-trans people. Are you pro-suicide too?
Exactly! That’s what I’m always saying! I feel like no one ever pays any attention to the growing and rising of the trans suicidal rates!!
Every person in Scotland needs to break these laws frequently and incessantly! Overload the system until it collapses!
If you google "anonymous hate crime reporting scotland" you can also contribute.....just saying 😉
Rowling is not stating an Opinion, she is stating Scientific , Biological fact.
But there is a difference between male and female brains so if you have a male brain in a female body or vice versa then it's not a opinion, it's not scientific fact, it's incorrect. It's just schools don't teach neuroscience, so people don't learn these things
Dumbass; there are intersex, XXY, XY women with intolerence for testosterone and numerous other deviations from the norm. Do read up matey, all facts.
Long story short; they ( the alt right/neo con/proto fascist ) got you riled up about a minute part of the population to distract you from major problems in YOUR real life.
and in that fact where did she place intersex people? one is born in every 1000 babies? Intersex babies do not fit into the male /female formula JK presents .... intersex babies happen because the transition( gestation) from the female fetus into a boy fails ( yes all babies start as female, every man ever born was a girl for the first 3-4 months of his life in the womb ) so are they allowed to pick their sex they identify as ? or should we have J.K. Rowling pick it for them? the fact is way more complex ... lots of intersex people are seen by the ignorant as trans ... well it is simple if you pretend as conservative bigots did since the dawn of humanity that there is no such thing as an intersex person
@@Berndr no has ever denied intersex babies exist, yet they are so uncommon, do we reorder society around them.
also the problem isn't intersex people.
It's the likes of Isla Bryson playing the system to get an easier time in Prison.
Or Lia thomas , a mediocre swimmer, who when they competed as a man where lucky to hit the top 500, as a women, one of the 'best'
The other issue is performing irreversible and damaging treatment to children who have no say in it, who are old enough to get a tatoo, drink a pint, but somehow , we feel we can decide if they get puberty blockers.
Conservative 'bigots' are not the ones denying reality and scientific fact. the only bigots in this fight are not the likes of rowling , but the likes of India Willboroughy and other Trans activists
This is about Women rights, Trans people have the same rights as everyone else. But a good number of them , this isn't enough , they want privilage and dominance over others
Due to these people they have lost a lot of friends, and have become a pariah. I hope you understand the likes of Bud Light, Biden, Starmer, Humza Yousaf care nothing for Trans people, so when they drop them, who will the Trans activist have, when the police don't cover for them, when the media is not bothered about them
the Trans activists have been short sighted and unbelievably stupid , they have managed to annoy not just women, but men, everyone, not a good plan. at the end of the day they are only 0.1%
Do you mean she wants to set the world into zeroes and ones and pretends there are no intersex people? to what toilet do you send an intersex person? the biological fact is that one in a thousand babies is born as intersex ... Intersex persons same as Trans do not fit into JK's formula of male and female ... she is stating facts based on bigots' beliefs, not a biological fact, particularly if you do know the biological fact that every man ever born was actually a girl for the first 4 months of his life because every fetus is a female, till Y chromosome mutates the female fetus into a boy, reason boys still have nipples ... that's how intersex people are born because this mutation for some reason does not get finished... and who decides what sex is an intersex person J.K.R. or themselves? it is a gray area not black and white
Let her speak her mind without fear. Do not apologize!!!!
I applaud her, but I feel like this is just going to be another clear example of how people like her can get away with what they'll lock us up for. Which is just ABSURD that you can be fined/jailed for speaking the truth. 'Hate crime'. What a ridiculous way of describing FREE SPEECH that someone gets offended over. NO ONE CAN CONTROL SOMEONE'S FEELINGS and NO ONE SHOULD BE ABLE TO CONTROL YOUR SPEECH.
I love it because she's got the money to back it up too 😂 she's like, sue me 😂
Let us all speak our minds, the problem with this "hate speech" is ,to disagree with something is not hate speech ,it's just an opinion and the minority don't have the right to demand we accept there view
Trans man enters the boys locker room. Society: I sleep
Trans woman enters the girls locker room. Society: wide awake
@@lightghost7524sadly true.
