As the CEO of Google and Microsoft are Indian, India is being forward in tech world, but they had to go to US to become successful as India lacks opportunities. Indians are becoming CEOs not Founders, that's concerning because there is not nurturing environment for techies present in India.
The Indians working in these western companies need to come back to India, and innovate for Indian infrastructure, software, and marketing that way, India as a whole can benefit from innovative Indian minds, rather than these western companies benefiting from our Indian minds
See, you know when you said "Excluding PM Modi" that right there is faulty logic. You are trying to say that everyone in the country is against in grown talent except the PM and he STILL got a majority. Corruption, Edu System, Reservation The Mind Set of Indian politicians are all valid points. But if you have been following the political news for the past few weeks, it just doesn't seem that he is a national leader. It seems like his first priority is being a politician and his party and for "World Leaders" nation and it's unity comes first. And as far as talents go, it the leaders are too busy campaigning, desh kaun chalayega?
Indian government doesn't provide funds to research. We have 0.4% of our gdp in research while developed nations spend 4-5 %. Thats the reason of lack of opportunities in India and that's why Indians leave for better opportunities. As long as government does not provide funds no one will come back.
The number of challenges faced in India by a young aspirant-- Lack of funding, Research resources, indian mentality, societal pressure to settle in given time and start a family, the inefficient system, corporate politics, cut throat competition, less opportunities etc etc... US to has its own challenges like racism, expensive living but it gives you the freedom and funding to create. It follows-- the best man win mentality...In India its may the offsprings of the best and rich man win!
@ 10:38 - "....India is represented in the invisible submerged portion" - means, India is the "back office" of Research scene also, just like they are the back office of everything else. When will we be the front office of anything ?
This was the best insight i ever got on indian talent. All this time was under the impression that indians can never innovate.. Most interesting facts and explanation ever heard..
The recognition of invisible innovation is quite impressive but I do believe that a much efficient education system that doesn't cripple students with unreasonable demands and is uniformly application based (this privilege is only given to the rich or through certain boards) will surely revolutionise the landscape of the Indian economy.
All the countries with the vision and energetic people to work on their vision are capable of doing innovation...we are taught about our vision by the leaders like abdul kalam sir and we are on the way...
India's innovations were ultimately best infinite, simplicity, eco friendly and permanent solutions, not killing nature by using luxury life style, development globalisation
The conclusion was mind blowing this Ted talk definitely proves india is going to be ahead of many developed countries and hopefully the next super power
What about the disparities caused by the caste system. Caste abuse is worse than the racial abuse. See all IIT who merit based settle abroad. Instead let government bring one child policy which will be solution to all problems. Still you are people are caste prejudiced.like you people will soon turn this country into Islamic or Christian country.
woww fantastic sir, we done know from where u have come but u not only make to realise not people infront of but also us people in india by giving a grest statistics which most of indians sont know really it may not only knowing factor but also inspiring thing.......thank u sir
+mayank sharma if person like u lier given some dump means fals can't be truth. I read report witch is done by Congress (central government) it's proved modi nothing to with that even Supreme Court confirm modi innocent in this issue. but people like u Vatican slaves India want to Vatican slaves country & no development for India ,creat some paid scripts for hide truth&stopping person who going to develop nation .like u slaves times come end
Reminds me of an Ironical Dialogue from the Villain of the Tamil Movie 'Thani Oruvan' ... "நீ உலகத்தை இந்தியா ஆளனும் என்று நினைக்கிறாய்...நான், ஒரு இந்தியன் ஆளனும் என்று நினைக்கிறேன்". Meaning "You want India to rule the world, I want an Indian to rule the world".
Indian have lack of vision to create who we are, instead of that we work for someone's else dream. Even we do have vision, no Indian companies want to invest in it. How many R n D lab in India which are built for India talent to innovate and for our own country benefits.
Indians are the "bell" of the bell shaped curve. Google was founded by American..but angel invested by Indian origin investors....and now run by Indian educated CEO. Indians are average...true...but average is the new exceptional.
