What an incredible performance. Magical & breathtaking. How good was Bono's voice back then? The rest of the band was also on top of their game. It doesn't get better than this. What an epic combination of drums & gutar by Larry & the Edge before Bono comes in with we'll shine like stars. Adam solid as usual. This is perfection. No other band has the "it" factor like U2.
well let's recognize tht it was not a typical live performance. It was a movie. and highly produced, probably highly choreographed, and edited Performance and Production.
@@denilsonzapataramirez9538 From 4:30 Yeah, we'll shine like stars in the summer night, We'll shine like stars in the winter night, One heart, one hope, one love, With or without you, With or without you, I can't live with or without you, With or without you
Everyone’s praising Larry and Edge and rightfully so. But let’s not forget Adam Clayton. That bass outro (on the record and live) give goosebumps. They were an incredible rhythm section and a tight band.
I agree, no version I have heard comes anything close to this. I personally think Bonos vocals peaked on the Zoo Tour, but this version if WOWOY is by the far the best.
3:55 onwards. It's not often you can say a lead guitarist and a drummer crsuh the show, but Edge and Larry did just that thanks to the great vibe the band has and the sponsorship Daniel lanois gave to Larry. Everything equal. They are all in. I love this version. There has never been anything like it ❤
This performance is absolutely breathtaking!!💖💖 Bono has a beautiful voice!!🩷 This song is a masterpiece, and I can’t get tired of it!!💜💜💜 Love U2 so so much❤️❤️❤️
in all the years listening to this and watching I never realised that about 4.10 the edge turns to Larry ...gives the nod.. and then this just explodes to perhaps the finest piece of rock n roll instrumental pieces EVER..........a song that really is so amazing... thanks for the upload .. rock on and be safe
The ability of Bono to shift registers so silky-smooth and yet raw and plaintively is astounding. So much power. It is grievous that he sold his soul. 😔😢
This song, I’d go over my grandmothers as child and mothers brothers lived at home and used to blast this from their bedroom on repeat and tell me that it was greatest band in the world. My mother’s side of the family are Irish and my dad’s Jamaican, it was such a diverse upbringing, music everywhere, but this song hits different and one day, when I’m laid rest, I want this blaring. Masterpiece
It just dawned on me that U2 is the only band that doesn't one song I would prefer to listen to the album version over contemporary live versions. There are other bands that are phenomenal live. But I can’t think of another band I can make my initial statement about. Not even Queen or Pink Floyd. Thats why in my view it makes them the greatest live band of all time.
Hola compañeros soy Ramón desde Valencia 62 tacos y para mi los grupos de los años 70 y 80 son inolvidables la mejor música de la 80 vueltas a la mierda de musica 💩 de ahora a partir de los 2000 hasta ahora 😊😊😊😊😂😂😂😂
One of the few times where the live performance is better than the studio track and original video. Edge/Adam/Larry are almost always engaged into the song, Bono not as much (he tends to look bored at times, especially since this tour), but he definitely was in this performance. I'm kicking myself til this day that I didn't goto Arizona (my friends did though) to see this concert.
Best part of this video is near the end of Edge's solo and the camera scrolls with Mullen Jr in the background pounding the skins and their body movements are so in tune with eachother. Also they sped up the tempo of this compare to the studio version, which makes it better.
I think we need to acknowledge the greatness that is Larry Mullen Jr. My God.
Bro was crushing it at the end
I wish the camera was on him for the whole song. He absolutely kills it!!!
This was probably the best live performance for this song. Every single one of the band members were able to showcase their individual talents.
You are probably right. At least it is the best live performance that we have recording for.
Bono's voice is at its pinnacle here.... 30 years later, about 50%
You are not a musician, right ?
this is a great live version especially as it has the extra verse...i am a musician
@@pocojoyoWhy do you need to be a musician? Do explain. A decent pair of ears qualifies to judge.
What an incredible performance. Magical & breathtaking. How good was Bono's voice back then? The rest of the band was also on top of their game. It doesn't get better than this. What an epic combination of drums & gutar by Larry & the Edge before Bono comes in with we'll shine like stars. Adam solid as usual. This is perfection. No other band has the "it" factor like U2.
Absolutely agree
Someone wanted money back then and band failed b4 lol😅😅😅 so of course 😂😂😂
its why they were the biggest band in the world around this time
Bono's voice was at its pinnacle then.... now its a shadow...... time is undefeated
@@Welovefarts Unfortunately that is all very true
That’s some drumming,
Larry Mullen Jr.!!
I know nothing about drums. But it’s the hard snare (I think) that sounds so good.
This is the best live performance of all time.
Watch Dire Straits Sultans Of Swing Alchemy Live tour for one of the greatest ever live performances👍👌
"Fairy Tail - Shaman (RITUALIVE)" is the BEST live performance ever for me!
well let's recognize tht it was not a typical live performance. It was a movie. and highly produced, probably highly choreographed, and edited Performance and Production.
that said---it is a fantastic production.