If hurting someone's feelings is a crime, there are a lot of politicians that need to be arrested.
The government telling you what you can and cannot say. Didn't Hitler do that.
She is not anti trans she is pro biological woman and standing up for the common sense of protecting real woman’s rights and safe spaces
The awful truth.
100% correct
I dont think she dislikes trans people as people, she just stands agaisnt the ridiculousness of the policies surrouding them and enabling them do do ridiculous things, including the people who abuse....well making use of said policies, eg Lia thomas ans Fallon something, and those are just little tips of the iceberg.
And dont even talk about transwomen in sports, its a shit show, I'm one and transitioned young, sure I have lost maybe 10% in muscle mass, but I have GAINED bone mass and density, now walking around with more bone mass than even most guys, and doesnt even look it. Yeah, fair game my as$, wouldnt even be fair even agaisnt men, well for certain sports that emphasizes resilience.
Safe spaces 😂
Stop saying she is anti trans. She is NOT anti trans, she simply doesn’t want MEN in bathrooms and women sports. She has never spoke hate, only basic facts and as usual you MSM blow it out of proportion 😑
I've embraced "anti-trans".
@@ribbrascal1065Same, considering just believing in science makes someone 'anti-trans' or 'transphobic' these days.
Every father with daughters should be supportive of Rowling it’s your daughters she is trying to protect, surely u don’t think it’s ok for men/boys to be in their bathrooms at schools and sport.
Exactly, were called Anti when we point out delusion or lies! Anti
@@IIIIAmSHODANIf you knew anything about science then you would also know, that every single fetus is a female, and every man ever born starts as a girl, then if Y chromosome is present these female fetuses will start mutating (gestation) the clitoris into the penis and so on, the reason men have nipples ... so when this mutation for some reason is unfinished the intersex people are born one in 1000 babies are born intersex approximately ... So what are they? because they do not fit into either male or female conservative formula, do they have the right to pick the sex they feel most like or is it up to you to tell them what sex they are, and I am not even going into trans waters here? My point is if you really want to talk science then know, genetically all men are women, and have 50% genetical female material because they evolved from a female fetus yet no woman is a man ... just as a caterpillar is not a butterfly
You go 'Lady'! You are wholly supported by 99.99999% of EVERYONE!
You're a star. Thanks for standing up against these ridiculous laws.
Stand up against all of this foolish bs! Don't give up! 💪😎
Really?
Like 5 people out of 250 million. It's taught in fucken kindergarten as part of the state sanctioned curriculum. Toddlers told that their parents are evil and wrong, horrible life destroying drugs given to children without parental consent, children removed from families because a so called educational professional says so, America started this bullshit, there are places in your proud America that if a 6y old boy plays with a barbie for ten minutes you can loose him to the system for ever.
You have delusional so called celebrities with five trans kid's, fuck off, I call total BS, these people need to be I prison getting the mental health help they need.
It's America driving this nonsense, hopefully you'll use your vote wisely this time.
We’ve all had enough of the trans agenda.
Women should have their safe spaces away from biological men.
Yes we damn well have 🙄
I concur 100%
They rule the world ONLy because we allow them
XX or XY………That is It……….According to EVERY Medical Book………..
Scotlands current parliament is mostly The Scotish National party and The Scottish Labour party. So there's now wonder this is happening. Scotland has been disgraced by these people.
The problem is even woke cowardly women politicians will not stand up for their own interest their own gender, and sex and defend themselves from men in dresses...
Scotts have lost their minds!
My Mom was a woman, my brother is not.
Let there be no doubt ! 😂
What about your father 😅
Yeah
Pity the people who should know better pretend that is not a thing
Probably need clarification on the "was" part for most people
The Anti free speech in Scotland doesn't mean a damn thing to JK. Woo hoo go JKR
It is not "anti free speech" it is against inciting hate against a person or group. Most countries have Hate Laws, just as England does. But the latter are making a fuss about Scotland's as they know people rect rather than think. This is another propaganda exercise of the English Establishment and their buddies.