It is good to know that more indians work in IBM than americans, but isnt that wrong. If i were working in IBM i would have a feeling that i am replacing some american to get that job even though i might be more talented, then isnt it justified that americans feel the way they do for indians and is it wrong? and shouldnt we be building a company like IBM ourselves?
Yes there are problems and all the tech giants that stand tall today must have faced similar or even worse problems. I agree with you when you say that we need to work on our educational system, a key point where the west has already made significant efforts
Not necessarily, we need a change in thinking here. Before the world wars anyone could travel to any country and work/live there, open mobility. National identity was not that strong. If more Indians are in IBM it's because they are good at the job, else they would have been fired. Problem with starting big companies in India is 1. Capital, who has money and who will lend you money 2. Too many rules in starting companies. America allows bankruptcy for companies, so if they fail, they get a free pass, don't pay back all the debt and can continue or start another company, all the while their personal property cannot be touched. So they remain rich to start another venture...you will be destroyed in India.
i had, a solid idea,, i discussed with a friend and found its not possible in india. So we decided to developed that idea for an American co. Work in progress, probably we will pitch soon. Its all about expouser which not letting Indian innovation.
balasara mohit Never give only this example of zero .It's the most oldest and out dated example .Give the example of ISRO . That's great . Now everything needs to be changed . We have to do that... We need to Shift RND to india .
balasara mohit babylonians and chinese did it before aryabhatta. He just gave it a symbol. Bhaskaracharya gave its properties, few of which were wrong. And by the way, who gave rest of the digits?
The R&D centres of the leading IT companies in the world are based in Haifa, Israel and the tech revolution in the world is largely credited to Jewish innovation which attracts the largest share of global venture capital
This is waste of time talk as whole indians work for prosperity of all other nations except their mother land their dollar dreams and pure materialistic pleasures far away from innovation ,their motto only to manage things which were already invented by great scientists of of other nations ,always thinking about rich life ignoring destitute below poverty line people who were discovered by social scientists like Amarthya sen
What a load of crock! In the 1990s a company called Inchcape plc had 60,000 employees worldwide with 40,000 of them in India. Did that make it an Indian company or a British company? British, because the Indian employees were all tea pickers in the tea estates in Assam. QED
You should be ashamed of spreading these kinds of utter lies. Any court up to Supreme Court could not convict Modi in the infinite cases filed by Congress until they were in power! What do you think, that all the Justice Processes Congress used all there muscles, that too when they were ruling India in the Central govt. could not wrongfully malign this pure man who wishes well for all 1.25 billion people which for Any Congress person is even not possible to think about this best thought, could not convict NAMO in any of those infinite cases has done anything wrong? You should be very much ashamed of, as NAMO includes you too in - "Sab Ka saath, Sab ka Vikas"
Don't worry sir at some part of your life you will realize that you miss now. But at some part you right that we all always gets surprised by the facts about the results for the things done by us in the past, But only when all of us can realize the powerful things we can do before doing that job not after seeing the results at that point the world will see the true power of India and Indians.
Time has come for doing visible innovation.
@@umangbadola this is the worst thing in india...
Its 2021 still not visible
@@pthegreat1104 agreed, IIT considering the dream project Btech in Design, to be launch 2024, let us see if it comes to reality
@@pthegreat1104 it already started you haven't notice is yet
I hope the process will speed up in 5 or 10 years
As the CEO of Google and Microsoft are Indian, India is being forward in tech world, but they had to go to US to become successful as India lacks opportunities. Indians are becoming CEOs not Founders, that's concerning because there is not nurturing environment for techies present in India.
I can bet that the CEOs we see today, we wouldn’t have seen them in the same way if they had been in India and started a start up or something
The Indians working in these western companies need to come back to India, and innovate for Indian infrastructure, software, and marketing
that way, India as a whole can benefit from innovative Indian minds,
rather than these western companies benefiting from our Indian minds
Indians need favorable conditions to innovate in India. Which sadly, are now being utilized by westerners too.
