Відео

5.723 lb in OnShape. 3 tries (fixing silly mistakes) Probably half an hour.

2476.081g Fusion 10:08 min

1441.16g Fusion 5:14 min

Thanks for the challenges Toby! Looks like a lot of runners are saving themselves for the Tournament now :D. Nice to have some easier models to warmup with! Looking forward to 1:1 modelling again Here's a recording of my challenge attempts for anyone looking for a SolidWorks walkthru: ua-cam.com/video/qzbugXR3cAA/v-deo.html

Video starts at 2:26

3 tries to get this one correct in OnShape. I mistyped 2 dimensions and took forever to find them. Gave up on the rib feature; instead I cut a 1/4 inch wide super-thin slice from the circular boss where the rib needs to go and then sketched a triangle and extruded it to make the rib. I'm sure there's a better way.

OnShape 1169g. About 20 minutes

999.2226g Fusion 12:37 min Used a 85mm circle before I spotted it was a spline. Doh!

1202g in OnShape...about an hour! 😝 Took 2 tries (misplaced dimension first time). I thought the hardest thing about this one was aligning the elements of the 2D drawings to the 3D model and keeping that in my head long enough to get the sketches correct. Another lesson learned: If you're going to use a loft, get it done as early as possible. Lofts don't like anything in the way.

.777 lb in OnShape. (about 45 minutes, I think) To do this one, I finally figured out I had to create 2 additional planes (after solving the first challenge of placing the base line for the tombstone shape on the base). Is there a better way to do this without 2 additional planes? Great exercise as usual! Thanks, Toby.

Have you done this one in OnShape?

1996.007g OnShape. First try (patting self on back)! But still..took way too long. Delete-face came in handy to take away the protuding part of the sloped extrude at the bottom.

627.367 in OnShape. Pretty challenging for me (only 2.5 months using OnShape). Didn't know about using guidelines for the loft...that was fun to discover. Every one of these models creates another challenge or two. I used the hole feature for the 7mm hole in the bottom jaw, which meant a bit of arithmetic and trial and error to get the depth right. I should have used a sketch/revolve to create that hole.

How do I know which value should I use for k-factor?

Hi, would love to participate in this some day...please can you help with the link to download the practice models. Thanks

That was a great tutorial, I first tried it myself with some more complicated sketches (e.g. I did not use the slot tool) and I ended up with 1590g. Then I followed your tutorial more closely and I realised that made a mistake when designing the slots manually. Changing the diameter from 6mm to radius of 6mm, I got the mass spot on! Many thanks!

metric / non metric = IQ

1086.05117 g Onshape 14.5 min I did see the "tutorial" for this before, otherwise the rib would've been much tricker!

826.01445 g Onshape 27 min, Second try, I flubbed the initial width and wrote 155 instaed of 156

337.08358 g 40 min OnShape

best video for sheet metal pure gold

2:53 347.10g SW2021

best video

Why not a real part? This is a sheet metal part - so why aren't the 'Rails' shown on the inside which would make the part more interesting and more difficult.

Very nice tip! I noticed some wonky behavior, though. I drew the tombstone and split the arc, made the points horizontal like you did, and put the dimension on there and changed it to 60 degrees, picking the points in the same order. When I chose other points on the arc in the same order, it dimensioned to 120 degrees instead of the expected 60 degree driven dimension. Lots of errors and odd behavior later I tried another sketch, with just points to eliminate any of the possible sketch issues, and it works, but when you choose the three points, the first point you choose is the center point, but that worked every time. For some reason I only sometimes got your result picking the same points in the same order...?

At 8:15, Mr Jon Hirschtick comments 'Whew what a match'. I believe that's the same Mr Jon Hirschtick, the the original Founder and CEO of Solidworks and also Onshape as well it seems. His picture looks very similar ( actually identical) to the Wikipedia photo's. Well, how about that guys - THE CAD GOD is truly keeping an eye on his subjects (haha).

0.5216 lb Fusion 10:09 mins

0.2844 lb Fusion 18:33 min

0.8385 lbs Fusion 5:55 min

Just found this tip. So good !! Thanks for sharing.

Its great to see how this model is created, especially in OnShape, although as what appears to be a folded metal shape, I was expecting all of it to be made with sheet metal tools, in particular I was hoping to see how the `dimple` is pressed into the disk. I was not expecting it to be a rotated shape, and I feel kinda cheated by this. There must be a way of pressing the dimple into sheet metal. TTT? Anybody?

I've done this model in practice and I think it took me north of 40 mins lol. Great work by both

Wizard! That's my name! I claimed that for the API. Jk. Toby! you have made this super fun!

GG, both! Congrats Airwick! Thanks TTT!

It was a great tournament!.... what does GG stand for?

346.784 g 0nshape 6:49

Hey Toby! Probably get this all the time but where do you get all the models from that you use here and in practice ? Thanks keep up this awesome concept!

1217.329 g Fusion 28 min Tricky one. Made my brain hurt!

Simple model at first glance but man you have to pay attention! The devil is in the detail as they say! Found it easier to start over once I saw my approach was wrong. Great model Toby! Thank you. 👋👋👋

347.04 grams in SW 2016; Time : 12 min; Feature used: loft, Extrude, Hole. Nice practice part. Thanx

2549.65505g OnShape in 30 min I really struggled with the distance between the hole in the top and the the top edge!

117.856g Onshape 25 min First answer was wrong, but got it on second 👍

149.057g Onshape 35min Beginner CAD, really good way to learn. Just wish there was a solve/walkthru at the end!

Wow, that sheet metal challenge #2 was a tricky one! I had to make a drawing to find where I went wrong. I still got to the answer quicker than in the live chat, though! Thanks for a great stream and challenges Toby Here's a recording of my challenge attempt: ua-cam.com/video/kmOK2CWciGc/v-deo.html

347g Onshape 11:30

1490.134 Fusion 17:24 min Would have been a bit quicker if I'd noticed I'd got the angle on the bottom at 60 instead of 65 that lost me 2g 😣

How do I join? - I have solid edge knowledge.

1085.082g Fusion 11:07 min