Відео

watched this for the first time in ages and holy copyright has ruined this vid 🥲

Crazy 😜

where’s james hird you are a genius

where’s james hird you are a genius

You just gained a subscriber amazing video mate. Keep making vids pls❤

where do you source your data. Doing a subject on modelling and thinking about doing something based on the afl.

could derm be considered for the premierships category? he probably wasnt as good as those other boys, but he would be close and he did win 5 premierships for a reason.

You HAVE to remake this as a 10 year remake. That list will change a bit.

I really enjoyed this. As with the Brownlow Medal, it unfairly rewards midfielders. Scott Wynd, Gary Dempsey, Barry Round and others, couldn't earn a Brownlow today. The closest was Corey McKernan in 1996, but Corey got more clearances than many midfielders and more goals than any ruckman. As we all know, the AFL cognoscenti list Carey, Matthews, Ted Whitten, and the Abletts as easily the leading AFL GOAT charts. But these numbers pretty much tend to reward possessions, goals, and games. This is a bad heuristic for greatness; it favours those who kick goals 10 times higher than those in the backline who stop many more of these goals. My grandfather played for Carlton and Fitzroy from the '30s to the early '50s. And Laurie Nash was the greatest player he ever saw on the field. He recounted Nash, as a ruck rover, kicking 15 goals in a game and also kicking four goals 17 points. Anyway, we all have different versions of what greatness should look like.

How does player ratings factor in finals? Dusty 2017 was third in all time, but does that account for a premiership and a norm smith?

chocky neale

sicily was better than jack sinclair in 2023 what is this

Why Leigh Mathews is the GOAT:11 times in top 3 in Hawthorn B&F between 1971 to 1982,including 8 wins,in a top side.Only missed 1979 because he missed 9 games.Skilton and Murray won 9 each but for lowly sides.

The fact that carey and abblett snr never won brownlow tell you that its a glorified midfield award

The problem here is that the top 3 players of all time didn’t win a Brownlow. Matthew’s, Ablett Snr, Carey. But good you’ve acknowledged that. Good work.

Lost me in the intro saying that LeBron is the only contender to Jordan. Once the dust settles he will be lucky to be top 5. It’s a bullshit debate created to get clicks. If you follow your mantra of using numbers the LeBron only gets longevity.

Most of these aren’t AFL facts. VFL is just one of the Aussie Rules comps in Australia. Good video though

You clearly have a vendetta against Neale winning last year, which is stupid. And the idiot in the comments that said that neale is the most overeated player in the league? Obviosuly doesn't understand anything about AFL. Neale is objectively one of the best players currently playing, as is Bont. I do agree though that Bont 100% deserves a Brownlow. But history has always shown that the browlow is not statsically the best player, brownlow votes get polled for so many other things than what gets shown on a data sheet.

Just imagine he stayed at geelong he’d have a even bigger case

ambrose the real g

Someone is PISSED that Bont didn't win Charlie last year 🤣

Nathan Fyfe

I think it's fairly apparent that forwards are at a clear disadvantage. Either posession is over rated or goals are under rated. They're much harder to get than they used to be. IMO a 6 goal game now is the equivalent of a bag of 10 in the 90's or early 00's.

How was he this good? You ever see his dad play? 😂 Nice vid bro!

The AFL is no longer a sport in my eyes, giving Neal the Brownlow last year cemented that idea that it's all just an entertainment business and no longer a sport. They will award to the best story line so the media can talk up the fairy tale. Going by your video it seems the AFL employed more people with their heads screwed on before 2015 but since then its the best story wins.

jxmyhighroller of the afl

Swanny just entered chat

Jimmy high roller, good video but try and find a bigger lane for yourself bro

the umpires cant look at the stats so its just based on what they saw

Bonts first season at 11.70 was top 10 not Ashcroft

Abletts 2009 was stunning. I remember one time he got caught on the boundary by 3 players and the commentators where making some comment about trying to contain him, he just started walking backwards and then somehow against all the laws of physics created space for himself and just moved the ball forward.

Gazza is the greatest player to ever touch a footy

jxmyhighroller for afl

Bont really deserves a brownlow 😭

Even if player ratings were calculated for pre-2012, like any stat, it is difficult to compare across eras. E.g given the number of stoppages in the game nowadays, hitout/clearance numbers (and hence player ratings) of current players would be inflated. On the flip side, a greater focus on team defence has led to lower scores -> present players disadvantaged as they kick fewer goals

Ablett was taking the piss when he was at gold coast. So many people dont realise just how good he was as they mostly remember him from the cats. He was insane at GC

Gary was a freak, I still ask why Nick daicos isn't up the too somewhere for 2023

i love watching danger play, he's a freak

ripper vid man really great production and info

What I got out of this video is that Naitanui had 5 seasons rated in the top 100 since 2012. Man was he an underrated legend. I doubt that his 2021 season will ever be matched for pure ruck craft and clearance dominance.

Ablett Jnr is an alien

Bont had 24 diposals and 2 goals and got a match rating of 31. Bont last night had 38 disposals and 2 goals and scored a 27.3. The first game was the highest rated of the season how does that make sense ?

Try applying the same metrics to Barney's 1977 season.....91 goals as a Rover.....incomparable.

jxmyhighroller?

Dusty in 2017 is hard to beat. 3rd highest player rating ever, brownlow, grand final win, norm smith.

This would be so good if you leant more into like Summoning Salt's style haha

GAJ is the GOAT and it isn't even close

Quality video brother

GAJ best player I've ever seen purely by the eye test and I've been watching since the early 90s.

IT IS NOT WATSONS BROWNLOW