We're still free to say what we please in Scotland. We can say a male is not a female and never can be. JK Rowling has highlighted her own bias and inanity. Of course, she is anti-Scottish Independence, and very much part of the propaganda machine.
Tell it Sister! Love you JK❤ think I’ll buy all your books again.
I will follow her into battle as well. We need to speak up! With our friends, in our community, we need to have critical thinking conversations, n make people uncomfortable...we need to stop being afraid of " being canceled "
Me too.
She’s not anti-trans. She’s made that very clear. Lazy journalism
sky news kinda sucks tbh
At this point just being rational makes you anti-trans, so they’re not so far off
@@TheSonoranSniper its far right, no wonder
@billpugh58 says the far leftist who's in the lead for bs propaganda. It IS anti-trans according to you mouth breathers who seethe over people who refuse to use bs pronouns.
She knows like the most of the planet that there is no such thing as a "transgender" person. Humans cannot magically 'transition' from one sex/gender to another, as it is biologically impossible.
I'm trans, and I really support J.K. Rowling. Most trans people know that she's not a bigot towards trans people.
Well maybe you trans people should get together and protest her mistreatment and the mistreatment of other people being accused of the same thing
Vast majority of us are not against trans. We have a live and let live attitude.
Thank god you see sense
@@LordSamuelJthey won't though.
Thanks Elsa - and I’m sorry that you and people like you will be negatively affected by the extremists allegedly fighting for “trans rights”, but actually setting everything back ;-(
I as a normal woman worship this woderful Lady. Thank you! 🥰🥰
JK Rowling is my hero. She is not anti-trans or anti-LGBT, she is just anti-woke. We NEED more people like her!
JK Rowling is not against Trans she is standing up for Women’s rights. There is a difference.
not true, you do not stand for the rights by oppressing someone else!
How does this opress anyone? Trans women are not females, you HAVE to be a female, of the female sex to be a women. A women is an adult human female. @@Berndr
@@BerndrI am Gay, I hate it when Trans men call themselves gay for dating a male, even though they are FEMALE. Same goes with sexuality. They are effectively erasing what it means to be a homosexual. Only a relationship between two MALES or two FEMALES can be considered gay, nothing in between. JKR is right.
@@Berndr Grow up. She stands for women's rights. Period. Oh, and if you're one of those who takes advantage of the fact that a dude can stroll into a girl's room and nobody would say or do jack, well, that's going to wind up not well. F the scot law.
@@oldgoat142Trans Rights ARE women's rights. JKR is a bigot who wants to oppress the trans community.
We have all had enough
YAAAAAAS! THANK YOU!!!
Absolutely!!!
Agreed 🇳🇿😑
I used to not care and just ignored the problem. Now I would go out of my way to call people the proper pronouns as determined by their sex.
Enough trans men and cleaning ladies entering guys locker room while they are changing?
Hooray for J.K. Rowling!
If only more high-profile people would have the guts to speak out against this crap forced down our throats ! Well done JK Rowling !
She's not anti-trans, she's pro common sense and I cannot help but stan.
Same thing. I'm anti-trans.
Being pro common sense, pro working brains, pro humanity is the same as being antiret@rded
anti trans is common sense dumb ass
Here in the States.....Democrats are running the asylum
That means anti trans
Imagine being imprisoned for using words that even your arresters can't define.
Excellent point.
Yes, I’m offended by being called something I can’t describe or explain.. or KNOW WHAT IT IS! 😂😂😂
It is a very nasty mental health crisis in the SNP and the Islamist Yousaf the dictator .
Orwell was not kidding
@@tobiasb9645 The only thing Orwell got wrong was the date.
"Two minutes of hate." How incredible it is that we have forgotten this novel as soon as we began to understand it.
Biological facts are not illegal.
New level of respect for JK Rowling. I stand by you as a fellow woman with a brain.
Her tweet thread was a string of jokes about genuine rapes, laughing about what happened during those rapes. You think this is great?
correction an evil brain! thank god she did not give birth to an intersex baby...J.K. Rowling probably would have strangled an intersex baby, because intersex babies do not fit her male-female format or decided what sex that baby would be without even considering what that child identified as and would have ruined that babies' life! nasty evil woman
Seriously? She wasn’t laughing at the rapes. She was laughing at the absurdity of how they were handled.