See, you know when you said "Excluding PM Modi" that right there is faulty logic. You are trying to say that everyone in the country is against in grown talent except the PM and he STILL got a majority. Corruption, Edu System, Reservation The Mind Set of Indian politicians are all valid points. But if you have been following the political news for the past few weeks, it just doesn't seem that he is a national leader. It seems like his first priority is being a politician and his party and for "World Leaders" nation and it's unity comes first. And as far as talents go, it the leaders are too busy campaigning, desh kaun chalayega?
Sunny shah India is shit no one needs to spoil their life in this.
Indian government doesn't provide funds to research. We have 0.4% of our gdp in research while developed nations spend 4-5 %.
Thats the reason of lack of opportunities in India and that's why Indians leave for better opportunities. As long as government does not provide funds no one will come back.
they can not, Indian investors are pussies and born vendors.
Hats off. Let's rock the world with innovation of Sanatan Dharma.
Pawan Singh I just passed my MBA watching this 😎
What does religion have to do with anything?
Suyash Awasthi This is the biggest flaw of india ... scratch that, "Indians". Tying knots between religion/heritage to global progression.
sanatan dharms is technically not a religion . its just a phrase that ties everyone in one group. its the first common belief.
Conclusion was rocking...
The number of challenges faced in India by a young aspirant-- Lack of funding, Research resources, indian mentality, societal pressure to settle in given time and start a family, the inefficient system, corporate politics, cut throat competition, less opportunities etc etc... US to has its own challenges like racism, expensive living but it gives you the freedom and funding to create. It follows-- the best man win mentality...In India its may the offsprings of the best and rich man win!
And not good quality entrepreneurs, who have no interest in patents
Rula diya yaar. . . Im so moved . . . My fifth ted talk of the night
Hats off, sir. Silently a lot of Indians are doing the job for making the country we can proud.
dont write in english
@ 10:38 - "....India is represented in the invisible submerged portion" - means, India is the "back office" of Research scene also, just like they are the back office of everything else. When will we be the front office of anything ?
Innovation is not about making anything new, it is about making something that is not Obvious. But India rarely does anything like that.
a great video giving the real picture of India's ecosystem of innovation
Thanks Nirmalya Kumar for reducing myths of India 🇮🇳🌏🌍🌎🌐 JAI HIND 🇮🇳 proud to be an Indian citizen.
This was the best insight i ever got on indian talent. All this time was under the impression that indians can never innovate.. Most interesting facts and explanation ever heard..
What Indians lack is the advertisement of the work and innovations done by us...
The recognition of invisible innovation is quite impressive but I do believe that a much efficient education system that doesn't cripple students with unreasonable demands and is uniformly application based (this privilege is only given to the rich or through certain boards) will surely revolutionise the landscape of the Indian economy.
Indian Invisible Innovation....i like this video
We were asked to watch this as part of our MBA program. Very impressive and well expressed. Thank you for sharing this!
college?
@@saanvi755 yes
All the countries with the vision and energetic people to work on their vision are capable of doing innovation...we are taught about our vision by the leaders like abdul kalam sir and we are on the way...
India's innovations were ultimately best infinite, simplicity, eco friendly and permanent solutions, not killing nature by using luxury life style, development globalisation
The conclusion was mind blowing this Ted talk definitely proves india is going to be ahead of many developed countries and hopefully the next super power
We should teach children to think freely rather than mugging up things
you are saying good .after watching this video i will do something for india .......
India can develop more if the reservation system in government colleges are thrown out. India need deserved people more than reserved
What about the disparities caused by the caste system. Caste abuse is worse than the racial abuse. See all IIT who merit based settle abroad. Instead let government bring one child policy which will be solution to all problems. Still you are people are caste prejudiced.like you people will soon turn this country into Islamic or Christian country.
arindam nandi dont u feel bored of putting up this single issue as the reason for everything wrong with india
This video was quite interesting.It showed us that companies name is american doesn't mean all the innovation is being done by americans only.