When people ask me why this is my favorite band, I show them this video.
My favourite version of With or Without You. Back when Larry's beat kicked ass!!
U2 prime version!
one of the best drum entries that I've ever listened to
Larry drumming like an absolute machine 🤘
He's like a metronome
Edge's guitar when he goes up high just before Bono breaks into that stars in the summer night bit is banging.
It’s just perfect
Best 30 seconds of guitar ever
yep. still the best live version of this song. incredible.
80's man. The golden age of music.
It was magical! I lived each and every second of it. ❤
Una meraviglia ❤
It is not possible to perform the song better than that.
believe me i have checked every other live version of this song on youtube and yes. This is the definitive and best version.
One of the best rock performances I can name
This is the definitive performance of this song.
I like this one more: ua-cam.com/video/h7p4BjD7wb8/v-deo.htmlsi=is8sT77IMhLiKT28
The best version, of the best song, by anyone, ever! Just sayin'
80's and U2 were god giving gifts to all humanity.
Edge and Larry killing it at the end!!!
probably the pinnacle of 80's music...
I call it the pinnacle of all music.
Masterpiece. Motzart, Beethoven, Bach would all be proud. Emotionally moving and technically brilliant.
What an amazing show this was! I was there for both nights in 1987. They sold tickets for $5. Still one of the best performances I've seen.
Second night for me!
What was the location?
Tempe, Arizona
Sundevil Stadium
we saw them in Australia in 1989. Still one of the best concerts I've ever been to.
we saw Rattle and Hum in the cinema and it was the best concert i've ever seen!
Simply the best version of this song that exists
I fell in love with this band when I heard this live version way back then
my introduction to U2 was the film of Rattle and Hum which I saw in the cinema. This song blew my freaking mind. so stunning.
04:30 "Yeeeaaah!!! We´ll shine like STARS...".
🙌🔥
Could you tell me what he says in those minutes since I don't speak English and I don't understand much:(
@@denilsonzapataramirez9538 From 4:30
Yeah, we'll shine like stars in the summer night,
We'll shine like stars in the winter night,
One heart, one hope, one love,
With or without you,
With or without you,
I can't live with or without you,
With or without you
Everyone’s praising Larry and Edge and rightfully so. But let’s not forget Adam Clayton. That bass outro (on the record and live) give goosebumps. They were an incredible rhythm section and a tight band.
Adam is the glue of the band. Genius
Music peaked right here. Period
4:26 A masterpiece shot!
This version of this song is a great showcase for the talents of all 4 members, but man.. Larry owns the stage here
Larry Smashes It
He puts so much in and never over plays it. Very difficult to do. Great pocket drummer
Masterpiece. We get a little taste of One in the works at the end
Larry and edge from 4 minutes 18.... breath taking..
2:56 - Ingenious camera shot!
For me, this is the best version of this song. Not even close
Best version of this song ever and best performance of this song ever! Thank you!! ❤
Yeah! This song to me sounds best when it’s in standard tuning, and this particular video is closer to it from the pitch adjusting.
One of the best songs of all time, hands down! I never get tired of it!
Amazing drummer
2024 and still my fav song ❤
Same here in South Africa 💯💯🔥🔥
Love this live version. At 4:32, the kernel of what would become “One” just a few years later.
How did I never realize that before?!
Everything sounded so crisp in this version. This was the peak of Bono’s vocals. Fantastic!
I agree, no version I have heard comes anything close to this. I personally think Bonos vocals peaked on the Zoo Tour, but this version if WOWOY is by the far the best.
Sheer class 💙👌🏼
Best edition of the best song ever
i feel like going heaven whenever i listen to this masterpiece
😊💋❣️I can live with or without you😊💋❣️. ……..thank you U2 for this beautiful song 👍😍♥️❣️
04:08 Larry Mullen Jr. doing what he does best.
Everything about this performance is the definition of perfection
3:55 onwards. It's not often you can say a lead guitarist and a drummer crsuh the show, but Edge and Larry did just that thanks to the great vibe the band has and the sponsorship Daniel lanois gave to Larry. Everything equal. They are all in. I love this version. There has never been anything like it ❤
4:20, what a moment. Edge's solo and Larry like an absolute machine in the background.
@@MarkSeddon-fw5uu has ALWAYS been my favourite part of the movie
Even better than BAD. And that's a tall order
Could you tell me what he says in those minutes since I don't speak English and I don't understand much:(
Bono was I his mid-twenties when he wrote this song. Incredible talent at such a young age.
Beatles were teens practically when they started
@@GlennJimenez As were U2
OMG!!!!!