If you were a woman with a penis maybe they would listen!
@@CatherineX-ph3on And, exactly, where and why did those rapes occur? They happened within the walls of women’s prisons by biological men, and they happened because biological men were allowed within the walls of women’s prisons. I’m not quite following what you find confusing about someone highlighting the absurdity of that…on behalf of the victims you’re referring to.
As a gay man I support her!!!!
Your not gay you are a homosexual... Gay means happy , enlightened joyful, pleasing ,,
@@dodgeboy9052 your are right, he is not homo, he is Home Essential...
@@dodgeboy9052 Homosexuals can be gay. They can also be merry, jovial, mirthful, and content.
I'm not gay, I'm just reasonably happy!
I feel like all of you guys should be against these people. I have use these vague terms or my comment will be deleted. Sorry about that. I mean, they're targeting y'all while you're young and could do SERIOUS, irreparable harm!
Confusion is getting worst!
J K Rowling is another proof that only a great person can write a great book.
Bravo.
I am sorry, why is she called anti-trans in this video? The only things she was saying was that trans-women and biological women are different things. This is not anti-trans.
Yes it is, and that's a good thing.
It's time to embrace "anti-trans".
It is pro-truth.
Did she say where she places intersex people? one is born on every 1000 babies because intersex people do not fit into her formula of male and female either! or shall we have J.K. Rowling pick sex for them ??? I think she is an evil disgusting woman... I would not be surprised if she gave birth to an intersex baby and strangled it
JK Rowling, I'm an American who stands behind you all the way! You are phenomenal ❤️
ME TOO!
@@user-jh4un7yy2h Me three! All rational people stand up for JKR, free speech, reality!
Australian here happy to support JK Rowling.
SAME
From Trinidad and Tobago I stand by you. J.K.
It's ironic that an author of fantasy books has to stand alone to defend reality and common sense.
I agree with her on this.
JKR is not anti-trans. She simply declines the notion that 'feelings' are more important than facts. Which the vast majority of men and women agree with!!!!
what about intersex people? They do not fit in JK 's formula of male and female either, and lots of ignorant think of them as trans ... one intersex baby is born in every 1000 babies, are you going to choose their sex for them? Of course, conservative bigots will be in the majority... because there will be never enough intersex people to outvote the rest of the population! in your words they could never choose for themselves ... it is a classic bigotry oppression you just presented... it would be like 95% of the population deciding if other 5% is allowed to live ... and their opinion is the fact for the only reason because they are in majority ... total disgusting immoral disgrace... people should always have right to chose for themselves otherwise we live in a fascist country! The very same reason I disagree with the anti-abortion vote in USA , that decisions should have been only for women no males!
Is that supported by stats?
She is standing for obvious fact over made up fantasy.
If trans need special classification then create a category for them. Don't force them into existing groups which they do not match.
I am a gay male (only MALES can be gay in a maleXmale relationship!, not females identifying as males) and I fully support JK Rowling. She is preserving the true meaning of gay and straight, I stand with her.
They are arresting someone for littoral speaking undeniable facts and truth. What the FUCK?
The only thing necessary for evil to succeed is for good people to do nothing, thank you Rowling for standing up to evil.
Everyone has to do same. Everyone wich has a comment sense about life and about himself.
Common sense
She has every right to stand up to that damaging law.
The people in power are laughing their asses off thinking they would never actually be able to pull off this stunt.
She is not anti trans as such, as i see it she is just anti unfair, unrealistic or unreasonable behaviour.
As a trans man, I agree. How does being realistic translate to anti trans?
@@miguelstanley4360 no disrespect intended to a trans who has "gone the whole hog" but I think there should be some different acceptance of those who are quite frankly playing the part for dubious reasons. It is these people who are giving the genuine trans a bad name.
Personally I think that some trans make more beautiful or attractive woman than those "born" to it, but that is just looking at it from my view point which I admit can be flawed.
And anti protecting an identity that can be misused to abuse others.