A complex analysis made simple to understand. For Us to succeed as a global power, We have to address basic issues first.
woww fantastic sir, we done know from where u have come but u not only make to realise not people infront of but also us people in india by giving a grest statistics which most of indians sont know really it may not only knowing factor but also inspiring thing.......thank u sir
This felt like a boxing match..with a powerful knockout blow at the end! Hats off Mr. Nirmalya Kumar :)
Jai Hind!
Companies like patanjali is our new hope. But they should bring something new.
No wonder how India produced its best head of the state in the world PM Narendra Modi!
Dave PM Nero modi is the person who has killed 32000 muslims in Gujrat and 800 muslims women have been raped.
+mayank sharma if person like u lier given some dump means fals can't be truth. I read report witch is done by Congress (central government) it's proved modi nothing to with that
even Supreme Court confirm modi innocent in this issue.
but people like u Vatican slaves India want to Vatican slaves country & no development for India ,creat some paid scripts for hide truth&stopping person who going to develop nation .like u slaves times come end
activelink activdisc heads off 😂😂😂 lol
Quite insightful and thought provoking. Over time, as someone has rightly observed, India should own innovations and create value for the country.
Hats off. Though our education system has to evolve a lot.
To innovate, Indian youth have to change their focus from Pakistan and Arab to South east asia
umm... software engineering doesn't require creativity? well most of the algorithmic problems require one to think creatively and efficiently.
tim cook normal people don't Kno it
Wow... sir big applaud for this presentation India always do invisible innovation but now its time to convert this in a visible. And what you did 👏👏
Superb video, till now I don't know we have that many R &D centres in India.
it was awesome ....proud to be a indian software engineer😎💻💪😘
sir thank u. it was great talk from feeling low to feeling awesome about India and self. thanks again.
WhAT a presentation ......
nailed it
Proud to be an indian
This talk on Invisible innovations is appealing as the learned author looks beyond Juggad .
Yeah. But Indian juggad solve many local problem which is more important that making social media apps.
India is great
we had values and they will follow us..............
Great talk!
Reminds me of an Ironical Dialogue from the Villain of the Tamil Movie 'Thani Oruvan' ...
"நீ உலகத்தை இந்தியா ஆளனும் என்று நினைக்கிறாய்...நான், ஒரு இந்தியன் ஆளனும் என்று நினைக்கிறேன்". Meaning "You want India to rule the world, I want an Indian to rule the world".
Good explanation and analysis of Market and its innovation .
A lay man like me can also understands.
All the best for India
Why India still not able to make fighter plan yet..
love singh tejas
Very interested video sir.👍👌🙏
My great country India 😳
Sorry भारत 😌
The education system needs an overhaul
Sujay Rao Mandavilli
really great speech
truly educational
Indian have lack of vision to create who we are, instead of that we work for someone's else dream.
Even we do have vision, no Indian companies want to invest in it. How many R n D lab in India which are built for India talent to innovate and for our own country benefits.
Great video
#jaishreekrishna
It is truth and wide open for me...
Good information sar.
Good and Best
He is true Indian.
Hats off sir for putting truth in front.
Indians are the "bell" of the bell shaped curve. Google was founded by American..but angel invested by Indian origin investors....and now run by Indian educated CEO. Indians are average...true...but average is the new exceptional.
Too good sir
amazing video..#respect!
Just No. Why ? I feel needless to explain.
amazing conclusion...
It is good to know that more indians work in IBM than americans, but isnt that wrong. If i were working in IBM i would have a feeling that i am replacing some american to get that job even though i might be more talented, then isnt it justified that americans feel the way they do for indians and is it wrong? and shouldnt we be building a company like IBM ourselves?
Yes there are problems and all the tech giants that stand tall today must have faced similar or even worse problems. I agree with you when you say that we need to work on our educational system, a key point where the west has already made significant efforts
we can just take over why build when you can take over and thats what this is.
Not necessarily, we need a change in thinking here. Before the world wars anyone could travel to any country and work/live there, open mobility. National identity was not that strong. If more Indians are in IBM it's because they are good at the job, else they would have been fired.