This performance is absolutely breathtaking!!💖💖
Bono has a beautiful voice!!🩷
This song is a masterpiece, and I can’t get tired of it!!💜💜💜
Love U2 so so much❤️❤️❤️
Qui écoute ça plus de 35 ans après?.. ma jeunesse 😟
This hits deep in the soul.... what a performance!
in all the years listening to this and watching I never realised that about 4.10 the edge turns to Larry ...gives the nod.. and then this just explodes to perhaps the finest piece of rock n roll instrumental pieces EVER..........a song that really is so amazing... thanks for the upload .. rock on and be safe
Incredible
I've Only just seen it myself
There's a Definite "nod"
Thx for pointing this out! Good catch
Bono qui ha una voce incredibile e The Edge nella parte finale è stratosferico...
♥️❣️♥️❣️♥️❣️♥️❣️♥️with you or without you I can live♥️I can live with you or without you♥️ilovevit thank you u2♥️❣️😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊❣️
Lovin it august 2024. Quality ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
いい曲
2024 still listening from Indonesia 😊
Best Concert of my lifetime in NYC at Madison Garden.
U2 nun sevdigim en guzel parçaları
1- with or without you
2- bad
3- every breaking wave
The best live version for me!😢❤❤
Bono’s voice sure has changed over the years, new U2 fan here first time hearing and seeing this performance..what a good one!
Best version of the best song. Period. ( I think its faster though)
Es sin duda la mejor canción que he escuchado hasta el momento.
your right !!t certainly the best version ....
Una de mis canciones favoritas de todos los tiempos, escuchándola un 16 de Septiembre de 2024.
still get chills -- hands down best live version
Боно красавчик❤голос завораживает, а эта песня одна из лучших. А проигрыш музыкальный в конце это нечто🥰🥰🥰
The ability of Bono to shift registers so silky-smooth and yet raw and plaintively is astounding. So much power. It is grievous that he sold his soul. 😔😢
La performance più bella di Bono vox in questa canzone 🔝
"you look so beautiful... So beautiful" - Bono - Slane Castle
Which song?
@@henriqueerenner5741Walk on, live from Boston 2001. ua-cam.com/video/wGs0aHqaZ0k/v-deo.htmlsi=g6_mEfhHeMTMLpAO
U2 ist immer und immer wieder sehr gut anzuhören
I feel this song so deeply! He’s singing to all the souls in the audience but the one person isn’t even there !
Larry Mullen superlativo, una macchina
U2 SOBERBO! Deus sabe o q faz !
0:19 he just appeared and it’s something spiritual…
True
He's just Bono being Mr Hewson!
the best live in my heart
This song, I’d go over my grandmothers as child and mothers brothers lived at home and used to blast this from their bedroom on repeat and tell me that it was greatest band in the world. My mother’s side of the family are Irish and my dad’s Jamaican, it was such a diverse upbringing, music everywhere, but this song hits different and one day, when I’m laid rest, I want this blaring.
Masterpiece
best drummer ever
Larry is criminally underrated. Definitely one of the best
Not the Best, but VERY underrated Yes
I was 4 years old when this was released yet heard it constantly in my childhood honestly can say this is an amazing performance
What a perfect ai rendition
The best! (Merci beaucoup pour cette chanson et votre grand talent, à TOUT votre groupe!) U2!
Wow
Doesn't come any better than that !
The best song ever!!!
Un temón de la banda U2 el gran Bono ,nunca me cansó de escuchar este tema 🙂↔️😌 escuchándolo ahora en 2024
Esta versión es apoteósica... Trascendentales... así los considero...
This was an incredible performance. Thank you for the remaster. Just beautiful.
so beautifully filmed 4:28 is perfection.
With or without I can't live!!! ❤🙌
congratulations for the beautiful work! video with great quality 👏👏 congratulations 👏👏👏
Thanks for the great work done by Topaz Video Enhance AI! ❤️
Larry at his best
Excelent
It just dawned on me that U2 is the only band that doesn't one song I would prefer to listen to the album version over contemporary live versions. There are other bands that are phenomenal live. But I can’t think of another band I can make my initial statement about. Not even Queen or Pink Floyd. Thats why in my view it makes them the greatest live band of all time.
Hola compañeros soy Ramón desde Valencia 62 tacos y para mi los grupos de los años 70 y 80 son inolvidables la mejor música de la 80 vueltas a la mierda de musica 💩 de ahora a partir de los 2000 hasta ahora 😊😊😊😊😂😂😂😂
Es una locura lo de esta banda!! Tiene un misterio el sonido,es profunda la melodia!!!
And I still get chills from it ... remember watching it on 1988 ... ❤
😊💋❣️I can live with or without you😊💋❣️. ……..thank you U2 for this beautiful song 👍😍♥️❣️
One of the few times where the live performance is better than the studio track and original video. Edge/Adam/Larry are almost always engaged into the song, Bono not as much (he tends to look bored at times, especially since this tour), but he definitely was in this performance. I'm kicking myself til this day that I didn't goto Arizona (my friends did though) to see this concert.
Best part of this video is near the end of Edge's solo and the camera scrolls with Mullen Jr in the background pounding the skins and their body movements are so in tune with eachother. Also they sped up the tempo of this compare to the studio version, which makes it better.