@@miguelstanley4360Please explain that to legions of trans people and their supporters who shut down any well meaning and well developed debate with name calling like terf and other name calling and make up their own facts and then focus on minutia instead of protecting girls and women!
@@chrisstephens6673I don’t know what you mean by the whole hog but yes it is people pretending to be trans who are taking advantage of this situation and posing real harm to girls and women! I have trans people who are my friends and they pose no threat but they are sincere not posers.
She’s not even stating “opinion” it’s a scientific fact.
Speaking her mind isn't a hate crime.
god bless you good work
I am gay and I totally support her and her defense of women rights
Which rights?
@@Zantonny the right to not have men competing in our sports, men out of womens changing rooms, men out of woman's prisons, is that enough to be going on with?
@@ZantonnyThe rights to not have weirdos like yourself be in women’s spaces
@@Zantonny You need to watch the videos, or pay closer attention
Trans ideology removes gay people too. In their world view you're in the wrong body.😕
Who's running the asylum?
The patients !
The new gender of course.........."Groanadic"
The government's 😂
Some guy who doesn't like white people.
Last time i checked, there are no such thing as Asylum in The West anymore.
I never liked Harry Potter myself, but J.K. Rowling is one of my personal heroes ❤
Thank you!!🙏
You know we are living in the end times when you can be put in jail for telling the truth!
She may be (currently) on the wrong side of the law but she will always be on the right side of history.
If Hitler won he would have also been on the right side of history because winners write it, it does not make her just or moral ... trans are not much different from intersex people, because they do not fit into JKR' bigot conservative formula of male and female either ... babies born as both male and female... there are 350 000 intersex people in UK ... so what makes you think JKR has the right to decide what sex they are supposed to be ... writing kids book made her an expert on genders?
The Law is on The "wrong side."
Thank you for your great engagement Mrs. R! ❤😊
Good for her! Go Rowling!
Love how she’s fighting back for free speech.
So when you have half the population locked up, then who is going to pay taxes?? Scotland didn't put much thought in this bill.
Refugees.
@@gfys756 holy, moley migoley
& they will need more prisons.
Perhaps they are trying to create more jobs? 😂😂😂
They will scare people by using some arrests to kill free speech
@@gfys756 think you mean immigrants. Uk is the dumping ground for the worlds immigrants.
Thank you!
Good stand your ground!
Jordan Peterson did this same fight in Canada 7 years ago and they are still trying to cancell him.
Cancel, not cancell.
@@mikeandhev😱
😂😂@@DianInHerOrb
@mikeandhev you paid attention in 3rd grade English look at you how special bet you are incapable of things real men need to know
Jordan P. is a douche and a pseudo intellectual.
JK is a women's rights warrior, god bless her👍.
RIP free speech and soon other human rights as well
I know little about the Potty Harry universe, but I love this woman, JK Rowling...and Kelli Keen. Thnk you both for standing up for us. Men can not be women.
It's literally straight out of the pages of 1984
It's straight out of the pages of Brave New World. Orwell wrote about people like North Korea or "N" Germany where compliance was instilled through militant authoritarianism. Motivation and drive was stripped away by making everything the same, and erasing natural impulses. In Huxley's Brave New World, compliance was instilled through sensory overload of "nice thoughts" and pleasurable living. By promising to take away all the bad things and keeping people dependent on the security provided by "benevolent" big brother. The left practices safe spaces, a false sense of individuality, hook up culture, hedonism, substance abuse, and cult like togetherness. This doesn't exist in 1984. Such things were not allowed as they had the potential to deviate from the authority's master plan. In BNW the master plan WAS to placate the people with such things while working behind closed doors.
Nobody should ever worry about the consequences of telling the truth
So, every time someone disagrees with me, I can sue them?
This IS the end of world!
If this passes in Parliament in Canada, people will simply stop talking to each other in fear of being charged. Everyone will follow in line like sheep.
Go get ‘em, J K Rowling
You go J.K. Rowling keep speaking the truth!
Stating facts should never be criminalised!
How can someone dress as the opposite sex to commit a crime and be protected by the law? It’s baffling!