Problem with starting big companies in India is 1. Capital, who has money and who will lend you money
2. Too many rules in starting companies. America allows bankruptcy for companies, so if they fail, they get a free pass, don't pay back all the debt and can continue or start another company, all the while their personal property cannot be touched. So they remain rich to start another venture...you will be destroyed in India.
can I see the actual reports(proofs) regarding what he is talking about?
very interesting and impressive.
That's amazing....
i had, a solid idea,, i discussed with a friend and found its not possible in india. So we decided to developed that idea for an American co. Work in progress, probably we will pitch soon. Its all about expouser which not letting Indian innovation.
But We Indians don't want to do Invisible innovations .... We want to make Visible changes...😡😡
All this is fine. But why such low salaries?
I love my india
who did invention of zero ...?????????????????
balasara mohit Not you.
balasara mohit Never give only this example of zero .It's the most oldest and out dated example .Give the example of ISRO . That's great . Now everything needs to be changed . We have to do that... We need to Shift RND to india .
balasara mohit babylonians and chinese did it before aryabhatta. He just gave it a symbol. Bhaskaracharya gave its properties, few of which were wrong. And by the way, who gave rest of the digits?
We invented shunaya not zero
Where are the Indian Google's and Microsoft's? Errr.... well they are in Google and Microsoft.
The R&D centres of the leading IT companies in the world are based in Haifa, Israel and the tech revolution in the world is largely credited to Jewish innovation which attracts the largest share of global venture capital
सर इन गोरो को कुछ इतिहास म भी ले जाते की भारत ने कितना कुछ दिया है इस दुनिया को
But IBM is only going worse after 2003. Any reasons for that?
0:16
patent.problem
is there a full report or paper on this subject ?
that's nice...do more of these clichéd topics like Indians are smarter... good for you... create more divide
IBM is an INDIAN COMPANY!!!
some communal fools are also watching this video😂😂😂
Hahaha...nalied it man
See how Hawaii is becoming a hub for innovation: ua-cam.com/video/u0Qp_PrUElo/v-deo.html
This is waste of time talk as whole indians work for prosperity of all other nations except their mother land their dollar dreams and pure materialistic pleasures far away from innovation ,their motto only to manage things which were already invented by great scientists of of other nations ,always thinking about rich life ignoring destitute below poverty line people who were discovered by social scientists like Amarthya sen
Hello? People go abroad to escape a life of poverty in India.
Serioulsy?? Perhaps you didn't get what's in this video.
Bb
What's the point of this speech?
The point of this speech is to shut those detractors who belittle Indian software minds for the lack of "innovations" they have to show.
Just google the word 'Chutiye' it defines you better....
What a load of crock!
In the 1990s a company called Inchcape plc had 60,000 employees worldwide with 40,000 of them in India. Did that make it an Indian company or a British company?
British, because the Indian employees were all tea pickers in the tea estates in Assam.
QED
Real innovation in the world is Islamic science and technology of flying donkey for interplanetary and space travel hahaha.
just because of your ego you put this much effort to find out the data...haha
You should be ashamed of spreading these kinds of utter lies. Any court up to Supreme Court could not convict Modi in the infinite cases filed by Congress until they were in power! What do you think, that all the Justice Processes Congress used all there muscles, that too when they were ruling India in the Central govt. could not wrongfully malign this pure man who wishes well for all 1.25 billion people which for Any Congress person is even not possible to think about this best thought, could not convict NAMO in any of those infinite cases has done anything wrong?
You should be very much ashamed of, as NAMO includes you too in - "Sab Ka saath, Sab ka Vikas"
B. Dave I fail to see the relevance of your comment to the topic of the video
USELESS to me...
-Brahman
Don't worry sir at some part of your life you will realize that you miss now. But at some part you right that we all always gets surprised by the facts about the results for the things done by us in the past, But only when all of us can realize the powerful things we can do before doing that job not after seeing the results at that point the world will see the true power of India and Indians.
Comment section full of Hindu extremists. Full of hate. Why don't you just ask the uploader to change title from "India's" to "Hindu's".
0:17
0:15