Check out the website Trans Crime UK
Good for you J.K Rowling.
Your absolutely right.
Right behind you Jo. 👏
She’s not anti-trans, she’s anti-stupidity
Demand that the SNP and Humza resign.
Agree 100%…..🇬🇧✝️🇨🇦
The Scots were Always considered to be Good, Intelligent People!
What the Hell is going on there?
Humchit, I think, needs to take a poopoo. 🙄. And then he can 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥🥵
Every politician who passed it, should be jailed.
No chance
FREEDOM OF SPEECH, NO BLOODY FEAR SPEAK UP PEOPLE.
Hear hear. It seems like the Western world has reached a critical point at which politicians are feeling emboldened in regards to regulating speech.
Many politician has hurt my feeling… please arrest everyone
I stand behind her.
Ironic she appears the only one with the balls to stand up.
No, she's got the t*ts ;) She's amazing and such a breath of fresh air in this madness
😅
Or the money...
It's because like Ricky Gervais, she cannot be cancelled or lose her job. Unlike some who have lost their job for the so-called crime of 'misgendering' someone.
She knows she is very high profile and wealthy so the filth won't come after her. They are cowards and instead just focus on arresting poor people
America stands with JK 🇺🇸🇺🇸
USA is pretty bad on the woke garbage.. and admittedly I thought we were the one vying first place of that but from what I gather there are other countries that have it worst ...New Zealand, Sweden, UK, Australia , and of-course the country who I thought we were in competition Canada, but I keep hearing it's worst in other places...
💯 Canada, too!
Period!!! We need more like her
@@Regin314A lot of pro-trans legislation got passed in European countries before anyone was paying much attention to what was actually being put in place. Trans people made up such a small percentage of the population, and your average person is willing to live and let live, as long as they're not being directly affected. There was a crap ton of money used to push this nonsense too. Once normal people started being affected by these laws, and realizing the connotations, there was already a net of them in place and entrenched. .. it's almost like people with money and an agenda and knowledge of how to manipulate government had an organized plan or something. 🤔
The US is sort of late to the party, and had for warning of this stuff before it was already entrenched in our legal system. Unfortunately, the social aspect of this madness has a pretty good hold already.
I honestly think in the US, the majority of the general public is not behind the woke garbage, but are either too afraid to publicly speak against it or are just being drowned out by the obnoxiously loud and belligerent wokies. And I know a lot of people (including myself) who used to identify as Leftists, but no longer do because the woke-cult has pushed many to the Right.
OMG The TRUTH! No one wants to hear that!!
Well done.
This is sickening and I'm so fucking tired of hearing about it. I WILL NOT EVER COMPLY WITH FORCED SPEECH.
Am I eligible for reparations from my schoolyard bully for calling me names back in the 70s?
@blueeyeddevil454 What an Awesome comment! Thank You! I was bullied relentlessly in elementary school by a group of Mean Girls. The teachers didn't intervene nor did the administration. Over the summer going into 8th grade something changed and the bullying stopped. I have seen the girls (women now) on FB and, let me tell you, Karma is, indeed, a bitch! No reparations needed!
@@Julybaby12619 Lmao, same for me. The mean girls who bullied me in middle school all peaked in their teens and did not age well at all. No reparations needed here either. Living well is always the best revenge anyway.
👏🏼 nice comeback to this bullsh**
I got physically slaughtered in primary school by 4 girls all head and shoulders above me. Funny thing is all but one have tried to add me on FB since 😂
One of them got my wrath… the others I just ignored but they still follow me from afar. These people have short lived memories. I on the other hand, *do not*.
I'm confused by these comments. You obviously didn't like being bullied as children but you seem to be using the fact that you were bullied , to attack attempts to stop the incitement of hatred towards vulnerable people. You all grew up to enjoy an adulthood where you aren't bullied. But how would you like to be bullied as adults?
@@campbella2796 Are you saying the Scottish law is an attempt to stop the incitement of hatred towards vulnerable people?
Wow! “1984” George Orwell was spot on. All Scotts should read it.
Never been a Harry Potter fan but I am now to support her 🙌🏻
Its not hate, its living in the real world.